A Deep Dive into Scraptrap's Design (and how i'd redesign him) [Part 1]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- Watch Part 2 instead it's just redoing this but better: • Another Analysis of Sc...
I have had an unhealthy obsession with Afton (Scraptrap) since the day Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator released. This video is the result of years of stewing over his design. I rag on him a bit but I love him dearly.
Please give him merch.
All fanart in this video is credited within the video itself. Anything by "SpringThatTrap" is from me, that was my online alias at the time. And yes, I consistently called him Gooftrap for like 2 years.
thank you to my wonderful gf Natalie for the very insightful comment at the end
![Another Analysis of Scraptrap's Design (and a new redesign) [Part 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cuu_9UNkz_c/mqdefault.jpg)
![Another Analysis of Scraptrap's Design (and a new redesign) [Part 2]](/img/tr.png)
Here's a "Part 2" that improves everything in this video. Go watch it: ruclips.net/video/cuu_9UNkz_c/видео.html
Thoughts on Burntrap (SB Spoilers): ruclips.net/video/A-xwa4kxRMg/видео.html
content! great the up Keep edits! the great did You
69 likes
Ayo wut happened to the discord?
@@HarambaeXelonmuskfans **English has left the chat**
Scott? Do you know this man personally?
I love how in the fnaf community the sister location ambiance is just accepted as the spooky music for videos
SL, FFPS, and UCN all have great osts and they're especially good for background music, I love them a lot
Yeah
@@theooftroop Ha Ha, love how it's all the side games
@@Purtle calling those side games is uh
definitely a way to refer to them
@@theooftroop i mean apart from the main 4 (the ones that have their series numbers on them)
I remember finding scraptrap SO ugly to the point where I found it absolutely hilarious and instantly loved him lmfao
Same?
Well the fandom now calls Scraptrap, 'Peepaw Willie'. That was the most hilarious thing that ever happened in this fandom.
is that a joke?
I used to think he had cheeks like the toy animatronics
Hello verified person
Same
depends on which cheeks u talking about
Ya same 😆😆😆😆😆
@@icecream7785 o.o
Springtrap's anatomy was, ironically, more accurate to the human anatomy than scrap trap's
You can forgive springtrap anatomy by saying that the springlocks mess up his entire body
Yeah but ankle guts
Guys what if scraptrap uses the bones of his victims to build himself as he couldnt find enough metal parts. See everything in the fnaf universe makes sense if you just think about it and stop throwing accusations like "it makes no sense" Or "bad design"
@@matthewmcbride778 stringlocks?
@@IFreakingLovePancakesFellasbasically William (springtraps/scarptraps real identity) made springlock suits that can be both an animatronic and be worn by a person if needed but the spring locks were fragile so there was a chance the springlocks could snap on someone and kill them which is what happened to William after he put one on after being chased by the ghosts of children he killed to assert power over them I know that was a lot to take in but that’s just the fnaf lore
"The only people having access to the full quality render are merch companies and MatPat."
That made me laugh.
Where the comments?
I wonder why matpat hasn’t released that? Isn’t he about being one with his community and solving it together? Feels wired he hasn’t just posted it to Instagram or something for people to examine
@@_the_missing_piece5552 perhaps Scott doesn't want him to and matpat is just honouring his wishes.
I feel he isn't just keeping it to himself cus he wants to.
@@yeahbuddy7217 thats a possibility.
It also could've just been a joke.
The matpat part anyways, not the merch.
Lol
Finally, someone who's realised that springtrap wasn't just following the sounds of children just for the hell of it, he was forced against his will to follow the sounds, just like the toys programing.
Thank you my dude, you've alleviated my anxiety
Wait... most people didn't know that?
We live in a society.
@@tea-stems7835 That's why I'm surprised the majority didn't know because it's a big reach. And also because phone guy literally says the suits go towards children they hear
Oh that's why, I never thought about it to much
I just didn’t care
I just thought he was like the fnaf 1 animatronics, he was mindless but remembered his urges to kill kids, that's why I thought he followed them, but this makes way more sense, the animatronics were designed to kill kids
5:45 I hate scraptrap's eyes, but LOVED Springtrap's. His looked like the animitronic eyes sprung forward and basically swallowed the real ones, combining them
Yeah, Scraptrap's eyes are the main thing that bug me. I love Scraptrap's design, but he does not look anything like Springtrap.
must've hurt
@@Tabth3778 well he isnt really supposed to
Scraptrap's eyes legitimately look like the tin foil balls after being microwaved in click art videos
Yeah, like the springtrap eyes look real-ish.
Honestly Springtrap in fnaf 3 was fnaf character design at its peak imo. A mix of the most iconic aspects of all 4 og characters into one frankensteins monster that was also the main antagonist of the series' lore.
160 likes no replies cuz you're just objectively correct, yuuup.
@@AverageJ03Gaming I'm not objectively correct, you can't be objectively correct about these things, it's just my opinion.
@@HappyMatt12345Don't be so modest.
@@AverageJ03GamingSince when has a comment having replies indicative of weather or not it’s correct
Very interesting design choice Mr Afton
*With all due respect, those aren't the design choices we were curious about, mr Afton.*
Quoting the games, didn’t think that was doable.
+ respect
This comment is way funnier in Handunits voice
@@whosflair3716 No, it's funnier in the Board Member's voice.
"Sure, he has a dispenser of peanuts"
To be fair I think the "flesh globs" are there intended for the mask, because they don't look nearly as out of place with the mask on
that's a good observation, I should've thought about that
Maybe they were some dirty adhesive to hold parts together? Like bind the suit with the internal structure?
that would make sense. if ooftroops theory of the suit coming from a closed fredbears location (note that it wouldve closed YEARS earlier) the suit being made out of a material that could rot could suggest those red globs are possibly wires that used to sit in the inside of that springbonnies head.
