Does the Palestinian Authority Fund Terrorism? | Explained
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- The Palestinian Authority’s “Martyr’s Fund,” also known as “Pay to Slay,” pays the families of Palestinian terrorists who are imprisoned or killed for acts of terrorism against Israeli civilians. Despite attempts by Israel and other countries to both deter terrorism and incentivize the PA to end its “pay to slay” policy, the PA continues to find creative ways to successfully financially incentivize terrorism.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:36 Terrorist payments from the PLO
03:03 Financial assistance to the Palestinian Authority
03:55 The PA's Martyr's Fund
05:01 The Second Intifada
05:39 The Prisoners and Released Prisoners Law
06:35 Israeli attempts to disincentivize terrorists
07:08 Western countries cut off PA funding
08:23 Israeli withholds tax revenue from the PA
08:58 Failure to end Pay to Slay
10:00 U.S. resumes payments
10:44 Palestinian support for Pay to Slay
11:09 PA exploitation of Palestinians
11:44 Palestinian resistance and martyrdom
Subscribe and turn on your notifications so you don’t miss future uploads!
ruclips.net/user/UNPACKED?sub_...
Recommended video-Why Did Israel Build a Wall Around the West Bank?
• Why Did Israel Build a...
We have merch! - shop.jewishunpacked.com/?...
Let’s connect:
Website - www.jewishunpacked.com
Instagram - / jewishunpacked
Twitter - / jewishunpacked
TikTok - / jewishunpacked
Facebook - / jewishunpacked
-----------
Image and footage credits:
The Nexus Institute
-----------
Executive Producer:
- Barry Skolnick
Co-Executive Producer:
- Shmuel Katz
-----------
Translation credits:
Portuguese: Saymon Pires, www.livrariasafra.com.br, @safralivraria
About Explainers: From ancient Jewish traditions to the modern State of Israel, we explain it all. Diving into anything and everything related to Jewish culture, history, and even religion.
Understand Jewish holidays, Israeli politics, Jewish diasporic communities, and more. Learn about Judaism in pop culture, debunking myths about Jews, and explore obscure Israeli landmarks. We’re asking questions as basic as “What is the Talmud?”, and as obscure as “How did hip-hop boost Kosher wine sales?”, and everything in between.
About Unpacked: We provide nuanced insights by unpacking all things Jewish. People are complex and complicated - yet we’re constantly being pushed to oversimplify our world. At Unpacked we know that being complex makes us more interesting. Because of this, we break the world down with nuance and insight to drive your curiosity and challenge your thinking.
#israel #politics #terrorism
RUclips have updated their community guidelines following the outbreak of the war in Gaza and as a result, our previous version of this video was subsequently age-restricted. We've since edited and uploaded a new version in the hope that an unrestricted video will be viewed and shared by the widest possible audience. Please continue to share your comments and thanks for your support!
Now talk about how America's working class hard earned money [taxes] goes to Israel to finance their free Education, Healthcare, etc; while they're stuck here with zero free Healthcare and student loans. 🤬
@@flordecempasuchil.2816what? Who told you that? You meant that the American money go to Muslin countries ( while their leaders are billionaires with oil money, at least most of them). This is the list of countries that receives more money from the US: 1)Ethiopia; 2) Jordan; 3) Afghanistan; 4) South Sudan; 5) Congo; 6)Yemen; 7)Nigeria; 8) Syria; 9) Sudan; 10) Somalia. Now, after receiving donations from the US, terrorists from these countries won’t think twice before blowing themselves on the streets of the same countries that donated to them. Ahh, they burn American flags all the time, don’t they? Just a symbol of their hate towards a country that helps them. 8/10 of these are muslin countries.
Sorry for your trouble. RUclips really has problems.
@@anitamwd Ethiopia and the Congo are not Muslim nations, they are both mainly Christian.
@@flordecempasuchil.2816 Lies. The US just helps Israel financially with American weapons and defense systems.
This was actually the 1st thing I researched after 10/7. While doing it I found investigation reports written by Blinken in 2003. While there he said he couldn't believe elementary aged Palestinians were talking about being Martyrs for the cause, that it was the most honorable death in the eyes of Allah. Truly sad what REALLY happened and is happening in Gaza.
