Yet to find someone with such discreet explanatory skills. Your diligence in preparation of this presentation & delivery is evident. More strength & success to you.
Dear Engineer, This is one of the best explanations I have seen till date! My humble request from my side is to make a video on "Response Spectrum Analysis" as well. It would also be helpful if you start a series on American codes. Warm regards and really appreciate your efforts.
I’m a mechanical engineer and so happy to find this video. Thank you! Let’s say I have a silo. In this case how we should find the action point of lateral force. Can we say it will act at the Center of gravity of silo? Many thanks.❤
All the info he is giving are by SK Jain from (Explanatory Examples on Indian Seismic Code IS ... - IIT Kanpur.) But the way he is explaining is good , so that we can understand more easily.
Thank you for you appreciation. I already have a lot of videos on my channel. If you are serious about learning more you can always enroll in my online course.
Fantastic Lecture sir. It would be beneficial if you could upload a video on seismic analysis of over head water tanks to me and many water supply engineers.
Thank you so much for your kind words. Please share this channel with your friends too in order to support my efforts. I will try making a video as per your request soon enough.
In clause 7.6 of IS 1893 part 1, it is mentioned that equivalent static method is applicable for regular buildings with height less than 15m in seismic zone 2. In our problem the seismic zone is 5. So should we solve this by dynamic analysis method?
can u plz make a vedio where the building will be designed using UBC 1997 code. explaining the code as it has been done here and also using and importance of Preform analysis and change
Hello Sir, thank you very much. For W the seismic weight of the building, you give the weight of each floor plus the weight of the roof. What happened with the weight of columns? Are they not included in the calculation for W or they are included in the weight of each floor?
Hi Christian. The problem statement was kept simple to make the manual calculations easy. In the real world example all the dead loads on the building is to be taken during calculation of Seismic Weight W which will include the weight of columns and beams and any other dead load imposed upon the structure. This example was however devoid of those factors just to minimize manual calculation on my part. Hope that helps. 🙂
good day sir. thank u for the great video. may i ask regarding the seismic weights. why is it that only floor loads are considered and how about the loads of the walls and stairs? hope to hear from you. TIA!
This was just an example problem. Hence, in order to simplify the manual calculations only floor loads were considered. In real life cases all the loads from beams, stairs, etc. will be considered. Great question btw.
Love the content...Found it very informative and cheers to you for showing some love towards Shillong. XD and I'm really hoping if you can make some more videos on analysis in ETBAS and Detailing in RCDC.
📕 Download FREE eBook "10 Step Process to Creating Your Structural Consultancy Firm" - www.civilblackbox.com/ebook1
Yet to find someone with such discreet explanatory skills. Your diligence in preparation of this presentation & delivery is evident. More strength & success to you.
Thank you for such a wonderful message. You made my day. ☺️
very nice video by the presenter. Learned about EQ. Thanks.
You are most welcome.
Definitely not a typical boring indian video tutorial.. Thank you for this sir ❤
Haha. Thanks for the compliment. Cheers.
Who dislikes this video man? :/. The speaker is extremely clear in what he explains.
Thanks for the support! 😊
A very good explanation on Earthquake loading
Thank you so much Lakshya
concepts cleared in very simple way for the beginers .Thank a lot sir .
You're most welcome
Such an underrated channel, this was very informative! Thank you
Thank you so much for your kind words. It really means a lot to me. 😊
I bow down to you... Thanks from heart.
You are most welcome. ☺
Miles of smooth sailing Fantastic journey Learning 100 percent
Thank you so much for your kind words of appreciation.
Dear Engineer,
This is one of the best explanations I have seen till date! My humble request from my side is to make a video on "Response Spectrum Analysis" as well. It would also be helpful if you start a series on American codes.
Warm regards and really appreciate your efforts.
Yes sir please make video on dynamic analysis method to.
Thank you for your kind words. I would try to consider your request.
I’m a mechanical engineer and so happy to find this video. Thank you! Let’s say I have a silo. In this case how we should find the action point of lateral force. Can we say it will act at the Center of gravity of silo? Many thanks.❤
Most deserving channl❤️
Thank you so much
Fantastic breakdown! Thank you for such a solid explanation of how to calculate these values!! I'm sure this will help many an engineer :)
Thanks for the compliment 😊
Civil Black Box...If you are reading comment.....this video is AWESOME(all bold).......Great work.
