Bari Weiss | Full Episode 3.12.21 | Firing Line with Margaret Hoover | PBS
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- Former New York Times editor and “How to Fight Anti-Semitism” author Bari Weiss joins Margaret Hoover to discuss the rise of anti-Semitism and intolerance across the political spectrum.
This program is made possible by viewers like you. Support your local PBS station: www.pbs.org/donate
Subscribe to the PBS channel for more clips: / pbs
Enjoy full episodes of your favorite PBS shows anytime, anywhere with the free PBS Video App: to.pbs.org/2Qb...
FOLLOW US:
Website: www.pbs.org/sh...
Facebook: / firinglinewithmargaret...
Twitter: / firinglineshow
Instagram: / shop.pbs.org
FIRING LINE WITH MARGARET HOOVER airs on PBS. Launched in June 2018, Firing Line maintains the character of the original series by William F. Buckley Jr., providing a platform that is diligent in its commitment to a balanced exchange of opinion. In weekly 30-minute episodes, host Margaret Hoover engages in a rigorous exchange of ideas with political leaders, cultural luminaries, thought leaders and activists who represent a wide range of ideas and perspectives. New episodes are available Fridays here on RUclips at 8:30 pm ET.
I get this is from a year ago, but her notion that the Democratic Party is moving towards being more like the Squad sounds downright ridiculous now and the party leadership has remained as steadfast behind Israel as they've ever been.
Wasn't she that journalist who infamously said "Assad toady" on Joe Rogan's podcast ?
yep
Dairy industry can have a lobby, Jews cam have a lobby, blacks can have the NAACP and Black Lives Matter, but where is the advocate or lobby for whites and white interests?
Bari is my favorite political writer right now. She tells the truth, right and left.
lol
Bari Weiss is hot, sorry not sorry.
iF YOU REPEAT A LIE ENOUGH DOES IT BECOME TRUTH???????
I like Bari Weiss. 💯☺️. Also I can’t wait until Margaret take my advice and post the show on Apple podcast 🙏🏾🥳
We like the way you are thinking and hope to make an announcement soon.
@@FiringLine yaaaaaaaaay 🥳🇺🇸
It was really helpful for Bari to describe a definition of Anti-Semitism; people throw around the term all the time but she actually but some meat on the bones of what that phrase actually entails in modern society. She's really intelligent and doesn't fit neatly into the "right/left" paradigm. I wonder if they would have fired her at the NYT if she didn't resign. Thanks for the informative interview, Margaret!
That she didn't formally prove her definition is the problem. She's just some stupid privileged sycophant.
@@shawnruby7011 It seemed to me that the entire interview was Weiss citing specific examples of what she considered anti-semitic policies and philosophies. She presented cases and I suppose it's up to the viewer to decide whether they count as anti-semitism.
Appreciate your thoughtful review! Thanks for watching.
she sucks omegalul (In all seriousness I thin consider Bari to be a very hypocritical and bad faith actor.)
I found her book to be conceptually all over the place, a rushed mess. If I was a high school teacher and she turned in that book I wouldn't even give it a passing grade. At times it was also just misleading. In chapter 3 she wrote "For the second time in American history, Jews were shot dead as they prayed in synagogue, this time in Poway California".
That's "Jews" as in plural, more than one. 1 Jewish worshipper was shot and killed that day while several others were injured. But read it again "For the second time in American history, *Jews* were shot dead as they prayed in synagogue, this time in Poway California". It clearly gives the impression that there were multiple deaths. How this passed the editorial stage without being amended is beyond me.
She also talks about other bigoted attacks (against Sikhs, Muslims, blacks and others) in a way that is supposed to create a narrative of America suddenly becoming a dangerous place for Jewish people? Non-Jewish victims, including the 50 Muslims of the Christchurch massacre, are morbidly paraded in front of the reader as proof that "It was clear after the Poway attack that Jews, never mind everyone else living in a divided nation awash in weapons owned by people who could radicalize themselves in front of computer screens, had reason to be afraid in America".
I'm pretty sure blacks and Native Americans were already pretty scared about living in America for hundreds of years before the Poway shooting. This book demonstrates the myopic, sheltered world view of this immature young woman.
