WAS AISHA A CHILD OR ADULT? - ALEX & ALI - SPEAKERS CORNER
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2019
- #SALAMCORNER #ALIDAWAH
Support our efforts:
www.salam.org.uk/donate/
Subscribe, share and like:
Instagram - / salam.initiative
Twitter - / initiativesalam
RUclips - / salaminitiative
Website - salam.org.uk/
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For sponsorship opportunities contact us at admin@salam.org.uk
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This guy was actually a pleasure to hear conversing with you! He was very calm and respectful!
I know!! I expected something a bit more timid or hateful out of this guy. But he truly listened and seemed to be actively participating👍
This is what I love about speakers corner when people can actually have conversations like this and it’s not about winning a debate or anything but it’s about learning about Islam and trying to understand the context of it.
It’s sad that this doesn’t happen that often in speakers corner
I acc like and respect people like that wallahi, not these hate preachers and ignorant low lives
And the woman as well
It’s more accurate to say “Arabian peninsula” than “Saudi Arabia” -- there wasn’t Saudi 1400 yrs ago
He may have done that just to help him imagine the area he was talking about
JOHN EDWARD child marriges according to who?
@@belogical2396 according to historians. And i checked it. The one about the indian guy was absolutely right. It's on google too, you can check it.
@JOHN EDWARD thanks for the knowledge.
When someone has good manners and is sincere and wants to learn. You have fruitful conversations like this. In This video this guy sounds like a good man.
I'm not a muslim and this ten seconds of the video makes so much sense 21:03
Thanks for your comment.
God bless! ❤️
keep it touch brother islam has everything that make sense :)
Asif Khan I would not go that far lol, but we both agree that god is one person not 3 so we are forever together on that stance.
@@aspreedacore brother never associate partner with God, believe in the judgement day believe in the Angels and know Muhammad p.b.u.h is the last messenger that's enough for u to get into jannah :)
Asif Khan I don’t believe in partner association with god, I’m a Unitarian Christian meaning god is a single unique being not a trinity or oneness position.
This was the best of Ali I've seen so far. Impeccable explanation of everything in very clear terms and to the point. I thoroughly enjoyed this
monga cha ..The Hadith clearly states that she was a child.
Sahih al-Bukhari 6130-
Narrated Aishah: I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah’s Messenger used to enter (my dwelling place), they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for Aishah at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.)
It is what it is ... peadophilia is peadophilia..STOP MAKING TOTALLY RIDICOULOUS COMPARISONS AND EXCUSES FOR IT...
@@littlepete6849 she lived 64 years bro..if she had any problem with prophet Muhammad PBUH..then definitely she would have said something in the life after the prophet Muhammad..but look what there is no narration of aisha criticizing or accusing prophet Mohammed PBUH..and also there is no narration of arabs pagan criticizing prophet Muhammad PBUH of paedophilia..and I am sure they were bigger haters of him then..so this proves he didn't do any thing unorthodox then..and 1 more thing not everybody believes she was 6 years old..many also believes she might be 13/14 at the time of her marriage by looking at the age of her sister Asma..but I am not here to discuss the difference of opinion on her age
@@inamdurrani9259 for gods sake read your hadiths..sahih al bukari
@@littlepete6849 brother you can type hazrat ayesha on google..you will easily get into her encyclopedia..in which it is clearly stated that muslims have difference of opinion on age of hazrat ayesha ra at the time of her marriage..
Love it when people come genuinely to learn and listen ask good questions.
This is the type of English couple that’s what it’s really about. They seem sincere and you can tell they have been influenced by the negative things they’ve heard but are willing to learn.
Should have given the lady the book since she was truly interested.
That's a very informative and beautiful conversation, thank you very much. Jazakallahukheiran.😊
24:06 shake my hand, shake my hand😂😂😂
Aisha (ra) had an elder sister called Asma. It is widely reported in multiple places that Asma was 10 years older than Aisha (ra) . Asma died in 73 AH/ 692 when she was 100 years old. This makes Asma 27 at the time of Hijra, making Aisha (ra) 17 at the time of Hijra. Aisha (ra) was married to the prophet (pbuh) around 3 years before that, making Aisha (ra) 14 when her marriage was consummated. Now, you can compare that with Maryam the mother of Isa (pbuh) who was around the same age when she gave birth and no christian finds that perverse in anyway. Because it wasnt . It was accepted practice at that time and still is to this day in certain parts of the world. May I take this opportunity to thank you and all the ones who attempt to belittle the character of Mohammed (swt) as you have given me a reason to research this subject and not blindly accept the words of someone who has done limited research. Salaam.
