Je suis brésilienne et quand j'ai vu votre vidéo transformation de la terrasse, j'ai été enchantée par votre travail. Et des idées magnifiques et excellentes. J'ai une terrasse et je veux utiliser votre idée pratique. Toutes nos félicitations!
To translate from some of the comments below: A lot of people are worried about the WEIGHT this has added to the terrace. I don't see it becoming a problem for 2 reasons; 1) the heaviest items seem to have been placed near the strongest parts of the structure --- near walls and corners. 2) Judging from the clever choice of plants, someone knows what they're doing; i.e. probably using very light soil mix in small quantities. Best growth will occur if this is designed for 'flood and flush'. In other words, the soil is never allowed to get saturated, heavy and mucky. Some comments in Spanish concerned the loss of the view, the panorama; followed by a pithy retort about the need for intimacy. I feel that the design strikes a good balance: height on each end for privacy, and to break the wind; and a bit of a view above the railing. It hasn't blocked any famous Paris landmarks. Someone commented that while out-of-towners find the rooftops of Paris to be of great beauty, a Parisian might not. I did ask, below, why the original paving-stone walking surface hadn't been left alone ... and others also commented on this. To be fair, the new floor may be hiding a new drainage system for the planters. I did question the use of so much Redwood (Sequoia). True, it is resistant to rot, but its being over-harvested in Calif. and takes centuries to grow. Its also much higher maintenance than lumber companies would have us believe, especially for decking. In 2019, a greener choice might be the no-skid, never-rot planking made from recycled plastic. I very much like the solid-colour wood panels that were used on the two end walls here. I've heard it called 'smart board', ( maybe because its easy on the environment ) ... but I don't know what they call it in France. There are many catty comments about things which are simply a matter of taste. What makes this a good design are the proportions and the clean lines. Terrace gardens are too often silly or sissy-looking ..... which this is not.
If responsible adults and no children are allowed out there it’s a wonderful spot but don’t we all have that one friend or family member who goes too far? It is a very nice area though. Good job French Man!
Safety rails are specifically set to a safe height to stop people from accidentally falling and younger children climbing. The floor has been raised and a permanent planter built along the front which would almost certainly make it illegal, regardless of how much or little someone had to drink.
C'est magnifique. I'm from Ireland (je suis Irlandaise et je ne parle no ecrit bien francais. Merci beaucoup pour cette video. Queal transformation. Formidable.
S Lars comme je l’ai dis dans d’autre commentaires , les rampes on été rehaussées après le chantier . Toute les rambardes de l’immeuble on été changer .
Seeing people build such beautiful things from scratch makes me hold such enormous amount of respect for them. The very sight of a tool box gives me anxiety. I wish I had such talent 😔
It's a terrace, not a balcony, so I think that there's a regular flat beneath it. It's like a flat part on the roof. (If you pause at 0:19, you can see a railing in the right upper corner, that's another terrace)
Beautiful home. ...very lucky and fortunate!!! I'd probably keep the depth and instal some steps down.... it feels like a lot of wasted space was created.
de toute manière les plantes vont pousser au niveau de la barrière, donc pas de risqu, à moins de courir en plein dedans, mais après, ça s'appelel de la sélection naturelle dans ce cas là
J'ai pensé a la même chose que toi mes rehaussé la terrasse me paraissez logique, il a fait du bon travail. Par contre ces un entretien les plantes courage a la propriétaire.
👍👍👍👍👍💜😅 j'ai visionné cette vidéo je suis nouvelle magnifique et j'ai visionné les trois ou quatre ans après pour refaire les plantations je suis effaré subjugué par votre encore félicitations nous sommes en 2021 et je vais encore et encore vous admirez continuer
Bravo Marvin ! J'adore tes vidéos. C'est du beau boulot ! Belle idée de surélever la terrasse pour ne pas avoir à enjamber le bas de la fenêtre coulissante.
Why? Do you fear he might hit his head on the sky? This way it is at least flush with the doorstep and he could hide the cables for the lights under it.
DoctorExitus There's only one way to touch the sky, doctor ;). But I see there's an awning, I wouldn't want to have it close. Other reasons: Accumulation of dust and dirt underneath have you thought? What about overweighted guests, or a bunch of people together? I am not lazy but longterm it becomes undesirable/unpleaseant to go outside just because you have to make an effort (big upstep out) to have access to your own terrace imo.