BS lies , from you and zionist Blinken
Guess what! All American dead soldiers are given 150000 to the families and we call them Gold Star Families
PLO, Hamas and UNRWA have been married for years living from money of taxpayers around the world. Palestinians rather prefer beeing refugees than an independent state to collect the "walfare check" from that money.
Truth! Thank you.
The work should stop sending money to the Palestinians and all this nonesense will end
bingo
Not true.
Jews are living off america taxes paying money.
Stop send american money to fund Israeli.
This is horrifying and outrageous.
Not so much that the PA does it.
But that there isn't a global outcry
Equally horrible... the world pretends not to believe it...
And the world pays for it!
@@Santirata Yes... ignorance at its best
Maybe stop the occupation
@@Santirataso true. My democratic country is complicit of terrorism and harming the only democratic country in the Middle East. 🤯🤬
For those who think a call for a cease-fire is a good idea. A few things to consider.
1. Hamas has repeatedly said they will repeat the October 7 ma$sacre as soon and as often as they can.
2. It is implied that not only will Hamas not return the 134 remaining ho$tages or the bodies of people they have m9rdered, they will do it again because it gives them leverage.
3. Given America’s reaction to three dead soldiers, one has to ask oneself what America would do if they were in the position Israel is in.
4. The ratio of terrori$ts to citizens in Gaza who have lost their lives is 1 to 1.5. This is unprecedented precision in an extremely densely populated area, infested, mind you, with terr0r tunnels. When the States and the UK invaded Afghanistan, the ratio was one to 10, meaning nine out of 10 Unalived were citizens.
5.There has been a cease-fire from 2005 until 6 October. Hamas broke it in the most atrocious way. instead of building up Gaza, since 2007 they have spent billions of dollars on tunnels and preparing for the atrocities they wanted to commit on October 7. What on earth makes you think they changed their minds?
I recommend you keep yourself informed. Follow the news, also on channels that you do not like. I do the same.
Honestly that's a well said paragraph of what's going on and the cease fire may not happen
30,000 dead Palestinians.
Mostly women and children.
Why do you support genocide?
Where did you get the information about 4.?
@@oisinmurphy8747 I think the 4 part is talking about that terrorist group hitting among they people instead of fighting by they own they will use they civilians as to get close to the targets that how taliban's did that before the withdraw
Thank you for putting together that information, these are all things I've seen before but the reminder is helpful especially for people who are not familiar with it
The Palestinian Authority is suspect, to say the least. I wish the war that resulted from the October 7 Hamas terror attacks never would have happened and my heart goes out to Palestinians and others who had nothing to do with it and never supported Hamas. This said, I noticed that many in Gaza complain about the war and how much they suffer but rarely a Muslim says that Hamas finally should return the Israeli hostages and what Hamas did was so wrong.
So you hurt because of the response to the atrocities that occurred on Oct 7th.
I didn't get the sense that the atrocities themselves bothered you much.
You wish the war wouldn't have happened but stopped short of wishing the atta k wouldn't have happened.
If the attack wouldn't have happen the Abrahamic Accord would have been signed by now.
@@user-vb9lm5ef6c as typically for anti-Semites, they never get it right
Abbas is on good money too. He’s worth $100m. Yasser Arafat was worth millions also. That’s why they won’t give up refugee status.
Thieves
I was so confused since I thought I saw this video already 😂 Great work on fighting against RUclips trying to silence this channel
Biden Biden Biden........dismisses his own Taylor Force law.
Does a duck quack?
Yes, ah shit oh yeah I forgot about Mahmoud Abbas saying that Jews can't be a Palestinian Citizen and didn't recognise the holocaust ever happened and supported Hamas.
oh yes!
People have eyes but can't see, they also have ears but ear😢
💯
Shocking !!!! This should be seen by everyone
The most outrageous fact is that all this could be fixed by gibing Equal rights to the Palestinians. And a binational state construction. The American model of Putting natives in reserves will Not fit.
How do you do that when your neighbour has sworn to attack you at every opportunity?.
Hamas and many Gazans are not trustworthy.
Will you take personal responsibility for every Israeli that is injured or killed....