@Ram Krish with due of respect shut up witless human being empty headed job 11:12
I’m a Muslim and I honestly just don’t think Muhammad sallahu alayhi wasallam married Aisha at 9 or anything it’s a lie
The Hadith upon Muhammad(sawws) is very weak and written in an attempt to slander the moral character of our Phrophet.
Lina Fares exactly yet everyone believes it smh the never research their selves or check
@@zeyanzabir6889 - so perhaps we should see these attacks as a big blessing. Is basically Allah (swt) telling his Ummah to read- just as these were Allah (swt) first words to our Prophet (pbuh). The Umma has never been stupid through the course of history. If we are educated we can counter the propaganda easily :-) We need to up our knowledge.
"Just because they cover their hair, doesn't mean they cover their brain"
@Baz L-Malabari And ofc the skull obscures the intellect.
@Baz L-Malabari - no, hair covers the skin and skin covers the skull
Ma sha ALLAH 🎉 . Beautifully explained my brother Ali. He is very intelligent and wise and explain things logically.
this was very articulate by Ali and well spoken . probably the best video ive seen him in.
Ali could says,, 50 years ago, the 50 years old men look better because there is no McDonald..LOL
What they forgot to mention was that Aisha Was the daughter of a very powerful and respectful man. That was Abu Bakr Al Siddiq (RA), she was only able to marry Rasulu Allah because Abu Bakr (RA) Accepted it. .
David Rodriguez
Yeah. Abu Bakhr told the Prophet that when he has a girl he will instantly marry the prophet to her when she has hit puberty and is physically and mentally capable and mature.
Russia/India gave us McDonald's... First country in the world was Iran a country next to Russia/in Russia yeah
@@DavidRodriguez-og4bmHow is that relevant? Doesn't make it okaym
Mash’allah this was 1 of the best videos I’ve watched of brother Ali Dawah, I loved it. May Allah swt grant him even greater knowledge about Islam.
Brilliantly articulated by my brother in Islam..MAY ALLAH PROTECT HIM AND CONTINUE HIS DAWAH.IA.
I HOPE INSHALLAH THESE TWO LOVELY ENGLISH PEOPLE READ MORE INTO THE TRUTH OF ISLAM.IA
May Allah bless you and your team for your efforts.
Very informative. Thank you!
This man is a very gentle man mashallah.. thats yhe second video i saw of him.. may allah give him hedya enshallah 🤲
Wallah Ali your growing on me brother keep up the good work. May Allah swt guide us all to the straight path insaAllah
Speakers corners is the best place in the UK, hopefully we will have more places like that in all countries
I am addicted to SALAM Dawah! Specially the parts where Ali talks about SHARIA'A Law
According to the biography of Asma the older sister; Aysha was 10 years younger than Asma.
And at the time of Hijri Asma born in 595 AD, was 27 years old . The prophet married Aysha 2 years after hijri which makes her 19 years old. (27-10+2=19)
Asma born - 595 AD
Aysha born - 605 AD
Hijrah - 622 AD
Marriage to the prophet - 624 AD
Very convincing and one of the most amazing speeches or explanations
Thank you Ali Daawah, you are doing a great job
If in 21st century age of consent can be 18 or even 14 in certain countries why cannot be it 9, 1440 years ago
ruclips.net/video/v3QNgvUZpVc/видео.html
May Allah bless you and your dawah work ahki..!
Get this bruddah on here more often he’s actually respectful listens and takes turns.
I really like how Ali conduct himself with all these questions different people throw it him, Alhamdullilah may Allah make it easy for you at all times Insha'Allah Amin.
