Victoria Atkins Chastised By Deputy Speaker Over Abominable Behaviour!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024
- Former Health Minister, Victoria Atkins, was called out by the deputy speaker of the house of commons over her behaviour. She made Jonathan Gullis sounds from the front bench and then stood at the dispatch box attempting to challenge the new Secretary of State for DEFRA.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @maximilienrobespierre1
Patreon - / maxrobespierre
Amazon - amzn.to/2QoRauj
Facebook: - / maximilienrobespierre1794
Twitch - / max_robespierre
Merch - maximilienrobe...
Twitter - / maxfrobespierre
Buy Me A Coffee - www.buymeacoff...
#victoriaatkins
#torychaos
#houseofcommons
Credit: Parliament TV
As the lady next to him said "You had 14 years" - no point shouting woulda, coulda, shoulda - you didn't
Spot on.
Was it not a Tory who said that?
(Incredibly ironic)
Appalling behaviour by both the equally odious Atkins AND Badenoch, however also appalling that the Deputy Speaker allowed them to get away with what they did. What was the point of him being there?
To give them a free pass. For someone who was so keen to stop stuff using parliamentary machinery by shouting "OBJECT!" himself, I am unsurprised.
Petulant, silly lady. They don’t know how to be in opposition after 14 years of unfettered power.
She doesn't know how to behave!
@@CashelOConnolly I didn’t say it did. I would have called a man petulant and silly too.
@@joangordon3376 No she doesn’t. Very disrespectful behaviour.
@@KevinMeeds oops, sorry. Hit the question mark instead of the explanation point! She displayed absolutely dreadful behaviour.
Absolutely agree with you their arrogance knows no bounds.
I have never voted Tory, but it is sad to see the Conservative party reduced to this level of mindless hysterical behaviour. Some of the most inept, deranged, shameful, uneducated MP's ever to enter the HoC in my long lifetime. Seriously, it's very sad and not good for democracy.
And yet folks on their constituencies voted for them on July 4th. You have to wonder why so many in our country, 25%, have such shocking judgement. 14 years of inept government and masterful cronyism and corruption and they think, “ You know what. I want five more years of the same.” As for our Parliament, it needs radical reform and modernisation with all the archaic nonsense binned and a less confrontational circular debating camber perhaps in a new building. I’d like to see a breakdown of what each MP is doing with their time. The idea that someone like Farage can swan off to the USA, or the Johnsons of this world can disappear on lecture tours etc. Let’s start treating it like a professional career rather than like being a member of a golf club with extensive expenses and allowances.
They want chaos, they aren't interested in democracy in the slightest, nor in even representing their own constituency.
Yeah, I've never liked the Tories but at least the likes of Ken Clarke, Philip Hammond and Oliver Letwin had some degree of integrity. This current bunch are utterly repulsive.
Everyone that had a spine was ejected from the party by Johnson when he was PM. Damage done to the party may be irreparable.
It'll be a while before the Tories get fixed
Ms Atkins….the MP who was proud and boasted of the increase in food banks in her constituency when interviewed…not a clue.
Despicable rudeness and yes quite unacceptable it went on for so long.
She should have been told to leave
These people are unfit for the job. Barely a political party. Just a lot of ruthless self serving people with no decency at all.
Non at all? I hope you can see where I would take this as a reductio.
@@jiubboatman9352
decency is reIative she may weII have s0me, I d0ubt she`d be indecent in the presence 0f her superi0rs 0r "betters"
but being pedantic unnecessariIy says m0re b0ut y0u
@@ob2249 Really? A person makes a demonstrably false statement and I am the one at fault?
One should not allow their bias to influence their rational faculties.
@@jiubboatman9352
hyperb0Ie is a c0mm0n en0ugh device
y0ur c0mment says m0re ab0ut pedantry
as y0u dem0nstrated again
@@jiubboatman9352 how are you getting on with your autism?
Deputy speaker was too slow and not firm enough 🙄
They never are for supposition to exist they exist in support of the tories regardless of their party origin
Watch it again, he wasn't going to do anything until the gentleman to his right said something to him.
Starmer is a fool if he lets them get away with this.
@@SirAntoniousBlockhe’s only acting deputy speaker, so I think he needed confirmation
Shameful way to act anywhere, never mind parliament.