It would be cool if they kept his eye sockets blank and dark, and for his jump scare animation add in realistic eyes but turn down the brightness on then. That way it’ll be creepier and more haunting seeing these very human eyes in what you thought were empty sockets. In keeping the brightness down, you can keep them hidden but have them still be noticeable which would def be scary.
great example of uncanny
You could also make it so that you could brighten the screen to see them, its basically fnaf tradition at this point
So basically like Nightmarionne.
Yeah, if you didn’t know, try brightening up Nightmarionne’s eyes.
@@wumpus976 huh, neat!
@@wumpus976 Oh dear god-
I don't believe he switched suits, mainly because being Springlocked means having the suit literally fuse with your body and dig all the way into your bones making them almost impossible to take off, so I think Scraptrap is the result of the OG suit surviving the fire.
This makes the design even WORSE for me. None of the wounds in the suit are in the same place, he suddenly has the suit's feet now instead of just human bits in metal endo feet, and the suit (despite being what I believe to be the same burned suit from FNAF 3) is suddenly brighter in colour instead of darker.
Honestly, I feel like they should've taken the FNAF 3 model, beat the shit out of it, tear off parts of the animatronic, make it darker and add some more flesh and bone on the inside to fix the damn Scraptrap design. In fact, they did! Fucking BURNTRAP is a much better design.
I mean, he escaped the suit in the fourth closet so it’s definitely possible
I think he removed the fabric of suit, dunno though
Springbonnie fur suit can removed but not springlock endoskeleton hence the reason why he has different suit but it doesn't explained how afton has his body back
I love Scraptrap's eyes because the eyelid hanging down makes him look like he went to a party and got ZONKED
Well, what else was he doing in those alleyways?
That’s what he was doing between 3 and 6.
Yeah I think that's cool☺
Looking absolutely torqued
This demon animatronic is FUCKED
Genuinely the more I get into the lore the more I believe that Scott is taking us for a wild goose chase and he wants the fandom to makeup whatever they want
Was it not obvious, there is no way he planned all of this lore from the first game
Theorists: *theorizing*
Scott: The lore just writes itself!
@@KarolOfGutovo mfw literally almost everything matpat theorizes ends up becoming confirmed in the next game or book
@@KarolOfGutovo that became very evident after the second game.
As someone who hasn't touched FNaF since UCN (due to lack of VR making me gradually lose interest since I couldn't play the new game and wanted to wait until I could), I still think the only way any of what Scott did makes sense is if he really is just trying to mess with us. I was one of those people who thought he'd planned everything from the start, or at least since the third game, since before he deconfirmed it, it was the only explanation I could think of. Why else would he tease Springtrap surviving the fire if he didn't plan for him to come back? Why would he add the box in FNaF 4 if he didn't plan to open it? Why did he, when he very obviously could've wrapped up the bite of 87 with FNaF 4, make it the bite of 83 instead if he wasn't saving the bite of 87 for an even later reveal? Why would he not address either question in SL if he wasn't planning a game after THAT?
But then when he gave the interview, saying he only came up with the idea to make each sequel after the previous game was already out, I realized he only left those plot threads open just to keep people talking about the game or something stupid like that.
The first two games are the only ones I never had this problem with. FNaF 1 was a self-contained experience. The most you could learn is that the animatronics were haunted, and that's all the backstory you need. The extent of FNaF 2's lore was finding out the game was a prequel, and all the plot details that came from the minigames. The only thing that could hint to games outside that one was the mention of the diner, and even that, when you think about it, only really served to give us backstory about Golden Freddy's origin, and why he's not "normal". Neither game felt like it was leaving questions unanswered, or that they had to be setting up for something later on.
Every time a game after the first two came out, I just couldn't bring myself to believe Scott would end the series when it was "so obvious" he was setting up for a sequel. When I learned that had been his intent every single time, I stopped caring about the lore altogether.
This is a great video. Legit improved all the issues visually and tonally with Scraptrap.
Now someone model this design please and thank u.
Yeah i really need this in a game
Thank you!
make a fnaf 6 mod that puts this in instead of the original scraptrap
Found you again Travis
Hey travis
I like the idea of all of the extra bones on Scraptrap not actually being his own. What I think would make his design more horrific is if those bones belonged to another springlock failure, and Afton is now wearing the suit that someone else died in.
Springtrap’s just…scarier tbh. Though part of me wonders if Cawthorn just put an endo in Spring to not give away the ending immediately + assets he can actually produce, since no lore implies a spring suit can hold a person AND an endo concurrently.
Spring trap suit + actual anatomically correct corpse inside? -shiver-
Might be talkin’ out me arse here bc I’m unfamiliar with the books and some extended lore but the tapes in FNAF 3 always gave me the impression that the Spring suits were interchangeably costumes and animatronic skins, with the connective wiring able to be wound back and hidden in the suit construction so a human could fit. Endos…aren’t small. There’s barely enough room for a single (GROWN) human in a suit, let alone a human + endo…
…and in that same vein how would a Spring suit have ‘programming’? There’s no motherboard or CPU, that’s in the endos.
Is there some ‘william ended up forcibly merged with an endo bc he managed to climb inside a suit that already had an endo inside it and the spring locks triggered and killed him even tho those locks would already be undone because they’d be attached to the endo’ that I’m missing here?
😒
I imagine the suits are designed with an integrated Endo that can just get cranked to the sides or something
@@AreGeeBee That is how it works from what I've heard
isnt the idea that the suit's endo was wound up but the suit wasa old so the springlocks winding the endo up failed and it went b ack into place, and thats what mangled afton? so they are both there and thats why he's so mangled
@@Puddor There will be a poorly written TL:DR at the end.
