@@candacemichelle8345 you have to help yourself. Regardless of what you eat cut back on your portion size. Make sure you get plenty of sleep-this is vital. Put more physical effort into things you ordinarily do and increase the amount you walk. Walking is a fantastic way to lose weight. Start of walking even for five minutes, increase it every second day by another 5 minutes until you can walk for an hour. Try to walk to and from school and anywhere that is close enough. The fitter you get the easier it will be. Do not eat after 6 pm. Drink plenty of water and do not drink any fizzy drinks. I hope this helps you to lose some weight. Set small realistic goals and just work on them. Do not just focus on losing weight but rather about gaining health and healthy habits to keep you well. Try work on your inner self and facing anything that you think is perhaps causing you to overeat. If you are honest with yourself. Best of luck 🤞
black star She was. I would’ve lost it. Brooke was trying hard to eat foods she didn’t enjoy, and she didn’t complain about wanting more. But Marie was complaining about every supersized meal. And trying to educate her like she is a dumb baby. It was horrible to watch.
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle.
It's so upsetting to me that Marie seems to be clearly suffering from an eating disorder and it's never truly addressed. She's so in denial it makes her seem like an unpleasant person when she really isn't. Someone needs to have a serious talk with her and get her some help.
Brooke is literally so sweet and I can see that she’s trying hard! But Marie is not even trying, and being super judgemental about brooke’s food.. i know that shes trying to help and all, but the way that she talks to Brooke is just so rude.
She's not rude at all. This comment is ridiculous. Brooke is obese and getting to a point where its serious. She can't sit there and act like its hard for her to eat less than she does. Anorexia is a mental disorder. Learn before you speak.
Jaxo Dude, can you like, maybe chill? Sniff a candle? Smoke some weed and like, relax? Just be less... extreme? Just calm down, man. Here, have a pizza. 🍕
Chaewon Yoon i agree with jaxo. also, it can be hard when you have an eating disorder to see other people eating unhealthily and can be just as distressing as doing it yourself. i’ve had friends with eating disorders who can seem like they’re being really rude and judgemental, but it’s just something which they can’t control because they’ve trained them self to be disgusted by unhealthy food. so much hate on her it’s appalling
I love how Brooke ploughs through the diet swap without a word of complaint. She's a really sweet girl and really shows determination to lose weight. Marie, on the other hand, does the opposite; not clearing her plate, judges what Brooke eats like white bread and cheese. She also thinks "super foods" are healthy but she's lacking certain nutrients. No wonder she didn't gain weight
Shes clearly autistic, the way she counts her almonds, eats the same everyday, is picky about what parts of the food is good to eat, the fact that she put ear plugs in before she grinded her almonds... She is clearly autstic and it can be painful to eat textures your bory chose it doesnt like and she shouldn't be forced to eat those!!! Please stop hating on her. (This is comming from ab obese person btw)
Marie has a serious eating disorder and needs counseling and therapy. She's also in complete denial. Brooke is so sweet :( I hope her schooling and career at going well!
I feel like Marie thinks she's only there to help Brook and that she doesn't really need help but she's got real control issues 27 almonds really like damn enjoy life once in a while
You can literally see that Marie is disgusted by food, just by the way she chews it. She's even struggling putting healthy food in her mouth. I can see the mental battle she is having, just by the excessive blinking and facial expressions, whilst she's eating.
Marie has disordered eating but she also feels quite superior about her diet. The way she speaks to Brooke is really patronising and quite condescending. I feel quite sorry for her. That’s a really joyless way to live
I suspect it is hortorexia, that's and ED where people are not concerned with calories and their body image but rather with "eating healthy" food. It can be just as dangerous as anorexia when it gets to this level but I guess it partially explains why she doesn't follow the diet given by the doctor: she thinks that her idea of "healthy" food is right so it wouldn't make any sense to her to eat "unhealthy food"
@@simonsms410 are you mad!! 4000 calories is double what a reasonably active woman should be having so expect to be double the size if you eat double the calories. 4000 calories is fine if you're a well built 6ft guy but if Brooke did 2 hours of gym everyday with that lifestyle she'd still gain weight. If you watch secret eaters there's a blonde woman who doesn't understand why she's running 6 miles everyday but still gained 2 stone in 6 months. It was because she was consuming nearly 4000 calories. Brooke would have to be dragging boulders by your logic to have a healthy BMI.
I feel so sorry for Brooke it makes me so upset because she is so lovely and intelligent and you can just see everyone judging her because of her weight and she’s really trying
Marie's situation is so not taken seriously. She isn't just skinny, she's mentally unwell and needs psychological help. it's most likely born from trauma, the need for control.
Alice Is not my real name a mental illness isn‘t a personality trait doe. She‘s dragging Brooke like 24/7 and that‘s rlly mean considering that Brooke had it just as hard and that Marie is just as sick as she is.
that woman saying she doesn’t care if she dies, and she’s ready to go whenever, truly shattered my heart. I myself am overweight, and I never want to have to go through that feeling. 💔
I hate how the “super skinny’s” are always giving advice and judging the “super sized” folks. Like you’re both on the show for a reason, not just one of y’all.
@@ovs4744 I know! What I’m trying to say is that the media production team (I believe) centers around the “skinny” person talking nonstop about how bad the “super’s” food is. But they are in the same boat health wise.
@@ovs4744 also we are kidding ourselves if we think Marie just has picky eating. She has an eating disorder and has had one for quite a long time. 2 days in a food swap/clinic will not change that.
Marie is sick. Not toxic. She needs help and her judgment is clouded by a lifelong eating disorder. Being paired with Brooke was the best thing for her so she could really see all the misconceptions and unhealthy eating habits she has developed.
I used to be really fat. I had 390lbs in September last year, and when I saw that number it was way more than I thought it is. I was really mad at myself. It really hit me hard, and I realised I got to do something. Not just sit and wait for problem to resolve itself. It was a life changing decision, because I have probably been on the verge of developing some serious health condition... So at first I got my diet plan created on NextLevel Diet, which was super helpful to me. In the first two months of following my eating plan I lost 42 lbs. And by February of this year another 40, for the total of 80lbs in 5 months... After that I started slowly exercising. First just by walking, and eventually I joined a gym and now I go five days a week, still walking on the weekends. I realised that I am stronger than I ever thought I have been. Never had any confidence, and now I can run, do burpees, do push-ups... I take these small victories!!
Well done on your weight loss journey! It takes a lot of willpower these days, especially when we are surrounded by addictive food. Congratulations and a Happy New Year! :)
It bothers me that they didn’t even to bother to demonstrate Marie’s food habits. Marie will not change with just a little chat about daily calories. Brooke was so kind and patient during every other demonstration. Broke seemed to have a genuine desire to change whereas Marie appeared to really not care.
When people with eating disorders like anorexia see people that are thinner then them even if they’re sick, they think of it as a new goal to lose weight. My doctor showed me pictures of to thin woman and I just thought that I should look more like them even thought they where extremely underweight.
I was in Marie´s state during my younger years (18-20) and all that talk about « health » was only a way to make me feel better about my eating habits (400 kcal per day). I was 1,72 meters for 36 kilos at the worsts times. I was not only in danger of immediate death like Marie is, I also looked and was very sad. No more good moments around a table with friends, whom I considered with mixed feelings of envy (since they ate all they want without paying too much attention - a thing I couldn’t allow myself), disgust (all those calories !) and almost pleasure to think that they were going to get fatter and I wasn’t (I know that’s horrible). I recognise myself in Marie, she seems uptight and sometimes scornful which I was until I began eating “normally” again. I feel for her. She’s sick. More years of this diet and she’s going to die. She has to visit a good therapist. Anorexia is less shamed in our society but it leads to death. (Pardon my English, I’m French)
@@katepausig8562 That’s possible, but they also have showed the effects of being super skinny to the super skinny before and yet they didn’t do it this time. Despite it seeming to be very necessary this time.
The whole "I think she quite enjoyed the porridge" "It was baby food, I wouldn't have it again." exchange made me lol. As soon as they said that Marie was into superfoods, I rolled my eyes. I hope the fact that she was eating half as many calories as she should have been sinks in.
Brooke is a stellar human. She cleans Christine's wound and emptied the commode without making a face or flinching. I don't care what her weight is, I would be happy to have her as my doctor. I do hope that she sorts out her diet so she can be healthy and have a long successful career saving lives. Edit: wow thanks for all the likes 🥰
Me to! I’d be thrilled if she was my doctor! She seems like a brilliant human being and it’s easy to see she’s really trying to be healthier, I wish they would do an episode where they check up in everybody. I’d love to see where she is at now!
I'm not sure at all, but I've sometimes wondered if it's because people who under eat are often seen as "ill" or "frail" where as there's a certain amount of judgement that people over eat are "lazy" "stupid". None of it seems fair at all.
@@thegreenmanofnorwich Or I mean I know this sound stupid or maybe they think "Wow I'm glad I'm skinny or I'll end up like that". Show up looking like Marie at my school oh that's fine but show up looking like Brooke is going to cause you a lot of hell. I'm 13 and chubby and I keep getting pick on while this stick like girl don't have to deal with it.
@@ilpveanimeiloveanjme9462 briefly. I was a somewhat chubby kid. Athletic as a term (I used to go rowing) and fit as a twenty something (I used to go dancing a lot), but if you hit 30 gaining weight, it will be much much more difficult to shift in your 30s than it was in your 20s. Being sensible with food types and portions is difficult to learn, but it really is vital to learn to eat like a sensible person.
@@angeloddrev wow, i dont know what i am more surprised for,, the fact that THIS is the grimmest thing, or that u think that THIS is saying something, ur name is quite fitting, u are an angel and live in heaven, on earth things are a lot different xD
I love how Brooke honestly admits and accepts how much she eats and the unhealthy food she eats. She’s trying her best to see what’s going on for her. But Marie keeps insisting that she’s better and she’s overall just more healthier when she is just actually unhealthy and judgmental.
Marie is kinda annoying. I get that it‘s hard to eat more but the other girl didn‘t complain ONCE and like less than half she would usually eat. Insane.
While I think she didn't go in to it with the right spirit, I have a small stomach and physically couldn't eat that much in one sitting, so I do understand where she is coming from. I am used to smaller portions more often.
@@MM-dq2pi that's fine but you can tell Marie had the wrong mindset from the get go because her weight didn't even change at the end of the episode. The issue wasn't with her stomach size, it was with her attitude. She was a bitch.
I honestly believe that she thinks because she’s told herself that she’s just such a healthy eater (even though she’s killing herself) that everyone who isn’t following her diet is beneath her. She came into the feeding clinic with the wrong mindset and picked on Brooke for trying to change.
Arms 4 Our Hands Official as someone who has been diagnosed with Anorexia, I absolutely do and I also understand her mindset but having an eating disorder ≠ being an asshole. It‘s not an excuse. You can always decide to not be a bitch but she didn‘t even try. My biggest problem isn‘t even her not eating, it‘s her being a literal asshole to the other woman, who seems to be the sweetest person ever. She probably has BED or an eating problem that is similar to BED. She literally didn‘t complain ONCE. She just sat there and watched Marie.
