How To Install a Skylight | This Old House

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 янв 2025

Комментарии • 188

  • @j8lech
    @j8lech 4 года назад +67

    I wish they would add like an extra 10 seconds at the end to show the finished product.

  • @BigcatMilo
    @BigcatMilo 4 года назад +70

    They are 10 ft off the ground and have 20 ft of slack of rope 🤣

    • @glassdogangle
      @glassdogangle 3 года назад +1

      And they kept tripping all over the rope. Rube Goldberg would be proud.

    • @jasonbooher4084
      @jasonbooher4084 2 года назад +3

      Don't forget the 6ft from the shock arrestor.

    • @elimartin5105
      @elimartin5105 Год назад

      Osha didnt say how much rope you need..

    • @Vothtrucks
      @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад +1

      ...... and on a 2/12 pitch too ! The one guy rode his bike to the job and had to wear a foam hat for safety . Any man that does this type of work sees how those ropes just keep getting in the way..... and nearly trips them up . Men..... we had better get this s%@ pushed back...... or very soon we wont be able to make a living .!

  • @lidex
    @lidex 5 лет назад +15

    Good to see Norm, the master carpenter. How many times did I watch the new yankee workshop completely hungover.

  • @rawbacon
    @rawbacon 5 лет назад +23

    "Norm & Charlie framed for the skylight"......Poor forgotten Carly.

  • @HarrisonD1981
    @HarrisonD1981 5 лет назад +6

    Norm omg I missed seeing this guy, new yankee's workshop, and the original second in command with Bob. Hell yea

  • @rdy4trvl
    @rdy4trvl 4 года назад +3

    7:15 Why does the curb overhang by 3/4" ...for drywall? And the interior of the curb will simply be painted? Also at 7:15 looks like they installed hangers for the joist headers which were not shown during the interior video shoot.

  • @davcot3675
    @davcot3675 5 лет назад +16

    I know when I watch TOH I am going to see the job done right by confident experienced experts
    So many hacks out there
    I always learn something

  • @mpwall123
    @mpwall123 5 лет назад +10

    Man...fine, rough, structural-carpentry, and furniture making. Is there anything Norm doesn’t do? Amazing guy.

  • @edlauren9434
    @edlauren9434 2 года назад +1

    Very helpful video. Thank you!

  • @ericr2zz
    @ericr2zz 5 лет назад +8

    No insulation around the skylight frame that extends above the roofline?

    • @probuilder6828
      @probuilder6828 4 года назад +3

      Eric R
      Nope. It isn’t necessary as the dimensional lumber if rubber applied tight, is a good enough insulator to avoid frost or condensation.

  • @jugalsharma8151
    @jugalsharma8151 3 года назад

    Awesome as always thank for the video

  • @DB_-
    @DB_- 3 года назад

    At 7:44 I don't know how much help that safety harness with 30 feet of slack rope on a 10-foot drop is going to be.)) But, I love the show and the work is top-notch!

    • @shaunpage4498
      @shaunpage4498 2 года назад

      Definitely they would never wear those if they weren't on camera.

  • @divyanshuarora1
    @divyanshuarora1 Год назад

    i believe the roof frame curb is not sitting flush with the inside. when they will do drywall inside, it will be zigzag. or is there another soultion to fix that ?

  • @DM-sb8tx
    @DM-sb8tx 2 года назад

    How much is the installation cost?

  • @merlinbrubaker1163
    @merlinbrubaker1163 4 года назад

    Those long screws are awesome. Anyone know what they are? Spax?

  • @andrewjames4346
    @andrewjames4346 5 лет назад +10

    Good video but I have to issue you with a STOP card and ask you to take a TOFS...there is more slack in your safety line than the height of the roof meaning you will simply go SPLAT (technical term from oil industry)...

    • @andrewjames4346
      @andrewjames4346 5 лет назад

      @DR PHIL agreed...i work ropes on the rigs and it's always getting on or off that cause the issues...but for tv shouldn't they at least be safe...broken back can still happen from 17'

    • @lennynelsons
      @lennynelsons 4 года назад

      Calm down nerd. Looks like he made it out alive.

    • @Vothtrucks
      @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад

      There is a time ( in an experiencied carpenters thoughts ) when so called " safety equipment " can trip you up and send you off the roof.... not keep you safe...... and people need to use their heads at times .

