Proof: lim (sin x)/x | Limits | Differential Calculus | Khan Academy

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025
  • Using the squeeze theorem to prove that the limit as x approaches 0 of (sin x)/x =1
    Watch the next lesson: www.khanacadem...
    Missed the previous lesson?
    www.khanacadem...
    Differential calculus on Khan Academy: Limit introduction, squeeze theorem, and epsilon-delta definition of limits.
    About Khan Academy: Khan Academy offers practice exercises, instructional videos, and a personalized learning dashboard that empower learners to study at their own pace in and outside of the classroom. We tackle math, science, computer programming, history, art history, economics, and more. Our math missions guide learners from kindergarten to calculus using state-of-the-art, adaptive technology that identifies strengths and learning gaps. We've also partnered with institutions like NASA, The Museum of Modern Art, The California Academy of Sciences, and MIT to offer specialized content.
    For free. For everyone. Forever. #YouCanLearnAnything
    Subscribe to KhanAcademy’s Differential Calculus channel:
    / channel
    Subscribe to KhanAcademy: www.youtube.co...

Комментарии • 599

  • @janedoefree13
    @janedoefree13 11 лет назад +134

    Thank you so much Sal! all my book does is state both the sandwich theorem and use that as proof to formally state that therefore lim sinx/x is 1. All my professor did was repeat that in class -___-. for the past week i've just been sitting here like, "i only know this equals 1 because you told me, but WHY does it equal 1!?" It's been frustrating me and this video made so much sense.

    • @TheGamingg33k
      @TheGamingg33k 10 лет назад +3

      I know that feel my prof just did that too :O

    • @stephenstruble5064
      @stephenstruble5064 5 лет назад +1

      I've been in similar situations myself.

  • @ozzyfromspace
    @ozzyfromspace 4 года назад +62

    This might be one of the prettiest proofs in mathematics. It's simple enough for most people to understand, but tricky enough for you to think about for a moment. That was an immaculate presentation, Sal! Godspeed.

  • @bcnicholas123
    @bcnicholas123 8 лет назад +244

    the squeeeeeeze theorem

    • @karimdrissi3892
      @karimdrissi3892 8 лет назад +8

      SQUEEEEEEEEZE

    • @splabbity
      @splabbity 7 лет назад

      SKWAIZE

    • @darthsion3844
      @darthsion3844 5 лет назад +2

      As they would say on screen rant pitch meetings:
      "The squeeze theorem is TIGHT"

    • @lucasfreire1090
      @lucasfreire1090 3 года назад

      @@darthsion3844 Bruh even here lmao

  • @khanacademy
    @khanacademy  16 лет назад +63

    Good point. Good thing we made sure that our terms are positive!

    • @mohamedrida132
      @mohamedrida132 6 лет назад +3

      Khan academy. Greetings to you from Morocco. You have given me a helping hand, because in our school they are only applying the rule and you gave me proof and thank you very much

    • @otaku-zr1kn
      @otaku-zr1kn 5 лет назад

      @@mohamedrida132 2bac?

    • @hellensea
      @hellensea 4 года назад +1

      Hello to 2008

    • @Joeyatw
      @Joeyatw 4 года назад

      @@hellensea yankee with no brim

  • @arshie26
    @arshie26 11 лет назад +25

    Sal, this is why I love you. I'm watching this 5 years after it was uploaded, and every time I was confused between steps, you clarified yourself. You made it seem so SIMPLE. Why couldn't my textbook be like this?

    • @sheffas
      @sheffas 10 месяцев назад

      Here to tell you that 15 years later textbooks are sitll as dissapointing

  • @irenecrepaldi6955
    @irenecrepaldi6955 9 лет назад +152

    At the end I was like Woooooooaoaaaaaaaaaaaa magic. Math is awesome sometimes.

  • @FunOrange42
    @FunOrange42 9 лет назад +797

    How the hell did anyone even come up with this proof

    • @rohitbhosle6521
      @rohitbhosle6521 8 лет назад +11

      lol

    • @utsavmanandharz156
      @utsavmanandharz156 6 лет назад +48

      Maaaaaath . Also they elected to be a virgin their whole life.

    • @friendly1016
      @friendly1016 6 лет назад +62

      Cocaines a hell of a drug.

    • @xLainik
      @xLainik 6 лет назад +7

      man you are an osu player, why i found you in so many times on yt comment sections? xD

    • @forklift1712
      @forklift1712 4 года назад +17

      Lots of curiosity, time, and fundamental math knowledge.