@@penelope342 thats prolly cuz eating disorders like hers are competitive, i dont think she means to be, its more what eating disorders do to your mindset
@@BOSSMOPS. ya thats why i explained cuz saying shes rude and judgemental sounds like something someone would say with no understanding of eating disorders
As someone who has been overweight for most of my life, the dynamic between Brooke and Marie really bothered me. I find that overweight people always get judged for their habits, and skinny people always get a pass even if they are not necessarily healthy. Glad to see Brooke was successful
That's not always true, read stories of thin people, others laugh at them and tell them to eat burgers, call them sticks and anorexics. Obese women hijacked body positivity movement and try to make everyone believe they're healthy nowadays. Being on both ends isn't very pleasant and obese women can be very cruel towards slim ones.
@@angelinalonnberg1014 This is the stupidest comment I've ever read. Do you know what happens if someone stops eating? They die. And quite rapidly, in a few days only. And do you know why someone is overweight? No you don't. Because there are various and multiple reasons someone might be like this, going from diseases and genetics to psyche. Yes, food is involved and when an overweight person wants to lose weight, their diet is the first thing that should be looked at and monitored, making sure it is balanced and full of good nutrients, but it does not make everything. You cannot "not be fat" just by changing your eating habits or worse, stoping eating. Please just be a little less judgmental.
@@feufolleth just wanna say you are wrong. No one will die after few days with no eating - maybe if someone weight less than Marie from this episode. You know record for no eating is more than year? Especially overweight people can live long without any food. Water - yes, u will die after few days, but food? nope.
I feel so bad for Brooke because by age 4 she was overweight, that’s her parents not her as you only eat what your parents give you until then and none of it is your fault. It was the same with me as a child and it was one of the most difficult things ever as I forced myself to completely change everything I ever knew
exactly! and when she was 14 she was already a size 22. if her parents allowed her to eat as much as she pleased then that is somewhat the parents fault.
@Hubert Landing are you ok? a 4 year old is a toddler, incapable of accessing anything outside of what their family gives them. if a 4 year old is overweight you cannot possibly put the onus on them, they were fed from infancy a horrid diet and know nothing else. what could a 4 year old possibly know about carbs and macronutrients, all they know is that pudding and cookies and snacks are tasty and its all thats been available to them. it is completely and 100% a parent’s responsibility if their infant or toddler is overweight, they are the ones feeding them and enabling it. also i hope you know force-feeding a defenseless child is very easy. even if it’s not shoving the food down the child’s throat, they can still be punished either physically or emotionally and confined to a seat until they finish everything on their plate. what would you suppose a 4 year old child, who has little understanding of the world other than what their parents have taught them and lacks the ability to fully understand long-term health consequences of eating whatever fried food they are told to finish, would do in this situation.
@Hubert Landing so when you were a two year old you were cooking up healthy meals and cooking yourself avocado toast every morning, yeah sure, maybe you didn’t realise it or just haven’t thought about it, but Im pretty sure no 2-5 year old is cooking their own meals or rejecting meals from their parents
Ikr!!! I'm a people pleaser if I don't like something or when somebody offers me more I take it Marcell says hey wanna donut icecream bowl do u want dessert littarly when I'm done eating I usually wait like a little bit intill I'm wanting to eat witch is a few hours
I’m sorry but marie isn’t “health conscious”, the poor woman has an eating disorder. i’m only 15 and i weigh 3 more stone than her. marie should’ve been escorted to an ed clinic immediately. she literally counts everything she consumes. a little chat isn’t going to change her habits.
I hate how skinny people are associated with "healthy" because everyone's bodies and metabolism are built differently. A group of people can eat the same foods in the same amounts and gain/lose weight differently. You can be healthy and happy even if you're on the thicker side you dont always need to be skinny :)
I'm imagining she's so in denial about her anorexia that the only help she was willing to accept was this show :/. Unless someone like a family member wants to make the case to a judge that she can't take care of herself, she can't be admitted against her will. Everytime he talks to her you can see her give canned responses that don't seem genuine at all, just telling him what he wants to hear. She didn't even look upset to hear she didn't gain weight lol.
Brooke's meals weren't even that big compared to what I have seen in this series. I can remember seeing a huge breakfast - like, chocolate, bacon, eggs, fries... that shit in one sitting. so I was very surprised to see two slices of bread. that was actually pretty normal, but I would just change the toppings (more veggies and perhaps avocado as a butter), the type of bread (not so white) and add fruits on the side, so it would be more filling and I wouldn't be starving when it's time to eat lunch. I can see that Brooke's main problem was the cheese and it's crazy to think about.
I don't think they include her seconds. That diet alone isn't too bad, it's probably when she keeps snacking/ getting extras causing the calorie excess.
i feel so bad for brooke she gets talked down by marie. i feel like marie isn’t even trying and brooke really is. but i’m glad both of them are trying and have signed up for it ;)
Marie isn't even a dietician/nutritionist. I don't know why the people let her give "advice" she has an eating disorder too so shes basically telling Brooke to change to a different eating disorder :(
You’re right. She literally admitted it towards the end. To prove it further she didn’t gain or lose. She stayed the same. I guess I didn’t consider that this super skinny does eat a bit. Just super healthy food. I thought she was trying since she was eating, but I guess she said herself she wasn’t.
All the people saying how Marie was toxic obviously have never gone through an Ed. Wait till you realize an Ed fucks up your mind HORRIBLY😳not just physically 😐
@@leila.7754 @Leila. She is toxic just because she hasn't eating disorder doesn't absolve her from being toxic it means she has a reason and people could be more gentle with it but it doesn't mean she wasn't rude and toxic. Doesn't matter if she's sick Brooke didn't deserve that.
@Sharee Mitchell yeah, I agree. When your period stops due to eating too little or exercising too much, this is a warning sign that your body is not functioning correctly, and should not be taken lightly.
For the first half of the show I was convinced 50% of Marie's problem was autism and food avoidance/sensory issues but watching her actually eat a good amount of food that she clearly doesn't enjoy and the fact she gained no weight throughout the experiment, lends itself to the idea she does infact have an eating disorder, quite possibly bulimia given her ability and willingness to eat fairly good sized portions
bulimia is when you eat large portions of food and then make yourself throw it up. i believe marie likely has orthorexia, which is only eating healthy foods very obsessively.
Bulimia is so far off... she doesn't binge and purge. She likely has orthorexia given her fixation on "healthy" food, "super foods", organic ingredients and the fact that eating white bread was such a big deal to her
It doesn't help that she didn't have a clue how to cook. Not when it comes to elevating food from a bland mess to something delicious via the use of herbs and spices. She seemed like a very fearful woman. Anxious over the harms that certain foods could do to her. Which is OK to an extent, but she was taking the fears far too far. There also may be an element of her thinking that she knew better about nutrition than the doctor advising her. Which might actually be true with some of his terrible advice. With her being stubborn and sticking to her guns instead of adopting his.
When Brooke told Marie that she probably should try eating a little bit more of the food since that’s what they came there to do and Marie said “ I don’t think that’s the name of the game“ my jaw dropped because that is literally exactly the name of the game and exactly what they are there for.
I may be entirely wrong but i searched for marie on google, there was a Marie Sheratt who passed away in May 2022 in the west of england (that’s the accent she has). I’d be so sad to hear she never put the weight on :(
Shes clearly autistic, the way she counts her almonds, eats the same everyday, is picky about what parts of the food is good to eat, the fact that she put ear plugs in before she grinded her almonds... She is clearly autstic and it can be painful to eat textures your bory chose it doesnt like and she shouldn't be forced to eat those!!! Please stop hating on marie
I love how Brooke is still positive and genuinely nice to other people. Like she knows she has a problem and she wants to fix it but she still smiles each day and that’s honestly so inspiring
I actually salivated over most of the skinny womans food.. Its actusloy really nutrient rich which is why sge was able to walk around on such small amounts of food.. The downside is she has no buffer... When you eat like that food affects your mood extremely quickly because your body sends distress signals when it doesn't have nutrients coming down the pipeline.... I think her attitude and crankiness is just down the diet change..
@@kkibela I don't blame her for getting cranky and good for her to take part! They say she can't exercise without getting exhausted unfortunately. She's obviously struggling with orthorexic behaviours. I love high nutrient foods but that can be such a slippery slope. I really like your comment about distress signals, I didn't think about that even being a thing!
My dad said about smoking, "we're gonna die anyway, so I might as well die doing something I enjoy!" I told him it doesn't work like that, you don't die with a lit cigarette in your hand and a smile on your face...20 years later he died from cancer and he suffered tremendously. We shouldn't be so willing to die for our addiction
"as usual, Marie has a complaint." Was such great shade. Love it. The supersize lady was so lovely and really making an effort. The superskinny lady really refused to admit she might have a problem. I think so many of these people (on both sides) have undiagnosed eating disorders (often food-type aversions).
Underfeeding her husband then starving herself and giving him scraps... something quite dark going on there. Bet Marie's husband is stuffing the bacon butties down on the sly, poor sod.
Alice InChristchurch There’s definitely an eating disorder she’s refusing to accept, disguising it as “healthy eating”. And must be hard for her husband.
@@Happyheart146 Me, too! I was 117, and still wanted to lose more! My friends said I looked like I'd come from a concentration camp. Right now I'm on the too fat side at 167. This is at 5'5. 130 would be nice. To think I thought I was TOO FAT when I WAS 130!! Lol
One of my mom's former coworkers has a strict organic diet. Her teenage niece converted to Catholicism, thought the diet was part of the religion and got super sick. This poor girl honestly she thought she'd go to hell if she didn't eat organic veggies!🤦♀️
@@KannyValentine you didn't have to call the girl a "fat cow" for all we know you could be fat as well so don't go saying shit when you are probably the same at least brooke is confident enough to go on this show and work on her weight so you shut your mouth and keep your nasty opinion to yourself and leave her alone
I annoy myself so much of Marie giving food advice while she has an eating disorder. Second of all she is so rude to Brooke and she keeps talking about the white bread like we know it Marie you hate white bread.
@Hubert Landing fat leads to more long term illnesses such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes, which doesn’t exactly leave you with a great quality of life, but being significantly underweight for a long period of time is often more deadly more quickly. someone who is underweight is far more likely to die immanently than someone who is obese, so even though you may think that skinny doesn’t absorb disease, it is much more likely to kill you faster than being obese will for the simple reason that the body shuts down sooner when it doesn’t have sufficient nutrients to keep going
I really loved how Brooke was willing to change and didn't complain!🥰 But tbh I can also understand Marie, I used to be anorexic too and if I saw someone the size of Brooke it would much more motivate me to keep my diet going or making it even more extreme I remember back then I was scared of even looking normal sized, my motivation to become skinnier was literally looking at fat people
Brooke: I'm sticking with your portion, maybe you could try and stick with mine Maria: that's not the aim of the game WELL THEN WHAT IS THE AIM OF THE GAME THEN?!
Being that skinny she would have food sensitivities. She would be puking that up later on when the cameras are off. It's the body that would stop her from eating all that food. The body not used to that could easily pull all the potassium from her blood killing her dead. So you want someone to die so you can be entertained. Asshole.
I'm amazed at how clear it was that throughout the series the skinny ones tend to have have more serious mental issues. Marie thinks she is the healthier one... but she is sadly mistaken... While fat will take 30 or so years to kill you, anorexia will do you in within 5.
Marie’s eating disorder looks more like orthorexia than anorexia, when you suffer from anorexia you definitely know what you are doing is unhealthy, and you eat little food but you are not completely obsessed with eating healthy foods. When you suffer from orthorexia, you are completely obsessed with eating so healthy it, obviously, becomes unhealthy.