Welcome to the human race, you are in for a bumpy ride.
Yes! Precisely! You probably wouldn't be allowed to behave like that in most public spheres.
@@jiubboatman9352Obviously you have given up, but most decent people haven’t.
@@david-pb4bi A tiny wafer of non-evidence and you think you know me?
I cannot fathom navigating the world making up your mind about people after a few sentences.
The trouble is the tories have normalised this petulant behaviour, children always think its ok if others have done it.
You wanna see their counterparts in the US...the MAGAts... absolutely wired to the moon... certainly not this planet anyways...
Tories and other tories rant about 'common sense'.
This is normal 'common sense' in action.
Next Door is full of it ;-)
The true Atkins comes to the fore as she shows her true colours, embarrassing herself and the conservatives, but not being censored sooner speaks volumes
It's Chope - what did you expect? As much of a bastard as the remainder of the Scum Party.
She showed her true colours the day before the tory government was dissolved
embarrassing herself and the conservatives?
that's like mud getting itself dirty!
Shocking behaviour from a conservatiive, especially from the ladies eg Minister of Trade.
She should have been marched out of the House.
this woman is abhorrent. I despised her as health secretary. Remember her husband is the MD of BRITISH SUGAR.
They don't realise they're no longer in power and are irrelevant.
But they are and they aren't, sadly. It's the power of the published opinion that festers into public opinion, gets amplified by social media, regurgitated back to the Tory media and vomited out repeatedly by their mouthpieces inside and outside party and parliament. They are muppets and puppets, but they feel that power, and wield it. The spineless speaker is only responsible for this instance of populist theatre, but anyone within labour not working day and night on media reform is responsible for ongoing Tory power. Oh, and bring back Bercow.
That would require a medical procedure
Presumably she's up for a GB News gig, so this is her audition piece.
There are several vacancies at the moment as the 'stars' of GB Spews are busy all trying to climb up Trump's funadmental passage in search of money.
ah yes, that makes sense.
The Deputy Speaker (a Tory!) gave the noisy lot way too much leeway during this speech. He only stood up because, from what it seems, someone nodded a word to him to actually do something. So far the new deputy speakers have been uninspiring and, as you said, look to be asleep. In this new Parliament, if I were speaker, I would have made very clear upon the return of the house that there would be NO WARNING MECHANISM for returning/experienced members - they would face sanction, like not being picked for questions in debates or, in the case of Atkins here, summarily removed from the chamber. Imagine how much more civil the Commons would be, outside of PMQ's at least, if Speakers put their foot down a lot more harshly. The job of the speaker is to maintain order, but its NOT orderly to be shouting down and chuntering the person speaking, regardless of whether or not you agree with them. Raise a point of order or shut up.
@@xMasterAssassin93
He may be new to the deputy speaker role - assuming that's his excuse - but he's been in parliament long enough and should well know right from wrong.
@@ChangesOneTimThat's just it: they succumb to obfuscation and delusion and can't tell the difference between right and wrong. Reread "Animal Farm"!!!!!!
Atkins one of the cruelest Health Ministers 😕. The NHS couldn't stand her.
that says a lot after what jeremy Hunt did. He was utter dispised by the NHS
Retired NHS worker here, we called him Hunt the **nt.
The Sacred Cow is just a behemoth tax-guzzling left-wing regressive ‘organisation’ that requires defunding as the British TAX-PAYER can no longer afford!
And let’s not forget the conflict of interest here…. Her husband is CEO of BRITISH SUGAR!
She always looks like she's woken up hungover after being pulled through a hedge backwards.
If the Tory's, have all the answers, why did the British people kick them out ?
More to the point, if they have all the answers why didn't they enact them over the last 14 years?
Tories
They had the answers to a different exam..
@@johnrussell3961 So glad I wasn't drinking my coffee when I read that
@@johnrussell3961 A demolitions exam paper
She should've been suspended from the house for the rest of the days sitting for disgraceful and unparliamentary behaviour, she knows it is not right to stand up and speak while another Parliamentarian is speaking!
Deputy Speaker should be reprimanded for not calling the tories to order!! That was absolutely shameful. The tories are DESPERATE to be the British Republican party and it's disgusting.
