Nothing gives a user more hope than to see the engineers actually USE the tools and understand what needs to be done. I initially tried using the NLA purely for animation and layering but went back to straight animating on the timeline for the reasons outlined in this talk. Namely that once a characters animation is a clip, it drastically slows down the iteration workflow. Also the ability to align two clips around any control on the rig would make it infinitely more useful.
Really excellent talk/workshop. Brad is such a great teacher. Pointing out what can be improved about the NLA while making people excited to dive into it. ❤❤❤
Hi, I'm using NLA and baking quite often, what I really would like is a bake function in which if a channell is transferred untouched (and controlled by two keyframes only, in example) it gets baked with the same two keyframes only, not with a key on every frame. This would help me a lot in terms of editing speed, because in my workflow i use baking during the animation process, not only at the end of the session. Thank you for your attention.
Thanks to this, I finally understand how to use it. However, the animation layers plugin is just much better to speed up the workflow process. The joke about geometry nodes was unexpected but very appreciated ! :D
Ok so it was not just me, I did some basic things in the NLA editor, it took me quite some time to find out how it works and I still did not understand 100% the idea behind it. A very confusing editor, I'm sure its very powerful if you really understand it, I'm just an amateur creating a simple animation every now and then. At the moment I'm scared to use it 😆, since its easy to mess things up that already worked. Numerous times I was pretty lost, using this editor. But I understand without this editor complex animations are not feasible.
@@GoldCountryballs All animation in Blender is stored in an Action. The NLA can help you combine them or you can mix between the current action aka "keyframes on the control" with the strips in the NLA that point to the other actions that are in the Scene but not active on the rig.
I recall spending half a year trying to learn NLA in cinema 4d, I liked the idea of combining mixamo animation which was providing free motion capture animation, and creating custom motion capture facial animation I would record with my iPhone, , and editing these animations in the timeline to make it even more unique. But damn the timeline was so full with animation keyframes it seemed impossible. But it the idea seemed so intuiative. Combining all animations and editing them further, seamlessly. And blender really out here making that a feasible approach. Thanks Bois
I have been so frustrated with NLA, but spent last couple of days watching a ton of tutorials, I think I am starting to get the hang of it. Will see, I am glad to hear you speak and sound's like you are going to help improve it. I been to Weta Studios (not in the studios but their gift shop). The Hobbit was seven days from being completed. We watched the film they show. A couple of days later my daughter said she wanted to go to work for Weta. When we got back to the U.S. we had a message from AI (art institute). We enrolled our daughter. She won a couple of prestigious awards. She was in the graphic art, though their was a teacher who practically begged her to come animation department as a story boarder. She is a fantastic artist but head strong like me. lol... Even though she didn't go to work for Weta she immediately was able to fill much needed spot in our church and has been working there every since. I believe God used Weta to speak to our daughter because He knew that there was going to be a need. It is a job. I think it would of been awesome if she did get to work for Weta or Dream Works or whatever.
NLA is great when you have to deal with a single armature but when you start using multiple ones (people interaction for instance) mixed with some shapekeys, it become quite a nightmare to use :(
Great talk ! Thank you very much for that ! 💖 You should have a look at the motion mixer tool from Lightwave 3D, it could give you some more ideas. The concept of actors for example is really useful and could be a great addition to NLA.
i have an animation in a t pose and at frame 30 it starts to move, so how do i only select a certain amount of keyframe animation to be repeated but still include the t pose ?
![Lethal Company Music Video 🎵 "Follow The Orders" [VERSION A]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QeooZB4Z7RA/mqdefault.jpg)
So glad I watched this, if only for the explanation of 'push down'. I was thinking the clips ended up on the same pile as the default cube.
Nothing gives a user more hope than to see the engineers actually USE the tools and understand what needs to be done. I initially tried using the NLA purely for animation and layering but went back to straight animating on the timeline for the reasons outlined in this talk. Namely that once a characters animation is a clip, it drastically slows down the iteration workflow. Also the ability to align two clips around any control on the rig would make it infinitely more useful.