Munchkin Pie well for someone who hasn’t had an eating disorder before, a lot of people just don’t understand what it’s like and actually how hard it is to eat. It’s not that she doesn’t want to try, but sometimes it’s soo hard..
Gotcha Info I think that was the bigger problem... imo she clearly had an eating disorder and needs help further than a doctor being like “you should eat more”
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle.
This is the first one I’ve watched so far where I felt like the skinny one was really, truly underweight and has an eating problem as opposed to just naturally skinny and poor diet.
There’s no such thing as “naturally skinny” but I do agree with everything else. She is truly underweight. Edit: Guys. Unless you have some kind of severe medical issue, you are not “naturally skinny” or “naturally big”. Science doesn’t lie and myths like these perpetuate disordered and unhealthy eating habits. For almost everyone (I’m talking over 90% of the population) the only way to get skinny is to burn more calories than you consume. If you eat as much as you burn, you stay the same weight.
@@Ines-nk4rr If I ate 2k calories everyday, I'd be skinny too. That's nothing. I usually eat 3k+ calories and that's why I'm at 16% body fat. You simply don't overeat, you're not naturally skinny. I've seen many of my friends become fat, and vice-versa.
A lot of the superskinnies on this series seem like they need more than just a diet plan. They need psychological intervention, the food issues are a symptom of a deeper issue.
Definitely. This show serves people like the guys who don't make time for food, think only eating fruit is healthy or drink too much tea. Their weight is a result of bad diet only. But people who consciously keep their calories down don't get much from this experiment.
@@Sabrina-ss6uq I agree with you in that it is common for there to be a psychological deficiency behind such enormous deviancies in weight, but I think that it is far more possible for there to NOT be a psychological element for the supersized because humans tend to naturally trend towards gaining rather than losing. Some even say that they became morbidly obese just because they love the taste of food or get bored (from r/loseit on reddit). I think psychological counselling should be necessary for both, but it's worth mentioning that being underweight is much more indicative of mental unwellness - it takes intention to be so underweight, while it is so easy to become overweight.
It was absolutely heartbreaking when the American lady Christina said she doesn’t want to change and doesn’t care. She wants to smoke and drink and is ready to go. What about her daughter? Doesn’t she want to see her daughter grow up, watch her daughter have children of her own and for her to become a grandmother? Broke my heart. I wonder if she would have given the same answer if her daughter was sitting there.
Because screw being healthy, why not just pour flavored lard down their throats to fatten them since that's the ultimate goal in half the viewers' minds?
Marie has a form of anorexia. Having an overflow bowl, where you have to remove/ organize your food is disordered eating. She's been that way for so many years of her life she doesn't even know it. I mean she moved a piece of carrot...
Orthorexia isn't in the ICD code. Its anorexia when the BMI is lower than 17.5 no matter what she eats . There is anorexia purging (laxatives , vomiting) and non purging ( no vomiting but sports/ exersice to compensate ) Otherwise its 2.) eating disorder not other specified or 3 ) bulimia when there is any form of purging and the BMI is over 17.5.
Jane Doe X keep in mind most people dont know what the ICD code is. Anyway I appreciate the insight on that, i thought it was recognized as specific disordered eating condition
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle. Her defensiveness is a symptom of a horrific mental illness. If it was so easy for people with anorexia to eat people wouldn’t have their lives ruined, become sick, or die. This may be a tv show but do your research before you trash someone who’s hurting.
@@kongwaguk8337 Brooke is probably in pain too yet she is still carrying on. Why the fuck pity skinny people but bash on bigger people doesn't fucking make sense at all. Also stop reply the same shit in other comments.
While I think she didn't go in to it with the right spirit, I have a small stomach and physically couldn't eat that much in one sitting, so I do understand where she is coming from. I am used to smaller portions more often.
It's not the fact that she physically couldn't finish the meals, I completely understand that, but she was being really rude about it, sitting there and picking apart everything wrong with Brooke's meal, like she already knows she eats unhealthy that's why she's on the show you don't have to judge her so hard. And I don't think she actually cared about gaining the weight because she saw nothing wrong with what she ate because in her head she was eating healthy so the portion size didn't matter and she used this as an opportunity to try to push her diet onto this other woman
Prob because of the way they’ve grown up and have been treated by peers etc... there’s a saying that “fat people are funny” I’m sure you’ve heard it before... or the saying you’re too ugly or fat to be mean..
I think your personality can predetermine what size you'll be. This is going to be very generalized but normally those who are more susceptible to accept overeating and becoming a larger uncomfortable size are more meek and passive while those who overly restrict their diet and exercise like crazy need a ton of self discipline and need to be overly harsh with themselves. Which is probably why we can see it so much in this series.
@@MangoRose1 that is an interesting observation, I don’t think it’s 100% true with everyone because there are always narcissists and exceptions to rules but I totally see what you’re saying.
@@MangoRose1 idk if you know who Amberlynn Reid is but she is a total narcissist and waaaaaay into herself. If you don’t know her then 👀💧hahaaaaa look her up dude it’s a SHIT show lolllll
28:40 Something tells me the producers were probably tired of hearing her complain about the white bread and so they made the sandwich with wheat... and she's still complaining.
@Skip White Eating a few high calorie meals for a TV show is not "asking her to eat herself to death." Don't be dramatic. She is starving herself to death. Funny how you agree with her killing herself by starving herself but cherry pick obese people as "eating themselves to death". No wonder anorexia is overlooked. People like you encourage it as being okay. Shame on you.
@@mandyschmidt7164 I would be so pissed off if I entered this an my housemate ONLY FUCKING ATE CHEESE AND WHITE BREAD. I like having a daily BM. And btw skip white never was in agreement with Marie's anorexia. Your jumping to unsubstantiated conclusions, and looking for a senseless argument.
1. Marie ate with her mouth open, like, ew. 2. She wouldn’t even try to eat as much as she could have. 3. She doesn’t accept the fact she needs help with her diet. She isn’t helping herself what so ever, however for Brooke, well done, I think she really tried!
that sandwiches with supermarket products don't look appetising. British food is rarely tasty and appetising.. I'm thin too and when the food is not delicious I just can't eat it! Or I should be very hungry to eat it. Or I should exercise before eating to get hungry. Also, thin people have little stomachs and we often can't finish the plates.
Honestly? You don't know what it's like being at that weight do you? Being anorexic means she'd find it hard to eat as for Brooke she could eat everything Marie had on her plate. I had anorexia and I would feel sick everytime I could smell food
I really feel for Brooke. What she’s eating isn’t necessarily the worst things she could eat but the portions are rather extreme. However the last thing she needs is for someone who is extremely underweight to tell her where she is going wrong. It’s discouraging
@@katiepurcell7200 that's true, but people having more weight than average do have more chance of getting sick. My uncle, was 90kg (I assume that he lied having a best friend with similar posture, 120kg. Must be about 110kg, 1.8 meters high.) He didn't looked bad looking quite fit for his weight. However it didn't end well for him. Even though he was still in his 40s.
@@RikuoSawamander no. underweight people who persist in eating too little die very quickly. When their bodies start to metabolize their organ tissues for fuel it releases a toxin. And we're genetically predisposed to avoid famine at all costs simply because it is so deadly. And in the event of an actual mass famine it usually isn't the starvation that kills them- its the spread of disease that they are unable to fend off. Think about it you can survive years and years of gluttony but less than one year of famine. It was very upsetting that the skinny woman in this episode was so pleased with herself that she was unwilling the even make an effort.
How tf did Brooke keep her temper with her swap partner constantly complaining about little things. I would have chucked my plate at her 2 seconds into the swap 😂
If they send the overweight person to the states to shock them they should also send the underweight people to an eating disorder clinic to see what there life could turn out to be
meryl freiman that’ll make people with eating disorders want to continue starving and doing there things. they would get competitive and try getting even thinner
“I can see you’re disappointed.” *Marie NOT disappointed one bit, nods head* Lmao she’s so pleased she didn’t put weight on. She needs more intensive help, tbh. Plus an attitude adjustment.
Maria is definitly a toxic person and her constant negativity is just... ugh. When Brooke tells Maria that Maria needs to "try a bit harder", and the call out about the portion size, should have been a moment for Maria but she stuck to her ways. You can tell that Brooke really wants to improve and is putting in the effort where as I honestly don't know why Maria even bothered with getting on this show. All the hugs and best of wishes to Brooke! I hope she has improved her health since this episode filmed and aired.
@Angelina Lönnberg No. Acknowledgement is the first step towards recovery. Brook acknowledged and took the steps towards making a change. Maria is in full out denial. And there is such a thing as being "unhealthy skinny". Maria has an eating disorder. DO NOT CALL THAT NORMAL!
@Angelina Lönnberg You're a horrible and toxic person. All you see is the surface appearance rather than the symptoms that these individuals are trying to treat. I've known people who are healthier than either of these two but, because of medications, put on a lot of weight. Appearances aren't everything. Being overweight isn't healthy. But neither is being too skinny because of excessive approaches to diet.
I don’t know what beef extract is, but it looked covered in butter. Agree though, that’s not too bad. Though white bread isn’t good for you. You also shouldn’t dowse bread in butter. Ewwwwwwww! She added beef broth to the toast. That’s disgusting! No wonder they said it like that. That sounds incredibly unhealthy.
100% he does I mean Marie is eating fine she’s just not eating enough she’s also probably younger then she looks if she’s still having a period I put her in her 50’s till I heard she misses periods so 35-40’s
i like how Brooke tried as hard as she could to eat the food and make an effort, whilst Marie signed up for this show and is complaining 24/7 about the white bread and cheese.
i think she was struggling with a severe case of anorexia/orthorexia. she was unnecessarily rude to brooke, but i dont think her eating patterns were necessarily her fault
remember she had an eating disorder aswell. its harder for a person with under eating to eat. than it is for a over eat to just eat a little. bc then the plate is done. they used to big meals. they can fit that small meal. under eaters cant.. + like this woman she thought much about what she puts in bc off her eating disorder. remember it goes both ways. non of them did wrong.
@@charlie.48420 ofc they both hard but as i said. i rather have eating dirsoder where i eat to much. then not being able to eat at all. Bc i miss food so fkn much but cannot eat. I just throw it up. So yes imma say i rather have the other side.
Why doesn’t Marie meet someone (maybe recovered?) who has/had anorexia? Not to be rude but I feel like they had Brooke meet someone large and see what has gone into her body so Marie should have something like that as well?
First problem is that the difference between an anorexic body and a normal body isn't that dramatic at first sight. Second is that it is much less common of a problem, it would be harder to find an anorexic with similar issues. Third is, anorexics die rather fast, fat will take 30 or 40 years to do you in, and for about 20 you won't really have massive hindrances to your life. The other side of the spectrum is a whole different game, from the start patients tend to be lethargic and many loose social contacts because of that, and a lot just die rather fast, although the vast majority not from the eating disorder itself, but from an infection or another disease that wouldn't have killed a normal person
@@violetavinocur4487 that's not really true though. Anorexia can kill you quickly, as can obesity. I'm 41, have had severe anorexia for 20+ years. Unfortunately I have several friends in the same situation.
@@silent_amy I think it depends on many more factors, a friend of mine (she was a bulimic) died from meningitis which she got from some random infection that would normally have been no big deal. Did you have any close calls like that? I get the impression that caching a flu can be very life threatening for anorexics.