They're called Springlock Suits because you use springs to, for lack of a better term, smoosh the Endo flat so a human can crawl in and use it as a suit. Although due to whatever reason, any, ANY, amount of moisture + pressure would release the Springlocks, unsmooshing the Endo, and causing a very painful death to any human inside. In SL, I think its the 4th night(?) it has you constantly cranking the locks of a Springlock suit that is coming unlocked with you in while you wait for other employees to come help you. The moisture was likely from Michael being trapped in there, probably sweating and the only thing that stopped him from getting sprung was Baby. The Suit William crawled into had an Endo in it that had been flattened, but due to the leaky roof dripping water onto it for who knows how long, plus his overconfident laughing, caused the Springlocks to fail, springing the Endo Skeleton into every part of William. The Endo head caving into the back of his skull. The Endo Torso crushing through his spine and the back of his ribs, rupturing his lungs, stomach, liver, etc. The Endo limbs breaking his arms and legs, causing him to fall to the ground. Not to mention how the spikes/hooks and springs likely still connected to the Endo parts also punctured through before the Endo did, hint why in Fnaf 3 he was able to stand up a few seconds before getting crushed.
TL:DR Springlock Suits, Endo goes Flat because of Springs that lock it into place so Humans can crawl in with Endo. Moisture + Pressure = Bad Time Squish Crunch Splat Human Endo Crunchy Smoothie for overconfident W. Afton.
*Afton both figuratively and literally putting his pants on for the first time in 30 years*
“Huh must’ve lost some weight…”
Let's just say, after fnaf 3, he manage to 'burn off' some calories
@@10.ikadekanandadwipayadnya83
That's a 'hot' pun right there-
@@10.ikadekanandadwipayadnya83 thats a slight *burn*
This is getting pretty "heated"
What the *hell* is going on
Huh. I always thought Scraptrap was Springtrap but repaired himself using literal scraps.
Scraptrap might have also damaged the Springbonnie circuit boards after the fire but might have fixed them.
Or the suit itself might have been overridden by Afton's soul. Leading to the circuit boards to be corrupted and overridden by his soul.
Well they did say in the lore in hw they scanned circuit boards for the game
Scraptrap is springtrap because william is in springtrap because purple guy is in springtrap who is william so they are the same but he was in a different suit
@@shawnsuckstm3353 I thought that his suit looked different cause it burned so I thought it would have dedored like plastic in real life if it does melt completely it deformed which is what I thought happend here
@@shawnsuckstm3353 ok that makes sense
@@shawnsuckstm3353 I believe that's exactly what happened)
the problem with the redesign is that it makes him look very frail , nothing more than a pile of bones. Whilst in the old spring trap design he was bulkier , more intimidating , and way more subtle about the corpse in the suit part which is what made the fnaf 3 design so great in my opinion
Wait, I always thought that since Afton died in the springtrap suit, and the fact that over 30 frickin years most of it rotted away, his corpse would’ve stuck to the metal (since with the locks closing in, they sliced into his body and couldn’t be removed)
I personally like the design of taking Springtrap and adding more wear and tear, since ‘Scraptrap’ makes no sense in my mind
Yeh so how could he have crawled out of the suit without pulling more of his leftover body out and tearing it and then go into another suit, then go through all the trouble to reattach his string muscles and twist them around the new suit?
@@starrcooper1430 he most likely modified the original suit, it's impossible for afton to escape the suit.
@@somerandomdude8887 most realistically
Isn't it weird how spring trap is average height afton' seems shorter than him, and burned Afton in security breach is tall🤔
Why I prefer the original model is because we can see his corpse is fused with the endo-skeleton in the weird images you can get
honestly Scraptrap’s design works best in fanart when it shows how horrifying he looks, because Scraptrap is totally fucked up looking, and like you said he’s more lanky and humanoid so he’s kinda more uncanny valley
Funny you should mention valley when we get introduced to him in a valley.
For me scraptrap would be terrifying if it werent for the fact that he has a skeleton, buck teeth, the weird head, and his modelling is poor (blockyness)
@@Phoen1xFeathers imo he should've just make a more destroyed spring trap. Expose the skull a bit and keep the same missing arm
@@f10pped36 most of it is fine, I would just clean up the details on the face and skull and just smooth everything down
Fnaf characters from the very start were made to be uncanny valley.
“I started hating him so much that I actually grew attached to him” enemies to lovers au
its literally like an enemies to lovers ao3 300k words au.
Batman’s relationship with the Joker in a nutshell.
Mans had a whole character arc
@@chazzywaz 2017/gacha life cringe stories in a nutshell
i need a fanfic of this lmaaooo
Honestly between springtrap's jumpscare in fnaf 3 and scraptrap's overall design, Scott has made the technically most terrifying characters kind of a joke. He made a serial killer funny and a map robot terrifying. What a guy
he wasn't involved in Security Breach
Whilst this is a great redesign and I appreciate your points, my preference would still be to just take Springtrap, apply some of the existing damaged aspects of Scrap Trap and some of your changes, such as adding a more realistic mummified corpse inside the suit, and most importantly, make it look like it had actually been in the Fazbear Fright fire. Imo he absolutely positively needs to look burned. Not completely, otherwise he'd just be whatever endoskeletal parts the suit has and a skeleton, but some fire damage at least should be easily noticeable.
