Mary Caroline -- very similar to Colonel Klink (probably misspelled) from Hogan's Heroes. The actor had to flee Germany when he was young because he was Jewish, and only agreed to play a Nazi if he could make him stupid. If you haven't heard of this show, it is a classic and quite funny 😂
The night I saw the show my friends and I were the only ones saying "nazis aren't so bad" so Curt yelled directly at us...It was the best moment of my life.
It's interesting watching Joe play a character that's not in charge, since he often (in starkid shows anyway) plays characters that are at the top of the pecking order (Voldemort, Umbridge, Up, Batman, Achmed, etc)
I'm rewatching this with hebrew subtitles and the translator has little segments like "oh no" and "this was physically hurting to write" they are hilarious: Edit: it just said: "kill me please" Brian: "we made some mistakes" Translator: "some?!" Brian: "perhaps the nazis aren't so bad" Translator: "I fucking hate myself rn" Translator: "I'm gonna puke on your glittery swastika"
This whole scene is very reminiscent of the 'Springtime for Hitler' show-within-a-show in The Producers; I'd be surprised if it wasn't an influence, even down to the swastika-formation choreography
There's a Craftersations with MK and Joe Walker where he says "There was a time at the start where we were like "Are we REALLY going to sing about Nazis?" and then when we were doing it we were like "Yeah, no this is cool! and funny!" and now a year or so after the show we're like "did we REALLY sing about Nazis?"" ITS A GREAT VIDEO I LOVE IT XD
This is one of those songs that would be terrible to have stuck in your head. You can't sing it out loud because people would look at you like you were insane... :D
OKAY BUT how is Brian (and everyone else as well I suppose) able to keep an accent/voice all the way through and sing with it so well (a.k.a. I envy and wish to have the ability very very much?)?! Is it magic? It's magic. I'm right. Tell me I'm right.
i think it varies in difficulty depending on the accent you have, and the accent you're trying to do. As an Australian, it's fairly easy to do English or American (or French, but that's just cause I've studied it for ages) , but I could never do, say, welsh or german. And I think Americans generally find it difficult to sing in English or Australian accents. So it just depends I guess!
DoctorWhoTrailers those two are actually some of the easier ones, at least in my experience. Languages that roll their “r”s can be a bit tricky if you don’t get the hang of it, especially after a “t” or a “d”, and being consistent on vowel sounds are always a struggle since they’re used so many ways in English. But it really depends on the person and what they’ve been exposed to
@@olivetreewhimsy2016 yeah, exactly my point! I think for most people it's fairly easy to do a stereotypical American accent, because so much of the media we're exposed to comes from the USA. Whereas I don't hear a lot of other accents nearly often enough to imitate them :)
I don’t think I properly appreciated Brian Rosenthal’s acting before he’s not used enough in Starkid musicals but in TCB he really shines. The depiction of madness is just brilliant Also he got an entire audience to say “Nazis are not so bad” which I’m not is a good thing but even so
Only YOU guys are able to sing a song like "Nazi are not so bad"! XD In Italy you would probably have gone to jail for performing this... I still love you!
I clearly have no faith in fandom, i was so worried about the comments/potential hate and there's nothing. it's beautiful. 0 dislikes too. very cool. also this was hilarious and absurdly offensive but that's where the comedy comes in. :) great job boys.
Anyone expected Brian to go "when I was just a boy ...an orphan boy"? Just me? Must b3 for Joe in the background and the Quirrelmort feeling at the beginning xD
It has a similar feel to “no one remembers Achmed”, the whole time I was thinking about the verse, “the slaughter of millions of innocent civilians” I was C A C K L I N G!!!!!
Warning: if you live in a Jewish house with 8 siblings and little personal space, don’t play Nazis Are Not So Bad when you’re working unless you have earphones in. I had to do some very awkward explaining Extra warning: don’t get it stuck in your head, especially if you go to a Jewish school
As someone who’s Jewish father and Grandmother showed me the producers (Musical) for the first time at age 8, and who’s Jewish great-uncle showed me the ORIGINAL film for the first time and talked about how it was ‘better’, your experiences are not universal.
you know, i used to hate how long this song goes on for, thinking like 'is the dance break really necessary' but honestly i appreciate that they took the time to make the presence of the nazis uncomfortable, overtly silly and childish, and clearly people you ARENT rooting for but can be entertained by with their damnably catchy song
this number is dangerously catchy omg no XD gotta really watch out so I don't get to sing it around the different tunes! the interaction!! Curt's (very appropriate) response! that ending! Rosenthal!!!