@@violetavinocur4487 Saying that anorexia is more rare is a pretty sweeping statement. And people can live a pretty long (albiet low quality) life with it.
Marie clearly has orthorexia (obsession with clean eating). Orthorexia, like anorexia, is all about "having complete control over food," to the extend of being an obsession. I fell into orthorexia as well as an undergrad, and one spring break I was on a trip for a whole week with friends, and had to eat tons of my "forbidden food." It just broke me, and together with a few other factors, that pushed me into binge eating, where I fell from "I have to have complete control over everything, including eating super clean" to "I can't have control over anything, so I'll just stuff myself mechanically." I've mostly recovered now, and I hope all the best for Marie. She needs a therapist and a whole different mindset, other than just eating a few almonds or broccoli, or try to bite into a piece of cheese but still feel sick about it from inside.
Marie looks too old to have periods; that's how bad her diet is. I was surprised when he said, "You probably haven't had periods in a while." I thought she'd already gone through menopause.
@@PrincessStarSparkle My mom stopped having periods at 30, not morally obese or anything, it’s different for every woman. Early meno pause is o in the family tho but I’ve seen it with many women.
Many people don’t realize that over eating can be an eating disorder too
because they don't want to consider they could end up that way. It's easier just to be rude about it.
Jake Dean under-eating is also a coping mechanism but let’s ignore that
@Jake Dean that's not the only reason kinda fucked if you think that
Mothernature i need to quit . I’m an obese teenager and have seen a dietitian but nothing’s helping :(
@@candacemichelle8345 you have to help yourself. Regardless of what you eat cut back on your portion size. Make sure you get plenty of sleep-this is vital.
Put more physical effort into things you ordinarily do and increase the amount you walk.
Walking is a fantastic way to lose weight. Start of walking even for five minutes, increase it every second day by another 5 minutes until you can walk for an hour.
Try to walk to and from school and anywhere that is close enough. The fitter you get the easier it will be.
Do not eat after 6 pm. Drink plenty of water and do not drink any fizzy drinks.
I hope this helps you to lose some weight.
Set small realistic goals and just work on them. Do not just focus on losing weight but rather about gaining health and healthy habits to keep you well.
Try work on your inner self and facing anything that you think is perhaps causing you to overeat.
If you are honest with yourself.
Best of luck 🤞
I love Brooke, she didn't complain once, ate everything, and kept a good temper against Marie who is honestly quite difficult to put up with.
I would have blown up mad so i respect her alot.
J B I totally agree. Brooke is actually acting like a child.
black star She was. I would’ve lost it. Brooke was trying hard to eat foods she didn’t enjoy, and she didn’t complain about wanting more. But Marie was complaining about every supersized meal. And trying to educate her like she is a dumb baby. It was horrible to watch.
Sarah Miller damn right like wth puts beef on bread. Just gross
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle.
It's so upsetting to me that Marie seems to be clearly suffering from an eating disorder and it's never truly addressed. She's so in denial it makes her seem like an unpleasant person when she really isn't. Someone needs to have a serious talk with her and get her some help.
She could probably have orthorexia
@@violetskiy854 definitely has orthorexia
Anyone that counts out exactly 27 almonds clearly has an eating disorder.
All the eating disordered people in comments tend to diagnose others. I want to tell them, being crazy doesn’t make you a psychiatrist.
Exactly. This show doesn't help people and that's why i stopped watching long ago
Brooke is literally so sweet and I can see that she’s trying hard! But Marie is not even trying, and being super judgemental about brooke’s food.. i know that shes trying to help and all, but the way that she talks to Brooke is just so rude.
She's not rude at all. This comment is ridiculous. Brooke is obese and getting to a point where its serious. She can't sit there and act like its hard for her to eat less than she does. Anorexia is a mental disorder. Learn before you speak.
Jaxo Dude, can you like, maybe chill? Sniff a candle? Smoke some weed and like, relax? Just be less... extreme? Just calm down, man. Here, have a pizza. 🍕
Jaxo she chose to go onto the programme lol
Jaxo over eating can be a disorder too
Chaewon Yoon i agree with jaxo. also, it can be hard when you have an eating disorder to see other people eating unhealthily and can be just as distressing as doing it yourself. i’ve had friends with eating disorders who can seem like they’re being really rude and judgemental, but it’s just something which they can’t control because they’ve trained them self to be disgusted by unhealthy food. so much hate on her it’s appalling
my body dysmorphia literally makes me feel like both of them on different days
you kinda bad tho, HMU on snap 😍😉
Saaaaameee
ik sometimes it doesn’t feel like it, but your body is absolutely perfect, also your like super duper gorgeous 😂❤️❤️❤️
Nose ring lil peep ?
Alana Stirling 🤫I know
Marie: never finishes one meal. Bashes Brooke 24/7 rude
Brooke: Eats everything, no complaints, doesn't bash her diet.
I know! Marie didn't know the word considerate, especially how to treat other people
I only agree with Marie's bad attitude
Brooke: makes great strides towards her goal
Marie: returns to the clinic exactly as she left it with only herself and her excuses to blame.
@@FrostyApril 0
@@FrostyApril she is fat
I love how Brooke ploughs through the diet swap without a word of complaint. She's a really sweet girl and really shows determination to lose weight. Marie, on the other hand, does the opposite; not clearing her plate, judges what Brooke eats like white bread and cheese. She also thinks "super foods" are healthy but she's lacking certain nutrients. No wonder she didn't gain weight
Shes clearly autistic, the way she counts her almonds, eats the same everyday, is picky about what parts of the food is good to eat, the fact that she put ear plugs in before she grinded her almonds... She is clearly autstic and it can be painful to eat textures your bory chose it doesnt like and she shouldn't be forced to eat those!!!
Please stop hating on her.
(This is comming from ab obese person btw)
super foods ARE good but vegetables by themselves are not enough
Brooke literally called Marie’s food baby food. Not sure if you just didn’t watch the video or what but maybe you should watch it again.
Brooke deserves to conquer her tyrimania.
Shes not shaming Brooke for eating white bread, she just feels icky because its highly processed which is totally understandable?
"But as usual, Marie finds a problem" 😂
hahaha 😂
Jess'x Sent me aha
Lmao
Annie Albrecht true😳
In it haha
Marie has a serious eating disorder and needs counseling and therapy. She's also in complete denial. Brooke is so sweet :( I hope her schooling and career at going well!
hi
Yea... clearly as extreme case of orthorexia
I was thinking the same tbh
@@icsx1797h it u r. Kzzmmxch no nkhh an in you bsbsccvscccccccç s
@@tamaramcgee5093 girl what you saying if u dona how to talk do not talk,geez
I feel like Marie thinks she's only there to help Brook and that she doesn't really need help but she's got real control issues 27 almonds really like damn enjoy life once in a while
Yeah I’m pretty sure she has orthorexia
@@dumpsterfire3214 wait what's that again? I know abt anorexia & bulimia but I've heard of that and never found out what it was
@@dog6380 it's an obsession with "healthy food". People with orthorexia find themselves unable to eat food they deem unhealthy.
@@JulieWhooly091 Oh woah today I leared I guess.
@@JulieWhooly091 well I didn't know that! Thanks for the information!
You can literally see that Marie is disgusted by food, just by the way she chews it. She's even struggling putting healthy food in her mouth. I can see the mental battle she is having, just by the excessive blinking and facial expressions, whilst she's eating.
Yes. She eats like a toddler trying food they don't like and almost spitting it out as they chew.🙄
And also the ,,overflow" bowl/plate is really concerning. Controlling how many carrot or briccoli pieces you eat screams eating disorder.
@@aussiemouth747🤣Complains like one too- “Don’t Wike it”!!!
I relate, anorexia is a bitch. Sometimes I roll my food up in little balls and swallow it like pills. The act of chewing alone is too much.
Marie has disordered eating but she also feels quite superior about her diet. The way she speaks to Brooke is really patronising and quite condescending. I feel quite sorry for her. That’s a really joyless way to live
I suspect it is hortorexia, that's and ED where people are not concerned with calories and their body image but rather with "eating healthy" food. It can be just as dangerous as anorexia when it gets to this level but I guess it partially explains why she doesn't follow the diet given by the doctor: she thinks that her idea of "healthy" food is right so it wouldn't make any sense to her to eat "unhealthy food"
@@loiracitr orthorexia
@@loiracitr its called orthorexia
Ya honestly that explanation was too nice. Marie's a bitch.
Yeah I agree
Marie complains way too much, Brooke's portions weren't even that big comparing to other supersizers'
I doupt she was recording all of the shit she ate
IKR, like she was a bit rude
Jamilyn Lethem exactly
3900 calories is really not that much.
Had she had a hard physical work and done exercises, she would be almost normal weight.
@@simonsms410 are you mad!! 4000 calories is double what a reasonably active woman should be having so expect to be double the size if you eat double the calories. 4000 calories is fine if you're a well built 6ft guy but if Brooke did 2 hours of gym everyday with that lifestyle she'd still gain weight. If you watch secret eaters there's a blonde woman who doesn't understand why she's running 6 miles everyday but still gained 2 stone in 6 months. It was because she was consuming nearly 4000 calories.
Brooke would have to be dragging boulders by your logic to have a healthy BMI.
I feel so sorry for Brooke it makes me so upset because she is so lovely and intelligent and you can just see everyone judging her because of her weight and she’s really trying
She's adorable just as she now and really patient and humble.
@Amritpal Kaur shes trying really hard, you could see at the end how much weight she lost.
@@smorsie1959 I think he got her name confused with Marie because she was the one hardly trying Brooke was trying hard the whole time
@@santiperalta9783 doesn’t mean she doesn’t need to change
lol like the the skinny girl isn't being judged. read the comments
Marie's situation is so not taken seriously. She isn't just skinny, she's mentally unwell and needs psychological help. it's most likely born from trauma, the need for control.
Alice Is not my real name a mental illness isn‘t a personality trait doe. She‘s dragging Brooke like 24/7 and that‘s rlly mean considering that Brooke had it just as hard and that Marie is just as sick as she is.
Dionysus Child I didn't say it was. I wasnt commenting on her personality, I was commenting on her health.
Alice Is not my real name aahh sorry. I thought u mean the way she acts and her attitude is bc of her mental health only
You can tell how self concious she is about her food
Kamaboko Gonpachiro marie probably has orthorexia
that woman saying she doesn’t care if she dies, and she’s ready to go whenever, truly shattered my heart. I myself am overweight, and I never want to have to go through that feeling. 💔
So incredibly sad for her daughter too
this makes Me feel fat and skinny at the same time
Perfect
Same!
Epic 🤣🤣🤣
I relate
Me too
I hate how the “super skinny’s” are always giving advice and judging the “super sized” folks. Like you’re both on the show for a reason, not just one of y’all.
They have a mental disorder ...
@@ovs4744 I know! What I’m trying to say is that the media production team (I believe) centers around the “skinny” person talking nonstop about how bad the “super’s” food is. But they are in the same boat health wise.
@@ovs4744 also we are kidding ourselves if we think Marie just has picky eating. She has an eating disorder and has had one for quite a long time. 2 days in a food swap/clinic will not change that.
It’s not entirely her fault, it’s her mindset because of her ED. Although she could’ve been nicer, she can’t help it that much.
L.p.
brooke was so sweet about everything, it’s sad that she was paired with marie because marie was quite toxic
Well she had an eating disorder and she’s had one for most of her life.
