Hazrat ESA عليہ السلام ki HAYAT aur NUZOOL ??? Reply to GHAMIDI حفظہ اللہ (Engr. Muhammad Ali Mirza)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 окт 2020
- A Critical Video Clip from 134-ILMI-o-Tahqeeqi MAJLIS (Open Q & A Session) with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Bhai (Studio Recording for 11-Oct-2020). Link of Complete Video : • 134-ILMI-o-Tahqeeqi MA...
Ref. No. 1 : 20-Questions on GHAMIDI Sb. in 96-ILMI-o-Tahqeeqi MAJLIS of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (03-Jan-20) : • 20-Questions on GHAMID...
Ref. No. 2 : Kia Saheh BUKHARI 100 % hi SAHEH hai ??? An ILMI Reply to GHAMIDI Sb. (Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza) : • Kia Saheh BUKHARI 100 ...
Ref. No. 3 : Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi حفظہ اللہ & Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ki MEETING (30-Dec-2019) ki Details ??? : • Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi ح...
Ref. No. 4 : Dr. Israr Ahmad رحمہ اللہ & Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Bhai ki MEETING (13-Jun-2008) ki Details ??? : • Dr. Israr Ahmad رحمہ ا...
#Hazrat_ESA #Javed_Ahmad_GHAMIDI
Ref. No. 1 : 20-Questions on GHAMIDI Sb. in 96-ILMI-o-Tahqeeqi MAJLIS of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (03-Jan-20) : ruclips.net/video/9v5GeL9am20/видео.html
Ref. No. 2 : Kia Saheh BUKHARI 100 % hi SAHEH hai ??? An ILMI Reply to GHAMIDI Sb. (Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza) : ruclips.net/video/qWl-z8HN2JI/видео.html
Ref. No. 3 : Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi حفظہ اللہ & Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ki MEETING (30-Dec-2019) ki Details ??? : ruclips.net/video/Q54vfYImTWs/видео.html
Ref. No. 4 : Dr. Israr Ahmad رحمہ اللہ & Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Bhai ki MEETING (13-Jun-2008) ki Details ??? : ruclips.net/video/4Qila_-tMr4/видео.html
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza - Official Channel plz mery comment ka jawab dein Ali bhai
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza - Official Channel khuda k liye mery comment ka jawb dyn
Baba G meri walida 2 din pehly is dunia fani sy intqaal kr gai hyn mujy sabar nhi aa Raha
Mujy koi Amal bata dein jo Mai roz her waqat karta rahu apni maa k liye
Or un k liye dua Krein
@@haiderilyasofficial7607 .....
Aap har waqat
INNA LILLAH HE WA INNA ELAEHE RAJEEOON
Perhayn ....dill say soch ker, k
aap ki mother Allah ki theen ,Unn
ki taraf say aaee theen Allah ney wapis bula leya .......
Asal main koi cheez bhee hamari
nahee.....hamari rooh,hamari eyes,hamarey hands,feet,body ,hamarey siblings
sabb Allah ka hay ......
سب نے جانا ہے ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
In sha Allah sabar aaey ga.
best soch keh
"sabar kerney waley k saath Allah hota hay "(Quran)
پپ
Allah pak ki rehmtain Hon Hazrat Esa bin Maryam Alay Salam par..
Ghamdi sb's view point is right. If you have any doubt please listen this topic in response to 23 question series of peof. Javaid Ahmed Ghamdi sb with Hasan ILYAS.
Great research by Engg Ali helpful for Muslim Brotherhood JazakAllah ❤❤❤
سبحان اللہ وبحمدہ سبحان اللہ العظیم وبحمدہ استغفرُللہ بھائی اللہ تعالیٰ رحمتوں برکتوں سے نوازے آمین
علی بھاٸی آپ بہت علمی بندے ہیں آپکو سن کے میں نے مدرسوں میں پڑھانے والوں کو بھاگیا ہے علمی طریقے سے آپ ایک جیتی جاگتی علمی اکیڈمی ہیں
sir I love you😘
شیطان کا ساتھ دیا آپ نے
it feels so relaxing and satisfying listening Ali bhai
Zabardast Masha Allah. One of the most enlightening videos on this topic.
All doubt cleared Very well first time in my life
Assalam walekum Ali bhai aap ki wajha se main Barelvi se ab srif muslim ho gya or aap ki baton ko aage bhi btaya logo ne mana bhi Allah ka shukr hai aap jawab de
Jazak Allah Khair Wa Ahsanal Jaza...❤️
سبحان اللہ الحمداللہ اللہ اکبر لا الہ اللہ محمد رسول اللہ صلی اللہ تعالی علیہ والہ وسلم
بہت سارے منطقی کمالات میں سے اس معاملے میں آپ نے جو کمال دکھایا ھے۔۔۔واہ جی واہ ۔۔اپ اپنے استادوں کے بھی استاد نظر آئے۔۔۔
ماشاللہ بہت قابلیت ھے۔۔۔ جو چاھے آپ کا حسن کرشمہ ساز کرے۔۔۔۔سات دن نجران کے علماء ایسی ھی کرشمہ سازی دکھاتے رھے۔۔۔۔
Ali bhai ko dawat deta ho k Ghamidi sahab ke series “Response to 23 questions” ko sunnay aur apna mouqif bhe batai.