  • @balendravirsinghchauhan6006
    @balendravirsinghchauhan6006 4 года назад +15

    Omg.!! I am attracted.. your videos are like magnet.!! I am watching them since 3 hours continuously like some movie series, and at any point of time I didn't lost my curiosity and interest.!! The are useful even after 12 years.!! True Genius.!! Thank you from the deep of my heart.!!

  • @DessertUnicorn
    @DessertUnicorn 9 лет назад +115

    Ok, i understood it, and this all for a tiny expression, I am going to go take advil now......

    • @dancetron1
      @dancetron1 9 лет назад +8

      +GooseGamingHD Thats pretty funny of you to say

    • @moaydsparklug8311
      @moaydsparklug8311 5 лет назад

      John Secor at least you now understand where the derivative of sinx how it comes, and from there you can derive other derivatives of trig functions, so its very useful

    • @TheFarmanimalfriend
      @TheFarmanimalfriend 5 лет назад

      This 'proof' almost makes me wish I hadn't quit drinking.

  • @adrianchivas2014
    @adrianchivas2014 10 лет назад +29

    This guy right here is simply awesome...

  • @B9ashtima
    @B9ashtima 10 лет назад +33

    It was such a big announcement "And now we're ready to use the sqeeze theorem!"

  • @camillecardoze5501
    @camillecardoze5501 2 года назад +8

    it's been almost 15 years and this is still super useful. Amazing work

  • @lexinaut
    @lexinaut 15 лет назад +14

    Thanks! You've squeezed a great deal out of this topic. I did feel pretty x-hausted by the end. Very clear, and informative. Presentation had a nice arc to it. I'll sin out for now. Again, VERY HELPFUL PRESENTATION!

  • @LilStevie369
    @LilStevie369 11 лет назад +3

    This is the only time I have seem this explained in a forthright and logical way without making a bunch of crap assumptions. Thank you.

  • @scenesonn
    @scenesonn 13 лет назад +4

    15:30 That was an "Ooohhhhhhh, I get itttttt" moment at its finest.

  • @tomriddle9489
    @tomriddle9489 Год назад +1

    thank you soo much, i would not hav e gotten that in a million years

  • @amazingannyoing1716
    @amazingannyoing1716 4 года назад +2

    Ok, i've just finished the 48th vid in this series, and i finally understand this

  • @msven
    @msven 12 лет назад

    Awesome! My calc teacher decided not to explain this because he said we wouldn't understand and said just to know that lim x->0 of (sinx)/x=1. This makes perfect sense! Thanks!

  • @maximum_entropy
    @maximum_entropy 6 лет назад +2

    i iove this guy. he just made me understand everything. keep up the good work please

  • @261Maryam
    @261Maryam 12 лет назад +1

    I feel the excitement in your voice when you started talking about the squeeze theorem LOL .. Thank you soo much this was very helpful!

  • @OldDrunkStudio
    @OldDrunkStudio 3 года назад +1

    Really brilliant... ❤

  • @fuzzypenguino
    @fuzzypenguino 8 лет назад +22

    all these squares make a circle
    all these squares make a circle

  • @ibraheemelansari7793
    @ibraheemelansari7793 10 лет назад +1

    Thank you very much teacher , this is even much better than Arabic , I haven't found anything about this proof in Arabic

  • @NicolasGomez97
    @NicolasGomez97 11 лет назад +1

    this video was like the harlem shake, my brain was building up tension, and then it went bazaar when Khan asked "What is the limit as x approaches 0 of cosine of x" - 15:04

  • @H0oLIgAnSsRo0lMaRrSz
    @H0oLIgAnSsRo0lMaRrSz 13 лет назад

    I refused to watch these videos when the teacher told us to, but now I regret it!! They're VERY helpful! Thank you so much!

  • @rwayne5616
    @rwayne5616 7 лет назад +1

    Beautiful work Sal! This is needed to show that the derivative of sin(x)=cos(x).

  • @johnblack6819
    @johnblack6819 Год назад

    2:40 not sure I like the fact the variable x is being used both as a coordinate and as the angle of the triangle

  • @priyadarshinijv9463
    @priyadarshinijv9463 Год назад

    SIR SIR SIR , I FREAKING LOVE YOU , THE AMOUNT OF HELP YOU PROVIDE IS INCREDIBLE

  • @jovas14rocks
    @jovas14rocks 8 лет назад

    this example is badass. The squeeze theorum states that f(x)

  • @RANDINTMCR3U3
    @RANDINTMCR3U3 12 лет назад

    This gave the answer to my question...I wasn't able to prove that lim x -> 0 sin x/x = 1...it is one of these things about limits that I did not know why...LONG LIVE KHAN ACADEMY!!!!

