Hadith Explained | Islamic Lessons Made Easy | Non Muslim Reaction Video

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 100

  • @halfmoon8296
    @halfmoon8296 5 дней назад +55

    The person in the video you reacted to is a Shia, representing approximately 10% of the Muslim population. Instead, you should consider reacting to "Are Hadith Reliable? A Practical Demonstration" by One Message Foundation.

    • @JUFFAIR101
      @JUFFAIR101 5 дней назад +9

      Less than 10%

    • @tarno_bejo_
      @tarno_bejo_ 4 дня назад +1

      Thats true. But, are they even ever honest to themselves of learning islam?

  • @majestictaleb
    @majestictaleb 5 дней назад +36

    This is not Islamic reaction videos
    this is shia video they are not related to Islam

    • @Maddy-c8v7d
      @Maddy-c8v7d 5 дней назад +1

      Who told you that

    • @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د
      @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د 4 дня назад +1

      Exactly 😊

    • @shychanel7615
      @shychanel7615 4 дня назад +1

      EExactly

    • @majestictaleb
      @majestictaleb 4 дня назад +1

      @@Maddy-c8v7d we don't have the "الائمه الاثني عشريه." And we don't believe in theme further more the N°12 imam in their beliefs is not the son of the N°11 imam since the last one was revealed sterile and can't be his son
      The imam action of hiding the boy from the public will confirm this accusation from his brother

    • @Maddy-c8v7d
      @Maddy-c8v7d 4 дня назад

      @@majestictaleb shia 12 imams= one way of praying.
      Sunni four imams= four ways of praying.

  • @LiONeLMeSsi13579
    @LiONeLMeSsi13579 5 дней назад +14

    Those Shia people say only 4-5 companions of the prophet are muslims, they reject all the other companions

    • @lionskid2393
      @lionskid2393 5 дней назад +1

      @@LiONeLMeSsi13579 Who burned the house of the Prophet after his death, killed Fatima and caused her to miscarry her fetus, Al-Muhsin? Aren't they the companions whom you revere and glorify? Where are you fleeing from the Mahdi, you cursed terrorists?

    • @mohammedomar6383
      @mohammedomar6383 3 дня назад

      @@lionskid2393 This all things not happened in the first place what are you talking about!! ALL FABRICATED FROM LIARS!!!

  • @Golden_Scholar
    @Golden_Scholar 4 дня назад +5

    We appreciate you're thirst for knowledge and looking into the aspect of hadith in Islam. It should be noted that this video is by a shia, and is not representative of Islam (It's a whole thing and y'all will probably have to watch several videos on this matter lmao). Hadith in a nut shell are sayings of the prophet, however to verify the validity of hadith, a stringent and meticulous science was developed to ensure the authentic of the narration of the prophet and so and so forth.
    This differentiates itself from Christianity, because the Christians and most other religions don't have a strong system of preservation when it comes to their books. For example, we don't know the author's of the bible, we have a first name but we don't know their last name, lineage, character, how were they known in their community, were they trustworthy, etc. Again this is not "Christianity vs Islam" this is just to point out a fact regarding the preservation of the scriptures and text that govern a people. If you can't authenticate and validate the words you follow, as Muslims, we believe that is a major problem and risk.

  • @RoyalBlue292
    @RoyalBlue292 4 дня назад +16

    Shia video???? No, no, no, we are Sunni Muslims.

  • @johndoe6817
    @johndoe6817 5 дней назад +8

    they should react to the cowboy muslim, maybe they will like him because he is American so i think they would understand him better

  • @mubarakngabonziza11
    @mubarakngabonziza11 5 дней назад +12

    This is a shia video, plz listen to the sunni perspective as well

  • @iAmA_Revert
    @iAmA_Revert 5 дней назад +19

    This a Shia video ?

    • @BosniannMuslim
      @BosniannMuslim 5 дней назад +2

      Thats what im thinking

    • @SoufBouchahati
      @SoufBouchahati 5 дней назад +7

      @@iAmA_Revert yes, unfortunately. Shia channel. Completely ruined the video with unauthentic info.

