Metallica - Black Album (1991) All Songs Ranked

[@felixz.z]

12. Don't Tread On Me
11. Holier Than Thou
10. The God That Failed
9. My Friend Of Misery
8. Enter Sandman
7. Wherever I May Roam
6. Of Wolf And Man
5. Nothing Else Matters
4. The Struggle Within
3. Sad But True
2. Through The Never
1. The Unforgiven

[@gabrielpaiva9070]

Here's my list:
12) Through The Never (but I don't hate it) 10/10
11) The Struggle Within 10/10
10) Don't Tread On Me 10/10
9) Of Wolf And Man 10/10
8) Enter Sandman 10/10
7) Nothing Else Matters 10/10
6) My Friend Of Misery 10/10
5) Holier Than Thou 10/10
4) Wherever I May Roam 10/10
3) Sad But True 10/10
2) The God That Failed 10/10
1) The Unforgiven 11/10

[@vinceyrankings]

Wow 11/10. That's actually breaking the system but alright!

[@gabrielpaiva9070]

@@vinceyrankings I know. It was a bit of a joke.

[@emolga3147]

This is like exactly the same as my list, though I might put sad but true lower because I've listened to it wayyy too many times

[@gabrielpaiva9070]

@@emolga3147 Well, that's your opinion.

[@TheNyxCabin]

Fair list.

[@mrsorakary]

12. The Struggle Within
11. Don't Tread On Me
10. Wherever I May Roam
9. The God That Failed
8. Nothing Else Matters
7. My Friend Of Misery
6. Of Wolf and Man
5. Enter Sandman
4. Sad But True
3. Trought The Never
2. Holier Than Thou
1. The Unforgiven

[@FL_CORPSE]

Wherever i may roam 10/10 this is the only song of metallica starts to chorus.

[@arthurdevieirasobral6467]

1.Nothing else Matters
2.The Unforgiven
3.Sad But True
4.Enter Sandman
5.Wherever I May Roam
6.Of Wolf and Man
7.The God that Failed
8.My Friend of Misery
9.Don't Tread On Me
10.Holier Than Thou
11.Through the Never
12.The Struggle Within

[@FL_CORPSE]

The Unforgiven 12/12 ❤❤❤

[@FL_CORPSE]

Through the never 10/10

[@Pifmeister]

Most Controversial album, but we both have Controversial rankings
12 Enter Sandman
11 Nothing Else Matters
10 Unforgiven I
09 Sad But True
08 Don't Tread On Me
07 Of Wolf & Man
06 The God That Failed
05 Wherever I May Roam
04 Struggle Within
03 Holier Than Thou
02 Through The Never
01 My Friend Of Misery

[@codyhutchison4521]

Someone who agrees with me that MFOM is the best song in the album.

[@YEAH340]

12. Don’t Tread On Me 6/10
11. Through The Never 7/10
10. Holier Than Thou 7.5/10
9. My Friend Of Misery 8/10
8. The God That Failed 9/10
7. Struggle Within 9.5/10
6. Of Wolf And Man 9.5/10
5. Wherever I May Roam 9.5/19
4. The Unforgiven 9.5/10
3. Nothing Else Matters 10/10
2. Sad But True 10/10
1. Enter Sandman 10000/10
Not a single bad song on this album
Sorry this list being a bit basic

[@vinceyrankings]

10000??? Hahahaha. good one. Yeah, i'm glad we can all share each other's opinions and i can see why some ppl top Sandman as n°1.

[@khurram2970]

Here my top 5:
1. The Unforgiven 10/10
2. Wherever I may roam 9.8/10
3. Sad but true 9.5/10
4. Nothing else matters 9.3/10
5. Enter sandman 9/10

[@JoeFolgers]

1. Of Wolf and Man
2. The Struggle Within
3. Don't Tread On Me
4. Through the Never
5. The God That Failed
6. Holier Than Thou
7. Wherever I May Roam
8. Enter Sandman
9. My Friend Of Misery
10. Sad But True
11. The Unforgiven
12. Nothing Else Matters
I love all of them, but this is what I'd do if I was forced to rank them.

[@vinceyrankings]

Plus it's your opinion

[@JoeFolgers]

Yes. I like your opinion on it too@@vinceyrankings

[@cocballus250]

I must've forgot to comment on this one:
12: The Struggle Within (6.9/10)
11: Don't Tread on Me (7.5/10)
10: Holier than Thou (7.8/10)
9: My Friend of Misery (8.2/10)
8: Through the Never (8.8/10)
7: The God that Failed (8.8/10)
6: Wherever I May Roam (9.3/10)
5: Of Wolf and Man (9.4/10)
4: Sad But True (9.5/10)
3: Enter Sandman (9.9/10)
2: Nothing Else Matters (10/10)
1: The Unforgiven (10/10)
While the album is more consistently good than RTL, It's my 2nd Favorite Metallica album behind Ride the lightning.

[@FidgetMDCCLXIV]

In my scale:
Irredeemable is 0/10
Disgusting is less than 1/10
Bad is less than 3/10
Likeable is 4.5/10 or more
Good is 6/10 or more
Legendary is 9/10 or more
Classic is 9.5/10 or more
Untouchable is 10/10
12. Of Wolf And Man 2.8/10 (I’d rather listen to Purify for 2 hours straight at full volume than listen this song just once at half volume)
11. The God That Failed 5.5/10
10. Through The Never 5.7/10
9. Holier Than Thou 6.5/10
8. Wherever I May Roam 7/10
7. Sad But True 8.4/10
6. The Struggle Within 8.6/10
5. The Unforgiven 8.8/10
4. Enter Sandman 9.2/10
3. My Friend of Misery 9.3/10
2. Nothing Else Matters 9.8/10
1. Don’t Tread on Me 9.9/10

[@JacobAery]

My Ranking
12: My Friend of Misery (4/10)
11: Through The Never (6/10)
10: Holier Than Thou
(6.5/10)
9: The God That Failed (7/10)
8: The Struggle Within (8/10)
7: The Unforgiven (9/10)
6: Of Wolf and Man (9.5/10)
5: Don’t’ Tread On Me
(10/10)
4: Sad But True (10/10)
3: Wherever I May Roam (10/10)
2: Nothing Else Matters
(10/10)
1: Enter Sandman (10/10)