Hope you all enjoy the video! This one's a little different- but the copyright issues are the same as always. Third time's the charm! I'll be back to be posting regularly from here on out so don't forget to leave a like and subscribe gamers
WHAT? WHAT? WHAT? "America doesn't have charity shops"? WHERE did you hear this complete load of 💩?! I've got 5 or more in less than a mile from my house! Some are religious or the same you have, like Salvation Army, St.Vincent DePaul & Catholic Charities. Others are community-oriented, like Goodwill, or Veteran-oriented, like D.A.V., or even a combo of for-profit & charity-ish, like Savers! (yes, the punctuation is part of their official name), which benefits Boys & Girl Scouts (aka Girl Guides; I forget what the UK name is for Cub Scouts/Boy Scouts). In fact, if not for charity shops, most early DW fan costumes wouldn't have existed. In fact, fan films that utilized original characters of The Doctor in US fan films routinely contained scenes of them getting their look from a charity shop, many times as a promotional trade for the shop's assistance in making the film by supplying everything from costumes, props, set decorations (or entire sets/shooting locations) and, in at least one instance that I know of, the video camera used to shoot the fan film itself! I know what you mean about the 80's gatekeeper intelligence, particularly amongst the US fans of that era who mistakenly believe themselves to be the official "original fans" in the country. That would actually be MY group, the ones who got to see a package made up of the early Jon Pertwee/UNIT serials, sans Spearhead From Space, that ended just before The Three Doctors 10th Anniversary special. As both of those serials referenced previous Doctors, it was thought the rest of the serials could make up a series that could more easily stand on their own and were sold alongside the original US syndication run of other BBC programs for the fledgling network, including Monty Python's Flying Circus, The Goodies, Upstairs/Downstairs, I,Claudius and other UK programs that helped shape the image of US's first (and, so far, only) public television broadcaster. PBS tried to emulate the BBC as much as they possibly could, particularly with their news coverage, an image they continue to try and maintain to this day, regardless of what individual opinions their viewers might have of their foreign counterparts or their native network levels of coverage and/or biases. Wandering a little further into the weeds here, PBS of that period had a much more independent attitude and for some reason were given a high degree of latitude regarding what they put on the air. They were sort of purists and amazingly, they got away with it. They wouldn't censor news footage or any television programs or films they aired. This was interesting because some of that programming seriously crossed the line of what was considered acceptable for broadcast then and now. Much of that BBC content contained swearing and nudity, content that went out untouched back then. whether that was because they were just not notified (or at least they could claim they were unaware of) potentially offending content, they'd get the benefit of the doubt. It should be noted that the complaints about a National Public Radio affiliate running George Carlin's Words You Can't Say on Television unedited was in 1972 while Python began airing on local PBS affiliates in 1974. Because of the immense popularity of Flying Circus and the not-inconsiderable amount of pledge fund money the series generated, my local PBS affiliate, KDIN, aired an unedited print of Monty Python and the Holy Grail in late 1975/early 1976. KDIN in Des Moines, Iowa, was (and still is) the flagship station for the Iowa Public Broadcasting Network so this didn't just run in one city in the Midwest, it was simulcast across the entire State of Iowa as part of the network's regular financial pledge drive. Holy Grail proved to be so popular that a pledge drive goal was set that would guarantee a second airing of the film was reached within minutes of being announced. To my knowledge, the broadcasts generated no complaints to the FCC, despite documented incidents of children below the age of 16 viewing the film, like the series that spawned it. As many as 15 of those children were in my bedroom for both broadcasts of the film. I mention this because now, the network is so neutered that they not only censor every little "shit" or "piss" that might be uttered in dialogue but they oftentimes blur nudity in paintings in the background that's so visually jarring that it's hard to pay attention to what's going on. Worse yet, if you pay them to be able to access their programming library online, a truly inexpensive fee that would be the best deal in online streaming if not for the fact they censor that content as well. I mean, couldn't you at least give us an option? They have a PBS Kids section so I would assume they believe that the adult programming is being viewed by, well, ADULTS. There's also an incorrect narrative that the Pertwee series of Doctor Who wasn't well received in the US and that it was only the act of the Gods on high bestowing the holy Tom Baker series in its place that saw the dawn of the true fans. This, of course, is complete bollocks. In Iowa, the Pertwee package of episodes ran 6 times/week. It had a daily slot Monday-Friday that was very popular as well an additional slot on Wednesdays. The Wednesday timeslot was its original original home where it ran as part of a 5-day rotation of foreign half hour programs. Most of these were comedies and included the original location for Monty Python's Flying Circus, The Goodies, The Paul Hogan Show from Australia (a series that pre-dates Crocodile Dundee by at least a decade and seriously deserves some RUclips attention). Flying Circus, Doctor Who & The Goodies were all promoted to Mon-Fri stripped timeslots but also continued to occupy their original weekly time slots, all three series continuing to run in apparent broadcast order, which contradicts the information presented. In the case of Doctor Who, this resulted in occasions where the earlier Wednesday episode would be the episode previous to the M-F daily episode running later in the evening. Other dates would see the same episode running in both slots or the two Wednesday episodes running in the reverse order. It continued to run this way until it disappeared one night in the cold darkness without warning or explanation. It was with the same amount of advanced announcement that saw Doctor Who suddenly appear back on the schedule, right back in its old daily timeslot. We were really excited and hoped that we'd not only see the return of favorite episode but that we'd see new stories of our fancy-dressed alien scientist and his daft girl companion. Imagine how we felt when the titles ran and the first thing we got to see was the Doctor die for some reason, to be replaced with whatever the hell this guy was supposed to be. I was on the phone the next day with the station, trying to find out what the hell was going on here. The station had no clue. As a kind of apology, the station sent me the entire media kit and sales information Time-Life had sent them. I still have it. The sales brochure had phone numbers for people at Time-Life so I started making phone calls. This was the start of a telephone adventure that would see me running up my parent's with calls all over the country, then to England, where I wound up speaking with Graham Williams, Douglas Adams, and several people who were fans then and run the series now in various capacities. This post has gone on far too long and I'm not even sure what the original point I was going to make before I got swallowed by the weeds, far more than knee-deep in the Who-plah. So I'm just gonna end it and leave this here for anyone whose interested. Thank you and goodnight. KJB
I got my grandparents to watch Doctor Who from An Unearthly Child right up to The Hand of Fear (there's no real reason why we stopped there, I think it was just because we were all just kind of getting sick of it, and I was growing up, and I figured Sarah Jane's exit isn't the worst of hiatus moments). Point is, I remember when we watched the end of Planet of the Daleks, and It never really dawned on me that this was the first time The Doctor manages to pilot the TARDIS correctly, until both my grandma and grandpa screamed at the same time: "YOU MEAN HE CAN FLY IT NOW?!"
The one thing I disliked about some of Jodies episodes was: She wouldn't walk into a room and just take charge like the previous Doctors. She had to work to get people to listen to her. Now I know that was a choice to show how us women need to work to get recognition etc etc, but I felt the Doctor should be above that. There's literally a scene in Silence in the Library. The doctor has known these people for minutes. He then tells someone to do something. The guy starts doing it. Some else asks "what're you doing that for?" " cos he told me to" the Doctor remarks " spooky isn't it? ". That just sums the doctors ability to control whole rooms of people. That was really my only big problem with Jodies era. Did it completely ruin my enjoyment of it? No. I still had fun watching it, and that's what it's all about in the end.
i definitely get why you can see that as a deterrent to enjoying the era as a whole, but i also feel like you hit the nail on the head with the "that was a choice to show how us women need to work to get recognition" comment. as long as the doctor sticks around earth, especially in historical settings, its gonna be way less likely for people to see her as The Leader in a situation. shes a bubbly yet socially awkward blonde woman, while Ten was a tall, british (estuary accent to be specific) man who could demand a room with his frequent arrogance (no hate). It seems like a very natural process for both individually, and it makes me appreciate the episodes where she does have that leadership role immediately more satisfactory (TWWFTE, It Takes You Away, Eve of the Daleks)
Just started the video and already fist punching the air- loved Capaldi so much when his run began. So glad people are ready to celebrate him. Is it perfect? No, but it's peak Who for me. I hope in time people will view Whitaker the same way 💗
I was just n denial for a long time but Peter Capaldi is my favourite doctor. Whittaker was let down by unfortunately weak writing but she as a doctor was fantastic and very fresh, which was needed.
There's so much value in knowing why someone loves something, coz it can be a window to learning to love it too. Learning why someone hates something is much less valuable in that way.
You actually made we rewatch all of the 13th Doctors run awhile back i’d always liked series 11 and flux but i was a huge timeless child hater but you bought me back to the light and now i quiet enjoy series 12 thank you dwfan91 you are a true hero
Genuinely could not agree more. This video is such a relief. I just rewatched all of NuWho while binging some of the older serials and it's like: Heartbreaking news, everyone: It's. . . it's all good. It's all pretty consistent, excellent TV. All the Doctors and companions are enjoyable and dynamic. Episodes remain unique and high quality with very little discernible departures. I had a blast.
You wanna know the moment I began liking you? When you said you didn't enjoy the melodrama between 10 and Rose because THANK YOUUUUUU honestly. I have been fighting friends over Rose so much, because everyone tells me "bUt iT's tHe tRaGeDy" and goddamn I am sooooo over it. I am a very new fan, as in I literally began watching Doctor Who last year in December and spent most of my vacations simply binge-watching it, and honestly it has all been enjoyable. Has it been perfect? No, not at all, but I've never come out of an episode saying "well that was a waste of time" Honestly watching it all has been amazing, and nearing Jodie, I'm getting quite exited, and of course once I finish nuwho, I will watch as much of Classic as I can get in my hands. It's a lot but I'm just so exited to learn more. I just really love this series
I never liked Rose. Not in her titular episode, not in , not when we finally got rid of her and certainly not the times we kept bringing her back. I was so happy when I found out we were getting Donna and nothing of Rose when Tennant returned. Finally, Tennant's Doctor relieved of whining over the little blonde twit that made Jo Grant look like the General Manager of MENSA. Did I mention I don't like Rose?
@@akakjb thank youuuuu, honestly I just preferred Donna 100%, Rose always felt static. Yes she saved the Doctor quite a few times but it always felt that the Doctor was always kinda babysitting her, while Donna forced the Doctor to grow because of how much she always challenged his choices, and viceversa. Honestly Donna and ten are siblings, and the tragedy of Donna being forced to forget everything in my opinion is far more tragic than the separation between the Doctor and Rose. I just love me a good sibling dynamic
@@chaostreeorsomething3586She was the first companion of the First New Era (I guess we're starting the Second New Era with Ncuti Gatwa) that wasn't tripping over her panties over the Doctor. It's really weird but my life strangely echoed what was going on with Doctor Who from the first episode of the reboot in 2005. I was going through major trauma that was coupled with severe PTSD so I really understood the Doctor when that series launched. When the regeneration happened, some things had kind of turned for me and I made the mistake of thinking that this traumatic series of events that culminated in a dramatic resolution of sorts was the ending and I'd put everything behind me. But it doesn't work like that. Slowly, the cracks began to show and a bad evening or morning became a bad day which became a bad week...things started to spiral a bit...just like they were for Doctor #10. By the time we reach the end of his run, it's obvious that he's really not okay and neither was I. I won't go through everything but suffice it to say that this continued all the way through Whittaker's run. In many ways, some of it wound up hitting the closest to home. aWith the 60th specials where we get revisit who we thought we were, back when we were 'fixed' so many years ago,. Turns out that some things weren't meant to be 'fixed'; they were meant to be let go of. It was time to let that part of me rest and enjoy a form of retirement. The person I was is still brilliant and shows up from time to time when necessary. But overall, today is for who I am now and that person kicks some serious ass. Wow, sorry for using this as an impromptu therapy session but i think I'll go ahead and leave it over here just in case any random passerby might be able to get something out it.
I think relationships with the doctor, because of his age and the fact that he doesn't look or act that age, are extremely hard to get right without getting creepy. My rule of thumb is, if you could see the characters together even with the 1st incarnation, then it's OK. Rose with William Hartnell would b absolutely disgusting. And that's 10 lifetimes younger! But River and Hartnell? I could absolutely see, I eat that shit up. So River x Doctor is much more entertaining to me. Yaz is interesting, because she discovers her own sexuality through her love for the doctor, and that's something I can really relate to as a lesbian myself. But the Doctor loving Yaz back feels wrong. William Hartnell being in love with Yaz would be really creepy.
Side note here, I wish both Akinola and Gold would have reused motifs or pieces of music from classic who. They can be reorchastrated to fit the style of music at the time, I just want to hear them again.
funny enough, Gold's Cyberman leitmotif sounds like it could have been derived from the beginning of their theme in "The Tenth Planet." but yeah, more musical continuity would be great across the board. e.g. Akinola's Cyberman theme felt like just a backing. Obviously that was setup for the cybermasters scene, which was (musically) incredible. But before then, it would've been so easy to incorporate the Gold or Revenge theme as the melody. Honestly, I'd be ok with Gold leaving whenever, as long as his themes stay this time
The same fans who criticized Clara for her actions towards the new Doctor in deep breath are the same ones who hated Matt Smith when he took over Tennant, I understand your points 😂
I really like the Capaldi era (writing of several episodes aside, lol) because Peter Capaldi looks just like my dad. Like, EXACTLY like him. So it was fun to imagine my extremely serious father who's told maybe 6 jokes since 2015 dealing with all the crap 12 had to go through.
I even tried to use pics of Peter Capaldi as the doctor to try to convince my dad to embrace his curly hair and grow it out a little, still working on that one!
When i watched the chibnall era on broadcast, I didn't think much of it. I liked it, but I guess I kinda dissociated with it cuz I realized I didn't even remember half of the episodes. Then I watched the classic era and loved it. I got a taste of a bunch of different styles and eras and takes and showrunners, and I rewatched the entire whittaker era in a binge. I loved it. I loved it a lot.
Honestly who is such a fun thing to do rewatches for, especially the classic show, very different compared to modern but very lovely and as a fan of slow burns, definitely my preferred cup of tea. Glad you came out with an enjoyment of all those Eras!