SheShe is incredibly smart and articulate and relatable
7:00 Actually the Democrats said that Trump was watching fake news so he threw it back at them and said they are the fake news. Trump is the best president for Jewish people I've ever seen in my life. And I am grew up political just like Bari Weiss. And I challenge anyone to dispute me on that in here in the comments because I’ve made a list of all the things he’s done for Jews so I can refer to my list.
If I become an expert on Antiwhitism, will I get an interview? Or is it just the Js who get this sympathy and support when they become Warriors for their race. And yes, they consider themselves a race and a religious group.
10 Things Most People Don't Know About Bari Weiss - ruclips.net/video/DQLhXGvgHSo/видео.html
Does Bari understand her argument?
"It was activism that led Bari Weiss to journalism" ... WHAT??? WHAT??? ... you tube "NY Times writer criticizes Tulsi Gabbard on Joe Rogan" and see if Weiss has earned her "journalism" distinction!!! ... what a phony with her false narratives!
@terence francis ... and Rogan's 10 million subscribers terence? ... (have you considered night school? ... you're welcome!)
Watch her on Joe Rogan, she’s got an IQ of 14
You are dead on correct
Bari says by all accounts Jews are an oppressed minority, and therefore racists arent punching up. I would like to understand that point better. It would be good to know what the poverty rate is amongst Jewish Americans, or higher education levels, or wealth, or prison rates vs other groups. If these comparisons fare well for Jewish americans, would that counter her argument about not punching up, or that Jews are by all accounts an oppressed minority group?
So you’re saying it’s okay to be anti-Semitic, because it’s punching up? WTF is wrong with you?
@@Thorbie unfortunately, that is the way the left thinks.
Resilience and creativity don't mean a group isn't historically oppressed, nor not a minority. It's impressive that people like Elie Wiesel and Viktor Frankl were sufficiently resilient, creative and free of bitterness to move on with their lives after facing horrific enslavement and oppression, build successful careers in their fields, and focus on helping others and the world rather than remaining mired in self-pity. But that doesn't negate the fact that they were oppressed, and in the most egregious of ways.
Oppression is oppression.
@@carinamoses2704 Absolutely correct that Jews were historically oppressed. What I was questioning was Bari's claim that they are presently oppressed (and or to the degree she claims here).
I'd also poiint to Frederick Douglas, Marcus Garvey, Harriet Tubman and Ralph Ellison as being impressive in ways redolent of Elie Wiesel and Victor Frankl.
I love how people like these two casually reference "populism" in a negative way, as if having subjugated and starving underclasses is an unassailable tenet of any civilized society.
They're either idiots that assume populism means rw or what you said
To be fair, populist policy is fine as a matter of supporting things that everyday people care about, but often times ends as resenting and beheading the elite (literally and figuratively). Legitimate reason to be cautious in my opinion.
Populism leads to tyranny by the majority.
@@davidmersiovsky we have a wide swathe of Americans who have no concept of political philosophy or history.
Hoover is just a journalist, what shitty replacement is this? Buckley actually dove into it. Journalist integrity isn't the sole way to have a non-confrontational conversation. Buckley would critique them make them bring their points around at to them take criticism himself... what in modern privileged upper class conversation is this? At least privileged aristocratic conversation you could admire the moral and ethical displays they showed throughout it (some very ingenious), this is about as flat as the American accent and I'm not critiquing her so much as whatever the fuck spawned this terrible rhetoric style. You probably shouldn't open up w them being lesbian turbo dogmatists tho. No wonder these get no views. It's just comandeering an old show name for some new podcast crap. Even if you disagreed with Buckley, and I have my fair share of doing so, you can appreciate the guests and conversation. This is pathetic. She's a horrid rhetorician, no style at all - just bland.
I'm a liberal Dem and Jew-hatred amongst leftists is very upsetting
Are you saying that anti-Zionism is Jew-hatred?
@@holyworrier He is saying as he has written. I will chime in and say yes to your question.
@@keithasiegel your dead wrong bud
@@holyworrier "When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews, you're talking antisemitism"
Martin Luther King Jr
@@davidsheriff9274 - No one should be above criticism. That's bullshit. Criticism is not hate. Repudiation is not hate. And another thing. Christians have been Zionists for centuries in America and Britain, which are hotbeds of superstition. The Balfour Declaration was largely to placate British Christian Zionists.