  • @BBBrasil
    @BBBrasil 9 лет назад +9

    6:07 If like me, you had a little problem converting the angle x to x radian, they seem to be different. Just remember, when we say angle x we really mean a fraction of a complete circle, which means x of 360 (x/360) by adding the 360 fraction. Now it is easy to convert a fraction of 2piR to a fraction of 360.

    • @sachariasvonkoch7355
      @sachariasvonkoch7355 9 лет назад

      +Marc Abelha If you use agnles you get Lim x--0 sin(x)/x=3.14/180

    • @BBBrasil
      @BBBrasil 9 лет назад

      Yep, radians makes this theorem really elegant.

    • @pemifo260
      @pemifo260 2 года назад

      @@BBBrasil Hey, can you help me? Still, I can’t understand. In sinx and tanx we are using x as degrees but when we are calculating the are of the sector we are using x as radians.
      I can’t understand. When we change x degrees to radians I get a completely different thing.

  • @Smmmile
    @Smmmile 12 лет назад +1

    The area of the 'pie' was derived using the definition of the angle in radians, so the proof of sinx/x = 1 as x->0 is only true when the angle is measured in radians. This limit is used importantly in definining the derivative of Sinx to be Cosx in calculus. This means that derivative also only holds if X is in radians. Power series is based on differentials of sin and cos, so again you must use radians. Everything comes back to how this limit was proved and affects all proof stemming from it.

    • @pemifo260
      @pemifo260 2 года назад

      So, if we are talking about 𝑥 in radians, how we are writing sin𝑥 or tan𝑥? Is it possible?

    • @Smmmile
      @Smmmile 2 года назад

      @@pemifo260 Whether x is in degrees or radians, doesn't effect the way you write Sinx or Tanx, as long as you're clear on the units you're using. However it does make a difference as to what you say the derivative or integral of Sinx and Tanx are. The Derivative of Sinx is only Cosx when you are using x in radians. If using x in Degrees then the derivative of Sinx is instead Cos(x*pi/180).

  • @IkennaUgwu97
    @IkennaUgwu97 10 лет назад +1

    that was so revealing and helpful on so many levels

  • @kelvintowns8417
    @kelvintowns8417 2 года назад +1

    I always love your videos but this one is my favorite. Superb job!

  • @reneedargie8344
    @reneedargie8344 4 года назад

    Thanks so much! I love the added visual and graphical portions to make the proof easier to understand and see.

  • @terrab1ter4
    @terrab1ter4 9 лет назад +1

    That moment you get this .... MY GOD THIS MAKES SO MUCH SENSE

  • @iloveuanonlyu
    @iloveuanonlyu 14 лет назад

    u are jus simply the best teacher ever.. how would i understand maths without you :)

  • @imegatrone
    @imegatrone 13 лет назад

    I Really Like The Video From Your Using the squeeze theorem to prove that the limit as x approaches 0 of (sin x)/x =1

  • @UmTheMuse
    @UmTheMuse 13 лет назад

    @eileenBrain This isn't supposed to teach anything; it's supposed to be a proof. Which was done admirably.
    kudos, khanacademy, this was just what I was looking for.

  • @parcel98
    @parcel98 16 лет назад +2

    That was very helpful! omg i wish you were my teacher

  • @sandeepchauhan6836
    @sandeepchauhan6836 3 года назад

    Khan academy is too much helpful

  • @ddw-x7g
    @ddw-x7g 10 лет назад +1

    Thank you, that really helped clear my foggy understanding of that proof.

  • @melac12
    @melac12 14 лет назад

    The melody of logic always plays the notes of truth

  • @BlackWolf4830
    @BlackWolf4830 14 лет назад

    I tried something similar. It was called the "Definition of an Equilateral Polygon" test.
    As x approaches infinity, Sin(pi/x) * x / cos(pi/x) --> Pi
    X = number of sides
    Cos = apothem of equilateral polygon
    Sin = equal length side divide by 2 of the equilateral polygon
    Sin(pi/x) * x = half of the perimeter
    As x approaches infinity, the perimeter starts to resemble that of a circle

  • @sanahaskuranage8071
    @sanahaskuranage8071 6 месяцев назад

    What a beautiful proof, why isn’t this taught in school?