Is series mein Parda (part 3 - part 12) k topic par mein nay is se achi analysis kabhe pehle nahi sunni. Ali bahi ka jo parda ka thought hai woh bohat extreme aur Maulana Maudodi rehamtuAllah ke qitab “Parda” se similar hai lekin us kitab mein bunyad zaif hadith per hai
علی بھائی سے صحیح احادیث سے پردہ ثابت کیا ہے اور ان علماء جیسے شیعوں کے امام خمینی، اہل حدیث کے شیخ ناصر الدین البانی کو جواب دیا ہے جو چہرے کے پردے کے قائل نہیں ہیں۔
@MS thesmart Mein aap ko bhe dawat deta ho k woh series sunnay. Us mein sare parde ki hadith ka mafoom bataya hai. Dono mauqif sun kar apna faisla krlein
@whatthe Baat yeh hai k “parda” ya “hijab” ke word se Quran aur Hadith khali hai
@@sch4972
Parda and hijab are not even arabic words. Jalabeeb is Arabic word used in Quran for hijab.
I will spend time on Ghamdi series to see why munkareen hadith follow him.
Yes
جزاکم اللہ خیرا، المھندس مرزا محمد علی صاحب!
46.01
سورت الزمر 39
آیات 42
لفظ ( یتوفی) ترجمہ (موت, قبض کرنا)
مرزا صاحب آپ کا جھوٹ پکڑا گیا ہے یہ جو آپ ترجمہ یا معنی کر رہے سوائے شعیہ کے ایک مولوی کے سب نے اس کا ترجمہ (موت) ہی کیا ہے, خدا کے عذاب سے ڈرو مولوی اپنی مرضی کے ترجم مت کرو قرآن کے.
گدھے آدمی یہاں جو تم ترجمہ مختلف کر رہے اسکا حکم کیا اللہ نے دیا ہے؟ یا اسکے رسول نے دیا ہے؟ تمہاری ساری باتیں کہانی سے زیادہ کچھ بھی نہیں.
جن مفسرین نے اسکا ترجمہ موت کیا ہے انکے نام یہ ہیں اور یہ پڑھ کر ڈوب مرنا اگر شرم ہوئی تو.
1-ڈاکڑ اسرار
2- امام راغب
3- امین اسلہی
4- طاہر القادری
5- نگیت ہاشمی
6- مولانا مودودی
7- کنزل المان
8- جونا گری
9- تاقی عثمانی
حرام خور مولوی اگر اسکا ترجمہ پورا پورا لینا ہے تو ان سب نے غلط ترجمہ کیوں ہے؟؟
آج سے نفرت ہو گئی تمہارا سفید جھوٹ پکڑ کر, مولوی تم اپنے چیلوں کو کہنا تھا کہ قران کھول کر ایک بار خود پڑھ لیں.
First, be clear that I am quite a fan of yours in many of your view points. But, that said:
1. Just like Hajj, Salat is also Sunnat Ibrahimi and was also performed before Hazrat Mohammad (PBUH). People knew how to perform it. Just like Hajj, Hazrat Mohammad (PBUH) corrected the wrong. People performed the way He (PBUH) performed. He (PBUH) didn't tell them how to do it.
2. You, yourself say that Hazrat Issah (PBUH) says that he will come back and will stay for 40 years and be taken up again. Will he be taken up alive again, just like as first time, or dead? You are using the same words as in his (PBUH) first appearance but, contradictory argument in second appearance.
3. If Hazrat Issa (PBUH) was to come back again, the Christian of that time would have the same faith also, so, in His (PBUH) conversation with Allah would have been that "once I went back second time I corrected them.
Mr. Mirza, your arguments are still not to the ilmi & Aqli standards.
4. You, yourself, goes against majority of Muslim in many a aqeedas so, don't give me an argument to go with majority (ijmai ummat).
Keep your ego aside when in discussion.
Thnx.
Agreed with you mostly.
Agreed!
We all MUST WATCH THE SERIES OF RESPONSE TO 23 QUESTIONS of GHAMIDI SAAB.
He explained each and every thing very clearly.
Correct. Engineer sb is dismissing ghamdi sb without any sane argument. Ghamdi sb's arguments are elaborate and logical.
When he comes second time he will have a natural death. Because he did not yet experience death and everyone has to die.
Your 3rd point is wrong.. Ab duniya me koi aik b aysa Esai mojod nhi jis ko Hazrat Esa ne direct tableeg di.... Wo sab mar chuky hain...or ab k esaion k aqeedon me Hazart Esa AS ka koi lena dena nhi na hi is k jawabda hn wo .. So wo ab nabi bn k nhi ayen gy jo un se tableeg ka sawal kiya jaey
Jahan Zikar ALLAH paak ka wahan Zikar Mohammad(SAW) Mustafa ka jahan Zikar Mohammad (SAW) ka wahan Zikar ALi(as) ka ....
Mazeed ayaat. Surah Alimraan ayet 46. Surah Marium ayet 31. Surah Alnisa ayet 172.Surah Alhadeed 57 ayaat 27 28 29.
ماشاالله
جزاك الله خيرا❤️🇮🇳
Firs of all the about the Ijmaa, there is a very famous narration that when Prophet Muhammadﷺ passed away, the companions were in a state of shock, especially Omar R.A. who went to such extent that he took out his sword with the intention of beheading anyone who says that the Prophet ﷺ is dead. It was of course a very sentimental moment for every Muslim, and it was Abu Bakar Siddiq R.A. who recited the verses 3:144
وَمَا مُحَمَّدٌ إِلَّا رَسُولٌ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِنْ قَبْلِهِ الرُّسُلُ
It is mentioned that when Omar R.A. heard these verses, he became calmer and later in his life when he recalled this incident, he said that it was as if that was the first time, I had heard this verse as I had never imagined the true meaning of this verse.
