Tata Punch vs Honda Amaze | Watch before you buy | Unbiased review | Pros and cons

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024

Комментарии • 144

  • @nasirkhan22
    @nasirkhan22 2 года назад +28

    Bought Amaze S MT In June fist week. very nice drive experience, Very comfort seting, low sound No vibration, High Ac cooling, Mileage 14-15 in City, 20-22 on Highway. Highly recommended.

    • @alpharomero3826
      @alpharomero3826 Год назад

      Bro petrol or diesel variant ???

    • @suchintsharma
      @suchintsharma Год назад

      Engine hai usme?
      0-100 kar leti hai ek Trip me?
      Adjustable Head Support hai na?
      Safety to 5 stars hai na?
      Thigh support to adhe me khatam ho jata hai..
      Sun roof???
      Ground Clearance City se zada hi hoga, City me to har Speed Brraker me Jack lagana padta hai, jab wo fans jati hai.
      TouchScreen and Android Auto?
      Sensible people buy Punch or Altroz, not Japanase 80s Technology of the AIWA, AKAI, Matsushita, Mitsubishi, Sony era...

    • @getgoodsleep1607
      @getgoodsleep1607 Год назад +4

      @@suchintsharma
      Punch ain't a powerhouse either
      You buy Sub-4 Cars for drag race? Then buy a Polo or something..
      Safety - Agreed. Tata is doing well
      Punch or Altroz offer great thigh support according to you?
      Sunroof in Punch Altroz?
      City almost never touch the ground eventhough low GC.
      Yes, both present.
      And 3 biggest factors you conviniently ignored. Reliability, Brand recall and refinement. Tata is nowhere near Honda in these..

    • @suchintsharma
      @suchintsharma Год назад +2

      @@getgoodsleep1607 Honda never touch the ground? Have you ever driven it?
      Noe listen to the harsh reality. I wonder if you are living in India or which part of the world.
      Honda makes the most Noisiest Diesel Engines!!!!!!
      Honda is selling generations old dashboard and features and are resting on their laurels, just like Canon, Mitsubishi, Sony which are extinct.
      Japanese take 4 decades to update their cars and comeback with lower and lower quality and weight, in the name of technology.
      Japanese charge a Bomb as premium and are not at all cost effective.
      Japanese were buying Fiat sourced engines and are still selling 4 decade old boxes, a.k.a. WagonR.
      Honda did massive cost-cutting in offering not just features, but even basics, like touchscreen, Music system, Air purifier, Temperature Control, Air Cooled Seats.
      Honda does not have a single successful SUV in their portfolio or will have it on the next decade, when the world demand will change.
      Honda is completely against EVs.
      Honda considers India as a very small and non-serious market and just like others, will eventually merge and co-brand Shit Boxes, in order to survive.
      Honda could never understand Indian sentiments or requirements, except cost-cutting, which was consistent across Amaze, Jazz, WRV, with their underpowered engines and 70's technologies
      Honda has never considered creating Indianised vehicles, like Ford did with Ikon and Ecosport, Nissan did with Magnite.
      Gone are tge days of charging Premium by Japanese, like by Toyotas and Hondas, as India is a Global market with Koreans, Germans, Chinese nad now Indians fighting it out.
      Now Indians will not buy Hondas, because, Hondas make silent petrol engines. Indians want value for their money, not AndhBhakti with Japanese.
      And Tata and Mahindra are evolving and listening and trying with all their might to take on the Japanese, despite knowing how to make engines or cars a few decades back only, but Change is the Name of the Game, because time of Sony, AIWA, Panasonic, Mitsubishi, Akai, Xerox, Kodak is over, because they never evolved.

    • @getgoodsleep1607
      @getgoodsleep1607 Год назад +3

      @@suchintsharma I agree with some of your sentiments, but you did ignore a lot of my points. Like you said Honda lacks thigh support, Sunroof, Powerful engines but Altroz and Punch aren't having those too.. Are they?
      And what about Reliability, Brand recall and refinement. Should fancy features like Air purifier, 10 inch infotainment, Ventilated seats take place of Reliability, Brand recall and refinement? And what about the fact that Amaze is a 4 Cylinder and does have a Diesel option incase if you want more power..
      Japanese going down in various industries is a different topic altogether but yeah, Honda is kind of weak in India right now and might even exit anytime..