Gaza has had the opportunity since 2005 to show the world how they can behave and run their economy but chose to hate, destroy and leech and live off the world's taxpayers money...
If the Palestinians had equal rights that defeats the purpose of being a “Jewish” state.
Jewish in the Adolf Hitler way ironically, in that it’s predicated on *blood* and/or *faith*
Why would they instantly become a minority, especially after 80 years of doing what they’ve done.
They know, anyone with a brain knows, Arabs getting equal rights in Israel means no Israel.
P A, Hamas, isis, unrwa, moslem brotherhood and all fundamental islamist are of the same roots
🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱👍
remember the left in United States supports the "slay to pay" idea
“The left in the United States” 😂 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
There hasn’t been a left in the United States since the Black Panther Party was destroyed by the FBI, but go off on what the center-right does.
Way to tell the world you know so little about economics you think capitalists are “left” because of their social views. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I'm disappointed in my progressive friends in the states.
Intentions seem to be one sided.
if i told you whats the answer to 1+1 you would be pretty one sided on the answer 2.
Please state your counter arguments then.
U mean the PAs intentions? Yea, they are. Jean oh side.
@@darnit1944 It’s a corrupt organisation that most assuredly doesn’t funnel money towards Palestinian refugees (they wouldn’t be so horrifically poor then)
Not that they care, ideally for them they’d *return* to *their* *land* so it being used for that purpose (irrespective of methods) doesn’t concern them.
The irony being at least the money that goes towards these terror organisations doesn’t get embezzled or stolen…
Imagine a *terror* *organisation* (or twenty) being more *honest* and “ethical” (in the sense that they actually use it for its intended purpose) then an investment/refugee fund…
What a sick world we live in.
The way DW covered yesterday story about the shooting on the road shows why nobody has stopped it. They’re all in it
For DW the story was more about the “occupied territory” than anything else
They act like they care that’s all
What's DW?
@@Daniper1 German news channel
I just saw intense debate on piers morgan show about this martyr fund and i must said i would'nt surprise that palestinians defended at all cost this fund although in purpose to kill a nation not just human kind,,,
You are doing such important work. Good job. Hopefully one day everyone will understand who is the real criminal in this conflict
Isn't it obvious!!?
Standing with Israel and IDF.
Great work!
You just explain the madness, easilly.
Pray for Israel! 🇺🇸🇮🇱🙏
That’s horrifying
Religion of peace or what?
Beautifully explained - totally spot on.
Unsubscribe this Channel
Spot on 🇬🇧🙏🇮🇱
why did you reupload this video????
See the pinned comment!
thank you so much.
@@UNPACKED
CUT THE DAMN FUND
That's disgusting, they dag their own graves
🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱
Not just me; I count 18 comments showing, but it says there are 49. Where are the other 31comments.
The replies count.
Still, some 70 or so comments and replies missing. That I for one would like to see, to get the full picture.@@Ellaliluleloka
@@ellenfarnsworth7111😂 this is the full picture on this issue. Jeez youre incredibly simple.
HaHa adhominem, adhominem,. Ewe r a joke, thanks for the laughs, useless and delusinal.@@useyourdelusion6807
That’s just heartless
Wasnt this already video already uploaded?
See the pinned comment
@@UNPACKED ah ok
This is one dimensional and very biases. Not all Palestinians in Israeli jails are terror related. Palestinians are occupied and under military law with convictions rate of 99%(global highest). When breadwinners are arrested how does one expect the families to fare? Die?or migrate out as israel wants?
Of course resistance against occupation is legal under international law. PA doesn't rely on aid solely taxes which are collected by Israel and Israel dictates on how it's spent after looting it
This is such basic knowledge in Israel that we just take it for granted. 💔
You mean the successor of the PLO?? Yeah they do.
Can you make a video about the assassination of Isaac Rabin or you did already?
Yep, we have a video about that: ruclips.net/video/TDHYHuGFnao/видео.html
And we also talk about it in our video about Oslo: ruclips.net/video/5SIAW4cX62I/видео.html
then they sale there family
You just hit the nails head!!!
I ❤ this channel, keep up the Great work guys!
that way prisoners will shut up
Revelation 12:17
King James Version
17 And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.
And how do YOU explain this?