  • @Youngballer739
    @Youngballer739 2 года назад

    Nothing like some classic Khan

  • @iamahier4148
    @iamahier4148 4 года назад

    15:48 I got such a big surprise after lot of calculation!!!

  • @BioRockLennon
    @BioRockLennon 14 лет назад

    Thank you very much !!! I have my oral exam on next wednesday...so one more theorem I understood^^

  • @caiobarros585
    @caiobarros585 2 года назад +1

    Just a question: isn't strange dividing a segment by an angle? Like, sin(x) and x aren't in the same unit measure, so there is no division of sinx/x.

  • @brain274
    @brain274 16 лет назад

    you just saved my weekend - the way it's explained in my textbook, i couldn't get my head round it, and you've explained it really well! thanks! :)

  • @asalad083
    @asalad083 15 лет назад

    waw i can believe this equation i took roday in my cal class. thank you very much my math teacher Khan.

  • @KirbehsBizzatch
    @KirbehsBizzatch 14 лет назад

    Man, you needed to really think out of the box for this one. Really cool though.

  • @pontap90
    @pontap90 15 лет назад

    Three words:
    You are amazing!!!!

  • @crumcon
    @crumcon 15 лет назад +2

    Khan, you´re our hero!
    You get my infinite ´thank you´

  • @markgraham2312
    @markgraham2312 4 года назад

    Since x >= 0 for all x in the 1st and 4th quadrants, you don't need the absolute values.
    You seem to have confused the 2nd and 4th quadrants.Also, your < & > need to be =.
    The squeeze theorem states that if f(x)≤g(x)≤h(x) for all numbers, and at some point x=k we have f(k)=h(k), then g(k) must also be equal to them.

  • @brucelapointe2524
    @brucelapointe2524 9 лет назад

    Thanks! This is suppose to help my proficiency in mathematics and toward things I would use calculus and trig in! Its something my family never have used in any case of measuring.

  • @saranshkhare2658
    @saranshkhare2658 5 лет назад

    Best proof till date covers almost everything that need to know 👍

  • @ttomace
    @ttomace 12 лет назад

    our book has an easier proof...
    But yo have presented the information very very brilliantly.
    and i understand much more.

  • @SL1PP3R5
    @SL1PP3R5 15 лет назад

    wow, and my mathematical analysis class finally becomes understandable

  • @varunk25
    @varunk25 13 лет назад

    Wow. Spoon feeding cant get better than this. Wonderful video

  • @funkiichiicka
    @funkiichiicka 13 лет назад

    I just fell in love with you. We weren't taught this, hence why I had to find this video!!! Thank you!

  • @Ayush1206
    @Ayush1206 9 лет назад +2

    dude you are simply amazing !!!
    thank you so much....

  • @Silver-eo5vh
    @Silver-eo5vh 3 года назад

    It's been 13 years. I'm seeing this video 13 years after it was uploaded and....just wow.

  • @deytutorials99
    @deytutorials99 2 года назад

    It's one of the most amazing theorems and proofs I've ever seen

  • @ksfishchannel
    @ksfishchannel 6 лет назад

    Why cant my math teachers ever be this good

  • @TheGamingg33k
    @TheGamingg33k 10 лет назад +1

    My prof just threw everything at us and suddenly he said he proved sinx/x. I was like O.O UMMM WHAAAT But thanks to you I completely understand it perfectly!

  • @discuss2130
    @discuss2130 10 лет назад

    Finally the proof as promised in your earlier video. Thanks very nice.

  • @spikygoldfish
    @spikygoldfish 14 лет назад

    Thanks so much! My professor sucked at explaining this

  • @andreasggeorgiou000
    @andreasggeorgiou000 13 лет назад

    Sal you 're a GENIUS!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @sadmanishrak9529
    @sadmanishrak9529 8 лет назад

    It would have been a lot easier to understand if you had made this video on a bigger screen with higher resolution because staring at such bad resolution hurts the eye. But the explanation and video is perfect! Its very helpful! Thanks a lot!

  • @saadhaider9576
    @saadhaider9576 12 лет назад

    Thank you soooooo much. I have been looking sooo long for a good proof of this, and you have finally proved it to me. Thank you thank you thank you!!!!

  • @Wortoltje
    @Wortoltje 11 лет назад +6

    great video!
    But shouldn't the area's be smaller or equal to? And later on greater or equal to?