  • @sunny787
    @sunny787 2 года назад +11

    Overall looks Amaze, engine smoothness , Honda service, very dashing looks punch, drivability punch

  • @abhiseklahirisarod
    @abhiseklahirisarod Год назад +6

    I own a CVT variant of Amaze and I can safely say that the experience has been superb! Refined engine and it’s so premium in this price range. Such a smooth driving experience with no cabin noise… just loving it!

    • @Irahhtan
      @Irahhtan 11 месяцев назад

      No cabin noise? U sure bro

  • @advertise6
    @advertise6 12 дней назад

    I am the owner of Amaze, best mileage on road @80 speed 25 kmpl, no noise of engine, super look, good space in cabin, comfortable driving, radius of turning is very very good, 140 speed easily you can go but I won’t recommend this high speed. Only minus is pickup at initial point.

  • @gowherulislam5480
    @gowherulislam5480 2 года назад +11

    Low ground clearance is an issue in Amaze, if any one buys just upgrade the tyres to 195/55/16 inch ,but Amaze being compact but it is great practical car in space

  • @Abhishek.j.p
    @Abhishek.j.p Год назад +2

    Very nice and informative video, especially the rating given at 8:33 to allow anyone to make any informed decision.
    As an Amaze owner owning both the old and now, the new Amaze, I can confidently say that this is a no nonsense car. For city driving, with bumper to bumper traffic, it's more than adequate. Go with the CVT transmission for a hassle free driving. The engine is super silent and so smooth that it gives a feeling of sitting in an aircraft. It's also easy to drive on the highways(high speeds) and very reliable. I didn't feel any body roll on high speeds. The bonnet visibility is good, gives a good judgement of the road and vehicles ahead, unlike some bigger/compact SUVs.
    Yes it lacks the punch or the power as the low end torque is missing, and has less features compared to the competition. However, the positives compensate the negatives in my opinion. One negative I observed is the suspension is stiff on the new Amaze, which wasn't the case in the old one. It gets a little bumpy on bad roads. The after sales service experience for me so far has been good. Nevertheless, if you are tight on the budget and looking for a reliable car, which will not make you feel regret for atleast 3-5 years then Amaze is not bad.

  • @77chotu77
    @77chotu77 2 года назад +16

    I'm 6'5"... I couldn't even sit in Punch's driving seat... Literally, I couldn't fit...
    -
    In Amaze, my sitting was quite comfortable...

  • @Maharaj65
    @Maharaj65 2 года назад +9

    Bought Amaze VX CVT and have rode around 1500 kms. It's really amazing car.
    Positives: Very silent cabin, absolutely zero noise. Forget about interior noise there is not even external noise. I literally have to honk at a pedestrian walking in the middle of the road by coming very closer to him. He will turn back astonishingly to realise that car is behind him. 4 cylinder NA engine works really well. CVT is extremely easy to drive. High ground clearance.
    Negatives - low initial pick up. Little low AC cooling at the rear sit. Dated infotainment system.
    But still it's a great value for money.

    • @RangerV8
      @RangerV8 Год назад

      Brother, What is the mileage for city n highway?

    • @brahmaguptapatil4552
      @brahmaguptapatil4552 Год назад +1

      @@RangerV8 I go against trafic. So I get city mileage of 12+
      But if I go towards traffic in peak area then it will drop to 7-8 only

  • @rohitsontakke8661
    @rohitsontakke8661 2 года назад +3

    Amaze vx - mileage 22 + on highway,
    City mileage . 12 to 15 . Rear leggggroom.
    Punch - rubber band pickup. Rear cabin is not comfortable. Is it really SUV ?

