Ae Watan Mere Watan REVIEW | Sucharita Tyagi | Sara Ali Khan | Amazon Prime Video movie
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 мар 2024
- A sad lack of artistic vision and uneven pacing prevent Ae Watan Mere Watan from truly capturing the essence of the Quit India Movement.
SUBSCRIBE - bit.ly/35NEDO7
Ae Watan Mere Watan Movie Review by Sucharita Tyagi - Watching this film was an emotional experience. Zara bhi critical nazariye se agar aapne desh mein media ke halaat dekheien hain aajkal, toh yeh film bas yehi keh rahi hai ki jitni cheezein badal gayi hai, utni hi they remain the same. Kyun duniya ki harr regime sabse pehle mass communications ke mediums ko control karti hain, chaahe 1930s Germany ko, angrez adheen bharat ho, yaa aaj chaaro taraf phaila propaganda, coming to you from the news, from movies. When Usha tries to talk to her pro-government father about her dissatisfactions, jawaab aata hai “toh phir kaun chalaayega yeh desh?”, a refrain you STILL here anytime an election is around the corner. You hear pro-system people in the movie refer to movements of resistance to as “so called”, you see kaise legally dissenters ko jail kiya jaata hai, matbhed karne ke koi avenues khule nahi chore jaate, aur anonymous hokar ki khulle vichaar present karne ka option bachta hai. 80 saal pehli ki baatein lagti hain current agar, toh shayad film ki mansha wahee hai.
Mansha aur execution mein lekin, unfortunate gap hai kaafi bada, and the film, despite its intensions of perhaps reminding the Indian populace that intellectualism is good and debate is important, gets caught between its over-the-top staging, and bad performances.
#AeWatanMereWatan #SucharitaTyagi #PrimeVideoIndia #saraalikhan
In the midst of India's struggle for freedom in 1942, a brave young girl starts an underground radio station to spread the message of unity, setting off a thrilling chase with the British authorities during the Quit India movement. Ae Watan Mere Watan (transl. Oh Country My Country) is a 2024 Hindi-language historical biographical film about India's struggle for freedom in 1942, on the life of Usha Mehta, a brave young girl who starts an underground radio station to spread the message of unity, setting off a thrilling chase with the British authorities during the Quit India movement. It is written and directed by Kannan Iyer and produced by Karan Johar, starring Sara Ali Khan as Mehta. The film was premiered on 21 March 2024 on Amazon Prime Video.
Join me!
Instagram - / su4ita
Twitter - / su4ita
Facebook - / sucharitakapage
Producer - Maitri Dharod
Video editor - +919323003333
/ darkreationz
Be decent people,
Sucharita 
Кино
Second tragically disappointing Sara Ali Khan movie in as many weeks. Have you seen either?
I have. Did not like her acting at all it’s like force feeding audience with crappy actor like her. For this role they could have taken method actors like Wamika Gabi or Saniya Malhotra or Tripti Dimri.
Bad Sara Ali Khan films and performances have stopped being tragic but have become a norm. She's beyond saving at this point.
Murder Mubarak was highly disappointing and this film I think I will skip. But Sara needs to really improve
She has it in her as she has a lovely personality off screen it just doesn’t translate when she plays a character
Wonder why?
@@tasribarahman907Fatima Sana Shaikh would have nailed it
@@swatitrivedi6039 acting is a talent , a craft and she does not have it in her.
The worst part is Sara will still get big banner movies and thousands of actually good actors will struggle day and night to get a role because they are not star kids.
Being a star kid is not a crime. But despite of all the privileges when they do nothing for the craft of acting then that is a criminal.
Sara was good in atrangi re and Zara hatt , but bcoz this looser Sushant committed suicide so sara is getting unnecessary hate
Who care people love foreign commercial why they like garbage Indian commercial
I don’t think she will get big films even murder Mubarak and ea watan aren’t big films plus they are being dumped on OTT and nobody knows about her upcoming films ether.
All actresses who could have played sara -
1. Sanya Malhotra
2. Radhika Apte
3. Tanya Maniktala
4. Shweta Tripathi
5. Rasika Duggal
6. Paoli Dam
7. Mehreen pirzada
8. Naina Bhan
9. Anjali Sivaraman
10. Medha Shankar
……. Or a TREE .
🌳🌳🌳🌳😂
Rasika duggal is too old i don't know why people love 40+ uncle aunty in young role
Or a tree 😂
Fatima Sana Shaikh would have easily nailed this role!
You forgot wamiqa gabbi so let me just add her
The trailer itself was proof of miscasting.sanya malhotra would have been a good choice.
So would Fatima Sana Shaikh
@@faridahabdrashid1543 yes.absolutely correct.
