@Kase Trey exactly i fucking hate it when losers like that have this sick demented fetish for having blood related children when there are so many damn kids in the world who would do anything for a loving home with parents. Adoption is the only answer people need to stop giving birth to kids they never planned on having.
Well if this is possible, the trans woman would only be able to do a c section. There is no way she could deliver vaginally. And they have to do c section with epidural. So no, the question will never be answered in that way 😅 But I could tell you the answer, think you know already tho lmfao.
Most of women want to have another baby, even after they experienced horrendous pain during delivery. On the other hand, I have never heard a guy ask for another kick in the balls. I hope that helps. Just to make clear and avoid polemical responses, this is a joke.*
@@ElMizuki women are designed to forget the pain of giving birth so that they will continue to reproduce, so that doesn't matter at all lmao, and I could tell you plenty of men who would gladly take a kick to the balls if it meant they could have a kid smh 😒
you know that before puberty, the male and female pelvis are identical right? its that the estrogen in the females body morphs the bones while they are still able to be shaped (until roughly the age of 25). Its the same reason men have broader shoulder bones.
Most people are immediately like going transphobic on this which sucks. But like if he does it, it would be a literal medical break through. If you could do it with trans women fully. Then you should be able to apply some of the process to infertile women
@@unimunoz1159 the process has already been applied to an infertile woman if i am not mistaken, it worked. but really the only reason most people would get it is because of the influence of transphobia, “you dont have a uterus and cant get pregnant!” its risky but someone might be so fed up with this shit that they wont be clear headed.
Well, starting hormones replacement therapy and hormone blockers early on while the bones are still developing would solve that. Also there are people who are intersex. Aaaaaand every body is different. Im not a doctor, so id leave it up to them to assess risks.
The pelvic region in a woman is able to expand during pregnancy. And it's shaped different to allow for the baby to fit. Multiple hormones work together in a pregnancy.
Yes there a separation of the pubic bones a joint called the pubic symphysis and with pregnancy the hormones allow this area to soften and stretch to allow a baby to pass through. I really don’t know if they could artificially make it happen. But if a man ever succeeds in getting and carrying a pregnancy I bet they might give birth once but never again. Why? You ask because they are pretty big babies about pain. Women have had years of period cramps to get used to having that horrible pelvic pain but I can’t imagine a man doing it more than once. My husband would faint at the sight of blood especially his own. He was a huge big baby about any illness. I would kind of like to see it happen because I think it would be Justice. Men make lousy mothers too because they were never supposed to be.
@@patriciasmith7074 Maybe men would actually feel less pain with this one because their nervous system isn't really wired to have a womb. Though the other pains of pregnancy, like back pain etc would still be present I guess
@@godhateseveryonewhodoesntr5977 Yes you have a point! But the pubic bone didn’t cause pain on me, it only made me walk funny, kind of like a duck waddles. It was embarrassing to me because my mother was always so critical of the way I walked liked my dad’s big sister and mom thought his sister walked unladylike. So here I was feeling ugly and fat and we went to a formal dance and my mother looked gorgeous in a blue velvet dress and I was clumsy and fatter than my mom and she made me feel ugly but I was pregnant with my daughter which I was thrilled about having a baby. Way back then they didn’t know the sex of your baby till it was born. It didn’t help because my stupid husband told me how great my mother looked that night. I had done her hair and makeup and made her look fabulous and everybody raved at how beautiful she was. Pretty hard for a young first time pregnant young married woman to hear how gorgeous her mother is!
@@patriciasmith7074Jus be happy you are pregnant....some women have a hard time conceiving and having healthy babies...your family sounds toxic....I'm sorry....
@@honeybadgerknockoutbadgers9642 Yes my mom didn’t love me because my conception made her get married at 17. She always claimed she didn’t know that act resulted in a pregnancy and her mom was a widow with two other daughters so her mom found out she was pregnant and said get married now. Luckily my dad was a good guy and he loved her and wasn’t opposed to the idea. He had just come home from WWII. She only really wanted her two boys. I knew I wasn’t important to her so I was glad to get married and move out. I tried to win her over but she never changed. So I gave up trying.
You need a uterus, ovaries, Hypothalamic-Pituitary- Ovarian axis. Pitocin, oxytocin etc…. It talks a whole lot of chemistry and biology to make and carry a pregnancy to term successfully
@@user-rw6ui5nv5i yes many hormones are found in men and women in significantly varying quantities, but it takes all of these ingredients and more to work symbiotically to make and carry a baby to term. REAL WOMEN with all of the parts and ingredients sometimes have difficulties. Medical science can’t help infertile REAL women 100% of the time. Now they want to try to help the build a chic 🤦🏾♀️ ok
Just because we *can* attempt something scientifically, doesn't always mean we should try. In this case I wouldn't suggest it's transphobic to say that... Trans people going through multiple surgical procedures are already facing enough of a health risk. After all those elements, why risk losing your life for the pursuit of something that at this point in the debate shouldn't have to validate your gender? Trans healthcare should be a specific and much further funded/researched field of medicine.
Frankly with all of the more dystopian technology that exists at this point I think letting trans women finally birth their own kids is a beautiful and valid use of it. We live in a world where we rot our brains with social media and put creatives out of a job with AI. Letting consenting adults attempt a risky affirmation surgery is the least harmful thing we've done to society in decades. Let them try.
@newyoutubeaccount2023 you don't need to go through a whole medical procedure to die if that's really what your aim is buddy. im not saying you should, just saying surgery isn't the only thing in the world that will kill you and i'm sure u know this
@newyoutubeaccount2023 I want to die without pain too but that's not gonna happen. Even dying from old age has pain involved, I watched my great grandmother die from old age. Not fun. But also, I've had two whole surgeries in my lifetime that I could've died from. Still extruciatingly painful as soon as the anesthesia wears off. I had c-sections, where I was cut into 7 layers of skin to cut into my uterus and pull my babies out. Felt nothing during the procedure, but just an hour afterwards was screaming from pain, begging for medicine. A c-section itself increases the risk of hemorrhaging, infections, and death. To hope u die from something painless, it's more than likely not going to happen painlessly if you do die.
@@melynn_0355no u couldnt why do you think the only differenc men and women have is in body? We literally have different fucking chromosomes a man has YX and a woman has XX lets say somehow a man get a uterus and another man wants to make a baby with him Do you know what kind of a mutated freak a YY chromosome creature could look like???? It would be basically dead within minutes of being out Fucking delusional people not knowing about biology
Actually the main problem is body chemistry. A male body isn't designed to support a uterus no matter how many hormones you give them. Womens bodies literally have so many systems that support the uterus, from our digestive and endocrine systems to pituitary glands, and separate functions in the brain. All of those things are literally designed in women to support the uterus and child birth. If you can't rewire those systems in a man, then the body will always reject the organ.
Fuckin same dude. I've discovered there are four types of comments in this comment thread. 1) people fully supporting the idea 2) people fully against the idea and calling anyone involved monsters 3) infertile women professing their "boo hoo poor me", like we haven't spent the last hundred years and billions of dollars researching female fertility. 4) and finally the me and you's.
I knew exactly what I was getting into, lol. I have a day with nothing to do. I happen to be a biological woman with a child just trying to share the facts with others who may not be aware of what happens during pregnancy. I'm not even taking a political stance here and don't really mind whose side anyone is one. I just wanted to state some facts today. Though the one opinion I do state is that I feel that it is selfish. So that is an opinion- not a fact.😄
@@commandershepard4235 Im in the: How would that even work anatomically?? Would that even be safe for her if we sorted out the hormones etc?? Like with our current technology and medicine it does not seem plausible to end well for any mtf trans women who want to get the surgery done
As a pregnant woman I’ll say watching the way my body AUTOMATICALLY knows what to do to hormonally and chemically carry a baby, the male body does not have the hormonal ecosystem to support a uterus. There’s more to it than just an organ.
@@mopippenger7373 clearly it’s not because trans women on hrt still can’t get pregnant or receive a uterus that doesn’t become septic and kill them. It must be more than JUST hormones.
@@mopippenger7373 into women?? Because the bio men who received a uterus transplant did not survive very long because their bodies did not have the ECOSYSTEM to support it.
There is a lot of things a womans body and immune systems are doing during a pregnancy, the hormonal phone is adjusted very carefully by the body itself. Even if he succeeds implanting the uterus, and somehow we put someone's impregnated egg in there, the poor fetus will not be able to develop into a normal child. It's insane.
A woman's body goes through immense changes during pregnancy. Just getting a uterus stuffed into your abdomen isn't enough to prepare your body for what happens during pregnancy. The hormonal changes that are required to sustain the life of that child are insane. Not to mention the physiological changes that occur that the female body is literally made to endure. This experiment if so incredibly selfish. It's not just their life they are endangering. They would be endangering the life of the child they would be attempting to carry. It's like when trans women try lactating. Their bodies are literally not made to produce the nutrition required to sustain a baby. I'm not trying to be mean- I'm being factual here. Just let a biological woman carry the baby. It's safer for all parties involved. Stop trying to do something that your body quite literally cannot do. Your bones are not made to move the way women's bones are during child birth. Just let it go and be happy with all the other changes that can be done to your body. This is ridiculous.
Yes this was just a small clip from the podcast but there are numerous hormonal; anatomical and ethical obstacles to consider which makes this very unlikely in the near future anyway
@@nhehe10 the doctors who think they can do it defenitly have some major problem and shouldnt even try it, much like the doctors who do sex change opperations on kids
...master of logical fallacies lol. That's just a medical fad that died out, there was no advancement in the field. What's going to improve? Flow rate? You can't really improve something that doesn't work. The wives tale still exists today just as arcaic "just pee on jellyfish stings and it's cured" 1.) It doesn't work 2.) Seems exactly like how it was in Victorian times with no advancements. Atleast with lgbt they succeeded in their goal and have had advancements, originally people like emperors elagabalus would just wear female sex worker clothing and act like women. Now they can slice and dice their bodies any way they want.
Everyone's saying "You don't just need a Uterus to get pregnant!" as if this doctor doesn't know that and all the other stuff needed is probably where a big chunk of the challenge comes from
@@nono_noxx most likely they havent and all they are trying to do is be the first to do it to get fame and not giving a fuck about the complications it will bring to their testsubject.
@@gurgangurganstumph7172they're trying to be the first to successfully do it. If you actually watched the short, youll hear that its already been done before but unsuccessfully
Yes. The blood supply alone is increased 45-50 procent during pregnancy plus hundreds of other factors. It's a really really long shot to make this possible.
Or considering saving a life via organ donation! Daily people like me are dying awaiting for a life saving organ. I want to start a family too but can’t on dialysis. Kidney transplant would make me healthy enough to have my dream
I'm reading a lot of uninformed nonsense around here. Correct an cis man is not going to give birth. He has the wrong hormones. Trans women are given the correct hormones. A uterus transplant with ovaries if that ever becomes possible. Is not just for pregnancy. But it could allow a trans fem person to discontinue HRT. Weather a pregnancy is advisable is between them and their doctor. Many cis women are advised aginst giving birth for a myriad of reasons. It's a step of scientific progress. It should be applauded.
I am a transgender man, and I think that the issue a lot of trans people seem to have is this dire need to replace their organs to be "real," men or women. It just doesn't work like that. Sorry. I understand that it's painful to not have something you feel your supposed to have, but there are some things that just can't happen, and we have to accept that and stop being delusional. You can dress, present, and identify as a woman. Or a man. But you should NOT cut yourself up and shit to try and make yourself feel whole, when you won't. Hormones? Sure. They do a lot of good when used right, but a uterus can't be in a man's body. And honestly, from personal experience and experience from most women I've encountered, having a uterus BLOWS. Just adopt a baby ffs. It sounds insensitive but, don't kill yourself chasing something that is genuinely, physically, not meant to be housed by your body.
The idea of pregnancy and childbirth as a biological woman scares the bejeesus out of me... I couldn't even imagine the concept of trying to surgically implant a functioning organ that has such a minimal chance of acceptance by the body's biology. Hormones and cosmetic/plastic surgery are already major things for a person to undertake... But the amount of risk and potential for the body to reject the whole darn uterus, get infected and just die would be enormous... I'd rather adopt or use a surrogate and still be able to live to raise a baby than even consider this. What if the surgeon after all that would be like "it's just for show, don't get pregnant because you will die"
trans dude here, with full intent to medically reassign myself in years to come. i agree that its real dangerous for trans women to implant a uterus because its not supposed to be there, and generally the hip bones are too narrow to have any real chance of developing a child. i believe medically transitioning is fine if the person fully believes it will make them feel more at peace, but implanting a uterus is playing god. it wont work, youd need to replace a lot of stuff including bone which would cause a whole amalgamation of health problems
What's something special about giving birth anyway? Tbh I'd rather eat my own shit than give birth Besides, like you said, there's plenty kids around the world. People should provide love and care for someone who needs them. We don't need more kids. We need more good parents
I'm guessing they'd have to have a caesarean section. Ethically this is wrong - not just the danger to the trans person but also to any subsequent baby.
I think there is an ethical concern on the sourcing of these uterus. Like older women’s uterus are going to have scar tissue. This mean younger women uterus are going to be needed leaves open for more human trafficking. And if a cis woman and a transwoman are both on a waiting list. The viability of a successful uterus transplant will always lie with a cis woman. Also a uterus transplant can only be used once. Meaning if they wanted multiple children they need multiple uterus transplants. Not to mention this surgery is unsuccessful in most cis women.
I think you could bypass that -- C-sections already exist. I feel like issues like hormone and chemical balances and signals would be a much bigger issue. Getting a uterus in without it rejecting seems like the start of an uphill battle tho, u right about that Edit: y'all stop coming at me. I stated that my opinion that getting the hormones and chemical pathways right are wwaaaaayyy more difficult to overcome than the physical parts of such a procedure, like bone modification or the insertion of a uterus. I'm not saying "teehee no problem bones are easy peasy." Im saying doctors don't even know all the chemical intricacies of what's going on in bio women's reproductive systems. Much less during pregnancy. How tf are they gonna replicate it in a trans woman.