  • @KamalSinghBaghel-si6kk
    @KamalSinghBaghel-si6kk Месяц назад +1

    Bro please tell the difference between amaze and triber

  • @aryankumar-zi5gk
    @aryankumar-zi5gk Год назад

    I am getting Amaze feb 2020 at 5.80-6lakh vs Punch pure base with showroom accessories in 2023? Plz suggest

  • @sudhirgovilkar1280
    @sudhirgovilkar1280 9 месяцев назад

    Reasons to choose amaze over punch:
    Smooth iVTEC 4 cylinder engine
    CVT gearbox with paddle shifters
    420 litres of boot space
    Reasons to choose Punch over Amaze:
    Good ground clearance
    Slightly better built quality

  • @ashutoshbasak4865
    @ashutoshbasak4865 3 месяца назад

    Puch is a good small city car i bought the base model and the waiting period after booking was just 1 months

  • @justicechowdhury2353
    @justicechowdhury2353 Год назад +1

    Thanks bhai ..mujhe yeh video chaahiye tha. Mujhe bas acchi car kharidni hai. I am confused between amaze, altroz, punch

  • @sawan005
    @sawan005 5 месяцев назад

    You said ki punch me issue hota hai 80 ki speed ke upar jane me to fir wo amaze se Better kese hai ?

  • @lgmn5262
    @lgmn5262 Год назад +2

    Which one is better for hilly road

  • @bharatram178
    @bharatram178 Год назад

    I am like Amaze I try to purchase Amaze u tell me yes ya no

  • @GOMZY40
    @GOMZY40 2 года назад +1

    anyday amaze diesal rocks, gr8 torque, more power, more comfort, excellent boot space, superb engine.

  • @adarsh5035
    @adarsh5035 Год назад +1

    in amaze i think you can get an ev hybrid kit, a cng tank in it's impressive 420l boot space and a petrol variant in after market which you will miss in tata punch slightly because of lower boot space of around 350l but a cng tank takes 70 % of it so luggage can't be taken in punch as much as in amaze

  • @sandeepsarva
    @sandeepsarva Год назад

    Is it good idea to install CNG in newly bought Amaze top model. Since average is low. pls ans

  • @niteshjain1265
    @niteshjain1265 2 года назад +3

    Is punch better than amaze in automatic gear variant?

    • @solomoba7186
      @solomoba7186 Год назад +1

      10 times better because of cvt gearbox .

    • @sreyaspillai2720
      @sreyaspillai2720 Год назад +2

      Bro amaze is best in automatic because of cvt

    • @Abhishek.j.p
      @Abhishek.j.p Год назад +1

      Punch has amt gearbox and amaze has a cvt, which is superior. In terms of reliability, both should be fine, but overall in terms of experience honda is slightly better

  • @arnabgoswami6044
    @arnabgoswami6044 Год назад

    On road price?

  • @iamdeepakarya
    @iamdeepakarya Год назад +3

    For those who are confused :--
    Figure out your requirements in the car u want..and then look booth cars..
    U' ll get ur answer !! Thats the thumb rule to buy a car !!

  • @dp6748
    @dp6748 8 месяцев назад

    What about safety rating?

    • @lifehacksbyharshal
      @lifehacksbyharshal 8 месяцев назад

      Amaze 4 punch 5
      But not big difference

    • @dp6748
      @dp6748 7 месяцев назад

      @@lifehacksbyharshal what about bulid quality 😂😂

  • @niteshjain1265
    @niteshjain1265 2 года назад

    Which car is better - Glazna or Punch?

  • @krisindia
    @krisindia Год назад +2

    I took a td today of cvt amaze with light foot....out of 10kms...4 was city. 6 was highway....I set mid to 0 on trip and avg. At the end of 10km td...mid on amaze showed 12.8kmpl on amaze. Im ok with low mileage...but refnement and reliability is what i want. Idc for much features. Mereko ghadi atleast 10 yrs rakhna hain and time service centre pe spend nahi karna

    • @Abhishek.j.p
      @Abhishek.j.p Год назад

      Depending on what you mentioned, Amaze should be fine, it's super smooth engine, reliable and trustworthy and very easy to drive

  • @neerajjadhav3407
    @neerajjadhav3407 2 года назад +9

    The windows in Punch has no lock, it can easily be removed by a small child while riding the car.

    • @autocritic
      @autocritic  2 года назад +2

      This is a good point I forgot to mention in the video..Thank you !!

    • @Gcci2016
      @Gcci2016 2 года назад +2

      Yes, this point is very risky and people are very concerned about it. Unfortunately Company has no solution for it.

    • @chandanreshma4775
      @chandanreshma4775 2 года назад +2

      there is child lock

    • @kumaran140
      @kumaran140 2 года назад

      Its the door

    • @iamdeepakarya
      @iamdeepakarya Год назад +3

      ..if ur driving with kids.. Punch has complete safe child lock!!