If you say that the Ijmaa of the Ummah is that Eisa A.S. is alive, then Omar R.A. would have argued that if Eisa can live so can Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. But what we learn from this incident is that the first ever Ijmaa of the Ummah after the passing of the Prophet ﷺ was that all prophets before them had passed away.
Very Strong argument.
They people can't understand
I dont agree because at the time when prophet SAW passed away when the ayat was recited by Abu Bakr RAD, Umar RAD he said that it was as if that was first time. This tells us at that time the grieve of demise of Rasulsallallahu had overtaken hazrat Umar. Umar RAD was not only Sahabi left after the prophet but there were lot of sahaba alive. If hazrat umar would have argued then definitely he would have received the answer .
Your Reply to Ijamah
At-Tirmidhi (2167) narrated from Ibn ‘Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Allah will not cause my ummah to agree on falsehood; the hand of Allah is with the jamaa‘ah (the main body of the Muslims).” Classed as hasan by al-Albaani.
The meaning of this hadith is that Allah has protected the scholars of the ummah of Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) from unanimously agreeing upon something false.
This protection is only for all the scholars of the ummah during any given period. As for the agreement of some of them or most of them on something, that is not protected from error.
Similarly, if the common folk are agreed on some matter, that does not indicate that it is true, because what matters here is the scholars, not the common folk or the ignorant.
Abu ‘Eesa at-Tirmidhi said in his Sunan: What is meant by the jamaa‘ah (the main body of the Muslims), according to the scholars, is the scholars of fiqh, knowledge and hadith.
Al-Mulla ‘Ali al-Qaari said: The hadith indicates that if the Muslims unanimously agree on something, then it must be true, and what is meant is the unanimous agreement of the scholars. The consensus of the common folk does not carry any weight, because it is not based on knowledge.
Urdu channel hy yeh or yaha english aisy bol rahy ...just logon ko gumrah kernybk liye english bol rahy
Ali bhai ap ka muslman ummat pe bohat ahsan hai Allah ap ko apne hifzo eiman me rakh Ameen ya rabolle Alamein. 🌴🦋🌴🦋🌴🦋
Asslam.o.alaikum...! Owesome lecture...👌👍❤ Love you E.M.A.M..😍🌹
My Best Teacher...❤💝🌹
مرنے سے پہلے اے مسلمان..! کر لے اس پے غور...👌
کتابوں کا خدا اور بابوں کا خدا اور....👍
جزاك اللهُ خيرًا
This video was uploaded on Oct 12, 2020. Need a new video in response to Ghaamdi sahb video uploaded on Nov 5, 2020
aur kou kam nahi
@@roomanhamza7170 Jawab huga tu aye ga brother. Baqi kam tu dunia men boht hen. Khush rahen
@@malikkashifnawaz inkar e hayat e Isa apky galy mai.phanda ban sakta hai
Qayamat mai yaad karogy meri baat
@@sherkhan8135 ghamdi fitna hy. Bacho
ماشاءاللہ
اللہ سبحان و تعالٰی آپ کے علم و فضل میں اور زیادہ اضافہ فرمائیں
Very good lecture Ali bhai.
Jazak ALLAHHU khaira.
ماشاء اللہ ❤️❤️❤️
بہت خوبصورت علی بھائی
Na me wabi na me babi me hn Muslim ilmy kitabi. 📚📙📘📗🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Ap ka tamam sawalo ka jawab ghamdi sb de chuke hain
Assalam O Alaikum
My Best Teacher
Allah Bless you Aameen Sum Aameen
He is a liar
He is not Teacher but an Iblees
@@abdar-rahman6965 agreed
@@Rising_Star922
All what this Dajjal Mirza has said in this video, can be RATIONALLY debunked. He is the biggest Shameless Liar of present time
@@moinisnice jealousy 😂
Subhan Allah! All doubts are ambiguity is clearly explained with true and authentic references by the Mujadid e Azam until qayamah, Muhammad Ali Mirza. He is the greatest scholar and researcher of renaissance of the pure Islam in a world of shirk among Muslims.
Did he claim as Mujadid? First time I read it. Please explain. Thanks
@@peaceloveandcompassion6185 I talk to human being and real people not fake ID. However, briefly I can tell that he claims himself as a teacher while I claim him the Mujadid e Azam of all times until qayamah. I don’t know if he agrees on that. He is a great man who wants to be known as a common Muslim.
@@MajidGhori Thank you dear brother. Rest assure two human beings are talking. I am interested in your claim about “ Mujad dai Azam” about Mohtram Engineer Shb. As we know about the prophecy of Hazrat Muhammad(pbuh) related to coming of Mujadid in the beginning of each Century. Are you referring that?
@@peaceloveandcompassion6185 obviously, I believe in Quran Kareem and all mustanid Ahadees. Not kahania.
Isha a.s and Mahdi a.s are both names of the same person.