27:53 caught me off guard 😂
It would be amazing if you guys would put all the references in the description for the viewers so we can see them too ... The ones u mention in the video
Good work Ali . I advice you that with the help of other brothers to come - up with a collection of the many verses and Hadiths which are in favor of women , and put them in a list so you can show the sincere visitors how much is Islam calling us to take care of women ! There are a lot of great verses and Hadiths that can impress any one with misconception of islam especially when it comes to women issues . I would also recommend you to have a print copy of the last sermon of the prophet in which the prophet urges us to take care of women . The prophets sermon which is 1400 yrs old transcends the UN declaration of human rights
Finally a longer video
The hijab is not about religious symbol there are lots of other beneficial factor ie modestly, protections from jinns and health etc
@Baz L-Malabari dont listen to a feminist on tedx
LOL heat emits via the head child, skin has to breathe, nd hair loss,deficiencies,weeping sores/scalp disorders aren't t all beneficial and jinns are a figment of your childish imagination and the bullshit/nonsense islsma brainwashes your weak mind with
@@abdulazizfareh8927 oh...so you don't want people to know/learn about slavery in islam and the vile/vast islamic slave trade eh insecure dumb kid
Such a beautiful conversation... Very informative nd Interesting.. Ma sha Allah
The fact that you can say i was not born muslim makes your opoinen so strong i love that. I am born muslim and i am thankful for that. I did not have to struggle to find islam
InshaAllah I cant wait to come to speakers corner to listen to these amazing talks by SALAM network brothers, also ones by Brother Mansur, Brother Adnan, Brother Hamza and others are great (May Allah be pleased with them all, Ameen). I am going to ask my mahram to take me sometime inshaAllah
who told you then islam mean peace..????
Napo Laguerre sorry? I don’t follow your comment. Please be more clear. What does your question have to do with what I wrote?
I know most muslim do not read their own sources- Islam do not peace and your so- called prophet was not anywhere a man of peace when he moved to MEDINA IN 622 NOT ACCORDING TO CHRISTIANS BUT ACCORDING TO Muslims scholars such as Muhammad ibn ishaq, al wakidi, ibn sad, al tabari whereas they show tat Muhammad was but a pirate, a mass murder and liar...
this is list of people that your so called or evil prophet Muhammad had beheaded: Asma bint Marwan, Abu ' afak, your evil prophet beheaded Al-Nard ibn Harith in March in 624, Uqba bin abu Muayt, Ka'b ibn al-ashraf, abu rafi' ibn abi al huqaiq, khalid ibn sufyan, abu azzah amr ibn abd allah al- jumhi, muawiyhah bin al mugheerat, and your so called prophet beheaded al harith bin suwayd al Ansari,
Muslims learn from their pagan god allah how to lie or deceive people by spreading ISLAM.
Nice conversation Ali..let's meet u such good Christian we called them people of book.
Very clear explanation Ali. Well done brother
Liked the way Ali tackled their questions!
See it’s hard for u to understand remember ur talking about 1400 years ago law was different back than please do more research bless u all
Brother Ali. Did you know that a few hundred years ago, British Kings married 9/10 year olds. Some of whom even died during childbirth because their bodies couldn't handle it. Also, you should have pointed out the life expectancy during the prophets time hence people married much earlier.
But kings of old are not held up as the best of humanity ...Muhammed also married his adopted sons wife...raped prisoners of war ...married one woman the same day he killed her whole family and village...sucked on a young boys tongue...i have also heard he had sex with his dead aunt...but even i admit that seems a bit far fetched...
Ian Murray Do you know the reason why he married his adopted sons wife? When did he rape prisoners of war. Your lying stop with the slander. If what you said is true famous historical philosophers and scholars of western heritage would never have held him on a high standard. In 1935 Muhammad was honored as the best lawgiver by the United States supreme court itself.
I wish Allah (SWT) would let Muhammad (SAW) come alive for a few days to simply dispel this nonsense about beloved Aisha
Evidences which
show it was Not True that AISHAA was 6 / 9 yrs Old.BUT = 18 / 19 yrs Old YOUNG WOMAN
1st= 610 MHMD pbuh receives 1st revelations
2nd= 623 migration to Madina
3rd= 623/624 Aishaa may Allah be pleased with her =lived with the prophet
evdnce/ 1 bukhri 5 Aishaa said i was a jarryah (little girl) btwn 6/12yrs when AL QAMAR chpt was revealed.... AL QAMAR chptr was revealed abt 9 yers before migration =614
SO abt 9 yrs b4 her marriage Aishaa was btwn 6/12 yrs BUT according to this Aishaa was btwn 15/19 whn she marry...
4th Tabari = all 4 of Abu Bakar children were born of his 2 wives during pre islamic period= b4 610 which mean Aishaa was born during pre islamic period b4 610=she could not have been less than 14 yrs in 624...