  • @MN-ke3yj
    @MN-ke3yj 9 месяцев назад

    Can you make comparision video for Kiger Vs Amaze.

  • @TheAshwanig
    @TheAshwanig 2 года назад +14

    I am confused in Amaze S and Punch Adventure Rhythm.

    • @milanpatel2606
      @milanpatel2606 2 года назад

      Main bhi confusion main hu

    • @milanpatel2606
      @milanpatel2606 2 года назад

      Amaze n Tata punch main kaunsi loo

    • @UmeshSharma-ub1ob
      @UmeshSharma-ub1ob 2 года назад

      Tata punch osm car h yaro...

    • @dal546
      @dal546 2 года назад

      1

    • @sound_man23
      @sound_man23 2 года назад +2

      Go for Honda 4cyl reliable smooth engine, low maintenance, comfort...
      Punch 3cyl engine lot of noise and vibrations.

  • @SudheerKumar-te6wv
    @SudheerKumar-te6wv 2 года назад +5

    Sir, really tata punch/nexon/Altroz 3 cylinder engines are reliable for 10 years,can we expect a good life like maruti cars..how can we believe on life???

    • @sound_man23
      @sound_man23 2 года назад +2

      No, tata not reliable as much as maruti..... After 6 months of waiting i cancelled punch due to constantly increasing the price. and booked amaze.

  • @basavarajganachari4744
    @basavarajganachari4744 8 месяцев назад

    Thanks

  • @hiteshkaware4742
    @hiteshkaware4742 9 месяцев назад

    But now a days tata after sales service experience by owners reviews not much better recently maximum issues facing with tata safari owner their new safari.

  • @neerajjadhav3407
    @neerajjadhav3407 2 года назад +2

    Punch seems to be under power , what do you think?

    • @HealthCoachKK993
      @HealthCoachKK993 2 года назад +1

      Hamko lgta h ap tata punch ki burai karne hi ayi h yha par 😕☺️

    • @neerajjadhav3407
      @neerajjadhav3407 2 года назад

      @@HealthCoachKK993 ney, see my comment on Honda cars.

  • @savanpatel8994
    @savanpatel8994 2 года назад +2

    Amaze s ivtec he mere pass
    Highway pe 17 se 18.6 Tak mileage milti he aur city me 12-14 Tak milti he mileage

    • @Knowledgable_Factss
      @Knowledgable_Factss Год назад

      Are you overall satisfied,Regret to nahi hai aapko that Ivtec S model liya isse better kuch aur le skta tha??

  • @sashitourandtravel3065
    @sashitourandtravel3065 Год назад

    You are right

  • @amitsony7664
    @amitsony7664 2 года назад +2

    honda amage 21 in highway. and city in 13-15

  • @shekharsingh5471
    @shekharsingh5471 Год назад

    Good analysis bro..👍

  • @MandeepSingh-oc2jj
    @MandeepSingh-oc2jj 7 месяцев назад

    15 years used amaze 5,6 years used punch that's all

  • @lifehacksbyharshal
    @lifehacksbyharshal 8 месяцев назад +1

    You can drive Honda cars for 20+ years!! I doubt same with Tata!!

    • @MohanJan1954
      @MohanJan1954 6 месяцев назад

      You have to wait 20 years to know. I find Zest still running on the roads. I saw video of Tata cars being run above 150,000 km also

  • @arunpandey9769
    @arunpandey9769 2 года назад +1

    Bhai background music kise suna rahe ho, awaj sahi hai phir phi

  • @rockstar55142
    @rockstar55142 7 месяцев назад

    Nice video

  • @SudheerKumar-te6wv
    @SudheerKumar-te6wv 2 года назад +2

    I can't afford cars repeatedly i would like to purchase a car with good long life,less maintenance,suggest one,my view is as below
    1. Baleno-plastic box,if hits at any part,need to invest huge on repairs, milege figures comes good,but it is like a plastic box,so rejected
    2. Altroz, i have no confidence on engine,it is the only reason i am rejecting.
    3. I20, it is a heavy vehicle with high cost,i am not rejecting,but not considering due to below choice
    4. Brezza,it costs may be 60k above i20,but it is 4 star and good engine reliabity and gives milege as same as 17kmpl.
    So in my mind brezza is there
    Crct me if wrong or suggesitions r invited..