I'm just imagining him running out of fazbear's fright and jumping into a lake
@@spectralpeeper4424 lmao that'd actually solve the issues of programming too
Its the fact that this later became burntrap or whatever it is called in security breach. Where the shell looks more like a polished springbonnie but at the same time afton's jaw just looked very polished in there that it just was unbelievable. I personally Would've been fine if they at least removed a bit of the jaw and made the bones more yellow/brown-ish while the veins, nerves and arteries looked like a mixture of black and dark blue/dark red with torn parts kn the middle just to signify how the man's body has progressed throughout the years and that his soul is still present, but his human self is just a lifeless and useless parts of him that he has no choice but bear it since the broken endoskeleton has been wrapped and kept formally by his muscles and skin. Also I did like additions such as extra protection on the remains of his organs in the chest and also extra gears on his back bone just to clip it steadily so that if his parts get ripped off, these back bone structures can hold the shell intact while the muscles and intestines just leaves the whole body
Exactly
omg! imagine if instead of scraptrap/springtrap, they putted an endoskeletton with the remaining of afton.. that would've been terrifying
Honestly it was Scraptrap’s eyes that freaked me out the most. Like his eyes burned away in the Fazbear Fright fire so he just jammed some animatronic eyes where they used to be, in an attempt to retain his “Springtrap” identity that he had fully leaned into at that point. As goofy as it sounds it’s kinda off-putting.
Same, though I thought that the eyes were what remains of his springlock endoskeleton's eyes (they are grey, just like Fredbear(1983)
@@douglasprobst5677 I think they’re supposed to be a reference to the book series - the silver eyes - where Afton, the name, first appears
I thought it was meant to be his soul peering out from the sockets
The fact that only merch companies and matpat has access to the high quality render is hilarious
For me personally, I'd have really liked for scrap trap to be designed more around being burned, having a lot more burns and visible endoskeleton. Seeing that William is still in there but that he does indeed "always come back" no matter how much he falls apart
That redesign face is wonderful. He looks tortured and still dangerous, not flirtatious and stupid. All the other touches are superior as well. Great work.
Idk how could people find the other design flirtatious. Dang, I really hate some parts of this fandom
@@LucasSantos-ss6ou pretty disturbing, right?
not flirtatious, just stupid
Personally I would have had more broken bones due to the spring lock failure
@@LucasSantos-ss6ou same lmfao wtf
I dont think I could ever say I like scraptrap. Even with your redesign, I would much prefer a springtrap that looked like it had been burned severally. And while burntrap is a step in the right direction, nothing in my opinion, comes close to the classic springtrap.
Same. While in no way do I dislike Scraptrap, I think he’s pretty cool, I think it would have been easier, faster and just a better decision to make a burnt looking Springtrap, although I might be biased since Springtrap is in my top 3 favourites lol
(Edit) I do think Burntrap is amazing though. Obviously not as good as good old Springyboi, he’s much better than Scraptrap
No no, I don’t think you realize…
He sharpened his fucking bone to make a makeshift shiv. How can you dislike something as metal as that?
Agreed, they should have just kept the original Springtrap but just had various degrees of burning. Except Burntrap, he looks good. But SCRAPTRAP NEEDS TO DIE IN A FIRE-oh wait…
….I….don’t know my answer to that
The teeth.. that’s all I have to say..
I really like your redesign, and I’m glad finally someone is pointing out those weird blocky bumps all over his body. *They’re so weird.*
The redesign you went with makes him look decrepit and frail while also lanky and menacing, like some cryptic that roams around sewers shanking children.
My only problem with it would be the sharp teeth at the bottom since I don’t really see how those would fly in a kids restaurant.
Personally, I’ve always taken the “take the core concept but radically change it” approach whenever I try to redesign him.
I’ve had this idea in my head for a really long time which I don’t want to get into yet, but it sorta is an AU that remixes the series to be more fit for the format I’m choosing to present it in, and FNaF 3 is essentially just gonna be replaced by Springtrap being brought to a boardwalk, he fucks shit up, Mike finds him, they split, etc etc.
Because of this, when the “FNaF 6” chunk appears, I want to make it seem as if William was intentionally trying to make himself not look recognizable, so I change up a lot.
His arm is still gone, but he still has a lot of robot parts in him (notably his legs and a chunk of his torso). His torso and head resemble a Chuck E. Cheese mascot with a flat cutesy expression and a very bulky build.
If you think the teeth are bad, don't look up repaired withered animatronics.
@@glowinggames1561 9:04
hmmmmmm yeah i pick scap trap or whatever
I don't think Scott is that bad with anatomy, he just didn't think that people would be brightening every single picture of scraptrap in existence to recreate the model of his insides and see that he looks dumb underneath
i think the sharp teeth were made like that after afton got sprungtrapped :(
aka: he sharpened the teeth, like how he sharpened his arm
@@ilijacavic9049 If you see his other games/animations featuring humans, you'll know that he's not great at designing/modeling them.
In the final cutscene in the custom night of Sister Location, when Springtrap is revealed, we see that his pelvis is missing. It's clear that the fire damaged his suit, so he obviously fixed himself up. Another thing to note, is that Aftons Fnaf 6 form has more bone than flesh. So fire clearly can damage him, it just wasn't enough.
Even Fnaf Security Breach shows us Burntrap with only his skull and small flesh tendents in the endo. So clearly the Fnaf 6 fire did enough where William's body isn't fully there anymore, so the endo is a necessity.
Bro I see you everywhere and it doesn't help that I actually used to watch u when I was younger
Scott could've literally just bought a skeleton asset to build off of for like $40 on cgtrader or something. Pretty cheap considering how much money the franchise is raking in.
Yeah but that’s kinda lazy. Plus when has Fnaf ever had anatomically correct humans?
No, it's not lazy. In game development, it's important to know what to cut corners on to save time and money, especially in making indie games.
Cheap? CHEAP? In Brazil $40 is R$208,02.
@@reddwarf5133 Heh, You fool, you thought that was expensive? 40 Dollars is 342,24 liras in Turkey
we are talking about a guy that chose to "correct inconsistencies" in his timeline by putting the right thing in the next game, instead of you know... Updating the game where the inconsistency began. I know he has made more games than I will ever make in my lifetime, and I respect him as a person for many reasons, but Scott is not the best at making good story/game-making choices.