Haha. Thank you so much. Your comment made my day!
All doubts cleared..amazing
Never came across a more comprehensive and lucid video... Keep up the good work.... You deserve a lot more subs ....
Much appreciated!
Very nicely explained, one can solve any frame problem. Good work.👍
So nice of you 😊
Wow !!! Wot a great explanation. I was in zero and after watching this video am upgraded. Thanks a lot sir
Thank you so much for such a wonderful comment. 😊
Best explanation on RUclips ..
Wow, thanks!
Fantastic experience understanding with minimal effort of listener
Sir Hat's off to you for that
Thanks a lot
Great work bro...you deserve a lot more number of subscribers
Thank you so much 😀
All the info he is giving are by SK Jain from (Explanatory Examples on Indian Seismic Code IS ... - IIT Kanpur.)
But the way he is explaining is good , so that we can understand more easily.
Very good explanation sir in a simple way, please explain base shear is distributed to the internal joints of each beam and column
Sure I will
The sheer clarity is amazing Sir. Thamkyou so much.
Thank you for your kind words
nice explained thanks 🙏🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍👍...keep it up guru jii
So nice of you
One of the best video I watched on RUclips for static analysis. Keep it up Sir👍
Thanks a ton 😊
The best video on the topic!
Learned with enjoyment 👌👌
Thanks.
Very useful and very simple to understand
Thanks
Very methodical presentation of topics.
Thank you so much
The best video on this topic ! Thank you. Expecting some more videos related to building design.
Glad you liked it! More videos are coming up very soon.
Excellent explanation.
Glad you liked it
Thank you sir for clarifying the concepts which were so tough for me so long। Sir you are a great teacher.
Thank you so much for saying that. It really means a lot to me.
Best explanation I have ever seen..
Thank you so much 😊
Thank you so much sir. Concepts clearly explained. Understood everything 2 years after graduation.
Haha. Glad it helped.
Great explanation
Thank you 🙏
Your explanation was just awesome was looking for exactly this video
Glad you liked it! 😊
Please make video on dynamic analysis response spectrum analysis method
What a great video, worth watching really helpful for beginners
Thank you so much 😊
Very well explained! Thank you
Glad you enjoyed it!
Thankyou so much for this, You have a remarkable talent of explaining things, keep it up.
You're very welcome!
Very well explained sir, understood every point in the topic.
Thank you so much! 😊
very well explained and superb video visuals...!
Thanks.
Very informative presentation
Specially the way of your presentation is outstanding , Thanks
Thanks a lot 😊
Thank you so much for the wonderful presentation :)
You are most welcome..
Very good presentation,simple and interesting .Thank you
You are welcome!
Very helpful video, please do the dynamic also. Thank you !
Sure thing!
Very well explained. Thanks a lot
Wowwwww..superbly explained.👍👏👏
Thank you so much.
most subtle explanation on youtube sir....
waiting for dynamic analysis and also wind load sir
Will upload soon
Well Explained. Thank you
You are welcome!
Really very informative videos. Thanks for sharing your knowledge with everyone through RUclips. Hopefully we'll see many more videos. Many thanks Sir
So nice of you. 😄
Awesome explanation. Please post a video on steel truss. Tq.
You've excellent sense of Delivering please do cover all the aspects of structural design
Thank you for you appreciation. I already have a lot of videos on my channel. If you are serious about learning more you can always enroll in my online course.
Excellent explanation,thank you very much. please provide dynamic analysis, temperature analysis and p delta analysys
thank you for this video,you are the best your teaching level is just awesome,hope for soon complete video on staad
Thank you so much for your kind words. Join our FB group facebook.com/groups/staadbeginnner/
Great video , thank a lot sir , Video shows that you might be spend many hours to make such content and editing
Thanks a lot !! i follow your videos from Bangladesh
You are most welcome Asif.
Explained at top level. Can you provide the same lecture for dynamic method also please..
Thank you. Dynamic method is coming up in the near future. If you want immediate access check out my course at www.civilblackbox.com/sca
Marvellous❤️❤️ teaching🥰
Thank you for your kind words 😊
Fantastic Lecture sir. It would be beneficial if you could upload a video on seismic analysis of over head water tanks to me and many water supply engineers.
