I have the "Platinum" version of this case, which I love. It's my favorite case! I've really never felt the horn wasn't protected. I've flown with it (overhead bin) on multiple occasions with no issues. Yes, some stitching wears over time but I've taken it to a cobbler and they've (inexpensively) done fixes on them.
I've been using a protec for my Bach Soloist for a little bit, it didn't crunch the bell but it did depress the trigger when I stored it in there. Everytime I took it out I was always confused as to why my trigger acted weird, and now I know why. I'd much rather use the heavier bag that it came with now.
Looks very much like the horn I just built for myself (I run a shop in Ohio,) same valve and slide assembly, Bach af3 with Olsen infinities and a shires 2 leadpipe fitted to a Bach lightweight slide and a 10.5 inch tr181 bell. Thanks for the review, my finger was hovering over the eBay listing before I saw your video.
Oh, thanks. I was thinking about buying that case so I was finding any comments about that one. But now that I've heard your opinion, I'm thinking about it again.
I have a protec elite bag for tenor and used it daily for a few years. There is wood in the lining of the spot in front of the bell, so never had it crunched, even with a thin annealed bell. That being said, the slide compartment seemed bound to problems with the amount of stress it put in the slide.
Upon a rewatch of this video, that bag is the old design (gold series?) The new kind is O style, like the Gard bags/Reunion Blues/what have you. Perhaps they have ironed out the kinks in the new explorer design in the past few years.
I've had a trumpet/flugel case by the same brand which I've used very regularly , although not at full capacity since it is enormous which has served me perfectly well for the past half year or so. Real shame about those trombone bells though...
I use the tenor version for work everyday, and of course I'm careful with my stuff, but it's been tossed around a little bit and I haven't gotten any damage at this point. I keep it upright most of the time too. Maybe just the bass version is cursed? I wouldn't trust a bass in a gig bag anyway because of how it depresses the triggers.
Interesting, it seems the one you showed is the “deluxe” version and is around $125. I could only find it one place. The $90 one is the “explorer” version and has a music pocket rather than a long accessory pocket. The “platinum” of course seems to be a different story as well
May I suggest a different / better case for bass trombone, by Protec: IP309CT. It's their latest&greatest, less clunky then the earlier models. Its a case, with straps/backpack straps aswell. It has a large side compartiment for a4 sheetmusic etc. Another sell8ng point is the price, wich is half of what you pay for Bonna. I have both the Protec / Bonna, happy customer. Thanks for the videos, keep 'm comin' 👊
I have two pro-tec hard cases and they’re actually pretty nice. A little heavy and a tad bit wider than something like a bonna, but very nice and protective. Sucks the gig bag is trash though, pro-tec cases and nice and cheap.
@@PosauneundPapier simple, old ones are huge and heavy. Modern cases are better in every way. Plenty out there with carbon fiber or fiberglass outsides though.
Get a TANK case if you can find one, it will never get destroyed - stronger than a Bach Bass case. I still use old Bach 90s case for my 42T. Not sexy at all but my horn is perfect. Never trusted gig bags , ever.
i switched from the big protec bass case to this exact bag. looks like it's time to start breaking my back again
I'm very sorry for the bells, thank you for sharing your -sadly achieved- advice.
I have the "Platinum" version of this case, which I love. It's my favorite case! I've really never felt the horn wasn't protected. I've flown with it (overhead bin) on multiple occasions with no issues.
Yes, some stitching wears over time but I've taken it to a cobbler and they've (inexpensively) done fixes on them.
I'm sure the top trim is nicer than this one!
I've been using a protec for my Bach Soloist for a little bit, it didn't crunch the bell but it did depress the trigger when I stored it in there. Everytime I took it out I was always confused as to why my trigger acted weird, and now I know why. I'd much rather use the heavier bag that it came with now.
Looks very much like the horn I just built for myself (I run a shop in Ohio,) same valve and slide assembly, Bach af3 with Olsen infinities and a shires 2 leadpipe fitted to a Bach lightweight slide and a 10.5 inch tr181 bell. Thanks for the review, my finger was hovering over the eBay listing before I saw your video.
Oh, thanks. I was thinking about buying that case so I was finding any comments about that one. But now that I've heard your opinion, I'm thinking about it again.
I have a protec elite bag for tenor and used it daily for a few years. There is wood in the lining of the spot in front of the bell, so never had it crunched, even with a thin annealed bell. That being said, the slide compartment seemed bound to problems with the amount of stress it put in the slide.
Upon a rewatch of this video, that bag is the old design (gold series?) The new kind is O style, like the Gard bags/Reunion Blues/what have you. Perhaps they have ironed out the kinks in the new explorer design in the past few years.
Perhaps! I've only seen this version myself in real life.
I've had a trumpet/flugel case by the same brand which I've used very regularly , although not at full capacity since it is enormous which has served me perfectly well for the past half year or so. Real shame about those trombone bells though...
Protec is still a fine brand, it's these gig bags that are bad.
I use the tenor version for work everyday, and of course I'm careful with my stuff, but it's been tossed around a little bit and I haven't gotten any damage at this point. I keep it upright most of the time too. Maybe just the bass version is cursed? I wouldn't trust a bass in a gig bag anyway because of how it depresses the triggers.
Interesting, it seems the one you showed is the “deluxe” version and is around $125. I could only find it one place. The $90 one is the “explorer” version and has a music pocket rather than a long accessory pocket. The “platinum” of course seems to be a different story as well
I didn't know there were 3!
May I suggest a different / better case for bass trombone, by Protec: IP309CT. It's their latest&greatest, less clunky then the earlier models. Its a case, with straps/backpack straps aswell. It has a large side compartiment for a4 sheetmusic etc. Another sell8ng point is the price, wich is half of what you pay for Bonna. I have both the Protec / Bonna, happy customer.
Thanks for the videos, keep 'm comin' 👊
Yes, I have owned several protecs. They are OK but I personally like either a higher quality, lighter case or a good gig bag.
I have two pro-tec hard cases and they’re actually pretty nice. A little heavy and a tad bit wider than something like a bonna, but very nice and protective. Sucks the gig bag is trash though, pro-tec cases and nice and cheap.
yup, I've had the cases in the past. Not bad for the price.
I really don't know what happened to hard cases.
What do you mean? Plenty of hard cases around!
@@AidanRitchie Well I'm referring more to cases that are completely hard (No fabric). It's very trendy right now
@@PosauneundPapier simple, old ones are huge and heavy. Modern cases are better in every way. Plenty out there with carbon fiber or fiberglass outsides though.
What etude was that at the beginning? Sounds great!
"German Song" from the Art of Phrasing section in the latest and greatest Arban's book
Too late for me.... I bought this and sold it along with another trombone I had at the time and chose to keep the coffin case back in the day..
Hi, what bass trombone do you play in the intro?
That's my custom bass. Shires 2 leadpipe, Shires B62/78 slide, Instrument Innovations axial valves with lightweight wrap by my tech, Hoelle seamed copper tuning slide (reversed), Corporation Bach 50 bell
Woow that sounded incredible
Could always be better
I will buy that case
reported
Get a TANK case if you can find one, it will never get destroyed - stronger than a Bach Bass case. I still use old Bach 90s case for my 42T. Not sexy at all but my horn is perfect. Never trusted gig bags , ever.
A tank is good if you want take your horn on an international tour... I wouldn't use one around town!
@@AidanRitchie yep the caveat is they are a back breaker!
ok I won't
hi