Ibn mazah 4039
Surah maryam 29 look at arabic words
Then prove both are diffrent with proof
Give me reference
جزاک اللہ خیرا کثیرا
Ali bhai love u Allah pak ap k ilam m izafa farmaye.ap ki videos dkh k dil khush ho jata h ilmi dalel sun k
Ghamidi sahab k nazdeek yeh ahadess mahil-e-nazar hai, woh inkar nae kartay but kuch context se questions karty hai. Abhe Ghamidi sahab ki eik series hai “Response to 23 Questions” us mein Imam Mehdi (part 24 se) ka baab zair behas hai, aap tafseel ilmi ikhtalaf waha dekh saktay hai.
Please Ali bhai aap Ghamidi sahab k sath apna interview record karwai hum jaise kumzoor musalmano ka bohat faida hota hai. Aap he 2 personalities hai jo haq baat kehnay se dartay nahe aur dosro k liye nafrat nae pehlatay
Ghamdi Sahab ne 2 maslo mei thokar khai hai. Ek Haz. Esa ka mamle mei aur dusra Isra wal meraj mei. In 2 baato ki wajah se Ghamdi Sahab ki saari sahi baatein logo ko mashkook karti hain.
@@asimsparks Sahi kaha aap nay
@asimsparks Ghamidi sahab ne Quran ki woh hasiyat bahal ki hai jo ummat bhula chuke thi. Aur is ke sath Sunnat aur Hadith ka farq bhe bataya hai.
Miraj ka waqia toh Quran (17:60) mein saaf alfaz mein ruyah (rohani) aya hai. Phir bhe important baat tou yeh hai k waqia ka inkar tou koi nahe karta. Hazrat Esa (A.S.) k mutabiq bhe unki baat mein wazan hai k eik Messenger k wapis anay ka aqeeda Allah Tala ko Quran mein direct alfaz mein bata dena chaiye tha. Yeh kehna ke noazubillah Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) itne bari baat sirf kuch logo ko batai (Hadith) bhe ghalat hoga. Mein Ghamidi sahab k “response to 23 questions” ka wait kar raha ho jaha woh apne baat ke mazeed explanation de gai. Aap ko bhe yeh series dekhni ki advice deta ho
Ghamidi sahab k “Response to 23 questions” mein Parda (part 3 - part 12) k topic par mein nay is se achi analysis kabhe pehle nahi sunni
I love ......all your videos ....they are sooooo interesting ....full of knowledge.
Abhi main Ghamdi sahab k 23 critical questions ki series k isa as ke unwaan ka intezar kr raha hu, uske baad apke dlael aur unke dalael sununga...abhi sirf download krleta hu
Dear Asim ayyubi, shayad apko galti lagi, Ghamdi sahab jin 23 etrazat k jawab de rahe hain us tafseeli guftagu me abhi ye mauzu zer e bahas ni aya, aap ekbaar aur check kare on response of 23 critical questions series. Jahan tak kisi alim ko ahmak bolne ki baat hai to main aise byanat se ijtenab krta hu. Shukriya
Asim brother un ki last video zahoor e mehdi k uper thi
@Asim Ayyubi The upcoming series I am talking about is not just an argumentative discussion about his ideology, but a rational discussion of all the principles of the Qur'an and Sunnah behind his ideology. I beg you to be patient. If their arguments are not strong enough, I will not support them myself. Thanks
yeah dear brother that lecture under meezan is not a thorough analysis of Ghamdi sahab's view so I am waiting for his tafseeli guftagu under 23 critical response series.That's all I was trying to explain to you and may be it's my fault I couldn't explain my point to you clearly.
@Asim Ayyubi You have said your thing, now give them a chance to say their whole thing. And wait a moment. I will keep your point in mind while reviewing this topic. Don't worry if I follow Ghamdi sahab's view then there should be strong evidence from Qur'an and Sunnah behind it, we are all seekers of truth.Thank you very much for your concern.
Sir Mola Hussain asws apko humesha abad rakheee
Ap humesha humko hidayat ka rasta bataty hai Allah swt apko humesha is raste par qaim rakheee Amen:
Mola Hussain AS is not capable to protect himself how can he than save Muhammad Ali Engineer..... Allah can protect all. Of us
what.. mola Hussain ?
are u serious...
ALLAH IS THE ONLY CARING AND SUSTAINER
@@mnadeem7797 well said
@@mak9934 well said
MashaAllah Subhan Allah Alhamdulillah jazak Allah Khair o Ahsano Jaza bhai sab
❤🤲🤲🤲❤
Too much intellectual and intelligent personality we have proud and our duty to respect in regard his ability. Thanks. God.may live long.
اللہ ھم صل علی سیدنا و مولانا محمد و علی آلہ وصحبہ و بارک وسلم
Alhamdulillah we have such a scholar like you sir. 😭❤️
Alhamdolillah hmary aqaid hmry walidein se e ye chal rhy hain ❤ Alhamdolillah, Ali bhai, ye sb references sun k iman taza hua or Allah ka shukr zuban pe jari k usne hmy khatm e nabuwat or nazul e eesa a.s jese critical topics ki smjh boojh hm me dali ❤ Or Allah s.w.t iska ajar meri amm ko den, ameen ❤ hmy bchpn se e btaya gya k kis trh hazrat eesa a.s k zinda uper uthaye janay vla waqeya paish aya or ye b k wo end times me dubra ayengy or apni paused dunyawi zndgi dubara jiyengy ❤❤❤
or jo duties Allah ne unki a.s, lgai hain wo fulfil krengy or as per system, unko moat aye gi or phr obviously qayamat mzeed kreeb
Aoa, may Allah bless you a lot Ali sahib , remain safe and happy .