@@randomjoke69667 I came to realize that I literally just love all of Doctor Who. I liked the bloody Twin Dilemma. Vengence on Varos is peak 80s. Doctor who is less of a show and more of a crazy rollercoaster ride that takes you to so many different places and all of them are good.
@@ItsMeGPZ While personally I wouldnt go as far on saying I agree with that, I do however understand and really appreciate that you feel this way! That's very awesome and nobody can take that away from you, Besides any love for 6 or classic is very good in my Books! Honestly a goated way of thinking!
I've always said that Jodie's era will be more appreciated in retrospect, and we're already started to see it which your comment proves and I love that!
In Rosa, the fact that Krasko is underdeveloped IS the point. Not all racists have a Dalek masterplan. Mostly they're just people. Racism isn't an external threat, it's a shitty part of humanity.
Just because that's the point doesn't mean it's compelling. Just look at the newest episode, I think that handled a racist antagonist a lot better than Rosa.
@@cannonbyrd1755 Dot and Bubble did an excellent job at portraying racist attitudes, but to call Lindy or her friends the antagonists of that episode is robbing it of its nuance. I find Rosa a very compelling episode because of her story. Overloading it with a villain that is overly arch would feel somehow like it would trivialise it too much.
@@stark_harshly I do think Rosa is a good episode, I just think the villain is the weakest part of that episode. And yeah I guess Lindy isn't the antagonist, but in the same way she kind of is once we change perspectives from her to the doctor.
i think capaldi really was the modern doctor that was done dirtiest by the scripts provided to him. i feel like moffat’s writing very rarely fully exploited what capaldi was capable of.
@@andrescarnederes2295 Absolutely. Whittaker had so much potential that was squandered, partly because of trying to pander to the "fans" who had been all for the consideration of a female Doctor for decades until they got one. It was like they expected the same character as before and for everyone to ignore the obvious lady bits & the impact that would have on a standard DOCTOR WHO story. I feel it wasn't explored enough and that they left a lot of good story potential on the table. We'll see how RTD handles the racial aspects of Gatwa's Doctor in the new series.
I agree with this for both capaldi and Jodie tbh. I don’t think the way Moffat saw the doctor aligned with how capaldi saw and performed the doctor a lot of the time (until maybe the Bill and Nardole season). I could almost say the same about the way he wrote 11 sometimes too, but also Matt was younger and more malleable to the scripts he got
@@ae0ns Moffat is easily the writer who understands the character of The Doctor the most. His characterization of 11 and 12 is the peak of the character from an objective perspective.
I wanna point out at around 44:00 you talk about the whole ‘lonely god’ thing compared to the timeless child. While that is a valid point I think the reason why myself and so many others take issue with it is because it feels as though the Doctor earned that title after hundreds of thousands of years, he became quite literally a living legend. The impact of him going from bashing a cave mans head in to cherishing all life and actively seeking out danger to ‘play his role’ feels so less inspiring if he was just born into being ‘the main character’.
@@Musydid911 "my mates who had watched about 4 episodes of series 11" Seires 11 had 10 episode not including the special Resolution. They had watched 4 out of the ten episodes of the series. This means they watched 4/10 of the series or 40% of the series. I didn't think I'd have to explain this.
Nice to hear some love for Woman who fell to Erath. Honestly think it's a sevearly underated first episode. I'm not the biggest fan of series 11 tbh, I think 12 and Flux are better in ways but I'm not afraid to admit there are some episodes I really enjoy in series 11. Also I agree about Tzim Sha, He's great, that speech he delivers at the end of the finale whilst the doctor is running away is epic.
I'll admit, I used to be one of those who didn't like Capaldi's era at first. But when it came to his last series my opinion changed. I've also been rewatching his era and my opinions on a lot of his episodes have changed for the better. I realised that he may not be my favourite Doctor but his era had a good arc. I felt similar with Smith during his first two series but warmed to him during his final series. Although that was due to me having a strong empathy for 10 and David's departure hit me hard. So when it came to Jodie's era I wanted to go in optimistic. I didn't want to give in to new showrunner/Doctor bias. I gave her first outing a go. It was okay, the writing clearly was the main issue. There are a few gems of episodes in her era, Haunting of Villa Diodati (hope I spelt that right) is the highlight for me. I will concede Jodie's era did have great VFX, possibly the best we've had so far. I just wished the writing was better. Going into Ncuti's era I was elated at RTD's return and despite Tennant's caretaker Doctor I was more excited to see Ncuti's debut and so far I've not been disappointed. Doctor Who I think is unique in the way a fine whisky is. The more an era matures and enough time passes, it improves in its taste than the newest batch would. I think one of the biggest problems is channels that claim they are fans of the show just to release a video critising literally any bad press, viewing figures, latest released episode or series or comments the showrunners/actors make. Channels that openly spew hate instead of providing proper criticism and scrutiny.
Thank you so much for talking about this. I'm so, so tired of people online getting irrationally angry about Chibnall stuff or the RTD2 specials of late for really no good reason. You're absolutely right to notice that the Capaldi era is suddenly loved now despite it being hated back in the day. It would be nice if people could just try to enjoy something instead of trying to hate it (sometimes without watching it)
Haven’t finished the video yet, just gotten to where you start talking about The Timeless Child, but I just wanted to say something about that. I don’t think it’s a big deal. I think it’s perfectly fine. I like the idea behind it, and I think it actually helps broaden the mystery of the Doctor and give the show more room to grow. What didn’t we know about the Doctor before TTC? Quite a lot! What don’t we know about the Doctor after TTC? Well, we know that the Doctor was adopted by Tecteun, who performed experiments, and that the Doctor was part of a special force called Division, and beyond that, there’s quite a lot we still don’t know, and I would argue, there’s even MORE room for what we don’t know. We don’t know exactly what happened in Division, or before that, or even what may have happened between that and An Unearthly Child. It gives more room for future writers to have blanks that they can fill in.
In 2027 we’ll all be looking back at the ‘jodie era’ and especially flux saying ‘Actually, this wasn’t that bad, and ‘we were really harsh on it.’ Recently I rewatched the Timeless Children episode and I actually quite enjoyed it. This is the way these things go
That is always the plan.... For future generations. If an alien came to Earth, beyond Star Trek and Star Wars Doctor who would be the one series I believe a peaceful race might enjoy
TBH, my expectation is I'll still be loving it as unintentional comedy for it's charmingly bizarre character dialogue and characterization as I do with early 80's Who. Because as someone relatively immune to the bandwagon effect, and someone who has been kinda shit on for daring to compare Whitaker and Davison... The early JNT and Chibnall eras are pretty much the same take on the show, and those two Doctors are very much the same characterization. Questionable moral choices and all... The Fam is very similar to Nyssa Tegan and Adric... You have the one that kinda fades into the background despite having massive dramatic potential (Nyssa and Ryan) the character that is often used comically but has a twinge of tragedy (Adric and Graham), and the relatively grounded one (Tegan and Yaz)... None of which are characterized very well in series... Big Finish audios for 13 are gonna be so cathartic for patching that up... Both eras of the show got increasingly dependant on treating the fans for quick ratings boosts every season often leading to bad stories (Arc of Infinity, Warriors of the Deep, The Timeless Children, Revolution of the Daleks, etc) And as specific as it is, the show creating a giant spectacle drama where half the universe gets irreversably destroyed and despite that not following up on the consequences in any meaningful way... (Logopolis and Flux, and I'm willing to bet if the episode count hadn't been lowered it would have been Dhawan's master doing the "people of the universe" quote...) I think both of these eras are bad in some pretty notable ways... I also think time heals all wounds and both of them are unintentionally hillarious with the occasional spots of brilliance. And some people seem to genuinely think the Fifth Doctor's era is great, so maybe 13 will be highly regarded...
@@nodatastored684Heh... You may not know how right you are... I will always maintain that The Doctor is the most universally relatable main protagonist humanity has ever made in spite of looking identical to a human.
I really wish that the Thijarians returned to watch over 13’s death in PotD. It’d be a great way to tie her era together, almost like the Ood’s presence in 10’s regeneration scene
I won’t argue that The Doctor didn’t become a super special God-like being quite early in the show, however I always appreciated the idea that anyone from any background could reach that level by learning and growing through their experiences. Honestly, The Timeless Child doesn’t take that away from the 1st Doctor really thinking about it. I don’t know how else to summarize how I feel except to say that the additional lore feels tacky and unnecessary.
What a great video! I feel this way a lot too! Like I stopped watching Doctor Who during Matt Smith. And I started up again last year and when I got to Peter Capaldi, I was like oh my God I love him. Why did young me deny me such great doctor who! Sometimes all the fan stuff makes me feel like I’m missing something. But if missing something allows me to have a good time with a show that I like it’s fine with me
In the case of Jodie Whittaker, I like her as an actress. I like her portrayal of the doctor. I got about halfway through her first season on two seperate occasions. But I couldn’t handle the writing. I felt it was all very on the nose. Something about the writing waa just. Not it for me. Although listening to your review I might have to give it a third try.
I don't think American's have a problem with the accents. I didn't watch it myself, but Jodie was on Broadchurch, which was very popular in the US. It even won at American award shows. Believe me, we get plenty of British TV here and different British accents and I don't see that as being a reason people hated 13. Honestly, from what I see from the fans that hate 13, it's because the doctor was a woman. It's really that clear and if you read comments on Dr. Who videos you will always come across, "the show went downhill when they made the doctor a chick." Stupid as hell, but I think that's really the biggest reason for all the hate. As for charity shops, many have already pointed out that we have plenty of them in the US. We just don't call them charity shops. Honestly "Goodwill," while the name of an actual chain of charity shops, is what my family has used to describe any kind of charity shop. There are places like Savers, the Salvation Army, and then local shops that are unique to each town/city. My whole childhood was spent getting clothes from charity shops in the US, but not once did anyone ever call them charity shops even though most of them are actual registered charities. Loved the video and looking forward to watching more from you!
For me I think it's mainly the performances of the main cast. As you mentioned every series of Doctor Who has had it's fair share of bad scripts, some more than others. But usually whoever is cast as the Doctor/Companion at the time, can just carry that bad script to a degree and I can still enjoy there performance, even in a script that's not great. Jodie as the Doctor just never worked for me. Hard to pinpoint exactly why and it's going to feel like a cop out answer but she doesn't feel very "Doctory" to me lmao. Not a fan of the way she delivers most of her dialogue and I think the exact same scripts, with someone else in the lead could of been much better. As for companions, I think this without a doubt is the weakest of the NewWho era. Ryan and Yas to me are straight terrible outside of maybe a few moments here or there. Graham for me like most people is my favourite and in large part I feel he just stands out in comparison to Ryan and Yas, because Bradley Walsh can act. It feels like he's actually trying. Long story short, this era for me was the first time in NewWho at least that the cast, was mis cast and I just can't get into the performances, I watched the whole era 3 times between Power of the Doctor and the 60th too and it just didn't connect :( PS. Your content is genuinely fire bro, I disagree with alot of your takes but still love the videos haha!
I like genuinely being able to talk with people about what they like/didn't like about certain parts of dr who. When people get specific and actually say what they think it's so much more interesting than "bad writing init." Thanks for the comment man!
@@dwfan91- I think that's why so many of us have gravitated towards your channel and content brother. You've created a space where it feels like you can start a dialogue with other passionate fans, where opinions may differ but it doesn't turn into a screaming match and petty insults. (Apart from the odd weirdo but that's inevitable lmao) You should be real proud of what you're doing here man genuinely, look forward to the next upload!
@CrikeyItsDan I completely agree with what you said about the era. There was just something lacking in Jodie's performance. Like she was lacking a certain gravitas that all the others had when delivering speeches and whatnot. I found it hard to put my finger on what it was, but i never got into the performance. I was disappointed as well. Jodie is from really nearby to me, and I love seeing someone local do good, and was looking forward to her in the role, but just didn't hit. The 3 companions really was too many to have all the time. I think it just gave her even less opportunity to shine, when she was floundering anyway.
I got into the show right when the 50th was happening and Capaldi got announced just as I was sort of getting used to Matt Smith and David Tennant, and being like who is this old guy he's not doctor who this is gonna be boring and horrible, and I hated the idea of him right away, fast forward a few years later and I was deep into series 10 and Capaldi had become my favorite Doctor by then, like mans on my current pfp it's kinda ridiculous in hindsight how much of a massive one eighty I had on him as the Doctor.
39:35 We have thrift stores which I think are the same thing as charity shops (ie people donate the clothes and appliances they don't want or need and the places sell them at low prices) The one that I know best is called Goodwill, but there are lots of local ones everywhere as well.
Yeah, as an American, I totally related to the doctor in the charity shop scene because of shopping throughout my life in thrift stores. We have tons of them.
I'll say, I generally liked the Chibby Era but I don't like the way he introduced these huge world shattering revelations and then... did nothing with them. We finally got back Gallifrey and Chibby destroys it again for shock value. I was willing to let the Timeless Child twist do its thing but then they don't do anything with it the next season...