Are you following safety construction codes. Railing is too low and is the rain water going to accumulate below the wood floor. Looks nice but I think the weight structure might be over the balcony weight capacity. Danger! Danger! Danger! Mister Robin
Gianfranco Sale ok. Fine. It is a Terrace. BUT...that railing is way too low for that elevated floor. Also, try to correct people and teach them rather than ask weird questions. Not helpful.
If you had bothered to translate the creator's comments, you'd know that all the railings in the building were changed (that is something that is done as a whole, decided on by the owners of all the apartments, and you can't just change the railing when you want to) and they had taken this into account when doing this renovation.
1 - there's enough weight for the terrace to hold. 2 - sacrificed height to the sky??? (if anything, they gained more fresh air) 3 - Railings were supposed to be changed in the whole building a few weeks after this build 4 - Build a half wall to eliminate people staring at you from the street and the buildings on the side. There's enough light because guess what... It's outside
Je viens de tomber à tout hasard sur tes Vidéos tu fais un travail de ouf qui défonce sachant que tu es tout seul bravo à toi toutes mes félicitations continues comme ça tu déchire deux ouf 🤗🤗
C’est très sympa 😉 Par contre je m’interroge par rapport à l’écoulement des eaux en cas de pluie, elles doivent se faire emprisonner et stagner entre la terrasse d’origine et les lames en bois non?
Oui c'est jolie sur le coup mais sur le long terme ça ne tient pas, aussi la hauteur du sol rehaussé fait que la barrière de protection du balcon se retrouve beaucoup trop basse ce qui est extrêmement dangereux..
@@dioeilmiogiuramento5506 c'est toi le débile la y' a pas de trou vu que c'est une rambarde en fer , elle a raison car en mettant les bacs a fleurs plus bas que la terrasse et en mettant une bâche géotextile il a boucher toute la terrasse et l'eau stagnera quand il pleuvra et feras une piscine si il pleut beaucoup.
the balcony is very nice, thank you very much, i would like to ask where the drainage is in case of heavy rain. Thank you again and best wishes to you.
The result is beautiful I am concerned how long it will last, I'm not sure about the waterproofing beneath the terrace, this whole thing may rot very fast
C'est tres bel a voir, mais le point negatif plus grave est que c'est trop de poids pour la structure ancienne. La terre des plantes et la pluie sont une combi fatal, comme tous les installations. Aussi la pauvre barriere de fer. Cette maison est tres probablement protegee pour sa structure. Si c'est passe qlc chose tu serais en matiere brune....
Antes era mejor porque podias mirar el panorama completo y ahora puso un muro y plantas pero te hace sentir encerrado. Antes conectabas la vista al panorama :(
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa pensé que era la única!!! Es PARISSSSS osea lo que más se busca ahí es la vista, y dónde quedó la vista?! En Francia son súper caros los departamentos y ellos sacrificaron muchísimo espacio!! 🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦
Estoy d'accuerdo que la panorama esta importante. No se pierda intimidad si hacen una apertura adonde no hay plantas. Esto que me molesta es el cambio de piso. En total la selecion de plantas y los proportiones del deseno son formidable.
très beau mais il a mis de nombreuses plantes tropicales qui ne résisteront pas au froid de l'hiver, qu'arrive-t-il à ce sol en cas de pluie, comment fonctionne le drainage?
I question putting down plastic on top of the floor under the new wood floor. Why? The cement floor apparently drains fine, and water will get trapped underneath the plastic. Also, I don't see why the need to raise the floor so much. With drainage already achieved with the original floor, only an inch or so is necessary to put in an attractive floor, or you could have been creative coloring the existing floor. Looks very nice.
![ROSÉ(로제) - APT. (Band VER.) (With. 이영지) [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IW8qaemx74g/mqdefault.jpg)
Je suis brésilienne et quand j'ai vu votre vidéo transformation de la terrasse, j'ai été enchantée par votre travail. Et des idées magnifiques et excellentes. J'ai une terrasse et je veux utiliser votre idée pratique. Toutes nos félicitations!