5th= Aishaa accompanied Muslims in battles carrying waters skins battle of BADER/UHUD 624/625 = BUKHARI+MUSLIM=
CHILDREN under 15 yrs old was not allowed in battles= she was over 15yrs
6th= Abu Baker planned to emigrate to HABBASHA )= SUDAN 8 yrs b4 migration 2 Madina
AISHAA was engage 2 MUTAM,S son (tabari)9 but because Abu Baker embrace Islam
the marriage was off
7th Aishaa accepted Islam during 1st yers = 14 yrs b4 marriage
8th= Asma is 10 yrs older than Aishaa . Asma died 73 yrs after migration= Aishaa was 16-18 at time of migration.
9th KHAWLA suggest that the pht marry a( bikr) a virgin after the death of KHADIJA..REFERING TO Aishaa( THE YOUNG LADY)
QURAN=4 :6 QN 30 :21= THE PHT would not contradict what QURAN teach..
NOTE = its not a logic that pht would marry under age/ her father would oppose such
+ the believer will turn away from the pht...
reminder= dont you ever doubts THE PROPHET pbuh as he is the 1 who by permission of GOD bring us to the light of GOD religion= submission// beware of the test...
quran 65 4 ......And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women - if you doubt, then their period is three months,And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women And for those who are pregnant, their term is until they give birth. And whoever fears Allah - He will make for him of his matter ease
GOD in this Surah talk abt WOMEN not MINORS....
What’s the name of the book he mention?
people just be looking at their own spoilt kids who dont grow up until the age of 25 and compare them to responsible and mature young women from back then
Exacty
2 mates just having banter ey😜
Good job again Ali. Nice presentation
This is probably the best video of Ali dawah
Well done Ali.. This 1 you handled well MashAllah... You do mess it up whenyou are debating but calm Dawah I think that's your Forte.. Well done mate
this sounds even better on mute
@@JackSparrow-ii5gt ok
I benefitted a lot from this discussion. Jazakallah khair
ruclips.net/video/vIzVBeXanj8/видео.html
Nice one Ali...mshaallah
Hope Alex comes to the park mote often. Hes a very nice guy may Allah guide him and his wife
Howard E. Williams
Tasers and Arrest-related Deaths (Criminal Justice: Recent Scholarship
Good argument at minute 21 brother, maşallah
MASHA ALLAH BROTHER ALI.. FROM 8:32 TO 9:27 ALLAHU AKBAR WELL SAID AKHI MAY ALLAH SWT GIVE YOU THE HIGHEST OF JANNAH AND BE WHIT OUR BELOVED PROPHET SAW AMEEN
It is amazing we are still talking about Aisya r.a. I think 50 years from now we probably see the same discussion.
yes indeed you will...decent human beings who `KNOW islam and the obscenities it still allows to this day re children/abuse are REPULSED/SICKENED by islam , what your dirty prick mohammed was and did, and how muslims even SUPPORT the hideous suffering of little girls, due to islam
@@pollykerr7092 Go to Library and learn about your western history especially in Europe and see what is the marriage age for the past 200 years. educate yourselves.
A* from me sir. very well done.
mashallah very fruitfull discussion with respect and open minded.
My salute to Ali and the visitors.
I enjoy this talk , always find interesting topic and people discuse in salam corner .
I watched lecture imran Hussain he says she was much older and he has more knowledge than ali dawah I do not believe she was 6 no way or 9
It's not Ali dawa it's other scholarly information he looked up,
But the crux of the matter :
the fact is we don't really know how old she was
even if we take worse case reports,
The proof is in the result of was she harmed mentally
or physically in anyway had anything bad like the haters describe happened,
if it did...
She couldn't have ever lived the full great life she lived
and was a scholar, a teacher, a military leader etc
@@abuanihas3pazg149 You are ashamed of your own profit. That is understandable because he was a very sick individual.
of course you don't want to believe truths,facts,reality or even why to this day islam still allows the obscenity of child and prepubescent child marriage...you;re muslim and you prefer to living in cuckoo land, in denial, and believing the lies,inane stories,bullshit the hoax of islsm shackles weak minds with
@@lionheart4552 professor Michael H Hart , wrote the book: 100 most influential, people ever,
And he wrote (about the greatest person) in all categories, who has been, supremely successful,
on all levels,
The number 1 on his list is Mohammed (saw).