Goated ass video once again and I just 100 percent agree that just mindless hate when you haven’t even formed the opinion yourself is just so stupid I remember when I was watching the chibnal era I would sometimes look at the reviews for it on youtube and it was just so dumb in retrospect, I remember thinking I actually liked this episode and then I watched one review and felt like a dumbass
Also one very random thing to add to what you said earlier in the vid when you were talking about things you didn’t like in each era I do really agree with you on of moffats insistence on domestic violence is really bad but just to add to that is how with moffat some scenes were just really creepy like on that comes to mind is the crimson horror when 11 just kissed jenny for like 5 seconds unprompted which just made me uncomfortable and I thought creepy also in time of the doctor when the doctor is naked and then going to the church naked and clara doesn’t really want to is just first of all cringe and its weird I find that moffat just makes things to adult for no reason its kinda hard explain but yeah, also 11 saying sexy like a billion times there’s probably more examples of this but those were just on the top of my head hopefully this wasn’t to ranty also once again goated video
(tl;dr: i used to dunk on chibnall's era, and it wasn't until i repeated what i was saying to other people irl that i re-watched it and formed my own opinions. bandwagoning is bad folks, don't do it.) i gotta be honest... i came around on the chibnall era. i watched series 11 and 12 initially all at once, then immediately after i watched "the fall of doctor who". i thought there was some good points in there, but didn't completely agree with everything said (and there was quite a bit of "this video sucks" from people who haven't watched it, which is always terrible). i didn't realize how much i had let it color my opinions on this era of the show until i tried to talk to my friends about the timeless child reveal. look, i don't like the timeless child because it gives me 'chosen one' vibes from the dominance of mid young adult novels trying to be the next hunger games or divergent - i don't even *like* divergent, but the amount of books trying to be divergent felt never-ending. that's it! it's just that, and i'm pretty sure that's a me problem anyway. but the amount of people saying it "ruined" doctor who is ridiculous. this show is 60 years strong, nothing like a minorly mishandled reveal is gonna stop it. if that was all it took, it would've died out in the 60s. but that's what i told people online. that's what i told my friends; that it ruined it. they weren't doctor who fans - that is gonna color their experience of watching it for the first time, if they ever decide to. so i was like "wtf just came outta my mouth?" i examined that feeling, i rewatched the episodes, and honestly? truthfully? it's good! series 11 is good. i don't like rosa because it goes with the lie that all she contributed to the civil rights movement was refusing to move on that bus, but to be fair, where were they gonna fit that in? another me problem probably. it's good though! and rest of the series is mostly good! series 12 was a little more hit-or-miss with the returning villains (should've stuck to their guns for longer) but its highs are even higher! i love sacha's master so much, you have no idea. that man is genuinely terrifying. i say this as a "missy is my favorite master" fan: i'm glad they brought the master back. series 13 is the greatest car crash i've ever seen. yeah i'm a flux enjoyer now. also this whole era's cinematography is beautiful. i didn't like this era's tardis because despite the wide open space, having to dodge around those giant crystals made it feel claustrophobic to me? i dunno. but every time they have it in a wide shot i'm like "ohh i see the vision". i say all this to say that this era isn't that bad. it's even good! i dream of the day i can say that outside of this comment section and not get dunked on by bots - or even other people who haven't done the work of re-examining it. for doctor who, this bandwagon was particularly bad, but i've been in fandom spaces for a while now, and it's not the worst i've seen. i made the mistake of thinking dw was immune to that sort of mob mentality. i know better now. i do better now. the chibnall era gave that to me. so hey, hate it all you want if you've actually seen it. if you've read all of this then thank you! if you still hate it i can't change your mind. but it's special to me, and it always will be. (edit: misspelled sacha's name, i'm a fake fan /s)
THANK YOU for being such a breath of fresh air in the fandom! Seeing someone fairly enjoy the eras and episodes, I’m new to ur channel and videos so I was wincing in anticipation/fear when seeing the Chibnall era was approaching wondering if there was another person gunna shit on it, so glad not all fans r like that lol
nikola tesla's night of terror is actually so much fun. love the doctor and tesla's admiration for each other! the historical episodes in general were straight up bangers in this era, can't wait for people to celebrate that once the whittaker renaissance comes around lol
0.01% guy here! Watched EVERY episode (including missing eps via telesnap, recreations, and animations). And listened to every bigfinish audio up until 2020. (I'll get to the rest sooner or later) I love classic Who, But I love modern Who too! Not every episode is great, but none suck.
I think you mean it can't be overstated how much _Doctor Who_ you watch. I can understate it right now: You have only seen one episode ever. It's easy to understate it, in your case. :)
For me, being from Yorkshire, the characters being from Yorkshire and episodes being set here was one of my favourite parts of the Chibnall era. The same with the Flux episodes set in Liverpool. It was nice to see Doctor Who in the North, made the characters more relatable to me. I never even considered that the accents could be a barrier, as compared to most people I know, the accents are not that thick 😂
I was speaking with some americans and they said they couldn't understand anything was being said. They also said that Peter Capaldi's accent was too thick as well so that goes to show you something😂
I'm a started-watching-when-Jon-Pertwee-took-over fan, and I have every episode, 1963 to Christmas 2017.. I wanted to see Peter Capaldi ever since I saw him in, 'Neverwhere' in 1996. When it happened, I felt fully vindicated, and I stand by it ! Clara outstayed her run, but Bill was excelent. It was like the 7th and Ace all over again. I'm glad now to see other fans realizing what they missed.
The fact that you cannot accept anyone having legitime reasons for disliking 'Demons of the Punjab' is a little closed minded, to be honest. No matter how good you think it is, other people are allowed to disagree without that making them WRONG.
Just wanna say that thanks to you, I gave the Jodie era a second chance and I thoroughly enjoyed myself. There are some Chibnalisms that I don’t vibe with, but there are Moffatisms I don’t vibe with either. I’m so glad u put me on and made me remember why I love this show so much and the conversations I’ve had with my dw fan friends are much more lively now that we’ve given the eps a chance and can discuss them for real ❤❤❤
I do wonder where you get some of the criticisms you push back against from here - places like Gallifrey Base or the Reddit communities have always loved Capaldi for example. Similarly I recall McGann being liked even while the movie itself was not. There are others I could mention but maybe its a twitter/Tumblr thing? Its certainly true that a lot of the time these people haven't watched it and I do think you give them a little too much credit here - its bad faith, and designed to be bad faith. How could a culture warrior fool be a part of fandom? I don't think 90% of these people ever were, ratings etc are just the excuse for the war. I think you're totally spot on with the music though. If there was one way I'd describe Gold, its the word "manipulative". The guy brings out a full orchestra if someone's shoelaces come undone, telling you how to feel. Its very effective, but I don't care for that personally. In contrast when the music leaves the audience room to breathe and decide for themselves...everything feels flat to many of them? Weird, but OK.
@@dwfan91- Ah OK. I'm assuming there are indeed bots or whatever involved then, probably culture warrior proxies. RUclips comments are not exactly high quality.
Ill be honest, I wasn't paying attention to fandom in 2014, but I also didn't like series 8 at the time. Capaldi was just so different than 9, 10, and 11 that I didnt continue to watch after series 8 finished. I am also only now watching the classic series so I had no reference to doctors 1-8 and how they were. I picked up Doctor who again in 2020 when The Timeless Child hate made its way to me. I had no clue what was going on so I started at Series 8 again and watched up to The Woman Who Fell to Earth and got less that 30 minuets in because I was bored. (Also I LOVED the Capaldi era after I finished it. I wasnt and am still not a big fan of Twice Upon a Time, even now having watched all of the First Doctors stories. If anything I like it less because of that) I think it was probably a year later I watched TWWFTE all the way through and then all the way to The Timeless Child. Revolution of the Daleks wasnt available to me (without pirating) at the time and I dont think Flux had started so I stopped until Autumn of 2023 where I caught up again. I didnt hate Whittaker's era, though I do think its boring, but I actually like The Timeless Child and think it opens up a lot of interesting doors. Ive watched everything that has come out up to this point and plan to keep up with the show and in the meantime continue to watch the classic series in full as Im only up to series 9. My hate or dislike was never a bandwagon though. It wasnt until December, when I rewatched the 2005 series from the beginning to series 11 that I actually liked Matt Smiths Doctor, and I remember that while his era was going people were huge fans of him (especially other girls and that confused me lol). Now im just excited to see where the series goes from here and I and I can truly say I love every actors interpretation of the Doctor (that I have seen) even if I dont enjoy all of their episodes
I think the problem is the moral inconsistencies, the timeless child being WAY too game changing and confusing, and the weird and bad acting from supporting cast and villains. Also, the closeups start off well done, but as the era goes on, they become overused, even in situations where they add nothing to the scripts. This makes the direction feel off and the audience's proception of space within a scene hazy. I agree it is over hated, but it falls far shorter than any other era does for me.
I think the Chibnall era is the lesser of the three Doctor Who revival era, but a lot of the criticisms against it were overly harsh and incredibly unfair. Talking about Doctor Who became very unenjoyable back then. Also I still think series 11 is one of the better seasons of Doctor Who. Demons of the Punjab is my favorite historical episode, and yet I saw people tear it apart like it was trash. It left an incredibly bitter feeling in me. And contrast that with how people talk about RTD2 era, where people are praising the heck out of them while having a lot of the similar flaws to the bad Chibnall episodes, or having moments that people nitpicked the hell out of in Chibnall era episodes. The thing that really bothers me is just how the standards are being applied so unevenly. Anyways, glad someone talked about this because I genuinely hated the fandom at that point. Regarding Timeless Children, I liked all the ideas of it, it made sense to me and what I knew of the Time Lords (they have always been bad), and recontextualizing the Doctor as an orphan was very interesting to me. I just think the poor execution, along with coupling it with a Cyberman finale made it an especially bad episode. Two finales in one episode, both finales incredibly underserved. And yeah, 10th/Rose dynamic was incredibly obnoxious.
gotta hand it to you, I love how I can both agree and disagree with some of your takes yet still come back for more videos. This channel is super refreshing and you are crushing it mate! Alons-Y! PS always loved capaldi since his announcement glad hes getting love now because for ages I thought I was going mad being the only one in my friend group who adored his take.
AYO american here! RAH RAH!! we def do have charity shops we just call them thrift shops such as salvation army and shit. I liked that the doctor had that scene honestly i have more complaints about what she found. ITS TOO CLEAN!! i am not a hater of jodies first season but the fit is bad. It is way too clean and calm.
7:37 I think a lot about this like A LOT. If Doctor Who fans hypothetically like really start hyping up a usually disliked classic Hartnell who episode I wonder if due to the fact most people havent watched it could he possible to gaslight casual Doctor Who fans into thinking its the holy grail of Peak Doctor Who content up there with Genesis.
The worst part of Doctor Who bouncing around between streaming services is that I STILL haven't been able to watch 13's era. Amazon prime wont put past season 10 so I haven't even had a chance to form my own opinion, I've just heard all the bad reviews.
The crazy thing is that Jodie’s run, especially her first season, was probably one of the more conservative leaning seasons. Multiple episodes saying that there’s nothing inherently wrong with “the system”, it just needs a little reform. There’s actually two episodes that I find have similar plots but very different responses; season 4’s Planet of the Ood and season 11’s kerblam episode. In the former, they take a strong stance against the slavery system and end up destroying it, in the latter they end up siding with the system of essential slavery and end up saying “the system is fine, people who are against the system is the problem. The system just needs a little reform”
I don't think Series 11 was "looking to good to be Doctor Who". I think it looked good, but to me, it didn't FEEL like Doctor Who. Which is odd considering that Jodie Whitaker was the Doctor immediately in my eyes. But the "not Doctor Who" feel did end by the end of Series 11. I don't think Rosa was bad. I just feel like if you removed the villain from the story, it would change nothing. The villain felt so shoehorned in that I'm not even convinced that the original script had him. Many of the criticisms of the Chibnal Era in my opinion is that many of the stories are good ideas, but I feel like they were executed poorly. They weren't bad, they were just "meh". Simply put, my criticism is lost potential. The music may be what messed with my head. It was beautiful, but it just didn't sound like Doctor Who. But that's not a problem in my opinion. I liked the Chibnal Era.
0:50 To be honest, I just assumed you were a fan of Arthur's sister in the popular Children's TV show on CBBC/PBS. With Doctor Who being a side project. Still waiting for your Mr Ratburn character breakdown ⌚👀
I'm a very new Doctor Who fan, I haven't seen the classic series yet, but I caught up on the modern show in time to view the latest David Tennant specials and Christmas special as they came out. I own season 1 through 13 of the "new" show on DVD, my favorite era was definitely Russel T Davies, Matt Smith never quite clicked with me though I did like him in the part. I really liked Peter Capaldi but I will concede that a lot of his episodes were hit or miss. But Capaldi was so good in the role that I feel like he carried some of the worse episodes. I'd head for years about the Jodie Whittaker/Chibnall era, but I was determined to see it for myself. I was pleasantly surprised. It seemed clear to me that the people calling it woke hadn't seen the Capaldi era because it was pretty similar in that way. I thought season 11 was solid enough, I really liked season 12 though I have mixed feelings about how it effects the cannon (but it's not really a big deal. I thought Sacha Dhawan was great as the master. Season 13 really suffered from being made during caronavirus restrictions and wasn't very coherent in my opinion. I thought Jodie Whittaker's sendoff special was pretty good though. I actually disliked the return of Russell T Davies more than the Chibnall era so far. I thought the star beast was ok, but it could have been much better if it didn't get so bogged down on trying to upset people who didn't like the Chibnall era and I thought it really undermined one of my favorite Doctor Who arks. I was fine with them writing in a way for Donna to keep her memory but the fact it boiled down to "a male presenting timelord is too stupid and or ignorant to just let the energy go" was really unsatisfying. The wild blue yonder was good. I hated the toymaker episode, I thought Neal Patrick Harris was insufferable in the role. Bigeneration was a really odd choice imo, and if we never see the 10th/14th doctor again than idk what the point was (besides giving a version of the doctor a "happily ever after" sendoff). The church on ruby road didn't win me over. I'll keep watching and I'm sure it'll find its footing. I do prefer the generally more grounded camerawork of the first 4 seasons to the more cinematic look now, there's a charm to it and when done right it still hold up.
depends. I don't feel original when I say 'genesis of the daleks is good' but I still feel it. I think what matters is that you're not copying something word for word- make sure your opinions *are* your opinions and not just something you feel pressured or forced into believing👍
I may not like the Chibnall era, in fact I really dislike a lot of it, but I can honestly say I sat down and watched every episode because I never want to judge something without giving it an honest chance. There are some episodes I like, a lot of episodes I hate, and I'll probably never come around to loving it, but at least I know every opinion is my own. It was actually the Chibnall era that allowed my teenaged self to fully break away from the right wing reactionary crowd that was becoming more and more radical every passing year. Seeing such an overblown reaction to such mediocre television, all the vitriol centered around the pettiest shit as opposed to the actual problems, made me realise that it wasn't a scene I was interested in being a part of anymore. And thank god I did because what a cess pool.