Really excellent talk/workshop. Brad is such a great teacher. Pointing out what can be improved about the NLA while making people excited to dive into it. ❤❤❤
Thank you!!
Good talk, I am very happy Brad Clark is part of the effort to evolve the Blender animation tools.
I know this NLA talk will get very far in the industry. Thank you Sir @Clark for an amazing conference. Point on.
Hi, I'm using NLA and baking quite often, what I really would like is a bake function in which if a channell is transferred untouched (and controlled by two keyframes only, in example) it gets baked with the same two keyframes only, not with a key on every frame. This would help me a lot in terms of editing speed, because in my workflow i use baking during the animation process, not only at the end of the session. Thank you for your attention.
Thank you, you aren't the only one that wants this. I will add it to the NLA roadmap.
Thanks to this, I finally understand how to use it. However, the animation layers plugin is just much better to speed up the workflow process. The joke about geometry nodes was unexpected but very appreciated ! :D
Whoah, I was using NLA for exporting and for managing exports, but that trick with separate Scene for Export is gold. Thanks!
Ok so it was not just me, I did some basic things in the NLA editor, it took me quite some time to find out how it works and I still did not understand 100% the idea behind it. A very confusing editor, I'm sure its very powerful if you really understand it, I'm just an amateur creating a simple animation every now and then. At the moment I'm scared to use it 😆, since its easy to mess things up that already worked. Numerous times I was pretty lost, using this editor. But I understand without this editor complex animations are not feasible.
Very confused, why can't NLA and keyframes be mixed and edited like iclone, does every small adjustment of NLA need to be made into action clips?
@@GoldCountryballs All animation in Blender is stored in an Action. The NLA can help you combine them or you can mix between the current action aka "keyframes on the control" with the strips in the NLA that point to the other actions that are in the Scene but not active on the rig.
I recall spending half a year trying to learn NLA in cinema 4d,
I liked the idea of combining mixamo animation which was providing free motion capture animation, and creating custom motion capture facial animation I would record with my iPhone, , and editing these animations in the timeline to make it even more unique. But damn the timeline was so full with animation keyframes it seemed impossible.
But it the idea seemed so intuiative. Combining all animations and editing them further, seamlessly. And blender really out here making that a feasible approach. Thanks Bois
Thanks for pointing out the full stack feature, it was driving me mad not having (knowing) it
Thank you @CGDive
I have been so frustrated with NLA, but spent last couple of days watching a ton of tutorials, I think I am starting to get the hang of it. Will see, I am glad to hear you speak and sound's like you are going to help improve it. I been to Weta Studios (not in the studios but their gift shop). The Hobbit was seven days from being completed. We watched the film they show. A couple of days later my daughter said she wanted to go to work for Weta. When we got back to the U.S. we had a message from AI (art institute). We enrolled our daughter. She won a couple of prestigious awards. She was in the graphic art, though their was a teacher who practically begged her to come animation department as a story boarder. She is a fantastic artist but head strong like me. lol... Even though she didn't go to work for Weta she immediately was able to fill much needed spot in our church and has been working there every since. I believe God used Weta to speak to our daughter because He knew that there was going to be a need. It is a job. I think it would of been awesome if she did get to work for Weta or Dream Works or whatever.
NLA is great when you have to deal with a single armature but when you start using multiple ones (people interaction for instance) mixed with some shapekeys, it become quite a nightmare to use :(
Awesome, thanks!
Blender is awesome👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 just like maya❤ I wonder how blender isn't concerned about making money😮 God bless your team
Great talk ! Thank you very much for that !
💖
You should have a look at the motion mixer tool from Lightwave 3D, it could give you some more ideas. The concept of actors for example is really useful and could be a great addition to NLA.
Good humor, i like these talks with jokes
OMG 🙀 the guy from rigging dojo great.!!
very good presentation. @39:30 says it all. I don't care about this. nice addon
i have an animation in a t pose and at frame 30 it starts to move, so how do i only select a certain amount of keyframe animation to be repeated but still include the t pose ?
You would have to duplicate linked the clip and then trim the tpose from it then repeat that
Criminally few laughs for some funny jokes.