To translate from some of the comments below:
A lot of people are worried about the WEIGHT this has added to the terrace. I don't see it becoming a problem for 2 reasons; 1) the heaviest items seem to have been placed near the strongest parts of the structure --- near walls and corners. 2) Judging from the clever choice of plants, someone knows what they're doing; i.e. probably using very light soil mix in small quantities. Best growth will occur if this is designed for 'flood and flush'. In other words, the soil is never allowed to get saturated, heavy and mucky.
Some comments in Spanish concerned the loss of the view, the panorama; followed by a pithy retort about the need for intimacy. I feel that the design strikes a good balance: height on each end for privacy, and to break the wind; and a bit of a view above the railing. It hasn't blocked any famous Paris landmarks. Someone commented that while out-of-towners find the rooftops of Paris to be of great beauty, a Parisian might not.
I did ask, below, why the original paving-stone walking surface hadn't been left alone ... and others also commented on this. To be fair, the new floor may be hiding a new drainage system for the planters.
I did question the use of so much Redwood (Sequoia). True, it is resistant to rot, but its being over-harvested in Calif. and takes centuries to grow. Its also much higher maintenance than lumber companies would have us believe, especially for decking. In 2019, a greener choice might be the no-skid, never-rot planking made from recycled plastic.
I very much like the solid-colour wood panels that were used on the two end walls here. I've heard it called 'smart board', ( maybe because its easy on the environment ) ... but I don't know what they call it in France.
There are many catty comments about things which are simply a matter of taste. What makes this a good design are the proportions and the clean lines. Terrace gardens are too often silly or sissy-looking ..... which this is not.
A lot of work! This guy deserves and award!!!
En un seul mot … j’adore. Travail très bien exécuté, avec beaucoup de goût et d’imaginations …Bravo
Looks nice but the terrace balustrade is too low now, you rise too much the floor! It could be dangerous, be carefully!
He can’t even walk to the front since plants cover it now
Camila Díaz Campos stfu dipshit
@@hassankhokhar204 Obviously, Muslim "men" (or boys) cannot talk to women on eye level.
If responsible adults and no children are allowed out there it’s a wonderful spot but don’t we all have that one friend or family member who goes too far? It is a very nice area though. Good job French Man!
I was thinking the same. The floor is too high right now. However, the video has a lot of good points and some good lessons like “do not do that”.
I think the planter boxes create distance from the rail so that falling off is unlikely, much more private. Super amazing job, awesome view!
beautiful but the railings are way too low. C'est dangereux.!
This is all I thought throughout the video!!!
cattuccino fung even worst in the opera garnier.
If someone falls of they're too drunk.
Safety rails are specifically set to a safe height to stop people from accidentally falling and younger children climbing. The floor has been raised and a permanent planter built along the front which would almost certainly make it illegal, regardless of how much or little someone had to drink.
Need taller plants!
Nossa,a gente daqui vê vídeos como esse,ficamos encantados com tanta habilidade e perfeição. Parabéns ficou ótimo
C'est magnifique. I'm from Ireland (je suis Irlandaise et je ne parle no ecrit bien francais. Merci beaucoup pour cette video. Queal transformation. Formidable.
DANGEREUX! La rampe n'est pas à une hauteur légale. Autrement, c'est très beau.
Un enfant de 2 ans pourrait y grimper...
Effectivement mais il peut rajouter des écrans en verre derrière les plantes. A part ca c très joli
Judith Stuart not everybody has kids!
Of course. And the makeover is lovely.
S Lars comme je l’ai dis dans d’autre commentaires , les rampes on été rehaussées après le chantier . Toute les rambardes de l’immeuble on été changer .
Great work! I can not understand why people give this video a thumb down.
It's a beautiful patio love all the plants you never can have enough. Fantastic job👍
Seeing people build such beautiful things from scratch makes me hold such enormous amount of respect for them.
The very sight of a tool box gives me anxiety. I wish I had such talent 😔
J’aime voir ton projet se réaliser en accéléré ; le résultat final est toujours une agréable surprise !
On the end, where the black wall is, you've lost the long view. I would have kept the long view instead of boxing it in.
Was that balcony designed to handle all that extra weight?
That's what occurred to my mind, too. But the balcony is beautiful, however!