I respect the chibnall era but i find most the episodes boring and bad, but thats not to say i dislike it all, i especially enjoyed her third season, Eve of the daleks and Power Of The Doctor were great in my opinion.
Excellent video and some solid takes. I totally agree with the critique of bandwagons, and it certainly doesn't make sense to hate a show you haven't watched, but I was confused by the characterization of some critiques of the show especially the early Whitaker era, as well as some of the points you made in its favor. I confess I didn't watch much past series 11 as I didn't enjoy the show much anymore, but I have found most people think that Demons of the Punjab was one of the best episodes in that series. I can't offer criticism of the other episodes, as you've pointed out, but I do think that part of the show deserves much of the judgement it gets, if not the hate. My biggest issue is with the doctor's characterization. Like in the very first episode, I grant that it has some fun doctor who-esque moments, but the one thing it doesn't do is show us who Jodie's Doctor is. She's definitely supposed to be the Doctor, but I don't think I can come up with any traits that distinguish her from the others. The best I can say is that she, for some strange reason, frequently lacks confidence in herself(except when the plot requires her to have it) and really doesn't seem to have a grip on the moral core of the character. Take Arachnids, the entire plot of Kerblam!, or her inability to articulate why "guns bad," as evidence for that point. I am sure only that the newer iterations are trying to satisfy expectations of who the doctor is so hard that they fail to capture the true qualities of the character. Perhaps the later series or the recent regeneration have changed all of this. It's good for the show to evolve over time with different iterations, but I really felt like there was a lot of the core of what made the show good missing in recent times. Still, you've motivated me to have a glance at the recent Specials and maybe I'll have to finally delve into the classic seasons and see if they seem more to my taste.
Honestly, I'm still not a massive fan of the Capaldi Era. Series 10 is pretty great, but I dropped off hard with series 9 and even 8. Even now a days my Doctor Who marathons tend to slow down here because the episodes don't grip me in the same way Russell era or even Chibnal Era stories do. I think most fans are re-evaluating Capaldi's era because it's not what the show is doing rn and distance is important for these things, Doctor Who fans are incredibly fickle and we struggle to vibe with the current eras
Yes yes, blah blah new thing hate, etc etc. I NEED THAT ORCHESTRAL ARRANGEMENT OF THE CURSE OF FENRIC FINALE AT 21:45. Where is that from. Also excellent video
I’m incredibly grateful for this video, seeing the double standard where fans rip apart things in the Chibnall era that would have been perfectly fine if they happened the same way under RTD or Moffat makes me want to tear my hair out. I like being able to criticize media I enjoy, and I like having good-faith critical discussions, but it’s immensely evident when someone hates the Chibnall era because they’re misogynistic or “anti-woke”. I’d easily say that Chibnall is my least favorite of the 3 show runners for New Who but the fact people on the hate bandwagon refuse to acknowledge the era has any merit is so, so frustrating.
RTD and Moffat were better. That's simply it, but of course, you have no real argument, and it's evident with people like you who have misogyny of the brain all day long anytime someone doesn't like the shit you do.
We do have thrift shops in the United States. I used to go in to Goodwill and walk out with ten dresses for $30. The prices are a little higher now, but not by much. We have Goodwill, the Salvation Army, and Threads, just in my town. I don't know what kind of ritzy (posh) Americans are making comments that these don't exist and only want to hear BBC newsreader accents.
Here's the way i recall seeing the chibnall/whittaker hate train barrel out of the station: Them: the doctor cant be a woman! That will ruin the show! Us: the show's creator Sydney Newman wanted the doctor to change into a woman. Since 1980 everyone involved with making the show has been publicly saying the next doctor could possibly be a woman. Them: I dont have a problem with the doctor being a woman, i just hate them shoving all these sociopolitical messages down our throats! Us: the show (classic & new) has always been political [numerous examples]. The pertwee years were particularly notorious for beating the audience over the head with messages. Them: i dont have a problem with the messages or the female doctor, its just the writing is so bad! That last argument cant really be disputed because its subjective, yet they act like its objective. Its kind of a nebulous rorshach test type of thing. People see what they want to see. And its what they are able to make others see. The original chibnall haters actually hated bc of their sexism and intolerance. Once they learned those werent valid reasons to hate, they made up the seemingly valid reason of "bad writing" and made a bunch of videos and posted a bunch of comments to convince others the writing is "bad" and before long, groupthink settled in. The influencers led the lemmings off the cliff. I remain convinced if more people were more familiar with classic who, and had watched the chibnall era and formed their own opinions without going online to be told what to think, then the chibnall era would be more popular. Perhaps more highly respected than the rtd era. The truth is, every writer/showrunner has their pros and cons, strengths and weaknesses. If a few people devoted a bunch of videos to explaining everything thats bad about rtd, then a lot of people who watch those videos would end up only seeing the bad about rtd and hating every one of his episodes. Then those people would in turn spread their hate with their own videos & comments
39:38 late to this video, and someone's prob already said this, but hello from America!! While I don't think we have places called "charity shops", we have thrift stores which sound similar to me. They're particularly popular among college age people, lots of my friends go there for fun to find unique clothes you wouldn't be able to find elsewhere! But also America is really big so maybe things are different in other areas lol
I loved Jodie so much, shes my second favorite doctor from the new era, first being Capaldi, she just has a certain charm and energy to her that plays so well with the Doctor as a character, especially how she contrasts Capaldi's personality in the role Can't say I liked all the episodes but it's the same with every doctor for me, and it just sucks that people took the "controversy" of her era and use it as proof that doctor SHOULD be a male or it loses fans, I mean sure it does but those probably aren't the type of fans the showrunners would care to keep
this is a great video! my two main issues with chibnall's era were that the acting wasn't what i was hoping it would be, many lines felt flat. and i also think that the writing was on average lower than what previous seasons were. there were absolutely some good episodes, but for me, the great episodes of the chibnall era were about on par with the fairly good episodes, while some of the bad episodes felt like some of the lowest in recent memory. (especially the episode with the sea devils, i really was not fond of that one when it came out) thinking back on all three seasons, i feel like the biggest struggle all of the episodes had was they didn't have a majorly memorable line or moment. i can think of dozens of iconic lines from s1-10, but it's a pretty big struggle to think of especially iconic lines in s11-13 (edit) i think the best comparison is with the episode 42, which was written by chris chibnall. i genuinely really like that episode, and it has some very iconic moments. the phrase "burn with me" was very memorable, and it's those kinds of moments that i wish chibnall's full seasons included
So I'm one of those people who watched 13 religiously but... Didn't enjoy it. I'd get glimpses of what I used to love but it just wasn't there. A TARDIS team that never gelled and a Doctor that was disaffected, drowning in toxic positivity. Having said that... RTD has written the 14th Doctor in such a way I feel like I understand the characterization of 13 better now. That the closed off nature that we just assumed was bad writing can be attributed to someone forcing a positive image because they don't want anyone to see the pain they're in. I think I'm gonna try re-watching series 8 through 13 again to give it a proper shakedown now that I've had time. I still hold Jodie was the best cast Doctor with the worst headwriter.
Great video. The massive over-reaction that certain people in the fandom have to things is so draining and it makes it so difficult to give genuine, good-faith criticism without being seen as part of that group. For instance, I'm really not a fan of the Chibnall era and there's a lot of your points in this video that I'd personally disagree with or counter. But with that said, I'm glad that people enjoy it and find things to like about it, and there are loads of things that I like about it myself. It makes it difficult to have discussions and voice opinions (which used to be one of the best things about fandom) without it turning into an all-out war held in Twitter/RUclips comments...
I honestly thought i was going insane reading the reviews of the first two episodes and reading #ripdoctorwho tweets till i found this video youtubers like nerdrotic have found a infinite view and subscribe glitch by keeping the hate bandwagon cycle alive.
Demons of the punjab, amazing episode. It takes you away, great episode on its own and great developement in graham and ryan's relationship. The battle of ranskoor av kolos, really great ideas, horrible mess of an execution, on all fronts (characters, story etc.). I hate kerblam for a bunch of reasons, I don't like the tsurange conundrum, I don't remember 95% of what happened in the witch finders, I strongly dislike the arachnids episode. Rosa I generally didn't care for the villain and the whole episode kinda fell flat for me. The ghost monument I just didn't care for at all (thought it was a bit boring) and the woman who fell to earth I just found very weird and didn't like the ending. Over all I really liked how it looked visually (most of the time. Tim shaw's space fig just looked bad) and while the music wasn't too memorable to me that also means it wasn't so bad that it was memorable so not a bad thing imo. And that was my unasked for short review for all of series 11 based mostly on personal opinions.
I know i am late to this video. When it first came out I didn't like Chris Chibnall's writing. I find it more boring than the other writers of new who. I don't think it is bad, or worse than classic who (which I haven't finished watching). I have now watched all of the 13th era 4 times and decided... that it is still kind of boring. I do like the flux, even though it is a mess, because it just isn't as boring. And Jodie Whittaker squeezed water out of stone with the role, as she was the one keeping it interesting enough to watch 4 times.
@@dwfan91- Thankyou. Having thought even more about it, i think it is all the exposition. That was the issue i had with The Hungry Earth and Cold blood (I think that's what they are called)
Good video! Honestly I think you made a number a good points, I for one don't like the Chibnall era and will fully admit I've only watched about half of series 11, resolution(which I actually thought was decent), spyfall part one and then The Power of the Doctor. I still think for what I have watched the writing is not very good. I will say that as a Doctor Who fan the things that I don't like or things that make me angry I do tend to mellow out on given time. Maybe one day I'll give the Chibnall era another chance. I will say it's funny being a Doctor Who fan though, I walked away from the specials finding some enjoyment but ultimately underwhelmed feeling like the show might not be for me anymore then 3 months later wondering when the blu-ray set is coming out in North America.
Look i get where you're coming from and I also believe there is some good value in the era, but like saying the people who didn't enjoy it just didn't watch it is just not true, cos I watched every episode as they came out and sometimes go back to revisit them but I still think there is a whole lot of issues present, Orphan 55 was an incredibly boring episode at best. Series 11 having no returning villains isn't an issue, its the villains that we got instead, there was Tim Shaw who was an interesting villain in episode 1 but the payoff to what the series was clearly leading up to the stenza being the big bad was underwhelming to put it lightly, when the hight of the series is the bloody pting you know theres a problem. I'm not even going to bring the timeless child into this cos we've all had enough hearing about it so i'll spare you all
Hope you all enjoy the video! This one's a little different- but the copyright issues are the same as always. Third time's the charm! I'll be back to be posting regularly from here on out so don't forget to leave a like and subscribe gamers
Currently got copyright on my hitlist, in the death note and shi
it's as if they have a vendetta against you specifically
39: 00 the USA has Charity Shops ( i think ) . We have "thrift stores" which support charities ( Salvation Army, goodwill other smaller ones )
WHAT? WHAT? WHAT?
"America doesn't have charity shops"? WHERE did you hear this complete load of 💩?! I've got 5 or more in less than a mile from my house! Some are religious or the same you have, like Salvation Army, St.Vincent DePaul & Catholic Charities. Others are community-oriented, like Goodwill, or Veteran-oriented, like D.A.V., or even a combo of for-profit & charity-ish, like Savers! (yes, the punctuation is part of their official name), which benefits Boys & Girl Scouts (aka Girl Guides; I forget what the UK name is for Cub Scouts/Boy Scouts).
In fact, if not for charity shops, most early DW fan costumes wouldn't have existed. In fact, fan films that utilized original characters of The Doctor in US fan films routinely contained scenes of them getting their look from a charity shop, many times as a promotional trade for the shop's assistance in making the film by supplying everything from costumes, props, set decorations (or entire sets/shooting locations) and, in at least one instance that I know of, the video camera used to shoot the fan film itself!
I know what you mean about the 80's gatekeeper intelligence, particularly amongst the US fans of that era who mistakenly believe themselves to be the official "original fans" in the country. That would actually be MY group, the ones who got to see a package made up of the early Jon Pertwee/UNIT serials, sans Spearhead From Space, that ended just before The Three Doctors 10th Anniversary special. As both of those serials referenced previous Doctors, it was thought the rest of the serials could make up a series that could more easily stand on their own and were sold alongside the original US syndication run of other BBC programs for the fledgling network, including Monty Python's Flying Circus, The Goodies, Upstairs/Downstairs, I,Claudius and other UK programs that helped shape the image of US's first (and, so far, only) public television broadcaster. PBS tried to emulate the BBC as much as they possibly could, particularly with their news coverage, an image they continue to try and maintain to this day, regardless of what individual opinions their viewers might have of their foreign counterparts or their native network levels of coverage and/or biases.
Wandering a little further into the weeds here, PBS of that period had a much more independent attitude and for some reason were given a high degree of latitude regarding what they put on the air. They were sort of purists and amazingly, they got away with it. They wouldn't censor news footage or any television programs or films they aired. This was interesting because some of that programming seriously crossed the line of what was considered acceptable for broadcast then and now. Much of that BBC content contained swearing and nudity, content that went out untouched back then. whether that was because they were just not notified (or at least they could claim they were unaware of) potentially offending content, they'd get the benefit of the doubt. It should be noted that the complaints about a National Public Radio affiliate running George Carlin's Words You Can't Say on Television unedited was in 1972 while Python began airing on local PBS affiliates in 1974. Because of the immense popularity of Flying Circus and the not-inconsiderable amount of pledge fund money the series generated, my local PBS affiliate, KDIN, aired an unedited print of Monty Python and the Holy Grail in late 1975/early 1976. KDIN in Des Moines, Iowa, was (and still is) the flagship station for the Iowa Public Broadcasting Network so this didn't just run in one city in the Midwest, it was simulcast across the entire State of Iowa as part of the network's regular financial pledge drive. Holy Grail proved to be so popular that a pledge drive goal was set that would guarantee a second airing of the film was reached within minutes of being announced. To my knowledge, the broadcasts generated no complaints to the FCC, despite documented incidents of children below the age of 16 viewing the film, like the series that spawned it. As many as 15 of those children were in my bedroom for both broadcasts of the film.