I think it would be a c section, because they remove the uterus after the pregnancy, too. At least when they do a uterus transplant for a cis woman that's what they do
Not really. While hip bones can be used *with other factors* to help determine sex of a skeleton there's plenty of overlap between male and female humans. If you'd need to do surgery on most males to give birth a very large % of females would also need surgery. Like a third.
@@iamthebean940 people get C sections for a miriad of reasons, not just one.... Do your.... Basic human.... Thinking???? What do i even say here you're just delusional
At least in my country, adoption is not legally possible for anyone that isn't a heterosexual couple. Even in a homosexual couple, you can't be legally recognized as the parent of your partner's biological children, which means that if something were to happen to the kid's biological parent, you would have to engage a long legal battle in order to keep caring for them. It sucks. It would be awesome if everyone could apply to take kids out of the system, but taking a look at the current situation, I can't blame anyone that chooses extreme measures in order to have a biological child
@@bleachnbones7107 In the US even if you were able to get through the massively strenuous and difficult process of adoption, adopting a single child generally starts at around $35,000 (and thats not counting all the actual costs to actually adopting a child and beginning to care for them, thats just the fees). It's pretty impossible for the average person to be able to do.
The problems arise more with actual pregnancy as there is a very specific and needed hormonal process involved that requires the ovaries and the brain, not just the uterus. Certain hormones are produced at specific times to ensure that a fetus can actually develop and go to term. And the complex muscle contractions and hormones released to cause said contractions. Its a delicate process of balance and timing. If ever this can be achieved it will be incredibly innovative, but at the same time the whole process would be incredibly complicated. Edit: To clarify I am not against the research, I'm just worried about the people who want to be the test subjects for this kind of thing. It is a LOT to go through and it needs to be studied extensively. Transplants are already a huge risk to the body. Transplanting an organ as complicated as a full female reproductive system adds so much more to the complexity. Trying to make it function as intended is even more complex. You need so many different neural, endocrine, and exocrine parts to work correctly, and it has to be in perfect balance.
i feel similarly; It isn't as easy as just slapping the thing into a male, but if someone thinks out all of the resulting issues and questions, and it, yknow, works..? Honestly, i'd be ultimately impressed.
Yeah, that's my main concern as well. I wish trans women could carry their own children like cis women but pregnancy is such a complicated and delicate thing. I don't know if anything like an artificial uterus (alongside the hormones) can ever be made. I hope trans women will have an option like that in the future but the way science is now (and how unsupported trans people are) I don't know how long it will take.
@@pixelatra_ As one myself & a bit of a science nerd I have no doubt that conditions for an “artificial” pregnancy can be made in the future esp with how science has developed technologies like cloning, I don’t feel the need for it myself however it is a really interesting thought to me
Okay I'm a physical therapist and let me tell you something. The male pelvis is not formed to have a baby it is that simple. People are going wild these days to achieve something.
@@eldritch_Sage doctors are not perfect. with my last pregnancy i went into labor two days before my planned c-section. i went to the hospital immediately where my doctor told me "i'm going to give you medicine to slow down your contractions and send you home" and i have heard of stories like this where women are sent home by their doctors and later either end up giving birth on the way back to the hospital to straight up dying. so i said no to the medicine and labored unmedicated for 12 hours. at the end of 12 hours, i still haven't dilated past 3cm. my doctor admitted defeat and said he would perform the c-section on me in the morning. his initial plan was to send me home and perform the surgery two days later, on the initially planned date. so just because someone is a doctor doesn't mean lives haven't been unnecessarily lost
They stop at nothing! Let them create Frankenstein babies 😂playing god never works out and never will………the amount of genetic defects that aren’t even discovered that 2 males would create! These people and demonic doctors are literally killing people…
If there were no major medical ramifications, I would donate my uterus in a heartbeat to someone who really wanted it. I love being a woman, but I have no plans for pregnancy and my uterus has been nothing but an annoyance my entire life.
Yeah, but so is transplanting it to another woman. Personally I don't get peoples need to biologically reproduce, but the force do be strong for some people. And for them it's worth it
@@za.monolit Well I don't feel it. I want children, but no biological ones and I do not get how people specifically want their children to be biological. Like, obv I know that that's a thing, I just don't understand it
@@Maura237 uterus can be implanted in a women with defected uterus bc she already had one at that place they just have to remove one and add another where tf are they gonna add in a man and the difference between angles of pelvic bones in males and females makes it more complicated
@@Maura237 people want biological child bcz it's their own blood their own bloodline continues I belongs to a dynasty that rules North india for around 120+ years why I wanna end my royal bloodline?
The entire human society is a struggle against nature, technology is not natural,your phone is not natural, cars are not natural, our institutions are not natural, language is not natural, medicine is not natural etc. To stop "playing" with nature is an insult to the things human society has done.
There was a tiktok personality who wants a uterus implant so he can have the first abortion after an implant, I'm completely disgusted at this kind of absolute selfishness.
@@a_donut4823 It was a joke towards christians who are transphobic. They're a bunch of idiots why would anyone care what they think is scientifically possible anyways?
I don't even know how to react to that! I get it for women who have uterus issues, but so many things beside a uterus is needed and even some women can't take that type of shock to the body (like all transplant surgeries). I get it some want that transition, but we are barely doing this for women - See if this works first! There is so much about women's bodies that some male doctors don't get! I know I have had a couple that thought menstrual cramps were nothing and women who are pregnant just want special treatment! I hope they don't say that to their wives and daughters!
@@ami.2327 i don't think It can be called an organ, it is more of endo-layer of epithelial actually formed just to provide nutrition, an organ is a group of tissues, but placenta is not a complete tissue it is more of cytosolic-group of cells
@@heheboi9823 Please do your research. Placenta is a group of tissues, thus called an organ. Cytosol is the liquid matrix found inside cells. Placenta is not a liquid substance. If you haven't seen one, please Google it.
@@heheboi9823 Also, it does all the work of lungs, liver, kidneys etc. It not just provides the baby with oxygen and nutrients but also removes waste and carbon dioxide from the baby. It also produces hormones that help the baby grow. It's an organ that detaches itself from the uterus after the baby gets out of the same.
Yes and it's incredibly evident. What an evil selfish doctor. Not to mention it still doesn't make that man a Woman. They naturally born man is going to be a man forever no matter how many hormones they're pumped with or surgeries they're sliced and diced with
As someone who has lots of trans woman friends and coworkers they are not at all interested in risking their lives like this for something so dangerous. It’s horrendous how some doctors and scientists use the community as a experimental field and not human beings. It’s not the first time.
If they manage to transplant a healthy functional uterus . It would take decades before they would be able to successfully transplant uterus and keep it healthy in more cases than just a few . If that transplantation surgery becomes and relative success in majority cases and depending of how that changes the body and every thing else then the next step is to see if an IVF would be viable. They wouldn’t just implant a fetus without all of that first . So it’ll take quite some time for that to happen .
as a trans girl, I planned to adopt even before I accepted myself for who I am. My parents fostered and one of my friends was an orphan. I've heard about how shitty the system is/can be, and I'd feel better if I can get even one kid freed from it.
@@AliceMGTFoster care in general is not horrendous. I don’t know why people are labelling it as such. It is the chances of the child being adopted by an abuser that people should be concerned about.
@@enigmence it's less about the concept and more about the system itself. on paper "kids without families get a family" sounds absolutely amazing, but as you pointed out, there's a lot about it that could be problematic.
Well, adopting is not a bad option, but some people are rich and own blood is own blood is the concept. But most people do adopt. But the process of pregnancy is what most people look forward to, the happiness and this is exactly the difference
please say what you think instead making vague statements. who are the common sensers and what's their stance? who are the smooth brains and what's their stance?
Isn’t that true for any surgery then? Heart transplant or eye surgeries (cornea transplant ) or life saving stent placements and kidney and liver transplants? Isn’t that considered playing god ?
@@princetonis2realIt kinda is. Imagine telling Julius Caeser that you can just take out an organ and then put another in without killing him. He'd start worshipping you
Men can breast feed… doesn’t mean their bodies won’t adapt to produce life in a uterus… that’s the beauty of humans. Have you looked at nature? Ever heard of a clown fish? We’re connected wether you like it, or not. That’s why our bodies are represented in nature, and some animals are homosexual. ✨Nature✨
@@babs_babsGet help, please. You cannot trust your mind anymore. It is not functioning properly, and you’re going to get worse unless you receive intensive mental treatment. Please please please save yourself. You still seem to be functional enough to type, so please get the help you desperately need.
This is 100% correct if all you need is a healthy uterus and a few hormones why do woman have miscarriages. I had one in 2021 and it was the worst day of my life. I did everything right took vitamins stopped eating all the things I was not supposed to and drinking the things I was not supposed to also didn't take any medication but the prenatal vitamins. So these people that just say yeah they just need to take the hormones that they need and they will have a healthy pregnancy. I am a female and I did all the things I was supposed to do for my baby during my pregnancy. I have all the equipment for a healthy pregnancy. Then why is my son not in my arms? I have my uterus and the hormones, if those are the only things for a successful pregnancy tell me what happened because I would like to know.
spreading content like this without further context is dangerous and you should know better, doctor. look at the hate in the comments, you did this on purpose for engagement.
Hate of what? Ill people being taken seriously? If you have gender dysphoria, its not your body thats giving this problem, its your brain. Therefore the only solution for these people is psychiatric help. I know you hate im right, but im the good one here, telling your ill friend that they are healthy is a disservice to him
@@imjustwolfyeah, I thought he was better than that.. like, if it’s specifically to help trans women, why the hell is he saying it’s to “put them in men”? He’s a doctor, he should know the difference between gender and sex and just use the sex to describe the anatomy.. or just say “trans women” instead of men, it’s so simple..
@@BlaireTheGlare Trans women aren’t women, sorry (not really tho, get a helmet), a trans women doesn’t understand what it is to be a true woman, to grow up as one, to experience a period. God dammit if you don’t have a period, a uterus, two X’s on your fucking chromosomes, and tits that can lactate naturally, you aren’t a woman. You can put a name tag on a dog and call it a cat, it’s still a dog. It’s offensive to be reduced to a ‘cis’ woman because men want to become women.
I'm a transgender man, and i agree. I see blood on his hands already. :( Even if it's found to be possible one day, it's most certainly no where close to being a possibility now. That transgender woman is sacrificing her life for the dream of giving birth... It makes me wonder if she's in a healthy enough head space to be volunteering for something like this.
Even if he could make it work, I think the only way that woman could give birth would be through a c-section… unless they found a way to modify that pelvis
It'd have to be through c section. That kind of breaks that a pelvis would need to widen the male form enough would make it break under the muscle strain contractions give. I also wonder how contractions would work given the differences in body
@@therealzizmon1748 SRS is more focused on aesthetics. Of course there is functionality for intercourse, but that does not mean there is the same level of functionality for giving birth. We don't even have the technology/ability to transfer a fetus and the womb right now, there's no way we could surgically create all of the biological necessities for vaginal birth essentially from scratch.
Unfortunately a c-section would be the least of their worries. The female pelvis widens over the course of the pregnancy to allow for the increase in size and weight of the uterus as the child grows. So IF they would even physically able to carry the child to term then yes, a c-section would be required. But I HIGHLY doubt it would get that far. They would literally end up being unable to walk. Have you ever seen the pregnant waddle that women do later in their pregnancy, that's because of the size and weight of the uterus and the widening of their pelvis altering their gait. The male body would probably be on bedrest the entire pregnancy and unable to sit up.
im trans and this is definitely dangerous and im confused on how its going to work without the hormones and stuff of a female in the body of a male, like go adopt a child instead. - surely people arent that self conscious about their identity that they need to "become" the body that they do not have to validate their identity
Honestly, it is more dangerous to not know how something works. Every surgery is dangerous when it is done for the first time. Lots of things have to line up before they can try something like this. Experimental surgeries not just to placate some superficial desire, they are huge learning opportunities. Some things can never really be understood unless you push things to their limits. I would not be surprised if the things they learn from trying to do this have implications for solving various currently unsolvable reproductive issues, or even help create artificial wombs.
@@DigitalSteel It's dangerous not to understand something but that doesn't mean you need to attempt to replicate everything. There is a difference between replicating and understanding. A composer doesn't have to play every instrument they use. " unless you push things to their limits. " pushing things to the limits means that we will cause some miscarriages and birth defects? I get the advancement at all cost vibe, I really do but that seems especially cruel.
@@wiczus6102 The reason so many people are alive today that otherwise would not be for various medical reasons can thank experimental surgeries just like this one done in the past that have indeed sometimes ended up with complications at the time they were first done. It is not cruel if everyone is doing everything they can do insure it goes well and everyone involved agrees to the risks.
@@DarkFlamesDarkness Male and female bodies are so incredibly different, males do not have the foundation for a uterus and especially not to become pregnant
All jokes aside, the main problem beyond rejection is bone structure. The female pelvis is designed to be more wider and flexible than a man’s to aid childbirth. Male pelvis’s are more rigid for speed and strength. You can’t change bones without damaging the structural integrity
@@FormaxLtof course , how could a man be completely be changed to women , men's anatomy is way different from women in terms of reproduction. Bones structures , skin etc I think it's understandable 🙂
@@prestonbruchmiller497doesn't matter no such thing as a man turning into a woman. It's hilarious that technology needs to be inserted into the argument to implement the notion that yes it's not possible for woman to be men.
Let people do what they want and need for themselves. This shouldn’t be a public discussion it’s a discussion between a patient and their doctor. People who really don’t understand what kind of difficult situation it can take to lead someone making a decision like this shouldn’t be the ones talking about it.