@@Grace-mb4pc eating disorder it's NOT AN FUCKING EXCUSE
@@emiliakoceak8911 it kind of is tho, her brain is just fucked up and she probably isn't responsible for all thoughts that comes to her mind
@@leo-gt6jm how did she find a husband then? Not fair. She’s not even pretty either
Marie is sick. Not toxic. She needs help and her judgment is clouded by a lifelong eating disorder. Being paired with Brooke was the best thing for her so she could really see all the misconceptions and unhealthy eating habits she has developed.
I used to be really fat. I had 390lbs in September last year, and when I saw that number it was way more than I thought it is. I was really mad at myself. It really hit me hard, and I realised I got to do something. Not just sit and wait for problem to resolve itself. It was a life changing decision, because I have probably been on the verge of developing some serious health condition... So at first I got my diet plan created on NextLevel Diet, which was super helpful to me. In the first two months of following my eating plan I lost 42 lbs. And by February of this year another 40, for the total of 80lbs in 5 months... After that I started slowly exercising. First just by walking, and eventually I joined a gym and now I go five days a week, still walking on the weekends. I realised that I am stronger than I ever thought I have been. Never had any confidence, and now I can run, do burpees, do push-ups... I take these small victories!!
Well done on your weight loss journey! It takes a lot of willpower these days, especially when we are surrounded by addictive food. Congratulations and a Happy New Year! :)
Congratulations 🎉 That takes a lot of self discipline and i’m happy you chose better for yourself. Good luck to you in your journey ❤
Have fun further😊 ❤
Brooke was so patient and remained kind with how condescending Marie was, props to her
The. ApexWolf it’s hard to believe Marie is married.
Marie is a pain and a snob. What she has to snobby about is beyond me.
It bothers me that they didn’t even to bother to demonstrate Marie’s food habits. Marie will not change with just a little chat about daily calories. Brooke was so kind and patient during every other demonstration. Broke seemed to have a genuine desire to change whereas Marie appeared to really not care.
They probably did more than what we saw. They were there for 2 days and we only got like maybe 20-30 maybe 35 minutes of them at the clinic.
When people with eating disorders like anorexia see people that are thinner then them even if they’re sick, they think of it as a new goal to lose weight. My doctor showed me pictures of to thin woman and I just thought that I should look more like them even thought they where extremely underweight.
It might be cuz it could be very triggering
I was in Marie´s state during my younger years (18-20) and all that talk about « health » was only a way to make me feel better about my eating habits (400 kcal per day). I was 1,72 meters for 36 kilos at the worsts times.
I was not only in danger of immediate death like Marie is, I also looked and was very sad. No more good moments around a table with friends, whom I considered with mixed feelings of envy (since they ate all they want without paying too much attention - a thing I couldn’t allow myself), disgust (all those calories !) and almost pleasure to think that they were going to get fatter and I wasn’t (I know that’s horrible).
I recognise myself in Marie, she seems uptight and sometimes scornful which I was until I began eating “normally” again. I feel for her. She’s sick. More years of this diet and she’s going to die. She has to visit a good therapist. Anorexia is less shamed in our society but it leads to death.
(Pardon my English, I’m French)
@@katepausig8562 That’s possible, but they also have showed the effects of being super skinny to the super skinny before and yet they didn’t do it this time. Despite it seeming to be very necessary this time.
I just wanna hug Brooke, she is a sun and you can see her struggling for beeing kind and keep herself smiling, but Marie don't make it easy.
Period
moria?????
marie woulda got popped in tha mouth. with tha most disrespect.. 💅🏽
My name is marie 🥲
Jóéhàrríll0
What happened lp
The whole "I think she quite enjoyed the porridge" "It was baby food, I wouldn't have it again." exchange made me lol. As soon as they said that Marie was into superfoods, I rolled my eyes. I hope the fact that she was eating half as many calories as she should have been sinks in.
Brooke is a stellar human. She cleans Christine's wound and emptied the commode without making a face or flinching. I don't care what her weight is, I would be happy to have her as my doctor. I do hope that she sorts out her diet so she can be healthy and have a long successful career saving lives.
Edit: wow thanks for all the likes 🥰
hoda aden I'm so relieved to hear that! She is a good egg.
Me to! I’d be thrilled if she was my doctor! She seems like a brilliant human being and it’s easy to see she’s really trying to be healthier, I wish they would do an episode where they check up in everybody. I’d love to see where she is at now!
they get paid to do that...
I wish I was like her
I’m very squeamish
she's a medical student...so yes and no
I hate that the thin ones always act superior that the larger ones, they both have issues not just the obese person...
I'm not sure at all, but I've sometimes wondered if it's because people who under eat are often seen as "ill" or "frail" where as there's a certain amount of judgement that people over eat are "lazy" "stupid". None of it seems fair at all.
@@thegreenmanofnorwich Or I mean I know this sound stupid or maybe they think "Wow I'm glad I'm skinny or I'll end up like that". Show up looking like Marie at my school oh that's fine but show up looking like Brooke is going to cause you a lot of hell. I'm 13 and chubby and I keep getting pick on while this stick like girl don't have to deal with it.
@@ilpveanimeiloveanjme9462 briefly. I was a somewhat chubby kid. Athletic as a term (I used to go rowing) and fit as a twenty something (I used to go dancing a lot), but if you hit 30 gaining weight, it will be much much more difficult to shift in your 30s than it was in your 20s. Being sensible with food types and portions is difficult to learn, but it really is vital to learn to eat like a sensible person.
Fern Davies sometimes the chubby people act superior tho n that pisses me off aswell
@@chloecox8041 Lol there is a difference between acting superior and acting nice.
That man says “you’ve got a toe missing” like it’s nothing. Like “oh you dropped your wallet”
Such are the effects of desensitisation.
That was the grimmest thing I ever saw on youtube, and that's saying something! Absolutely rank.
What time was this?
@@angeloddrev I was eating lmao
@@angeloddrev wow, i dont know what i am more surprised for,, the fact that THIS is the grimmest thing, or that u think that THIS is saying something, ur name is quite fitting, u are an angel and live in heaven, on earth things are a lot different xD
I love how Brooke honestly admits and accepts how much she eats and the unhealthy food she eats. She’s trying her best to see what’s going on for her. But Marie keeps insisting that she’s better and she’s overall just more healthier when she is just actually unhealthy and judgmental.
Marie is kinda annoying. I get that it‘s hard to eat more but the other girl didn‘t complain ONCE and like less than half she would usually eat. Insane.
While I think she didn't go in to it with the right spirit, I have a small stomach and physically couldn't eat that much in one sitting, so I do understand where she is coming from. I am used to smaller portions more often.
@@MM-dq2pi that's fine but you can tell Marie had the wrong mindset from the get go because her weight didn't even change at the end of the episode. The issue wasn't with her stomach size, it was with her attitude. She was a bitch.
I honestly believe that she thinks because she’s told herself that she’s just such a healthy eater (even though she’s killing herself) that everyone who isn’t following her diet is beneath her. She came into the feeding clinic with the wrong mindset and picked on Brooke for trying to change.
Arms 4 Our Hands Official all of us?
Arms 4 Our Hands Official as someone who has been diagnosed with Anorexia, I absolutely do and I also understand her mindset but having an eating disorder ≠ being an asshole. It‘s not an excuse. You can always decide to not be a bitch but she didn‘t even try. My biggest problem isn‘t even her not eating, it‘s her being a literal asshole to the other woman, who seems to be the sweetest person ever.
She probably has BED or an eating problem that is similar to BED. She literally didn‘t complain ONCE. She just sat there and watched Marie.
Marie is what kale would be like as a person.
Violet Seven 😂😂😂
Yessss 😂
Kale is delicious sautéed with bacon 😂
Pahahaha or brussel sprouts
@@anubagchi1436 no it's just bacon is delicious
Brooke literally deserves the world. You can see she's actually trying her best to lose weight, and she's so nice to Maria. ❤️
ik and maria is so rude and judgemental
@@penelope342 thats prolly cuz eating disorders like hers are competitive, i dont think she means to be, its more what eating disorders do to your mindset
@@jax-ou6yh It's an explanation, not an excuse.
@@BOSSMOPS. ya thats why i explained cuz saying shes rude and judgemental sounds like something someone would say with no understanding of eating disorders
@@BOSSMOPS. not saying its okay to be but if you say something like that ; chances are you dont understand eating disorders
As someone who has been overweight for most of my life, the dynamic between Brooke and Marie really bothered me. I find that overweight people always get judged for their habits, and skinny people always get a pass even if they are not necessarily healthy. Glad to see Brooke was successful
That's not always true, read stories of thin people, others laugh at them and tell them to eat burgers, call them sticks and anorexics. Obese women hijacked body positivity movement and try to make everyone believe they're healthy nowadays. Being on both ends isn't very pleasant and obese women can be very cruel towards slim ones.
@@angelinalonnberg1014 This is the stupidest comment I've ever read. Do you know what happens if someone stops eating? They die. And quite rapidly, in a few days only. And do you know why someone is overweight? No you don't. Because there are various and multiple reasons someone might be like this, going from diseases and genetics to psyche. Yes, food is involved and when an overweight person wants to lose weight, their diet is the first thing that should be looked at and monitored, making sure it is balanced and full of good nutrients, but it does not make everything. You cannot "not be fat" just by changing your eating habits or worse, stoping eating. Please just be a little less judgmental.
@@feufolleth just wanna say you are wrong. No one will die after few days with no eating - maybe if someone weight less than Marie from this episode. You know record for no eating is more than year? Especially overweight people can live long without any food. Water - yes, u will die after few days, but food? nope.
@@feufolleth most of the time you can tho, most of you just love shoving your mouth too much
@@SavannahDias-Gill-it6wt not everyone wants to die like u
Brooke has such a beautiful face and she has such an amazing personality
Omg
Haritha Reddy she is pretty and her heart and personality r beautiful !
So true
Lol
I feel so bad for Brooke because by age 4 she was overweight, that’s her parents not her as you only eat what your parents give you until then and none of it is your fault. It was the same with me as a child and it was one of the most difficult things ever as I forced myself to completely change everything I ever knew
I completely agree, if a child is overweight or underweight it should reflect on the parents. I wish you all the best by the way 😃
exactly! and when she was 14 she was already a size 22. if her parents allowed her to eat as much as she pleased then that is somewhat the parents fault.
@Hubert Landing are you ok? a 4 year old is a toddler, incapable of accessing anything outside of what their family gives them. if a 4 year old is overweight you cannot possibly put the onus on them, they were fed from infancy a horrid diet and know nothing else. what could a 4 year old possibly know about carbs and macronutrients, all they know is that pudding and cookies and snacks are tasty and its all thats been available to them. it is completely and 100% a parent’s responsibility if their infant or toddler is overweight, they are the ones feeding them and enabling it.
also i hope you know force-feeding a defenseless child is very easy. even if it’s not shoving the food down the child’s throat, they can still be punished either physically or emotionally and confined to a seat until they finish everything on their plate. what would you suppose a 4 year old child, who has little understanding of the world other than what their parents have taught them and lacks the ability to fully understand long-term health consequences of eating whatever fried food they are told to finish, would do in this situation.