  • @MichelleGlauser
    @MichelleGlauser 8 месяцев назад

    So curious what the finished skylight looked like from inside.

  • @hjwang4477
    @hjwang4477 5 лет назад +1

    What’s the lifetime for rubber roof? Is it shorter than shingle?

    • @lidex
      @lidex 5 лет назад

      Always a maintenance time. Some longer than others

  • @azarakhzari5103
    @azarakhzari5103 8 месяцев назад

    How much it cost?

  • @numb3r458
    @numb3r458 5 лет назад +6

    Norm's back...wow...thought this was an old episode they were just uploading.

  • @shawnpa
    @shawnpa 3 года назад

    Beautiful.

  • @robertoler3795
    @robertoler3795 5 лет назад

    well done and of course what a treat

  • @matthewvandam4701
    @matthewvandam4701 2 года назад

    Never seen the code call for screws on hangers.... Also, what sense does it make to have hangers on single joists when the new double joists they're nailed to doesn't use hangers?

    • @shaunpage4498
      @shaunpage4498 2 года назад

      It's because those doubles they were nailed to are sitting on top of load bearing walls. They don't need any hangers.

    • @matthewvandam4701
      @matthewvandam4701 2 года назад

      @@shaunpage4498 no comment on the screws then?

    • @TheRayDog
      @TheRayDog 10 месяцев назад

      I think it's optional rather than code. Structural screws. I prefer them to nails in many cases.

  • @j.lo.5996
    @j.lo.5996 4 года назад +2

    WOW, such an unsafe practice at minute 2:01 - 2:03. Someone could've gotten hurt pretty bad.

  • @godbluffvdgg
    @godbluffvdgg 5 лет назад +4

    I only do skylights on shingle roofs... I always passed on flat roof installs...I've done too many repairs from other peoples installations...

    • @bigvegass
      @bigvegass 5 лет назад +3

      So....not skilled enough to do flat roofs then? Gotcha

    • @godbluffvdgg
      @godbluffvdgg 5 лет назад +25

      @@bigvegass ...Oh, Wes, you silly boy!..A shingle roof is actually harder because of step and head flashings... I don't do them because flat roofs are notorious for leaks and if you go on one and do a repair and the roof gets a leak ANYWHERE you will get the call for it...It's called "limiting liability" ..... You'd understand if you owned a construction business....

    • @GlitchedPepsi
      @GlitchedPepsi 4 года назад

      ROB-IN-PHILLY lol calm down

    • @jackmyhre8759
      @jackmyhre8759 2 года назад

      I worked for an old man doing so yard work when I was in highschool. He told me that there’s only 3 guarantees in life.
      1.) Death
      2.) Taxes
      3.) and a flat roof will leak
      He built his house in the 70’s and made that mistake along with 4 leaky skylights.

  • @dancooper3066
    @dancooper3066 3 года назад

    how do you install and waterproof a skylight on an existing torch down flat roof

  • @James-wk5mj
    @James-wk5mj 4 года назад +1

    Charlie is the real backbone of Silva Bros lunchpale guy dosent need all that fancy Festool 1000$ this and Festool 800$ domino joiner that Practical man

  • @UncleBuck560
    @UncleBuck560 3 года назад

    Norm Abram has to be the best carpenter in the world!

  • @dagnabit29
    @dagnabit29 7 месяцев назад

    What insulates that as it is part of the light shaft and wood is not a good insulater

  • @The32bitVideos
    @The32bitVideos 5 лет назад +5

    That flashing job is done so wrong. The rubber should I be pinched under curb with a separate wall sheet or fasteners around the curb and a separate wall sheet. That curb is going to bridge out in the future.

    • @chrishenderson5444
      @chrishenderson5444 2 года назад

      what do you mean bridge- out? i dont know much about roof installation but would like to install a skylight...

  • @VampireOnline
    @VampireOnline 5 лет назад +3

    NORM!

  • @douglassmith9818
    @douglassmith9818 3 года назад

    How was the interior finished? Drywall?

  • @nightreader4121
    @nightreader4121 4 года назад

    Doesn’t look like a VELUX unit. What is it?

