🇳🇵Sir Doesn't matter what The Nepalese Politicians say but we the people absolutely love India and we always appreciate How the India has consistently helped us. 🇳🇵
How? Especially when it comes to Bhutan.. he seems dumb. He is giving all the wrong answers. 1. Bhutan took our foreign policy back only in 2007 after signing the revised friendship treaty of 1947. 2. The 80’s and 90’s problem in Bhutan with the Nepalies speaking population was R&AW work. It worked in Sikkim, but not in Bhutan because unlike Sikkim, the Drukpas were in majority in Bhutan. In Sikkim, unchecked immigration has resulted in making the original Sikkimish Bhutias, indegenious Lapchas and other groups into a minority group in their own country. 3. The 90’s problem is not a Hindu Genocide, its simple and illegal immigration and Anti National issue, so why would India protest when it’s wrong doing were exposed although Both India and Bhutan looked away from this matter pretending to not know about it or dismissing it as an internal matter. If Bhutan’s 90’a problem is a Hindu Genocide then the Khalistani issue of Punjab is also a Sikh Genocide and like wise all other Anti National Movements in India. 4. All of Bhutan’s Border with China is not demarcated at all. India was sitting and negotiating Bhutan’s Border with China until 2007. After 2007 India Do not sit at the negotiation Table but still hold significant influence Hence our Dispute with China is still on.
It is nice to watch Tilak in any podcast. He is knowledgeable, articulate and cultured person. Very informative and enriching discussion. Details on Myanmar were hardly known before. Thanks for that Tilak.
सादर प्रणाम भारत माता की रक्षा मैं तयनात इन सपूतों पुत्रों के चरणों मै जो बिना किसी राजनीतिक प्रभाव और लालच के मां भारती की सेवा करते रहे ये बिके नहीं ये झुके नहीं मां भारती के वस्त्र को कोई छू भी ना सके ये officers ऐसा काम कर गए।।।।। सादर प्रणाम।
Excellent analysis, much appreciated. I have 3 of Tilak Devasherji's books, The Pashtuns A Contested History (yet to read),Courting the Abyss (half way through, fast paced & absorbing), At the Helm (finished reading, highly recommended). I have two of Sanjayji's books Unbreaking India (Highly recommended, gifted a copy to a friend), All Religions are not the same ( not yet read, a friend has borrowed).
Best guest to have for a legit, no nonsense and factual conversation.A must listen to guest . And do like to hear to Shushant Sareen as well minus Abhijeet M . And one or two non regulars .
This was a wonderful interview full of new insights and learnings. I’d recommend bringing Tilakji back and doing deep dive episodes on the data he’s presenting and the impact of it. These would be great to listen to.
This is not just a podcast but an indepth analysis and a lecture on geopolitics and security. Devesh sir is an institution in himself. Thank you so much sir for this enlightening session.🙏
22:22 Thank you in earnest Sanjay for speaking the hard truths to soften incoming blows. You are the upper echelon of Ind. Geo. Pol. content creators @ YT (luckily found u end of '17). Appreciate your consistency, insight and discernment. Kind regards to you and yours.
Audio quality needs serious improvement in TJD podcasts. Echo is a major issue. Room needs sound/audio dampening. Content 4.5/5 Video 4.5/5 Audio 2.5/5
All these experts are very laid back, they keep pointing other countries issues, talk about how India will be ready for any situation and is prepared for worst.
We can form a vrihat-bharat treaty (a group of Indian Ocean countries with Nepal, Myanmar, Bhutan, Sri Lanka and possibly Bangladesh) having a senate kind thing having office in Odisha region. Same like European union having Hague/Vienna.
Sir the new Semi Conductor plant that will be set up in Assam is going to be in Morigaon. 50% of Morigaon is filled with Mia Bangladeshis. Also when will centre as well as state government of Assam actually work on deporting these people otherwise the things that r happening in Manipur will also happen in Assam.
Countries adjoining Chaina , have developed a unique blackmailing strategy of deriving maximum benefits from India failing which they could tilt towards China .