Hazrat Isa A.S is strong and real example of time travel
Travel from its present time to future & past is called time travel in english
And Isa A.S come from his present time to future
Aj kal ky bacho ko samjhna ka liya
You are delusional!!!
Another example Mahraj is the best example of time travel
JB nabi aely salam Mahraj pr gy to earth ka time roka nhi tha balky scientist khaty hin agr insan light ki speed Sy travel karty to earth ka time Sy wo insan aezad hu jata Hy
Nabi aely salam ny farmaya KY Mari Nazar Jahan tk jati thi bhurakh waha tabhi phuch jati thi
Or wasy hi Nabi aely salam earth pr ae gy boht Kam time ma!
Assalamu alikum Ali bhai, Today I became very very happy after listening to ur video clip on the most crucial matter, May Almighty Allah bless you more and more with all kinds of His blessings. AAMEEN 🤲🤝❤️🌹👌✔️📌🤔
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a gem of a human being and a sensible scholar.
After listening to him, one can truly believe that Islam is indeed the ultimate source of guidance for all humanity, and for the rest of so-called ulemas, people like you come and go and no one even notices !
جاوید احمد غامدی کو منکر حدیث کے سوا کوئی پوچھتا بھی نہیں ہے اور آپ بہکے بہکے دعوی کر رہے ہو۔
سلام ہے آپکو
Ghamidi is one of the best players of words. One needs to make sure you have the knowledge. If people like him can deviate us from the Islam followed by the companions of the Prophet ﷺ, think about what chance do we have against when Dajjal will come.
MashaAllah is tarah ke knowledge waali videos hame dusre molviyo me nahi milti
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
( Allah ki app pr salamti , rehmat or fazal ho )
App apni app iphone k liye b bna dein JazakAllah ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Listen to Ghamidi sahab viewpoint on this in “Response to 23 questions” series. He doesn’t deny hadiths on this topic but critque them as “mehl-e-nazar”. Maybe it’s not as literal as people are taking them. Most are the dreams of our prophet (saw) and in dreams the things are dramatized; they are not shown in actual but as a interpretation of some other events.
You shared my heart's content...
All should listen JAVED AHMAD GHAMIDI SAAB
Engineer Mirza points are not satisfying. Rather, Ghamdi sb's views are more convincing.
He does deny everything I’ve heard this yesterday
Yes it's quite close to 4 injeels which are mostly reports by people about Eissa AS whereas Jesus words quoted is as less than 20 percent
Ghamidi has told Truth but this Mirza is a Bigggggggggggggggggg Mushrik Liar
Ali bhai sorry m pehle aap ko galat samajh ta tha but now I'm 100%satisfied with you. Allah aap se haq baat byan krata rhe hamesha ammen ammen
جزاک اللہ خیرا
First from Kashmir
32:36 ’بَلْ رَّفَعَہُ اللّٰہُ اِلَیْْہِ‘۔ اِس رفع کی وضاحت قرآن نے سورۂ آل عمران (۳) کی آیت ۵۵ میں اِس طرح فرمائی ہے کہ وفات کے بعد اللہ تعالیٰ اُنھیں اپنی طرف اٹھا لیں گے۔ اِس کے معنی یہ ہیں کہ روح قبض کر کے اُن کا جسم بھی اٹھا لیا جائے گا تاکہ اُن کے دشمن اُس کی توہین نہ کر سکیں۔ مسیح علیہ السلام اللہ کے رسول تھے اور رسولوں کے بارے میں اللہ تعالیٰ کا یہ قانون قرآن میں بیان ہوا ہے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ اُن کی حفاظت کرتا ہے اور جب تک اُن کا مشن پورا نہ ہو جائے، اُن کے دشمن ہرگز اُن کو کوئی نقصان پہنچانے میں کامیاب نہیں ہوتے۔ اِسی طرح اُن کی توہین و تذلیل بھی اللہ تعالیٰ گوارا نہیں کرتا اور جو لوگ اِس کے درپے ہوں، اُنھیں ایک خاص حد تک مہلت دینے کے بعد اپنے رسولوں کو لازماً اُن کی دست درازی سے محفوظ کر دیتا ہے۔
غامدی صاحب۔۔البیان
ھم تو قران کو مانیں گے
Allah ap ko salamt rakhi or ap si raje ho or ap ko jaza akhair dy AAMEEN ya rabbul Alameen
Great Scholar of Islam!....ALLAH aap ko Jannat E Firdous mein muqam e aala ata ker chuka.