4:03 - it was the most elegant Nazi salute ever done. 6:02 - the most unexpected one :) When I watched this scene first time I had to pause bcs I laughed so hard.
Honestly this is the kind of stuff that i wont ever be able to tell anyone about like "hey mum i was listening to a song about nazis being real cool wanna listen?"
Making Van Nazi Hitler’s nephew is really funny when you know that in real life one of Hitler’s nephews actually moved to the US to fight against the Nazis in WW2.
So I’ve watched this musical through several times, and I JUST realized he is in hotel room 2009. 2009 is the year StarKid officially formed 😊! Love these boys.
@@naomishe Actually, there's a fan made video where they sort of proof that kicklines are inevitable. But yes, there's also a tgwdlm reference in there
The title is right: I really did Nazi Nazis coming XD (Also Brian has one of the best fake german (well.. more Nazi-)accents that I ever heard (It's still horrible, but it's not the worst XD))
That first part when Dr Baron von Nazi was talking to Hitler reminded me SO much of Jojo Rabbit, I can't help but think the movie got inspiration on this play.
Just… the accents. The amount of different accents in this show. Even just in this room. American. Cockney. German (x5). Russian. Like… also, Lauren’s accent range in this… I love this show.
And yet another example of show tunes that I should not sing in public.
CurlyTop MAMD...
And half of Twisted
And some of TTO
So effectively half of all starkid songs. (Twisted, MAMD; I'm thinking of you.) xD
As well as "Lovely Ladies," "Dead Girl Walking," and "Blue."
Excuse me, sir, that's just my emotional support dictator puppet...
BraveNewTarot I’m wheezing
Props to you for making me snort harder than usual
Excuse me, That’s my Pol Pot emotional support flower pot
“Nazi are not so bad”
“No one remembers achmed”
They have the same beat or am I crazy
the intro also feels very similar to the beginning of To Dance Again lol
It’s a genre of music created by Starkid I like to call the “sinister kick line”
@@FirstnameLastname-zq4rt a kickline is inevitable
oh my god yes
Firstname Lastname it’s inevitable
The fact that Brian is Jewish makes this so much funnier
Mary Caroline Omg I'D FORGOTTEN THAT
YES
I've forgotten that and now I think this song sounds so awkward with Brian singing it
Mary Caroline -- very similar to Colonel Klink (probably misspelled) from Hogan's Heroes. The actor had to flee Germany when he was young because he was Jewish, and only agreed to play a Nazi if he could make him stupid. If you haven't heard of this show, it is a classic and quite funny 😂
OMGS I FORGOT THAT
It probably helps to tone it down a little tbh
The night I saw the show my friends and I were the only ones saying "nazis aren't so bad" so Curt yelled directly at us...It was the best moment of my life.
That is totally awesome
Must have been pretty awesome especially with the vile stares you musta gained :D
Wow I love that for you 😂 miss you b!!
Amazing
That sounds amazing
Brian Rosenthal, Jewish icon, dressed as a Nazi, singing a song about Nazis being good. I love it so much.
And if I'm not mistaken, he wrote the song, too
I feel like before their first show, they had a bet on how many people would join in the song.
y e s
That’d be great lol
And a dollar for each person joining in
I personally feel proud of Brian. He's come so far and grown so much as a performer since his days as Quirrell. We like you Brosenthal x
I agree! He's grown so much as a Naz- A person!
I'M JEWISH. I SHOULDN'T BE LAUGHING AT THIS.
Anna Banana, Brian and Corey are Jewish too :)
StarkidLissy corey too?
Same
I'm german (well half german at least). I shouldn't be laughing at this either.