Gotta say, the way they've handeled it in Security Breach was just perfect.
he changed suits 3 times at this point his body must be literally hell, but yeah I love burntrap
@@oliverlovesbbc burntrap? …
@@Musti101 It's the name for the Springtrap that appears in the secret ending of Security Breach. If i remember correctly, im pretty sure that's the name in the files too.
@@DerUbermonke now it just sounds odd
Burntrap is what I thought would be Scraptrap's design in Pizzeria Simulator. It's probably my favorite design of the 3.
I'm so glad Steel-Wool's design & modeling department "retconned" this design and gave us something A LOT Better!
For the most part I like Scraptraps design, but I've always REFUSED to believe that it's supposed to be his skull in there. To me, It was always just another layer of the suit and his actual head is hidden underneath. I just can't with those lips man. No, It's a layer of the suit. Please, I beg you
given scott acknowledged it was a human it's no use to deny it
PLEASE I'M BEGGING
suffer
@@theooftroop 🤣 "suffer"
@@theooftroop The thing is Mat Pat made a theory that his head was actually an endoskeleton head
I'm guessing the reason the human parts look so consistently shoddy on Springtrap's designs is because you're not really supposed to see them by themselves. They're supposed to poke out of the suit; thus all the weird fleshy bits that stick out for no reason. Those are the parts that stay visible when you put the suit over the top.
It's not a perfect solution - but given you'd NEVER see the full human body in normal gameplay, I don't really blame Scott for doing it that way. I work for an indie dev studio right now, and one thing I've learned is that you come up with some WEIRD solutions sometimes to make the game do what you want.
Basically.
Yeah. Clearly Afton’s model wasn’t supposed to be closely examined like some of the others are. With SpringTrap, Scott created some very interesting images with that model while with Afton he’s not seen the same way.
Besides, none of these suits looks like anyone can fit in them to begin with so they never made sense on that front anyway.
@yo lo bone lip
@@Bestgameplayer10 when you see their actual scale, a human could easily fit
@@ttracs if you insist
When I first saw Scraptrap's design it really threw me for a loop. For a good while I honestly couldn't tell if he was meant to be Springtrap. Lore wise his design makes no sense. Because, despite supposedly his new look is because of the fire in Fnaf 3. He looks way to intact and not burned in the slightest.
I imagine like he had to rebuild most of the body from scrap, the same thing happened to Scrap Baby, she was tossed out of Ennard and had to rebuild herself from scratch.
Ennard meanwhile just didn't bother re-building himself.
@@AngelEmfrbl Molten Freddy probably tried but couldn't because Baby was the leader who gave them direction. Comparing ScrapBaby and Molten Freddy's designs shows how incompetent they are compared to her and how much they still needed them
@@sanicboom6443 true, Freddie is also deranged in this version.
@@AngelEmfrbl I can see a Molten Freddy, but the leader being Ballora or Funtime Foxy... dear god.
He knows how to build animatronics meaning that he most likely started rebuilding himself with the only tools he had
I believe that William changed his suit to a more scary looking appearance, so the fan girls wouldn’t pester him as much as they did with his Spring trap Design.
Makes sense
Now that’s some damn good lore developement
William walking*
Everyone: Omg that’s Springtrap!
William: oh shiet
But they didnt stop
@@apple_aj1162 we never do 😏
My personal headcanon for his design was that the first fire did so much damage to him, he was actually falling apart and it became harder to get around. He lost all of his original Springtrap outer suit and instead, replaced it with bits and pieces from other springsuits.
I agree with you on how Scrafton looks infinitely better during the salvage parts because he's shrouded in darkness. Honestly, I've seen so many redesigns for Springtrap that I assume many others have too that fnaf6 wasn't going to meet many people's expectations. Sorry for rambling.
Wrong!!!! All the Springlock suits are all gone.
@@dragonborn7955 not all of them!
Nah. He just lost his pants, you cant live with that.
“Also known to unfunny people as…”
Me who’s been calling him “Jimmy trap” for years: 👁👄👁
imagine
Unfunni
Gotta blast
He always gets compared to a peanut so, I began to ironically call him THE NUT KING
@@balls8927 that’s awesome 😂
4:25 Either Scraptrap’s thumb has an extra phalange or his thumb is the only finger with metacarpal bone attaching it to the hand
*Ooftroop: Scott's design sucks!*
*Scott: Weeps at Ooftroop's disapproval, wipes his eyes with multiple hundred dollar bills, and returns to making his lucrative franchise.*
what concerns me is that 15 year old me very well mightve played a part in the scraptrap hate crusade and I'm kicking myself in the shins knowing that Scott canned the only scraptrap merch due to his unpopularity
@@theooftroop this is what happens when your over opinionated for no reason other than self gratification.
Plenty of people get rich without any real talent or skill. Just saying. Being rich is often more a matter of LUCK than anything else, and doesn't really mean anything by itself. It certainly doesn't have to mean you did anything good; and plenty of far more talented people than Scott have lived their entire lives without ever being rich. There is no actual correlation between talent and success.
With that said, Scott obviously does understand his market - because he managed to make his franchise super popular, and sustain that over time. It may have started as sheer luck, but he did manage to hold onto it. But if that was your argument, that should have been your argument. Just saying "yeah well he's rich" doesn't f--king MEAN anything. That's not the argument you think it is. Yeah, he's rich. That doesn't actually mean he's incapable of making sh-t character models.
@@LordofFullmetal we don't give a fuck
@@LordofFullmetal it wasn't luck it was hard work
I think the theory that Afton replaced his suit is dumb. The whole point is he's trapped and combined with the suit. It's his prison. It's just a stupid dumb poopy poopoo retcon.