    • @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د
      @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د 5 дней назад +2

      Exactly, I noticed it firsthand

    • @lionskid2393
      @lionskid2393 5 дней назад +1

      ​@@SoufBouchahatiThe twelve Imams are metaphors for what you contain, O denier of God. They are names and spirits in the being of humanity, and for every time there is a pole and a god. Have you asked yourself why the names of the Imams refer to goodness, such as the name Hassan, which means the one with goodness, and Hussein, which means the one who does good, and Ali, which means the highest, and Fatima, which means expansion and division, and Muhammad, which means the praised one, and al-Sadiq, which means the one who speaks the truth, and al-Baqir, which means the one who penetrates things, and al-Sajjad, which means the one who worships and communicates a lot, and al-Kazim, which means the one who forgives, and al-Rida, which means the one who is satisfied with what he has, and al-Jawad, which means the one who is generous and kind, and al-Hadi al-Naqi, which means the one who guides people and is pure, and al-Askari al-Zaki, which means the one who shows beautiful appearance and the one who gives alms and gives, and you, O denier, deny them, you and the Sunnis. The curse of Ali and his family and Muhammad and his family be upon you and upon everyone who denies them. If it were not for them, God would not have been known and the truth would not have been known, and this is what happened. You were lost and Islam was lost by assassinating them and setting up hatred for them. O blind man, why does the Prophet refer to Ali in many places in your books?? And he did not mention the companions?? Do you know the incident of Ghadir Khum after the farewell pilgrimage of the Prophet because he will leave and he recommended you to Ali because God is among the servants, do not tell me love and this scum because it will become a farce to gather people to tell them to love Ali 🤣🤣🤣😅 The Sunnah is a farce.

    • @gamingone1036
      @gamingone1036 5 дней назад

      yes

  • @SoufBouchahati
    @SoufBouchahati 5 дней назад +4

    Great reaction guys! Love your sincerity, open mindedness and wisdom.

  • @SamT.93
    @SamT.93 5 дней назад +1

    The science behind Hadith is unique and far more detailed than how history is typically studied, even in the West. When we verify a Hadith, we don’t just accept the words- we investigate the entire life of the person who narrated it. This rigorous process, called "Ilm al-Hadith," classifies narrators based on their trustworthiness and memory. Only narrators who pass this thorough check are considered reliable, and their Hadiths are accepted as authentic.
    This method is far more comprehensive than how history is studied in the West, where there is less scrutiny over sources. The history we learn in school is often less reliable than the Hadiths because it hasn’t undergone the same level of verification.
    For non-Muslims, this can be hard to grasp, as the checks Muslims use for Hadith are much more in-depth than what is typically applied in Western history studies or Christian approaches. The science behind Hadith verification is rigorous and on a level of scholarly research that goes far beyond ordinary historical methods.

  • @AK-up3hx
    @AK-up3hx 5 дней назад +1

    One of the most underrated channels, Many Prophets One Message.

  • @mouhameduzi667
    @mouhameduzi667 3 дня назад

    9:19 The response to your question “how do your know” is exactly the science of hadith ( the video basically 😅)

  • @عبدالله-ن6ه2ص
    @عبدالله-ن6ه2ص 5 дней назад +2

    These books should be in your personal library to better understand Islam:
    1. The Book of the Sealed Nectar
    2. The Book of Tawhid, Sheikh Muhammad Abdul Wahhab, explained by Ibn Uthaymeen
    3. The Divine Reality: God, Islam & The Mirage Of Atheism, by Hamza Andreas Tzortzis
    4. The Qur'an: An Eternal Challenge, by Muhammad Abdullah Draz
    5. The Bible, The Quran and Science, Maurice Bucaille
    6. There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind by Antony Flew
    7. Structure and Quranic Interpretation - Dr. Raymond Farrin
    8. The Last Prophet: Evidences for the Authenticity of Islam by Haitham Talaat
    9. The Final Prophet: Proof of the Prophethood of Muhammad by Mohammad Elshinawy
    10. Why the Companions Converted to Islam? Farid Al Bahraini (Explains the reasons for the conversion of a completely pagan society to a Muslim society in the time of the Prophet Muhammad, may God bless him and grant him peace)
    11. Scientific Miracles in the Qur'an & Sunnah by Abdullah Bin Abdul Aziz Al-Musleh