Nice literature
Victimhood is a big business.
oh! an antisemite! so edgy!
Don’t go add that bus guys or else you’re gonna be the same like that
Why anyone takes them seriously as a governing authority baffles me.
They're gangsters, and not the cool type.
And they're dorks.
By the way: cool necklace bro 🇮🇱👌
I have never heard of this in the 48 years i have been alive.
no doubt ! they do
Is the pope Catholic? Does the bear poop in the woods?
Then why can I make the same exact comment on a more balanced channel and it does not get deleted.
What got deleted? Very curious, as they don’t delete anything as far as I know
I keep telling you, we don't delete comments
ewe said that twice, me thinks thee doth protest to much. I noticed ewe didnt say anything about your channel not being balanced reporting.@@UNPACKED
This chan is extremely balanced. Youre not looking for balance, youre looking for marxist jargon, distortion and solipsism. 😂😂
@@ellenfarnsworth7111😂😂😂 why would he say that? Its extremely balanced and factual. Just because you fall for conspiracy theory, propaganda and idiotic marxist revisionism, doesnt make this chan one sided. He gives the facts and truth.
The hypocrisy is ASTOUNDING.
YES they do
Thank you
105 percent...same feather...same bloodline...same ideology...same religion...whats else??
I have deep criticisms of the way this video discusses this issue but I wish to be clear from the outset that I do not support violence against civilians as a method of advancing a political end, this isn't an issue conceptually with an Israeli state but rather with the actions of that state and the way it's being depicted in this video.
The funds are for prisoners broadly not just terrorists, though they are included. I highlight this distinction, which this video handily avoids, as it also handily avoids talking about the insanely huge number of Palestinians from the occupied territories kept prisoner in Israel without a fair trial. 1/3 have had no trial at all, they cannot see what evidence they are being held under, those that do face court are in Israeli military court, under Israeli military law, (not civil law, not the same laws the govern Israeli citizens) without the public defender an Israeli citizen would be entitled too, statements are taken in Hebrew not arabic, so prisoners are forced to sign statements they don't understand and could be used against them in future. Conviction rates are 99.7% which is simply not plausible, symptomatic of a system that operates to legitamise arrests rather then adjudicate innocence. The military law that governs Palestinians in the occupied territory is not applied to settlers that live there, it is draconian, it limits the ability for Palestinians and the PA to function and reports of the on the ground behaviour of military police doing these arrests if often worse. It's under these conditions that the PA pays a stipend to the family's of people who are kept prisoner by Israel, now set at 9,000, uo from 5,500 before Oct 7th. Only a small fraction are convicted of violent crimes, convictions which would have more merit if they were done under fair conditions.
The PA should not fund terrorists who kill innocent people, for the most part, they dont; and they only do so under conditions of near inability to figure out what is a fair or unfair conviction due to the application of Israeli military law. Israel's having their cake and eating it too. It blames the PA and then hobbles the PA from actually being a state by imposing military law on most of the west bank and on ALL Palestinians in the west bank. This is where the accusations of aparthied become convincing to me and where I'd encourage Israeli's to examine their governments actions and seek reform. Either by ending the military law and moving Palestinians to civilians courts with changes to accommodate language differences, or setting up the PA to take over as the judicial body of the west bank. The first, while probably the most likely also amounts to annexation of the westbank and that entails extending voting rights to a group that has been agitated under military law for coming on 50 years. The other entails enabling the PA to actually flourish as a government, supporting it instead of throttling it, probably reigning back settlements and definitely reigning back military police and handing over more land putting Palestine on a clearer path towards independence. The choice is yours. But, I understand the apprehension many Israeli's feel to either option giving the popular opinions towards Israel in the westbank. But these opinions orginate from how they perceive they have been treated, and I must say, it does seem pretty enraging. But rage can be calmed it can be soothed bridges can be built. Ignoiring their issues as the scream them tho will not build bridges.
A very weighted and considerate response, thank you!
An excellent response and a great read!