Auditions karwa lo yaar aise important roles ke liye... No hate for Sara but someone more skilled couldve gotten a chance to do justice to this role..
Exactly. I just saw the movie and this role is such a good fit for Shweta Tripathi from Masaan!
Auditions wo baaki sabke karwate h except for lead role
@@Shoonyaveer mission impossible and jawan both are same typical action blockbuster but i always prefer mission impossible isse pata chalta h ki bollywood ka standard kitna low h
@@Shoonyaveer jab dhoom 2 ayi thi tab bollywood cool lagta tha uske baad mujhe bollywood kabhi cool nhi laga
I cringed so hard seeing Saras acting in trailer, my heart goes to people who watched her over react in the entire movie 😅😅😅
Sara Ali Khan is one person who seems to be getting worse with more pictures. Her acting is sooooooo bad!!! I wish she has the self awareness to understand this and move on to something else she is good at.
She is like Sonam Kapoor
Yet she said that this performance is one that she is proudest off!
Can't bear sara Ali Khan's acting. It was painful
True
Tum mujhe tang karny lagy ho
@@freakingcold1385 Sara Ab haam e taang Karen laagey hain
Sara is wasting her Ivy League education by trying to act in movies. I think she is confused about her career choices. She would be better to pursue other avenues
How did Sara's actong go from Kedarnath to an inept and inane Love Aaj Kal 2 in every movie?
Probably no director could get out of her what is needed, like the director of Kedarnath. She was so good in that film
Film is directors medium
The trailer shows us that the acting especially of Sara wasn't convincing enough because her body language and facial expressions show how she tries hard to imbibe the character that it terribly falls flat on the movie surface.
Sara did not do justice to the role, they should got someone have acting skills.
When struggling actors and directors watch such movies do they cry silently how they were robbed of a golden opportunity ?
Loved the review. Thanks. By the way, there's a book called, "Congress Radio: Usha Mehta And The Under: Usha Mehta and the Underground Radio Station of 1942" by Usha Thakkar that I think the makers and the writers could've done with reading, for detailed research and nuance, which to my mind the movie lacked completely. A great read that tells the extraordinary story of Usha Mehta, the voice of resistance.
Thanks for the recco Vivek
11@@SucharitaTyagi
@@SucharitaTyagiyour not sexy
Typical example of how bad acting ruines good project.
It has been done many times
Good movies bad casting
@@pennyc8252 hollywood don't cast megan fox in biopic movies
@@raja-jl9os 🤣🤣🤣🤣true but it bollywood n family business not cinema
@@pennyc8252 hollywood also have bad actor's but they2 only work in commercial action movies
You're so good, man. "Scene ke upar chipki hui lagti hai, rather than uske andar" SO TRUE.
Sara as a freedom fighter! What's next ? Nawazuddin as Mr Olympia?
No Vivek o and anupam kher
@@Firozshaikh1973 Salman khan as F1 racer
These x generation products of nepotism continue to be shoved in our faces. Eventually we will accept this and celebrate even their slightest improvement. Which SAK has not even mustered like Ananya and Janhvi. Then self made common person origin actors like Tripti are criticised for their choices in big banner than spotlighted a very accomplished resume. And similarly an actress as talented as Mrunal is ignored in Bollywood. Look at her recognition and love in Telegu cinema.
She is 28 year old women 😂
Nowadays most of the biopics are not researched properly and focus mainly on the star power of the actor. If you take the other biopics like milka singh, mary kom....despite their issues, the research was done very well. Even the Telugu movie, mahanati, it was done so beautifully. The actor and the actress were not Telugu industry still they were chosen to play the role as the director believed in his vision and knew that the movies is bigger than any actor. Seeing the trailer itself I knew that sara was not ideal for the role.
Bollywood think if they make biopic and social drama then critic's like bollywood movies 😂
Sardar udham
I laughed during the flag scene watching sara's performance😢
Karo ya maro dialogue felt cringe to me due to her
i don't understand how Sara is getting such big characters and ruining them continuously even after her previous disasterous records. Sorry to say, even kangana would've been better than her. She is insane, but she knows how to grab the character. I am just tired of watching her ruining "could've been good" movies.
What a beautifully nuanced review Sucharita. I loved the way you presented a balanced argument, analysed each aspect of the movie and also reflected upon the dips. But above all you did it with such acute empathy.
A cute empathy to your mum
Apparently, on trailers RUclips video they don’t let you post any negative comments. It gets deleted. That’s why all comments were only how good Sara is. Sucks!
ah! NOW it makes sense
The last part where you say there’s a longer discussion around this film in the link right here I think there you haven’t added the link by mistake. It’s not showing up on the screen. Thought I’ll point that out. Also I really think your review made me feel a greater sense of pride and respect for the sacrifices our freedom fighters made than Sara’s acting would. I really was hoping for her to ace this role. She’s been given way too many chances to overcome the performance barrier.
