The REAL Reason Why The Pinkertons Were Able To Find The Gang's Hideout In Red Dead Redemption 2!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
  • The REAL Reason Why The Pinkertons Were Able To Find The Gang's Hideout In Red Dead Redemption 2!
    ►Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: www.g2a.com/r/...
    In today’s Red Dead Redemption 2 video - We'll be figuring out the REAL reason why the gang's camp hideout in Lakay was discovered so easily by the Pinkertons and Agent Milton!
    ►My Facebook:
    / mrbossftw
    ►My Snapchat:
    / mrbosssnaps
    ►My Twitter:
    #!...
    ►My Instagram:
    / jamesrosshudgins
    Hope you enjoyed this video! See you guys in the next one! ✌🏻

Комментарии • 465

  • @MrBossFTW
    @MrBossFTW  5 лет назад +49

    The REAL Reason Why The Pinkertons Were Able To Find The Gang's Hideout In Red Dead Redemption 2!

    • @melkerkarjalainen0789
      @melkerkarjalainen0789 5 лет назад +4

      MrBossFTW 🤗🤗

    • @melkerkarjalainen0789
      @melkerkarjalainen0789 5 лет назад +4

      I NEW IT😨😨

    • @flippanthail0373
      @flippanthail0373 5 лет назад +4

      It’s because of Micah. Simple. Love your videos tho.

    • @TrolledByKBR
      @TrolledByKBR 5 лет назад +5

      But it was bill because he asked people around to see where the gang went

    • @flippanthail0373
      @flippanthail0373 5 лет назад +2

      But then the Pinkerton would have said it was also bill. And why was Micah the last one back after they returned? Because it was Micah.

  • @bleezieg
    @bleezieg 5 лет назад +153

    The same thing happens even if you kill them all before they see the letter.....it was Bill Williamson asking all over town where they were

    • @dr.skulhamr3220
      @dr.skulhamr3220 4 года назад +5

      Ah I wondered what would happen if no Pinkertons survived the visit to Shady Bell. Thanks.

    • @phredphlintstone6455
      @phredphlintstone6455 4 года назад

      I steal one of their horses and let them live

    • @mindaugaszemaitis9378
      @mindaugaszemaitis9378 3 года назад +5

      Exactly. Arthur kills everyone so Pinkerton would no be able to use info on letter

    • @peteroates2908
      @peteroates2908 Год назад

      You know l think you may have the answer to the mess nice one all the best Peter x.

    • @peteroates2908
      @peteroates2908 Год назад

      @@mindaugaszemaitis9378 my thoughts exactly you know what's going down 👇 all the best Peter x.

  • @Game_Ranger527
    @Game_Ranger527 5 лет назад +76

    I think it was that loud mouthed Bill Williamson. He did say he asked everyone he could until someone pointed him there. So I believe the Pinkerton's followed Bill. He was the last to arrive after all.

    • @thicc6785
      @thicc6785 5 лет назад +6

      That and the Pinkertons picked up Micah after they got back from Guarma

    • @dr.skulhamr3220
      @dr.skulhamr3220 4 года назад +8

      That makes a ton of sense and Bill is not exactly someone who blends in anyhow.

    • @phredphlintstone6455
      @phredphlintstone6455 4 года назад +4

      Not to mention that he's not exactly quiet

  • @jmcgee39
    @jmcgee39 5 лет назад +31

    It was actually Bill Williamson indirectly. Listen to when he said that he had to ask around on how to find the hideout. Maybe the Pinkertons heard him or heard someone he talked to give him the directions.

  • @francescocasillas4965
    @francescocasillas4965 5 лет назад +236

    Because they picked up Micah at some point and he ratted the gang out. Video over so go, spend your time on something else.

    • @francescocasillas4965
      @francescocasillas4965 5 лет назад +2

      @The-phantom788 no problem

    • @Bennyb99
      @Bennyb99 5 лет назад +4

      Fr... I don’t see why this man had to make a whole ass pointless ass video about something that was pretty common knowledge from just playing the game 😂

    • @francescocasillas4965
      @francescocasillas4965 5 лет назад +1

      @sadie drunk ok

    • @francescocasillas4965
      @francescocasillas4965 5 лет назад +8

      @@Bennyb99 his content used to actually be good but now he just makes videos about obvious stuff, i wont be supprised if he makes a video titled "What Happens If You Try to Feed Your Horse Classic Outcakes During a Mission Secret Ending"

    • @timmullaly8945
      @timmullaly8945 5 лет назад +3

      It could also be that Bill asked around the town before reaching the camp

  • @VOLKSPANDA
    @VOLKSPANDA 5 лет назад +31

    I've find the letter before The Pinkertons, and manage to escape without they see. For me it's Bill's fault..