Its really not. It is reckless and dangerous. And it should be a public discussion. Biological realities dont allow the privilege of “doing what you want”.
Yeah I didn't have high hopes because the guy in the video misgenderimg trans women by calling them men. Transphobes will scatter to any place where they feel welcomed like vulchers
@mohammad alomari in many countries, it is either illegal or impossible for same sex couples to adopt. In most cases, it is easier faster and cheaper to find a serogate womb or sperm donor. Even for cis straight couples, it can be impossible to adopt a child.
@@burntmarvmallow141 but in those countries don't you think it'll be illegal to have this surgery. Why is this necessary is the point to try and erase women altogether?
@K.Snow How is a random person getting a womb transplant erasing women? The way many people define a women these days actually excludes some of the cis women you are trying to protect. Not all women can have children naturally, not all women have wombs, not all women have XX chromosomes.
For the sake of trans women around the world I wish this was doable, but unfortunately the amount of systems required for pregnancy and menstruation just makes this seem pretty much impossible. But trans women, many cisgender women can't give birth, some don't menstruate, it doesn't make you less you. ❤️
MEN WILL NEVER: GET PREGNANT GIVE BIRTH A man’s body sees a uterus as an intruder and attacks it and that’s why MEN die. There are women who can’t get pregnant but have the reproductive system to do so, but for what ever reason her system does not work. Some women don’t have a uterus cervix fallopian tubes ovaries or periods because they had a hysterectomy or take medication to stop the periods. Trans woman HAVE NEVER HAD A VAGINA CERVIX UTERUS FALLOPIAN TUBES OVARIES OR PERIODS BECAUSE THEY ARE MEN.
Even if we get to a point where we can literally modify our entire body like in cyberpunk. With 0 differences between males and females. People will still be transphobic. It's sad.
ManWoman perfect transition will mean that there will be no trans to begin with. So yeah, in such a world there will also not be any transphobia. You cannot hate what doesn't exist.
@@agamemnonofmycenae5258people would still hate on people who are not the way the were born. Even nowadays it goes so far that cis people get targeted because people think they're trans for some reason
@tomlxyz well, as of now transitions aren't "perfect". In most cases you can sense that the person was a bio male or female. So trans people are identifiable making them easy targets for bigots. But once the transitions reach perfect levels i.e. where you really couldn't tell what they were originally born as, the hate will disappear cos no will be able to find a target to persecute. And let's be honest, if perfect body modifications would become a reality most of the bigots will be more focused on increasing the size of their own dick over fussing about who's changing to other genders lol.
@@tomlxyzhumans are tribal by nature. Even if society as a whole accepts that all humans are equal, there will always be dumb ignorant people to be racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobe, shit when neuralink hits you really think there won't be purists who discriminate based on that too, on both sides? (Deus Ex game franchise portrays this one the best imo) You can push for 95% of people to accept something, but as sad as it is, there is no real way to eradicate prejudice other than the passage of multiple generations. And even then you're only attacking them one by one, and there's no guarantee every generation will make the same forwards progress you're striving for.
@@galileoandthecrystalgatc1915 pregnancy isn't just about uterus,pelvic bone or hormone.its about the entire body system.during pregnancy,there is specific hormones involves, which even some women cannot produce enough and still hv problems.amd man immune system are stronger than woman,which can rejecting the baby inside the body.woman's entire body system are made for carrying a child.if all it takes is uterus,hormonenand hip bones to have a baby,no woman will be infertile,they just had to insert uterus or hormones to make it work.but no... carrying a child to full term needs an entire body system to work.even diabetes can affect a baby..so many things had to be taken care of..so now you know,getting own child is a sacrifices,many things had to be done,even by someone who naturally born as woman who actually had correct reproductive organs and hormones
@@galileoandthecrystalgatc1915 the thing is that doesn't help. The woman body has a lot of changes made to carry a pregnancy, even if you add hormones, the immune system can just reject the baby or the female genitals implanted don't work because, guess what, they're controlled by a small gland at the base of the brain and even with hormones and all that, the possibility of doing that and dying are high, almost guaranteed
@@methane5211 Exactly! I highly doubt that humanity will every be able to tailor a man's body to work even similar to a woman's during the process of sexual intercourse, fertilization, pregnancy and child birth. Women are more complex than a set of hormones and a organ that's not even yours. I'm not saying im an expert on biology, but you don't exactly have to be a scholar to know common sense holy he*l.
It doesn’t necessarily need to be used for transwomen. It can benefit ciswomen who have fertility issues. I would be willing to donate a uterus and I think other women who want to be childless would be willing as well.
What confuses me the most is all that would go into carrying the child. Without ovaries, they wouldn’t be able to produce an egg to be fertilized. So, presumably, they’d have to get the egg from someone else and hope that it implants after fertilization. The only thing they’d be able to do is carry, which is already known to have a tremendous toll on the human body. If they can’t produce all the hormones required to keep the baby, they’d have to manually take them. I cannot imagine the kind of stress that would cause, knowing that missing a dosage could potentially kill their baby. And even if they were to carry their baby to term, they’d most likely have to get a c-section which is also a very traumatic procedure. There’s so much that could go wrong and the transplant is risky. Even if it were possible, I can’t only imagine the cost. And even after all that, there’s no guarantee of implantation. If they had the money for the surgery, survived the surgery, still had money for an egg donor, and have enough money to afford all the necessary hormones just to see that the egg did not implant. Well, that would be very very depressing
Not only this you have to think about their bodies attacking the uterus and or (if they make it to this stage) the baby. Their body will look at these things a foreign object and will try to rid the body of it.
@@Chocolatebuttacupoet You'd have to take whatever that antirejection medication is called that people have to take when they get other types on implants, but odds are it's not gonna be healthy for the baby and mighr kill it anyway.you're supposed to check women for pregnancy before operating on them because there's so much that has to be avoided to ensure the baby survives. These trans people talk about pregnancies as if what they desire wont cause innocent lives to be lost over mere delusion.
Trans people already receive HRT (hormone therapy ) and transplant of external sexual organs in their teens . This makes their body feminine (wider pelvis and fat deposits in the feminine areas and a softer body type ) . If they successful in transplanting a uterus and are successfully able to maintain the uterus using hormone therapy and make it possible to have periods . Then the next step would be to try IVF implant. It’ll take a long time for that to happen but with the range science is going ahead , it might happen one day in the future.
@@avk94 these are synthetic hormones though ?? Sounds like Frankenstein’s monster being created Personally I don’t think we should mess with nature Setting people up for a big fall IMO
There’s absolutely nothing bigoted or ‘transphobic’ about speaking facts. Especially coming from a qualified medical expert. I appreciate your honesty.
I mean he never once said that he was attacked, only that it “divided the room”. Sounds more likely to me that you’re just seething over tránnies 24/7 and you’ll find any excuse to vent your paranoia.
@@verysadcatc7897well they won’t do shit. At this point homophobic and transphobic arnt even words to be even sad about tbh. It’s almost like a joke word at this point.
Afair, I think early supercars were actually car/airplane engines on a bicycle. Wooden frame, thin tires, and very very aerodynamic body panels because of how inneficient early engines are. Please, PLEASE, CMIIW, though.
& why shouldnt they? The ability to create new human life even in the face of next to total extinction sounds like a pretty useful scientific venture to me. Even many stories written about it.
@@DarkFlamesDarkness First of all, this is alteration, not creation. There are experiments done to have more and more of a pregnancy done in an artificial womb outside of a living being (if I recall correctly mostly on sheep), along with fertilization that would be more akin to creating life and could safe several severe pregnancy complications in the future. Gender reassignement surgery and using womb transplants for it are very different, we don't even have the endocrinology of humans or mammals in general completely mapped out and are not at a point in surgical technology (although that might be rather reachable) to tend to that many nerves and vessels and most of all the serose skin and ligaments holding organs in place. Female to female uterus transplantations are still an extremely dangerous, experimental operation and some already want to skip ahead to the next step and do female to male transplants? Sounds a bit too ahead of its time to me. Also I just have a different view about extinction events, but that's rather a philosophical discussion. I guess that's often the problem in discussions, people disagree with each other and everyone has almost flawless logic, but they still can't agree since the underlying assumptions about life are vastly different. I don't expect humanity to last forever, I think it's important to try to accept that everything that is will someday not be anymore and thus I don't want life extension and see trying to avoid death or extinction by any means as hubris. This doesn't mean complaciency in any extiction event. IMHO trying to solve environmental issues is the right thing to do, same as trying to deflect asteroids etc, while overrushing experimental technology in medicine with kind of a naive sci-fi image of saving the human race feels very off to me, that is btw also the message of many stories written about this.
Politics or no politics, I always gotta upvote a good Jurassic Park quote. But fr tho yeah, this whole thing sounds like a mess. Bro doesn't give a damn about helping these women, he just wants to be the first at something
I'm not a medician, but some basics information everybody should know.Being a woman is not just having an uterus. Our body is way more complex and it's a closed system. I'm wondering a surgeon didn't know it,much worse: all the rest took part. It's like playing Germans during the II world war, like Dr. Mengele. It's terrifying, that this is happening nowadays.
I love how he's not transphobic just concerned as hell for whoever receives this surgery tf are these replies guys please stop nahh actually this is 2 months old stop
I think trans people need to accept that, whatever they’re switching to, it’s just an identity and nothing more. They’re never going to biologically be that gender, so things like these shouldn’t matter if these people wake up to reality. Also, adoption will always be a significantly better choice regardless.
They say we should accept them when they can’t accept themselves (This was 3 months ago, I don’t really know what I meant at the time. Basically outdated)
@@ignaciogonzalez7904they accept themselves so much that they pay hundreds of thousand of dollars to mutilate themselve in a desperate attempt to imitate something they aren't. Right.
I’m all for trans rights and bodily autonomy but at some point you have to consider if the risks are really worth it. Like. There are other ways to become a parent. First, we preach genitals don’t determine who you are, and that fertility doesn’t make you more or less of a person. We are all agreeing that women who can’t give birth aren’t less of a woman. And then you go take these immense risks for something you just deemed irrelevant? This goes both for cis and trans women, by the way. There is no need to start a high risk pregnancy when surrogates and other means to have children exist.
@@wedoalittletrolling3305 you don't seem to know what a c-section is...i was delivered via c-section, there weren't any "complications" as far as i know
@@wedoalittletrolling3305 Bro I was c section and the old difference is my head is perfect. My face never needed to be squeezed through the birth canal.
I think of it like this, if a person feels so deeply disconnected with themselves that they are willing to go to extreme lengths of pain and unbearable measures. Then let them. They clearly know something about themselves that I don't, and they are willing to put their bodies through basically torture to feel better and many of them come out of it actually feeling better. So be it. They're more women than I ever will be and I was born that way
i wonder if you hold the same opinion for people with body dismorphia, or that have mental illnesses that make them want to be disabled, another species of animals or other. with your logic we shouldn’t treat their disorder but just let them try to live their delusion by prescribing a bunch of surgeries right?
@@lambsauce8937 no, that is very much more complicated because that goes beyond cosmetic surgery. That goes far beyond altering relatively external bodily functions that don't impact human quality of life in the same way. Those are not the same situation nor are they related. Something that renders somebody disabled impacts ability to function in life such as walk, talk, interact in a negative way, meaning it takes away a necessary function. Whereas gender confirmation surgeries are changing the breast changing the voice, changing the way the body presents, changing genitals is the most severe, yet it does not actually impact their ability to function in life. So no, I don't have the exact same opinion about that because those are two different things. Well they are both in the realm of mental health. One may impact vital functions while the other allows them to feel free and able without compromising their ability to function. What I'm trying to say is one is relatively harmless. The other is jeopardizing more than just superficial things
@@Bibirallie I don't think they're forcing anyone to believe anything. Because you can't do that. You can't force somebody to believe something that they don't. It is how they feel. Other people empathize with that, or understand it in some way, or relate to it in some way That is very real to them . And so you don't have to believe anything. You just look like a dick. If you don't support, love and respect them, they simply won't have anything to do with you. You may not agree with it or understand anything about it, but that does not mean that you should hurt another person or make them feel bad because you think they're being delusional. If it was your family then it'd be okay to just treat them horribly all of a sudden? Usually what happens is you end up losing a lot of your family and you end up alone. Maybe show some empathy or at least understanding, otherwise you're kind of just a dick. You don't have to believe it but it is a very real experience for them. Everyone deserves basic human respect, "delusional" or otherwise.
@@lambsauce8937Different mental conditions are treated differently. For people who feel the need to cut off their own limbs for example, we refrain from encouraging them to do so because it would negativley effect their quality of life. For trans people who suffer with gender and sex dysphoria, NOT transitioning negativley effects their quality of life, so we encourage them to transition becuase there's no other way for them to reach a quality of life that will allow them to exist comfortably in their own bodies.
I agree im nb and want to have children but i wouldnt subject myself to that it just doesnt make sense, the surgery + the having that organ + pregnancy and childbirth when theres so many children up for adoption. But just like theres so many bio women that have that as their own goal if a trans person is willing to go tru all that why not let them? I dont think its morally wrong but i think its just not worth it and a bad idea cause of the risk
it's not just the uterus, it's your brain, hormones, even your bones are a part of it. You have to be able to carry the kid full term, it isn't just simply putting the embryo there and it existing in a separate environment from your body thise 9 months. if the body doesn't know how to make all the connections and shit it has to do with blood vessels, nutrient transport and bodily fluids to have the fetus survive and actually grow without major complications, it won't work.
@@hsuyaa_ have you seen the hio bone of a male and woman? the baby head cant fit in the male bone. also they died u know why? bcoZ biology wont allow it
Bro people in the comments acting like nobody is trying to cure cancer :/ A surgeon's capability to cure cancer is the same as yours. Do it yourself if you think he can spend his time better.