  • @heroknaderi
    @heroknaderi 4 года назад

    Incredible

  • @hassanal-mosawi6049
    @hassanal-mosawi6049 5 лет назад +1

    Thanks for showing how and sharing that

  • @hammer86_
    @hammer86_ 5 лет назад +32

    "... and it'll never leak."
    Yeah, right.

    • @paulp1008
      @paulp1008 5 лет назад +6

      it`ll never leak for a few years : )

    • @b_rad5678
      @b_rad5678 5 лет назад

      Never a matter of if...but when...

  • @RC-Heli835
    @RC-Heli835 4 года назад +6

    I can just about bet you that most roofers don't take the time to do this leak proofing.
    One of my brand new sky lights covered the dining room table this morning with rain water.

  • @justinwoods240
    @justinwoods240 5 лет назад +1

    Charlie loves those nails he used like 20 nails on one board

  • @kyakarrenamiyaan
    @kyakarrenamiyaan 5 лет назад

    something soothing about watching old people work

  • @WDFH
    @WDFH 5 лет назад

    What about a shingled roof???

  • @donabele1243
    @donabele1243 5 лет назад +3

    Water tight...until it leaks!

  • @aiymankhan7222
    @aiymankhan7222 4 года назад +1

    1:18 I like the way he turned the gorilla's face to the camera

  • @Wastinglotsoftime
    @Wastinglotsoftime 5 лет назад +16

    I always love how this show has the home owners doing the most useless stuff to help.

    • @linkinprk1981
      @linkinprk1981 5 лет назад +9

      What homeowner? If you are referencing Carly - they clearly said and showed she was an apprentice, she even had the same company shirt as the other guy...

    • @MorganHunter92
      @MorganHunter92 5 лет назад

      @@linkinprk1981 hahaha that makes it way worse.

    • @myronward203
      @myronward203 4 года назад +2

      Probably liability reasons. Don't want anyone getting hurt.

  • @SteS
    @SteS 5 лет назад +1

    It fascinates me the difference in other countries. It must be a warm location with the thickness of the insulation in that roof which would be around 80mm here. It must be a very high-performance board for that thickness. Also, any kerbs where I'm from need a min of 25mm insulation as there's nothing preventing cold bridging and that 45-degree edge also made from insulation as opposed to that piece of timber to prevent the same thing. And any flat roof lights require a 3-degree pitch.

  • @bkoz319
    @bkoz319 5 лет назад +3

    leak waiting to happen

  • @Doobie2100
    @Doobie2100 5 лет назад

    Excellent work Carly and crew!!!

  • @BLODSWIPER
    @BLODSWIPER 4 года назад

    What's the "activator"?
    Non-English/American here btw.

    • @MK-qv7bq
      @MK-qv7bq 4 года назад +1

      The activator is a catalyst chemical that activates the glue on the non cured rubber to make it stronger and more adherent to the existing epdm roof.

  • @--2
    @--2 5 лет назад +7

    Why not aligning the skylight with the other skylight on the roof?

    • @Vothtrucks
      @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад

      It,s in a different room .....

  • @Macron87
    @Macron87 5 лет назад +8

    Water will puddle and settle on that flat roof light. It will look a dirty mess in a few weeks. Needs to have some drop on it.

    • @SteS
      @SteS 5 лет назад

      Yes, should have a 3-degree slope minimum.

    • @JosephWheeler14
      @JosephWheeler14 4 года назад

      MKRM27 rain won’t hurt it, it’s 0ppm in my area at least

  • @johnroberts9560
    @johnroberts9560 4 года назад +1

    Hi TOH , Wow that's a really nice skylight that you guys installed , what kind of glass is that , is it tempered in case of large hailstones or something else that might hit it ? 👍😊🛠

  • @lrodriguez9315
    @lrodriguez9315 5 лет назад

    She is good anybody notice the way she maneuvered that hammer.

  • @PatrickPoet
    @PatrickPoet 5 лет назад +1

    I love the way you guys keep working to bring the next generation in and super glad that you include women as well. Also, secretely, don't tell anyone, (shhhh), Tommy is my favorite on This Old House in this generation. Hope you have Carly's (sp?) on the show on the regular. It will attract a younger audience and keep things going. Boy, you can sure tell she's been slinging a hammer for quite awhile, back arm at a strange angle she's hitting with confidence. Wish she could have been in on the end. Remember when Tommy WAs the younger generation?
    If you didn't know about Tom and Tommy, you'd still be able to tell they worked together a lot, they work like a dream team, like one man with four hands, and they hammer exactly the same.