    • @technicalshubhu3507
      @technicalshubhu3507 2 года назад +1

      amaze is also a good option on long term bro
      brezza will update this year
      and honda is planning to launch an suv in market next year (as said by my dealer of honda)

    • @77chotu77
      @77chotu77 2 года назад

      Indians have very low opinion on plastics and composites...
      To be frank, transitioning to plastics and composites is a good thing... It is modern technology and also makes the car light in weight increasing fuel savings...
      -
      Anyways, 2022 Baleno is quite strong from outside and has more safety features than previous versions... It is expected to get 4 star rating...

    • @technicalshubhu3507
      @technicalshubhu3507 2 года назад +1

      @@77chotu77 only some will understand this like experienced enthusiasts like me
      u are right see magnite 4 star but adequate weight
      and scorpio too much weight and 0 star rating
      so it safety depends on many things like how structure is build etc.
      not heavy metal everytime

    • @ckastic
      @ckastic 2 года назад

      Buy amaze

    • @pranitnikam007
      @pranitnikam007 Год назад

      Brezza pricing now 😂

  • @domnicanthony3314
    @domnicanthony3314 2 года назад +1

    Punch is best budget SUV but misses on rear AC and 360 camera

  • @theunlimitedindia5696
    @theunlimitedindia5696 2 года назад +3

    Honda amaze sale 2500 unit PM
    Low Ground clearance, low quality built quality, above 120 speed no stability, poor miledge in petrol, rear seat not much comfortable,
    But engine smooth and silent, pickup is good, resale value, very few honda owner sale his cars, low maintenance and service cost,
    Tata punch-sale unit 10000 PM, Suv feel, built quality, bulky look, good suspension and pickup, killer road presence,
    Cons, 3 cylinder, some engine noise and vibration, no resale, door lock safety not good,

    • @rahulkukreti2325
      @rahulkukreti2325 Год назад +1

      Killer presence....khn se 😂😂😂😂

    • @theunlimitedindia5696
      @theunlimitedindia5696 Год назад

      @@rahulkukreti2325 le le bhai khud lgne lgega🤣

    • @skk6610
      @skk6610 Год назад +1

      Punch doesn't have killer looks, But, Amaze do. 😎
      Punch looks like a child on steroids

    • @skk6610
      @skk6610 Год назад

      And.. Build built quality of amaze is also good.

  • @radhamadhav1314
    @radhamadhav1314 2 года назад +1

    Bhai confuse kar diya aapne. Both are good cars, my dad want namaze and i like punch.

  • @lifehacksbyharshal
    @lifehacksbyharshal 8 месяцев назад

    Now are we really comparing Honda and Tata!!
    Sorry Honda lovers!!
    Honda is too superior than Tata!!

  • @shrishailkhirapate276
    @shrishailkhirapate276 9 месяцев назад

    Amaze se 20 milage nikala skata hai

  • @adarsh5035
    @adarsh5035 Год назад +1

    i think this is very biased towards tata punch

  • @ckastic
    @ckastic 2 года назад +2

    Amaze ki mileage kafi sahi hai

  • @kgotsomampa6184
    @kgotsomampa6184 8 месяцев назад

    Im convinced and frustrated enough to have enough data to prove this points.
    I'm Convinced the entire Indian community genuinly believe writing a video in Enligh makes the video understandable regardles of the completely different language thats in the title of the video.
    We'll... Youre all wrong it doent

  • @suchintsharma
    @suchintsharma 2 года назад +1

    1 Chonch wali seat
    2 Patlr tyres
    3 Only 80bhp in automatic
    4 Low ground clearance
    5 Low safety
    6 Cheap dashboard
    7 Sedans are in their of Life Cycle

    • @dimaagkharabhaimera
      @dimaagkharabhaimera 2 года назад

      Kis car ki bata Raha hai ?

    • @suchintsharma
      @suchintsharma 2 года назад

      @@dimaagkharabhaimera Ab Punch me to Chonch wali seta nahi hai, Amaze automatic me hi hai na

    • @dimaagkharabhaimera
      @dimaagkharabhaimera 2 года назад

      @@suchintsharma hume kaise pata chalega na punch li na amaze. Apun ne to safari li

    • @suchintsharma
      @suchintsharma 2 года назад

      @@dimaagkharabhaimera Dekhi to hogi. Kabhi sadak pe dikhe to driver's seat headrest dekhna, its good for nothing.