I mention this because now, the network is so neutered that they not only censor every little "shit" or "piss" that might be uttered in dialogue but they oftentimes blur nudity in paintings in the background that's so visually jarring that it's hard to pay attention to what's going on. Worse yet, if you pay them to be able to access their programming library online, a truly inexpensive fee that would be the best deal in online streaming if not for the fact they censor that content as well. I mean, couldn't you at least give us an option? They have a PBS Kids section so I would assume they believe that the adult programming is being viewed by, well, ADULTS.
There's also an incorrect narrative that the Pertwee series of Doctor Who wasn't well received in the US and that it was only the act of the Gods on high bestowing the holy Tom Baker series in its place that saw the dawn of the true fans.
This, of course, is complete bollocks.
In Iowa, the Pertwee package of episodes ran 6 times/week. It had a daily slot Monday-Friday that was very popular as well an additional slot on Wednesdays. The Wednesday timeslot was its original original home where it ran as part of a 5-day rotation of foreign half hour programs. Most of these were comedies and included the original location for Monty Python's Flying Circus, The Goodies, The Paul Hogan Show from Australia (a series that pre-dates Crocodile Dundee by at least a decade and seriously deserves some RUclips attention).
Flying Circus, Doctor Who & The Goodies were all promoted to Mon-Fri stripped timeslots but also continued to occupy their original weekly time slots, all three series continuing to run in apparent broadcast order, which contradicts the information presented.
In the case of Doctor Who, this resulted in occasions where the earlier Wednesday episode would be the episode previous to the M-F daily episode running later in the evening. Other dates would see the same episode running in both slots or the two Wednesday episodes running in the reverse order. It continued to run this way until it disappeared one night in the cold darkness without warning or explanation. It was with the same amount of advanced announcement that saw Doctor Who suddenly appear back on the schedule, right back in its old daily timeslot. We were really excited and hoped that we'd not only see the return of favorite episode but that we'd see new stories of our fancy-dressed alien scientist and his daft girl companion.
Imagine how we felt when the titles ran and the first thing we got to see was the Doctor die for some reason, to be replaced with whatever the hell this guy was supposed to be. I was on the phone the next day with the station, trying to find out what the hell was going on here.
The station had no clue. As a kind of apology, the station sent me the entire media kit and sales information Time-Life had sent them. I still have it.
The sales brochure had phone numbers for people at Time-Life so I started making phone calls. This was the start of a telephone adventure that would see me running up my parent's with calls all over the country, then to England, where I wound up speaking with Graham Williams, Douglas Adams, and several people who were fans then and run the series now in various capacities.
This post has gone on far too long and I'm not even sure what the original point I was going to make before I got swallowed by the weeds, far more than knee-deep in the Who-plah. So I'm just gonna end it and leave this here for anyone whose interested.
Thank you and goodnight.
KJB
WELL, THAT'S ALRIGHT THEN!
me melon balling my eyes out because doctor who has been declared "dead forever" for the 5th time this week:
bawling
@@prettyoriginalnameprettyor7506 no I'm melon balling my eyes out cuz i dont wanna see that sh- any more
my god this hits so deep i've seen too much of this 😭 never read the comment section on the doctor who official youtube channel
@@tzarg Real
I think it was RTD who said it was dead, now he's just become another necrophile
finally, someone who actually LIKES the show
they do call me the dwfan91 for a reason🫡
the fandom in a nutshell: oh, you've redecorated! i don't like it.
What will make them say"You've redecorated, I really like it"
Oh yeah? You never do!
I got my grandparents to watch Doctor Who from An Unearthly Child right up to The Hand of Fear (there's no real reason why we stopped there, I think it was just because we were all just kind of getting sick of it, and I was growing up, and I figured Sarah Jane's exit isn't the worst of hiatus moments).
Point is, I remember when we watched the end of Planet of the Daleks, and It never really dawned on me that this was the first time The Doctor manages to pilot the TARDIS correctly, until both my grandma and grandpa screamed at the same time:
"YOU MEAN HE CAN FLY IT NOW?!"
LMAO that is amazing
‘They fly now?’
‘They fly now!’
@@maegor-targaryengod damn it I was gonna reply this exact same comment this community shares one single brain cell 💀
Nothing like sitting by the fireplace and watching dwfan91
nothing like drinking my cup of tea while reading a comment from dsdots :)
@@dwfan91- nothing like liking a dwfan91 comment as a means of procrastination
Nothing like snogging Madame de Pompadour and watching dwfan91
The one thing I disliked about some of Jodies episodes was:
She wouldn't walk into a room and just take charge like the previous Doctors. She had to work to get people to listen to her. Now I know that was a choice to show how us women need to work to get recognition etc etc, but I felt the Doctor should be above that.
There's literally a scene in Silence in the Library. The doctor has known these people for minutes. He then tells someone to do something. The guy starts doing it. Some else asks "what're you doing that for?" " cos he told me to" the Doctor remarks " spooky isn't it? ". That just sums the doctors ability to control whole rooms of people.
That was really my only big problem with Jodies era. Did it completely ruin my enjoyment of it? No. I still had fun watching it, and that's what it's all about in the end.
i definitely get why you can see that as a deterrent to enjoying the era as a whole, but i also feel like you hit the nail on the head with the "that was a choice to show how us women need to work to get recognition" comment. as long as the doctor sticks around earth, especially in historical settings, its gonna be way less likely for people to see her as The Leader in a situation. shes a bubbly yet socially awkward blonde woman, while Ten was a tall, british (estuary accent to be specific) man who could demand a room with his frequent arrogance (no hate). It seems like a very natural process for both individually, and it makes me appreciate the episodes where she does have that leadership role immediately more satisfactory (TWWFTE, It Takes You Away, Eve of the Daleks)
Just started the video and already fist punching the air- loved Capaldi so much when his run began. So glad people are ready to celebrate him. Is it perfect? No, but it's peak Who for me. I hope in time people will view Whitaker the same way 💗
It was perfect in its own way🙏
Capaldi had the worst companion. Fred was such a troll sidekick.
I was just n denial for a long time but Peter Capaldi is my favourite doctor. Whittaker was let down by unfortunately weak writing but she as a doctor was fantastic and very fresh, which was needed.
There's so much value in knowing why someone loves something, coz it can be a window to learning to love it too. Learning why someone hates something is much less valuable in that way.
You actually made we rewatch all of the 13th Doctors run awhile back i’d always liked series 11 and flux but i was a huge timeless child hater but you bought me back to the light and now i quiet enjoy series 12 thank you dwfan91 you are a true hero
🙏🙏
Genuinely could not agree more. This video is such a relief.
I just rewatched all of NuWho while binging some of the older serials and it's like: Heartbreaking news, everyone: It's. . . it's all good. It's all pretty consistent, excellent TV. All the Doctors and companions are enjoyable and dynamic. Episodes remain unique and high quality with very little discernible departures. I had a blast.
As a 13th doctor fan I cannot wait for the Renaissance
I liked her, but Wide Blue Yonder was a massive return to form
Same here. It's always good to see a renewed appreciation for each Doctor.
we do have charity shops in america 😭 they’re just called thrift stores or secondhand stores here
tbf thrift shops are different, we have both over here
Except at USA thrift stores the profits don't go to charity.
The profits go to the members of the Goodwill family, consisting of. Janet Goodwill and her 7 kids @@UranusMcVitieFish-yd7oq
@@UranusMcVitieFish-yd7oqsome do, but they tend to be very local
@@dwfan91- What’s the difference? I think we just use the same name for non-profit and for-profit thrift shops.
My god I remember the Hell Bent hate. Funny how the script has flipped since then among everyone. Great vid.
wait people hated it??? (note i watched it in isolation on my own without fandom interaction..and made everyone around me watch it)
@@ohdarah yep. People swore it was one of the worst, more disappointing episodes of DW to ever air. It was genuine group-think. So dumb.
@@issh0 oh man. well, glad people are wising up now.
I loved the Heaven Sent / Hell Bent episodes. I don't recall anyone disliking it at the time either, and I am very alive to these things.
@@Saltybuher My experience was that people loved Heaven Sent and hated Hell Bent. Wrap your head around that one.
You wanna know the moment I began liking you?
When you said you didn't enjoy the melodrama between 10 and Rose because THANK YOUUUUUU honestly. I have been fighting friends over Rose so much, because everyone tells me "bUt iT's tHe tRaGeDy" and goddamn I am sooooo over it. I am a very new fan, as in I literally began watching Doctor Who last year in December and spent most of my vacations simply binge-watching it, and honestly it has all been enjoyable.
Has it been perfect? No, not at all, but I've never come out of an episode saying "well that was a waste of time"
Honestly watching it all has been amazing, and nearing Jodie, I'm getting quite exited, and of course once I finish nuwho, I will watch as much of Classic as I can get in my hands. It's a lot but I'm just so exited to learn more.
I just really love this series
I never liked Rose. Not in her titular episode, not in , not when we finally got rid of her and certainly not the times we kept bringing her back. I was so happy when I found out we were getting Donna and nothing of Rose when Tennant returned. Finally, Tennant's Doctor relieved of whining over the little blonde twit that made Jo Grant look like the General Manager of MENSA.
Did I mention I don't like Rose?
@@akakjb thank youuuuu, honestly I just preferred Donna 100%, Rose always felt static. Yes she saved the Doctor quite a few times but it always felt that the Doctor was always kinda babysitting her, while Donna forced the Doctor to grow because of how much she always challenged his choices, and viceversa.
Honestly Donna and ten are siblings, and the tragedy of Donna being forced to forget everything in my opinion is far more tragic than the separation between the Doctor and Rose.
I just love me a good sibling dynamic
@@chaostreeorsomething3586She was the first companion of the First New Era (I guess we're starting the Second New Era with Ncuti Gatwa) that wasn't tripping over her panties over the Doctor. It's really weird but my life strangely echoed what was going on with Doctor Who from the first episode of the reboot in 2005. I was going through major trauma that was coupled with severe PTSD so I really understood the Doctor when that series launched. When the regeneration happened, some things had kind of turned for me and I made the mistake of thinking that this traumatic series of events that culminated in a dramatic resolution of sorts was the ending and I'd put everything behind me.
But it doesn't work like that. Slowly, the cracks began to show and a bad evening or morning became a bad day which became a bad week...things started to spiral a bit...just like they were for Doctor #10. By the time we reach the end of his run, it's obvious that he's really not okay and neither was I.
I won't go through everything but suffice it to say that this continued all the way through Whittaker's run. In many ways, some of it wound up hitting the closest to home. aWith the 60th specials where we get revisit who we thought we were, back when we were 'fixed' so many years ago,. Turns out that some things weren't meant to be 'fixed'; they were meant to be let go of. It was time to let that part of me rest and enjoy a form of retirement. The person I was is still brilliant and shows up from time to time when necessary. But overall, today is for who I am now and that person kicks some serious ass.
Wow, sorry for using this as an impromptu therapy session but i think I'll go ahead and leave it over here just in case any random passerby might be able to get something out it.
I think relationships with the doctor, because of his age and the fact that he doesn't look or act that age, are extremely hard to get right without getting creepy. My rule of thumb is, if you could see the characters together even with the 1st incarnation, then it's OK. Rose with William Hartnell would b absolutely disgusting. And that's 10 lifetimes younger! But River and Hartnell? I could absolutely see, I eat that shit up. So River x Doctor is much more entertaining to me. Yaz is interesting, because she discovers her own sexuality through her love for the doctor, and that's something I can really relate to as a lesbian myself. But the Doctor loving Yaz back feels wrong. William Hartnell being in love with Yaz would be really creepy.
@@akakjb People complain that Adric is the worst companion but I'd say it's definitely Rose.
Side note here, I wish both Akinola and Gold would have reused motifs or pieces of music from classic who. They can be reorchastrated to fit the style of music at the time, I just want to hear them again.
I mean Akinola’s Master’s theme sounds a bit like the Sea Devils soundtrack
Segun Akinola did reuse motifs from Gold but not much from Classic
funny enough, Gold's Cyberman leitmotif sounds like it could have been derived from the beginning of their theme in "The Tenth Planet."
but yeah, more musical continuity would be great across the board. e.g. Akinola's Cyberman theme felt like just a backing. Obviously that was setup for the cybermasters scene, which was (musically) incredible. But before then, it would've been so easy to incorporate the Gold or Revenge theme as the melody.
Honestly, I'd be ok with Gold leaving whenever, as long as his themes stay this time
@@dwfan91- really? I was listening for Gold's leitmotifs whenever recurring villains showed up. Didn't hear any
@@cement_eater The Cybermen Theme has the Murray Gold 'dunanana' (i dont know how else to say it) when it gets quieter
"The Music of Doctor Who" would be a classic dwfan91 video, i love it
The same fans who criticized Clara for her actions towards the new Doctor in deep breath are the same ones who hated Matt Smith when he took over Tennant, I understand your points 😂
I really like the Capaldi era (writing of several episodes aside, lol) because Peter Capaldi looks just like my dad. Like, EXACTLY like him. So it was fun to imagine my extremely serious father who's told maybe 6 jokes since 2015 dealing with all the crap 12 had to go through.
I even tried to use pics of Peter Capaldi as the doctor to try to convince my dad to embrace his curly hair and grow it out a little, still working on that one!
When i watched the chibnall era on broadcast, I didn't think much of it. I liked it, but I guess I kinda dissociated with it cuz I realized I didn't even remember half of the episodes. Then I watched the classic era and loved it. I got a taste of a bunch of different styles and eras and takes and showrunners, and I rewatched the entire whittaker era in a binge. I loved it. I loved it a lot.
Honestly who is such a fun thing to do rewatches for, especially the classic show, very different compared to modern but very lovely and as a fan of slow burns, definitely my preferred cup of tea. Glad you came out with an enjoyment of all those Eras!
@@randomjoke69667 I came to realize that I literally just love all of Doctor Who. I liked the bloody Twin Dilemma. Vengence on Varos is peak 80s. Doctor who is less of a show and more of a crazy rollercoaster ride that takes you to so many different places and all of them are good.