@Hubert Landing so when you were a two year old you were cooking up healthy meals and cooking yourself avocado toast every morning, yeah sure, maybe you didn’t realise it or just haven’t thought about it, but Im pretty sure no 2-5 year old is cooking their own meals or rejecting meals from their parents
Ikr!!! I'm a people pleaser if I don't like something or when somebody offers me more I take it Marcell says hey wanna donut icecream bowl do u want dessert littarly when I'm done eating I usually wait like a little bit intill I'm wanting to eat witch is a few hours
I’m sorry but marie isn’t “health conscious”, the poor woman has an eating disorder. i’m only 15 and i weigh 3 more stone than her. marie should’ve been escorted to an ed clinic immediately. she literally counts everything she consumes. a little chat isn’t going to change her habits.
I totally agree. She needs help
I hate how skinny people are associated with "healthy" because everyone's bodies and metabolism are built differently. A group of people can eat the same foods in the same amounts and gain/lose weight differently. You can be healthy and happy even if you're on the thicker side you dont always need to be skinny :)
@@catherineb6889 i agree. the “ideal” standard that society has set is just stupid. like you said, everyone’s bodies are different.
Dude why the fuck do you think she's on the show
I'm imagining she's so in denial about her anorexia that the only help she was willing to accept was this show :/. Unless someone like a family member wants to make the case to a judge that she can't take care of herself, she can't be admitted against her will. Everytime he talks to her you can see her give canned responses that don't seem genuine at all, just telling him what he wants to hear. She didn't even look upset to hear she didn't gain weight lol.
Brooke's meals weren't even that big compared to what I have seen in this series. I can remember seeing a huge breakfast - like, chocolate, bacon, eggs, fries... that shit in one sitting. so I was very surprised to see two slices of bread. that was actually pretty normal, but I would just change the toppings (more veggies and perhaps avocado as a butter), the type of bread (not so white) and add fruits on the side, so it would be more filling and I wouldn't be starving when it's time to eat lunch. I can see that Brooke's main problem was the cheese and it's crazy to think about.
Yeah, cheese can add serious calories to a diet that was somewhat normal otherwise. Her last dinner served was a VERY large plateful though.
I don't think they include her seconds. That diet alone isn't too bad, it's probably when she keeps snacking/ getting extras causing the calorie excess.
I love the doctor hes very straight forward and doesnt sugar coat it but he isnt rude.
sugar-coating would defeat the point now, wouldn't it
janet's babyshower if he coated it in sugar they’d probably eat it
@@olliedylan1381 oh my god lol
It's the British in him that makes him seem like that.
@@micellea It's totally true isn't it? He could probably say the rudest thing to me and I'd be omg I LOVE your accent! Insult me more, please!
i feel so bad for brooke she gets talked down by marie. i feel like marie isn’t even trying and brooke really is. but i’m glad both of them are trying and have signed up for it ;)
Marie isn't even a dietician/nutritionist. I don't know why the people let her give "advice" she has an eating disorder too so shes basically telling Brooke to change to a different eating disorder :(
You’re right. She literally admitted it towards the end. To prove it further she didn’t gain or lose. She stayed the same. I guess I didn’t consider that this super skinny does eat a bit. Just super healthy food. I thought she was trying since she was eating, but I guess she said herself she wasn’t.
@@FullmoonPhantom-dn2sr she's orthorexic. it's really a bad eating disorder
All the people saying how Marie was toxic obviously have never gone through an Ed. Wait till you realize an Ed fucks up your mind HORRIBLY😳not just physically 😐
@@leila.7754 @Leila. She is toxic just because she hasn't eating disorder doesn't absolve her from being toxic it means she has a reason and people could be more gentle with it but it doesn't mean she wasn't rude and toxic. Doesn't matter if she's sick Brooke didn't deserve that.
The lady without periods seriously needed to stop giving nutrition advice.
I love how you referred to her as “The lady without periods” instead of Marie or the skinny one 😂
I figured that would be the one positive thing about being underweight is not having periods anymore. I would be excited.
@Sharee Mitchell yeah, I agree. When your period stops due to eating too little or exercising too much, this is a warning sign that your body is not functioning correctly, and should not be taken lightly.
just because they have a disorder doesn't mean they don't know how to diet that's usually how eating disorders get started
@@KeepItUpbeat I wouldn't recommend it. Mine came back with a vengeance.
For the first half of the show I was convinced 50% of Marie's problem was autism and food avoidance/sensory issues but watching her actually eat a good amount of food that she clearly doesn't enjoy and the fact she gained no weight throughout the experiment, lends itself to the idea she does infact have an eating disorder, quite possibly bulimia given her ability and willingness to eat fairly good sized portions
She definitely has orthorexia or arfid… not bulimia
bulimia is when you eat large portions of food and then make yourself throw it up. i believe marie likely has orthorexia, which is only eating healthy foods very obsessively.
Bulimia is so far off... she doesn't binge and purge. She likely has orthorexia given her fixation on "healthy" food, "super foods", organic ingredients and the fact that eating white bread was such a big deal to her
It doesn't help that she didn't have a clue how to cook. Not when it comes to elevating food from a bland mess to something delicious via the use of herbs and spices.
She seemed like a very fearful woman. Anxious over the harms that certain foods could do to her. Which is OK to an extent, but she was taking the fears far too far.
There also may be an element of her thinking that she knew better about nutrition than the doctor advising her. Which might actually be true with some of his terrible advice. With her being stubborn and sticking to her guns instead of adopting his.
When Brooke told Marie that she probably should try eating a little bit more of the food since that’s what they came there to do and Marie said “ I don’t think that’s the name of the game“ my jaw dropped because that is literally exactly the name of the game and exactly what they are there for.
Yep! Poor Brooke got landed with a terrible partner.
She literally has an eating disorder of course she’s gonna try to get out of eating more food
I may be entirely wrong but i searched for marie on google, there was a Marie Sheratt who passed away in May 2022 in the west of england (that’s the accent she has). I’d be so sad to hear she never put the weight on :(
@@fiiawiiaouch.
Shes clearly autistic, the way she counts her almonds, eats the same everyday, is picky about what parts of the food is good to eat, the fact that she put ear plugs in before she grinded her almonds... She is clearly autstic and it can be painful to eat textures your bory chose it doesnt like and she shouldn't be forced to eat those!!!
Please stop hating on marie
I love how Brooke is still positive and genuinely nice to other people. Like she knows she has a problem and she wants to fix it but she still smiles each day and that’s honestly so inspiring
She'll be a wonderful doctor!
I actually salivated over most of the skinny womans food.. Its actusloy really nutrient rich which is why sge was able to walk around on such small amounts of food.. The downside is she has no buffer... When you eat like that food affects your mood extremely quickly because your body sends distress signals when it doesn't have nutrients coming down the pipeline.... I think her attitude and crankiness is just down the diet change..
Everyone has problems.
@@kkibela I don't blame her for getting cranky and good for her to take part! They say she can't exercise without getting exhausted unfortunately. She's obviously struggling with orthorexic behaviours. I love high nutrient foods but that can be such a slippery slope. I really like your comment about distress signals, I didn't think about that even being a thing!
brooke!
My dad said about smoking, "we're gonna die anyway, so I might as well die doing something I enjoy!" I told him it doesn't work like that, you don't die with a lit cigarette in your hand and a smile on your face...20 years later he died from cancer and he suffered tremendously. We shouldn't be so willing to die for our addiction
Watched my mum go through chemo and surgeries due to lung cancer. She no longer used that line now she realises the reality of it
Currently, she has lung cancer
Damn. You said it all. I'm sorry for your dad.
My sister passed from sepsis, renal failure....complications of cancer treatment Nov. 2021
@@stargazer1359 i am so sorry. She atleast was surronded by the people she love.
"as usual, Marie has a complaint." Was such great shade. Love it.
The supersize lady was so lovely and really making an effort. The superskinny lady really refused to admit she might have a problem.
I think so many of these people (on both sides) have undiagnosed eating disorders (often food-type aversions).
Did you obsessively watch this show as a teenager or did you have a healthy relationship with food?
Teenager rn and I watch 2 episodes a day 🧍🏻♀️ sos
@@seggs1270 me too... :/
My nightly activity ❤️ this or the weight loss kids camp or just people eating lol
Still obsessively watching and am now settled down with a child of my own
I feel very called out by this...
Underfeeding her husband then starving herself and giving him scraps... something quite dark going on there. Bet Marie's husband is stuffing the bacon butties down on the sly, poor sod.
Alice InChristchurch There’s definitely an eating disorder she’s refusing to accept, disguising it as “healthy eating”. And must be hard for her husband.
I bet he ate like a king while she was away lol
I wouldnt blame him
@@Happyheart146 Me, too! I was 117, and still wanted to lose more! My friends said I looked like I'd come from a concentration camp.
Right now I'm on the too fat side at 167.
This is at 5'5.
130 would be nice. To think I thought I was TOO FAT when I WAS 130!! Lol
One of my mom's former coworkers has a strict organic diet. Her teenage niece converted to Catholicism, thought the diet was part of the religion and got super sick. This poor girl honestly she thought she'd go to hell if she didn't eat organic veggies!🤦♀️
"health conscious Marie"
more like eating disordered
Margot Denise they all have eating disorders..
yeah. i'm not a psychologist but she has a lot of orthorexia tendencies
Salamae Salamae I said the exact same thing.
More like orthorexic
@@eveh9003 Orthorexia is still an eating disorder
Marie's food looks absolutely disgusting, like something they'd serve in the orphanage in Oliver twist.
😂😂
yes , except little oliver wouldnt be asking for more
I think I would like both of their meals (except for that beef toast thing)
But overall I love porridge, healthy stuff, white bread, cheese...
Lmao that’s so specific
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Brooke might be over weight but I think she’s absolutely adorable
Sarah Alise she is adorable , n she seems to be a really good person and very sweet
@@KannyValentine they are just saying that she is kind
@@KannyValentine you didn't have to call the girl a "fat cow" for all we know you could be fat as well so don't go saying shit when you are probably the same at least brooke is confident enough to go on this show and work on her weight so you shut your mouth and keep your nasty opinion to yourself and leave her alone
kk1209 you disgust me ugh
Sarah Alise i knoww, she’s so kind I felt bad for her
I annoy myself so much of Marie giving food advice while she has an eating disorder. Second of all she is so rude to Brooke and she keeps talking about the white bread like we know it Marie you hate white bread.
Exactly. It got on my nervesssss.
@Hubert Landing fat leads to more long term illnesses such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes, which doesn’t exactly leave you with a great quality of life, but being significantly underweight for a long period of time is often more deadly more quickly. someone who is underweight is far more likely to die immanently than someone who is obese, so even though you may think that skinny doesn’t absorb disease, it is much more likely to kill you faster than being obese will for the simple reason that the body shuts down sooner when it doesn’t have sufficient nutrients to keep going
@Hubert Landing ur just like Marie ur effing rude! And also you don’t call people fat and Marie was the underweight one.
This made me lol
White bread could probably be a fear food for her.
Could you squeeze a couple of more ads in here? Twenty-three just doesn’t seem like enough in a 45 minute show.
dude just get an ad blocker
@@uhh-rb9us adblock doesn’t work well on mobile
Go to the end of the video and then go back to the beginning it should play no ads for you.
No ads played for me; how come?
Yes I didn’t get a single ad weird. I think youtube decides that🏃♀️
I really loved how Brooke was willing to change and didn't complain!🥰
But tbh I can also understand Marie, I used to be anorexic too and if I saw someone the size of Brooke it would much more motivate me to keep my diet going or making it even more extreme
I remember back then I was scared of even looking normal sized, my motivation to become skinnier was literally looking at fat people
Brooke: I'm sticking with your portion, maybe you could try and stick with mine
Maria: that's not the aim of the game
WELL THEN WHAT IS THE AIM OF THE GAME THEN?!