I agree, like, hes practically melted with the suit
I think it's more of... it already existed, the 'new corpse' is some kind of prop and his old form is so badly broken that he actually had to leave his own body and was forced into a different one, the only time we see anything of Springtrap later on is in SB where the suit a combination of Springtrap and Scraptrap where you have some of the unnerving parts of Scraptrap while keeping the nice aesthetic of the classical murder bunny we all know and love
Completely agree! They put so much emphasis in the games like "yo, he's fucking stuck in there, and it's literally the death of him" smh that made more sense. If he was so trapped, how did he manage to escape the suit in the first place???
“Poopy poopoo”
I’m liking this.
*sigh* he has such a way with words
Dude that Scraptrap model you drew was on POINT! It looks cool as hell
thank you!
Springtrap:(*exsist*)
(Ball pit)Time travelers:(*sneeze*)
Springtrap:(*regenerate some part and becomes gooftrap*)
Scraptrap's corpse looks utterly awful and bizarre.
I can't tell what Scott was going for or even THINKING.
It looks like he created textures for meat, white bone, and yellow bone, then randomly smooshed together spaghetti, weird shapes, and a model for an ugly human, and stuck the textures onto it.
This is why he never made humans till security breach where he had help. He fucking sucks at it.
@@diamondguycarlosortega4075 he retired after security breach too
I think it’s so weird how Springtrap and Burntrap look pretty damn similar, but Scraptrap is just so different from the two. He feels like a completely different character despite canonically all three being the same
I do like your redesign though, it’s such a huge improvement
I like to think that Burntrap is the result of Vanny recovering Afton’s burnt remains from Fazbear’s Fright, and rebuilding him with Glamrock Bonnie parts. Hence the body still trapped inside but with glamrock looking body parts.
I can understand why some people have springtrap and scraptrap as separate characters now
i think scraptrap fits the title "Afton" the most. i love his more human-like proportions and the evil look on his face. it really does give off the evil mastermind vibe that william should have
Mimic just explained all this
@@christosdoesthings the mimic doesn't even looks like springtrap
The whole “afton switched his suit” thing, as far as I can tell, just isn’t correct. Of course, the actual answer isn’t too great, that being that scott just wanted to redesign springtrap and didn’t care enough to canonically explain his new appearance, or just hoped he would retcon springtrap’s old appearance or something like that, but even if that isn’t a great answer, it still makes more sense than getting out of the suit and finding a completely different one, because, just why?
Also, he wouldn't be able to get out of the suit anyway
@@zabtronics he might destroyed the suit before wearing the different thingy mabob
I think the feet and few other parts he found and the new face design is part of the casing fusing to his head
I think that he replaced the headpeice and feet but everything else is old springtrap
in the end of fnaf 3 the building burned down maybe the suit got destroyed and his spirit searched for a backup spring bonnie that can also explain golden Freddy and Fredbear
No one can convince me that Scraptrap is a good design or even better than Springtrap. To this day Springtrap has been my favourite, he is just creepy, more life like than the rest of the animatronics. His corpse looking more realistic and decayed than the Scraptrap one, the big wide smile and glowing eyes absolutely terrifying. Scraptrap just looks like a joke now, I don't know if its the stylisation I don't like or in general design wise. The little bottom teeth are terrible i hate them. Also Scraptrap just looks small, comparing him to Springtrap he just looks like tiny idk, he doesn't seem threatening to me compared to Springtrap. Like i feel like i could kick him and he will go flying across the whole country easily haha.
Your redesign is 10 times better. I feel like you analysed exactly what's wrong with the design.
For me, i like the idea for Scraptrap, but the execution is what let's it down. Springtrap is more like he's hiding a dark secret inside the suit, only visible for brief moments where you can peak inside. They are fused together but it's still pretty easy to distinguish the suit exterior from the human inside.
Scraptrap on the other hand feels more like a perfect blend, the corpse is almost just as visible as the suit, and i agree he's shaped more humanlike.
If you think of Scraptrap more like he's a zombie, i think the design is much more likeable. The half closed eye, the huge missing patches, missing limbs, bones and flesh showing through, the ripped up mouth, dead eyes, etc, both the suit and the body sell this effect, a perfect blend, the zombie animatronic.
My headcanon to explain the messed up anatomy is that William completely rebuilt himself and since his body didn’t need to work for him to be alive he intentionally shoved random parts everywhere to make himself look scarier
I don’t think that’s the actual reason at all but it’s something
Sorry if I’m late, but I seen a video of a in depth lore of the entire fnaf series and apparently after the fire, Afton found the old Fred bear diner and many other businesses and decided to rebuild himself using spare parts.
@@starry402 i dont think william could find bits of meat flesh and bones in a burnt up resturaunt
@@eggpods9995 true, there’s a big plot hole that doesn’t explain how his entire body and the suit looks so different
@@starry402 hmmm yeah, with Springtrap was enough
The re-design is honestly cool. I like the feature with him missing an eye and the new skull design was just better than the emotion the old skull had
My head cannon is that scrap trap is a different spring lock victim that had died many years before. And since his suit was broken, Afton put his soul into the spring lock victim, explaining the fact he looks so different. And to explain his new look in Security Breach, it is just the new jimmy neutron suit he got, being burned so he needed to go back to the original one.
Honestly I don't get the logic of "he changed suits" when this one is actively worse. I think the more logical answer would've been making the PS springtrap a more deteriorated FN3 model. Show more of the corpse, make it charred and black, hard to see in the vents, more mechanical details to show how little is left of him. SB's new body makes sense since it's really only his skull left and he lost the arm and presumably even more after his SECOND fire, but constantly swapping bodies just feels counterintuitive.
I always tought the same, but maybe the suit from the fnaf 3 got even more burnt you know? But idk, scraptrap design is horrible scott could've used his original design again and no one would say a word 😭
For me, while I think your redesign looks great, I just dont understand how afton would have ever been able to switch suits. If you take out the mechanical parts of the original suit, hes just a head, some torn muscle, remnants of organs, and maybe one or two bones. Springtrap can move because of the animatronic suit, remove that and he would be completely immobile
It'd be like possessing your own corpse
It ain't gon work
@@chonflis3834 Funnily enough, that's what happened to Michael.