  • @yeahehtheseguyseh3703
    @yeahehtheseguyseh3703 5 дней назад +2

    This is a Shia video, Shia makes up 10% of Muslims, while Sunni makes up 85% of Muslims. The narrator did add the majority way, but they also added to much extra noise or rhetoric because they are Shia, and it even got me confused. It is better to react to known scholars than random videos.

  • @Serialkillers736
    @Serialkillers736 5 дней назад +1

    أَفَلَمْ يَسِيرُوا فِي الْأَرْضِ فَتَكُونَ لَهُمْ قُلُوبٌ يَعْقِلُونَ بِهَا أَوْ آذَانٌ يَسْمَعُونَ بِهَا ۖ فَإِنَّهَا لَا تَعْمَى الْأَبْصَارُ وَلَٰكِن تَعْمَى الْقُلُوبُ الَّتِي فِي الصُّدُورِ (46)
    سورة الحج الآية 46 القرآن العظيم

  • @abdullhahmed4669
    @abdullhahmed4669 5 дней назад

    for the trust, each saying of the prophet always has a chain of narratives in the commentary
    my advice is if you have unclear questions, visit any mosque and ask the shikh or the imam, and he will bring you resources and history to back up the authenticity
    i really enjoy your videos, guys. i hope you all the best

  • @malekanas-zz6xu
    @malekanas-zz6xu 5 дней назад +1

    لا اله الا الله وحده لا شريك له له الملك وله الحمد وهو على كل شيء قدير ومحمد عبده ورسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم لا اله الا الله سبحانه وتعالى عما يصفون واتوب اليه واسبحه

  • @RumySulaiha
    @RumySulaiha 5 дней назад +1

    8:30 That's what we call tafsir which are different from hadith because hadith record the sayings and actions of Prophet muhammad pbuh.

  • @shychanel7615
    @shychanel7615 4 дня назад

    May Allah guide you truth islam those video is not sunnah

  • @Мусульманин-ц3п
    @Мусульманин-ц3п 5 дней назад +1

    Sura maryam reaction

  • @rolamohamed2188
    @rolamohamed2188 5 дней назад

    Hadith science is taught at Al-Azhar University in Egypt, and many religious sciences as well, and jurisprudential comparisons, religious sciences are a great sea.

  • @englishguru0007
    @englishguru0007 5 дней назад

    The science of hadith is an advanced topic and it's easy for newbies to get lost in it. Laymen only need know to know which is authentic and which is not, wiyhoit delving ino the sciences. The scholars have done a great job classifying which is authentic and which is nogover the millenia.

  • @CHCH-mc4mi
    @CHCH-mc4mi 5 дней назад

    profesor thimothy j winter one of greatest sufi of europe ,he is very good teacher

  • @yorkbyop8233
    @yorkbyop8233 2 дня назад

    man ask to see the sun,but he closed his eyes..just open it and see it even its hurt

  • @mouhameduzi667
    @mouhameduzi667 3 дня назад

    9:38 omg this guy is always entertained 😭😹 he said “who deliberately lies about me” not “everyone who lies”. Like the people who fabricated fake hadiths

  • @__NOONE__
    @__NOONE__ 5 дней назад +3

    First a lot of peoples try to compare bible and Quran and this wrong because our Quran is the unchanged word of god compare to bible wrote by different peoples about Jesus pbuh hundred of years later, what's right is to compare bible to hadith but you can't too because no one know who wrote the bible compare to hadith who wrote by the companions of Muhammad pbuh, imagine a lot of them wrote the same think about the messenger of God, if one person can't trust the hadith then this person must be don't trust anyone in history for example "Alexander the great" you can't proof anything about his life or what he said