So you haters can keep crying your eyes blind,
But it doesn't change the facts.
@@lionheart4552 You should be ashamed of your spelling of Prophet 'Profit', but what else would I expect from Haters and unintelligent bigots
The title is a false dichotomy. We don't just evolve from child to adult like a Pokemon. It's a process called adolescence.
Not back then. Kids didn't have the luxury to be teenagers.
@@Mimi-Maa18 Yeah I was talking about the physical process not the social.
The concept of Teenager has begin to be developed in the mid of 19 century before that, the teenager concept didn't exist
Especially with the start of the school system. Society started to create an idea of childhood/adolescent. Before this, boys even matured and got married at 13. However, the school system helps make a lot of money. It also has become necessary now with the more complex jobs we have than before. Before all this, a 9 year old was basically an adult
@@Mimi-Maa18 grow up....the transition from ONSEt of puberty takes FOUR YEARS
what's the name of the book
I think you guys missed or forgot that he swore at 2:58 but just letting you know so u can take it out or bleep it
Ali Dawah you are NOT CORRECT.
Here are three classical Muslim commentaries on Quran 65:4: Showing Aisha WAS A CHILD.
Tafsir Ibn Kathir-
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her `Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate, which is based upon the Ayah in (Surat) Al-Baqarah [see 2:228]. The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their `Iddah is three months like those in menopause.
Tafsir al-Jalalayn-
And [as for] those of your women who (read allà'ï or allà'i in both instances) no longer expect to menstruate, if you have any doubts, about their waiting period, their prescribed [waiting] period shall be three months, and [also for] those who have not yet menstruated, because of their young age, their period shall [also] be three months.
Tafsir Ibn Abbas-
(And for such of your women as despair of menstruation) because of old age, (if ye doubt) about their waiting period, (their period (of waiting) shall be three months) upon which another man asked: “O Messenger of Allah! What about the waiting period of those who do not have menstruation because they are too young?” (along with those who have it not) because of young age, their waiting period is three months.
It doesn't work like that brother , you need to see what scholars said about this , in fiqh there's what's called collecting evidences ,there's many hadiths about this you can't take it as it is, and I believe you are not a Muslim scholar , so you need to see what the scholars had to say about this .
And this verse and those tafassir are setting the boundaries of remarriage ,it is not talking about Aisha at all .
@@madkhalisupremacy You Said it is not about Aisha but it says YOUNG Children so it means today 54yrs old men can marry young Children like Aisha was married by the Prophet.So you want us to believe that the Tafsir Ibn Kathir, Ibn Abbas, al-Jalalayn are all wrong when they say Quran 65-4 Speaks about Young Age? "[also for] those who have not yet menstruated, because of their young age, their period shall [also] be three months"
@@madkhalisupremacy Aisha was a child playing with DOLLS,which is forbidden for adults in Islam.
Aisha was a child playing with DOLLS,which is forbidden for adults in Islam.
Sahih al-Bukhari 6130-
Narrated Aishah: I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah’s Messenger used to enter (my dwelling place), they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for Aishah at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.)
Qur'an 65:4 (Hilali-Khan)-
And those of your women as have passed the age of monthly courses, for them the 'Iddah (prescribed period), if you have doubts (about their periods), is three months, and for those who have no courses [(i.e. they are still immature) their 'Iddah (prescribed period) is three months likewise, except in case of death]. And for those who are pregnant (whether they are divorced or their husbands are dead), their 'Iddah (prescribed period) is until they deliver (their burdens), and whosoever fears Allah and keeps his duty to Him, He will make his matter easy for him.
@@adosados2760 I don't know if you understood what I told , you trying to interpret the verse , and coming with judgments based on tafasir is a dumb act , there's something called collecting evidences , so sort out judgment on those tafasir is far beyond your knowledge , you have to collect other hadiths and verses on the matter to come out with a final judgement, which is not your work nor mine , that's a work of scholars , all you can do is see the opinion of different scholars then compare which of them came with better proofs from Quran and sunnah then you can make your judgment, so brother if you are here to learn that's how you do it , but if you are here to take the offence on the Mohammed or the Quran you are free to do that as well , it is the same what ISIS are doing ,they simply get things out of their context to support their extreme ideologies .
Despicable Jay Smith's ancestors. Sickening indeed.