@@ItsMeGPZ While personally I wouldnt go as far on saying I agree with that, I do however understand and really appreciate that you feel this way! That's very awesome and nobody can take that away from you, Besides any love for 6 or classic is very good in my Books! Honestly a goated way of thinking!
I've always said that Jodie's era will be more appreciated in retrospect, and we're already started to see it which your comment proves and I love that!
@@friendlyotaku9525Confirmation bias.
In Rosa, the fact that Krasko is underdeveloped IS the point. Not all racists have a Dalek masterplan. Mostly they're just people. Racism isn't an external threat, it's a shitty part of humanity.
Just because that's the point doesn't mean it's compelling. Just look at the newest episode, I think that handled a racist antagonist a lot better than Rosa.
@@cannonbyrd1755 Dot and Bubble did an excellent job at portraying racist attitudes, but to call Lindy or her friends the antagonists of that episode is robbing it of its nuance.
I find Rosa a very compelling episode because of her story. Overloading it with a villain that is overly arch would feel somehow like it would trivialise it too much.
@@stark_harshly I do think Rosa is a good episode, I just think the villain is the weakest part of that episode. And yeah I guess Lindy isn't the antagonist, but in the same way she kind of is once we change perspectives from her to the doctor.
i think capaldi really was the modern doctor that was done dirtiest by the scripts provided to him. i feel like moffat’s writing very rarely fully exploited what capaldi was capable of.
Strongly disagree, I think this applies to Jodie.
@@andrescarnederes2295 Absolutely. Whittaker had so much potential that was squandered, partly because of trying to pander to the "fans" who had been all for the consideration of a female Doctor for decades until they got one. It was like they expected the same character as before and for everyone to ignore the obvious lady bits & the impact that would have on a standard DOCTOR WHO story. I feel it wasn't explored enough and that they left a lot of good story potential on the table. We'll see how RTD handles the racial aspects of Gatwa's Doctor in the new series.
I agree with this for both capaldi and Jodie tbh. I don’t think the way Moffat saw the doctor aligned with how capaldi saw and performed the doctor a lot of the time (until maybe the Bill and Nardole season). I could almost say the same about the way he wrote 11 sometimes too, but also Matt was younger and more malleable to the scripts he got
@@ae0ns Moffat is easily the writer who understands the character of The Doctor the most. His characterization of 11 and 12 is the peak of the character from an objective perspective.
@@user-fu7zf4ck9z I half agree with this for 12s sake lol but that’s an interesting take for sure
I for one, am happy to find another Demons of Punjab defender, as i understand, there are dozens of us.
I don't like Chibnall, but Demons of Punjab is one of the few good episodes of those three seasons, for sure. I quite liked it.
its my favorite series 11 episode
I really liked that one 💖
Tbh I never realised the ep had such hate I loved it I was moved to tears
IT'S SO GOOD
I wanna point out at around 44:00 you talk about the whole ‘lonely god’ thing compared to the timeless child. While that is a valid point I think the reason why myself and so many others take issue with it is because it feels as though the Doctor earned that title after hundreds of thousands of years, he became quite literally a living legend. The impact of him going from bashing a cave mans head in to cherishing all life and actively seeking out danger to ‘play his role’ feels so less inspiring if he was just born into being ‘the main character’.
I actually really enjoyed series 13 on broadcast, and I was hit by waves of confusion by my mates who had watched about 4 episodes of series 11
About 4 episode's? That's like 66% of the series lmao
@@Musydid911 yeah but none of them gave series 12 or 13 a chance
@@Musydid911
4/10 =/= 66%
@@brewster_4 what percentage is 4 out of 6
@@Musydid911
"my mates who had watched about 4 episodes of series 11"
Seires 11 had 10 episode not including the special Resolution. They had watched 4 out of the ten episodes of the series. This means they watched 4/10 of the series or 40% of the series. I didn't think I'd have to explain this.
Thanks for this, 13 is my favorite Doctor :)
Nice to hear some love for Woman who fell to Erath. Honestly think it's a sevearly underated first episode. I'm not the biggest fan of series 11 tbh, I think 12 and Flux are better in ways but I'm not afraid to admit there are some episodes I really enjoy in series 11. Also I agree about Tzim Sha, He's great, that speech he delivers at the end of the finale whilst the doctor is running away is epic.
I'll admit, I used to be one of those who didn't like Capaldi's era at first. But when it came to his last series my opinion changed.
I've also been rewatching his era and my opinions on a lot of his episodes have changed for the better.
I realised that he may not be my favourite Doctor but his era had a good arc.
I felt similar with Smith during his first two series but warmed to him during his final series.
Although that was due to me having a strong empathy for 10 and David's departure hit me hard.
So when it came to Jodie's era I wanted to go in optimistic. I didn't want to give in to new showrunner/Doctor bias. I gave her first outing a go. It was okay, the writing clearly was the main issue.
There are a few gems of episodes in her era, Haunting of Villa Diodati (hope I spelt that right) is the highlight for me.
I will concede Jodie's era did have great VFX, possibly the best we've had so far. I just wished the writing was better.
Going into Ncuti's era I was elated at RTD's return and despite Tennant's caretaker Doctor I was more excited to see Ncuti's debut and so far I've not been disappointed.
Doctor Who I think is unique in the way a fine whisky is. The more an era matures and enough time passes, it improves in its taste than the newest batch would.
I think one of the biggest problems is channels that claim they are fans of the show just to release a video critising literally any bad press, viewing figures, latest released episode or series or comments the showrunners/actors make.
Channels that openly spew hate instead of providing proper criticism and scrutiny.
Thank you so much for talking about this. I'm so, so tired of people online getting irrationally angry about Chibnall stuff or the RTD2 specials of late for really no good reason. You're absolutely right to notice that the Capaldi era is suddenly loved now despite it being hated back in the day. It would be nice if people could just try to enjoy something instead of trying to hate it (sometimes without watching it)
Haven’t finished the video yet, just gotten to where you start talking about The Timeless Child, but I just wanted to say something about that.
I don’t think it’s a big deal. I think it’s perfectly fine. I like the idea behind it, and I think it actually helps broaden the mystery of the Doctor and give the show more room to grow. What didn’t we know about the Doctor before TTC? Quite a lot! What don’t we know about the Doctor after TTC? Well, we know that the Doctor was adopted by Tecteun, who performed experiments, and that the Doctor was part of a special force called Division, and beyond that, there’s quite a lot we still don’t know, and I would argue, there’s even MORE room for what we don’t know. We don’t know exactly what happened in Division, or before that, or even what may have happened between that and An Unearthly Child. It gives more room for future writers to have blanks that they can fill in.
In 2027 we’ll all be looking back at the ‘jodie era’ and especially flux saying ‘Actually, this wasn’t that bad, and ‘we were really harsh on it.’
Recently I rewatched the Timeless Children episode and I actually quite enjoyed it. This is the way these things go
So true, you get it man
This comment is delicious as a colossal FLUX fan I can't wait for that day
That is always the plan.... For future generations. If an alien came to Earth, beyond Star Trek and Star Wars Doctor who would be the one series I believe a peaceful race might enjoy
TBH, my expectation is I'll still be loving it as unintentional comedy for it's charmingly bizarre character dialogue and characterization as I do with early 80's Who.
Because as someone relatively immune to the bandwagon effect, and someone who has been kinda shit on for daring to compare Whitaker and Davison... The early JNT and Chibnall eras are pretty much the same take on the show, and those two Doctors are very much the same characterization. Questionable moral choices and all...
The Fam is very similar to Nyssa Tegan and Adric... You have the one that kinda fades into the background despite having massive dramatic potential (Nyssa and Ryan) the character that is often used comically but has a twinge of tragedy (Adric and Graham), and the relatively grounded one (Tegan and Yaz)... None of which are characterized very well in series... Big Finish audios for 13 are gonna be so cathartic for patching that up...
Both eras of the show got increasingly dependant on treating the fans for quick ratings boosts every season often leading to bad stories (Arc of Infinity, Warriors of the Deep, The Timeless Children, Revolution of the Daleks, etc)
And as specific as it is, the show creating a giant spectacle drama where half the universe gets irreversably destroyed and despite that not following up on the consequences in any meaningful way... (Logopolis and Flux, and I'm willing to bet if the episode count hadn't been lowered it would have been Dhawan's master doing the "people of the universe" quote...)
I think both of these eras are bad in some pretty notable ways... I also think time heals all wounds and both of them are unintentionally hillarious with the occasional spots of brilliance. And some people seem to genuinely think the Fifth Doctor's era is great, so maybe 13 will be highly regarded...
@@nodatastored684Heh... You may not know how right you are...
I will always maintain that The Doctor is the most universally relatable main protagonist humanity has ever made in spite of looking identical to a human.
I really wish that the Thijarians returned to watch over 13’s death in PotD. It’d be a great way to tie her era together, almost like the Ood’s presence in 10’s regeneration scene
I won’t argue that The Doctor didn’t become a super special God-like being quite early in the show, however I always appreciated the idea that anyone from any background could reach that level by learning and growing through their experiences.
Honestly, The Timeless Child doesn’t take that away from the 1st Doctor really thinking about it. I don’t know how else to summarize how I feel except to say that the additional lore feels tacky and unnecessary.
I agree
What a great video! I feel this way a lot too! Like I stopped watching Doctor Who during Matt Smith. And I started up again last year and when I got to Peter Capaldi, I was like oh my God I love him. Why did young me deny me such great doctor who! Sometimes all the fan stuff makes me feel like I’m missing something. But if missing something allows me to have a good time with a show that I like it’s fine with me
In the case of Jodie Whittaker, I like her as an actress. I like her portrayal of the doctor. I got about halfway through her first season on two seperate occasions. But I couldn’t handle the writing. I felt it was all very on the nose. Something about the writing waa just. Not it for me.
Although listening to your review I might have to give it a third try.
I don't think American's have a problem with the accents. I didn't watch it myself, but Jodie was on Broadchurch, which was very popular in the US. It even won at American award shows. Believe me, we get plenty of British TV here and different British accents and I don't see that as being a reason people hated 13. Honestly, from what I see from the fans that hate 13, it's because the doctor was a woman. It's really that clear and if you read comments on Dr. Who videos you will always come across, "the show went downhill when they made the doctor a chick." Stupid as hell, but I think that's really the biggest reason for all the hate.
As for charity shops, many have already pointed out that we have plenty of them in the US. We just don't call them charity shops. Honestly "Goodwill," while the name of an actual chain of charity shops, is what my family has used to describe any kind of charity shop. There are places like Savers, the Salvation Army, and then local shops that are unique to each town/city. My whole childhood was spent getting clothes from charity shops in the US, but not once did anyone ever call them charity shops even though most of them are actual registered charities. Loved the video and looking forward to watching more from you!
For me I think it's mainly the performances of the main cast.
As you mentioned every series of Doctor Who has had it's fair share of bad scripts, some more than others.
But usually whoever is cast as the Doctor/Companion at the time, can just carry that bad script to a degree and I can still enjoy there performance, even in a script that's not great.
Jodie as the Doctor just never worked for me. Hard to pinpoint exactly why and it's going to feel like a cop out answer but she doesn't feel very "Doctory" to me lmao. Not a fan of the way she delivers most of her dialogue and I think the exact same scripts, with someone else in the lead could of been much better.
As for companions, I think this without a doubt is the weakest of the NewWho era. Ryan and Yas to me are straight terrible outside of maybe a few moments here or there. Graham for me like most people is my favourite and in large part I feel he just stands out in comparison to Ryan and Yas, because Bradley Walsh can act. It feels like he's actually trying.
Long story short, this era for me was the first time in NewWho at least that the cast, was mis cast and I just can't get into the performances, I watched the whole era 3 times between Power of the Doctor and the 60th too and it just didn't connect :(
PS. Your content is genuinely fire bro, I disagree with alot of your takes but still love the videos haha!
I like genuinely being able to talk with people about what they like/didn't like about certain parts of dr who. When people get specific and actually say what they think it's so much more interesting than "bad writing init." Thanks for the comment man!
@@dwfan91- I think that's why so many of us have gravitated towards your channel and content brother.
You've created a space where it feels like you can start a dialogue with other passionate fans, where opinions may differ but it doesn't turn into a screaming match and petty insults. (Apart from the odd weirdo but that's inevitable lmao)
You should be real proud of what you're doing here man genuinely, look forward to the next upload!
@CrikeyItsDan I completely agree with what you said about the era. There was just something lacking in Jodie's performance. Like she was lacking a certain gravitas that all the others had when delivering speeches and whatnot. I found it hard to put my finger on what it was, but i never got into the performance. I was disappointed as well. Jodie is from really nearby to me, and I love seeing someone local do good, and was looking forward to her in the role, but just didn't hit.
The 3 companions really was too many to have all the time. I think it just gave her even less opportunity to shine, when she was floundering anyway.
THANK GOD PEAK HAS RETURN
WE'RE BACK
I got into the show right when the 50th was happening and Capaldi got announced just as I was sort of getting used to Matt Smith and David Tennant, and being like who is this old guy he's not doctor who this is gonna be boring and horrible, and I hated the idea of him right away, fast forward a few years later and I was deep into series 10 and Capaldi had become my favorite Doctor by then, like mans on my current pfp it's kinda ridiculous in hindsight how much of a massive one eighty I had on him as the Doctor.
39:35 We have thrift stores which I think are the same thing as charity shops (ie people donate the clothes and appliances they don't want or need and the places sell them at low prices) The one that I know best is called Goodwill, but there are lots of local ones everywhere as well.
Yeah, as an American, I totally related to the doctor in the charity shop scene because of shopping throughout my life in thrift stores. We have tons of them.
I'll say, I generally liked the Chibby Era but I don't like the way he introduced these huge world shattering revelations and then... did nothing with them. We finally got back Gallifrey and Chibby destroys it again for shock value. I was willing to let the Timeless Child twist do its thing but then they don't do anything with it the next season...
Goated ass video once again and I just 100 percent agree that just mindless hate when you haven’t even formed the opinion yourself is just so stupid I remember when I was watching the chibnal era I would sometimes look at the reviews for it on youtube and it was just so dumb in retrospect, I remember thinking I actually liked this episode and then I watched one review and felt like a dumbass
You're not alone! I saw this happening to so many people!