Well it's up to Labour to get rid of him.
The Tories have a real issue with other peoples opinions. Narcissistic behaviour 101. Don’t fall into the hate you’ll be miserable.
Absolutely disgraceful, immature and idiotic behaviour. Exactly what we've come to expect from every single Conservative and their voters.
And people voted these two thugs back in, unbelievable.
Badanock was just as bad with Rayner. She didn’t want to debate what the labour minister had said , but instead tried to make a joke about her being stitched up by Starmer.
Badenoch had to fall back on her usual repulsive, slimy condescension because that's ALL she's got to offer.
Badenoch needs to find a one way flight back to Nigeria.
@@belfagorable Two-brick thick Badenoch will resort to anything because she knows she's got zero to offer. She's got away with superciliousness and mendaciousness to mask her abject incompetence.
@@iVenge You sure they'll take her?
@jaredbasic5743 What the Tories have proved, again and again, is that Rayner never had anything to apologise for, in Autumn 2021.
I lost respect for Parliament and it's current Speaker, when we witnessed Diane Abbott standing up 46 times and getting ignored at a debate about racist abuse hurled at her by a Tory donor.
Agreed - Despicable. Also the underhand deal with Starmer/Hoyle to deny the SNP motion over Gaza.
@@Badgerbeard What deal?
Can you point to any actual evidence of any deal? Any minutes detailing it from any officials that were in the rooms?
Any statements from any individual that was in any meetings?
Or any evidence at all?
I have as much evidence to claim Thor beamed down from the Baliskner and told the Speaker what to do.
@@Badgerbeard Also the SNP were not denied the opportunity to present thier amendment. They decided to walk out with the Tories before they could. If they really wanted to do so they would have actually presented their amendment to call for a ceasefire instead of bickering with the speaker.
You maybe can't find any evidence....but that doesn't get away from the fact that Hoyle did it.@@EdJames-tb9oz
@@EdJames-tb9ozAlso it wasn't an amendment to Labours question that was of any issue, it was the rare opportunity of asking a question that was denied to the SNP , a question which would have highlighted Starmers hypocrisy and put real pressure on labours MPs to stand with Israel or to embarrass Starmer and support the Palestinians.
The same Victoria Atkins, who, with her mouth wide open, laughed so performatively loudly as Rishi Sunak slagged off the trans people, while Brianna Ghey's mum was in attendance. Oh how she laughed and laughed.
If she had any sense of shame, she'd have resigned then.
She is not fit to be a MP I wood not give her a job as a shopping assistant
Did I hear someone shout, "Where's the money going to come from?!"
Perhaps someone might like to shout back, "'What have you people done with our money!?'"
Absolutely Shameful behaviour!!
Wasn't just Atkins is that also Kemi Badenoch behaving like a child? Speaker is useless.
What a disgraceful exhibition. The Tories are not fit to be in opposition.
We're in such desperate need for strong speakers to keep the house in order!
Atkins has always behaved like a spoilt, petulant child whilst pontificating with her ignorance
He took his time to say something, that was appalling behaviour form both of the Tory MPs. If I was him, I would have stopped speaking, stared at the speaker and asked him if he was going to do his job? Rather than try and continue with that sort of behaviour going on.
You're not in power any more, sit down, shut up.
Same old tories, still scraping the barrel.
Kudos to Steve Reed for keeping going ! ❤
"Made Jonathan Gullis sounds" - I didn't even have to hear her to know what that meant.
The deputy speaker is a spineless wimp.
So he has shown himself to be 😢
Can’t believe it’s upskirting Chistopher Chomp as Deputy Speaker ,I know it’s temporary but still not a great look in my opinion
Yes, that was a pretty pathetic display. Chocolate teapot.
@@mikey50boy criticize him by all means but you could at least get his name right.
Deputy Speaker for Upskirting Chope. God help us all
Shocking behaviour. This is what happens when there is no leadership. How did a 5 year old get into parliament?
He took his time bringing order. Not acceptable.
Hoyle now understands you have to explain to the likes of Badenock why they have been admonished. You have to treat them like little children .