  • @alexisyanish2368
    @alexisyanish2368 5 лет назад +11

    They found the camp so quick because of Bill Williamson. He said he asked all over and finally someone told him where they were. You are met to find the letter before they find it so it wasn't Sadie. Plus,not standing up for him at all but, Micah was already in the homestead before Dutch got there so it wasn't Micah. It was Bill.

  • @nojopro908
    @nojopro908 4 года назад +5

    I think it was bill Williamson.When he showed up he seemed mad Maybe he accidentally asked someone He shouldn't have .Or threw a fit in the middle of the public .And the pinkertons followed him .After all he was the last one to show up.

  • @skynyrdjesus
    @skynyrdjesus 5 лет назад +9

    It's not like it was that hard to find. Even Bill found it quickly without much trouble. It seems pretty obvious the Pinkertons knew where it was well before the gang returns and were probably watching it. That would explain how they picked Micah up so easily, and it would make sense they would wait for the ambush until they managed to turn a rat in the gang. This really isn't a mystery.

  • @RomanMickelsen307
    @RomanMickelsen307 5 лет назад +11

    I thought they followed Bill. Cuz he said he asked everyone around town and I think the Pinkerton heard and followed him cuz they showed up seconds after him

    • @liammurphy3062
      @liammurphy3062 5 лет назад

      Yeah they did it just Mr boss wasting your time again

  • @Pangde122
    @Pangde122 5 лет назад +21

    I'm not defending Micah but from what I have seen already the Pinkertons already knew the gang will be in lakay but they didn't know where is the exact spot to bust, what I really think exposed the gang exact location is actually Bill Williamson he did even say (I asked everyone about you) which is so obvious that the Pinkertons tracked him right to the spot it would really make since after all the Pinkertons are detectives and it will be so easy to track someone who's just asking people around like a lunatic ;)

    • @phredphlintstone6455
      @phredphlintstone6455 4 года назад

      Right? Just walk up to someone he just asked and ask them, what's with that guy? He get kicked in the head or something?
      Most people will then tell you the full story

  • @ryanadams9872
    @ryanadams9872 4 года назад +4

    Bruh bill walks in and admits that he was the one that got the gang found out he literally says he asked everyone he saw the Pinkertons probably followed him there and that’s how they were found out about

  • @gworebel
    @gworebel 5 лет назад +6

    Micah or Sadie's letter maybe but you can find the letter before the Pinkertons in which case they will not see it. Also considering they show up right after Bill he could've unwittingly led them there after asking all over about the location

  • @johnclarkjr1422
    @johnclarkjr1422 5 лет назад +7

    Me Milton: I’m going to be just fine
    Abigail: I’m about to end this mans hole career

  • @joelarias55
    @joelarias55 5 лет назад +8

    On my first game play I actually picked up this note & snuck out without alerting the agents & they found the gang lol

    • @donyehmorales2131
      @donyehmorales2131 4 года назад

      And I couldve swore karen wrote the letter, cause i found letter before pinkertons

    • @moodyowlproductions4287
      @moodyowlproductions4287 4 года назад +2

      It was Sadie...she wrote it....not that she had much choice....how else would Arther have found them

  • @incomparablegamer5011
    @incomparablegamer5011 5 лет назад +15

    Don't worry guys 10 videos coming today on the casino dlc.
    Jamir baker has crabs.

  • @sburton015
    @sburton015 2 года назад +3

    That's would leave be wondering how the Pinkerton's were able to find Lakay and the gang so quickly even if Arthur got to the letter first. I probably think they had other clues.

  • @Carterkaiine
    @Carterkaiine 5 лет назад +16

    Just expect a casino dlc in about 2 hours or so....

  • @briandumpher
    @briandumpher 5 лет назад +4

    The Pinkertons find them in chapter 2 when Arthur and Jack were fishing and even can came to the camp to offer the gang freedom for Dutch. It was Micah from the beginning because we saved him from Strawberry jail but he never came to the camp til they moved to Rhodes.