Aïcha was not 6 or 9 when the prophet married her! There is only one source stating that and it is not reliable. She was more like 16 or 17 years old. Which makes sense. That is clearly demonstrated by some scholars and by historians like Youssef Hindi. Check his books for more details.
Haters r gunna hate allst ima say eloquent etiquette my brother you enlightened many people with this video ... would love to find out if that couple embraced Al Islam ... May ALLAH S.W.T bless you and bless your movement keep u safe and protect tou against the enemies of Islam n give you the ability to gain enormous amounts of knowledge #Ameen Ya Rabbb
*y
It's called cradle snatching!!!!!
That applies to anyone who sleeps with a younger person, so what point does your comment actually have other than to sound stupid?
@@EpikMunk
Yep, so will you admit its disgusting?
But nobody else claims to be from God and best of mankind!!!
@@jattnijjerable - so any older person in a relationship with a younger person is disgusting? You should be condemning your own people and country for allowing such "disgusting" behaviour before pointing fingers son.
@@EpikMunk
I have no country my friend, and I condemn them all, they all should burn for such disgusting things
Ok?
@@EpikMunk
Where is the evidence chain for the Koran being from
God, was it God?
To
Gibreel, who? Is it Gabriel?
To Muhammad
To Othman, the burnings and compilers
To different schools
Jewish hindu nasara converts
Scholars
To the standardised version printed in Venice 1500's
Then 1924 Cairo canonized version?
Saan'a manuscript hafs, wash, doodi etc.?
2020: girls day: doing nothing all day long.
700: girls day: doing everything all day long.
if a human gets more responsibility it grows faster mentaly and physically. so simple
bullshit. you don't see her being able to vote at six do you.
@@JackSparrow-ii5gt vote ? man just go away with your hate I dont need it, and she wasnt six either.
@@nutriaamor7620 she was definitely six.
@@JackSparrow-ii5gt did you watched the vid ?
@@nutriaamor7620 the generally accepted age by the majority of scholars is 6
Shukran . Good dawah akhi
Brilliantly explained Ali.
The hell is wrong withh people's in the comments much talk but less thinking.
long video
edit: good video
Good video ruclips.net/video/vIzVBeXanj8/видео.html
Indeed ur are bless. May Allah reward u
Masha allah 💡
I can't getting enough of this video ♥️♥️♥️♥️
@@maxsant123
Marry PBUH was 12 when she had jésus PBUH you could ask your Pope 😅.. she married juzef in the same year and guess what he was 90 years old 🧓.. It's normal thing back then 😺
@@maxsant123
It's really ironic that I know more then you as Christian about you relegion 😕 it's the first time that I meat someone who didn't know that Mary was pregnant at the age 12 you should read more honey.. It's okey get some information.
ruclips.net/video/62kfJ3NywuA/видео.html
@@maxsant123
Remember that we are not talking about 2020 we are talking about (-2020)and (-1500) time back then there was no TV no Internet the day was long like a year child at 5 years old already working not like now 18 years old and steal a child playing PlayStation 😑
@@maxsant123 hhhh I know the truth hurts.. I am sorry its not my fault 😁
@@maxsant123 yes 😂😂😂
If Aisha was mature at 9 than why would she still play with dolls at that age lol.
BiG-C Official prior to marrying the Prophet, Aisha was engaged to someone else- which confirms marrying at a young age was the norm back then.
The prophet marrying a 9 year old doesn't give leeway to muslims to do the same in the sense that the stage of development is more of a point here than age- thats why theres no set age of being ready for marriage in the Quran or hadith as Allah knows it differs from generation to generation and is dependant upon multiple factors
At one time I believe the prophet had 9 wives but it is haram for rest of muslim men to have more than 4 - as stated in the Quran
Yes we follow the Prophet (peace be upon him) as much as we can but there are exceptions to that rule- and they have been dictated by God
@@Uroojis96 Firstly Man use to marry younger girls because there was no Law back than, that could stop them, it was laws made by Muhammad himself, so he could do watever he wants.
Secondly you mentioned marrying a 9 year doesn't give leeway to Muslims to do the same, well let me correct you on that, Muhammed is suppose to be the best example for mankind at all time and as Muslims you are suppose to follow his footsteps so your argument has no ground.
Thirdly you said there is no set age of being ready for marriage in the Quran or hadith well let me correct you on that according to islam if a woman is a matured she is ready for marriage but as we see in the hadiths, we see that aisha was still a baby who use to play with dolls at the time of marriage as we see in the hadith, if aisha was mature we would see her actions and thinking to be more mature.