I want to point out a couple things, from my point of view:
1. While the payments are for all prisoners, it is impossible to ignore the fact that the culture itself glorifies martyrdom, so when you combine the glorification plus the incentive, you get a lot more terrorists that go to kill and die than you do people who are just "wrongfully imprisoned". You can just look at the numbers (these are accurate to 2016, last time i researched this was 2 years ago and I couldn't find anything more updated, but considering this legislation has been around literally for decades, I'd assume it isn't so different now. As always, I encourage you to DYOR :) ) - The PA payed out around 140$ million to prisoners and families of prisoners still imprisoned, and 175$ million to families of martyrs, so the incentive system is there, and it's working really well, unfortunately. - Imagine all this money being actually invested into their future, and imagine all the frozen money that'll be unfrozen once this abhorrent legislation is finally abolished.
2. They call it the martyrs fund themselves, they aren't trying to hide it, mask or obfuscate it. It is very clear that they mean for it to be a fund for terrorists that die. And usually, terrorists die during their terror attack.
3. A lot of terrorists that were arrested have confessed, in videoed interrogation as well as transcripts, that they simply do it to allow their families to live comfortably. I think that if your people are so financially destitute that they have to resort to killing another country's citizens to get paid well, while 7% (!!!!!!!!!!) of the total budget of the government funds something that benefits such a low percentage of the population is just not sound fiscal planning. That money could have been invested to promote growth and to allow your citizens to flourish and not be so desperate that they have to resort to these types of actions. And their absolute non-compromise on this issue really make me think they want the situation to stay this way.
As to the figures you have stated - that the number is up to 9000 from 5500, and that only a small fraction are convicted of violent crimes. That large uptick is mainly due to the arrest of combatants AND gaza citizens that invaded israel from Gaza on the 7th. So I dont really see how there can be a near doubling of the number of prisoners, that nearly all of them were arrested while they were invading a neighboring country, some armed to the teeth and have done unspeakable things, some unarmed and just there to pillage and loot the homes of desecrated families, and there can STILL only be a "small percentage" that have committed violent crimes, even assuming, that the 5500 that were there before were all saints wrongfully convicted.
@@buttermuffin3752 1) What is the definition the PA is using for martyr in these funding differences? If im not mistaken it's death right. Israel is widely criticised for 'rutine unlawful use of lethal force'. So if you view things the Palestinian perspective there's another explanation for this, While it might give some incentive to fight the occupying nation (not my framing) it also gives the occupying army and incentive not to kill these people but rather arrest them where they might one day be released, if they do get killed by what they view as a eagerly violent force then their families will at least receive support, especially important if the killing was motivated by intentions to settle of the families land, a pattern which many Palestinians seem to identify.
A big moment that heightened my attention on Israel's administration was the killing of American-Palestinian Journalist Shireen Abu Akleh in 2022 as she covered an Israeli military operation in the westbank from behind the IDF. An IDF member turned around, and shot her in the head, despite her press flack jacket, they then shot at her colleague as they tried to pull her to safety and administer first aid. Fighting had stopped a while before and it was on the other side of the IDF forces. The Israeli government initially denied this even after irrefutable video evidence was released until they received wide spread international criticism, they then admitted 'the high probability of an accidental killing'. Israeli police then attacked her funeral and coffin bearers during the procession to the church. It seems to me that she was murdered by a member of the IDF, while many on the Palestinians side will say it was planned by the government I don't see any proof of that but it's hard to push back against those claims when the government denies the clear proof and then doesn't make any arrests, nor the assault on her funeral. It wrecked the credibility of the Israeli government, it revealed something sick, either a maliciousness or a paranoia in the military police and either a complicity or an apathy in the administration and judicial system. Is she a martyr? Is her family receiving funds? Also is that a difference in total budgetary funding or a difference in stipend amount, if its the former that's not an extra incentive towards violence compared with any other crime or slight or being the victim of an arbitrary arrests.
2) Calling it the Martyrs Fund seems to me to be more of an optimistic spin on an incredibly bleak outlook for ever being free of what they are identifying as a violent occupation where they are at the whims of military police who can send them to prison without needing evidence.