    • @lidex
      @lidex 5 лет назад +1

      Tommy is way knowledgeable. Half the time I have no idea what he's doing until it all comes together.

  • @sdolman79
    @sdolman79 5 лет назад +4

    Good job Tom arrived to make sure the job was done right.

  • @midian3288
    @midian3288 4 года назад +4

    "Bend it over... and nail it"

  • @michaeledwards2919
    @michaeledwards2919 Год назад

    Incomplete instruction on framing layouts. They forgot the width framing layout.

  • @SimonTekConley
    @SimonTekConley 3 года назад

    I wonder of they have skylight into metal roofs. It's hilarious that I have no issues with asphalt, and rubber roofs. Scared of a metal roof screwing it up.

  • @roccoconte2960
    @roccoconte2960 5 лет назад +2

    Why the hell didnt you put the skylight in before the rubber roof?

    • @NochEinKamel
      @NochEinKamel 5 лет назад

      Would have made a boring video

    • @Minzerr
      @Minzerr 5 лет назад

      As a roofer, It is actually easier and safer(leakage wise) to do it the way they did in the video. It is a huge pain to lay new rubber around curbs.

    • @John_GGG
      @John_GGG 5 лет назад

      But as the roofer, wouldn't you have rather done the job. Because you'll get the blame when it leaks? That is the inevitable weak spot, correct?

  • @dekor1981
    @dekor1981 5 лет назад +2

    The safety rope on your workers is greater than the height to the ground. So your workers will already fall to the ground, and the insurance will not work ....

  • @bbtank3000
    @bbtank3000 4 года назад

    Time for the real entertainment in the comments section where the experts weigh in.

    • @Vothtrucks
      @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад

      Nah...... Not really. The entertainment are the so called REAL pros who follow rules such as implementing slack safety ropes on a 2/12 pitch that nearly trip them as they attempt to work. Now THATS entertainment !

  • @notj5712
    @notj5712 5 лет назад +1

    wonder why they didn't double up at least one of the existing rafters instead of going between.....
    Weird.

    • @lidex
      @lidex 5 лет назад

      Because they know what they're doing.

    • @wenliu7875
      @wenliu7875 4 года назад

      Probably because the design calls for an exact location for the skylight.

    • @notj5712
      @notj5712 4 года назад

      @@lidex nah, not in this case.

  • @roccoconte2960
    @roccoconte2960 5 лет назад +4

    Deffenision of a sky light , whole in a perfectly good roof.

  • @dagnabit29
    @dagnabit29 7 месяцев назад

    Why wouldn’t they start with the corners and work there way up

  • @jameshoward8544
    @jameshoward8544 5 лет назад +1

    Im going to MAAAAAK it.

  • @CrunchyBaguette
    @CrunchyBaguette 4 года назад

    Shouldn’t those hangers been installed with nails instead of screws?

    • @MK-qv7bq
      @MK-qv7bq 4 года назад

      They are a special screw made for joist hangers.

  • @Nail56
    @Nail56 5 лет назад +1

    just curious.. where are the safety lines tied off?

    • @scallywag1716
      @scallywag1716 5 лет назад +5

      To one another. If one goes...they both go!

    • @chrisryan846
      @chrisryan846 5 лет назад +1

      They looked more for show then anything else.

    • @MrJramirex
      @MrJramirex 5 лет назад

      To air, it is clear they were not attached to anything but not clear enough for OSHA to make a case against them.

  • @AnthonyBehnk
    @AnthonyBehnk 5 лет назад

    Please do not apply sealant to the skylight lens. How do you suppose someone to take it off? It has a rubber seal inside the lens. Also you say in the video "it doesn't say to do this"

    • @AnthonyBehnk
      @AnthonyBehnk 5 лет назад

      @Joe T skylights tend to leak. Especially on shingle roofs. I work on then weekly.

    • @williamdillon7852
      @williamdillon7852 5 лет назад

      @Joe T Read B.Thomas comment , when it breaches out the corner sealing leaks . If someone needs sealant to make it work , u should figure out on ur own , that the stuff ur using isnt good .