Im drawing a scraptrap based on springtrap model
@@XD-yn6hb
Shutup
@@chonflis3834 it did in fnaf 5 and 6 👀
Now imagine : scrap’s goofy design with glitchtrap’s goofy personality. The ultimate being
*SmElL MY FlEshY FiNgErS*
Zajcu: I gotchu fam.
Uhyuck
From that Menacing Voice at the End of the Security Breach Trailer, that Goofy Personality is *VERY* likely just a charade to seem less threatening.
Not to mention the whole "When I first found you, you were weak" speech.
I'm honestly impressed how William Afton's corpse in Scraptrap was kept together even though the only skeletal parts he had was his head, right arm, and left arm
As much as I love Scott’s work, he should’ve had someone help him with the human anatomy of Scraptrap and Springtrap. This redesign is very nice, and I especially like the heart reference. Watching the next redesign video next.
Afton’s face looks like if Springtrap took a look at the FNaF section of Rule34.
Is cleansing by implicate order annihilation field an option?
@Rondaru preferably matter-antimatter warheads just to be sure
you should see scraptrap rule34, its pretty weird
@@horizon1g on my way
@@poxy5122 i hope you had fun
Spring trap is honestly a perfect design, a rotting corpse haunting a ragged and beaten old animatronic. While scrap trap just looks like a buck toothed idiot, I really don’t like how his head is shaped and looks. it’s honestly the main reason why I don’t like the design
you were so dedicated about how much you ironically love this design you started to sound like you were crying and i love it
Scraptraps design is ok, if you put him in dark and creepy lighting he looks awesome, but if he's in ANY light lighting he looks pretty eh, and another thing to note, he looks a lot better if you put him in orthographic view (no matter how close or far something is it's the same size) when he has a high FOV the snout looks really big and weird
I want to see someone make this into an actual 3d model and replace the FNaF simulator/UCN versions with him.
man I'd love to see how it'd look as an actual model
YES
@@theooftroop I kinda love this design too
thank you!
@@theooftroop
If you want I am interested in doing it in 3D, but I am not the best ^^
My head canon is that the “skull” is just a mask since FNAF 3 springtrap had no nose or ears therefore couldn’t have them “grow back”
Remnant exists
@@TheShape45 is that how remnant works?
@@brolookatthatthingbehindyo1324 Kind of? It can regenerate dead organic material.
@@the4tierbridge I’m sorry, it can *W H A T ?*
@@wumpus976 After William, escapes the Springtrap suit in the 4th closet, he uses it to try and make him immortal (his goal throughout the series), and to try and fix himself.
AMAZING, he was my favourite character but the eyes is what I hate, and you improved it!❤
If Afton could pull himself (On his own, no help) out of the spring lock suit (Which by the way impaled him in literally every way possible), then get in ANOTHER springlock suit (While being nothing but an endoskeleton with flesh covering it), then Afton is more badass than I thought.
I don't think he did that, I think what he did is just change some parts of the original springtrap suit (especially the ones more damaged by the fire) but leaving the main suit there, so that I think is he didn't change suits at all, he just replaced the most damaged parts of the original suit by new ones, and that's why he looks so different, (because most of the spring bonnie suit was really damaged by the fire so he had to replace most of its parts with new ones, however, he left some of the parts that the old suit had, leaving basically the base of the suit alone but replacing some of the original springbonnie parts with new ones, like his head or his legs, that look so different now because he replaced the. That's at least what I think it happened
I love your design for Scraptrap! He looks why better, so it's a shame that the official design didn't look this good.
A proper skull shape, and more solid build would make him terrifying, on top of better detailing and a tiny bit more resemblance from fnaf 3 springy boi would be great + the whole 2 sets of teeth from the other animatronics. Like his jaw and teeth tucked inside the suits teeth would be good too and the bone knife to be just higher than the hand similar to the butcher enemies from dead island if anyone is familiar, to be usable instead of having to swing the whole body.
Or maybe he doesn't have the arm bone at all but instead holds it in his other hand as a weapon, that he usually carries with him in an odd way, like stabbed in one of the holes of the suit, kept by a piece of his flesh so that it doesn't fall off of his torso when he's not holding it
I actually really like his design unironically, I liked the more slim approach, it looks a lot more intimidating instead of the chubby look springtrap had, while the head inside was goofy at first, I don't really see that anymore. His hand was also something I loved, Instead of the chubby looking fingers Springtrap had, he now had genuinely menacing bone claws of sorts
I respect ur opinion but springtrap was always the only thing in this series that genuinely scared me, scraptrap on the other hand, just doesn’t scare me. He looks goofy
It was a better choice for scott to make someone else do the human models in security breach, gregory looks great and so does vanessa; not to mention she’s gorgeous but hey that’s another topic
white woman jumpscare
@@guywithrevolver a g r e s s i v e l y looks at you while jumpscare sound plays
Wish vanessa could jumpscare me🥴
Gregory, i think you deserve a reward😫
Bro she's not real... Go touch grass XDD
Springtrap was a masterpiece, scraptrap is a desperate bid to breathe new life into the series by rehashing one of its most popular characters, thats all it is
The "long and lanky" factor of scraptrap's design has got to be one of my favorites, he looks more mobile that way rather than the big clunky suit Springtrap has, I prefer a few of scraptraps design choices over Springtraps, and vice versa. Both great characters
I think I have a pretty good guess on what it is. From the book series ( in The Fourth Closet mainly ), William actually made a mixture of both human and animatronic, of some sorts. He transferred himself from full on Springtrap, to a more robotic, human body, not like Scraptrap, however. More like the opposite of Scraptrap: leaning over to a more humanoid side than the robotic side. I've a feeling the same thing happened in the games, except he leaned over to a more robotic side. This is why his body looks like a mixture of bone and metal, which I think is the case. And because of this, extra flesh and organic material were also extracted on the outside, leaving those muscle-like bits on his body. What do you think?