Atkins - spoilt little privately educated rich girl - her father was tory MP Sir Robert Atkins and her husband is managing director of British Sugar. As for speakers - do we have any?
quite, and so she got where she is due to Daddy and hubby, no actual talent of her own
Spoilt brat
The deputy speaker was asleep at the wheel. They ask members to respect the institution and yet do nothing to discipline those who don't.
Just goes to show that the electorate were totally correct to vote out the cretinous and repugnant Tory’s!
I agree with you. This shouldn't be tolerated.
Protocol means nothing to those people
She should have been suspended for days.
Max, this is one example of many of why Parliament's rules of governance are insufficient. They have been weakened to enable juvenile behaviour by the Conservative party, which displays open contempt for the Speaker, the government in office and the reputation of Parliament. Thanks for documenting it, this shows why checks and balances including the powers of the Speaker to eject disruptive MPs need to be strengthened.
Absolutely useless speaker
Say what you will about Bercow, he didn't tolerate poor etiquette and behaviour. He is missed! Likewise Betty Boothroyd!
To be fair to The Speaker, he wasn’t overseeing this episode of Opposition truculence. Agreed, the Deputy (one of three) was in error for not nipping this in the bud.
Shocking behaviour by both women! Awful behaviour.
The speaker had to be told to act by the guy next to him.
What the hell was that. How spineless can the deputy speaker be to take so long to bring order. Never seen such disruption
5 stages of grief on display on the Tory front bench.
And people will claim "they are all the same"
What disgraceful behavior from Victoria Atkins, no respect, sit down and wait your turn
Despicable. Tories have been the sorest of losers
They were sore losers even while in power.
That's because they know they're losers
And they complained endlessly about ‘snowflakes’!!!
It’s funny bc Sunak has been pretty gracious in the defeat, certainly not perfectly gracious, but well enough, but the rest of the party seem to be choosing bitterness over the loss, instead. Performance over politics has them in shambles.
@@agwarddd Performative Politics, yes. And helping their supporters to £billions upon £billions of our money.
It's never been in doubt that she was shite at being an MP, but this is appalling and she should be punished for this. And the speaker should have stepped in way sooner than he did, there was way too much shouting from the sidelines even before she stood up, but he should have told her to get back down as soon as she stood up.
Never seen an opposition MP actually walking up to and standing at the dispatch box in this way before. Definitely against the rules. One can stand up in one's place and speak if the MP speaking has 'given way' - I'm sure frustration got the better of Atkins because she felt she was being denied a right to reply because the Labour MP speaking was not giving way (he was running out of time and needed to complete his statement). But this is being very generous to 'Mad as a Bat' Atkins. She was bang out of order really, and the deputy speaker failed in this job totally. But, not surprised. The H of C is a circus where the only performers on show are clowns, clowns, clowns.
This deputy speaker is Christopher Chope, he is a member of the Conservative Party. First elected in 1983 and lost his seat in 1992, he was then elected as an MP in 1997 and has remained an MP since. His clear lack of experience as a deputy speaker is definitely on display, even so having served in the Commons for such a long time you would think he would have grasped the understanding of how a speaker should act when controlling the house.
Badenoch did a bit of bobbing about too. Perhaps Atkins decided to out-do her. What a despicable display from both of them. If this is how all of them intend “operating” through this parliament, I can’t see them getting back into power until my grandchildren are in their dotage.
"The Right Honourable Lady"? The Tories may be (far) right, but in what universe are ANY Tories "Honourable"? It's in witnessing displays like Atkins' that, whatever else you may think of him, makes you a little nostalgic for John Bercow, who would've stamped down hard on this kind of behaviour from the start.
The Tory party have become the Chimps Tea party that the chimps have disowned as being an embarrassment to the species.
The Downright Abominable ...
That speaker of the house was insufferably slow in stopping these petulant 14year old schoolgirls from some deprived area.
This has just become the go-to for Conservatives these days; don't like something, throw a very public and embarassing tantrum. It's been Braverman's immediate response for years, just going on tirades and throwing her toys out of the pram. It's just rank unprofessionalism, and I think we do need to curtail this behaviour.
Excellent delivery from Steve Reid.
Deranged cackling from Atkins and Badenoch.