Asslam o alikum
Ali Bhai meri walida is dunia fani sy intqaal kr gai hyn
Un k liye dua kry sab dosto sy dua krwa dy boht mehrbani ho gai
Mujy koi esa Amal bata dy jo Mai roz her waqat krta hun apni maa k liye
Allah tala ap ko sabar ata kare ap ki walida ko junat me jaga de un ke liye asaniyan peda kare
Bhai jab aap nemaz parhen gay na har roz 5 waqt tau iss me unke liye bhi dua he hogi aur yeh unki maghfirat ka baes bhi bne gi insha Allah . Aap khud unke liye dua karen logon se kyu request kar rahay hen. Jis dard ke sath aap apni maa ke liye dua karen gay dosra koi bhi nai kar payega so mobile ko side pe rakhen aur apni nemaz ki fikr karen aap ne apni isslaah kar le tau apni Maa pe yhe bhot bara ehsaan hoga aap ka aur apne aap par bhi
Mashah Allah❤❤
جزاک اللہ
Love you sir I have been listening you since last year.The most logical and superb personality
In translation of the 5:116,
فَلَمَّا تَوَفَّيْتَنِي كُنْتَ أَنْتَ الرَّقِيبَ عَلَيْهِمْ ۚ
The hadees 4625 of Bukhari Kitab-u-Tafseer, should be enough to clarify the meaning of the word “Tawaffaitani” once in for all, where the Prophet Mohammed ﷺ has used the same words for himself. Now we all know that Prophet Mohammed ﷺ died here right on this earth, so to say that when these words are used for Eisa A.S., it should be translated as “ascend to sky”, is not acceptable because the translation provided by the Prophet Mohammed ﷺ will always be considered as final. It should also be noted that the section Katab-u-Tafseer of Bukhari is where all narrations are related to commentaries of the Holy Quran provided by none other than Prophet Muhammad ﷺ himself.
In addition to the verses related to Eisa A.S., the word “Tawaffa” is used 24 times in the Holy Quran and every time is used for the capture of soul. In justification of the incorrect translation, many often refer to 39:42 and 6:60 where Allah uses the same word for capturing the soul while asleep. The fact that is ignored is that Allah uses the word to capture the souls, not the body. But for 5:116, they say that the whole body was ascended which is clearly an incorrect translation.
To further justify the true meaning of the word “TAWAFFAITANI”, Imam Bukhari has also mentioned a reference to Ibne Abbas R.A. who has clearly said that the word means death. Ibne Abbas, a companion of high stature, a cousin of the Prophet Mohammad ﷺ, and one through whom hundreds of hadees are narrated, surely it was a very wise act of imam Bukhari to mention his translation. Some scholars get confused and say that this is a week hadees because it has no number. Please note that this translation of Ibne Abbas is not a hadees, that’s why it has no number. It was the wisdom of Imam Bukhari to mention this translation so that people don’t look further and get misguided by other scholars.
The death of Eisa A.S. is also confirmed by the Hadith related to the incident of Miraj where the Prophet Mohammad ﷺ met with Eisa A.S. along with the prophets. We all know that the other prophets died right here in this earth and their bodies were also buried right here on this earth. So, when the Prophet Mohammad ﷺ met with the other prophets, their existence must be in some spiritual form which is after death. And to say that Eisa A.S. was able to exist in that place with his actual body sounds absurd.
I wanna contact you directly. Can you please come in a direct contact contact with me. Your justifications are satisfying thus I need some answers.
👍👍👍
Isa is dead in 5:117, and dead never return; and also Bukharti writes: Ibn Abbas said that meaning of Wafat is death. This Mirza is a Bigggg liar
You are absolutely right brother.
You say as if you know for fact that he is alive. Only Allah best knows the fact. No human can claim that. Unless its proven by the Holy Quran. My argument is based on the Holy Quran. Your argument is totally subjective and influenced by scholars.
ماشاءاللّٰه
Beshak Hazrat Isa Zaroor Duniya main wapis Ayenge Kyu ki ALLAH ne Quran main unka wapsi ka zikar Kiya aur Humare Pyare Nabi Pak ne bhut se Ahadees Farmai Hain
Quran ki knsi ayat ma howa ha ? Hazrat Isa ka zikr to boht jaga aya ha Quran ma lakin unki wapsi ka zikr mjy nai mila, apki nazr ma aya to zaroor btaiye yha
@@Screen-Explainedquran mai kisi chz ka na hona itna strong arguement nai h k aap sahih ahadess ka inkar krden
Very good explanation JazakAllah
Kindly make a video on students , how to excel in education and motivation from Hades's and Qur'an . engineer Saab, this is my request from past several months.kindlly do make a video .on this topic.
@@sadiqmohiuddin8660 g bilkul theek kh rhe hain ap.
Sir with due respect apka argument kamzoor hai.
Beshmar ahadees hai apka dimag to thek hai ya ap munkir e hadees hai
Waaaaao what a great analysis i do appreciate bro.
Ap ka samjane ka tarika buhat Acha g allha ap ko salamt rakhy ☺️👌
💓💓
اللہ اپکو کامیاب کرے۔۔
Ali Bhai ap apny purany lectures i.e masla no. Dobara se record krwa rhy hain I think due to camera 📸 issues those days
Ghamidi Sahab Kay unn aitrazaat ko kindly address karain Jo wo ab detail main Bata rahay hain hasan ilyas Kay sath
Quraan is very clear about ESA'S wafaat
Ghamdi is clear mirza bss rawayat follow kr raha hai
You're a great great guy. May God bless u
Ghamidhi SB. will be coming with this Question's answer this month on his RUclips channel "Ghamidhi center of Islamic learning". "Response to 23 questions"..So let us see what he will say and should we accept it...