Also you said it depends on generations and generations let me correct you on that aswell, A 9 year 1400 years ago is the same as a 9 year old girl in the 21st century, if your saying a 9 year old was mature 14000 years ago than why is it that in todays society we do not find any 9 year old girl who is fully matured and knows about life. Its just disturbing to hear these stuff. Muslims never consider the fact that aisha could not even carry a baby from Muhammad i wonder why is that. I'll leave that for you to think about.
And marrying 4 wives are you serious, this is not only disturbing but horrifying to hear that a women would let her husband have sex with other women in the name of religion, thats just totally wrong. The whole arab culture and religion and mindset is of the norm. And people still follow this cult in places like Yemen where men are marrying kids and the kids are asking for help. I would suggest you watch the documentary on child bride in Yemen. Its just sad and sickening.
BiG-C Official Statistically women out number men. Polygamy is a solution to the problem of women left unmarried. Marriage gives women full rights, not what you see nowadays in the west (or all over the place really) where the so called 'side chicks' are treated like sex objects, not given any value, disregarded and the relationship not being recognised by law.
Islam didn't invent polygamy- it just regulated it- limiting it to 4.
And yes a 9 year old of over 1400 years ago IS completely different to a 9 year old of today- thats why this whole topic even became a topic of contention just 100 years ago- before that even the harshest critics of Islam never used this against the Prophet. This is why context is very important
And like I said before yes we do follow the Prophet but there are exceptions to that rule.
And if it was so barbaric of our Prophet to marry a 6 year old they why in the world did he wait 3 entire years to consummate the marriage? Surely if he was a monster he wouldve just done so at the point of marriage- there was nothing holding him back, he was the Prophet after all
@ÒγÓ REGIMÈ islam STILL allows the obscenity of child and prepubescent child marriage...and `NO child is mature or able to give INFORMED consent...and koran was written after the dirty prick mohammed existed dumb kid
@@Uroojis96 WHY on earth would yo so unashamedly show such ignorance..and `WHY would you claim women outnumber males lol....and in islam marriage doesn't give women `ANY FULL RIGHTS at all...and a dishonest,dumb,childish,sick little deviant like you wouldn't have a clue about adult women in the west lol
WHAT makes you claim women outnumber men, when this is `UTTER NONSENSE lol
this was such a good explanation
جزاكم الله خيرا
38:00 Young girls in England in the early 1900 use to wear hijab
Mathius S are you referring to Iran? You have no idea just how ignorant you sound
Abdulrahman Alenezi no the arabs used to fornicate with everything on the streets. Middle east was house of decadence and nudity.
MINTY what’s good about that? Look around you today, std’s are RAMPANT spreading at rates we can’t even control
He did NOT marry a child at all
Child marriage is NOT allowed in Islam
that's funny
thats a lie
@@patrickmckenna6873 - Aisha (ra) was 14 when her marriage was consummated. In many places to this day that is an acceptable age to be married , and in this instance, we are discussing the 6th century CE.
@@marykilbane7738 the islamic scriptures say she was 9
@@patrickmckenna6873 - Ok. I have done research on this , so may I ask you specifically, which part of 'scripture' do you think says that?
Brother Ali all You Need To Do Is Ask Their Parents Age Differeace . Most of our Parents have a huge age gap
dear ali
Please try to bring the history of contraception into this kind of debate next. And also historically there was not social security
You are fooling no one, Sir.. Defending the indefensable.
..in your narrow mind.
Wrong. He's fooling himself.
Give your rational argument why it's indefensible.
Or is it just the appeal to emotion fallacy?
But the rules were meant for all time from the prophet, you lie again Ali!
Nowhere does it say we have to marry at that age so your point is?
@@richbaines9752
So what are the rules ?
@@jattnijjerable the rules are physical, mental and psychological preparedness.
@@alameenahmed9585
Why did Muhammad have sex at 50 with a girl of 9 is that the character of a perfect example for all time ?
Are you arabian?
@Mohammed Shorif
She was 9, even with the advanced education system we have now people are intellectually and emotionally immature until early 20s
I dont give a fuck about Joseph or king James
MUHAMMAD WAS THE PERFECT MAN FOR ALL TIMES FROM ALLAH
pure bullshit
Why would a god order that on a 9 year old girl ?????
its not even 9, the actual age of Aisha according to the events she witnessed and that her sister witnessed she was 15. Search it well we didnt have a calender. she was 15 actually.