In here i see a desperate plea for people to open their eyes. Thank you for voicing my emotions
Zone of Interest kahan dekhein?
As much I like Sara's interviews I dislike her acting. I really hoped this worked, sadly she failed to deliver.
I really appreciate how you got into the nuances of her acting. Helps to appreciate a performance more when you understand what is and what could have been. Also, is this the first time with a background score in your video!?
It's incredibly disheartening to witness the missed opportunity surrounding the portrayal of someone as significant as Usha Mehta.
Her story deserves to be shared and understood, yet the decision to cast a mediocre actor like Sara raises doubts about the
sincerity of the storytelling. Why not conduct thorough auditions to find an actor who can truly embody the nuances of such a
complex character on screen? The makers' choice seems to disregard the audience's intelligence, delivering a narrative with
subpar acting and a lackluster storyline.
Hats off for discussing collective vigilance in any democracy against oppressive regimes. Including current ones. Patriotism also means being vigilant in protecting the rights of oneself and others, and stopping governments that use
division to control the masses.
Such movies are just made to position Rich Kids like Sara Ali Khan as good actors..But unfortunately one needs to know their limitations and choose right kind of movies.
KJo is providing opportunities to nepokids to act in biopics
The performance is never effortless. There is so much talk about prep work and performance and you can almost hear Sara quiver in every dialogue. How are these ppl given repeated chances. Such mediocre performances and what a miss on an amazing chance from Murder Mubarak and Ar Watan makers. She is the new Arjun Kapoor
Sara looked out of place...
What a wonderful review! I especially liked the constructive feedback on Sara’s acting. You are doing great - this is one of my favorite reviews by you! Keep it up! We will support you to be swatantra
Sara is new Arjun Kapoor, started with a bang and getting worst with each movie
: Sara Ali Khan’s dialogue delivery is more painful to watch than India’s freedom struggle
Sara ali khan screen pe door se dekhne pe tik lgti hai but jaisi hi uske face expressions dikhate hain itni zyada stiffness hai sara k face pe mein ek baar sara ko reality mein rote huye dekhna chahti hun just to satisfy my soul ki wo aisi hi dikhti hai. CRINGE
Please talk about Madgaon Express. I heard it's really good. I also feel you talking about good Bollywood movies will always give audiences a good reason to go and watch the movies in theatres. I personally love Kunal Khemu as an actor and I am happy he has been able to do what he has done with his debut directorial. 😊
Sanya Malhotra, Radhika Madan, Shreya Chaudhary, Trisha Chaudhary, Manjari Pupala, Kubra Sait - any of these would have been better than Sara Ali Khan.
Any time plans to review Savarkar?
Evidently fake acting by Sara may be under pressure, other actress could have done more justice to this brilliant role…rest of the cast gave impactful performance 👏🏼
Legacy of Resistance with Sara's expressions. I thought you'd say this lol
What a review, rather what a speech!! Loved every bit of it and also the underling messages. Well done Sucharita. Absolutely impressed
There is no diff to the fate of dissenter even now. By the way, Sucharita, have you seen “All the light you can’t see”.
Amazing review Sucharita . Your eloquence blew my mind !
After long time , watching your video. & Glad to know that you are speaking in hindi
why are you talking inhindi ? wat happend to anglais?
They should have taken inspiration from mini series 'all the light we cannot see' it also had blind with radio against nazi really good show
Thank you for an honest review Sucharita. And for not being as lenient as Anu where she barely mentions Sara and other Nepo kids poor performance as "manicured". That is it!
Weighing words before delivering. A sad reality of today.
I feel like watching the movie to relate to the insights compiled in this elegant review!
New trend observed to keep the relevance of non performing nepotism products - Cast them along side true good actors # Sparsh Shrivastav
Thank you for continously elevating the standards of movie critiquing Sucharita. This review could have easily been only about Sara Ali Khans acting and remained superficial and obvious. Instead, you made a deeper connect with the current political scenario and technicalities. The way you handle each movie ( other than some wtf , total disaster a la Selmon bhai 😂) , shows your love for movie making - the good, the bad the ugly..they all get your attention.
Hi, From fast and fury to slow and mellow, you took so long. I wonder how this miracle happened. What ever, I like you more now.
I understand whatever you are saying.
Love.
Such a well put opinion with respect to the movie. A very well made film criticism. I found this review so well put.
Ma'am you are a TRUE film critic. I felt a bit as if Roger Ebert was talking about a film.
Ma'am your commentary on the film and the parallels with society and the criticism of the film is an amazing piece.
yaar kitni mehnat ker rahi ho sucharita, itna asaan ker ker kay sub kuch samjhaya hai rona a gaya! love you!