Also one very random thing to add to what you said earlier in the vid when you were talking about things you didn’t like in each era I do really agree with you on of moffats insistence on domestic violence is really bad but just to add to that is how with moffat some scenes were just really creepy like on that comes to mind is the crimson horror when 11 just kissed jenny for like 5 seconds unprompted which just made me uncomfortable and I thought creepy also in time of the doctor when the doctor is naked and then going to the church naked and clara doesn’t really want to is just first of all cringe and its weird I find that moffat just makes things to adult for no reason its kinda hard explain but yeah, also 11 saying sexy like a billion times there’s probably more examples of this but those were just on the top of my head hopefully this wasn’t to ranty also once again goated video
doctor who more like Doctor woke am i right lads
so true😹
Doctor Them
You are right lad😂
Thanks lad
it was always woke
(tl;dr: i used to dunk on chibnall's era, and it wasn't until i repeated what i was saying to other people irl that i re-watched it and formed my own opinions. bandwagoning is bad folks, don't do it.)
i gotta be honest... i came around on the chibnall era. i watched series 11 and 12 initially all at once, then immediately after i watched "the fall of doctor who". i thought there was some good points in there, but didn't completely agree with everything said (and there was quite a bit of "this video sucks" from people who haven't watched it, which is always terrible). i didn't realize how much i had let it color my opinions on this era of the show until i tried to talk to my friends about the timeless child reveal.
look, i don't like the timeless child because it gives me 'chosen one' vibes from the dominance of mid young adult novels trying to be the next hunger games or divergent - i don't even *like* divergent, but the amount of books trying to be divergent felt never-ending. that's it! it's just that, and i'm pretty sure that's a me problem anyway. but the amount of people saying it "ruined" doctor who is ridiculous. this show is 60 years strong, nothing like a minorly mishandled reveal is gonna stop it. if that was all it took, it would've died out in the 60s.
but that's what i told people online. that's what i told my friends; that it ruined it. they weren't doctor who fans - that is gonna color their experience of watching it for the first time, if they ever decide to. so i was like "wtf just came outta my mouth?" i examined that feeling, i rewatched the episodes, and honestly? truthfully? it's good!
series 11 is good. i don't like rosa because it goes with the lie that all she contributed to the civil rights movement was refusing to move on that bus, but to be fair, where were they gonna fit that in? another me problem probably. it's good though! and rest of the series is mostly good! series 12 was a little more hit-or-miss with the returning villains (should've stuck to their guns for longer) but its highs are even higher! i love sacha's master so much, you have no idea. that man is genuinely terrifying. i say this as a "missy is my favorite master" fan: i'm glad they brought the master back. series 13 is the greatest car crash i've ever seen. yeah i'm a flux enjoyer now. also this whole era's cinematography is beautiful. i didn't like this era's tardis because despite the wide open space, having to dodge around those giant crystals made it feel claustrophobic to me? i dunno. but every time they have it in a wide shot i'm like "ohh i see the vision".
i say all this to say that this era isn't that bad. it's even good! i dream of the day i can say that outside of this comment section and not get dunked on by bots - or even other people who haven't done the work of re-examining it. for doctor who, this bandwagon was particularly bad, but i've been in fandom spaces for a while now, and it's not the worst i've seen. i made the mistake of thinking dw was immune to that sort of mob mentality. i know better now. i do better now. the chibnall era gave that to me. so hey, hate it all you want if you've actually seen it. if you've read all of this then thank you! if you still hate it i can't change your mind. but it's special to me, and it always will be.
(edit: misspelled sacha's name, i'm a fake fan /s)
THANK YOU for being such a breath of fresh air in the fandom! Seeing someone fairly enjoy the eras and episodes, I’m new to ur channel and videos so I was wincing in anticipation/fear when seeing the Chibnall era was approaching wondering if there was another person gunna shit on it, so glad not all fans r like that lol
nikola tesla's night of terror is actually so much fun. love the doctor and tesla's admiration for each other! the historical episodes in general were straight up bangers in this era, can't wait for people to celebrate that once the whittaker renaissance comes around lol
Well, I think I just found my new favourite DW RUclipsr. Someone who actually loves Doctor Who and gives it a shot instead of blindly hating on it.
0.01% guy here!
Watched EVERY episode (including missing eps via telesnap, recreations, and animations).
And listened to every bigfinish audio up until 2020. (I'll get to the rest sooner or later)
I love classic Who, But I love modern Who too!
Not every episode is great, but none suck.
we gotta stick together🤝
We got a time lord over here!
I always loved Peter capaldi, he had an actual arc and it was so good
bruh i got 14 minutes in and didn't realize that it was over an hour long. i love your videos bro
I think you mean it can't be overstated how much _Doctor Who_ you watch. I can understate it right now: You have only seen one episode ever. It's easy to understate it, in your case. :)
u got me
For me, being from Yorkshire, the characters being from Yorkshire and episodes being set here was one of my favourite parts of the Chibnall era. The same with the Flux episodes set in Liverpool. It was nice to see Doctor Who in the North, made the characters more relatable to me. I never even considered that the accents could be a barrier, as compared to most people I know, the accents are not that thick 😂
I was speaking with some americans and they said they couldn't understand anything was being said. They also said that Peter Capaldi's accent was too thick as well so that goes to show you something😂
@@dwfan91- If Peter Capaldi's accent is too thick, they may have to start casting BBC presenters for the Americans to understand.
@@dwfan91-the *thick* of it
I'm a started-watching-when-Jon-Pertwee-took-over fan, and I have every episode, 1963 to Christmas 2017..
I wanted to see Peter Capaldi ever since I saw him in, 'Neverwhere' in 1996.
When it happened, I felt fully vindicated, and I stand by it ! Clara outstayed her run, but Bill was excelent.
It was like the 7th and Ace all over again.
I'm glad now to see other fans realizing what they missed.
The fact that you cannot accept anyone having legitime reasons for disliking 'Demons of the Punjab' is a little closed minded, to be honest. No matter how good you think it is, other people are allowed to disagree without that making them WRONG.
People are entitled to their wrong opinion.
@@grandsome1 As you prove.
Just wanna say that thanks to you, I gave the Jodie era a second chance and I thoroughly enjoyed myself. There are some Chibnalisms that I don’t vibe with, but there are Moffatisms I don’t vibe with either. I’m so glad u put me on and made me remember why I love this show so much and the conversations I’ve had with my dw fan friends are much more lively now that we’ve given the eps a chance and can discuss them for real ❤❤❤
I do wonder where you get some of the criticisms you push back against from here - places like Gallifrey Base or the Reddit communities have always loved Capaldi for example. Similarly I recall McGann being liked even while the movie itself was not. There are others I could mention but maybe its a twitter/Tumblr thing? Its certainly true that a lot of the time these people haven't watched it and I do think you give them a little too much credit here - its bad faith, and designed to be bad faith. How could a culture warrior fool be a part of fandom? I don't think 90% of these people ever were, ratings etc are just the excuse for the war.
I think you're totally spot on with the music though. If there was one way I'd describe Gold, its the word "manipulative". The guy brings out a full orchestra if someone's shoelaces come undone, telling you how to feel. Its very effective, but I don't care for that personally. In contrast when the music leaves the audience room to breathe and decide for themselves...everything feels flat to many of them? Weird, but OK.
I get them from my RUclips polls
@@dwfan91- Ah OK. I'm assuming there are indeed bots or whatever involved then, probably culture warrior proxies. RUclips comments are not exactly high quality.
Ill be honest, I wasn't paying attention to fandom in 2014, but I also didn't like series 8 at the time. Capaldi was just so different than 9, 10, and 11 that I didnt continue to watch after series 8 finished. I am also only now watching the classic series so I had no reference to doctors 1-8 and how they were. I picked up Doctor who again in 2020 when The Timeless Child hate made its way to me. I had no clue what was going on so I started at Series 8 again and watched up to The Woman Who Fell to Earth and got less that 30 minuets in because I was bored.
(Also I LOVED the Capaldi era after I finished it. I wasnt and am still not a big fan of Twice Upon a Time, even now having watched all of the First Doctors stories. If anything I like it less because of that)
I think it was probably a year later I watched TWWFTE all the way through and then all the way to The Timeless Child. Revolution of the Daleks wasnt available to me (without pirating) at the time and I dont think Flux had started so I stopped until Autumn of 2023 where I caught up again. I didnt hate Whittaker's era, though I do think its boring, but I actually like The Timeless Child and think it opens up a lot of interesting doors. Ive watched everything that has come out up to this point and plan to keep up with the show and in the meantime continue to watch the classic series in full as Im only up to series 9.
My hate or dislike was never a bandwagon though. It wasnt until December, when I rewatched the 2005 series from the beginning to series 11 that I actually liked Matt Smiths Doctor, and I remember that while his era was going people were huge fans of him (especially other girls and that confused me lol). Now im just excited to see where the series goes from here and I and I can truly say I love every actors interpretation of the Doctor (that I have seen) even if I dont enjoy all of their episodes
I like how half of the rebuttals are just “B-but… *I* hate thing… and that would make me wrong! I can’t be… wrong!”
I think the problem is the moral inconsistencies, the timeless child being WAY too game changing and confusing, and the weird and bad acting from supporting cast and villains. Also, the closeups start off well done, but as the era goes on, they become overused, even in situations where they add nothing to the scripts. This makes the direction feel off and the audience's proception of space within a scene hazy. I agree it is over hated, but it falls far shorter than any other era does for me.
I think the Chibnall era is the lesser of the three Doctor Who revival era, but a lot of the criticisms against it were overly harsh and incredibly unfair. Talking about Doctor Who became very unenjoyable back then. Also I still think series 11 is one of the better seasons of Doctor Who. Demons of the Punjab is my favorite historical episode, and yet I saw people tear it apart like it was trash. It left an incredibly bitter feeling in me. And contrast that with how people talk about RTD2 era, where people are praising the heck out of them while having a lot of the similar flaws to the bad Chibnall episodes, or having moments that people nitpicked the hell out of in Chibnall era episodes. The thing that really bothers me is just how the standards are being applied so unevenly. Anyways, glad someone talked about this because I genuinely hated the fandom at that point.
Regarding Timeless Children, I liked all the ideas of it, it made sense to me and what I knew of the Time Lords (they have always been bad), and recontextualizing the Doctor as an orphan was very interesting to me. I just think the poor execution, along with coupling it with a Cyberman finale made it an especially bad episode. Two finales in one episode, both finales incredibly underserved.
And yeah, 10th/Rose dynamic was incredibly obnoxious.
gotta hand it to you, I love how I can both agree and disagree with some of your takes yet still come back for more videos. This channel is super refreshing and you are crushing it mate! Alons-Y!
PS always loved capaldi since his announcement glad hes getting love now because for ages I thought I was going mad being the only one in my friend group who adored his take.
AYO american here! RAH RAH!! we def do have charity shops we just call them thrift shops such as salvation army and shit. I liked that the doctor had that scene honestly i have more complaints about what she found. ITS TOO CLEAN!! i am not a hater of jodies first season but the fit is bad. It is way too clean and calm.
She looked better in 12's clothes I'm just sayinng
@@dwfan91-amen 🙏🙏🙏
I think 13 should've gone for something vintage and bohemian, kind of halfway between what 4 had going on and 15's very '70s style.
7:37 I think a lot about this like A LOT. If Doctor Who fans hypothetically like really start hyping up a usually disliked classic Hartnell who episode I wonder if due to the fact most people havent watched it could he possible to gaslight casual Doctor Who fans into thinking its the holy grail of Peak Doctor Who content up there with Genesis.
WDYM disliked? The Gunfighters beats Heaven Sent!
The way the title is worded makes it sound like you hate both bandwagons and Doctor Who. And hating doctor who is the mark of a true fan
The worst part of Doctor Who bouncing around between streaming services is that I STILL haven't been able to watch 13's era. Amazon prime wont put past season 10 so I haven't even had a chance to form my own opinion, I've just heard all the bad reviews.
Babe wake up king dwfan91 posted a new video
The crazy thing is that Jodie’s run, especially her first season, was probably one of the more conservative leaning seasons. Multiple episodes saying that there’s nothing inherently wrong with “the system”, it just needs a little reform. There’s actually two episodes that I find have similar plots but very different responses; season 4’s Planet of the Ood and season 11’s kerblam episode. In the former, they take a strong stance against the slavery system and end up destroying it, in the latter they end up siding with the system of essential slavery and end up saying “the system is fine, people who are against the system is the problem. The system just needs a little reform”
I don't think Series 11 was "looking to good to be Doctor Who". I think it looked good, but to me, it didn't FEEL like Doctor Who. Which is odd considering that Jodie Whitaker was the Doctor immediately in my eyes. But the "not Doctor Who" feel did end by the end of Series 11.
I don't think Rosa was bad. I just feel like if you removed the villain from the story, it would change nothing. The villain felt so shoehorned in that I'm not even convinced that the original script had him.
Many of the criticisms of the Chibnal Era in my opinion is that many of the stories are good ideas, but I feel like they were executed poorly. They weren't bad, they were just "meh". Simply put, my criticism is lost potential.
The music may be what messed with my head. It was beautiful, but it just didn't sound like Doctor Who. But that's not a problem in my opinion. I liked the Chibnal Era.
0:50 To be honest, I just assumed you were a fan of Arthur's sister in the popular Children's TV show on CBBC/PBS. With Doctor Who being a side project.