    • @adambadr15
      @adambadr15 5 лет назад

      R Sevin yea, but they change camps multiple times during the chapters, making the pinkertons unable to deduce the location of the camp with the location of the previous camp

    • @briandumpher
      @briandumpher 5 лет назад

      @@adambadr15 The Pinkertons find them in every location except for Clemens Points in Rhodes. The reason they left Rhodes because they got involved with the Greys and the Braithwaite family feud also Jack was kidnapped. The Pinkertons even found their hideout in Shady Belle after the failed bank robbery attempt.

  • @wasiurrahman549
    @wasiurrahman549 3 года назад +3

    Dude you found this out so late it bill who reveals their info he himself told everyone ‘there you are i’ve been asking everyone i could find and eventually someone knew told me you was here’ aurther even tells bill ‘so leading the pinkertons to camp’ so its bill williamson

  • @darya.b151
    @darya.b151 5 лет назад +13

    I Kill The Pinkertons in The Old Camp Every Time I Play This Mission and They Still Came !

    • @fredvalencia2205
      @fredvalencia2205 5 лет назад +3

      The pinkertons text messaged there buddies before you killed them

    • @MobySlick
      @MobySlick 5 лет назад +1

      @@fredvalencia2205 Bullshit. It was the rat who spoke. Simple as that.

    • @rubitena4374
      @rubitena4374 5 лет назад +1

      Baqi Osman i now

    • @deathitself6985
      @deathitself6985 5 лет назад +1

      @@MobySlick Obvious joke..

    • @MobySlick
      @MobySlick 5 лет назад

      @@deathitself6985 Not so obvious...

  • @Adrian_Gonzales
    @Adrian_Gonzales 4 года назад +2

    It was Bill, Dutch and Micah. Depends if they found Dutch decided to follow him then saw Bill then they probably thought hey heading same place and well Micah we all know what happened there two on accident one on purpose

  • @victorgrenier
    @victorgrenier 2 года назад +2

    If you pick up the letter before the Pinkerton the same thing still happens even if you kill them all

  • @littlfluffydino1327
    @littlfluffydino1327 4 года назад +5

    Correct answer: *video*
    Fun answer: They put a Tracking device on Arthur

    • @user-hh3gk2pq5n
      @user-hh3gk2pq5n 3 года назад

      l don't want to be mean but that's not funny ):

  • @TheHappyPotatoe
    @TheHappyPotatoe 4 года назад +1

    Yeah I found this out when the pinkerton agents read the letter Sadie left even thought about how stupid that was to leave it there like that should have left it with someone the gang knew

  • @The_zickron
    @The_zickron 5 лет назад +5

    10:41
    Just like rdr2 in john's last mission

  • @jholmes7646
    @jholmes7646 4 года назад +5

    Arthur killed them so howd they tell milton were the camp was

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 4 года назад +1

      Its was bill they followed to tge camp

    • @saintsrowyt5494
      @saintsrowyt5494 4 года назад

      I think canon is you leave the Pinkerton alive and sneak out of shady belle

    • @phredphlintstone6455
      @phredphlintstone6455 4 года назад

      I steal one of the horses, but ya. My money is on bill. Mica would have to have been, picked up, turned, found the camp, and somehow gotten word back.
      It's not like he has a cell phone.

  • @spetsnaz3198
    @spetsnaz3198 2 года назад

    1-they followed micah bill after they ratted him
    2- Nice Mr. Williamson was asking about the gang in the town

  • @uncledave6174
    @uncledave6174 5 лет назад +9

    easy as soon as Micah and Dutch entered it was "come out with your hands up"

    • @saintsrowyt5494
      @saintsrowyt5494 4 года назад +1

      So your saying that Dutch betrayed his own gang and Micah was just a pure rat

  • @shpongle7322
    @shpongle7322 5 лет назад +10

    At this rate you'll be making a video soon about, ”why does is never snow in ambarino?? ” DUN DUN DUN

    • @Rawkwilder
      @Rawkwilder 5 лет назад

      or " why there are never the animals you need for the "its art" questline? ThE ReAl ReAsOn!1!eleven!"

    • @shpongle7322
      @shpongle7322 5 лет назад

      Rawkwilder title would be. EVERYTHING you DONT know about SECRET animal spawns!

    • @Rawkwilder
      @Rawkwilder 5 лет назад

      @@shpongle7322 that and "UFO solved..."

