3. Islam and Refugees - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani - Muharram 1437 - Masjid-e-Ali

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024

Комментарии • 56

  • @5maz
    @5maz 9 лет назад +5

    May Allah keep you safe and bless your knowledge with even more barakah

  • @majeedmlp
    @majeedmlp 9 лет назад +2

    Very important topic, well chosen by Dr. Sayed Ammar nakshawani.
    This one is much needed.

  • @MRiizvii786
    @MRiizvii786 9 лет назад +5

    This audio gives me life

    • @fakeguy12
      @fakeguy12 9 лет назад +4

      gives me cancer

    • @Crunkops
      @Crunkops 9 лет назад +4

      +fakeguy12 i can see it from ur username

  • @thereszainab
    @thereszainab 9 лет назад +1

    Ma shaa Allah! Very good lecture.

  • @shanayapatel2233
    @shanayapatel2233 9 лет назад

    Thank you

  • @Abbas7077
    @Abbas7077 9 лет назад +1

    Does anybody have the email of sayed amaar on which i can snd questions to him?

  • @hesamseraj
    @hesamseraj 9 лет назад

    It is a very good lecture. How can i find a Ashura's Azadari in New York City? Please help me if you know any place. I live in Harlem, West side.

    • @otowi3333
      @otowi3333 9 лет назад

      +Mosa Rahimi Please ask your question here: facebook.com/groups/1449317905317444/1620335198215713/?notif_t=like

    • @hesamseraj
      @hesamseraj 9 лет назад

      +otowi3333
      Thank you very much.

  • @techunitedbiz4311
    @techunitedbiz4311 9 лет назад +1

    The baby cutting story was from Suleman (AS) from thousands of years ago. I'm surprised someone fell for that a second time.

  • @Dogru__Yol
    @Dogru__Yol 8 лет назад

    sayyed when you come to holland???

  • @relaxedsoul8600
    @relaxedsoul8600 7 лет назад

    Amazing audio & video.. just a bit more zoom needed.

  • @zainabzaidi3611
    @zainabzaidi3611 9 лет назад

    If wealth is doubling how can bibi Khadija die hungry? It does not make sense.

  • @ismaelmuosa5801
    @ismaelmuosa5801 8 лет назад

    wonderful

  • @هدىكمشاد
    @هدىكمشاد 8 лет назад

    I wish Sayed Ammar prayed for the Kuwaiti orphans and shohada who died in Imam Sadeq Mosque in Kuwait

    • @mariamdawi268
      @mariamdawi268 6 лет назад

      I'm sure he did. We can't know what a man does behind closed doors.

  • @ayatalmanfi8709
    @ayatalmanfi8709 9 лет назад

    Where is Sayyid this year?

    • @dalakooly
      @dalakooly 9 лет назад

      Ayat he's in New Jersey this year

  • @zainabzaidi3611
    @zainabzaidi3611 9 лет назад

    In Quran it says, If you give qarza hasna your wealth doubles. How can bibi Khadija who gave all her money for Islam die without a kafan that does not cover her???

    • @mariamdawi268
      @mariamdawi268 6 лет назад

      because she never kept the rizq long enough to bask in it. Before the rich get rich they have to save and more times than others they're cheap and seriously stingy. The same rule applies towards the other side of the extreme, you have to keep a bit for your self and she didn't do that she gave away everything she had, the moment she had it because she was not consumed by the dounya. Hope this helps.

  • @mbousry
    @mbousry 8 лет назад

    Nice

  • @bumbro07
    @bumbro07 8 лет назад +1

    About the story of cutting the baby in half, I thought that was something King Solomon did. Did Ali also do that?

  • @zainabzaidi3611
    @zainabzaidi3611 9 лет назад

    In Surah Hujrat it says, No matter how beautiful you are or how smart you are you should never make fun of other people. How can you call people son of illegitimate? How can you insult someones mom? Its because of these mama insults people are killing.