Still waiting for your Mr Ratburn character breakdown ⌚👀
this is the best comment
I'm a very new Doctor Who fan, I haven't seen the classic series yet, but I caught up on the modern show in time to view the latest David Tennant specials and Christmas special as they came out. I own season 1 through 13 of the "new" show on DVD, my favorite era was definitely Russel T Davies, Matt Smith never quite clicked with me though I did like him in the part. I really liked Peter Capaldi but I will concede that a lot of his episodes were hit or miss. But Capaldi was so good in the role that I feel like he carried some of the worse episodes. I'd head for years about the Jodie Whittaker/Chibnall era, but I was determined to see it for myself. I was pleasantly surprised. It seemed clear to me that the people calling it woke hadn't seen the Capaldi era because it was pretty similar in that way. I thought season 11 was solid enough, I really liked season 12 though I have mixed feelings about how it effects the cannon (but it's not really a big deal. I thought Sacha Dhawan was great as the master. Season 13 really suffered from being made during caronavirus restrictions and wasn't very coherent in my opinion. I thought Jodie Whittaker's sendoff special was pretty good though. I actually disliked the return of Russell T Davies more than the Chibnall era so far. I thought the star beast was ok, but it could have been much better if it didn't get so bogged down on trying to upset people who didn't like the Chibnall era and I thought it really undermined one of my favorite Doctor Who arks. I was fine with them writing in a way for Donna to keep her memory but the fact it boiled down to "a male presenting timelord is too stupid and or ignorant to just let the energy go" was really unsatisfying. The wild blue yonder was good. I hated the toymaker episode, I thought Neal Patrick Harris was insufferable in the role. Bigeneration was a really odd choice imo, and if we never see the 10th/14th doctor again than idk what the point was (besides giving a version of the doctor a "happily ever after" sendoff). The church on ruby road didn't win me over. I'll keep watching and I'm sure it'll find its footing. I do prefer the generally more grounded camerawork of the first 4 seasons to the more cinematic look now, there's a charm to it and when done right it still hold up.
I agree, even in the darkest times, Peter Capaldi made every episode worth it to me. Honestly my goat
youre so real
I feel like I can't even express my opinions on certain aspects of the show without being 'unoriginal'
depends. I don't feel original when I say 'genesis of the daleks is good' but I still feel it. I think what matters is that you're not copying something word for word- make sure your opinions *are* your opinions and not just something you feel pressured or forced into believing👍
I think the most annoying thing about the timeless child twist is that it would be perfect for the master
That makes sense and I like it
Its weird, i disagree with a lot of what you say, not all of it just I think you generalize a bit too much. But I still enjoy hearing your opinion
I’ll not to do that so much in the future then :)
I may not like the Chibnall era, in fact I really dislike a lot of it, but I can honestly say I sat down and watched every episode because I never want to judge something without giving it an honest chance. There are some episodes I like, a lot of episodes I hate, and I'll probably never come around to loving it, but at least I know every opinion is my own.
It was actually the Chibnall era that allowed my teenaged self to fully break away from the right wing reactionary crowd that was becoming more and more radical every passing year. Seeing such an overblown reaction to such mediocre television, all the vitriol centered around the pettiest shit as opposed to the actual problems, made me realise that it wasn't a scene I was interested in being a part of anymore. And thank god I did because what a cess pool.
The goat has returned for another banger!
I respect the chibnall era but i find most the episodes boring and bad, but thats not to say i dislike it all, i especially enjoyed her third season, Eve of the daleks and Power Of The Doctor were great in my opinion.
Excellent video and some solid takes. I totally agree with the critique of bandwagons, and it certainly doesn't make sense to hate a show you haven't watched, but I was confused by the characterization of some critiques of the show especially the early Whitaker era, as well as some of the points you made in its favor. I confess I didn't watch much past series 11 as I didn't enjoy the show much anymore, but I have found most people think that Demons of the Punjab was one of the best episodes in that series. I can't offer criticism of the other episodes, as you've pointed out, but I do think that part of the show deserves much of the judgement it gets, if not the hate.
My biggest issue is with the doctor's characterization. Like in the very first episode, I grant that it has some fun doctor who-esque moments, but the one thing it doesn't do is show us who Jodie's Doctor is. She's definitely supposed to be the Doctor, but I don't think I can come up with any traits that distinguish her from the others. The best I can say is that she, for some strange reason, frequently lacks confidence in herself(except when the plot requires her to have it) and really doesn't seem to have a grip on the moral core of the character. Take Arachnids, the entire plot of Kerblam!, or her inability to articulate why "guns bad," as evidence for that point. I am sure only that the newer iterations are trying to satisfy expectations of who the doctor is so hard that they fail to capture the true qualities of the character.
Perhaps the later series or the recent regeneration have changed all of this. It's good for the show to evolve over time with different iterations, but I really felt like there was a lot of the core of what made the show good missing in recent times. Still, you've motivated me to have a glance at the recent Specials and maybe I'll have to finally delve into the classic seasons and see if they seem more to my taste.
Honestly, I'm still not a massive fan of the Capaldi Era. Series 10 is pretty great, but I dropped off hard with series 9 and even 8. Even now a days my Doctor Who marathons tend to slow down here because the episodes don't grip me in the same way Russell era or even Chibnal Era stories do.
I think most fans are re-evaluating Capaldi's era because it's not what the show is doing rn and distance is important for these things, Doctor Who fans are incredibly fickle and we struggle to vibe with the current eras
I gave up in series 9 but decided to try 10. 10 is a step up for the most part.
Yes yes, blah blah new thing hate, etc etc.
I NEED THAT ORCHESTRAL ARRANGEMENT OF THE CURSE OF FENRIC FINALE AT 21:45. Where is that from.
Also excellent video
I’m incredibly grateful for this video, seeing the double standard where fans rip apart things in the Chibnall era that would have been perfectly fine if they happened the same way under RTD or Moffat makes me want to tear my hair out. I like being able to criticize media I enjoy, and I like having good-faith critical discussions, but it’s immensely evident when someone hates the Chibnall era because they’re misogynistic or “anti-woke”. I’d easily say that Chibnall is my least favorite of the 3 show runners for New Who but the fact people on the hate bandwagon refuse to acknowledge the era has any merit is so, so frustrating.
RTD and Moffat were better. That's simply it, but of course, you have no real argument, and it's evident with people like you who have misogyny of the brain all day long anytime someone doesn't like the shit you do.
We do have thrift shops in the United States. I used to go in to Goodwill and walk out with ten dresses for $30. The prices are a little higher now, but not by much. We have Goodwill, the Salvation Army, and Threads, just in my town. I don't know what kind of ritzy (posh) Americans are making comments that these don't exist and only want to hear BBC newsreader accents.
Here's the way i recall seeing the chibnall/whittaker hate train barrel out of the station:
Them: the doctor cant be a woman! That will ruin the show!
Us: the show's creator Sydney Newman wanted the doctor to change into a woman. Since 1980 everyone involved with making the show has been publicly saying the next doctor could possibly be a woman.
Them: I dont have a problem with the doctor being a woman, i just hate them shoving all these sociopolitical messages down our throats!
Us: the show (classic & new) has always been political [numerous examples]. The pertwee years were particularly notorious for beating the audience over the head with messages.
Them: i dont have a problem with the messages or the female doctor, its just the writing is so bad!
That last argument cant really be disputed because its subjective, yet they act like its objective. Its kind of a nebulous rorshach test type of thing. People see what they want to see. And its what they are able to make others see. The original chibnall haters actually hated bc of their sexism and intolerance. Once they learned those werent valid reasons to hate, they made up the seemingly valid reason of "bad writing" and made a bunch of videos and posted a bunch of comments to convince others the writing is "bad" and before long, groupthink settled in. The influencers led the lemmings off the cliff.
I remain convinced if more people were more familiar with classic who, and had watched the chibnall era and formed their own opinions without going online to be told what to think, then the chibnall era would be more popular. Perhaps more highly respected than the rtd era.
The truth is, every writer/showrunner has their pros and cons, strengths and weaknesses. If a few people devoted a bunch of videos to explaining everything thats bad about rtd, then a lot of people who watch those videos would end up only seeing the bad about rtd and hating every one of his episodes. Then those people would in turn spread their hate with their own videos & comments
I feel like I’m being gaslit, it’s genuinely making me want to rewatch the Whittaker episodes to make sure about my own experience
maybe you should 🤯🤯🤯
39:38 late to this video, and someone's prob already said this, but hello from America!! While I don't think we have places called "charity shops", we have thrift stores which sound similar to me. They're particularly popular among college age people, lots of my friends go there for fun to find unique clothes you wouldn't be able to find elsewhere! But also America is really big so maybe things are different in other areas lol
I loved Jodie so much, shes my second favorite doctor from the new era, first being Capaldi, she just has a certain charm and energy to her that plays so well with the Doctor as a character, especially how she contrasts Capaldi's personality in the role
Can't say I liked all the episodes but it's the same with every doctor for me, and it just sucks that people took the "controversy" of her era and use it as proof that doctor SHOULD be a male or it loses fans, I mean sure it does but those probably aren't the type of fans the showrunners would care to keep
LETSS GOOO ROUND 2 BABYYY‼️‼️‼️‼️
ERIC!!
You forgot past the bins before the door on the left 😂 😉 love your content bro! Keep it up! All the best 👍
Thank you!
this is a great video!
my two main issues with chibnall's era were that the acting wasn't what i was hoping it would be, many lines felt flat. and i also think that the writing was on average lower than what previous seasons were. there were absolutely some good episodes, but for me, the great episodes of the chibnall era were about on par with the fairly good episodes, while some of the bad episodes felt like some of the lowest in recent memory. (especially the episode with the sea devils, i really was not fond of that one when it came out)
thinking back on all three seasons, i feel like the biggest struggle all of the episodes had was they didn't have a majorly memorable line or moment. i can think of dozens of iconic lines from s1-10, but it's a pretty big struggle to think of especially iconic lines in s11-13
(edit)
i think the best comparison is with the episode 42, which was written by chris chibnall. i genuinely really like that episode, and it has some very iconic moments. the phrase "burn with me" was very memorable, and it's those kinds of moments that i wish chibnall's full seasons included
I loved Jodie as Doctor, actually I liked all of them and all the companions never understood the haters
So I'm one of those people who watched 13 religiously but... Didn't enjoy it. I'd get glimpses of what I used to love but it just wasn't there. A TARDIS team that never gelled and a Doctor that was disaffected, drowning in toxic positivity. Having said that...
RTD has written the 14th Doctor in such a way I feel like I understand the characterization of 13 better now. That the closed off nature that we just assumed was bad writing can be attributed to someone forcing a positive image because they don't want anyone to see the pain they're in.
I think I'm gonna try re-watching series 8 through 13 again to give it a proper shakedown now that I've had time. I still hold Jodie was the best cast Doctor with the worst headwriter.
Great video. The massive over-reaction that certain people in the fandom have to things is so draining and it makes it so difficult to give genuine, good-faith criticism without being seen as part of that group. For instance, I'm really not a fan of the Chibnall era and there's a lot of your points in this video that I'd personally disagree with or counter. But with that said, I'm glad that people enjoy it and find things to like about it, and there are loads of things that I like about it myself. It makes it difficult to have discussions and voice opinions (which used to be one of the best things about fandom) without it turning into an all-out war held in Twitter/RUclips comments...
I honestly thought i was going insane reading the reviews of the first two episodes and reading #ripdoctorwho tweets till i found this video youtubers like nerdrotic have found a infinite view and subscribe glitch by keeping the hate bandwagon cycle alive.
Demons of the punjab, amazing episode.
It takes you away, great episode on its own and great developement in graham and ryan's relationship.
The battle of ranskoor av kolos, really great ideas, horrible mess of an execution, on all fronts (characters, story etc.).
I hate kerblam for a bunch of reasons, I don't like the tsurange conundrum, I don't remember 95% of what happened in the witch finders, I strongly dislike the arachnids episode. Rosa I generally didn't care for the villain and the whole episode kinda fell flat for me. The ghost monument I just didn't care for at all (thought it was a bit boring) and the woman who fell to earth I just found very weird and didn't like the ending.
Over all I really liked how it looked visually (most of the time. Tim shaw's space fig just looked bad) and while the music wasn't too memorable to me that also means it wasn't so bad that it was memorable so not a bad thing imo.
And that was my unasked for short review for all of series 11 based mostly on personal opinions.
This channel is so good I could cry - man it’s so high quality. Thanks for all the hard work
18:24 - the music here is so beautiful
I know i am late to this video. When it first came out I didn't like Chris Chibnall's writing. I find it more boring than the other writers of new who. I don't think it is bad, or worse than classic who (which I haven't finished watching). I have now watched all of the 13th era 4 times and decided... that it is still kind of boring. I do like the flux, even though it is a mess, because it just isn't as boring. And Jodie Whittaker squeezed water out of stone with the role, as she was the one keeping it interesting enough to watch 4 times.
Timeless child: I don't really care, but I think that it should have been the story of the master instead.
i think this is a great criticism of the chibnall era
@@dwfan91- Thankyou. Having thought even more about it, i think it is all the exposition. That was the issue i had with The Hungry Earth and Cold blood (I think that's what they are called)
Yeah, I think most people just bandwagon
People defend the time lord victorious but shit on hell bent which is the same thing but different doctor
EXACTLY
Remember kids! Actually watch the thing in question before forming an opinion! :D
mentally pinning this
Good video! Honestly I think you made a number a good points, I for one don't like the Chibnall era and will fully admit I've only watched about half of series 11, resolution(which I actually thought was decent), spyfall part one and then The Power of the Doctor. I still think for what I have watched the writing is not very good. I will say that as a Doctor Who fan the things that I don't like or things that make me angry I do tend to mellow out on given time. Maybe one day I'll give the Chibnall era another chance. I will say it's funny being a Doctor Who fan though, I walked away from the specials finding some enjoyment but ultimately underwhelmed feeling like the show might not be for me anymore then 3 months later wondering when the blu-ray set is coming out in North America.
Look i get where you're coming from and I also believe there is some good value in the era, but like saying the people who didn't enjoy it just didn't watch it is just not true, cos I watched every episode as they came out and sometimes go back to revisit them but I still think there is a whole lot of issues present, Orphan 55 was an incredibly boring episode at best. Series 11 having no returning villains isn't an issue, its the villains that we got instead, there was Tim Shaw who was an interesting villain in episode 1 but the payoff to what the series was clearly leading up to the stenza being the big bad was underwhelming to put it lightly, when the hight of the series is the bloody pting you know theres a problem. I'm not even going to bring the timeless child into this cos we've all had enough hearing about it so i'll spare you all