    • @pranitnikam007
      @pranitnikam007 Год назад +2

      Bhai sedan ka comfort samjhate ho?

  • @Globaldob
    @Globaldob Год назад

    Add timestamps

  • @h-i_m.
    @h-i_m. Год назад

    Amaze nyc car ❤

  • @Alpha_M.
    @Alpha_M. 2 года назад +1

    Honda Amaze best.

  • @ckastic
    @ckastic 2 года назад +1

    Amaze is better im mileage 22 in highway

    • @pg-129
      @pg-129 Год назад

      Petrol or diesel ?

  • @ritesharora1891
    @ritesharora1891 2 года назад

    Pta nhi yrr drma h koi video m kehta h punch 12 , 15 se upr nhi deta h milage... or yha kuch or hi bata rhe h...

  • @ranadebsil496
    @ranadebsil496 Год назад +1

    How much money did you get from Tata for this video?
    Perplexed when you say Punch has better suspension and handling 😝

    • @autocritic
      @autocritic  Год назад +1

      I have rejected multiple sponsors and do not take money from anyone, thanks for watching 🙂

    • @sudhirgovilkar1280
      @sudhirgovilkar1280 9 месяцев назад +1

      I own both cars and the autocratic review is absolutely right. The fact that Amaze is better in drivability than Punch 😊. In terms of rough roads, Punch is better than Amaze.

    • @DineshKumar-et9di
      @DineshKumar-et9di 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@sudhirgovilkar1280 Hi first car to a middle class family with 60% city and balance in highway. Highly reliable vehicle with 20 yrs life with good performance. Low maintenance cost. Pl suggest from your driven experience.

  • @adityaborah5120
    @adityaborah5120 Год назад

    Punch vs XUV 300
    Vedo chahiye

  • @anoopnkanoopnk4552
    @anoopnkanoopnk4552 2 года назад

    Amaze

  • @neerajjadhav3407
    @neerajjadhav3407 2 года назад +1

    I heard,Honda company would be the next to leave India.

    • @neerajjadhav3407
      @neerajjadhav3407 2 года назад

      @Food Travel Gadgets Auto Honda cars sale is lowered recently

    • @pranitnikam007
      @pranitnikam007 Год назад

      No ways

    • @ShubhamVerma-xm8jv
      @ShubhamVerma-xm8jv Год назад

      Even I was worried that honda should not become ford. But today I spoke with dealer and they said honda is launching suv in price range of city.

    • @cut-a-lyst
      @cut-a-lyst Год назад

      @@ShubhamVerma-xm8jv elevate

  • @grijeshmandlik3205
    @grijeshmandlik3205 Год назад

    Amaze..

  • @yashdahiya7486
    @yashdahiya7486 Год назад

    Meri amaze 25cep millagel deti hsi

  • @deepaksasane7471
    @deepaksasane7471 2 года назад

    👍👍👍

  • @cosmictruth3600
    @cosmictruth3600 2 года назад

    Amaze is a khataara..bael gaadi.. useless .. seat comfort is terrible ...horrible pickup... power is pathetic
    .only positive is ..lot of space inside..mileage is poor .. not more than 11

    • @tejaswianand9142
      @tejaswianand9142 2 года назад +15

      jindgi me chlayi hai kbhi amaze

    • @cosmictruth3600
      @cosmictruth3600 2 года назад

      @@tejaswianand9142 tere sawaal se lagta hai tune kabhi zindagi mei car mei nahi baitha hai... varna mera comment padhne ke baad aisi gawaanro beakal waali sawaal nahi karta...abey kaaniye phir se mera phle waala comment padhle ..agar Zara sa bhi akal hai to aisi chotte bachon waala swaal nahi karega ...

    • @pranitnikam007
      @pranitnikam007 2 года назад +7

      Kitna fekega bhai 😂

    • @Dream_hunter_077
      @Dream_hunter_077 Год назад +3

      @@tejaswianand9142 best shot 👌👌🤣

    • @lifehacksbyharshal
      @lifehacksbyharshal 8 месяцев назад

      😅😅😅😂😂😂

  • @palanimech
    @palanimech Год назад

    Thanks