  • @clairesylvestre6663
    @clairesylvestre6663 4 года назад +5

    i found the letter first, they never read it in my story.

  • @FootballRob2010
    @FootballRob2010 4 года назад +1

    The Pinkertons tracked Micah's facebook account for clues on the gang's whereabouts

  • @straightoutacopenhagen1672
    @straightoutacopenhagen1672 5 лет назад +5

    If kill the pinkerton they would not have known why would u even sneak away ur supposed to kill them micha did it nothing new

  • @ArthurMorgan-_-
    @ArthurMorgan-_- 5 лет назад +1

    It’s because there was a note at shady belle, bill led them back and Micah ratted them out
    (Edit) and Micah ha most likely snitching since chapter 2 because they already knew about the train robbery and the bank robbery in saint denis when they occurred

  • @randombluepig8905
    @randombluepig8905 5 лет назад +6

    It was obviously MICAH! You don’t even have to watch the whole thing to know!

  • @lydiapotter4812
    @lydiapotter4812 5 лет назад +1

    Hey Boss love your videos. I am in chapter 5 and I love this game. It is the best novel I ever read in a video game. I'm a 52 yr old lady and I have not been this emotional about a man since I met my husband. Lol. When Arthur looks at the rocks and mountains through his binoculars he sees his thoughts carved in rock. On one of the mountains north west of Strawberry as Arthur is facing southwest looking in the binocs he sees a VERY sinister Dutch face with puppeteer strings of glinting gold strapped to Arthur and I just broke out sobbing. Take a look at Horseshoe Overlook through Arthur's binoculars his son is playing with a pony they look so happy. Sob sob Brilliant Rockstar! Bravo.

  • @izzybat666
    @izzybat666 5 лет назад +2

    Yes but, when you get the letter first before the pinkertons , they still know where you are, even though you got the letter first

  • @CarterSandoval
    @CarterSandoval 5 лет назад +2

    MrBoss, when I was in that mission I killed them before they red the letter and they still showed up to our camp in Lakay.

    • @liammurphy3062
      @liammurphy3062 5 лет назад

      I know same Bill barges through door and says its about time i asked everyone in town were you was (thats how they knew they was in lakay) and micha says asked everyone in town huh bill so nothing to do with letter just another bs ten min vid

    • @GTLoHarris
      @GTLoHarris 5 лет назад

      Radio Hits if they showed up everyday clearly they’ve seen the letter and left it to wait and see when it got picked up so they know when to bust it

    • @CarterSandoval
      @CarterSandoval 5 лет назад

      Very true I did not think of that

  • @123h.e
    @123h.e 2 месяца назад

    When the pinkertons showed up.Dutch said ''already?'' and then he looked at micah.And micah saw dutch...

  • @cyberpunkmodels692
    @cyberpunkmodels692 5 лет назад +18

    Yay so this means casino video in two hours 😃

    • @phaes
      @phaes 5 лет назад +1

      Yes sir👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾

    • @phaes
      @phaes 5 лет назад

      dream team do u play PS4?

    • @deaconfrost9
      @deaconfrost9 5 лет назад +1

      No doubt!

  • @kawikalo
    @kawikalo 7 месяцев назад

    I think they already knew... They were just waiting for everyone to be there so none would be left alive...

  • @dmthandmade5674
    @dmthandmade5674 5 лет назад +3

    Because it's a videogame, the Pinkertons finding them was an essential plot device and as such the script was written that way.
    You're welcome.

  • @dejota9818
    @dejota9818 5 лет назад +1

    Dude when I was doing this mission and got to shady bell I searched all the first floor before I went to the second floor, and I found the letter Sadie had written for Arthur and Arthur puts it away in his satchel so there is no way the Pinkertons could've come to lakay. I think that's something rockstar missed.

    • @briandumpher
      @briandumpher 5 лет назад +1

      In chapter 2, the Pinkertons came to Arthur and Jack when they was fishing and came face to face with the gang at the camp which force them to move to Rhodes. It obvious Micah was the rat from the beginning when we save him from jail.

  • @theniteinrusteearmour5354
    @theniteinrusteearmour5354 5 лет назад +25

    BREAKING NEWS: "Jamir Baker was spotted in public blowing Ross in his McLaren!"