Thanks to Sanjay ji for hosting a very good JD discussion with Tilak Devasher. One would have liked to listen to the erudite views of Tilak ji regarding the origins of the Baloch problem also, right from 1947, when Jinnah annexed Balochistan without the consent of its ruler and people. As both discussants mentioned, Pakistan is an artificial construct based on religion. But as its military heads and puppet governments have realized, a religion with exclusivist beliefs cannot form the firm foundations of a country. It has become a victim of its own internal dissensions and machinations. But with Pakistan's history and educational system built on hatred towards India, it is going to keep sinking into its own quick sand of falsehoods. In its concocted 'desert' fables, "the land of the pure" is becoming little more than a mirage! One would have also liked to hear more about the future of the Pakistan-China relationship which is now becoming an economic 'drag' on China. Tilak ji's views on what China hoped to gain by supplying Pakistan with nuclear bomb technology decades ago, and the current calculus of the Chinese leadership would have been interesting to know. Clearly, even in Afghanistan, it is not Pakistan which carries much weight in China's relationship with the Taliban-ruled state.
Agar Kashmir pakistan ban sakta Muslim population ke adhar par tab to Afghanistan aur Iran me bi Muslims hi rehte he. Unko pakistan banane ki koshish kar ke dekho 😂😂😂😂. JAI SRIRAM JAI HIND
Our thinking on strategic planning in geopolitics is some what very silly: 1) during liberation of Bangladesh, we should have made chicken neck area wider by getting some area, we did not why? 2) Bhutan to be independent state of India with one representative in our parliament. We do not have vision. 3) Maldive at the time of water crisis, we should have made this as a non contiguous state of India. Why we did not because we are idiot. 4) why we have away whole winning part of Pakistan and not keeping POK is also idiotic planning. 5) why Baluchistan can not join India as it has great strategic geopolitical interest in future. We have no plan to think ahead at all. I can say more on our Indian silliness. Yes we are better but not enough.
When you see that both Atal ji and Modi ji ignored years of institutional knowledge and lived experience of evil Pakistan and thought they could achieve peace unilaterally , one realizes the folly of such egotistic ventures. Less said about the PMs earlier to Atal ji, the better. 59:32
Five more people were arrested in connection with the gangrape of a Spanish national in Dumka district of Jharkhand even as the survivor left Dumka along with her husband on their bikes amid heavy security. This has taken the total number of those arrested to eight. The foreign national had, in her FIR, said seven people were involved.
Sanjay ji, since you call Mr Sumit Peer quite regularly, could you please advise him to be less excited, more patient in his expressions. He will have better control and will make better sense. He is actually too good to be wasting himself in the haste to speak too much too quickly.
Mout musalman ka gehna hai, asli zindagi mout ke baad shuru hoti hai, 1 muslman 10 hinduo pe bhari hai, hindi "kafir" hai, butparast hai (usse kya farak padta hai pata nahi 😂) And you think Bharat will accept paxtans friendship offer? Do you think Bharatiyas are stupid? 😂😂
Sanjayji I have said this before but no change so far.Once again 'You need to do physical exercise to avoid health hazards' please take this seriously. Jayant.Joshi London.
🇳🇵Sir Doesn't matter what The Nepalese Politicians say but we the people absolutely love India and we always appreciate How the India has consistently helped us. 🇳🇵
Nepal ko wapis Hindu rajya banao varna Bharatiya Hinduon ki tarah rona padega. Inn Krishchian aur Mooshalmano ne naak Bharat mein damm kar rakha hai.
Am Nepal 🇳🇵 Hindu I stand with Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil
@@gagaq-xd7cj You are neither a Nepali nor a Hindu. You are a lier by DNA.
@@gagaq-xd7cj Aap na toh Nepali hain na Hindu hai. Aap kewal paidaishi jhootein hain.
@@gagaq-xd7cj Abdul .. asli ID se aaa ... aaj aata mila ??
Mr.
Tilak Daveshwar is a very learned person
Well said
How? Especially when it comes to Bhutan.. he seems dumb. He is giving all the wrong answers.
1. Bhutan took our foreign policy back only in 2007 after signing the revised friendship treaty of 1947.
2. The 80’s and 90’s problem in Bhutan with the Nepalies speaking population was R&AW work. It worked in Sikkim, but not in Bhutan because unlike Sikkim, the Drukpas were in majority in Bhutan. In Sikkim, unchecked immigration has resulted in making the original Sikkimish Bhutias, indegenious Lapchas and other groups into a minority group in their own country.