  • @peterhanson3962
    @peterhanson3962 5 лет назад +1

    Just out of curiosity, why does Tommy pulse the trigger of the impact driver , rather than hold the trigger until the screws are driven all the way home?

    • @AnthonyBehnk
      @AnthonyBehnk 5 лет назад +3

      more control of the driver. Also prevents stripping

    • @RoastBeefSandwich
      @RoastBeefSandwich 5 лет назад

      makes sure they're getting started straight.

  • @ubacow7109
    @ubacow7109 2 года назад

    These episodes never show the finish or final steps like screwing it on or how it works afterwards

  • @chrisryan846
    @chrisryan846 5 лет назад

    I was always told to use nails in hangers and not screws and there not as strong. Can anyone tell me which is correct?

    • @williamdillon7852
      @williamdillon7852 5 лет назад

      Nails take the friction in , screws just break cause they are way harder . Nails it is .

    • @Vothtrucks
      @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад

      Anyone who tells you that a nail is stronger than a screw needs to change occupations.!

  • @sean5253
    @sean5253 5 лет назад

    Put you corners on so wrong on the epdm.

  • @itsthatonekid6188
    @itsthatonekid6188 5 лет назад +8

    Bring roger back

    • @MemoGrafix
      @MemoGrafix 5 лет назад +2

      Roger has been sick for awhile now. He only shows up once in awhile.

    • @someone321
      @someone321 5 лет назад

      MemoGrafix he actually doesn’t show up anymore... the videos you see him in are old ones being uploaded recently

    • @MemoGrafix
      @MemoGrafix 5 лет назад

      @@someone321 - I've seen a few where he's clearly not well from some illness, assuming those episodes are from last year or 2017 where TOH was transitioning of the female landscaper on TOH. He was doing more of the I guess supervising, not much work.

    • @staticcharm3808
      @staticcharm3808 5 лет назад

      He is sick

    • @someone321
      @someone321 5 лет назад

      MemoGrafix i agree, he does indeed look very ill

  • @cantstoptommy7077
    @cantstoptommy7077 2 года назад

    I reckon they'd hit the ground before all that slack in their safety ropes was taken up!

  • @scott6bartley496
    @scott6bartley496 5 лет назад +3

    Lose the safety Gear it's dangerous

  • @josephkrol1676
    @josephkrol1676 5 лет назад

    It's not a matter of if a skylight will leak it's a matter of when a skylight will leak

  • @mallengirl1834
    @mallengirl1834 5 лет назад +7

    Female Apprentice:- I'm really excited to do a sky light.
    Scene on roof:- two males doing the skylight????

    • @MrMattChristensen
      @MrMattChristensen 5 лет назад +2

      Maybe because of the rain? She could have been on another job site the follow up day.

    • @chocolate1donut
      @chocolate1donut 5 лет назад +1

      Its the patriarchy!!! Reeeee

    • @MemoGrafix
      @MemoGrafix 5 лет назад

      @super extreme David Piacenza - The only Women that don't belong on construction jobsites are those who's ...
      Pregnant or bring their children to get in the way
      Bimbos - the men won't do the job(s) right, because all their logic & skills will go straight to their *_"stiff members."_*
      Not trying to get dirty
      Afraid to sweat their *_"fake-up"_* off and/or break a sweat
      Construction *_"illiterate"_*
      Slow learners
      Scared to chip a manicured & polished fingernail
      The rest of Us Women who do construction work will do just fine of being part of the construction team.

    • @darylfitz4189
      @darylfitz4189 4 года назад

      She was busy down below polishing Normy’s wood.

  • @UncleBuck560
    @UncleBuck560 3 года назад

    I wonder if Norm has ever shot anyone with a nail gun for slacking off?

  • @sianahmad6018
    @sianahmad6018 Год назад

    😊

  • @rknotz187
    @rknotz187 2 года назад

    Charlie is a little intense!

  • @tombryan1
    @tombryan1 5 лет назад

    Who did the load calcs for the skylight? No permit or engineer, just hack out 3 joists and head them off? Really.

    • @Luckingsworth
      @Luckingsworth 4 года назад

      Permit? For a window? Only time I have ever heard of needing a permit for a window is on a second story that overlooks a neighbors yard

  • @mrswolls
    @mrswolls 5 лет назад +3

    I wonder if tom ever gets mad and just kicks the useless helper off a roof?