As a transgender woman, I really don’t think this is a good idea, at least for now. Cis women have endless problems at birth, and a trans woman giving birth would present tenfold those problems. From hormones to bone/muscle structure, this just doesn’t seem reasonable in 2023.
its really sad to see other transfems agreeing with these people. no, bone structure is the result of bone *development* that happens during puberty, for a male it is broadening shoulders, for a female it is a widening pelvis, and for BOTH it is generally getting taller. if you start hrt early enough, bone structure is not going to be a problem for you. many people dont realize this, and they want us to stay oblivious to it so they can continue invalidating us with “bOnE sTrUcTuRe”.
We’re not cis or anything but women. We’re the only women. We’ve been HALF the human race since before we were Homo sapiens. Nice to meet you. You’re a gender anomaly. You’re at high estimate about 0.02% of the human race. If that. Stop appropriating women we’re not a costume we’re not a set of self identifications for those with mommy issues.
I'm so concerned about what success will even look like. I'm all for being your authentic true self but who will take responsibility for complications.
@@mohamadtoriquekhan9697 this is posed like it is a new issue, but it really is not. They have already said uterine transplant has been successful in cis women. Were you there worrying about the liability for complications then? Or do you feel okay with it because it's succeeded a couple times? Do you go and research medical liability laws? Common law liabilities? Or do you sit there and postulate about an issue because you don't know how it works? This isn't a jab at you, but I guess a bit of information to help digest new situations like this. In truth, this will be treated like any other surgery. The dr and hospital take on a level of liability, having a dr patient relationship. Firstly, they must adequately inform the patient of risks, complications, procedures, and expectations. They must act within ethical obligations of their certification board. That probably means, among other things, not acting out of self interest, not aiming to reduce the quality of life of a patient, acting in the patient's interests safely in the circumstances, and properly informing themselves of all necessary medical literature and training in order to make this as safe as possible. They likely also have to have the hospital they work at sign off on the surgery, especially being such a new situation to perform this procedure. Their patient probably has to undergo several general referrals, psych referrals, significant testing, and counselling to make this decision. They also have to pay out of pocket for this to go ahead. In the end, patient also has to sign legal documentation acknowledging they understand the situation they are in, and are accepting a degree of risk. This DOES NOT mean the dr/hospital incur no liability (as tv would have you believe) , but that the Dr/Hospital are only liable for mistakes/errors/misjudgments that they themselves make, as the patient is very aware of what information is available, and has asked to receive this procedure despite all of that.
@@mohamadtoriquekhan9697 in comparison, I could wake up tomorrow and fuck up my life so much faster, and so much cheaper, if I so wished. I would not need one, let alone 2, 3, or 4 psych referrals to do so. No one in this situation is wandering into it blind of the risks, or intending harm. It is a very careful decision, that, at the end of everything, everyone agreed would be worth it
I think this is exactly why the first treatment option given to any woman over 30 is a hysterectomy - collecting uteruses to experiment with - the 'medical' field has gone rogue.
this is ONE doctor. A huge percent of them are still working on a cure for cancer, we didn't just give up on that. it doesn't work like that lmao there's 8 billion ppl.
@@fudgecakes1313 so like you're doing now by not only viewing, commenting but engaging with other people, thus pushing this video towards more people ? not very smart now is it
Fairly common issue also for cis women. I am more concerned about the hormonal changes that ebbs and flows during a pregnancy, and how we could mimic that sufficiently well. Hormonal issues is even a problem for quite a few cis women that miscarries, and throw in HRT? It becomes complicated. Incredibly interesting on many levels, but complicated. I suspect that for the foreseeable future, the most realistic way trans people can be parents is by a trans woman contribute with sperm cells, trans men contribute with egg cells, and then either the trans man manages to partially de-transition, or they use a surrogate. That said, most trans people I know would be more than willing to adopt instead of going through this mess.
I mean, yes and no. Bone structure, while generally being different between male and female anatomy, also differs between every person individually. I don't know the numbers, but there probably have been women with very small pelvic bones who have given birth. Just in general, it would be a huge leap in the medical world if it can be achieved
@@BigMac4141 definitely not saying it's very likely, but it is possible. Maybe that's what's needed for the first one to succeed? Ah well, I'm not a doctor at all, so I really can't speak too much on this.
If the presence of a uterus was the only thing that was needed for pregnancy, there would be zero women with fertility issues, zero miscarriages
@@tenzinchokdup3466 nah imma keep being trans, thanks tho
God will not be mocked this way. What evil this world has descended into.
@@zan890 solution for overpopulation
@Kase Trey exactly i fucking hate it when losers like that have this sick demented fetish for having blood related children when there are so many damn kids in the world who would do anything for a loving home with parents. Adoption is the only answer people need to stop giving birth to kids they never planned on having.
I should know since I'm an orphan.
If any of this ever works, we can answer the age old question, "Is delivering a baby more painful than getting kicked in the balls?"
asking the real questions here
Well if this is possible, the trans woman would only be able to do a c section. There is no way she could deliver vaginally. And they have to do c section with epidural. So no, the question will never be answered in that way 😅 But I could tell you the answer, think you know already tho lmfao.
Most of women want to have another baby, even after they experienced horrendous pain during delivery. On the other hand, I have never heard a guy ask for another kick in the balls. I hope that helps.
Just to make clear and avoid polemical responses, this is a joke.*
@@ElMizuki women are designed to forget the pain of giving birth so that they will continue to reproduce, so that doesn't matter at all lmao, and I could tell you plenty of men who would gladly take a kick to the balls if it meant they could have a kid smh 😒
@@ElMizuki You do kind of get a baby from giving birth, but you get nothing from getting kicked in the balls.
Wouldn’t the meds needed to keep the body from rejecting the uterus harm a growing fetus?
even without the meds lol a fetus growing from a male body with another male body is NOT gonna end well.
And the trans hormones will effect the baby !
And a man would not have the correct hormones to carry and nurture a baby 💀
@@Shamrock_queen98 wth are "trans hormones" 🤔
@@Shamrock_queen98 Hormones are hormones. You just gotta make sure you’re taking the right ones. 🤨
id be most curious on how they would manage to reshape the pelvis cause that kinda change doesn't sound like it'd be a quick and easy process
you know that before puberty, the male and female pelvis are identical right? its that the estrogen in the females body morphs the bones while they are still able to be shaped (until roughly the age of 25). Its the same reason men have broader shoulder bones.
Most people are immediately like going transphobic on this which sucks. But like if he does it, it would be a literal medical break through. If you could do it with trans women fully. Then you should be able to apply some of the process to infertile women
@@unimunoz1159 the process has already been applied to an infertile woman if i am not mistaken, it worked. but really the only reason most people would get it is because of the influence of transphobia, “you dont have a uterus and cant get pregnant!” its risky but someone might be so fed up with this shit that they wont be clear headed.
Well, starting hormones replacement therapy and hormone blockers early on while the bones are still developing would solve that. Also there are people who are intersex. Aaaaaand every body is different. Im not a doctor, so id leave it up to them to assess risks.
@@nono_noxxyou people are literally insane
The pelvic region in a woman is able to expand during pregnancy. And it's shaped different to allow for the baby to fit. Multiple hormones work together in a pregnancy.
Yes there a separation of the pubic bones a joint called the pubic symphysis and with pregnancy the hormones allow this area to soften and stretch to allow a baby to pass through. I really don’t know if they could artificially make it happen. But if a man ever succeeds in getting and carrying a pregnancy I bet they might give birth once but never again. Why? You ask because they are pretty big babies about pain. Women have had years of period cramps to get used to having that horrible pelvic pain but I can’t imagine a man doing it more than once. My husband would faint at the sight of blood especially his own. He was a huge big baby about any illness. I would kind of like to see it happen because I think it would be Justice. Men make lousy mothers too because they were never supposed to be.
@@patriciasmith7074
Maybe men would actually feel less pain with this one because their nervous system isn't really wired to have a womb. Though the other pains of pregnancy, like back pain etc would still be present I guess
@@godhateseveryonewhodoesntr5977 Yes you have a point! But the pubic bone didn’t cause pain on me, it only made me walk funny, kind of like a duck waddles. It was embarrassing to me because my mother was always so critical of the way I walked liked my dad’s big sister and mom thought his sister walked unladylike. So here I was feeling ugly and fat and we went to a formal dance and my mother looked gorgeous in a blue velvet dress and I was clumsy and fatter than my mom and she made me feel ugly but I was pregnant with my daughter which I was thrilled about having a baby. Way back then they didn’t know the sex of your baby till it was born. It didn’t help because my stupid husband told me how great my mother looked that night. I had done her hair and makeup and made her look fabulous and everybody raved at how beautiful she was. Pretty hard for a young first time pregnant young married woman to hear how gorgeous her mother is!
@@patriciasmith7074Jus be happy you are pregnant....some women have a hard time conceiving and having healthy babies...your family sounds toxic....I'm sorry....
@@honeybadgerknockoutbadgers9642 Yes my mom didn’t love me because my conception made her get married at 17. She always claimed she didn’t know that act resulted in a pregnancy and her mom was a widow with two other daughters so her mom found out she was pregnant and said get married now. Luckily my dad was a good guy and he loved her and wasn’t opposed to the idea. He had just come home from WWII. She only really wanted her two boys. I knew I wasn’t important to her so I was glad to get married and move out. I tried to win her over but she never changed. So I gave up trying.
You need a uterus, ovaries, Hypothalamic-Pituitary- Ovarian axis. Pitocin, oxytocin etc…. It talks a whole lot of chemistry and biology to make and carry a pregnancy to term successfully
Oxytocin isn’t sex specific at all, and Petocin is a brand of oxytocin used to induce labor lol.
@@user-rw6ui5nv5iYou also need relaxin which y'all don't produce lol.
@@user-rw6ui5nv5i I meant prolactin but thanks.
@@user-rw6ui5nv5i yes many hormones are found in men and women in significantly varying quantities, but it takes all of these ingredients and more to work symbiotically to make and carry a baby to term. REAL WOMEN with all of the parts and ingredients sometimes have difficulties. Medical science can’t help infertile REAL women 100% of the time. Now they want to try to help the build a chic 🤦🏾♀️ ok
@@Mrsjengood11 Prolactin isn't sex specific either
Just because we *can* attempt something scientifically, doesn't always mean we should try. In this case I wouldn't suggest it's transphobic to say that... Trans people going through multiple surgical procedures are already facing enough of a health risk. After all those elements, why risk losing your life for the pursuit of something that at this point in the debate shouldn't have to validate your gender?
Trans healthcare should be a specific and much further funded/researched field of medicine.
Frankly with all of the more dystopian technology that exists at this point I think letting trans women finally birth their own kids is a beautiful and valid use of it. We live in a world where we rot our brains with social media and put creatives out of a job with AI. Letting consenting adults attempt a risky affirmation surgery is the least harmful thing we've done to society in decades.
Let them try.
@newyoutubeaccount2023 you don't need to go through a whole medical procedure to die if that's really what your aim is buddy. im not saying you should, just saying surgery isn't the only thing in the world that will kill you and i'm sure u know this
@newyoutubeaccount2023 I want to die without pain too but that's not gonna happen. Even dying from old age has pain involved, I watched my great grandmother die from old age. Not fun. But also, I've had two whole surgeries in my lifetime that I could've died from. Still extruciatingly painful as soon as the anesthesia wears off. I had c-sections, where I was cut into 7 layers of skin to cut into my uterus and pull my babies out. Felt nothing during the procedure, but just an hour afterwards was screaming from pain, begging for medicine. A c-section itself increases the risk of hemorrhaging, infections, and death. To hope u die from something painless, it's more than likely not going to happen painlessly if you do die.
It probably could be if you didn't have so many countries trying to restrict such research
@@melynn_0355no u couldnt why do you think the only differenc men and women have is in body? We literally have different fucking chromosomes a man has YX and a woman has XX lets say somehow a man get a uterus and another man wants to make a baby with him
Do you know what kind of a mutated freak a YY chromosome creature could look like???? It would be basically dead within minutes of being out
Fucking delusional people not knowing about biology
Actually the main problem is body chemistry. A male body isn't designed to support a uterus no matter how many hormones you give them. Womens bodies literally have so many systems that support the uterus, from our digestive and endocrine systems to pituitary glands, and separate functions in the brain. All of those things are literally designed in women to support the uterus and child birth. If you can't rewire those systems in a man, then the body will always reject the organ.
But no
they'll shoot the gun on the shoulders of trans' rights.
gotta love my species. IntelligentNegligentRetards
@@raconteurboy6640that literally impossible with our technology right now.
@@zetoboogaloo8802 I guessed my skill lack to becoming next Dave
honeslty at this point, if you really want "the full experience", cloning a body and transfering the midn would mrobably be more managable
Libtard: *hisses, does exorcist crab-walk*
*pulls out a fresh bucket of popcorn*
Into the comments we go.
Fuckin same dude. I've discovered there are four types of comments in this comment thread.
1) people fully supporting the idea
2) people fully against the idea and calling anyone involved monsters
3) infertile women professing their "boo hoo poor me", like we haven't spent the last hundred years and billions of dollars researching female fertility.
4) and finally the me and you's.
@@commandershepard4235
thank you so much for the summary btw
xD
I knew exactly what I was getting into, lol. I have a day with nothing to do. I happen to be a biological woman with a child just trying to share the facts with others who may not be aware of what happens during pregnancy. I'm not even taking a political stance here and don't really mind whose side anyone is one. I just wanted to state some facts today. Though the one opinion I do state is that I feel that it is selfish. So that is an opinion- not a fact.😄
2 genders female and male. No wmount of self mutilati0n can change DNA
@@commandershepard4235 Im in the: How would that even work anatomically?? Would that even be safe for her if we sorted out the hormones etc??