Bloody loving it. ❤ 😂
These are the lowering of standards that the Tories want to make normal. I do wish the Lib Dem’s were the opposition. Shocking behaviour!
Been studying at the Marjorie Taylor Green's school of parliamentary procedure.
Have they learnt no humility? Apparently not 😕
For an opposition MP to move off her bench and to end up leaning on the opposition despatch box is poor form, particularly during a ministerial speech. After 14 years in government the dregs of the Tory Party will have to learn how to behave, and I expect The Speaker not to tolerate this and to rebuke in the strongest possible terms this type of behaviour.
Same old toxic tories
Is Starmer is to deliver in this Parliament, people in positions of power need to be held accountable. Firstly, the deputy speaker must be held to account for not upholding the necessary standards, and then allowed to hold the opposition to account. I am 100% behind Starmer and Labour but without proper governance of the house, the conservatives will bring everyone down to their level
They have never learned to lose gracefully. Children have better manners.
There a disgrace , that speaker wants to get a grip 😮
If it was the SNP they would have been out the door.
Labour had already done that in the election.
@@johnrussell3961. Humour not your strong suit?
@@johnrussell3961Fanny
Wait until 2026, and we will see the SNP win back Holyrood, since most constituents here, lent their vote to Liebour in the election, just to get rid of the CON party.
No doubt Audrey. And still the standard of the speakers in there is woeful. My heart sunk when I found out Hoyle was back in place. He sets such a low standard.
I have never seen anything like this. Astonishing.
That was probably part of her leadership bid: performance politics.
And to think that that woman was in charge of the NHS!
They're all fighting to be the fool of the week
Badenoch was up there as well... this shows how they will act if she gets to be leader. Reactive, thin-skinned and Ignorant.
This MP should have been removed from the house by the deputy speaker but wasn't, so the question now is the suitability of the deputy speaker in this role? My personal opinion he should have taken control of the situation much sooner - absolutely appalling. Out of control MP and a Tory deputy speaker - HOW BAD IS THAT
Deputy speaker seemed not to know how to intervene. Clueless.
It's Chope, he's older than the benches and knows full well what the rules are, he chose not to enforce them because... reasons 🙄
Disgusting behaviour and the deputy speaker sat and watched for too long.
Tories adopting the populist attitude of 'whoever shouts loudest' wins the argument. It might apply to Boris supporters but certainly not to rational minds. They care far more for themselves and adherence to ideology than constructive ideas that offer solutions in the real world.
Absurd that the deputy speaker allowed this to go on for so long
My god, the actual state of them.
Two of them stood up and touched the dispatch
They are in opposition and can't handle it - I've never seen anything like this in the House. Really awful, she was running around like a manic primary school kid.
you obviously haven't been watching parliament for the last 200 yrs
@@neilliversidge6012 Well, I have seen plenty of Parliament - but I've never seen an opposition MP screeching from the dispatch box *while* the Government have been putting their case.
I'd suggest you haven't seen much of Parliament
Who held them to account when they had 14 years to sort out any issues!
This was total disrespect...a mad ranting woman.
Can’t remember any Labour MP’s ever doing this, in all the 14 years the Tories were in power.
Yes. The speaker was sleeping 😴. Surprised? I am not
This is just an embarrassment for the U.K.!
Whenever she appears on question time, she sneers and smirks as she trots out her mendacious responses to the audience. Sad she got back in.
That truly was Abominable behaviour.
Oh, FFS Christopher Chope is now a Deputy Speaker!
To defend the (temporary) Deputy Speaker: There was a strict time limit in place with just a couple minutes left before the House automatically adjourned (1430 on a Friday), if he'd gone through the procedures of naming and kicking out Atkins that would have further eaten into the Secretary of State's time to finish his speech.
Speaker was USELESS!
Disgraceful behaviour.
Jonathan Gullis should have said, you've had your time, 15yrs and what did you achieve, nothing of any value
Best argument yet for removing VAT exemption on private school fees?
It’s Brexit benefit!
Anyone thinking they should've voted LibDem ...or Green .. or Labour. ....or Monster Raving Loony. Anything better than Conster Raving loony.
What is the deputy speaker thinking letting this occur.
Pathetic deputy speaker, what the hell was he doing,oh that's it he is a bloody tory