@@Hkihfzdchjgd Same here, I feel guilty
This song always has me torn between cackling and covering my mouth in horror.
NotKyoot I imagine that was what they had in mind 😂😂
Same
Just like the first audience watching "Springtime for Hitler".
Same
I'm from Germany and this song made me extremely uncomfortable. Half of the stuff they said and did is actually illegal here.
I don't think I've ever seen a nazi kick line
You've never seen The Producers then. Lol
artluver94c I was just about to say the same thing...🤣
artluver94c Iconic movie
It was inevitable
A kickline is inevitable
🎶When I was just a boy🎶
...an orphan boy?
I'd love to move my feet!
I'd hear a tune and start to swoon, my life would seem complete!
+Emma Hobbs the other boys would laugh and jeer but I'd catch them tappin their toes
And oh, how the feeling grows ...
I take my foot, dududududududu...
It's interesting watching Joe play a character that's not in charge, since he often (in starkid shows anyway) plays characters that are at the top of the pecking order (Voldemort, Umbridge, Up, Batman, Achmed, etc)
Ducker
Loren S he is lord
@@sisyphus.333 the duck is looooord
Flora Bochenska he is lord lord lord the duck is looooord
@@sabi_sue *dances in duck* He's loooooooooord ! The duck is LOOOOOOOOOOORD
Four years later, my favorite part is still Curt screaming at the audience, "The fuck is wrong with you people?!"
did anyone else remember Achmed?
Yes! (Another song inconvenient to get stuck in your head in public)
so i wasn't the only one who thought those two songs were similar! yayy
*jumps out of line* HE FUCKED A TIIIIGEEERRR
TIGER FUCKER! TIGER FUCKER!
_Do you mean The Tiger Fucker?_
I'm rewatching this with hebrew subtitles and the translator has little segments like "oh no" and "this was physically hurting to write" they are hilarious:
Edit: it just said: "kill me please"
Brian: "we made some mistakes"
Translator: "some?!"
Brian: "perhaps the nazis aren't so bad"
Translator: "I fucking hate myself rn"
Translator: "I'm gonna puke on your glittery swastika"
וואלה מצחיק
The translator's really voicing my exact thoughts
יא עכשיו אני חייבת לראות את זה מחדש עם כתוביות בעברית
Omg stop lmaooo
Props to the translator
Suddenly I feel confident about singing Dead Girl Walking in public.
Same ngl
Did Brian throw glitter at the end? This is like the eighth time I've watched this part and I just noticed it...
He did!
He keeps glitter up his sleeve, wakka wakka xD
"You're too flamboyant on stage!"
"Really Dad? PROVE IT!" 🤣🤣🤣
The 'Weekly' FanGirl that’s a perfectly placed reference I’m-
@@RayFlemming7080 Couldn't resist, man 🎉
Anyone notice when there surrounding Brian in the song they're forming a swastika.
I laughed sooo hard when I realized it.
This whole scene is very reminiscent of the 'Springtime for Hitler' show-within-a-show in The Producers; I'd be surprised if it wasn't an influence, even down to the swastika-formation choreography
I'd love to see a video of the choreography sessions for this song
There's a Craftersations with MK and Joe Walker where he says "There was a time at the start where we were like "Are we REALLY going to sing about Nazis?" and then when we were doing it we were like "Yeah, no this is cool! and funny!" and now a year or so after the show we're like "did we REALLY sing about Nazis?"" ITS A GREAT VIDEO I LOVE IT XD
Yeah I would've loved to get a shot from above! Oh well.
I just love how unimpressed Joe looks during the whole song, as if Baron Von Nazi does this a lot.
my favorite part is Curt's look of disgust lol
I'm from Germany and I know lots of people who speak english with exactly this horrbile accent of Von Nazi xD
🙊
same
same. it's horrible xD
Von Nazi sounds kinda like my grandpa and it's freaking me out
It sounds like my grandma when she tries to speak english geez xD
This year, one of my teachers is called 'Vannazzi" and everytime I hear her name, I think of the Baron Von Nazi and I laugh
I just hope I don't randomly start singing 'Nazis Are Not So Bad' in front of her x)
it's been 3 years. did you end up accidentally singing it in front of her?