3. The 90’s problem is not a Hindu Genocide, its simple and illegal immigration and Anti National issue, so why would India protest when it’s wrong doing were exposed although Both India and Bhutan looked away from this matter pretending to not know about it or dismissing it as an internal matter. If Bhutan’s 90’a problem is a Hindu Genocide then the Khalistani issue of Punjab is also a Sikh Genocide and like wise all other Anti National Movements in India.
4. All of Bhutan’s Border with China is not demarcated at all. India was sitting and negotiating Bhutan’s Border with China until 2007. After 2007 India Do not sit at the negotiation Table but still hold significant influence Hence our Dispute with China is still on.
😊😊@@vaibhav8941
E@@vaibhav8941
VERY GOOD DISCUSSION DEVESHWAR JI KI BAHUT ACHHI STUDY HAI
It is nice to watch Tilak in any podcast. He is knowledgeable, articulate and cultured person. Very informative and enriching discussion. Details on Myanmar were hardly known before. Thanks for that Tilak.
Excellent discussion. Tilak Deveshwar has exceptional geopolitical depth. Sanjay Dixit complements him well.
Excellent. Two of my favourites kept me engrossed for the entire 1+ hour. Jai Hind.
सादर प्रणाम भारत माता की रक्षा मैं तयनात इन सपूतों पुत्रों के चरणों मै
जो बिना किसी राजनीतिक प्रभाव और लालच के मां भारती की सेवा करते रहे
ये बिके नहीं
ये झुके नहीं
मां भारती के वस्त्र को
कोई छू भी ना सके
ये officers ऐसा काम कर गए।।।।।
सादर प्रणाम।
ruclips.net/video/8-iM4Il8EWU/видео.htmlsi=e5ewAGu-0rVK1C2u
❤
Mr. Tilak Deveshar is the best person to talk on the subject. His knowledge is amazing
IT WAS A VERY GOOD CONVERSATION . SUMIT PEER ... NO DOUBT ULTIMATE PERSON...
SUMIT PEER NHI HAI BHAI KYA HO GYA PEG ZYADA HO GYE KYA😂
Someone was writing about Sumit Peer; that's why I wrote this.
Sanjay ji no offence but itna interrupt mat Kiya Karo, let the guest bombard us with his wisdom nuggets.
If Abhishek does this he feels bad
Tikal ji , is ocean of Knowledge.
Brilliant brilliant brilliant great
Excellent analysis, much appreciated. I have 3 of Tilak Devasherji's books, The Pashtuns A Contested History (yet to read),Courting the Abyss (half way through, fast paced & absorbing), At the Helm (finished reading, highly recommended). I have two of Sanjayji's books Unbreaking India (Highly recommended, gifted a copy to a friend), All Religions are not the same ( not yet read, a friend has borrowed).
Best guest to have for a legit, no nonsense and factual conversation.A must listen to guest . And do like to hear to Shushant Sareen as well minus Abhijeet M . And one or two non regulars .
An excellent interview.
Very good conversation Sanjay Sir.. Please try to bring Tilak Sir on Jaipur Dialogues more frequently...
Such a brilliant conversation.
This was a wonderful interview full of new insights and learnings.
I’d recommend bringing Tilakji back and doing deep dive episodes on the data he’s presenting and the impact of it.
These would be great to listen to.
Thanks to Tilakji, Sanjayji and entire team!
Excellent insights as many myths busted - like same DNA, same culture and assi ek hain etc. Thanks for inviting Mr. Davesar. 🙏🏻
Jay Bharat ❤
This is not just a podcast but an indepth analysis and a lecture on geopolitics and security. Devesh sir is an institution in himself.
Thank you so much sir for this enlightening session.🙏
Thanks
22:22 Thank you in earnest Sanjay for speaking the hard truths to soften incoming blows. You are the upper echelon of Ind. Geo. Pol. content creators @ YT (luckily found u end of '17). Appreciate your consistency, insight and discernment. Kind regards to you and yours.
#wewanthindurashtra का पहल करे । और इस message को सबको पहुंचाए I हिंदु नए वर्ष पर इसे trend करवाए
Excellent conversation
Discussion is worth listening to 👍 I would like to listen to such discussions frequently🙏
Audio quality needs serious improvement in TJD podcasts.
Echo is a major issue. Room needs sound/audio dampening.