Like with our current technology and medicine it does not seem plausible to end well for any mtf trans women who want to get the surgery done
As a pregnant woman I’ll say watching the way my body AUTOMATICALLY knows what to do to hormonally and chemically carry a baby, the male body does not have the hormonal ecosystem to support a uterus. There’s more to it than just an organ.
Yeah that’s what HRT is for…
@@mopippenger7373 clearly it’s not because trans women on hrt still can’t get pregnant or receive a uterus that doesn’t become septic and kill them. It must be more than JUST hormones.
@@mopippenger7373 if that’s all it took then why hasn’t that worked yet?
@@thegoddessrising6115because the first successful uterus transplant didn’t happen until 2012
@@mopippenger7373 into women?? Because the bio men who received a uterus transplant did not survive very long because their bodies did not have the ECOSYSTEM to support it.
There is a lot of things a womans body and immune systems are doing during a pregnancy, the hormonal phone is adjusted very carefully by the body itself. Even if he succeeds implanting the uterus, and somehow we put someone's impregnated egg in there, the poor fetus will not be able to develop into a normal child. It's insane.
You will surprised
You will surprised
Exactly
Just the blood supply alone is increased 45-50% during pregnancy. Good Luck!
Any surgeon that attempts this should lise their licence and be made liable for all the health issues a child born this way will inevitably have.
A woman's body goes through immense changes during pregnancy. Just getting a uterus stuffed into your abdomen isn't enough to prepare your body for what happens during pregnancy. The hormonal changes that are required to sustain the life of that child are insane. Not to mention the physiological changes that occur that the female body is literally made to endure. This experiment if so incredibly selfish. It's not just their life they are endangering. They would be endangering the life of the child they would be attempting to carry. It's like when trans women try lactating. Their bodies are literally not made to produce the nutrition required to sustain a baby. I'm not trying to be mean- I'm being factual here. Just let a biological woman carry the baby. It's safer for all parties involved. Stop trying to do something that your body quite literally cannot do. Your bones are not made to move the way women's bones are during child birth. Just let it go and be happy with all the other changes that can be done to your body. This is ridiculous.
Yes this was just a small clip from the podcast but there are numerous hormonal; anatomical and ethical obstacles to consider which makes this very unlikely in the near future anyway
I will just stay quiet cause i am preparing for JEE session 2
Edit:
Gand mara JEE , Time to sleep and have fun till results
@@DrKaran you have a podcast?:o Love your shorts here on RUclips
C sections exist and so does formula milk
@@basilhidmari so does a normal fucking women giving births
you would literally have to rebuild the whole region, from bone to skin, birth is not exclusive to the uterus its the whole area
Even if they rebuild the whole area, it would still be weaker than anything that would be produced naturally. It honestly sounds terrifying.
Do you think he, a doctor, doesn’t know that?😂 That’s what they’re trynna figure out
@@nhehe10 the doctors who think they can do it defenitly have some major problem and shouldnt even try it, much like the doctors who do sex change opperations on kids
@@boombadaboom1439 pppp
@@nhehe10 trying to figure out, at the expense of people's lives. That's where it gets problematic.
At one point, we used urine as a contraceptive. Children died of polio. Medical feilds are always advancing.
And ur damn point is?
...master of logical fallacies lol. That's just a medical fad that died out, there was no advancement in the field. What's going to improve? Flow rate? You can't really improve something that doesn't work. The wives tale still exists today just as arcaic "just pee on jellyfish stings and it's cured" 1.) It doesn't work 2.) Seems exactly like how it was in Victorian times with no advancements. Atleast with lgbt they succeeded in their goal and have had advancements, originally people like emperors elagabalus would just wear female sex worker clothing and act like women. Now they can slice and dice their bodies any way they want.
@rudir6826
That all those people here crying "this is impossible" "it is an abomination" "tHeY aRe MoCkInG gOd" are hella annoying
@@the_godfather9974but of course it's annoying only to ignorants
Everyone's saying "You don't just need a Uterus to get pregnant!" as if this doctor doesn't know that and all the other stuff needed is probably where a big chunk of the challenge comes from
Oof exactly. As if they havent considered the implications.
@@nono_noxx most likely they havent and all they are trying to do is be the first to do it to get fame and not giving a fuck about the complications it will bring to their testsubject.
@@gurgangurganstumph7172they're trying to be the first to successfully do it. If you actually watched the short, youll hear that its already been done before but unsuccessfully
@@egghaverr yeah and they will never have any success no matter how many poor souls they sacrifice in this missguided endevour.
@@gurgangurganstumph7172 we will see, because nobody's gonna be able to stop them
Don't you need the ENTIRE female reproductive system for that?
It takes more than the reproductive system
Yes. The blood supply alone is increased 45-50 procent during pregnancy plus hundreds of other factors. It's a really really long shot to make this possible.
People out here researching how to make a man give birth instead of curing cancer or HIV💀
@wancitte acapella TF
They did, scientist and doctor are not just one group. Same as like electronic brands its not only samsung and iphone, they are doing their own thing.
@@firdausmahesa2931 yeah, but I think it's better to focus on the more important stuff. Ya know?
Or considering saving a life via organ donation!
Daily people like me are dying awaiting for a life saving organ.
I want to start a family too but can’t on dialysis. Kidney transplant would make me healthy enough to have my dream
Fr
It’s not just a uterus .. it’s a whole reproductive system.. system!
yes, but this would allow trans women to use IVF.
@@micahslashno it wouldn’t. There are multiple things that women have that men cannot have because they were born men
I'm reading a lot of uninformed nonsense around here.
Correct an cis man is not going to give birth. He has the wrong hormones.
Trans women are given the correct hormones. A uterus transplant with ovaries if that ever becomes possible. Is not just for pregnancy. But it could allow a trans fem person to discontinue HRT.
Weather a pregnancy is advisable is between them and their doctor. Many cis women are advised aginst giving birth for a myriad of reasons.
It's a step of scientific progress. It should be applauded.
@@Jeerin_... please enlighten us.
@@raintalon6138 Milk
I am a transgender man, and I think that the issue a lot of trans people seem to have is this dire need to replace their organs to be "real," men or women. It just doesn't work like that. Sorry. I understand that it's painful to not have something you feel your supposed to have, but there are some things that just can't happen, and we have to accept that and stop being delusional.
You can dress, present, and identify as a woman. Or a man. But you should NOT cut yourself up and shit to try and make yourself feel whole, when you won't.
Hormones? Sure. They do a lot of good when used right, but a uterus can't be in a man's body. And honestly, from personal experience and experience from most women I've encountered, having a uterus BLOWS.
Just adopt a baby ffs. It sounds insensitive but, don't kill yourself chasing something that is genuinely, physically, not meant to be housed by your body.
The idea of pregnancy and childbirth as a biological woman scares the bejeesus out of me... I couldn't even imagine the concept of trying to surgically implant a functioning organ that has such a minimal chance of acceptance by the body's biology. Hormones and cosmetic/plastic surgery are already major things for a person to undertake... But the amount of risk and potential for the body to reject the whole darn uterus, get infected and just die would be enormous... I'd rather adopt or use a surrogate and still be able to live to raise a baby than even consider this.
What if the surgeon after all that would be like "it's just for show, don't get pregnant because you will die"
trans dude here, with full intent to medically reassign myself in years to come. i agree that its real dangerous for trans women to implant a uterus because its not supposed to be there, and generally the hip bones are too narrow to have any real chance of developing a child. i believe medically transitioning is fine if the person fully believes it will make them feel more at peace, but implanting a uterus is playing god. it wont work, youd need to replace a lot of stuff including bone which would cause a whole amalgamation of health problems
What's something special about giving birth anyway? Tbh I'd rather eat my own shit than give birth
Besides, like you said, there's plenty kids around the world. People should provide love and care for someone who needs them. We don't need more kids. We need more good parents
I'm guessing they'd have to have a caesarean section.
Ethically this is wrong - not just the danger to the trans person but also to any subsequent baby.
I think there is an ethical concern on the sourcing of these uterus. Like older women’s uterus are going to have scar tissue. This mean younger women uterus are going to be needed leaves open for more human trafficking. And if a cis woman and a transwoman are both on a waiting list. The viability of a successful uterus transplant will always lie with a cis woman. Also a uterus transplant can only be used once. Meaning if they wanted multiple children they need multiple uterus transplants. Not to mention this surgery is unsuccessful in most cis women.
You need waaaaay more than a uterus. They gonna have to modify the freaking hip bones for that.
I think you could bypass that -- C-sections already exist. I feel like issues like hormone and chemical balances and signals would be a much bigger issue. Getting a uterus in without it rejecting seems like the start of an uphill battle tho, u right about that
Edit: y'all stop coming at me. I stated that my opinion that getting the hormones and chemical pathways right are wwaaaaayyy more difficult to overcome than the physical parts of such a procedure, like bone modification or the insertion of a uterus. I'm not saying "teehee no problem bones are easy peasy." Im saying doctors don't even know all the chemical intricacies of what's going on in bio women's reproductive systems. Much less during pregnancy. How tf are they gonna replicate it in a trans woman.
Thats it?
So the krogan Transplant is going to be real so except it is not Krogans.
It is humanity exchanging each others bitcoins.
I think it would be a c section, because they remove the uterus after the pregnancy, too. At least when they do a uterus transplant for a cis woman that's what they do
Not really. While hip bones can be used *with other factors* to help determine sex of a skeleton there's plenty of overlap between male and female humans. If you'd need to do surgery on most males to give birth a very large % of females would also need surgery. Like a third.
That pelvis bone gonna crack like it's under a hydrolic press 💀
The last person to try this died 2 weeks later sad because today they don't care who dies just to prove there point
Eh, lots of women get C sections because the pelvis is too narrow
@@nikoincroatia not the fucking point the chromosomes are different
@@nikoincroatia no they don't, they get c sections because they can't dilate in time, do your research
@@iamthebean940 people get C sections for a miriad of reasons, not just one....
Do your.... Basic human.... Thinking???? What do i even say here you're just delusional
Why do it? Why risk a babies life trying? What a waste of medical science, money and energy.
Wasting money and wasting eggs
- Why do it?
To hopefully perfect the procedure for the future
-why risk a baby’s life trying?
There’s no baby involved
@eldritch_Sage the purpose is to eventually have a baby. So at some point a baby or many babies will be an experiment.
If you care about babies then donate to charity or adopt them
@@P1nkNebula well you could also practice what you preach and sign up to be the first one to experiment on.
Our organs literally MOVE so we can carry a baby.
There are so many beautiful children waiting to be adopted.
wahi to
People would littrly cut their bodies open and fit a whole another organ... But won't adopt
At least in my country, adoption is not legally possible for anyone that isn't a heterosexual couple.
Even in a homosexual couple, you can't be legally recognized as the parent of your partner's biological children, which means that if something were to happen to the kid's biological parent, you would have to engage a long legal battle in order to keep caring for them. It sucks.
It would be awesome if everyone could apply to take kids out of the system, but taking a look at the current situation, I can't blame anyone that chooses extreme measures in order to have a biological child
This is what’s important
@@bleachnbones7107 In the US even if you were able to get through the massively strenuous and difficult process of adoption, adopting a single child generally starts at around $35,000 (and thats not counting all the actual costs to actually adopting a child and beginning to care for them, thats just the fees). It's pretty impossible for the average person to be able to do.
The problems arise more with actual pregnancy as there is a very specific and needed hormonal process involved that requires the ovaries and the brain, not just the uterus. Certain hormones are produced at specific times to ensure that a fetus can actually develop and go to term. And the complex muscle contractions and hormones released to cause said contractions. Its a delicate process of balance and timing. If ever this can be achieved it will be incredibly innovative, but at the same time the whole process would be incredibly complicated.
Edit: To clarify I am not against the research, I'm just worried about the people who want to be the test subjects for this kind of thing. It is a LOT to go through and it needs to be studied extensively. Transplants are already a huge risk to the body. Transplanting an organ as complicated as a full female reproductive system adds so much more to the complexity. Trying to make it function as intended is even more complex. You need so many different neural, endocrine, and exocrine parts to work correctly, and it has to be in perfect balance.
i feel similarly; It isn't as easy as just slapping the thing into a male, but if someone thinks out all of the resulting issues and questions, and it, yknow, works..?
Honestly, i'd be ultimately impressed.
Yeah, that's my main concern as well. I wish trans women could carry their own children like cis women but pregnancy is such a complicated and delicate thing. I don't know if anything like an artificial uterus (alongside the hormones) can ever be made. I hope trans women will have an option like that in the future but the way science is now (and how unsupported trans people are) I don't know how long it will take.
@@pixelatra_
As one myself & a bit of a science nerd I have no doubt that conditions for an “artificial” pregnancy can be made in the future esp with how science has developed technologies like cloning, I don’t feel the need for it myself however it is a really interesting thought to me
@@reneebear3641 That's good to hear!
@@pixelatra_ I agree completely
Okay I'm a physical therapist and let me tell you something. The male pelvis is not formed to have a baby it is that simple. People are going wild these days to achieve something.
The fact that you think that the doctor didn’t think of that and that you think they just are never going to address that is astounding
The blood supply alone is increased 45-50 procent during pregnancy. It's a really really long shot to make this possible!
@@eldritch_Sage doctors are not perfect. with my last pregnancy i went into labor two days before my planned c-section. i went to the hospital immediately where my doctor told me "i'm going to give you medicine to slow down your contractions and send you home" and i have heard of stories like this where women are sent home by their doctors and later either end up giving birth on the way back to the hospital to straight up dying. so i said no to the medicine and labored unmedicated for 12 hours. at the end of 12 hours, i still haven't dilated past 3cm. my doctor admitted defeat and said he would perform the c-section on me in the morning. his initial plan was to send me home and perform the surgery two days later, on the initially planned date. so just because someone is a doctor doesn't mean lives haven't been unnecessarily lost
They stop at nothing! Let them create Frankenstein babies 😂playing god never works out and never will………the amount of genetic defects that aren’t even discovered that 2 males would create! These people and demonic doctors are literally killing people…
Then surgically break and widen it, the new hips would be affirming anyway.