Will try
Very nice and helpfull presentation
Waiting 4 your Dynamic Analysis of Seismic oads
As soon as possible
Excellent and useful one....
Thanks a lot
Excellent explanation! I have one question though, why is Ah between 0 and 1? Can it be larger than 1 for stronger earthquake?
Nice explanation to understand and tq so much sir
You're most welcome
Amazing video... Thank you so much
Thank you for such a nice comment
Very appreciable work. Please make videos regarding basics of structure design also.
Thank you so much. Regarding basics of structure design, what do you have in mind? Any video ideas?
very good explanation. thank you
Glad you liked it!
Very nice explanation.. Please make some videos on Dynamic analysis
Thank you. Surely will try!
Very Informative.... Thanks...
Glad it was helpful!
Nice Explanation
Thanks.
much convening video, thank you bro
My pleasure!🙂
Nice explanation..
Thank you so much 😊
Could you make an video on response spectrum analysis and modal analysis , thanks to this video I solved this problem in my 8th sem exam .
I will make a video on it very soon!
Pls
Also make video on dynamic analysis
Surely
Hey, could you do the same thing but for wind loads. Thanks so much for all the free content. You are a life saver
Will try.
Ur teaching methodology is awesome
Can u plz explain response spectrum time history and push over analysis method in your style of teaching
Thanx
Thank you so much for your kind words. Please share this channel with your friends too in order to support my efforts. I will try making a video as per your request soon enough.
Top notch 👍👍
Thanks 😊
i was waiting for this video thank you sir again
Most welcome
perfect explanation!!!!!
can you please explain dynamic analysis also?
Yes, soon
Great job
Thank you.
Plz make a video on dynamic analysis of earthquake load by both methods.
First class sir..👏🤝
Thanks!
Fantastic 👏👏
Thanks a lot 😊
Still didn't found anyone on internet who describes like you . But the only disappointment is that no new videos are coming
Thank you and sorry.. 😉
Great video sir. Now waiting for Dynamic Analysis video. Please make it soon.
Thank you so much. I am working on that video too. Meanwhile please help out the channel by sharing it with your friends on social media. 🙂
Hi Sir
How to distribute load in each column by applying manual in Staad pro from your manual calculated value
you can use the stiffness parameters to calculate the same
In clause 7.6 of IS 1893 part 1, it is mentioned that equivalent static method is applicable for regular buildings with height less than 15m in seismic zone 2. In our problem the seismic zone is 5. So should we solve this by dynamic analysis method?
You are absolutely correct. This problem should ultimately be solved using Dynamic Method.
can u plz make a vedio where the building will be designed using UBC 1997 code. explaining the code as it has been done here and also using and importance of Preform analysis and change
Can you please provide the link for designing of RC beams subjected to Seismic Moments
THANKS A LOT. I LOVE IT
You're welcome 😊
Awesome explanation! I have a small doubt. Why we Calculated loads only at the floor level?
Structure under ground surface is fixed
Can you explain response spectra analysis and also time history analysis and finally make video for summary for three methods.
Hello Sir, thank you very much. For W the seismic weight of the building, you give the weight of each floor plus the weight of the roof. What happened with the weight of columns? Are they not included in the calculation for W or they are included in the weight of each floor?
Hi Christian. The problem statement was kept simple to make the manual calculations easy. In the real world example all the dead loads on the building is to be taken during calculation of Seismic Weight W which will include the weight of columns and beams and any other dead load imposed upon the structure. This example was however devoid of those factors just to minimize manual calculation on my part. Hope that helps. 🙂
good day sir. thank u for the great video. may i ask regarding the seismic weights. why is it that only floor loads are considered and how about the loads of the walls and stairs? hope to hear from you. TIA!
This was just an example problem. Hence, in order to simplify the manual calculations only floor loads were considered. In real life cases all the loads from beams, stairs, etc. will be considered. Great question btw.
Love the content...Found it very informative and cheers to you for showing some love towards Shillong. XD and I'm really hoping if you can make some more videos on analysis in ETBAS and Detailing in RCDC.
Thank you so much for your kind words. I will soon be releasing some content on ETABS too. 🙂
great video sir..keep going
So nice of you
Thank you so much sir🙏
You are most welcome
Sir please make dynamic analysis ,very easy explain in short time💯👌