Content 4.5/5
Video 4.5/5
Audio 2.5/5
Good listen
All these experts are very laid back, they keep pointing other countries issues, talk about how India will be ready for any situation and is prepared for worst.
They will not speak what you want. They will speak what they want. If you do not like it, leave it......
Awww so that you can preempt India’s actions 😂
Kya karna h wo public forum pe discuss nhi hota.
Good discussion
Very nice programme
Yes, he (Tilak Jee) give us very good information. Thank to the Team of Jaipur Dailogue.
Excellent talk. Thank you.
ruclips.net/video/8-iM4Il8EWU/видео.htmlsi=e5ewAGu-0rVK1C2u
Great subject matter!
Superb discussion... 👍🏻
Invite him again on another topic...
🇮🇳
Very good talk
Great analysis ❤
Tilak ji rocked it
Very good service
Superb ❤
What is a way for India for negotiation with our neighbouring countries
Well explained in very simple way
Like the discussion
One of your best discussions
Nice job Jai hind
What an intellectual podcast ❤
We can form a vrihat-bharat treaty (a group of Indian Ocean countries with Nepal, Myanmar, Bhutan, Sri Lanka and possibly Bangladesh) having a senate kind thing having office in Odisha region.
Same like European union having Hague/Vienna.
Sir you changed the start of Jaipur dialogue
मान्य सन्जय भाई जय हीन्दं जय श्री राम हर हर् महा देव् जय हो 🌷🌷🌷🌷🚩🚩🚩🚩💯🙏🏼✔
Why to reveal all the working pattern of the persons at very precarious positions and making all of them more vulnerable
Is aadmi ka kya name our post h,ye ajit dowal to nahi hai ,aapko likhna chahiye on thumb nail per.
tilak deveshar.
please put video with subparts and context
Ram Ram Saa Ram Ram both of you 🙏 💙 ❤️ ♥️
Main har roj 10 Hinduon ko The Jaipur Dialogues channel deta hoon aur unko jagne ko bolta hoon. 🙂🙂🙏🙏
Mazaa aa gaya!!
Superb
Jai. Hind. 🙏🙏
Sir please time stamps??
Sir the new Semi Conductor plant that will be set up in Assam is going to be in Morigaon. 50% of Morigaon is filled with Mia Bangladeshis.
Also when will centre as well as state government of Assam actually work on deporting these people otherwise the things that r happening in Manipur will also happen in Assam.
Countries adjoining Chaina , have developed a unique blackmailing strategy of deriving maximum benefits from India failing which they could tilt towards China .
Why loud music? Am I watching video game or action movie?
Unknown gun man ki Jai ho! Bharat Mata ki Jai!🖖
Thanks to Sanjay ji for hosting a very good JD discussion with Tilak Devasher. One would have liked to listen to the erudite views of Tilak ji regarding the origins of the Baloch problem also, right from 1947, when Jinnah annexed Balochistan without the consent of its ruler and people. As both discussants mentioned, Pakistan is an artificial construct based on religion. But as its military heads and puppet governments have realized, a religion with exclusivist beliefs cannot form the firm foundations of a country. It has become a victim of its own internal dissensions and machinations. But with Pakistan's history and educational system built on hatred towards India, it is going to keep sinking into its own quick sand of falsehoods. In its concocted 'desert' fables, "the land of the pure" is becoming little more than a mirage!
One would have also liked to hear more about the future of the Pakistan-China relationship which is now becoming an economic 'drag' on China. Tilak ji's views on what China hoped to gain by supplying Pakistan with nuclear bomb technology decades ago, and the current calculus of the Chinese leadership would have been interesting to know. Clearly, even in Afghanistan, it is not Pakistan which carries much weight in China's relationship with the Taliban-ruled state.
Please don't show the distorted map of India. At 18:35 you showed POK as pakistan. What's wrong with you?
Beta koi takleef ho rahi hai Kya gobar part ha Pakistan ka Tum apnay map Mai dalnay sy ho nhi jaye ga
Agar Kashmir pakistan ban sakta Muslim population ke adhar par tab to Afghanistan aur Iran me bi Muslims hi rehte he. Unko pakistan banane ki koshish kar ke dekho 😂😂😂😂.