If there were no major medical ramifications, I would donate my uterus in a heartbeat to someone who really wanted it. I love being a woman, but I have no plans for pregnancy and my uterus has been nothing but an annoyance my entire life.
That is sad
It really isn't about trans rights or any kind of right. It's just extremely dangerous.
Yeah, but so is transplanting it to another woman. Personally I don't get peoples need to biologically reproduce, but the force do be strong for some people. And for them it's worth it
@@Maura237 "I don't get people's need to reproduce" it's nature lmao you don't need a reason
@@za.monolit Well I don't feel it. I want children, but no biological ones and I do not get how people specifically want their children to be biological. Like, obv I know that that's a thing, I just don't understand it
@@Maura237 uterus can be implanted in a women with defected uterus bc she already had one at that place they just have to remove one and add another where tf are they gonna add in a man and the difference between angles of pelvic bones in males and females makes it more complicated
@@Maura237 people want biological child bcz it's their own blood their own bloodline continues I belongs to a dynasty that rules North india for around 120+ years why I wanna end my royal bloodline?
dont play with nature, nature always wins.
Whats different To a human and a animal?
@@gaspersnakes human is a animal
@@savirini1638 thats the point humans are animals but animals arent human if they were you know whats going happen 2100
nature a bi*vh
The entire human society is a struggle against nature, technology is not natural,your phone is not natural, cars are not natural, our institutions are not natural, language is not natural, medicine is not natural etc. To stop "playing" with nature is an insult to the things human society has done.
There was a tiktok personality who wants a uterus implant so he can have the first abortion after an implant, I'm completely disgusted at this kind of absolute selfishness.
damn killing unborn infants for sport, that's terrible.
Heartbreaking….
@@bumblingfool2211 maybe that's why republican man accuse women of doing it. because they've done it themselves first
I’m completely fine with abortions for physical or mental health, but doing it just to “be the first” is awful.
@@a_donut4823 It was a joke towards christians who are transphobic. They're a bunch of idiots why would anyone care what they think is scientifically possible anyways?
I don't even know how to react to that! I get it for women who have uterus issues, but so many things beside a uterus is needed and even some women can't take that type of shock to the body (like all transplant surgeries). I get it some want that transition, but we are barely doing this for women - See if this works first! There is so much about women's bodies that some male doctors don't get! I know I have had a couple that thought menstrual cramps were nothing and women who are pregnant just want special treatment! I hope they don't say that to their wives and daughters!
People be forgetting that a woman's body also has the ability to create a temporary organ for pregnancy. 💀
Huh?? What temporary organ is that. I’m a real woman, please explain.
@@phillybertful placenta is an organ. Temporary one.
@@ami.2327 i don't think It can be called an organ, it is more of endo-layer of epithelial actually formed just to provide nutrition, an organ is a group of tissues, but placenta is not a complete tissue it is more of cytosolic-group of cells
@@heheboi9823 Please do your research. Placenta is a group of tissues, thus called an organ. Cytosol is the liquid matrix found inside cells. Placenta is not a liquid substance. If you haven't seen one, please Google it.
@@heheboi9823 Also, it does all the work of lungs, liver, kidneys etc. It not just provides the baby with oxygen and nutrients but also removes waste and carbon dioxide from the baby. It also produces hormones that help the baby grow. It's an organ that detaches itself from the uterus after the baby gets out of the same.
The reason he wants to do this is for STATUS, the doctor doesn't really have patients best interests, he has his own
Yes and it's incredibly evident. What an evil selfish doctor. Not to mention it still doesn't make that man a Woman. They naturally born man is going to be a man forever no matter how many hormones they're pumped with or surgeries they're sliced and diced with
Narcissism at its finest
Truth
As someone who has lots of trans woman friends and coworkers they are not at all interested in risking their lives like this for something so dangerous. It’s horrendous how some doctors and scientists use the community as a experimental field and not human beings. It’s not the first time.
Just like John money the father of gender studies.
Even if it was successful, that would put a fetus in danger unnecessarily. Very unethical
If they manage to transplant a healthy functional uterus . It would take decades before they would be able to successfully transplant uterus and keep it healthy in more cases than just a few . If that transplantation surgery becomes and relative success in majority cases and depending of how that changes the body and every thing else then the next step is to see if an IVF would be viable. They wouldn’t just implant a fetus without all of that first . So it’ll take quite some time for that to happen .
It shouldn't even be legal due to the health risks to the fetus.
In science there's no place for ✨empathy✨
@@purplesoul1750unfathomabley cringe comment dude
@@aaronsmith3115 So what? That's how the life works
@@purplesoul1750 yeah sure dude
@@aaronsmith3115 Even nature have no such thing as empathy. It's just a concept
idk why some ppl think adopting is bad. a child is a child, raise it well
as a trans girl, I planned to adopt even before I accepted myself for who I am. My parents fostered and one of my friends was an orphan. I've heard about how shitty the system is/can be, and I'd feel better if I can get even one kid freed from it.
@@AliceMGTFoster care in general is not horrendous. I don’t know why people are labelling it as such. It is the chances of the child being adopted by an abuser that people should be concerned about.
@@enigmence it's less about the concept and more about the system itself. on paper "kids without families get a family" sounds absolutely amazing, but as you pointed out, there's a lot about it that could be problematic.
Well, adopting is not a bad option, but some people are rich and own blood is own blood is the concept. But most people do adopt. But the process of pregnancy is what most people look forward to, the happiness and this is exactly the difference
It has to be your child biologically. Both by skin and blood.
It divided the room between people with common sense and smooth brains.
please say what you think instead making vague statements. who are the common sensers and what's their stance? who are the smooth brains and what's their stance?
@@wabbajocky8235 people who think a male can give birth with a uterus transplant are smooth brains. OBVIOUSLY.
@wabbajocky8235 and you have given us the answer of which you are..
@@PurpleWolfer to reiterate: "please say what you think instead making vague statements."
@@wabbajocky8235 you said reiterate so clearly we know which you are.😂😂😂😂😂😂
Y’all keep tryna play God out here in these streets. Keep on.
Isn’t that true for any surgery then? Heart transplant or eye surgeries (cornea transplant ) or life saving stent placements and kidney and liver transplants? Isn’t that considered playing god ?
@@avk94 no it’s not. You’re welcome.
@@princetonis2realIt kinda is. Imagine telling Julius Caeser that you can just take out an organ and then put another in without killing him. He'd start worshipping you
We now live in a time where it is illegal to test medical breakthroughs on human beings until they are proven safe, however it is okay to do this…
That's usually for medication and medical devices, the rules and regulations for surgeries are a little different...
@@Ty-dk2sj and does that make sense? 😂 why is it okay to test uterus transplants into males, but not life saving vaccines?
Be gone, transphobe
@Ty-dk2sj
Indeed and adding to that rules are different from country to country
It’s takes a whole stack more than a uterus to grow a baby. Every part of a woman’s body responds, in some way to conception.
Source: trust me bro
@@frizzizzi
@@Jcremo how old are you? I’ll bet you $500 we see a pregnant “man” before you die
Men can breast feed… doesn’t mean their bodies won’t adapt to produce life in a uterus… that’s the beauty of humans. Have you looked at nature? Ever heard of a clown fish? We’re connected wether you like it, or not. That’s why our bodies are represented in nature, and some animals are homosexual. ✨Nature✨
@@mister_midnight189 give him a break. He’s got the all important feefees to guide his decisions. You can’t put lipstick on a pig. Haha.
Pregnancy is not just about the uterus , is about hormones , biochemical reactions and so on
that’s not a problem for trans women. their hormones are already regulated with hrt.
@@babs_babsGet help, please. You cannot trust your mind anymore. It is not functioning properly, and you’re going to get worse unless you receive intensive mental treatment. Please please please save yourself. You still seem to be functional enough to type, so please get the help you desperately need.
there are artificial hormones available
Obviously
This is 100% correct if all you need is a healthy uterus and a few hormones why do woman have miscarriages. I had one in 2021 and it was the worst day of my life. I did everything right took vitamins stopped eating all the things I was not supposed to and drinking the things I was not supposed to also didn't take any medication but the prenatal vitamins. So these people that just say yeah they just need to take the hormones that they need and they will have a healthy pregnancy. I am a female and I did all the things I was supposed to do for my baby during my pregnancy. I have all the equipment for a healthy pregnancy. Then why is my son not in my arms? I have my uterus and the hormones, if those are the only things for a successful pregnancy tell me what happened because I would like to know.
On a totally unrelated topic, has anyone read The Island of Doctor Moreau?
spreading content like this without further context is dangerous and you should know better, doctor. look at the hate in the comments, you did this on purpose for engagement.
Hate of what? Ill people being taken seriously? If you have gender dysphoria, its not your body thats giving this problem, its your brain. Therefore the only solution for these people is psychiatric help.
I know you hate im right, but im the good one here, telling your ill friend that they are healthy is a disservice to him
I don't know the context of the rest of it but I got the same feeling after his intentional misgendering comment.
@@imjustwolfyeah, I thought he was better than that.. like, if it’s specifically to help trans women, why the hell is he saying it’s to “put them in men”? He’s a doctor, he should know the difference between gender and sex and just use the sex to describe the anatomy.. or just say “trans women” instead of men, it’s so simple..
@@table2.0thanks your comment made me laugh so much
@@table2.0bruh
You ain't catching me lacking at sleepovers
Look how Robert fell asleep first. Let's do an operation to turn him into Roberta
😂😂😂😂 bros boutta become a woman 👠
Sounds like you need new friends, if that's what you worry about around them.
🤣🤣🤣
@@ccee4117 it sound like you cant decipher a joke
This is why I never sleep first in a sleep over.
Underrated comment
Idk why this made me laugh so hard 😂
@@chellilovesyou5969 because it's a joke
God damn it who put a uterus in me AGAIN.
Lmao bro that’s hilarious
there's no way a baby can go though a mans pelvis
Womans*
@@BlaireTheGlareno biologically that's and men not women .stop insulting biological women
@@BlaireTheGlarewell the pelvis belongs to a biological male
@@BlaireTheGlare Trans women aren’t women, sorry (not really tho, get a helmet), a trans women doesn’t understand what it is to be a true woman, to grow up as one, to experience a period. God dammit if you don’t have a period, a uterus, two X’s on your fucking chromosomes, and tits that can lactate naturally, you aren’t a woman. You can put a name tag on a dog and call it a cat, it’s still a dog. It’s offensive to be reduced to a ‘cis’ woman because men want to become women.
@@BlaireTheGlarenot a womans though it'd be a male pelvis in a "womans" body
It's not about helping people, it's clout. This "surgeon" is incredibly reckless.
I'm a transgender man, and i agree. I see blood on his hands already. :( Even if it's found to be possible one day, it's most certainly no where close to being a possibility now. That transgender woman is sacrificing her life for the dream of giving birth... It makes me wonder if she's in a healthy enough head space to be volunteering for something like this.
A claim that makes no sense. There is no clout for helping trans people in our transphobic societies.
This is called "experimental surgery," and sometimes, those can lead to breakthroughs or discoveries.
@@silentfriend369 pick me
Even if he could make it work, I think the only way that woman could give birth would be through a c-section… unless they found a way to modify that pelvis
It'd have to be through c section. That kind of breaks that a pelvis would need to widen the male form enough would make it break under the muscle strain contractions give. I also wonder how contractions would work given the differences in body
Yeah it would need a C-section 100%
SRS exists for this reason.
@@therealzizmon1748 SRS is more focused on aesthetics. Of course there is functionality for intercourse, but that does not mean there is the same level of functionality for giving birth. We don't even have the technology/ability to transfer a fetus and the womb right now, there's no way we could surgically create all of the biological necessities for vaginal birth essentially from scratch.
Unfortunately a c-section would be the least of their worries. The female pelvis widens over the course of the pregnancy to allow for the increase in size and weight of the uterus as the child grows. So IF they would even physically able to carry the child to term then yes, a c-section would be required. But I HIGHLY doubt it would get that far. They would literally end up being unable to walk. Have you ever seen the pregnant waddle that women do later in their pregnancy, that's because of the size and weight of the uterus and the widening of their pelvis altering their gait. The male body would probably be on bedrest the entire pregnancy and unable to sit up.
People should stop asking themselves "Can we?" and start asking "Should we?"
We should
@@AethenTheProotTheSecondclown
@@flamingrage100 you're the whole circus brother
@@AethenTheProotTheSecond at least I can accept myself for who I am clown.
@@patrioticcat5768I was born a man. I want to be a woman. You tell me I’ll never be a woman? No matter how hard I try?
Watch me sweetie.😘
This is exactly why I removed the donor sticker from my license. I will not have my uterus put in a man after my death.
You are so real for that
im trans and this is definitely dangerous and im confused on how its going to work without the hormones and stuff of a female in the body of a male, like go adopt a child instead. - surely people arent that self conscious about their identity that they need to "become" the body that they do not have to validate their identity
Honestly, it is more dangerous to not know how something works. Every surgery is dangerous when it is done for the first time. Lots of things have to line up before they can try something like this.
Experimental surgeries not just to placate some superficial desire, they are huge learning opportunities. Some things can never really be understood unless you push things to their limits. I would not be surprised if the things they learn from trying to do this have implications for solving various currently unsolvable reproductive issues, or even help create artificial wombs.
@@DigitalSteel It's dangerous not to understand something but that doesn't mean you need to attempt to replicate everything. There is a difference between replicating and understanding.
A composer doesn't have to play every instrument they use.
" unless you push things to their limits. "
pushing things to the limits means that we will cause some miscarriages and birth defects?
I get the advancement at all cost vibe, I really do but that seems especially cruel.