It's not hanging out of the building.....so it should be able to hold much more than this actually 🙂
It's a terrace, not a balcony, so I think that there's a regular flat beneath it. It's like a flat part on the roof. (If you pause at 0:19, you can see a railing in the right upper corner, that's another terrace)
I thought the same. Here, in Brazil, it is forbiden...
lol my first thoughts too, and I was like I can’t be the only one who questioned this 😉
Balcony transformation is amazing 💕
Un changement remarquable. Excellente performance vraiment impressionnante.
C'est un truc de fou ce que t'arrive à faire. j'ai déjà vu plusieurs de tes vidéos et vraiment tu fais un travaille Magnifique. Bravo!!!
Merci beaucoup je suis ravis que sa vous plaise ! merci merci merci !!!
Where water from the plants go after rain or watering? Is there a drainage system?
Bravo MARVIN pour cette superbe terrasse !!! Quel talent!! 😉💙👍
Très belle. Les plantes la donnent une atmosphère très moderne et élégante. Aussi le parquet.
C'est vraiment du HYPER beau boulot! Continue de nous émerveiller, c'est top!
Woow very beautiful, I love terraces full of plants
Очень здорово получилось! Много зелени, дерева. Хочешь - солнышко, хочешь - тенек! Вот что значит когда руки растут из нужного места
Un travail de titan, très beau rendu. Tu dois apprécier le temps que tu passes sur ta terrasse.
C'est vraiment splendide ! BRAVO !
Beautiful home. ...very lucky and fortunate!!! I'd probably keep the depth and instal some steps down.... it feels like a lot of wasted space was created.
Pourquoi surélever autant la terrasse ça m’a l’air hyper haut quand on regarde l’ancienne barrière en métal
ju SOC c ce que je me suis dis aussi
Pour que la terrasse arrive au niveau de la baie vitré , là cliente ne voulait surtout pas de marche ou autre
de toute manière les plantes vont pousser au niveau de la barrière, donc pas de risqu, à moins de courir en plein dedans, mais après, ça s'appelel de la sélection naturelle dans ce cas là
J'ai pensé a la même chose que toi mes rehaussé la terrasse me paraissez logique, il a fait du bon travail. Par contre ces un entretien les plantes courage a la propriétaire.
@@LolHawXGaMinG 😂😂
👍👍👍👍👍💜😅 j'ai visionné cette vidéo je suis nouvelle magnifique et j'ai visionné les trois ou quatre ans après pour refaire les plantations je suis effaré subjugué par votre encore félicitations nous sommes en 2021 et je vais encore et encore vous admirez continuer
Bravo!!! Beaucoup de taff qui en valait la peine
C'est splendide Marvin ! Tu es vraiment très doué.
Merci vraiment .. ça me motive tellement ! ..
Magnifique je suis sous le charme de la transformation 😍😍😍
Super beau boulot.quel talent
Cependant je trouve ça dommage d’enlever tant d espace.
Et le sol paraît beaucoup sureleve par rapport au départ
Hard working people are always getting rewarded
with good and beautiful things as they deserved.
Thanks ...enjoyed very much
Looks great!!
but... I wanted to see it at night with all lights on 😢
Bravo Marvin ! J'adore tes vidéos. C'est du beau boulot ! Belle idée de surélever la terrasse pour ne pas avoir à enjamber le bas de la fenêtre coulissante.
I can't believe you sacrifice like 30 cm of floor height to put your stave floor!
Why? Do you fear he might hit his head on the sky? This way it is at least flush with the doorstep and he could hide the cables for the lights under it.
DoctorExitus There's only one way to touch the sky, doctor ;).
But I see there's an awning, I wouldn't want to have it close. Other reasons: Accumulation of dust and dirt underneath have you thought? What about overweighted guests, or a bunch of people together? I am not lazy but longterm it becomes undesirable/unpleaseant to go outside just because you have to make an effort (big upstep out) to have access to your own terrace imo.
Bartolomeo J. Simpson French people aren't overweight to a point where they'd break a deck.
Idk, could humidity make it a flabbier parquet along the time? I don't remember seeing an outside stave before, maybe there's a reason….
@@aolbeto(must read with French accent!) Only Americans are so lazy, that 1 step up would prevent some of them from not enjoying the outdoors.