  • @DeniSuryono-h3n
    @DeniSuryono-h3n 5 дней назад

    It's not like the Bible is disconnected from its initial source. And the Bible is always being revised

  • @KasishAgarwall
    @KasishAgarwall 5 дней назад

    It is not so easy to go to heaven, where you want to live forever, you will have to go through difficulties to get there

  • @jamynora4121
    @jamynora4121 2 дня назад

    Are hadith Considère. Réa tong to are hadith A practical de monstration onéreux message 🥰❤️🥰❤️🙏

  • @shychanel7615
    @shychanel7615 4 дня назад +1

    They are only 5 percnt representing shiah nation thier not representing the truth islam

  • @عبدالله-ن6ه2ص
    @عبدالله-ن6ه2ص 5 дней назад +1

    Eight RUclips channels that I like about explaining Islam to non-Muslims from Muslim preachers: DawahIsEasy Channel, The Muslim Lantern( Mohamed Ali), DUS Dawah Channel(shamsi), and One Message Foundation Channel (Sheikh Othman bin Al-Farouq) , ManyProphetsOneMessage, EFDawah, ,One True Message Foundation, DawahWise.

  • @bowospriyo1449
    @bowospriyo1449 5 дней назад

    So actually there are many educated people or scholars who are involved in the study of hadith...not all Muslims have to master hadith like scholars, even though as Muslims we are required to be critical in assessing hadith studies.

  • @moafro6524
    @moafro6524 5 дней назад

    How do you know? How do you know? We have the Quran, and the Prophet (peace be upon him) would never alter, add to, or subtract from it. Any hadith that contradicts the Quran is clearly not from him. Thankfully, we have the Furqan, the Criterion, preserved by the will and power of the Almighty.

  • @IncognitoTrap
    @IncognitoTrap 4 дня назад

    You don’t listen to any part of the video where it mentioned “chain of narration “. Open your ears. Plus this is a video from a Shia point of view who practically make 7% of the Muslim population.

  • @innocent3163
    @innocent3163 5 дней назад

    You should react on basic and fundamental things first, your choice of course but without understanding basics you might misunderstand

  • @lionskid2393
    @lionskid2393 5 дней назад +1

    Lie, the science of chain of transmission, authentic, weak and good was invented after the Prophet, and the verse has nothing to do with this matter because the Quran is considered part of the hadith and those who transmitted it are weak, i.e. liars. This matter puts the Quran and the Sunnis in a predicament, because the Shiites do not have the science of hadith, so they rely on rules. If the hadith is appropriate to them, then it is authentic and not a lie. As for the Shiites, a section of them began to use the science of hadith because they are attached to the Sunnis and are traitors to the truth of Muhammad and his family, and now they rule Iraq and Iran and have destroyed the servants.

  • @bluewave4019
    @bluewave4019 4 дня назад +1

    Shia is not part of islam..
    Its an invention after the death of the prophet...
    The problem with ignorants in the west that they don't know anything about islam..
    Shia is an invention in the religion..
    A new religion born later ...the true religion of islam is the sunny believe which is following the prophet
    The prophet and his companion never been shia and even Shia knows that...
    The reliable hadiths are only came from sunny books ...
    There's no hadiths in Shia ...the only real narration and science of narration (hadith) is from the sunny way...
    ..its a long way to learn about that ...

  • @mouhameduzi667
    @mouhameduzi667 3 дня назад

    I Justin a philosopher? 😹 I mean I love philosophy but the guy never really reacts to what we are watching he always divague. I like your channel btw but I feel like James is the only one that tries to address the subjects

  • @shychanel7615
    @shychanel7615 4 дня назад

    This is not real islam as a sunni dont ever react this video because they are not real follower of islam shia is not thruth be care full guys you will astray like them

  • @iedufitrayana1796
    @iedufitrayana1796 4 дня назад

    What if it is Shia? I come from Indonesia and choose Shia. Whoever says Shia is not Islam is a lackey of the enemy of Islam who supports the division of Islam.