@@emmabradfordxx Did you sing the song infront of her?
now that's good karma
"What about genocide?"
ROFL seriously!
ROTFLD (rolling on the floor like Draco)
This song is one of the reasons I can't sing starkid songs in school or in public
I've got same problem with their songs from MAMD...
+Nastie True.
good thing this is tin can bros
I always get That One Part (TM) from No One Remembers Achmed stuck in my head. Just always.
No one:
My random AF braincells: hE fUcKeD a TiGeR
Coward.
This is one of those songs that would be terrible to have stuck in your head. You can't sing it out loud because people would look at you like you were insane... :D
It is....how you say? The forbidden bop
I think imma sing nothing like a dick instead
Bruh I accidentally sang it in the middle of class bruh
@@vermillion5196 my condolences 😂 I’ve been there. The looks of disbelief are not great
Starting humming it in history. Worst part? We're on our Holocaust unit....I still feel bad
"I feel a song coming on"
I love Joe
Around 1:30, Brian and Joe's faces being so close gives me slight Quirrelmort vibes.
THANK YOU!
LOVE QUIRRELMORT!
YES
Carly Fichtner haha!
YES
OKAY BUT how is Brian (and everyone else as well I suppose) able to keep an accent/voice all the way through and sing with it so well (a.k.a. I envy and wish to have the ability very very much?)?! Is it magic? It's magic. I'm right. Tell me I'm right.
Cassie Brey #insanetalent
And practice. Lots of practice.
i think it varies in difficulty depending on the accent you have, and the accent you're trying to do. As an Australian, it's fairly easy to do English or American (or French, but that's just cause I've studied it for ages) , but I could never do, say, welsh or german. And I think Americans generally find it difficult to sing in English or Australian accents. So it just depends I guess!
DoctorWhoTrailers those two are actually some of the easier ones, at least in my experience. Languages that roll their “r”s can be a bit tricky if you don’t get the hang of it, especially after a “t” or a “d”, and being consistent on vowel sounds are always a struggle since they’re used so many ways in English. But it really depends on the person and what they’ve been exposed to
@@olivetreewhimsy2016 yeah, exactly my point! I think for most people it's fairly easy to do a stereotypical American accent, because so much of the media we're exposed to comes from the USA. Whereas I don't hear a lot of other accents nearly often enough to imitate them :)
How are Joe and Mary Kate keeping straight faces???
Proablly practice. After a while things loose their humor.
@@ashlynnheller8400 exactly!
The "To dance again" part 2 😂😂
@Banaantje8 TeLL tHaT tO bAfUl'S tWiN bRoThEr AbDuL: hE wAs ThE vIcTiM!
The crossover we all needed
Anyone else notice the "Sound of Music" tune at 5:20? I nearly fell out of my chair!
Tbh only noticed it cause I had subtitles on 😹😹
Yep I hate it but it's because it works.
Zazzalil’s Got Some Nerve same haha
Holt shit, I didn't!!!
oh my god that's cruel twisted genius
SPOILERS: "Don't get involved, love."
MY HEART HURTS
Ow ow o w .
OH MAN
why did you have to heart me so hard
I KEEP GLITTER UP MY SLEEVE WAKKA WAKKA
Not gonna lie, if I was in the audience I totally would’ve joined in.
Being Jewish is amazing
I would have been that person who shouted “WHAT’S WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE”.
@@Stinkfly3 that was Curt by the way
I don’t think I properly appreciated Brian Rosenthal’s acting before he’s not used enough in Starkid musicals but in TCB he really shines.
The depiction of madness is just brilliant
Also he got an entire audience to say “Nazis are not so bad” which I’m not is a good thing but even so
I feel so guilty for liking this song
Bruh same
Same it's worse that I'm Jewish
"No One Remembers Achmed" Part 2
did they seriously throw gltter at the end
Yep!
Waka waka
this shit is hell when you want to clean anything
lOoK aT mE, i KeEp GlItTeR uP mY sLeEvEs. WaKa WaKa!
its so impressive they can do that all in an accent
Brian being jewish and portraying the nazi is peak comedy
Only YOU guys are able to sing a song like "Nazi are not so bad"! XD
In Italy you would probably have gone to jail for performing this... I still love you!