I love Bari Weiss. I support her on Substack, and I think she's an essential journalist and leader in a profession desperately in need of professionalism. But for a person who strongly believes in generous interpretations of what people say, she's awfully quick to jump on the vague accusation that Trump has debased political discourse and therefore is tacitly supporting anti-Semitism. That's quite a leap. Yes, Trump is narcissistic, impulsive, spiteful and even childish. But I try to to look beyond his rhetoric and give credit for what he has done. And his actions have consistently supported the Jewish people and Israel, despite massive political resistance. That should get more weight than Bari gives it.
Surprised she didn't pull out her phone to get her "facts" during the interview like she did when Joe Rogan dismantled her
You mean the guy made his career telling people to drink bull semen?
@@Thorbie yup! Thats the guy
Bari is a hack.
Anti-semituism? The relentless use of this term, as if it indicated knowledge and sophistication is puzzling. Did anybody in the Pittsburgh shooting hear "All these Semites need to die?" Any German Jew ever hear "Accursed Semites?" "Dirty Semites?" 'Anybody ever heard Arab muslims chant their relentless "Khaybar Kkaybar hey, Semites?" Of course not! Then, why, why on earth are intelligent people still attached to and keep circulating that idiotic, misguiding and tragic Arian-Semitic Race Theory (ASRT) terminology?
Where there is anti-Jew hate, bigotry, scape-coating, (envy, maybe?) and violence, no doubt, it should be addressed swiftly, directly and simply without the dubious reference to "Semitism." Indeed, like 350M Semitic Arabs and, unlike 100M Semitic Ethiopians (who are Black), many of the mere 15M multi-racial, multi-ethnic Semitic Jews are NOT a race, but a People. Ironically, about 50% of Jews don't even speak their Semitic language, Hebrew. Why? That's right, because of Anti-Jew hate, bigotry and violence. In short, the term "Anti-Semitism" needs to be deleted from daily usage ASAP and reserved to the history archives of WWII.
Also puzzling, to me, why should anyone be ashamed or proud of their identity? Comfortably aware (not Comfortably Numb) is all it should take to develop self-esteem and get along with others.
BTW, shouldn't Trump "embrace" of White Supremacists be mentioned without forgetting Obama's picture opps with the "delightful" duo Farakkan and Jeremaia Wright? And shouldn't the Arab-Israeli conflict be mentioned along with its underlying religious problem--the attachment of Ultra-Orthodox Jews to their biblical historic homeland and the attachment of Arab Muslims to the dogmatic Holy-Hate, love of death and Honor violence?
And shouldn't the hateful Congress woman from MN (who violates the 1st Amendment of the US constitution by admimiding to being "Proud" to market her religion) be mentioned with a fellow ex-refugee, Ayaan Hirsi Ali and her insightful, urgent book, "Prey?" Omaran is in Congress not to legislate, but to agitate against the Jewish State and normalize Sharia law. Towards that, she's learned to recite some "progressive" sounding phrases.
Jealousy causes prejudice against Jews
And now Asians too.
PBS brings on a "conservative", Margaret Hoover? Lol.
Shows how much debate they desire. None, at all.
For real, PBS is garbage now.
“Margaret Hoover”?
Bari Weis is not a conservative…
and she isn’t Margaret Hoover either. Try paying attention before you comment.
What are toadie...
LOL I was just about to say that.
13:26 eee ee none with guestmob
I would love to have Bari Weiss write an analysis of the Russian revolution and especially the principal characters. Just curious.
Why were the royals killed?
Nah, she would have to read something that's not on twitter or a """trusted news source""".
Why is this from a YEAR ago??
What is a Toadie?
She's a joke.
I don't understand what Buckley did that was so heroic in that clip shown here at 20:24. What did Buckley say that was so praiseworthy?
Exactly. It is known that Buckley strove hard to keep anti-Semitism out of the conservative movement, but this specific clip did not suffice to show that.