3) The Israeli government places vastly more resources into cracking down on Palestinian developments of houses and infrastructure then settlers, with infractions being commonly harshly punished with demolition. This is a burden primarily placed on Palestinians and only at times, wayword settlers. This is a hopelessly bleak situation which makes the thought of economic development difficult to imagine. Settlers have control of key fertile land and use far more of the westbanks water per capita then the Palestinians do. Israeli occupation is a HUGE economic burden. It seems to me that the PA is caught trying to put out fires created by the occupation, acting on Israels behalf like PR agent, trying to justify their non-violent stance towards Israel whilst Israeli settlers and members of the Israeli government do everything they can to inflame tensions.
4) I was under the impression this uptick was due to ongoing situation in the Westbank such as the lockdown of Hebron which has meant thousands of citizens haven't been able to leave their homes, the militarization of ideologically motivated settlers, bringing them into the police and active military service in these areas which has seen reported assualts of Palestinians sky rocket, and the killing of civilians (in a recent case a child) and then the attacking of the families killing during the funeral process being a horrifyingly common occurrence. If these people are empowered then the assumption that they'd abuse the military courts which have such opaque burdens of evidence doesn't feel like a stretch. Though the fact that it is military law might mean that POW's from Gaza are also counted with these prisoners from the west bank which I hadn't accounted for as I assumed there would be some separation of what feels like civilian area and military area but of course the west bank is treated as a military area so that went over my head. I still feel like there should be an administrative separation between these two though no?
5) Of the 5,500 before Oct 7 only 3,500 had been charged (in the opaque military courts) 2,000 had not even been allowed to defend themselves or know why they were imprisoned. Only 500 of the 3,500 had been charged for violent crimes, many of which we can assume were not acts of political violence against civilians although undoubtedly some of them were. Again, a 99.7% conviction rate for those that stand trial, its not a good look.
Great storyteller. Great STORIES.
You are calling PNA out, but the print Hamas.
before this is over Israel may have to go into the west bank
Not very anti-semitic comment section. Horaaay for @UNPACKED
Am Yisrael chai 💪
Nothing is immoral as long as Jews are the victims of it. That is how most people in the west and the Middle East seem to think. Jews were here from the beginning, and we have survived every attempt to eradicate us. We will survive this attempt too 🇮🇱
You are here from russia and Germany Arabs and formed a nation in 1948....the true owners are the Arabs
Don’t delete my comments if I’m wrong. Ppl who know they’re right will debate and not hide behind propaganda
Thank you. Good video.
Everybody blames ISIS,Hamas,Islamic jihad etc but nobody blames the sources- Quran and Hadiths
Yes they do.
Why doesn’t Israel allow DNA tests?
That’s a myth: www.tiktok.com/t/ZTLVcqcct/
It's against their religious beliefs. Just like the Jehovah's don't allow blood transfusions😮 what's the point? There still are no such ethnic groups of people called Palestinians 😅 and no such legal country or statehood named Palestine. 😅
Stop the adds!
14:6. “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. -(John)
19:10. for the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy. -(Revelation)
15:24. I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel. -(Matthew)
58:22. They are the party of Allah. Indeed, Allah’s party is bound to succeed. -(Quran)
50:7. All that found them have devoured them; And their adversaries said: ‘We are not guilty’; Because they have sinned against the LORD, -(Jeremiah)
58:19. The Evil One has got the better of them : So he has made them Lose the remembrance Of God. They are the Party Of the Evil One. Truly, it is the Party Of the Evil One That will perish ! 2:75. Seeing that a party of them heard the word of God and perverted it knowingly after they understood it. -(Quran)
2:3. Israel is the LORD’S hallowed portion, His first-fruits of the increase; All that devour him shall be held guilty, -(Jeremiah)
What a stupid question !
Nice peaceful pacifists
Yes and u fund them so
Israeli propaganda
Wtf
Your phenomenal, thanks so much for making these videos and stating the facts crystal clear.
Your videos are AMAZING
Thank you!
חובת צפייה !!!! כולם צריכים לראות ולדעת את האמת
Loto
Definitely the channel.
We don't delete comments
If you're complaining about your comments are being removed because you typed out some antisemitism, it's probably just regular people reporting your comments because of misinformation.
youtube is not america, you can't say what you want, they delete comments and even gives bans for 24h
Who decides what is misinformation? I say my comments are simply countervailing views that a certain lobby group does not want ewe to hear.@@toytacambery9427
Who decides what is misinformation? I say my comments are simply countervailing views that certain lobby groups dont want ewe to hear.@@toytacambery9427
example; Just saying the name, rabbi Shapiro.