Probably, since we had Nazi in our own homeland... So I'm glad this taboo song was performed in the USA, it's just pure genius!
I'm from Germany... can you imagine everyone's reaction to it being sung there? 😂
Ecco perchè non proporrò questo musical alla compagnia teatrale della mia chiesa-
Sto sclerando perché raramente trovo degli italiani che seguono questo canale
@@marinagovernatori2414 concordo!! Nessuno conosce TCB o gli Starkid in Italia 😭
Well this song definitely didn't age well
Thats exactly what i was thinking lol
Honey it wasn't born well.
this is the funniest comment oh my fucking god
@@tabimomeyer2515 I don't get it
How didn’t it? The joke is nazis are horrible
I love Brian so much lol he needs more solos.
my Jewish parents did not find me yelling “nazis are not so bad” in my room very funny
I clearly have no faith in fandom, i was so worried about the comments/potential hate and there's nothing. it's beautiful. 0 dislikes too. very cool. also this was hilarious and absurdly offensive but that's where the comedy comes in. :) great job boys.
Stephanie Walsh best part is Brian is jewish lmao
Anyone expected Brian to go "when I was just a boy ...an orphan boy"? Just me? Must b3 for Joe in the background and the Quirrelmort feeling at the beginning xD
It has a similar feel to “no one remembers Achmed”, the whole time I was thinking about the verse, “the slaughter of millions of innocent civilians” I was C A C K L I N G!!!!!
I liked how Deadliest Man Alive called Tatiana "love" (2:14), it's a subtle hint to how(spoilers!) he's Owen.
Brian: Nazi's aren't so bad
Mega: Unfortunately for you, history will not see it that way
8:07 Brian retrieves the glitter from his pocket.
8:16 Brian chucks glitter across the stage.
GLITTER!!
He keeps glitter up his sleeves, waka waka.
sparkles!!
this is so horrible. I love it so much
I fucking lost it at the human swastika 6:29
Warning: if you live in a Jewish house with 8 siblings and little personal space, don’t play Nazis Are Not So Bad when you’re working unless you have earphones in.
I had to do some very awkward explaining
Extra warning: don’t get it stuck in your head, especially if you go to a Jewish school
As someone who’s Jewish father and Grandmother showed me the producers (Musical) for the first time at age 8, and who’s Jewish great-uncle showed me the ORIGINAL film for the first time and talked about how it was ‘better’, your experiences are not universal.
you know, i used to hate how long this song goes on for, thinking like 'is the dance break really necessary'
but honestly i appreciate that they took the time to make the presence of the nazis uncomfortable, overtly silly and childish, and clearly people you ARENT rooting for but can be entertained by with their damnably catchy song
this number is dangerously catchy omg no XD gotta really watch out so I don't get to sing it around
the different tunes! the interaction!! Curt's (very appropriate) response! that ending! Rosenthal!!!
4:03 - it was the most elegant Nazi salute ever done. 6:02 - the most unexpected one :)
When I watched this scene first time I had to pause bcs I laughed so hard.
This is probably the wildest bit of audience participation in a musical ever.
7:29 who needs the fourth wall
No one
me: i have a song stuck in my head
mom: oh, what is it?
me, on the inside: the nazi's are not so bad!
me: its- its complicated...
Technically speaking, the name of the song is Not So Bad, so...
“Brian you want to play what role…?”
I feel like brosenthal is the most improved out of all the starkids. so proud
Honestly this is the kind of stuff that i wont ever be able to tell anyone about like "hey mum i was listening to a song about nazis being real cool wanna listen?"
5:53 bless Lauren's vocals
RIGHT?!
She’s amazing
Making Van Nazi Hitler’s nephew is really funny when you know that in real life one of Hitler’s nephews actually moved to the US to fight against the Nazis in WW2.
All the akward dancing Nazi's in the background at 7.04 are wunderbar :)
So I’ve watched this musical through several times, and I JUST realized he is in hotel room 2009. 2009 is the year StarKid officially formed 😊! Love these boys.