@@SamvedIyer He did the absolute bare minimum in asking a question as a journalist giving his guest the opportunity to respond to the charge of Jewish meddling in American politics. And on the Italian lobbying point he even provided some push back. This was his job as a journalist and it was still a softball interview. The fact that you guys can't see this shows just how biased you would like the media to be on the issue of Israel or Jewish American interests.
11:00 He’s not saying go back to where you came from he said go back there fix it and come back here and tell us how it’s done. Since their places they come from are so much worse than here and all they do is criticize and say how terrible this place is.
Bari Weiss is a Toady
I learned about Bari Weiss when she resigned from the The New York Times. I then thought to myself, “what a courageous young lady”. However, I don’t agree with her or see eye-to-eye on her thoughts or comments against President Trump or Prime Minister Netanyahu.
I'm with you
Ditto.
There are probably many things she and I would not agree on. But her saving grace is that you could have a debate with her without her demonizing you or trying afterwards to "cancel" you. Her reasonableness in this regard is a trait almost completely lacking on the Left (and too much of the Right, for that matter.)
She Quit because she made her self and more importantly her employer look like fools on the Joe Rogan show.
No one can speak honestly and openly about this matter. So the animosity and paranoia grows. The censors are playing a very dangerous game.
I think this woman is very brave . I am half Jewish and half Italian. Mom Jewish and dad Italian. Try being that and growing up with christians! Every bad thing that could be said was said to me. Now as far as I know, mom said mom is a new kids are Jews . Big probs growing up! Anyway , love Bari ! So smart!
Both beautiful, brilliant women. Lucky us..
"Spiritual Israel", made up of some ethnic Jews but mostly of gentiles, all of whom exercise faith in The Messiah, Jesus, is now the Nation that has God's approval. This is only because, as a Nation, ancient Israel rejected The Christ. BW is obviously a very sharp and intelligent individual but whenever I hear arguments like her's I can't help but remember factual, documented history.
We are literally Israel, there are more than 3 tribes, there are 13, and 10 were scattered into thr nations, we are them, those of us who accept Jesus as the Messiah, we are graftes back in by faith. We are Israel, and anyone that accepts Jesus as Messiah and keeps the commands of God are Israel and will enter the kingdom when He returns.
Bari Weiss. Trump Deraingement Syndrome. I saw her blog with Jordan Peterson June 10, 2021 and then she seemed to have the opposite view of attacking Trump.
Without NY, NJ, Fl...I think USA would be just as bad for J’s as any other country.
Bari sounds kinda like Dr. Abramson here, I wonder if she’s familiar.
I would love to hear about just who made up a plurality of the Cheka and the NKVD.
Hate just pours out of this girl. Trying to get people fired for no other reason than they were of Arab decent...
Just to refute some of the bullshit she said, Jews are neither oppressed nor a minority. They are a white ethnic group differentiated only by their religious affiliation and they are among the wealthiest and most privileged in our society. You can't have that large a conglomeration of billionaires and multi-millionaires as they do and be oppressed. And yes the idea that Jews are wealthy, powerful, well connected and run a lot of large institutions like media and Hollywood and therefore can control narratives is not a conspiracy theory or anti-Semitic. It is a statement of fact.
Wrong
@@heyitsme881 you can live in a fantasy world if you want. Everything I wrote was 100% on point.
@@bozeeke lol it’s really not. It’s a very silly and elementary take, honestly.
@@heyitsme881 that's typical leftist bullshit. When you're 100% on point and they got nothing, then the playbook dictates that you try and belittle a correct argument since you can't discredit it with facts. So Ok then genius, what's your take? I'll go get my popcorn because this should be entertaining and at least good for a laugh.
Jews make up about 3% of the U.S. population. By definition Jews are a minority. There are far fewer Jews in the the U.S. than blacks, and blacks are a minority. Also, Jews are an ethno-religious group, not a religious group. For any Jew that didn't convert, Jewish identity is not based on religion, it is based on parentage. If you were born to a Jewish mother you are a Jew, by Jewish law. This is how you get many Jews who are atheists, this is how you get Jews who not only don't practice Judaism they are practice a different religion. Also, any Jew that didn't convert isn't white. Countless DNA studies on Ashkenazi Jews show that they are a mix of European and Mideastern, so by definition Ashkenazi Jews aren't white.