  • @zainabzaidi3611
    @zainabzaidi3611 9 лет назад

    In Quran, there is no mention of the names of Prophets wife's. The only wife mentioned is Zaid's wife who Zaid divorced and Prophet later married. How can you abuse his wife's. Would you ever talk about your wife in public? How can you discuss Prophets family life and his wives. In Surah Ahzab it says, All of Prophets wife's are your mothers." There is a hadith that heaven lies underneath the feet of a mother. How can you make fun of a mother?

  • @zainabzaidi3611
    @zainabzaidi3611 9 лет назад

    Surah Hujrat: You should never backbite because when you backbite you end the flesh of your dead brother. How can you talk about the dead who are not even there to defend themselves. its a sin to abuse the dead.

    • @zahra-ee6he
      @zahra-ee6he 9 лет назад

      what sin..and on what grounds...on the other hand in Quran there's whole surah on hypocrites(surah munafiqun) and mentioned lanat on the disbelievers and on people who threaten humanity

  • @wadjay1117
    @wadjay1117 9 лет назад

    We live in such a complicated world. We live in a very unsecure and low self esteem world. Like think about the euopeans who are reluctant to accept and why are they reluctant? Christian and minority numbers are going down in the middle east and in iraq the culture is practically extinct yet islam grows in europe as well. Think about the strong men you keep hearing about. 18-25 year old refugees coming. You wonder why don't they stay and fight? Why burden a nation. You hear among them might be isis. You hear that not all of them are syrian. Some are Pakistani and some from African. Yes they face persecution to some extent, but otherwise shouldn't the whole of africa just decide to come to europe then? You hear that when muslims come they start parallel societies. Even Nakshawani brought it up once that the muslims don't assimilate after the attack in Greenwich, London. You hear about french people getting beat up for being french in their own countries. Think how unheard of is this. In many places i go to and travel it would be unheard of to get beat up because you are the descent of the nation you are getting beat up in. People are worried? Liberal society is diminishing christian culture yet islam is rising. You have to really understand what is at stake. You have to also know that historically islam has proven to be of high conquest and has taken over everything in its path. At the time of its peak it took 1/3 of the christian population and today there is very few christians left in those nations. It saturated and ate it whole and its where a chunk of the problems are today. Its easy to judge and say the europeans are evil, but prior to many jews invading palestine. The palestinians were uneasy. As we look at the news and just interaction with people you see that there is a seperation. I don't have to turn on the news to see that muslims and the standard conservative population of these countries don't see eye to eye. Its unfortunate but its true. People hold on strongly to their idealogies. I know you muslims think the quran is unchanged and straight from God and the truth. You will die by those words and not everyone will agree and there was a time in europe there were people who never heard about muslims. You have to understand the fear and the anger and look at history to really understand, and many muslims aren't making it easier. I feel the 12 imams would understand and take all considerations. It really comes down to respect and we europeans don't feel like we are getting it. Do you really appreciate our western society? Nakshawani brought it up that he is british as well as arab. That he appreciates England because in some countries he would risk his life for being shiite. Quite honestly we don't feel that level of respect and maybe if we did there would be more openess or at least your honor that no matter how shiity europeans could be no one could take that away from you.

    • @zeeshan2336
      @zeeshan2336 9 лет назад +3

      +Wad Jay my friend...islam doesn't teach us to hate Christians or jews...it teaches us that "people are of 2 types: either your brothers in faith or your equals in humanity" just because there are 1 or 2 rotten apples in the basket doesn't mean that the whole basket is impure...don't judge islam solely on the actions of a few idiot extremists who don't represent islam...

    • @wadjay1117
      @wadjay1117 9 лет назад +1

      zeeshan i don't disagree with you that is why i bring up Nakshawani and the 12 imams as good examples.

    • @nawrasalbadry4419
      @nawrasalbadry4419 9 лет назад

      Terrisom has no religion and justice has no religion my friend this comes in the heart if your a Muslim if your a Jew or an atheist it comes in the heart

  • @Servum24
    @Servum24 9 лет назад

    Nakshawani: "Number five: Can we give shelter and security to non-Muslims?"
    Really? Is this even a question? So if Islam tells you not give shelter to non-Muslim refugees, you'll abandon them? Do you lack common sense?