"Don't get involved, love" HOW DID I NOT NOTICE THAT?
he GLARED AT HER TOO FOR A SOLID FIVE OR SO SECONDS
can i get the time stamp? idk if i missed it!
@@itswherethecomedycomesin8864 2:10 ish
@@yeeeety6730 thank you sm!
Why is that so important?
somewhere, mel brooks proudly sheds a single tear.
Joe's 2:06 smile is 100% Umbridge smile
To me it reminded Voldemort in the scene with Malfoy, whn they discussed "the subject of payment" :))))))
+Klara Chiamarsi yeah that also xD
Lmao Joe almost looks like he's in pain with that smile!
The funniest part about this is Tatiana and Mr. "Deadliest Man" just watching this happen like: 😐
"Room 2009"
like starkid's birth year?
YESSSSS! I thought I was the only one who noticed.
Yes I also got the refferance!
I love how Joe's just in the background of the song, having no patience for this, but not in a position to object.
I don't think I've ever laughed so hard as I did when he said "Fuck is wrong with you people?"
Me: *sees Joe Walker buttoning Brian Rosenthal’s jacket*
Also me: Wait this doesn’t look like rollerblading on a Saturday
Voldemort: Wait Quirrel this isn't the rollerblading rink
(is that what you call it?)
Fara Tequillo honestly idk I assume so
Another beautiful piece to proof that kicklines are inevitable
Tgwdlm reference?
@@naomishe Actually, there's a fan made video where they sort of proof that kicklines are inevitable. But yes, there's also a tgwdlm reference in there
Not So Bad and Haus of Holbein are on opposite ends of the 'Song-sung-in-German-accents' spectrum
LMAO YOU'RE NOT WRONG-
Even though Joe hardly does anything in this he's still so amazing!!! This is one of my favourite scenes so far XD
ok but can we acknowledge how amazing Lauren did on this choreography??? it's beautiful???
i just noticed brosenthal threw glitter at the end 😂
the way they bring in audience culpability in an otherwise quite humorous musical is fascinating
‘twas a different time. this number has been altered, and the call & response section removed, for more recent performances.
springtiiime for hitleeeer and germanyyyyyy
Luna Varalda I wanna a producer of a great big broadway flop
I just realised something, he’s staying in room 2-0-0-9 aka 2009 aka the year starkid started?!?!?!!
Yeah I noticed that, too.
I was just thinking that!
the DMA looks so dead inside during the song, 10/10
My favourite part is DMA just chilling in the background and waiting patiently for the super catchy song to be over.
Brian is officially my queen
I CANT BELIEVE PEOPLE IN THE AUDIENCE REPEATED IT LMAO I SHOULDNT BE LAUGHING AT THIS
I feel a song coming up....
mitch's fandom literally any time I'm watching starkid or this
And a song is often a prelude to a dick.
StarkidMelly a song is a dick in sheep’s clothing
In this song Curt Mega is all of us.
Did anyone just CRACK UP when the sound of music started playing
a kickline truly is inevitable
i was just mesmerised by watching joe relaxing and moving slightly in the background the entire song just wow
I feel like they've taken a fair risk here with all this IT SHOULDN'T BE SO FUNNY
Joe Walker looks so pissed on the back because Brian is singing No One Remembers Achmed
This reminded me of Springtime for Hitler. Again, you never fail to make me laugh. Thank you for the two parts today!
The title is right: I really did Nazi Nazis coming XD (Also Brian has one of the best fake german (well.. more Nazi-)accents that I ever heard (It's still horrible, but it's not the worst XD))
Curt: "what about genocide?"
Von Nazi: "Shut up!" (push)
(my favorite part)
I don't know whether the tears coming from my eyes are tears of laughter or horror. I have lit never laughed so much in my life
That first part when Dr Baron von Nazi was talking to Hitler reminded me SO much of Jojo Rabbit, I can't help but think the movie got inspiration on this play.
Just… the accents. The amount of different accents in this show. Even just in this room. American. Cockney. German (x5). Russian. Like… also, Lauren’s accent range in this… I love this show.