Travail remarquable ! Félicitations
Superb and very #impressive 😍😍😍
I love your idea of adding some plants.
That is awesome and so wonderful!!!
Loving it from the Philippines!
Ça rend hyper bien et c’est hyper joli !
Beautiful! And it was also funny to watch that part where it looks like he’s sliding linearly.
C'est vraiment du bon boulot. Bravo
J'adore! Quel travail ! Bravo !
What an amazing and inspiration transformation ... love the mixture of texture, colors, above all, the greens ... bravo !!!
travail excellent woiouh!!
terrasse sublime!!
👍👏👏👏💓💓💓
C’est magnifique!!! Bravo👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Incroyable! C’est très jolie. Bravo 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Why the wood floor? The original floor was better. With the wood deck, where is the water to drain???🤔
Yes, I was already seeing a lot of Ratatouilles moving to live there 🤣
@@paulalixlix this comment just straight up killed me
tres beau travail, et les finitions paraissent parfaite bravo et surtout tu as beaucoup de courage de faire cela seul
It's beautiful, but I think a fresh coat of paint two lounge chairs would be enough
Very nice job u just added a lot of value to your house
Waaw !!! Super boulot ; ça inspire et donne envie de bricoler, j’suis jalouse !!!
🤩
Are you following safety construction codes. Railing is too low and is the rain water going to accumulate below the wood floor. Looks nice but I think the weight structure might be over the balcony weight capacity. Danger! Danger! Danger! Mister Robin
Why the hell are you all talking about a balcony? It's not a balcony, it's a terrace.
Gianfranco Sale ok. Fine. It is a Terrace. BUT...that railing is way too low for that elevated floor.
Also, try to correct people and teach them rather than ask weird questions. Not helpful.
shut the fuck up
If you had bothered to translate the creator's comments, you'd know that all the railings in the building were changed (that is something that is done as a whole, decided on by the owners of all the apartments, and you can't just change the railing when you want to) and they had taken this into account when doing this renovation.
WRONGGGGGG!!!!!!!!
*Tooo much weight
*sacrifice valuable floor hight
*railing too low
*built a wall and eliminate light....
DANGER!
1 - there's enough weight for the terrace to hold.
2 - sacrificed height to the sky??? (if anything, they gained more fresh air)
3 - Railings were supposed to be changed in the whole building a few weeks after this build
4 - Build a half wall to eliminate people staring at you from the street and the buildings on the side. There's enough light because guess what... It's outside
QUE LINDO....UN CACHITO DE NATURALEZA EN TU BALCON.BUEN TRABAJO.
Marvin toujours au top 👍😋
The design is beautiful!
Je viens de tomber à tout hasard sur tes Vidéos tu fais un travail de ouf qui défonce sachant que tu es tout seul bravo à toi toutes mes félicitations continues comme ça tu déchire deux ouf 🤗🤗
Pouiki story Snapchat merci beaucoup c’est très gentil ! ☺️
Un vrai coin de paradis bravo 👏
Merci ! hésite pas à partager ! :)
BRAVOOOOO 👏👍 pour ce travail de « titan »😜😁👌
C’est très sympa 😉
Par contre je m’interroge par rapport à l’écoulement des eaux en cas de pluie, elles doivent se faire emprisonner et stagner entre la terrasse d’origine et les lames en bois non?
Anie D'Agostino oui je pense et l’eau stagnante sens pas la rose
Oui c'est jolie sur le coup mais sur le long terme ça ne tient pas, aussi la hauteur du sol rehaussé fait que la barrière de protection du balcon se retrouve beaucoup trop basse ce qui est extrêmement dangereux..
Vous êtes un peu débiles vous. Il y'a toujours des trous pour que l'eau puisse partir. Déjà fait dans les balcons. L'eau s'evacue sans problèmes.
@@dioeilmiogiuramento5506 c'est toi le débile la y' a pas de trou vu que c'est une rambarde en fer , elle a raison car en mettant les bacs a fleurs plus bas que la terrasse et en mettant une bâche géotextile il a boucher toute la terrasse et l'eau stagnera quand il pleuvra et feras une piscine si il pleut beaucoup.