    • @pierreroy8124
      @pierreroy8124 5 лет назад

      mrswolls that’s his brother and company partner Charlie Silva

    • @mrswolls
      @mrswolls 5 лет назад

      @@pierreroy8124 i was just kidding, they do great work I'm a big fan 🍻

  • @pavelnesterov5554
    @pavelnesterov5554 5 лет назад +2

    Using roller on the rubber would of made you job way better and faster.

  • @matoko123
    @matoko123 4 года назад

    Harnesses on a flat roof !!!!

    • @brownwoodroofingohio8043
      @brownwoodroofingohio8043 4 года назад

      $13.5k 1st offense in Ohio without safety around an open roof or on a roof period

    • @matoko123
      @matoko123 4 года назад

      @@brownwoodroofingohio8043 Whoa. You'd be more likely to be fined for having any safety here in Bulgaria ;)

  • @ccorm3350
    @ccorm3350 5 лет назад

    ! Like everybody has a rubber-sealed roof !

  • @twelvethirtyfour
    @twelvethirtyfour 3 года назад

    Okay okay okay okay

  • @joseberistain3112
    @joseberistain3112 5 лет назад +1

    WHERE ARE THE FESTOL DRILL

  • @rewris
    @rewris 4 года назад +1

    22bahfawdiesix. Got it.

  • @aaronpthompson
    @aaronpthompson 5 лет назад +1

    *So Carly*

  • @pacificovw9522
    @pacificovw9522 5 лет назад

    Should have put a bead of sealant between that curb and the roof before you screwed it, and probably between every corner and nook and joint of that curb, but then...

  • @billsmith9249
    @billsmith9249 5 лет назад +3

    I hate how they make it look so easy. :(

  • @dandfgarage986
    @dandfgarage986 5 лет назад

    Sweeeeeeeeett

  • @opensourceguy730
    @opensourceguy730 4 года назад +1

    Nooorrrmmm!

  • @ivanbagual
    @ivanbagual 5 лет назад +2

    Tom silva has a Nice care on finishiment . The other guy not

  • @2aminitials
    @2aminitials 5 лет назад

    The people other than Norm must have forgotten the most important rule = to wear safety glasses (and not on top of your head).

  • @paulzapol2149
    @paulzapol2149 5 лет назад

    Their new videos are horrible!! Everybody in this one seems tired and not wanting to be there.

  • @Vothtrucks
    @Vothtrucks 9 месяцев назад

    What an embarrassment this show is for young men today ! I understand having a safety rope when working on a MAYBE 6/12 pitch and above but give me a break ! Guys walking on a nearly flat surface....... and moving the rope out of their way to work. Safety is important but they dont show how much time was spent connecting two ropes before they begin. When I was young I roofed a 4 way hip on the second story..... when it began to snow. That was a situation where we needed it. Today guys are unsure just what sex they are.... are told to act more like what used to be seen from ladies.... and install a safty rope when they walk down a street that goes slightly down hill. For one thing you couldnt make much money installing and carrying ropes and other " safety " items. Man up men ! Now if you wear a little purple foam hat when you ride your bike.... you,ve been eating too many Estrogen infused foods in my opinion. When you think that " Following the rules " is a sensible thing we should all do...... you need to take a closer look into who has come up with these rules..... and who REALLY benefits from us keeping on track with them all. Before you all start crying let me remind you that this stuff has become much more prohibitive to finishing our work in a timely manner since I was out there..... imagine ( if you let them ) how much more it will control your work down the road a bit ! What ! LOL..... You thought they were all done making tighter rules and codes !? LOL Wait until your sons get ready to build .

  • @lrodriguez9315
    @lrodriguez9315 5 лет назад

    Usually they use red chalk blue is used for mansonary work

  • @mnight207
    @mnight207 5 лет назад

    Who is this Charlie guy? He seems careless

  • @cupcakesansfrontier
    @cupcakesansfrontier 4 года назад

    That is SO gonna leak it's not even funny.

  • @malibudan
    @malibudan 3 года назад

    SLOPPY

  • @scallywag1716
    @scallywag1716 5 лет назад

    "Water tight"...that's what she said.