Jodi Dean - Communism or Feudalism?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024

Комментарии • 88

  • @riccardocuciniello2044
    @riccardocuciniello2044 5 лет назад +31

    CLASS SNUGGLE

  • @MK0118
    @MK0118 3 года назад +12

    Who else got here via Trueanon? The lady is a great speaker!

  • @fellowtraveler2251
    @fellowtraveler2251 5 лет назад +23

    Excellent talk. Very insightful.

  • @innergi5516
    @innergi5516 3 года назад +3

    Ot is highly like that two things will dominate this century. The fall of capitalism & the rise of something new we cant imagine yet.

  • @rballen420
    @rballen420 6 месяцев назад

    Since Oct 7 , I see Dr Dean as the only theorist left standing, since I used an unholy alliance of Jack Barnes, Jodi Dean, Nina Power and Chris Cutrone, Amazingly I did pretty good union work with these diverse touchstones!

  • @bostanistanbul3304
    @bostanistanbul3304 4 года назад +7

    very enlightening. however, feudo-capitalism would be a better terminology to use than neo-feudalism. also for reaosns given by her.

  • @vonvon3104
    @vonvon3104 2 года назад +5

    3 min and I'm urged to aknowledge her genius

  • @klarakrok
    @klarakrok 3 года назад +1

    Jodi Dean Her message At Brazilian Left Fight Facing Crescendo of Fascism

  • @archiveofearlyhumandigitality
    @archiveofearlyhumandigitality 2 года назад

    29:00 Quite apt to state this at such a festival of "cool, urban, experimental" music

  • @captivatingcurios
    @captivatingcurios 3 года назад +8

    This was brilliant

  • @nathanjohnston1176
    @nathanjohnston1176 Месяц назад

    The problem is that communism in practice is the same as feudalism as it tends to be highly hierarchical with wealthy farm bosses and factory managers inevitably finding ways to consolidate wealth and become new feudal lords

  • @sunilram3968
    @sunilram3968 17 часов назад

    Communism can also be feudalism just like what happened in dprk

  • @crakermac3818
    @crakermac3818 2 года назад +1

    I would say that the problem of lack of home ownership and private property is more from the changing of family structure.
    Boomers rely on social security, instead of thier family. Which requires more housing for boomers to live independently.
    Surging divorce rates leads to needing 2 homes instead of one.
    If these two things were removed available housing would increase by 2/3rds
    Edit: actually when you factor in divorced boomers that rare would be higher.

    • @_d2082
      @_d2082 2 года назад

      That contributes to the problem, for sure, but your 2/3 statistic is definitely off. That statistic relies on EVERY family being divorced with 2 houses, plus one or two for the boomers, which is not the case. It for sure contributes but I wouldn't say it is the main cause.

    • @crakermac3818
      @crakermac3818 2 года назад

      @@_d2082
      50% of marriages end in divorce and is on the rise.
      2/3rds is not 100%
      I said that if parents moved back in with kids and people stayed together we could easily, increase the houses available, by 2/3rds
      Possibly more, but probs not.
      If those 50% stayed together that alone is a 25% increase in housing

  • @MrApplewine
    @MrApplewine 3 года назад +2

    The whole point should be that it is a false dislchotomy to only be able to choose between communism or corporate feudalism or fascism. We need to address what is wrong with the world today by coming up with a system which is none of these bad alternatives.

    • @neuemilch8318
      @neuemilch8318 2 года назад

      sooo how do you imagine it?

    • @duffdingelmeyer7101
      @duffdingelmeyer7101 2 года назад +1

      Organize production to meet needs through democratic ownership of the means of production. This is all communism is. It's a no brainer.

  • @thoughtsurferzone5012
    @thoughtsurferzone5012 3 года назад +1

    Sorry. The future is a resource based economy, technology trumps labor.

    • @Cooliofamily
      @Cooliofamily 3 года назад +6

      Resources are finite. This type of economy isn't sustainable.