    • @thedirtysouth-st3gt
      @thedirtysouth-st3gt 5 лет назад +2

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @juananunez3522
      @juananunez3522 5 лет назад +1

      Man imma start checking out the comment of ross' vids now

    • @jdy-ew5gj
      @jdy-ew5gj 5 лет назад +1

      Lmaooooo

    • @rbflooring1
      @rbflooring1 5 лет назад +1

      I'm guessing jamirs rusty exhaust was also filled in by mrtoss?

    • @theniteinrusteearmour5354
      @theniteinrusteearmour5354 5 лет назад

      @@rbflooring1 According to eye witness reports, it was.

  • @joelarias55
    @joelarias55 5 лет назад +3

    On my second gameplay I picked up the note & murdered all the agents silently!

  • @juansaavedra7611
    @juansaavedra7611 3 года назад

    idk why but when the Pinkerton said I'd like to find a poisonous snake I died on the floor😂😂😂

  • @skoot0962
    @skoot0962 5 лет назад +2

    i read the letter and put in my satchel so the pinkertons never saw it

  • @Opie778
    @Opie778 2 года назад

    I wanna know how the pickertons knew about the bank job in Saint Denis when Micah didn't start talking till after Guma. ???

  • @Your_Host
    @Your_Host 5 лет назад +4

    Yeah michah told them shortly after they came back

    • @mizzoman6097
      @mizzoman6097 4 года назад +1

      bill came late so they followed him to lakay.

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 4 года назад

      No micah picked up only in chapter 6

  • @taven2264
    @taven2264 5 лет назад +4

    it might have been bill asking around everywhere and followed thar

  • @kasic2531
    @kasic2531 4 года назад +1

    I found the letter before the Pinkertons and I killed all of them... so how could that leak their hideout?? Also all characters that came from Guarma look pretty bad. With beards, dirty and kinda thirsty. But Micah looks as fresh as always... so he may have made himself „pretty“ for or at the meeting with the Pinkertons

  • @loudelk99
    @loudelk99 3 года назад

    Well, I played this and I had him put the letter away before the Pinkertons showed up. They still found the camp.

  • @samuelgirard8223
    @samuelgirard8223 5 лет назад +1

    The only way they get the letter is if you don't grab it as soon as you walk in, then they never see it

  • @thajarin
    @thajarin 4 года назад

    UM, Bill flat out says he talked to everyone he knew, they followed Bill to the camp.

  • @christophersconiers4979
    @christophersconiers4979 6 месяцев назад

    If rockstar wanted to they could have had a dlc as Sadie during the time Arthur and Dutch were in Guarma

  • @lukasmuntingh6138
    @lukasmuntingh6138 4 года назад

    Agent Milton was a very much intelligent man who did his job well.
    Lakay was a place where the cops didn't come same as Beaver Hollow

  • @nicholas1182
    @nicholas1182 3 года назад

    It’s gotta be Bill Wilson because he told the town where they were and he was looking for them and then he said that he was telling everybody so it’s gotta be Bill the Pinkertons heard and they heard about Bill and they followed him

  • @themrgolden5304
    @themrgolden5304 3 года назад

    The horse you use the horse when you get back from guarma looks like the one from Adler ranch

  • @xzx4020
    @xzx4020 4 года назад

    Pinkertons picked up Micah after Guarma. Also what is more interesting than this video is how the pinkertons found Arthur on the side fishing with little Jack...

  • @ericcasline1950
    @ericcasline1950 5 лет назад

    i think bill when asking around about the group was not cautious about it. I think that is how the pinkertons found the camp. they just followed bill. probably knew from the letter that they were in the area so they had thier troops and guns gathered near by arleady. bill just led them strieght to the camp.

  • @Bazyar202011
    @Bazyar202011 4 года назад +1

    It’s kinda simple . Micah told them and didn’t Milton say he picked up Micah when they came back ?? So to be honest their was no need for this video but good video

  • @coltonweber2135
    @coltonweber2135 5 лет назад +1

    When he said Sadie I remembered the note at shady bell

  • @DjSoSmooveMINTY124
    @DjSoSmooveMINTY124 5 лет назад +1

    Casino trailer is coming tomorrow guys get hype!!!!!!!!!

  • @linellfox5413
    @linellfox5413 4 года назад

    Bill is the reason. Searching all over for them.