@@freddymuller735 ouvre tes yeux abrutis
Watching the clouds is mesmerising
Que lindoooo! Ficou simplesmente maravilhoso! 😍
Super rénovation tu as de très bon goût !!!!!🌳🌴🌲🌳:-):-):-):-)
C'est magnifique bravo👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Bravo mon fils. Lah ybarek.
Fantastic job bravo u did it alone no help
😍😍😍
The idea and the Result so Amazing
Best Regards from Indonesia
Love it
Indy
Talentueux le petit. J'te souhaite un bel avenir.
Merci beaucoup !!! C'est tout ce que je me souhaite !
C'est incroyable! Très bien!! 😄
¡Un trabajo maravilloso!// Un travail merveilleux!// An amazing job!
So beautiful what a nice makeover i really love it!!
the balcony is very nice, thank you very much, i would like to ask where the drainage is in case of heavy rain. Thank you again and best wishes to you.
Un petit coin de paradis réalisé avec brio! Bravo à toi!
Good job. Looks premium apartment now.
The result is beautiful
I am concerned how long it will last, I'm not sure about the waterproofing beneath the terrace,
this whole thing may rot very fast
Un trabajo con mucha cariño, amé!😍😍😍😍👍
Encore admirative!!
😱😱😱tout simplement magnifique ❤
Wow incredible. Blessed hands😍😍🙌👀
Très très magnifique!!!
Waouh quel boulot de dingue tu as un vrai talents c est magnifique le rendu 🙂👏🏽
I’m too lazy to do all that but it looks really good. Greenery is key for city life. My balcony has a lot.
C'est tres bel a voir, mais le point negatif plus grave est que c'est trop de poids pour la structure ancienne. La terre des plantes et la pluie sont une combi fatal, comme tous les installations. Aussi la pauvre barriere de fer. Cette maison est tres probablement protegee pour sa structure. Si c'est passe qlc chose tu serais en matiere brune....
250 kg /m2 🤔
Antes era mejor porque podias mirar el panorama completo y ahora puso un muro y plantas pero te hace sentir encerrado. Antes conectabas la vista al panorama :(
Claudia Murillo se llama intimidad
@@MM-io5sd yo no ignoro lo que signifique intimidad solo dí mi punto de vista y dije que antes era mejor. Es mi opinión
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa pensé que era la única!!! Es PARISSSSS osea lo que más se busca ahí es la vista, y dónde quedó la vista?! En Francia son súper caros los departamentos y ellos sacrificaron muchísimo espacio!! 🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦
Estoy d'accuerdo que la panorama esta importante. No se pierda intimidad si hacen una apertura adonde no hay plantas. Esto que me molesta es el cambio de piso. En total la selecion de plantas y los proportiones del deseno son formidable.
Ahí en Paris esa vista de edificios es odiada
In Berlin this would have been a great result, but in Paris you killed the parisian charme.
"The parisian charme" 🤣🤣🤣 Non non, c'est un mythe, Paris est désormais une poubelle qui pue la pisse.
Salem j espère que tu vas bien super travail j adore quel courage j admire votre travail je m abonné tout de suite
très beau mais il a mis de nombreuses plantes tropicales qui ne résisteront pas au froid de l'hiver, qu'arrive-t-il à ce sol en cas de pluie, comment fonctionne le drainage?
Bravo bravo bravo franchement j’adore 👍
Franchement bravo c'est du très beau travail, tu t'es donné du mal et c'est très bien réussi :) Chapeau
Merci c'est vraiment très gentil !
Hermoso trabajo,saludos desde Perú.
Vraiment TOP !! Un vrai plaisir de voir tes vidéos.
genage1 merci je suis content que sa plaise ! 😍
magnifique bravo j'aime 👍👍👍👏👏
Bravo! Un bonjour de l' Australie.
Bellísimo!! felicitaciones!! 👏👏👏
I question putting down plastic on top of the floor under the new wood floor. Why? The cement floor apparently drains fine, and water will get trapped underneath the plastic. Also, I don't see why the need to raise the floor so much. With drainage already achieved with the original floor, only an inch or so is necessary to put in an attractive floor, or you could have been creative coloring the existing floor. Looks very nice.
Magnifique et bien filmé
Sei stato veramente bravissimo!!! il terrazzo è super!!! complimenti!! 🤩😍👍🏻
Magnifique. Bravo.