    • @neuemilch8318
      @neuemilch8318 2 года назад

      i agree because we already life in it.
      2 questions
      How do we divide power
      How do we divide recourses

    • @_d2082
      @_d2082 2 года назад

      @@Cooliofamily And we will abuse them until they are gone.

    • @HD-mp6yy
      @HD-mp6yy Год назад

      Well yes, but actually no

  • @x00p3
    @x00p3 3 года назад +3

    Communism or Feudalism. Neither.

  • @torquiloers3966
    @torquiloers3966 3 года назад +4

    I don't want to live under communism or Neo-fuedalism, I want my American individualism back.

    • @williampepper7709
      @williampepper7709 3 года назад +20

      Your American individualism led you here

    • @neuemilch8318
      @neuemilch8318 2 года назад

      why not both

    • @ianperfitt
      @ianperfitt 2 года назад

      American Individualism is a lie. Look closely.

    • @forevershampoo
      @forevershampoo 2 года назад

      @@williampepper7709 rather the exploitation of that individualism

    • @lepistanuda
      @lepistanuda 2 года назад

      Your American Individualism was always a lie, a single use plastic, a piece of bubble wrap to separate your from the world and its many others

  • @jeffwhite3309
    @jeffwhite3309 5 лет назад +9

    This speaker is an academic scholar? No wonder college enrollment is dropping.

    • @scrimblybringlesnatch7485
      @scrimblybringlesnatch7485 4 года назад +11

      grilling time is over, boomer

    • @neuemilch8318
      @neuemilch8318 2 года назад

      ha and I thought it was because nobody in your hellhole of a country can afford to study anymore.

    • @brunogantz7908
      @brunogantz7908 2 года назад

      Is this your actual name or your ideology, Mr. White ?

  • @ryanjohnson8933
    @ryanjohnson8933 3 года назад +4

    Theoretical word salad.

    • @bigollameo
      @bigollameo 2 года назад +4

      So you didn't understand it.

  • @Everyman777
    @Everyman777 4 года назад +4

    I was wondering where I'd heard this style of talk before, and then I remembered - this is exactly how astrologers sound.

  • @ahartley3529
    @ahartley3529 3 года назад +1

    There is no capitalism versus anything else. All there is is universal human economic behavior, defined as the exchange of goods or services or labor for more of the same. All there is is how it’s going to be regulated, under what over arching philosophy: less regulation or more regulation.

    • @never-walk-alone
      @never-walk-alone 2 года назад +1

      No lmao. Read marx

    • @ahartley3529
      @ahartley3529 2 года назад

      @@never-walk-alone I’ve read Marx, maybe before you were born… and I’m laughed out already. Marxists need to read their own messiah’s books before they lecture others. Better yet… read something else…

    • @never-walk-alone
      @never-walk-alone 2 года назад +4

      @@ahartley3529 if you actually read marx you would understand that the movement towards communism is in dialectic conflic against capitalist. the theory that Professor dean posits is that society is currently progressing toward re-amplifying aspects of society that defined feudalism. not really that complicated

    • @ahartley3529
      @ahartley3529 2 года назад

      @@never-walk-alone Again I say…. Reread my last post

    • @ianperfitt
      @ianperfitt 2 года назад +2

      Nope.

  • @louisetaylor2131
    @louisetaylor2131 3 года назад +3

    What cra p

    • @leiyang477
      @leiyang477 3 года назад

      CRAP! I wonder who is endowing that chair she occupies in that College, and who has funded her Cultural Marx indoctrination at Columbia. We do know the Frankfurt School of Marxists established their Stronghold at Columbia University, their Second Weimar Republic is finally coming into fruition against the current Fraudulent Election, openly trying to steal and hijack our Republic and turn it into “professor” Dean’s Communist Fascist distopia. Fortunately for the Republic, the unseen hands who have nutured the Communist Takeover will be exposed and their true intention of enslaving the population and turn the earth into a prison planet will be exposed and they will not be able to walk down the street!

    • @11sagara
      @11sagara 2 года назад +1

      @@leiyang477 lol

    • @bigollameo
      @bigollameo Год назад

      For simple minds, I'm sure it sounds just like crap.