  • @ItsDume
    @ItsDume 5 лет назад

    it was Bill who led them to the camp. He asked everyone he could and the Pinketons over heard him and followed him to the camp

  • @weluvquacks_4483
    @weluvquacks_4483 4 года назад

    mrbossftw it wasnt actually sadies fault because on my playthroughs i dont go upstairs you can just go straight to the letter and arthur finds it first and its actually bills fault but still nice video

  • @theniteinrusteearmour5354
    @theniteinrusteearmour5354 5 лет назад +4

    Because Micah was working for them? It's told in the game.

    • @simon-px3rr
      @simon-px3rr 5 лет назад +4

      Yep. This video was pointless

    • @deaconfrost9
      @deaconfrost9 5 лет назад +4

      @@simon-px3rr Aren't they all?

    • @shadowwriter4538
      @shadowwriter4538 5 лет назад

      ikr

    • @simon-px3rr
      @simon-px3rr 5 лет назад +1

      @@deaconfrost9 yeah. Just got to the point, it's like a chapter book. You have to get through hundreds of pages for nothing

  • @shawnstoner7867
    @shawnstoner7867 4 года назад

    I think it was bill asking around that did it. No bill didnt tell anyone exactly and thats why Milton didnt mention him but if he managed to find out by asking then someone could of told the pinkertons when they realized bill was back n the gang prob was to if he was asking where they were.

  • @dr.skulhamr3220
    @dr.skulhamr3220 4 года назад

    Love that Hungarian Half Bred Piebald Tobiano. I need a dozen more openings in my stable.

  • @rasmusdamkjr5270
    @rasmusdamkjr5270 4 года назад +2

    4:09 u can actually read the note ur self-that's what I did

  • @michealhagner9556
    @michealhagner9556 5 лет назад

    Dude if you kill those pinkertons at shadie Bell they cant tell mr Milton Where to search

  • @darthwalrus1327
    @darthwalrus1327 2 года назад

    You can also read the letter to get to the location and I believe you take it in your satchel

  • @lagging38828
    @lagging38828 3 года назад

    i didn't ride my horse to shady belle, i had to walk.

  • @brettstover1850
    @brettstover1850 5 лет назад

    It was still Micah because I killed all the Pinkerton’s at the old hideout. So they never read the letter

  • @BBPinkyairsoft
    @BBPinkyairsoft 4 года назад

    I felt for Jack 5 year old being a shot

  • @god_d_doflamingo8415
    @god_d_doflamingo8415 5 лет назад +2

    spoiler alert nothing interesting or fascinating happens expect the same treatment for gta 5 as well.

    • @theniteinrusteearmour5354
      @theniteinrusteearmour5354 5 лет назад +1

      @Jamir Baker At this point, there is no spoilers for his videos. They're all stupid.

    • @jdy-ew5gj
      @jdy-ew5gj 5 лет назад

      @Jamir Baker lol 6 year old Jamir getting pissed at people "spoiling" 10 minute videos lol

  • @riley4198
    @riley4198 Год назад

    Dude they literally stated in the game that Bill definitely led them back to the camp

  • @BenderDigital
    @BenderDigital 4 года назад

    Yeah, but this is all predicated on the assumption that the player doesn't take the note and kill the Pinkerton Scouts which, even if they found the note, would render this moot.

    • @airhorn07
      @airhorn07 4 года назад

      No it was Bill, because right after bill came the Pinkertons came

  • @BuckBeakGaming
    @BuckBeakGaming 5 лет назад +10

    Duh it's Micah Bell running that mouth he's been running his mouth most likely since even before chapter 1 I'll give you an great example of this in chapter 3 when you have to meet Micah Bill and Sean and when sean gets shot in the head they could have killed any of you but I think it's just really odd that they chose to not shoot Micah they probably let Micah live because he's running his mouth to both the Braithwaites and the Greys and the same in Chapter 2 when Leviticus Cornwall finds y'all and in chapter 4 when the bank job gets ruined and how the pinkertons were able to easily captured Hosea why you think that is Michael Bell running his mouth so much even though Milton says that Micah had been working with them after guarma I just don't believe that I believe he's been working with him since like even before the Blackwater Ferry job

    • @kwaltze
      @kwaltze 5 лет назад

      Literally both of the families are not with the Pinkertons tf u talking about

    • @gimpyoutplayed5816
      @gimpyoutplayed5816 5 лет назад

      And when they killed Sean they didn't kill bill or Arthur either it's just because in the cutscene Sean goes separate from them he goes in front which would make him a easy target