    • @mrmo9289
      @mrmo9289 8 лет назад +5

      He is addressing the ignorance in SOME parts of the community! Ignorance exists in ALL communities however you choose to define them!

    • @mariamdawi268
      @mariamdawi268 6 лет назад

      He is using that as an example... just like the west has to "teach" us that we cant treat anyone differently because of the colour of their skin. They aren't implying that kids are racist until taught otherwise... it is information that is to be seen as common knowledge. Also, among all the religions there are different schools of thought, and some may EXTREMELY different (Daesh, Al Qaeda etc..) He is speaking to multiple parties that include but aren't limited to misguided Muslims, different schools of thought and even ignorant westerners that believe CNN, which BTW is as truthful as becoming spiderman when bit by a spider or if you kiss a frog he will become a prince. We cant know how ignorant people are and I think its important not to assume that everyone has the sense of common knowledge. If you listen to the whole thing he is trying to push a humanitarian agenda.

  • @nicolask5435
    @nicolask5435 9 лет назад

    Sad there are people clueless enough to swallow 7th century mythology whole. The smarter among them, like this speaker and imams, take advantage of the he sheep all the way.

    • @zeeshan2336
      @zeeshan2336 9 лет назад +7

      +Nicolas K islam is the truth...islam is a way of life...not mythology my friend...ur comment shows your lack of knowledge on the matter...peace to you

    • @zeeshan2336
      @zeeshan2336 9 лет назад +8

      +Nicolas K "oh man, you came from a drop of semen and you will leave as a piece of dust, u don't know whence you came and you don't know when you are going, so why do you walk around like you know everything"....this is what 7th century mythology teaches us to tell people like you who ridicule us....sheep u say? my friend your lack of knowledge on the matter makes you a sheep for the devil...may allah guide you to the straight path...peace to you

    • @wadjay1117
      @wadjay1117 9 лет назад

      +zeeshan Saying islam is the truth is a strong statement. It may be so since i don't really know what the truth is. I just hope when saying those things you take into account everything, but not as a spectator but trully feel and get to know what you deem untruth without bias opinion. Hence not think like a muslim. A scholar always thinks like a muslim. One thing i respect about Imam Ali is he knew what it means to feel jewish and christian, but yet he was muslim. That was his path, whats yours?

    • @zeeshan2336
      @zeeshan2336 9 лет назад

      islam uses sound reasoning and makes sense to me, imam ali himself says..."learn your religion, do not inherit it" also Judaism and Christianity are also religions of the same god "allah" the one and only god...the Christian and Judaism concepts do not make much sense to me...and islam has an answer for everything....and islam is an easy and peaceful religion that aims only to bring out the best in you for your success in this world and the hereafter...and If u wanna know for certain that whether islam is the truth or not...well my friend...imam ali cleared up that for me 2...u have to "feel" god in your heart....when u come at peace with yourself and god..you feel this peace in your hart which is undescribable....imam ali says" I haven't seen god with my naked eyes but with the certainity of my heart" and my friend I have felt god in my heart...not just me...ask any devout muslim..

    • @wadjay1117
      @wadjay1117 9 лет назад

      +zeeshan so i agree islam has everything. i studied the imams very very closely. they answered many of my questions and concerns. i have no doubt they were the greatest of men alive and that includes within islam and out. You sound very intelligent. i agree with a lot that you said. There are a few things that bother me though and that is the fact that it has an answer for everything like you just said. you hear god is merciful and god works in mysterious ways. yet we are to be satisfied with concrete answers like islam gives? this may or may not be something you understand maybe a personal discussion would be necessary.

  • @JohnDoe-ot7wv
    @JohnDoe-ot7wv 9 лет назад

    The final solution for a peaceful world is, to throw all these babaric idiologies away.

    • @pukrajfatima5424
      @pukrajfatima5424 9 лет назад +7

      islam does not fall into thr category of "barbaric ideology"

    • @JohnDoe-ot7wv
      @JohnDoe-ot7wv 9 лет назад

      I wish ur life will be that way...