In Sha Allah
my favorite aalim is you love from Nepal
Deen e Islam boht asaan hai samjhane Wala Ali Bhai jesa ho.... allah jazye Khair de
Next January coming back in Pakistan to meet with Ali bhai for more lesson
Salam Ali Bhai, JazakAllah for ur efforts for unity among Muslims. I have heard your arguments (dalail) regarding this issue and also ghamidi sbs and I wasn't convinced by this and your detailed mas'ala regarding this topic. JazakAllah Wa Salam
You should be convinced by the ijma of the ummat. By millions of scholars where gamdibis the fist to deny in this issue. It is clearly in Quran that he was taken up in the skies. Come to the main body of the ummah. You don't have to bear the burden of reading thousands of arguements on every single issue
So you will decide for yourself rather than accept abu huraira (r.a). For this you would have to be an extraordinary genius, a very old scholar and Arabic master. Lets accept the authority.
Bibi mazloom
46.01
سورت الزمر 39
آیات 42
لفظ ( یتوفی) ترجمہ (موت, قبض کرنا)
مرزا صاحب آپ کا جھوٹ پکڑا گیا ہے یہ جو آپ ترجمہ یا معنی کر رہے سوائے شعیہ کے ایک مولوی کے سب نے اس کا ترجمہ (موت) ہی کیا ہے, خدا کے عذاب سے ڈرو مولوی اپنی مرضی کے ترجم مت کرو قرآن کے.
گدھے آدمی یہاں جو تم ترجمہ مختلف کر رہے اسکا حکم کیا اللہ نے دیا ہے؟ یا اسکے رسول نے دیا ہے؟ تمہاری ساری باتیں کہانی سے زیادہ کچھ بھی نہیں.
جن مفسرین نے اسکا ترجمہ موت کیا ہے انکے نام یہ ہیں اور یہ پڑھ کر ڈوب مرنا اگر شرم ہوئی تو.
1-ڈاکڑ اسرار
2- امام راغب
3- امین اسلہی
4- طاہر القادری
5- نگیت ہاشمی
6- مولانا مودودی
7- کنزل المان
8- جونا گری
9- تاقی عثمانی
حرام خور مولوی اگر اسکا ترجمہ پورا پورا لینا ہے تو ان سب نے غلط ترجمہ کیوں ہے؟؟
آج سے نفرت ہو گئی تمہارا سفید جھوٹ پکڑ کر, مولوی تم اپنے چیلوں کو کہنا تھا کہ قران کھول کر ایک بار خود پڑھ لیں.
@@abdullahqureshi4750 there is no word for “taking up in skies” in quran
Ye to ilmi-kitabi guftagu ni hy Ali bhai..
Quran ar hadith ki authenticity ka level kesy ek jesa ho skta hy?
Kamaal krty hen ap
Kaisy aik nae hai. Explain bhai.
@@DataMaster786 because Allah himself has taken responsibility to protect Quran where hadiths are compiled 200 years after death of Prophet. And they are compiled by human beings so their are always chances of human errors. That's why their are sahih hadiths and zaeef hadees. Even sahih hadiths can't be 100% assure as sahih and we've to judge them through Qur'an and Sunnah. Qur'an and Sunnah are preserved through "Amli tawatar" of muslims
@@mohsinrehman3026quran mai kisi cheez ka na hone k mtlb ye nai k aap sahih ul asnad ahadees ka inkar krden
Engineer Mirza Muhammad Ali ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Beshak ALLAH paak he sab ko puch sakty Ankho sy ansoo aa gay apki bat sun kr ALLAH paak meri Jaaan hain😢😭😭😭
Masha Allah
Masha Allah
Jazza k Allah
Pura concept hi clear hogaya. Allah apko jannat me special mukaam ata farmaye... Ameen. Apke wajah se deen samjh me aagaya h sahi rasta. Bas aplog sab se guzarish h mere liye amal ki dua kare..
agar aur clear karna hai to Ghamadi sahab ki 23 aitrazat ki video dekh lan "Return of Jesus" par yaa phir Mufti abu layth ki
ماشاءالله حلو
Mashallah,From Mumbai.
Jazakaallahu khaira WA ahasanul jaza
Masha Allah😍
Plz AGR ap en ko sun rahy hain to ek bar ghamidi sab ko b un ki zabani sun lain aur pir faisala karay yai to insaf ho ga.jazak Allah. ALLAH Pak hum sab par rehm farmaye
Good
Ameen
Ghamdi school of thought ko bhi sun chuke han. Mehanti admi han. Intellectual bhi han. lekin Unki bunyadi fikar ma hi fault ha.Unhon na Islam ko nai sire sa Bayan krna ki koshish ki ha apna faham ka mutabik isliye inki baton aur ummat ka aqaid ma behad farq ha.
@@islamicvideos9788 Apni apni understanding ha.mujy to asa bilkul nhi laga.lakin per b ap ki jananay ki koshash ko salam.
@@AdilHussain-uc1xz SALAM
yahi to bat ha har bnda khara ho kr apni apni understanding ko deen ma add krta ha jis waja sa aj itna firqa han. Ghamdi sahab ki bunyadi fiqr agar apko nai pata to phir ap khud sun len unhon na DEEN ko nae tareeka sa dor e hazir ka mutabik apni soch sa explain kia ha. jab keh PROPHET MUHAMMAD PBUH qayamat tk hona wale mamlaat ka bta gae.
بدلے گا زمانہ قرآن نہیں بدلا جاۓ گا۔
ہے قولِ محمد قولِ خدا اور فرمان نہیں بدلا جاۓ گا۔
I would suggest you to start another english channel in which give all of your lectures and explanation in english .This will be help ful for a huge audience of english speaking and non muslims.