Thank youuuuuuuu.
Review Madgaon Express, it was a laugh riot.
Will you review Swatantrya Veer Savarkar?
A very well made introduction. Not at all "lambi introduction".❤
Tanya Maniktala would have been great
Your intentional pauses helped your point get delivered effortlessly. There was a sweet struggle between the Indian you and the critic you, who also happens to be the same person of course so neither part of your identity can be sidelined, knowing that you were circling back to the film while expressing your views about the current media situation in our country. Felt like you were sitting on a couch with us and speaking your heart out, the movie might be mid but the review was gold ❤.
Made my day. Thank you :)
Not Sara's fault if the filmmakers envision her in roles that require skillsets of Meryl Streep or Sir Anthony Hopkins 😂
There is this deep misconception among some Indian filmmakers that add a sepia filter and you make a historical film. Shyam Benegal films can come to their rescue.
Your opinion on sara ali khan is so true.. harsh truth but need to be told
Great review as usual
Your writing and articulation is so spot on! Most reflective and insightful reviews...thank you for bringing depth to the field!
Reviews by Sucharita is one of the finest out there. Her depth of analysis shows the depth of her personality. Amazing!
Thanks for this perspective
Why did you review this movie like how Sara Ali Khan delivers her dialogues in this film 😂
Sara ali khan , I’m sure very intelligent and educated , however She’s not an good actor
She is cunning not intelligent
Always the best review
Injustice with a great story.
Sara didi ko koi acting ki tuition dilao please.
Acting is not easy har koi nhi kr skta h most Indian a list actor's only have screen presence
If Sara knew she wanted to get into movies... instead of doing an history honours at Columbia maybe an acting degree would have been a better choice. Especially since everyone is not born with talent, and sadly she can't act to save her life. Common sense is not so common
Impeccable
Sara always cring act😂
Love your reviews, seems authentic than others but small suggestion: to use easier vocab. Have to google while listening sometimes.
Sara ali khan is the money and attention bringer for this movie
Now she is the reason for the film’s failure!
I like the idea of Sara Ali Khan in Period Dramas. Also, depicting history in our great nation will never be an easy task. (Not a comment on the show)
Aapne sahi kaha aaj ka environment aur uss time ka environment kai cheezo me similar hai .sad reality of our nation
Your not sexy
Sara should've continued with her education/higher studies. Columbia is not a joke.
It is if u get admission by making donations 😂😂
@@offred6013 maybe donations but padhaai khatm to ki na.... could've made a mark there
BRING JENNIFER WINGET IN BOLLYWOOD
Kudos to all the critics that stay true to their job rather than blaming the writing to shelter a talentless nepo
Watch manjumal boys
Where to watch
Ae Watan Mere Watan Review by Anzel | Sara Ali Khan | Emran Hashmi | Kannan Iyer | Karan Johar
ruclips.net/video/4s7-r8BGT0k/видео.html
Poor girl Sarah, aati he nahi acting toh kya kare bechari?
You look gorgeous
Love your work
Thanks !
❤
Brilliant movie
Saras expressions be it on ramp walks or movies and otherwise are always awkward! Constipated if I am honest!
Whats with the accent !
Over acting sara😂
Sucharita’ so views reminds of those who believe ‘we are living in a simulation’ 😂, when she says ‘there is propaganda all around us’ 😂
I watched the movie and to be honest as you are describing it ..its isnt bad at all i feel u overly criticise everything.. why??? Sara was good not bad at all yes definitely not amazing but not that bad as u are uttering and film is one time good watch..
She is literally a film critic
Seriously it like watching small baby doing play on his kindergarten graduation 😂😂😂😂😂😂
lol her stupid fans trying to defend her😂
“That Tyagi Girl”😂
Tone down the accent please it’s getting overbearing now. A bit too off putting Indian distracting me from what is otherwise a great review as always
lol please leave
Sucharita...was the review for the film ? Sara? Media or Govt..waise aap swantanra hai isiliye meine isse "propoganda" na samajh kar khuli soch k saath dekha..aap itne bade mukaam par hai..itni mehnat se pohochi hai..aapko kaun rokega..😅❤..comparison kuch hazam nahi hua...but bahut pyaari hai aap..❤god bless u❤
I appreciate your review, although I haven't had the chance to watch it yet. It seems Sara Ali Khan could benefit from further developing her acting skills, particularly for serious and emotional roles. It's interesting to note that she seems to excel under certain directors, as seen in "Atrangi Re" and "Kedarnath." While she possesses potential and passion, there's room for growth to transcend from being merely a glamorous heroine to a compelling actor.
Oh just shut up
Oh just shut up
I loved the film.