Comment still there😂
yeah for now. Maybe only because they want to make ewe think they are not censoring, with this one specific comment.Where are the rest, more then 70 by my last count? Exiled to misfit island?@@pugo7925
😂😂😂 do you know how many rabbi shapiros there are? Its gotta be hundreds.
Antisemite says what?
awkward
first
What a sick and twisted take on the martyrs fund.
u got a better take
That's exactly what it is what is your interpretation?
😂😂😂 its literally called martyr fund. There is only one take ignoramus. Stop being a marxist homunculus. 😂😂😂
Does a bear shit in the woods?!
Thanks for the facts!
Do you still Think We Support Terrorism Hamas And Fatah Are Different we r Aligned with Saudi and Hamas Align With Iran We Just want 1948 Borders of Palestine and Jerusalem Must be under UN Control 😊
Thank you for the comment!
Which 1948 borders of Palestine?
@@UNPACKED The Borders which was There before first Arab Israeli war at least Give it To Palestine of not whole Israel
This channel is massively biased.
It seems you just say that when you disagree with something. Which I get it, it’s hard to see things presented in a different way than you see it. But is anything incorrect here?
Netanyahu bragged about supporting Hamas
Enough said
You said nothing 😂 this video is about the PA in the West Bank , not Hamas lol
no he just gave them their Qatar money in exchange for temporary silence(its not something that was exclusive to Netanyahu by the way bennet did it too)
Blaming Netanyahu for Hamas being evil is like blaming a flashlight for cockroaches being gross.
Netanyahu is not a good person, but that doesn't mean Israel has to submit to Hamas murdering Israeli civilians, nor does it exonerate the PA.
@@DemPilafianwhat a unique analogy
Spoiler: YES, the answer is a resounding YES.
The PTSD UR POLICIES HAVE CAUSED THE PALESTINIAN PPL JUSTIFY THEIR RETALIATIONS
deleting my replies now.
You are? Why?
@@Nitzpitz If they don't like some comments they delete them but that's OK for me. We watch this for free😂
@@aneliyageorgieva5352than again is RUclips they will automatically delete it to talk about this situation that is going on
RUclips deletes replies randomly
Howd you escape the sanitarium?
everything wrong in this video in fact Palestinian Authority work with israel
😂 get your facts straight. The PA is openly jean oh sidal. They only work with izreal because they have to. Ignoramus rex over here.
What a hot take. Seriously. 😂😂😅
Dear Presenter. I am a Christian and have loved Israel from my childhood and have en been praying these 133 days, but I have to ask you this question. WHERE DO the Israeli people in JUDEA AND SAMARIA AND THE GOVERNMENT EXPECT THE PALESTINIANS TO LIVE ? THERE shall never be peace when they're pushed out of your way. Do they know and realise that God will judge them by HIS WORD which states in many places but to quote one.... "When a stranger sojourns with you in your land, you shall not do him wrong. You shall treat the stranger who sojourns with you as the native among you, and you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt: I am the LORD your God.". Leviticus19 : 33-34❤AM YISRAEL CHAI❤
❤❤ Please be a good presenter and ask the relevant Israelis these two questions especially the president and the PM and maybe Rabbi Jonathan Cahn ?
Very simple stop murdering jews setup a responsible government in gaza and west bank creat peace and harmony with real trust and the walls will come down and their own Arabic brethren will except them
You should go to Israel and see by yourself.
Arabs make up 20% of the population. I cannot speak for all Israelis, only myself, but what I say is I have no problem living side by side with people who don’t want to murdwr me. From a strictly Torah perspective, the Torah (5 Books of Moses) talks about non-Jews or residents residing in the land. They need to respect the sanctity of the land, recognize Gd controls the world and have this specific piece of real estate to the Jews as an eternal inheritance, and non-Jews on the land need to follow specific laws that include not murdwring or stealing, and recognizing Gd. The Druze people, and ethnic and religious minority in Israel, are very loyal to the Israeli government and many boast that they live by the Seven Universal Noahide Laws.