Josephine Ish for real! like, the name of the game is for you to gain weight! You gotta start eating!
Health!!
The name of the game is to eat what the other person would eat. If they would eat 300 cals and you only eat 70,YOU'RE FAILING
Being that skinny she would have food sensitivities. She would be puking that up later on when the cameras are off. It's the body that would stop her from eating all that food. The body not used to that could easily pull all the potassium from her blood killing her dead. So you want someone to die so you can be entertained. Asshole.
@@micks336 wow someones triggered
Brook has such cute style. 😭😭😭 The bows and ribbons, cute cardigans... I love it.
Ikr she’s so sweet!
Yess. 🤭☺️
I'm amazed at how clear it was that throughout the series the skinny ones tend to have have more serious mental issues. Marie thinks she is the healthier one... but she is sadly mistaken... While fat will take 30 or so years to kill you, anorexia will do you in within 5.
true
Marie’s eating disorder looks more like orthorexia than anorexia, when you suffer from anorexia you definitely know what you are doing is unhealthy, and you eat little food but you are not completely obsessed with eating healthy foods. When you suffer from orthorexia, you are completely obsessed with eating so healthy it, obviously, becomes unhealthy.
@@hanne4984 I've never heard of orthorexia before, I only thought it was anorexia and the one that makes you over-excercise
@@nanachi-dl7iq that's bulimia i think
@@yuh8754 bulimia is the one where you throw up after meals
When Marie put earplugs in to blend the almonds 😭😂😂
I thought that, blimey!
Yeah, that really highlighted that she is a woman with some serious anxieties and quirks.
😂😂😂
Marie: *joins a diet swap and complains about swapping
Also Marie: "I dOn'T tHiNk ThAt'S tHe NaMe Of ThE gAme"
She’s so annoying 🙄
Spot on 😂
this is the funniest comment ever lmao
“I feel jittery and even gentle exercise makes me tired.” THAT IS BECAUSE YOU ARE NOT EATING ENOUGH MARIE.
She has no desire to change. If she were in an eating disorder unit she’d get the tube.
Those are the healthiest meals I’ve seen the super size person eat... Marie really needs to try harder
Exactly like shes not gonna gain weight if she doesnt push herself
@@lexigarner8436 she probably doesn't want to gain weight.
Munchkin Pie well for someone who hasn’t had an eating disorder before, a lot of people just don’t understand what it’s like and actually how hard it is to eat. It’s not that she doesn’t want to try, but sometimes it’s soo hard..
Gotcha Info I think that was the bigger problem... imo she clearly had an eating disorder and needs help further than a doctor being like “you should eat more”
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle.
I think Marie should continue to eat the types of food she likes - just double the portions. I hope she finds her way. Eating disorders are tricky.
This is the first one I’ve watched so far where I felt like the skinny one was really, truly underweight and has an eating problem as opposed to just naturally skinny and poor diet.
yeah same
There’s no such thing as “naturally skinny” but I do agree with everything else. She is truly underweight.
Edit: Guys. Unless you have some kind of severe medical issue, you are not “naturally skinny” or “naturally big”. Science doesn’t lie and myths like these perpetuate disordered and unhealthy eating habits. For almost everyone (I’m talking over 90% of the population) the only way to get skinny is to burn more calories than you consume. If you eat as much as you burn, you stay the same weight.
@@K-lg5hk Yes there is, I am here.
@@K-lg5hk
There is such a thing
But yh she was very underweight
@@Ines-nk4rr If I ate 2k calories everyday, I'd be skinny too. That's nothing. I usually eat 3k+ calories and that's why I'm at 16% body fat. You simply don't overeat, you're not naturally skinny. I've seen many of my friends become fat, and vice-versa.
Brooke: I'm finding this quite hard to stomach
Marie: *shocked pikachu*
J3FF THE KILLER no
J3FF THE KILLER
.
.
.
.
.
mate i knew the joke i just said "no"
Marie wasn’t willing to try at all and she was just soo rude to Brooke, who was clearly trying her hardest
She has a serious eating disorder. Her mind was probably in a state of panic.
shes fucking anorexic let her breathe
??????? it’s an excuse for the not wanting to eat , NOT for being a bad person
@@damianmroczny That's not Anorexia. Also Anorexia doesn't make you a nasty person
@@msfs19941 i should know what anorexia is because i was diagnosed with it a year ago.
Oh gosh. That open wound was graphic...
I do honestly hope she's way much better now.
Love and prayers from London straight to her! ❤️🙏
“because it’s not what you’re eating, it’s what’s eating you”
that really spoke to me...
sunflower vol. 6 hobiii🥺
sunflower vol. 6 i love harry 🥺🥺
A lot of the superskinnies on this series seem like they need more than just a diet plan. They need psychological intervention, the food issues are a symptom of a deeper issue.
Definitely. This show serves people like the guys who don't make time for food, think only eating fruit is healthy or drink too much tea. Their weight is a result of bad diet only. But people who consciously keep their calories down don't get much from this experiment.
that’s true for both of them, most of the superskinnies seem like they have ana or ednos and the supersizes have binge eating disorder
So true
@@Sabrina-ss6uq I agree with you in that it is common for there to be a psychological deficiency behind such enormous deviancies in weight, but I think that it is far more possible for there to NOT be a psychological element for the supersized because humans tend to naturally trend towards gaining rather than losing. Some even say that they became morbidly obese just because they love the taste of food or get bored (from r/loseit on reddit). I think psychological counselling should be necessary for both, but it's worth mentioning that being underweight is much more indicative of mental unwellness - it takes intention to be so underweight, while it is so easy to become overweight.
True. Like Marie didn’t even wanna change as much as Brooke, probably because she needs therapy and more motivation to actually want to make a change
Marie seems to be a very miserable human. She even looks sad.
It made me feel a bit depressed just looking at her
Of course she is, she’s sick! That’s not her fault...
@@jazzhandss25 she can control her attitude with Brooke though
True. But honestly I’m not surprised. Food is fuel. Nothing on her could work properly with what she was eating. I wish them both a lot of luck.
I mean she has an ED. Cold and miserable and hungry all the time is kinda The Vibe lmao
It was absolutely heartbreaking when the American lady Christina said she doesn’t want to change and doesn’t care. She wants to smoke and drink and is ready to go. What about her daughter? Doesn’t she want to see her daughter grow up, watch her daughter have children of her own and for her to become a grandmother? Broke my heart. I wonder if she would have given the same answer if her daughter was sitting there.
Nobody:
Dr Cristian : send them to america
@Elin FYFFE i was about to comment that
Abby Gardner x I also love how they played bango music in the back when they opened kristie fridge
Because screw being healthy, why not just pour flavored lard down their throats to fatten them since that's the ultimate goal in half the viewers' minds?
@@RheeasDomain this comment right here 😆
They're actually good at representing America on this show
Marie has a form of anorexia. Having an overflow bowl, where you have to remove/ organize your food is disordered eating. She's been that way for so many years of her life she doesn't even know it. I mean she moved a piece of carrot...
Orthorexia isn't in the ICD code. Its anorexia when the BMI is lower than 17.5 no matter what she eats . There is anorexia purging (laxatives , vomiting) and non purging ( no vomiting but sports/ exersice to compensate ) Otherwise its 2.) eating disorder not other specified
or 3 ) bulimia when there is any form of purging and the BMI is over 17.5.
no, it's actually ortherexia it seems
@@MsLemon42 that anorexia is not the eating disorder
Jane Doe X keep in mind most people dont know what the ICD code is. Anyway I appreciate the insight on that, i thought it was recognized as specific disordered eating condition
I clicked I this out of curiosity at night while laying in bed... I did not need to see a half decomposed foot before I slept.
😂😂😂
Yes 👏
Yep.. randomly here at 2am and absolutely disturbed now lol
yesss
@@nikki30 same here lolll
you know things are getting bad again when you’re watching this, and ED short films 💀💀
Real
Sharing the secret is a great ed movie on RUclips it feels very realistic
The skinny women is completely clueless about healthy eating smh
It’s a mental disorder and telling someone to just eat more is like telling a person with depression to lighten up. In the video it said that these disorders take on average 6 years to combat. This is just start of a long battle. Her defensiveness is a symptom of a horrific mental illness. If it was so easy for people with anorexia to eat people wouldn’t have their lives ruined, become sick, or die. This may be a tv show but do your research before you trash someone who’s hurting.
James Wood well that's hella ignorant
She knows what to put in her body to be healthy, but not how to do it.
Yet she called herself 'an intelligent women'. 🤣
@@kongwaguk8337 Brooke is probably in pain too yet she is still carrying on. Why the fuck pity skinny people but bash on bigger people doesn't fucking make sense at all. Also stop reply the same shit in other comments.
I dONt tHiNK thAtS tHe nAmE oF THe gAmE.
Marie that is literally the name of the game 😂
While I think she didn't go in to it with the right spirit, I have a small stomach and physically couldn't eat that much in one sitting, so I do understand where she is coming from. I am used to smaller portions more often.
@@MM-dq2pi but the point is to push past your limit... Marie wasn't doing that; she was just stopping when she wanted to because of the type of food.
Yeah what was she on about, what did she think the aim was
It's not the fact that she physically couldn't finish the meals, I completely understand that, but she was being really rude about it, sitting there and picking apart everything wrong with Brooke's meal, like she already knows she eats unhealthy that's why she's on the show you don't have to judge her so hard. And I don't think she actually cared about gaining the weight because she saw nothing wrong with what she ate because in her head she was eating healthy so the portion size didn't matter and she used this as an opportunity to try to push her diet onto this other woman
She wasnt even full she just wasnt eating it because its unhealthy.
Why do I feel like mostly all the supersize people are the nicest
Prob because of the way they’ve grown up and have been treated by peers etc... there’s a saying that “fat people are funny” I’m sure you’ve heard it before... or the saying you’re too ugly or fat to be mean..
True
I think your personality can predetermine what size you'll be. This is going to be very generalized but normally those who are more susceptible to accept overeating and becoming a larger uncomfortable size are more meek and passive while those who overly restrict their diet and exercise like crazy need a ton of self discipline and need to be overly harsh with themselves. Which is probably why we can see it so much in this series.
@@MangoRose1 that is an interesting observation, I don’t think it’s 100% true with everyone because there are always narcissists and exceptions to rules but I totally see what you’re saying.
@@MangoRose1 idk if you know who Amberlynn Reid is but she is a total narcissist and waaaaaay into herself. If you don’t know her then 👀💧hahaaaaa look her up dude it’s a SHIT show lolllll
28:40 Something tells me the producers were probably tired of hearing her complain about the white bread and so they made the sandwich with wheat...
and she's still complaining.
Marie: "it just doesn't make sense to me to eat something that you know isn't healthy."
Jesus she's about as fun as a dud
Claire Bowen not being rude but Marie has a very sour personality
Imagine her at a party. No thanks lol
It’s cuz she has Ed
@Skip White Eating a few high calorie meals for a TV show is not "asking her to eat herself to death." Don't be dramatic. She is starving herself to death. Funny how you agree with her killing herself by starving herself but cherry pick obese people as "eating themselves to death". No wonder anorexia is overlooked. People like you encourage it as being okay. Shame on you.