Ali bhai Sureh maida k akhiri ruku me jo word aya hai falamma tawaffaitani ke word ka sahi tarjuma kya hoga ? aap ye word ka mtlb samjhaye aapne apni bat aage badhadi or point clear nh kiya. plz clear kare
Very nice preach Allah ap ko khush rakhey
Jazakallah for exposing the truth.
please do yourself a favour and copy the arabic word for "took me up" ( تَوَفَّيتَني ) and type it in Google translator or in any other online translator and find out what the truth is.
Jesus AS is dead and Not coming back!
Taking one's soul or body and soul are completely two different things!
@@TariQ-nx3uz its about death after second coming, not the first ascent. Jazakallah
@@ezekiel.1801 could you please translate 5: 117 from Quran for me?
@@TariQ-nx3uz ok i ll dear
It translates as
I didn't tell unto them except for which You had commanded me to do that is to worship ALLAH my Lord and your Lord, and i was witness unto them as far as i was among them, but when you completed my time then You were Witnessing them, and You are Witness upon everything.
The term wafaat doesn't specifically mean death only, it refers to the completion of term or time.
اِذۡ قَالَ اللّٰہُ یٰعِیۡسٰۤی اِنِّیۡ مُتَوَفِّیۡکَ وَ رَافِعُکَ اِلَیَّ وَ مُطَہِّرُکَ مِنَ الَّذِیۡنَ کَفَرُوۡا وَ جَاعِلُ الَّذِیۡنَ اتَّبَعُوۡکَ فَوۡقَ الَّذِیۡنَ کَفَرُوۡۤا اِلٰی یَوۡمِ الۡقِیٰمَۃِ ۚ ثُمَّ اِلَیَّ مَرۡجِعُکُمۡ فَاَحۡکُمُ بَیۡنَکُمۡ فِیۡمَا کُنۡتُمۡ فِیۡہِ تَخۡتَلِفُوۡنَ ﴿۵۶﴾
جب اللہ نے کہا اے عیسیٰ! یقیناً میں تجھے وفات دینے والا ہوں اور اپنی طرف تیرا رفع کرنے والا ہوں اور تجھے ان لوگوں سے نتھار کر الگ کرنے والا ہوں جو کافر ہوئے، اور ان لوگوں کو جنہوں نے تیری پیروی کی ہے ان لوگوں پر جنہوں نے انکار کیا ہے قیامت کے دن تک بالادست کرنے والا ہوں۔ پھر میری ہی طرف تمہارا لوٹ کر آنا ہے جس کے بعد میں تمہارے درمیان اُن باتوں کا فیصلہ کروں گا جن میں تم اختلاف کیا کرتے تھے۔
جزاک اللہ۔۔۔۔
Masha Allah bless on you Ali Bhai Aameen ❤️
Sir
Make a lecture on choosing a good spouse
Please watch the new series of ghamidi sb." Responsed to 23 questions " ghamidi sb very well explained this issue and given a very strong evidence
Ghamidi sb's view is more strong
Exactly...
Whatever Ghamdi says doesnt mean its true..... "Hadith
حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا اللَّيْثُ، عَنِ ابْنِ شِهَابٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ الْمُسَيَّبِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ أَبَا هُرَيْرَةَ ـ رضى الله عنه ـ يَقُولُ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم
وَالَّذِي نَفْسِي بِيَدِهِ لَيُوشِكَنَّ أَنْ يَنْزِلَ فِيكُمُ ابْنُ مَرْيَمَ حَكَمًا مُقْسِطًا فَيَكْسِرَ الصَّلِيبَ، وَيَقْتُلَ الْخِنْزِيرَ، وَيَضَعَ الْجِزْيَةَ، وَيَفِيضَ الْمَالُ حَتَّى لاَ يَقْبَلَهُ أَحَدٌ "
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "By Him in Whose Hands my soul is, son of Mary (Jesus) will shortly descend amongst you people (Muslims) as a just ruler and will break the Cross and kill the pig and abolish the Jizya (a tax taken from the non-Muslims, who are in the protection, of the Muslim government). Then there will be Abundance of money and nobody will accept charitable gifts.
Sahih al-Bukhari 2222
In-book : Book 34, Hadith 169
USC-MSA web (English) : Vol. 3, Book 34, Hadith 425 (deprecated)
Sahih Bukhari
What about sahih Muslim hadees 2897? Please explain also this?
@@ridudragneel219 my dear brother your knowledge in ahadith is amazing( may Allah reward you) it states clearly in the end of the hadith you mentioned that Allah will use Hazrat Isa(AS) to kill dajal and his lance(weapon) will have the blood of the enemys of Allah on it.
@@ridudragneel219 please also remember that ghamdi sahb is only a human not a prophet and thus can not be trusted in every afair, the returning of Hazrat Isa AS has been told by prophet Muhammad SAW and has been confirmed by the sahaba and their students (the greatest scholars of all time) and also by the scholars of today(mufti tariq masood and engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza) One person saying opposite to what all of the above said won't change anything
Allah Pak hum sub ko hidayat ataa farmaye
Please upload English subtitle if possible for all of your video. Specially this one. Zaja kallah...
Love From Sukkur Sindh
سب سے بہترین بات تو یہ ہے کہ آپ جاوید احمد غامدی کے ساتھ بیٹھیں اور آمنے سامنے دلائل سے بات کریں اور انھیں قائل کریں اور غلط ثابت کریں