@@wiczus6102 The reason so many people are alive today that otherwise would not be for various medical reasons can thank experimental surgeries just like this one done in the past that have indeed sometimes ended up with complications at the time they were first done. It is not cruel if everyone is doing everything they can do insure it goes well and everyone involved agrees to the risks.
@@newyoutubeaccount2023would a uterus without the eggs and capability to become pregnant be enough?
Exactly
my mans literally trying to build a house with no foundation 💀
No, he is a surgeon, he doesn’t do construction.
There is a foundation. The human body. The working uterus would be more like a workshop or the tools.
@@DarkFlamesDarkness Male and female bodies are so incredibly different, males do not have the foundation for a uterus and especially not to become pregnant
Exactly 👍🏻U Explain It A Veryy Straight Short Direct..
@@calebpryor3557😂😂😂😂😂
“It’s never been done.”
Sometimes that not a bad thing
He shouldn't go ahead with this. Its just wrong.
She
She, regardless if you accept it or not. And good luck to her and all of those who wish to give birth and could benefit if this goes well.
@@MamaMudiwa He, he has a mental illness, no normal person would even have a thought like this.
@@datura2430 He
@@MetalGearBepisshe
All jokes aside, the main problem beyond rejection is bone structure. The female pelvis is designed to be more wider and flexible than a man’s to aid childbirth. Male pelvis’s are more rigid for speed and strength. You can’t change bones without damaging the structural integrity
So you are saying that he will never be a woman?
@@FormaxLtof course , how could a man be completely be changed to women , men's anatomy is way different from women in terms of reproduction. Bones structures , skin etc I think it's understandable 🙂
@@FormaxLt exactly.
Stop stating facts. Biology is transphobic! /sarcasm off
Bruh what do u expect
Pelvic bone: let me introduce myself
Thank you huseim881 ! 👍
You know c sections are a thing?
@@prestonbruchmiller497you know men's bodies can't feel the growing baby right you need to do that naturally
@@skyjacksonA1 There all sorts of things humans weren't able to do until we had the technology to do them.
@@prestonbruchmiller497doesn't matter no such thing as a man turning into a woman. It's hilarious that technology needs to be inserted into the argument to implement the notion that yes it's not possible for woman to be men.
Let people do what they want and need for themselves. This shouldn’t be a public discussion it’s a discussion between a patient and their doctor. People who really don’t understand what kind of difficult situation it can take to lead someone making a decision like this shouldn’t be the ones talking about it.
what kind of difficult situation?
A man’s body will never be able to have kids.
there’s no actual surgery and there’s no patient yet. it _is_ a public discussion because it could potentially affect us all.
Its really not. It is reckless and dangerous. And it should be a public discussion. Biological realities dont allow the privilege of “doing what you want”.
This comment section is pure hell
Yeah I didn't have high hopes because the guy in the video misgenderimg trans women by calling them men. Transphobes will scatter to any place where they feel welcomed like vulchers
You can add whatever hardware you want, but if you don't have compatible firmware running on the CPU, it isn't going to work.
AYYYY
i hate how well this works lmao
Yet.. we dont know what else human beings will discover in the future but right now its a 1 step forward for science but its still a long way to go
hormone therapy
Comparing humans to machines lmao
Yall just adopt kids, give them love instead of doing random things.
Then let us adopt kids.
@@burntmarvmallow141 who didn't let you?
@mohammad alomari in many countries, it is either illegal or impossible for same sex couples to adopt. In most cases, it is easier faster and cheaper to find a serogate womb or sperm donor.
Even for cis straight couples, it can be impossible to adopt a child.
@@burntmarvmallow141 but in those countries don't you think it'll be illegal to have this surgery. Why is this necessary is the point to try and erase women altogether?
@K.Snow How is a random person getting a womb transplant erasing women?
The way many people define a women these days actually excludes some of the cis women you are trying to protect.
Not all women can have children naturally, not all women have wombs, not all women have XX chromosomes.
For the sake of trans women around the world I wish this was doable, but unfortunately the amount of systems required for pregnancy and menstruation just makes this seem pretty much impossible. But trans women, many cisgender women can't give birth, some don't menstruate, it doesn't make you less you. ❤️
ITS MAAAAN 👰🏻♂️
MEN WILL NEVER:
GET PREGNANT
GIVE BIRTH
A man’s body sees a uterus as an intruder and attacks it and that’s why MEN die.
There are women who can’t get pregnant but have the reproductive system to do so, but for what ever reason her system does not work.
Some women don’t have a uterus cervix fallopian tubes ovaries or periods because they had a hysterectomy or take medication to stop the periods.
Trans woman HAVE NEVER HAD A VAGINA CERVIX UTERUS FALLOPIAN TUBES OVARIES OR PERIODS BECAUSE THEY ARE MEN.
@@WakandaleezaRazzman youre a bigot maybe.
@@lifkid Yep. Me and the 99.9% of the population that don’t have your diagnosis or condition. Cope.
@@WakandaleezaRazz *10% **in America
Even if we get to a point where we can literally modify our entire body like in cyberpunk. With 0 differences between males and females. People will still be transphobic. It's sad.
ManWoman perfect transition will mean that there will be no trans to begin with. So yeah, in such a world there will also not be any transphobia. You cannot hate what doesn't exist.
@@agamemnonofmycenae5258people would still hate on people who are not the way the were born. Even nowadays it goes so far that cis people get targeted because people think they're trans for some reason
@tomlxyz well, as of now transitions aren't "perfect". In most cases you can sense that the person was a bio male or female. So trans people are identifiable making them easy targets for bigots. But once the transitions reach perfect levels i.e. where you really couldn't tell what they were originally born as, the hate will disappear cos no will be able to find a target to persecute. And let's be honest, if perfect body modifications would become a reality most of the bigots will be more focused on increasing the size of their own dick over fussing about who's changing to other genders lol.
@@tomlxyzhumans are tribal by nature. Even if society as a whole accepts that all humans are equal, there will always be dumb ignorant people to be racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobe, shit when neuralink hits you really think there won't be purists who discriminate based on that too, on both sides? (Deus Ex game franchise portrays this one the best imo) You can push for 95% of people to accept something, but as sad as it is, there is no real way to eradicate prejudice other than the passage of multiple generations. And even then you're only attacking them one by one, and there's no guarantee every generation will make the same forwards progress you're striving for.
Stop being delusional,you cant modify your natural sex and no one has ever been able to to that,seek therapy for your gender dysphoria
Other male body parts: “Yoooooo bro wtf are you doing in here, no girls allowed”
Female.body part: someone put me here, help!
It's like going into a opposite gender washroom
WBC cells : NO RUNNING! 🔫
@furrysuporter ur a troll right
😂😂
Listen I’m sorry but I will no longer be donating my organs if this is what they’d be using them for.
Yeah I'm opting out
No need to be sorry girl! You’re right this is just horrible
That "bruvvvv" was SO good.
This is the shit were doing instead of curing blindness
Fr like idk why this is even happening
You think scientists stopped studying blindness for this?😂
There's a reason why the women's pelvic bone is so much bigger then men's
Trans women who take hrt before 25 can develop a wider pelvis.
@@galileoandthecrystalgatc1915 pregnancy isn't just about uterus,pelvic bone or hormone.its about the entire body system.during pregnancy,there is specific hormones involves, which even some women cannot produce enough and still hv problems.amd man immune system are stronger than woman,which can rejecting the baby inside the body.woman's entire body system are made for carrying a child.if all it takes is uterus,hormonenand hip bones to have a baby,no woman will be infertile,they just had to insert uterus or hormones to make it work.but no... carrying a child to full term needs an entire body system to work.even diabetes can affect a baby..so many things had to be taken care of..so now you know,getting own child is a sacrifices,many things had to be done,even by someone who naturally born as woman who actually had correct reproductive organs and hormones
@@galileoandthecrystalgatc1915 the thing is that doesn't help. The woman body has a lot of changes made to carry a pregnancy, even if you add hormones, the immune system can just reject the baby or the female genitals implanted don't work because, guess what, they're controlled by a small gland at the base of the brain and even with hormones and all that, the possibility of doing that and dying are high, almost guaranteed
@@methane5211 Exactly! I highly doubt that humanity will every be able to tailor a man's body to work even similar to a woman's during the process of sexual intercourse, fertilization, pregnancy and child birth.
Women are more complex than a set of hormones and a organ that's not even yours. I'm not saying im an expert on biology, but you don't exactly have to be a scholar to know common sense holy he*l.
It doesn’t necessarily need to be used for transwomen. It can benefit ciswomen who have fertility issues. I would be willing to donate a uterus and I think other women who want to be childless would be willing as well.
What confuses me the most is all that would go into carrying the child. Without ovaries, they wouldn’t be able to produce an egg to be fertilized. So, presumably, they’d have to get the egg from someone else and hope that it implants after fertilization. The only thing they’d be able to do is carry, which is already known to have a tremendous toll on the human body. If they can’t produce all the hormones required to keep the baby, they’d have to manually take them. I cannot imagine the kind of stress that would cause, knowing that missing a dosage could potentially kill their baby. And even if they were to carry their baby to term, they’d most likely have to get a c-section which is also a very traumatic procedure. There’s so much that could go wrong and the transplant is risky. Even if it were possible, I can’t only imagine the cost. And even after all that, there’s no guarantee of implantation. If they had the money for the surgery, survived the surgery, still had money for an egg donor, and have enough money to afford all the necessary hormones just to see that the egg did not implant. Well, that would be very very depressing
Ya you put it very well, i feel like itd make more sense to adopt a newborn instead of risk death to yourself and potentially a child.
Not only this you have to think about their bodies attacking the uterus and or (if they make it to this stage) the baby. Their body will look at these things a foreign object and will try to rid the body of it.
@@Chocolatebuttacupoet You'd have to take whatever that antirejection medication is called that people have to take when they get other types on implants, but odds are it's not gonna be healthy for the baby and mighr kill it anyway.you're supposed to check women for pregnancy before operating on them because there's so much that has to be avoided to ensure the baby survives. These trans people talk about pregnancies as if what they desire wont cause innocent lives to be lost over mere delusion.
Because it's a man trying to be a woman which will never happen
@@Chocolatebuttacupoet life on immunosupresors.. mandatory..with ir without attempt at pregnancy
Humans have different size hip bones though
Don’t they need the female hormones for the uterus to work as it should ??
Trans people already receive HRT (hormone therapy ) and transplant of external sexual organs in their teens . This makes their body feminine (wider pelvis and fat deposits in the feminine areas and a softer body type ) . If they successful in transplanting a uterus and are successfully able to maintain the uterus using hormone therapy and make it possible to have periods . Then the next step would be to try IVF implant. It’ll take a long time for that to happen but with the range science is going ahead , it might happen one day in the future.
@@avk94 these are synthetic hormones though ?? Sounds like Frankenstein’s monster being created
Personally I don’t think we should mess with nature
Setting people up for a big fall IMO
There’s absolutely nothing bigoted or ‘transphobic’ about speaking facts. Especially coming from a qualified medical expert. I appreciate your honesty.
Is kinda common around the trans community, using the word "Transphobic" something they disagree or against commonsense.
@@verysadcatc7897 When logic and reality kicks in its 'transfobic', coz they are not sane people!
I mean he never once said that he was attacked, only that it “divided the room”. Sounds more likely to me that you’re just seething over tránnies 24/7 and you’ll find any excuse to vent your paranoia.
Says the transfreak.
@@verysadcatc7897well they won’t do shit. At this point homophobic and transphobic arnt even words to be even sad about tbh. It’s almost like a joke word at this point.
Nurse: Where did you get that uterus doctor?
The Doctor: My lawyer told me not to answer that question
As a trans man u can take mine I don't want it
@@gomes7066 as a woman you mean ?
Comes from a 12 year old girl who wants to become a man(by her parents)
@@kaelthunderhoof5619 well in come countries kids are free to transition no need for parents permission.
@@jamesbond4810 these people will advocate for 12 year olds to have their uterus removed. Sickos
This attempted normalization of this type of behavior needs to stop
It's like trying to install a car engine in a bike.
😂😂😂 these sickos are delusional
Perfect analogy.
Cant fit a hemi v8 on a bmx
Afair, I think early supercars were actually car/airplane engines on a bicycle. Wooden frame, thin tires, and very very aerodynamic body panels because of how inneficient early engines are. Please, PLEASE, CMIIW, though.
Yeah like it Just weird and stupid You were Born male/female Just stay that way Lmao
“Your scientists were so preoccupied with wether they could, they didn't stop to think if they should.”
& why shouldnt they? The ability to create new human life even in the face of next to total extinction sounds like a pretty useful scientific venture to me. Even many stories written about it.
@@DarkFlamesDarkness First of all, this is alteration, not creation. There are experiments done to have more and more of a pregnancy done in an artificial womb outside of a living being (if I recall correctly mostly on sheep), along with fertilization that would be more akin to creating life and could safe several severe pregnancy complications in the future. Gender reassignement surgery and using womb transplants for it are very different, we don't even have the endocrinology of humans or mammals in general completely mapped out and are not at a point in surgical technology (although that might be rather reachable) to tend to that many nerves and vessels and most of all the serose skin and ligaments holding organs in place. Female to female uterus transplantations are still an extremely dangerous, experimental operation and some already want to skip ahead to the next step and do female to male transplants? Sounds a bit too ahead of its time to me.
Also I just have a different view about extinction events, but that's rather a philosophical discussion. I guess that's often the problem in discussions, people disagree with each other and everyone has almost flawless logic, but they still can't agree since the underlying assumptions about life are vastly different. I don't expect humanity to last forever, I think it's important to try to accept that everything that is will someday not be anymore and thus I don't want life extension and see trying to avoid death or extinction by any means as hubris. This doesn't mean complaciency in any extiction event. IMHO trying to solve environmental issues is the right thing to do, same as trying to deflect asteroids etc, while overrushing experimental technology in medicine with kind of a naive sci-fi image of saving the human race feels very off to me, that is btw also the message of many stories written about this.