God bless you
May Allah bless you too! ❤️
Just more mental gymnastics from Ali Dawah to try defend child abuse and barbaric desert laws from 1000s of years ago which are incompatible with today’s norms.
Are you just stupid or naive ?
Critic Clips
Neither just a critic voicing his opinion.
why they keep asking the same questions ..
Man said the latest maybelline 😂😂😂😂😭😭😂😂😂😂😂
WAS AISHA A CHILD OR ADULT? - 9 years old. You must be our of your mind!
Did u listen to the lecture
@@richbaines9752 This tittle is ridicules unless it is for a comedy club! Whatever is the "Lecture". Read the tittle again!
Genesis 17 - Genesis 26
Explains the time lapse and commentaries by Christian scholars have agreed that when Sarah gave birth to rebecka she passed away
Isaac was 37 when rebecka was born
Isaac turned 40 and married rebecka at age 3
King Richard of England married Isabella when she was 6
Mary 12 gave birth to Jesus
Muhammad married Ayesha 9
@@romeohelix1966 Ok now give were in Christianity they claim Isaac is the best example for humanity and you are home free.
Quran talk abt - WOMEN not Minors
pht was no short of Women to Marry an under age child....
AISHAA AGE ...
Never 6 or 9 yrs But 16 - 19 Yrs Old Woman...Never a MInor
Al-Tabari says: “All four of his [Abu Bakr’s] children were born of his two wives during the pre-Islamic period”
(Tarikhu’l-umam wa’l-mamlu’k, Al-Tabari (died 922), Vol. 4, p. 50, Arabic, Dara’l-fikr, Beirut, 1979).
If Ayesha was betrothed in 620 CE (at the age of seven) and started to live with the Prophet in 624 CE (at the age of nine), that would indicate that she was born in 613 CE and was nine when she began living with the Prophet. Therefore, based on one account of Al-Tabari, the numbers show that Ayesha must have born in 613 CE, three years after the beginning of revelation (610 CE). Tabari also states that Ayesha was born in the pre-Islamic era (in Jahiliya). If she was born before 610 CE, she would have been at least 14 years old when she began living with the Prophet. Essentially, Tabari contradicts himself. CONCLUSION: Al-Tabari is unreliable in the matter of determining Ayesha’s age
. EVIDENCE # 3: The Age of Ayesha in Relation to the Age of Fatima According to Ibn Hajar, “Fatima was born at the time the Ka`bah was rebuilt, when the Prophet was 35 years old... she was five years older that Ayesha”
(Al-isabah fi tamyizi’l-sahabah, Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, Vol. 4, p. 377, Maktabatu’l-Riyadh al-haditha, al-Riyadh, 1978).
Until 1965, age of legal consent in US was 7 years.
Elvis Presley released Jailhouse Rock in the year 1957.
It's all about what you're made to believe.
Islam is not saying to reduce the marriage age but it's about when the woman get ready mentally, physically for marriage. Don't put a number to it.
DONT LIE and NO child is,was or ever has been mentally/physically or emotionally ready for marriage, when they can't give `INFORMED CONSENT to such
Ali Dawah, excellent open discussion, crystal clear. very impressive, may Allah reward you. Well done.
I love Ali's reasoning to this regard.
good explaination
I have yet to find a hadith that says aisha reached the age of puberty
Sahih al Bukhari , volume 1 , book 8 , Hadith 465 Aisha went thru puberty before marriage
4:26 Quran - age of puberty and maturity
Shayk Yusuf estes clarifys better Masha'Allah.
At the time of the Prophet (Peace be upon him) there was a companion named Amr ibn Al As who by the age of 11 was already married and by the age of 12 he already had his first son. 9 year old Aisha and 12 year old Amr ibn Al As were not considered children they were responsible, mature adults.Things were simply different back then.
Yes, Aisha was 9 years old when she was raped.
byteme9718 nah
@@ab_12_8 Yeah!
byteme9718 nah 9 years old back then we’re considered to be today’s 19 year olds meaning he didn’t rape her
Brother the point is, that book you should've gave it her free, instead of saying you can buy it on Amazon. But only Allah knows the intentions, nice talk.