Some right wing would love to see Palestinians move to Jordan or Egypt, I’m sure, but I imagine the majority just want to live our lives not fearing that the neighbor we’ve had for 20 years won’t suddenly radicalize and murd3r us in our home, or synagogue, or at the bus stop, or anywhere.
Have been there many times have visited remalla as well. have you been there?
It has always struck me as odd got the Palestinians are still supposedly refugees. Why have they not resettled? There are literally tens of millions of people who ended up having to relocate en masse in the 20th century including what happened to create Pakistan. In addition, more Jews were kicked out of other Middle Eastern countries than Palestinians impacted by what they call the nakba. The Palestinians are the only ones who are still considered refugees 75 years and multiple Generations later. why haven't the other Arab Nations taken them in? In terms of reparations for land that they allegedly lost-- and most of them never owned that land in the first place-- they have literally gotten billions of dollars in foreign aid since 1948.
The religion of peace
Dear pugo7925 What I said was; yeah for now, and where are the other missing comments , more then 70 by my last count.
😂😂😂😂 ok commrade.
Haha adhominem, adhominem. Ewe r a joke, thanks for the laughs, useless delusion6807.@@useyourdelusion6807
Typical ignorance sub
Of course they do. Next question.
U are the face of pUbLiC ReLAtioNS AKA PROPAGANDA
Islam is not a peaceful as everyone thought huh?
Find jesus
christanity tells women to stay with their r worder
@@peachyskies5158what do you mean by that?
@@peachyskies5158 Where?
deleting comments, someone is afraid of opposing views.
youtube deleting commnet not the channel
You oppose the truth?
ye sometimes it even happens at random RUclips censoring algorithm is broken(sometimes it can even delete a comment containing only a question mark)
depends on the channel, sometimes i can leave a comment as above but cant reply.@@nickdubov8316
or a name. Like rabbi Shapiro.@@MyIndieGameDevJourney3818
“Maintaining law and order” , “developing the economy”, “creating infrastructure” all things that they can’t physically sustain while being subjected to Israel’s occupation because of the policies they placed affecting their growth, and we know their growth affects the growth of Israeli settlements, and it’s clear that Israel has been favoring Jewish settlers over Palestinians in the land they have no sovereignty over. So I don’t wanna hear abt what the Palestinian authority can and cannot do until Israel understands what it can and cannot do. Terrorism is bad, just as occupation is bad.
Occupation is not bad per definition as you implied. For example, the Allied occupation in Germany and Japan led to these countries rise economically and become strong again. It always depends on the specific instance. Furthermore, the people in Gaza had better living conditions in the 1980s during Israeli occupation when they made their Intifada than they have nowadays under Hamas rule.
In which land do they have no sovereignty in?
In Gaza they managed to find the resources and ability to build hundreds of miles of tunnels along with rockets and bombs so surely they could have built something nice with all of those resources had they chosen to do so
Youre living in the past. The dream of falestin is over. The WB and Aza will be gradually integrated over many generations. Which requires settlments. Izreal HAS to maintain control of judea and samaria. They have no choice. And its for the best. The settlers are ultimately the best thing for palestinins in the WB. They provide jobs, industry and a path to integration.
Lol but they do have almost 300 million dollars annually to pay keelers?(misspelling on purpose)
Maybe give Palestinians state
And behave like Normal country
They don’t want a state
@@torbjornlindholm4098 Yes, they do, on the entire borders of Israel.
@@veeaxis3892to be clear they want the entire area where Israel is now. They don't support a two-state solution but somehow Israel is the only one blamed
Kinda tried it in Gaza. Israelis left in 2005 and not a single Jew lived there. Look what the Gazans have done. You have to show good faith before you can demand anything.
@@dmitryb9309
First.. Israel was built by expelling Palestinians
So.. Don't act like.. Palestinian state is unreasonable demand
Second.. Withdrawal from a Gaza was one sided.. Should have been part of larger process
Third.. Israel actually help create Hamas and Netanyahu bragged about it
So.. Don't act like... Rest of us don't know the reality
Yes.. Israel is very powerful
But are u really proud of what Israel has done to Palestinian people specially considering history of Jewish people being persecuted