@@DarkFlamesDarkness You’re actually mentally not ok bro 💀
@@DarkFlamesDarkness why should they risk killing women to say they are the first?
Politics or no politics, I always gotta upvote a good Jurassic Park quote.
But fr tho yeah, this whole thing sounds like a mess. Bro doesn't give a damn about helping these women, he just wants to be the first at something
I'm not a medician, but some basics information everybody should know.Being a woman is not just having an uterus. Our body is way more complex and it's a closed system. I'm wondering a surgeon didn't know it,much worse: all the rest took part. It's like playing Germans during the II world war, like Dr. Mengele. It's terrifying, that this is happening nowadays.
Absolute chaos.
This is the definition of "just because you can, it doesn't mean you should"
Why's that
@@beanfrog6708 going from man to "woman" is a big no no
people have said that about machines taking over textile factories, AI, vaccines and fecal transplant.
Why not? They’re consenting patients and it will benefit their mental health. No one asked you
@@MotherBroker why’s that?
I love how he's not transphobic just concerned as hell for whoever receives this surgery
tf are these replies
guys please stop
nahh actually this is 2 months old stop
transphobic??? fuck off..people have the right to be against this kind of shit..
Love how you think this is about anything other than money and fame
Love how you think the doctor cares about all this social BS and isnt just doing this for fame.
I also love your immediate use of the word "transphobic"
@@mr.x991 doctors are humans..they have beliefs..they have agenda..they are not isolated
I think trans people need to accept that, whatever they’re switching to, it’s just an identity and nothing more. They’re never going to biologically be that gender, so things like these shouldn’t matter if these people wake up to reality. Also, adoption will always be a significantly better choice regardless.
i accept that, biologically i’m still gonna be a boy, but i’m just doing this because it’s who i am, only live once so why not enjoy it and be urself
@@scar1139 hell yeah man
They say we should accept them when they can’t accept themselves
(This was 3 months ago, I don’t really know what I meant at the time. Basically outdated)
@@frostburn9104a trans person accepts themselves the moment they come to terms with being trans, not based on what you think of them
@@ignaciogonzalez7904they accept themselves so much that they pay hundreds of thousand of dollars to mutilate themselve in a desperate attempt to imitate something they aren't. Right.
I’m all for trans rights and bodily autonomy but at some point you have to consider if the risks are really worth it. Like. There are other ways to become a parent.
First, we preach genitals don’t determine who you are, and that fertility doesn’t make you more or less of a person. We are all agreeing that women who can’t give birth aren’t less of a woman. And then you go take these immense risks for something you just deemed irrelevant? This goes both for cis and trans women, by the way. There is no need to start a high risk pregnancy when surrogates and other means to have children exist.
arranging the veins and arteries would probably be a nightmare
Bro the bone structure is different for a reason, a male bone structure isn't built for this and will cause issues to both the adult and the baby
C-section
@@ellismerrill8501 And then the baby just cope with the problems then i asume
@@wedoalittletrolling3305 you don't seem to know what a c-section is...i was delivered via c-section, there weren't any "complications" as far as i know
@@wedoalittletrolling3305 i was delivered via c section and i don’t have any physical complications
@@wedoalittletrolling3305 Bro I was c section and the old difference is my head is perfect. My face never needed to be squeezed through the birth canal.
I think of it like this, if a person feels so deeply disconnected with themselves that they are willing to go to extreme lengths of pain and unbearable measures. Then let them. They clearly know something about themselves that I don't, and they are willing to put their bodies through basically torture to feel better and many of them come out of it actually feeling better. So be it. They're more women than I ever will be and I was born that way
except they try to force society to believe in their delusions. that's when it becomes a problem.
i wonder if you hold the same opinion for people with body dismorphia, or that have mental illnesses that make them want to be disabled, another species of animals or other. with your logic we shouldn’t treat their disorder but just let them try to live their delusion by prescribing a bunch of surgeries right?
@@lambsauce8937 no, that is very much more complicated because that goes beyond cosmetic surgery. That goes far beyond altering relatively external bodily functions that don't impact human quality of life in the same way. Those are not the same situation nor are they related. Something that renders somebody disabled impacts ability to function in life such as walk, talk, interact in a negative way, meaning it takes away a necessary function. Whereas gender confirmation surgeries are changing the breast changing the voice, changing the way the body presents, changing genitals is the most severe, yet it does not actually impact their ability to function in life. So no, I don't have the exact same opinion about that because those are two different things.
Well they are both in the realm of mental health. One may impact vital functions while the other allows them to feel free and able without compromising their ability to function. What I'm trying to say is one is relatively harmless. The other is jeopardizing more than just superficial things
@@Bibirallie I don't think they're forcing anyone to believe anything. Because you can't do that. You can't force somebody to believe something that they don't. It is how they feel. Other people empathize with that, or understand it in some way, or relate to it in some way That is very real to them .
And so you don't have to believe anything. You just look like a dick. If you don't support, love and respect them, they simply won't have anything to do with you. You may not agree with it or understand anything about it, but that does not mean that you should hurt another person or make them feel bad because you think they're being delusional. If it was your family then it'd be okay to just treat them horribly all of a sudden? Usually what happens is you end up losing a lot of your family and you end up alone. Maybe show some empathy or at least understanding, otherwise you're kind of just a dick. You don't have to believe it but it is a very real experience for them.
Everyone deserves basic human respect, "delusional" or otherwise.
@@lambsauce8937Different mental conditions are treated differently. For people who feel the need to cut off their own limbs for example, we refrain from encouraging them to do so because it would negativley effect their quality of life. For trans people who suffer with gender and sex dysphoria, NOT transitioning negativley effects their quality of life, so we encourage them to transition becuase there's no other way for them to reach a quality of life that will allow them to exist comfortably in their own bodies.
i’m trans and i don’t need this, adoption exists you know. And here comes the angry unga bunga people to harass me
I agree im nb and want to have children but i wouldnt subject myself to that it just doesnt make sense, the surgery + the having that organ + pregnancy and childbirth when theres so many children up for adoption. But just like theres so many bio women that have that as their own goal if a trans person is willing to go tru all that why not let them? I dont think its morally wrong but i think its just not worth it and a bad idea cause of the risk
@@ignaciogonzalez7904 yeah that’s exactly my stance, i might have kids in the future but don’t wanna risk the surgery.
it's not just the uterus, it's your brain, hormones, even your bones are a part of it. You have to be able to carry the kid full term, it isn't just simply putting the embryo there and it existing in a separate environment from your body thise 9 months. if the body doesn't know how to make all the connections and shit it has to do with blood vessels, nutrient transport and bodily fluids to have the fetus survive and actually grow without major complications, it won't work.
Yes during foetal ejection complex hormones are released by Brain which causes more uterine contractions.
These people don't get basic 11-12th grade Biology. Denial can't be cured.
@@hsuyaa_ that's what she said, now she's dead
@@hsuyaa_ 🤓
@@hsuyaa_ have you seen the hio bone of a male and woman? the baby head cant fit in the male bone. also they died u know why? bcoZ biology wont allow it
For future reference, you might want to link to that video in the comments or the description or both
Population decrease
@OwO we won’t
@OwO you need to post your OWN comment, not reply to mine, please
@@wagomus4323 population decrease? How about we start with you, then 😉
@@wagomus4323 what the hell is that even supposed to mean?
Bro people in the comments acting like nobody is trying to cure cancer :/
A surgeon's capability to cure cancer is the same as yours. Do it yourself if you think he can spend his time better.
Do not compare curing cancer to this. These things are miles apart from each other. Both medically and ethically.
@@pasijutaulietuviuesas9174 Yeah exactly.
As a transgender woman, I really don’t think this is a good idea, at least for now. Cis women have endless problems at birth, and a trans woman giving birth would present tenfold those problems. From hormones to bone/muscle structure, this just doesn’t seem reasonable in 2023.
its really sad to see other transfems agreeing with these people. no, bone structure is the result of bone *development* that happens during puberty, for a male it is broadening shoulders, for a female it is a widening pelvis, and for BOTH it is generally getting taller. if you start hrt early enough, bone structure is not going to be a problem for you. many people dont realize this, and they want us to stay oblivious to it so they can continue invalidating us with “bOnE sTrUcTuRe”.
We’re not cis or anything but women. We’re the only women. We’ve been HALF the human race since before we were Homo sapiens. Nice to meet you. You’re a gender anomaly. You’re at high estimate about 0.02% of the human race. If that. Stop appropriating women we’re not a costume we’re not a set of self identifications for those with mommy issues.
Why are you transgender? You are misusing your body which God has blessed you with
Damn as a med student I can't imagine to achieve that level of surgical mastery.
Mastery Frankenstein monster?
I'm so concerned about what success will even look like. I'm all for being your authentic true self but who will take responsibility for complications.
@@mohamadtoriquekhan9697 this is posed like it is a new issue, but it really is not. They have already said uterine transplant has been successful in cis women. Were you there worrying about the liability for complications then? Or do you feel okay with it because it's succeeded a couple times?
Do you go and research medical liability laws? Common law liabilities? Or do you sit there and postulate about an issue because you don't know how it works?
This isn't a jab at you, but I guess a bit of information to help digest new situations like this.
In truth, this will be treated like any other surgery. The dr and hospital take on a level of liability, having a dr patient relationship. Firstly, they must adequately inform the patient of risks, complications, procedures, and expectations. They must act within ethical obligations of their certification board. That probably means, among other things, not acting out of self interest, not aiming to reduce the quality of life of a patient, acting in the patient's interests safely in the circumstances, and properly informing themselves of all necessary medical literature and training in order to make this as safe as possible.
They likely also have to have the hospital they work at sign off on the surgery, especially being such a new situation to perform this procedure.
Their patient probably has to undergo several general referrals, psych referrals, significant testing, and counselling to make this decision.
They also have to pay out of pocket for this to go ahead.
In the end, patient also has to sign legal documentation acknowledging they understand the situation they are in, and are accepting a degree of risk. This DOES NOT mean the dr/hospital incur no liability (as tv would have you believe) , but that the Dr/Hospital are only liable for mistakes/errors/misjudgments that they themselves make, as the patient is very aware of what information is available, and has asked to receive this procedure despite all of that.
@this name cannot be used for your RUclips channel. You should probably learn what a word means before using it.
@@mohamadtoriquekhan9697 in comparison, I could wake up tomorrow and fuck up my life so much faster, and so much cheaper, if I so wished. I would not need one, let alone 2, 3, or 4 psych referrals to do so. No one in this situation is wandering into it blind of the risks, or intending harm. It is a very careful decision, that, at the end of everything, everyone agreed would be worth it
Damn I wish it was 2008 rn
bro take me bakk to 04 when I was juss bein born
@@sinister9th926 ong in 08 atla was out
@@sinister9th926 and we had Xbox and wii
@@sinister9th926Same. '04 was my birth year as well.
@@nickc1425 I really started noticing around 2011
Fun fact: many men are also born with ovaries and can go their whole lives without knowing.
Oh I've seen that! It's an intersex condition I believe
Honestly hope this never happens.
People out there really think human bodies work like lego blocks 💀
hope we'll reach a level where they do
@@cccbbbccc5910no are you crazy
@@Hippoartamus swapping a faulty kidney for a new one seems useful
The hormones controlling the functioning, stability and process of pregnancy left the chat. 💀
We'll a lot of hormonal injections will be given in that case
@@sayanswoonchol2606 should probably just stay as your natural gender tbh
@@dextersynesterformerlysorb5334 chad
@@dextersynesterformerlysorb5334 why do that when you can spend thousands of dollars on all these surgeries and injections
@@brycethoreson9216 ah yeah you're right I forgot I can get a designer vagina my bad thanks my guy taking estrogen rn
this is actually unnecessary 💀
I think this is exactly why the first treatment option given to any woman over 30 is a hysterectomy - collecting uteruses to experiment with - the 'medical' field has gone rogue.
Cancer: killing millions a year
Humans: let's make a man give birth
this is ONE doctor. A huge percent of them are still working on a cure for cancer, we didn't just give up on that. it doesn't work like that lmao there's 8 billion ppl.
you do know there's already millions of scientists all working in different fields.
notably alot of them workig on said issue
The point is is that this uterus transplant is useless, pointless and it shouldn't be given attention
@@fudgecakes1313 so like you're doing now by not only viewing, commenting but engaging with other people, thus pushing this video towards more people ?
not very smart now is it
@@isuckatusernames4297 nor is it smart to use that becuase it's a short I don't care about the argument I just hate this exuse
“We should make trans women have the ability to give birth”
The pelvic bones:
Edit: “umm actually c-section exist so there wouldn’t be a problem” 🤓
Fairly common issue also for cis women. I am more concerned about the hormonal changes that ebbs and flows during a pregnancy, and how we could mimic that sufficiently well. Hormonal issues is even a problem for quite a few cis women that miscarries, and throw in HRT? It becomes complicated. Incredibly interesting on many levels, but complicated.
I suspect that for the foreseeable future, the most realistic way trans people can be parents is by a trans woman contribute with sperm cells, trans men contribute with egg cells, and then either the trans man manages to partially de-transition, or they use a surrogate. That said, most trans people I know would be more than willing to adopt instead of going through this mess.
I mean, yes and no. Bone structure, while generally being different between male and female anatomy, also differs between every person individually. I don't know the numbers, but there probably have been women with very small pelvic bones who have given birth.
Just in general, it would be a huge leap in the medical world if it can be achieved
@@DanielDitte But what are the chances that a minority would have the right pelvic size
@@BigMac4141 definitely not saying it's very likely, but it is possible. Maybe that's what's needed for the first one to succeed? Ah well, I'm not a doctor at all, so I really can't speak too much on this.
@@DanielDitte me neither, I just know the pelvic bone is smaller in men