@@mandyschmidt7164 I would be so pissed off if I entered this an my housemate ONLY FUCKING ATE CHEESE AND WHITE BREAD.
I like having a daily BM.
And btw skip white never was in agreement with Marie's anorexia.
Your jumping to unsubstantiated conclusions, and looking for a senseless argument.
1. Marie ate with her mouth open, like, ew.
2. She wouldn’t even try to eat as much as she could have.
3. She doesn’t accept the fact she needs help with her diet.
She isn’t helping herself what so ever, however for Brooke, well done, I think she really tried!
Ella Louise - agreed
that sandwiches with supermarket products don't look appetising. British food is rarely tasty and appetising.. I'm thin too and when the food is not delicious I just can't eat it! Or I should be very hungry to eat it. Or I should exercise before eating to get hungry. Also, thin people have little stomachs and we often can't finish the plates.
@@Anasta313 I guess we need to ship her to america to gain more weight.
Honestly? You don't know what it's like being at that weight do you? Being anorexic means she'd find it hard to eat as for Brooke she could eat everything Marie had on her plate. I had anorexia and I would feel sick everytime I could smell food
I agree but I have one thing to say....
*BILLIE IS QUEEN* 👑
Marie: “I think she quite enjoyed it”
Brooke: “I wouldn’t want to be eating that more than once”
It's the other way around, sorry to be that picky person though
EVER.
Who else read that in the a British accent
Finella Debora other way round
Brooke should use her before & after story to motivate patients . She'll be a good doc.!!
I really feel for Brooke. What she’s eating isn’t necessarily the worst things she could eat but the portions are rather extreme. However the last thing she needs is for someone who is extremely underweight to tell her where she is going wrong. It’s discouraging
I don't get why he always targets the overweight people more. Being supper skinny isn't healthy either.
She's trying to prove that she's healthy when in fact she's very unhealthy, both mentally and physically.
Agreed. that sandwich was to big with too much cheese. Like if you gonna eat a sandwich have real toppings, color and variety.
@@katiepurcell7200 that's true, but people having more weight than average do have more chance of getting sick.
My uncle, was 90kg (I assume that he lied having a best friend with similar posture, 120kg. Must be about 110kg, 1.8 meters high.) He didn't looked bad looking quite fit for his weight. However it didn't end well for him. Even though he was still in his 40s.
@@RikuoSawamander no. underweight people who persist in eating too little die very quickly. When their bodies start to metabolize their organ tissues for fuel it releases a toxin. And we're genetically predisposed to avoid famine at all costs simply because it is so deadly. And in the event of an actual mass famine it usually isn't the starvation that kills them- its the spread of disease that they are unable to fend off. Think about it you can survive years and years of gluttony but less than one year of famine. It was very upsetting that the skinny woman in this episode was so pleased with herself that she was unwilling the even make an effort.
How tf did Brooke keep her temper with her swap partner constantly complaining about little things. I would have chucked my plate at her 2 seconds into the swap 😂
😂
That is because she is in medical field and they are trained to tolerate rude people like her.
100%
Ik she was annoying from the start
WhItE BrEaD
I thought she put carrots in her ear for a second
Promise Nani ok buddyyyyyy
I legit thought they were pills
I thought they were pills haha **carrots*
@@tams7411 thanks
@@yaaboiii3781 ??
Props to Brooke for her kindness. If I was being treated like how she was in this I probably wouldn’t have handled the situation like she has.
If they send the overweight person to the states to shock them they should also send the underweight people to an eating disorder clinic to see what there life could turn out to be
meryl freiman that’ll make people with eating disorders want to continue starving and doing there things. they would get competitive and try getting even thinner
This show is no longer running.
This won’t work. If you have anorexia, seeing skinnier people makes it feel even more worth while to continue. A vicious cycle really
They knew what they are doing
@@TomMinnow they'd probably want to go there for holiday every weekend if they show them the poorest parts of the world
Okay for anyone wondering
14 pounds = a stone
2.2 pounds = a kilogram
Thanckyou
IzzyAnne thank you so much young one
so a stone = about 6,5 kg? or am i dumb haha
Thank u vv much!
Thank you a hero in the comment section
“I can see you’re disappointed.” *Marie NOT disappointed one bit, nods head*
Lmao she’s so pleased she didn’t put weight on. She needs more intensive help, tbh. Plus an attitude adjustment.
Maria is definitly a toxic person and her constant negativity is just... ugh. When Brooke tells Maria that Maria needs to "try a bit harder", and the call out about the portion size, should have been a moment for Maria but she stuck to her ways. You can tell that Brooke really wants to improve and is putting in the effort where as I honestly don't know why Maria even bothered with getting on this show. All the hugs and best of wishes to Brooke! I hope she has improved her health since this episode filmed and aired.
@Angelina Lönnberg No. Acknowledgement is the first step towards recovery. Brook acknowledged and took the steps towards making a change. Maria is in full out denial. And there is such a thing as being "unhealthy skinny". Maria has an eating disorder. DO NOT CALL THAT NORMAL!
@Angelina Lönnberg You're a horrible and toxic person. All you see is the surface appearance rather than the symptoms that these individuals are trying to treat. I've known people who are healthier than either of these two but, because of medications, put on a lot of weight. Appearances aren't everything. Being overweight isn't healthy. But neither is being too skinny because of excessive approaches to diet.
@Angelina Lönnberg skinny body is uglier than an overweighted one＼(°o°)／
@Angelina Lönnberg I agree half of the statement tho... but Marie is definitely not healthy
Brooke literally has two pieces of toast for breakfast...
narrator - TWO THICK SLICES OF BUTTERED WHITE TOAST WITH BEEF EXTRACT
Lol
Beef extract does sound horrifying to be fair
I eat two-three pieces of toast and I'm not like fat tf
I don’t know what beef extract is, but it looked covered in butter. Agree though, that’s not too bad. Though white bread isn’t good for you. You also shouldn’t dowse bread in butter.
Ewwwwwwww! She added beef broth to the toast. That’s disgusting! No wonder they said it like that. That sounds incredibly unhealthy.
@@FullmoonPhantom-dn2sr In bloody ol' England they love beef bovril mate!
She's rude because she's hungry
Me too... my poor family😝😂😂
Lori Hutchings she's hangry 😂
Lori Hutchings you know what, that’s true. Every skinny (like, really skinny) friend I had verse all kind of rude
BAHAHAHAAA!
You’re not you when you’re hungry
I just KNOW her man sneaks a burger and fries on the way home😂.
I was thinking that too
100% he does I mean Marie is eating fine she’s just not eating enough she’s also probably younger then she looks if she’s still having a period I put her in her 50’s till I heard she misses periods so 35-40’s
Wow
@@kkandsims4612 om
He's sneaking ALOT more than that lol lol
Brooke is so sweet omg i just wanna hug her,i hope she is great now!
i like how Brooke tried as hard as she could to eat the food and make an effort, whilst Marie signed up for this show and is complaining 24/7 about the white bread and cheese.
i think she was struggling with a severe case of anorexia/orthorexia. she was unnecessarily rude to brooke, but i dont think her eating patterns were necessarily her fault
remember she had an eating disorder aswell. its harder for a person with under eating to eat. than it is for a over eat to just eat a little. bc then the plate is done. they used to big meals. they can fit that small meal. under eaters cant.. + like this woman she thought much about what she puts in bc off her eating disorder. remember it goes both ways. non of them did wrong.
god, people like you will do anything to demonise people with eating disorders
@@goldencleavage i get ur point but i wouldn’t compare them saying one is easier than the other. they’re both EDs
@@charlie.48420 ofc they both hard but as i said. i rather have eating dirsoder where i eat to much. then not being able to eat at all. Bc i miss food so fkn much but cannot eat. I just throw it up. So yes imma say i rather have the other side.
Why doesn’t Marie meet someone (maybe recovered?) who has/had anorexia? Not to be rude but I feel like they had Brooke meet someone large and see what has gone into her body so Marie should have something like that as well?
First problem is that the difference between an anorexic body and a normal body isn't that dramatic at first sight.
Second is that it is much less common of a problem, it would be harder to find an anorexic with similar issues.
Third is, anorexics die rather fast, fat will take 30 or 40 years to do you in, and for about 20 you won't really have massive hindrances to your life. The other side of the spectrum is a whole different game, from the start patients tend to be lethargic and many loose social contacts because of that, and a lot just die rather fast, although the vast majority not from the eating disorder itself, but from an infection or another disease that wouldn't have killed a normal person
@@violetavinocur4487 that's not really true though. Anorexia can kill you quickly, as can obesity. I'm 41, have had severe anorexia for 20+ years. Unfortunately I have several friends in the same situation.
@@silent_amy I think it depends on many more factors, a friend of mine (she was a bulimic) died from meningitis which she got from some random infection that would normally have been no big deal. Did you have any close calls like that? I get the impression that caching a flu can be very life threatening for anorexics.
She has orthorexia not anorexia
@@violetavinocur4487 Saying that anorexia is more rare is a pretty sweeping statement. And people can live a pretty long (albiet low quality) life with it.
Nobody:
Marie: oH mY aNoThEr WhItE bReAD
ckk 😭😭😭😭 yo 😭💀
She is complaining about only 2 slices of white bread while i do eat 6 slices daily just for breakfast
@@eileenchepkorir3316 White bread isn't that good. Should eat wheat bread. Also, that is a lot of bread for a day.
@@OmniscientWarrior its not a lot of break if it's your breakfast lunch and dinner
Thats the sort of thinking someone with an eating disorder like anorexia or bulimia has. Its a mental illness so she probably cant help it
Awww Brooke is an such a sweetheart!
I hope she’s absolutely blissful and healthier now.
Also cheese IS heaven sent so I get it.
Marie clearly has orthorexia (obsession with clean eating). Orthorexia, like anorexia, is all about "having complete control over food," to the extend of being an obsession. I fell into orthorexia as well as an undergrad, and one spring break I was on a trip for a whole week with friends, and had to eat tons of my "forbidden food." It just broke me, and together with a few other factors, that pushed me into binge eating, where I fell from "I have to have complete control over everything, including eating super clean" to "I can't have control over anything, so I'll just stuff myself mechanically." I've mostly recovered now, and I hope all the best for Marie. She needs a therapist and a whole different mindset, other than just eating a few almonds or broccoli, or try to bite into a piece of cheese but still feel sick about it from inside.
finally someone fucking said it she's very clearly orthorexic
They really should have realised that before putting her on the show.
@@patrickdoherty4527, she put on a facade of truly wanting to change.
Marie looks too old to have periods; that's how bad her diet is. I was surprised when he said, "You probably haven't had periods in a while." I thought she'd already gone through menopause.
Periods stop between the age of 50-60 so no she's not too old yet. However, bad health age's you.
How old was she then?
@@PrincessStarSparkle yeah but she looks that age
Missed her age how old is she?
@@PrincessStarSparkle My mom stopped having periods at 30, not morally obese or anything, it’s different for every woman. Early meno pause is o
in the family tho but I’ve seen it with many women.
american: The heaviest was 765 pounds.
british: That's over 50 stone
me: *cries in kg *
it’s around 346kg 😳😳
@@abbie794 holy shit
British use kg ya know
How tf do you measure in stone
Every stone is 14pounds
whenever I feel like starving myself or binge eating I just watch an episode of this and it puts me back in my place
REALL