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 4 года назад

      No actualy the game would say that but no the strange man in the ferry was and saw john and the gang said and said to the pikertins

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 4 года назад

      And why actualy bill and arthur live? The families cannot work with the pikertons they aint even know them

  • @dariushardin1942
    @dariushardin1942 3 года назад

    I still believe that Micah is a rat cause agent Milton said it himself that they picked Micah up after Arthur got back from the Caribbean

  • @sanchezmoonias8986
    @sanchezmoonias8986 4 года назад

    At shady belle when Arthur goes outside to help sadie Adler.. one of those Odriscols say " micah told us " sounded like it to me plus micah wasn't there at all at camp when the shoot out happened and I'm sure micah bell took Kieran Duffy back to colm... micah was playing it from both sides tipped off the Pinkertons and colms crew since chapter 1 micah bells the rat reason why dutch shoots micah at the ending..

  • @naser77naser41
    @naser77naser41 5 лет назад +2

    My boi arther is Right the gang got slopper than a fat house cat 🤠

    • @naser77naser41
      @naser77naser41 5 лет назад

      @Comment Cop can't catch me Police boah

  • @lordralph3730
    @lordralph3730 4 года назад

    It was Micah and bill Micah was picked up by Pinkertons and bill asked people where the gang where

  • @amycummings9441
    @amycummings9441 3 года назад

    Yeah, but you kill them pinkertons before they have a chance to tell anyone where the camp is at.

  • @thecowboy9698
    @thecowboy9698 4 года назад

    Thought about the Pinkertons finding Sadie's note, and that's what led them there. Thought about maybe it was Bill who inadvertently led them there, seeing as he shows up seconds before Milton does, and he asked all over where to find them.
    Or it could've been Micah who led them there.
    I thought that all through when I played the game the first time around.
    But, who cares? I say leave it to the writers.

  • @element9808
    @element9808 5 лет назад

    And yet, uncle still has his lumbago

  • @nojopro908
    @nojopro908 4 года назад

    It can't be Micah Because the pinkertons picked him up before He knew about the new camp

  • @Princessorginal
    @Princessorginal 4 года назад

    Arthur is 36 but he looks like someone in the 40s

  • @mourninggirl8825
    @mourninggirl8825 3 года назад

    They find it cuz you're literally just off the road.

  • @BreakHarpe
    @BreakHarpe Год назад

    Man I love ur red dead 2 videos

  • @pedrohenriquecanciamsantar2044
    @pedrohenriquecanciamsantar2044 4 года назад

    I think Micah is more slippery than Milton

  • @Jennifer-jt9cb
    @Jennifer-jt9cb 3 года назад

    It was Bill asking around all over trying to find everyone. Arthur can pick up the letter before the Pinkertons find it. If Bill had kept his trap shut, or pretended to be a bounty hunter or something, then he may have been able to find everyone without the Pinkertons following his dumb ass. I'm sure Micah helped them find the gang. There's no doubt in my mind about that. But Bill was the big player in them being caught with their pants down.

  • @talynburton657
    @talynburton657 5 лет назад +1

    But, how would they have known, if u already picked up the letter?

  • @prarora333
    @prarora333 4 года назад

    I found that letter before the Pinkertons caught hold of it and Arthur took it and kept it in his satchel. According to me it's Bill

  • @marioandultrachap
    @marioandultrachap 2 года назад

    1. Sadie is the most tokenized character in the game obviously.
    2. Yeah I don't think it was Micah why would Micah endanger himself like that and allow himself to be killed like that. I think they picked him up after this situation. Makes no sense as to why he would endanger himself like that

  • @nicholaslindenmeyer6472
    @nicholaslindenmeyer6472 8 месяцев назад

    Yeah but even if they did find the letter you (Arthur) kill them before they leave the house preventing their knowledge of the letter getting out.

  • @Jack_EFC
    @Jack_EFC 5 лет назад

    Because they had been there since before chapter 5. They moved around after the bank mission goes south and your on the boat.

  • @jay-joquendo9892
    @jay-joquendo9892 4 года назад

    bill found the pingkertens and used him to check if its a trap atall

  • @nonexzistantred
    @nonexzistantred 4 года назад

    My question is; why doesn't the gang kill the Pinkertons when they find the camp.

  • @charlesarayata7203
    @charlesarayata7203 4 года назад

    I actually found the letter immediately I did not climb up stairs, so I did not see this cut scene.