  • @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د

    Not that if you Christians worship three , then the Shiites worship 12 whom they calls Imam . They gave them attributes of God, for example, they control the atomes of universe, they don't err, they don't forget, they know what was , what will be and what is....etc .

    • @lionskid2393
      @lionskid2393 5 дней назад +1

      The twelve Imams are metaphors for what you contain, O denier of God. They are names and spirits in the being of humanity, and for every time there is a pole and a god. Have you asked yourself why the names of the Imams refer to goodness, such as the name Hassan, which means the one with goodness, and Hussein, which means the one who does good, and Ali, which means the highest, and Fatima, which means expansion and division, and Muhammad, which means the praised one, and al-Sadiq, which means the one who speaks the truth, and al-Baqir, which means the one who penetrates things, and al-Sajjad, which means the one who worships and communicates a lot, and al-Kazim, which means the one who forgives, and al-Rida, which means the one who is satisfied with what he has, and al-Jawad, which means the one who is generous and kind, and al-Hadi al-Naqi, which means the one who guides people and is pure, and al-Askari al-Zaki, which means the one who shows beautiful appearance and the one who gives alms and gives, and you, O denier, deny them, you and the Sunnis. The curse of Ali and his family and Muhammad and his family be upon you and upon everyone who denies them. If it were not for them, God would not have been known and the truth would not have been known, and this is what happened. You were lost and Islam was lost by assassinating them and setting up hatred for them. O blind man, why does the Prophet refer to Ali in many places in your books?? And he did not mention the companions?? Do you know the incident of Ghadir Khum after the farewell pilgrimage of the Prophet because he will leave and he recommended you to Ali because God is among the servants, do not tell me love and this scum because it will become a farce to gather people to tell them to love Ali 🤣🤣🤣😅 The Sunnah is a farce.

    • @محمدعسيري-س5ز5ق
      @محمدعسيري-س5ز5ق 5 дней назад

      @@lionskid2393عليك من الله ماتستحق ياشيعي ياضال يامشرك لا تغوي الباحثين عن الحق انعق خارجا

    • @lionskid2393
      @lionskid2393 5 дней назад +1

      @@محمدعسيري-س5ز5ق Why do you curse, O son of Aisha, the wicked prostitute, O son of Omar, whom Khalid fornicated with behind the mountain, O son of Abu Bakr, the son of fornication, O denier of God the Most High, O denier of the manifestation of God the Most High, you and the cursed Shiites of Iraq and Iran, on the Day of Resurrection, where will you turn from the Mahdi who will annihilate you, and every government other than the government of God.

    • @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د
      @الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د 4 дня назад

      Everything you have written has no weight because : a Muslim take his religion from Quran and the Sunnah of his messenger and your beliefs have no existence in the Quran. Prove to me from Quran the doctrine of imammah?? Then Islam is not a religion related to inheritance and kinship. What you said ( curse Ali) is polytheism itself. Where is Allah , o Shiites??? Call Allah , not Ali nor Fatima nor anyone else.

    • @lionskid2393
      @lionskid2393 4 дня назад +1

      @@الباقياتالصالحات-ت7د 🤣ignorance, sunnis are the gods of ignorance😩😩.

  • @cahlangse
    @cahlangse 2 дня назад

    syiah bukan Islam .

  • @ArdianBrajshori-b8r
    @ArdianBrajshori-b8r 5 дней назад

    shiaaa hahaahahahahb

  • @deendrawing6685
    @deendrawing6685 4 дня назад

    Majority of Islam is Sunni not Shia...they Shia is fake news

  • @sharulshah1979
    @sharulshah1979 5 дней назад

    That syia video you take syia only did not have 10% Muslim in the world you much chek Truely from where you take that video