Edit: None of this excuses how god awful the skull is, however.
Definitely agree with these points. I’m glad that Burntrap in SB looks MUCH closer to the OG and the original. It’s also really weird with how he would have been able to get this new suit.
why couldnt scott get a spring trap model and started to take more pieces of suit off because burntrap has a huge jaw with teeth and og spring trap looked like a melted gummy bear with like 7 teeth
I think Springtrap had to change his look after the whole “this attraction is great” PR disaster😂
I love your redesign and your analysis of scraptrap's original design. I especially love that your redesign includes so many details that are intentional and meaningful to scraptrap's character and origin -- it really makes him come to life. If there are any animators/modelers out there that can make a render of ooftroop's redesign.... that would be AWESOME.
Look I like Scraptrap, and your redesign but the transition of just little bits of flesh and a corpse head to a full skeleton has bothered me so much, the head makes sense but what about his bone fingers? Sorry it’s just I think that Scott could of toned down in the usage of bones and could of used more endo parts to show that he’s not a skeleton wearing a homemade cosplay he bought off of eBay, but a man trapped in a godforsaken robot that is still bound to him even after the fire.
That’s what would of make Scraptrap hit home, sure you can change a few things about the given model but it won’t change the real meaning of this character.
(Sorry for the rant, I really like your redesign and would be fine with it if it was in the game but that’s just my opinion)
I agree he needs more of the indoskeleten he's just too slender and looks off
@@mr.breadman4181 Agreed
@@xx_london_xx7807 yea a even a mix of endo and bone probably would look way better maybe the head is missing some flesh and the mask is heavily damaged showing part of the head then its perfect and I can't express how much more I like spring traps animatronic head design compared to scrap traps
"only merch companies *and MatPat* can have it" that's simultaneously hilarious and infuriating. Like scraptrap has been bumped up a bit in how much i like him simply because a high quality render of him exists but only matpat has it.
leak the renders, mat!
i'm so glad that i'm not the only one who immediately thought "wow what a bad design" when i saw afton. i'm excited to see how your redesign looks!!
I've had this video in my reccomended since it came out, but never watched it until now cuz I don't have strong opinions on ScrapTrap anymore. That being said, I feel pretty strongly about his design again. Scott got really close to something really cool. I think my favorite detail of this redesign (which might be unintentional) is that the mask is a lot looser, which better demonstrates that there is a face behind the animatronics. It's something we don't see a lot of in FNaF, and it's really nice when we do.
I remember a theory explaining the stupid corpse: Springtrap was eventually reused as a prop at the Spookfest seen on a poster in the After rare screen from Fnaf 6, and he had to be repaired, and modified to be more generically spooky, like the replacement of the mostly burnt-off real corpse with a semi-convincing fake one that was never meant to be seen underneath the mask, hence it’s manufactured, non-anatomically correct appearance and plasticy vibe. Same with the metal eyes, and the repairs in some areas, new withering in others.
Just thought I might put this out there.
Wait so the trashed his real corpse, the scrap trap shouldn't be possessed then🤔
@@starrcooper1430 SOUL
@@starrcooper1430 Remnant kept Afton from dying
"What...on EARTH...is going on here?"
That line combined with the zoom in to the derpy face had me dying XD
I love this redesign, it makes it feel more feasible in the lore. Something like Afton pulling off as much of the suit and endoskeleton as he could to break out of the animatronic prison, taking pieces off of him with it.
The fact they brought him back in security breach with an actually good redesign
alas it was only for 5 seconds
@@theooftroop still he was there
scott "i can't draw humans good" also scott: gives the best looking people in the book novels
He can probably draw them good, but can’t model them good, if that makes any sense?
So you’re telling me somehow spring trap grew his nose back
He also somehow grew his skeleton back bc he definitely didn't have it in the spring trap suit
I have always said that Scraptrap/Afton is a good design as it's own, but it is a bad redesign. And also, it definitely needed more polishing, but we know that Scott always tried to make things as quickly as possible, lol
I really love your redesign ^^
Great video!
I actually thought that the "Bone Ears" are supposed to be in his upper cheek idk, They made the (Arguably) most scariest animatronic model into an absolute goofball sequel model.
William prolly transfered his soul in a spring locked employee
I’ve never put this much critical thought into the fnaf models, probably because they don’t look like they’ve had that much thought put into them. I think redesigning the animatronics would be a fun project as a character designer :)
I had the same thing, I hated his design and was disappointed with the new design, but then grew to love him and his imperfections lol. Good redesign!
Honestly, I think that the imaee at 8:41 would have been a genuinely awesome design for slap-n-scrap
Your redesign is just amazing its just incredible i just can't explain how good it is. I love it so much you did a great job
2:50
Ah…I remember that day where everyone in the FNAF community made the realization that Scraptrap had “bone lips” and things started to spiral from there where noticed more “bone parts”. It was a glorious and terrifying.
there is still one thing that confuses me with springtrap's and scraptrap's design, though.
if we take off the outer layer, we get a endoskeleton with well, afton's rotting flesh and organs, but isnt the suit supposed to be empty when he got springlocked? whats a endoskeleton doing in there? he wears a springlock suit *with* a animatronic endoskeleton? he somehow wore the endoskeleton over or behind his head?
and lets say he did swap suits, how? half of his muscles are gone and hes only moving because hes possessing a animatronic suit, that zombie body of his is essentially crippled.
I always interpreted those little spikes on his lower jaw to be the pins that the suit's original teeth were once attached to.
enemies to lovers lmao 8:35