JAI SRIRAM
JAI HIND
Am Nepal 🇳🇵 Hindu I stand with Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil
❤❤❤
Our thinking on strategic planning in geopolitics is some what very silly:
1) during liberation of Bangladesh, we should have made chicken neck area wider by getting some area, we did not why?
2) Bhutan to be independent state of India with one representative in our parliament. We do not have vision.
3) Maldive at the time of water crisis, we should have made this as a non contiguous state of India. Why we did not because we are idiot.
4) why we have away whole winning part of Pakistan and not keeping POK is also idiotic planning.
5) why Baluchistan can not join India as it has great strategic geopolitical interest in future. We have no plan to think ahead at all.
I can say more on our Indian silliness. Yes we are better but not enough.
तुम जिसे भी मजबूत करोगे, वो तुम्हारी ही बैंड बजाएगा , मालदीव, मॉरीशस, नारी, गरीब, जाति, सिख आदि आदि ! क्षमा प्राथना सहित
सही कहा, लेकिन कुछ आकर घुटने भी टेकते हैं
100% truth
When you see that both Atal ji and Modi ji ignored years of institutional knowledge and lived experience of evil Pakistan and thought they could achieve peace unilaterally , one realizes the folly of such egotistic ventures.
Less said about the PMs earlier to Atal ji, the better. 59:32
Best, greatest conversation🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Five more people were arrested in connection with the gangrape of a Spanish national in Dumka district of Jharkhand even as the survivor left Dumka along with her husband on their bikes amid heavy security.
This has taken the total number of those arrested to eight. The foreign national had, in her FIR, said seven people were involved.
Vaibhav sir ko bulaiye sanjay ji.
Ads kam ho gaye, aur thora add kar dena tha
Sanjay ji, since you call Mr Sumit Peer quite regularly, could you please advise him to be less excited, more patient in his expressions. He will have better control and will make better sense. He is actually too good to be wasting himself in the haste to speak too much too quickly.
5:23 Sanjayji I am outraged at your conceding POK and Gilgit Baltistan to Pakistan
Kou beta takleef ho gaye part hai Pakistan ka Tum apnay map Mai dalnay sy tumhara nhi ho jaye ga
तो सर,ये आप लोगों ने पहले ही तय कर लिया था की unknown gunmen par कोई discusion नहीं किया जाएगा।
Jai Hind Jai shree Ram Krishna both of you sir
ruclips.net/video/8-iM4Il8EWU/видео.htmlsi=e5ewAGu-0rVK1C2u
Pakistan has been walking a wrong route for a very long time. We need to offer India a hand of friendship.
Mout musalman ka gehna hai, asli zindagi mout ke baad shuru hoti hai, 1 muslman 10 hinduo pe bhari hai, hindi "kafir" hai, butparast hai (usse kya farak padta hai pata nahi 😂)
And you think Bharat will accept paxtans friendship offer? Do you think Bharatiyas are stupid? 😂😂
Sanjayji I have said this before but no change so far.Once again 'You need to do physical exercise to avoid health hazards' please take this seriously.
Jayant.Joshi London.
विदेशों में ज्यादा खतरा देश के नागरिक जो राष्ट्र विरोधी तत्वों के हाथों में खेल कर रोज रोज आंदोलन करना है
Sanjay sir plz called j sai deepak
China has signed a Defence pact with Muizzu. 😮
Jai Bharat 🙏
जय हिन्द 🙏🙏
राम राम जी 🙏🙏🙏
58:42 Tilak sir drr gye drr gyee 😆😆😆😂 Sanjay ji ka sch sun kr !!
ruclips.net/video/8-iM4Il8EWU/видео.htmlsi=e5ewAGu-0rVK1C2u
revealing
I wish your channel's subscription grow very fast
🚩🚩🚩
Sir, how do we deal with Rohingya issue.
🙏🇮🇳
Jai Shree Ram 🚩
India needs to start backing Tibet openly.
Expectation can't fulfilled by you
Sanjay ji be like beech beech me Guest ko tok tok kr apna gyan chod deta hu cool lagunga😂😂
🙏🙏🇮🇳
Sanjay ji please dispel myths that Mr Tilak has about Sufism. He is deeply mistaken.
🙏🏼
जय भारत
ruclips.net/video/8-iM4Il8EWU/видео.htmlsi=e5ewAGu-0rVK1C2u
Namaskar
🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳👍👍👍