    • @Oshanii
      @Oshanii 10 лет назад +4

      indeed, it should. logically, 1 < 1 is not true. it works for

  • @visuaviewer
    @visuaviewer 12 лет назад

    Awesome - the book was very confusing on this.. you made it awesome-er

  • @harsimrankaur6901
    @harsimrankaur6901 4 года назад

    😍😍 Beauty of maths

  • @silverhawke
    @silverhawke 12 лет назад

    That is so you can get |x|/|sin x| from which we can get |sin x|/|x|, which is the expression we want to find the limit of as x tends to 0.

  • @deepakbellur9676
    @deepakbellur9676 11 лет назад

    Great explanations. I had studied it in college without appreciating it like this!

  • @xV3SP3Rx
    @xV3SP3Rx 14 лет назад +1

    Great explanation!! Hopefully this helps me on my calculus test!!

    • @tarik1316
      @tarik1316 3 года назад

      how are 10 years later. Did you pass the test

  • @salmachi9836
    @salmachi9836 7 лет назад

    You explained it so clearly, I like your explanation Mr.Khan

  • @Raiyun166
    @Raiyun166 14 лет назад

    Excellent video. I need to learn this apparently for my syllabus, and I'm glad to say I can reproduce this myself after your video. Thanks!

  • @rickybobby5584
    @rickybobby5584 5 лет назад +1

    this limit is very powerful in spite of its simplicity as its the key to prove that d/dx sin(x)=cos(x) and the other derivatives of trig functions follow. some people prove this limit using L'Hopital rule (LR) but that's wrong because LR requires the derivative of sin(x) which is proved based on the limit itself.

  • @lexinaut
    @lexinaut 14 лет назад

    Great video as I've said before! Just a reminder that a "pie piece" is formally called a "sector." Don't dump inSECTORside on me for being picky. It's just good to get the formal terms (although they can seem inTERMinable) since there are so many of them! I wish SUCCESS to all in your studies!

  • @HotPepperLala
    @HotPepperLala 15 лет назад

    Lol my teacher just did the quick way of showing us. You gave me ALOT of extra info.
    My teacher just told us to graph the sinx/x in radians and then use value x -> 0. We got 1 and that's why she said it was 1 lol

  • @Anantko
    @Anantko 13 лет назад

    @hubomba It's only to simplify. You may know that tan x = sin x/cos x. Thus when you divide it by sin x it becomes 1/cos x.

  • @craftbuzzwonky4752
    @craftbuzzwonky4752 3 года назад

    I'm in love with this proof!

    • @khaildalsadoon8814
      @khaildalsadoon8814 3 года назад

      Finally, a comment from this year. 😩❤️ Could you please help me understand how is it mathematically correct to cancel out π radian (180°) with π (≈ 3.14) 6:51

    • @highlander1075
      @highlander1075 3 года назад

      @@khaildalsadoon8814 because π rad and π is exactly the same

  • @mayukhintesarislam306
    @mayukhintesarislam306 Год назад

    pretty sure ur never gonna see this but thanx a lot for these videos!

  • @roxyrox511
    @roxyrox511 13 лет назад

    Nice, this is going to help on tomorrow's test!

  • @naimunnahar8330
    @naimunnahar8330 6 лет назад

    I loved loved loved how you explained the theorem sir. Thankyou.

  • @DerboyInChains
    @DerboyInChains 7 лет назад

    KHAN ACADEMY at 11:20 what is the basis why everything is divided by absolute value sin x?

  • @ChrisDuncanCodeCow
    @ChrisDuncanCodeCow 11 лет назад

    Brilliant, thank you for this video! I saw this identity in my textbook and did not understand how it could be true. This wrapped it up very nicely.

  • @abdullahfaizurrahman6486
    @abdullahfaizurrahman6486 2 года назад

    If the limit (x/sin(x)) happened to evaluate to 0, then inverting the signs would be incorrect right? I'm referring to the step at 12:39

  • @lightzebra
    @lightzebra 14 лет назад +1

    HOTDAMN I ACTUALLY UNDERSTAND THIS NOW

  • @jordankimia2324
    @jordankimia2324 8 лет назад +1

    Thanks Sal, very clear!

  • @stepbystepscience
    @stepbystepscience 12 лет назад

    You haven't confused me!

  • @sidstam
    @sidstam 11 лет назад

    He has used the Squeeze theorem in the last bit to equate sin x/x to 1. See his video in the Calculus playlist on the Squeeze theorem, just before this one.

  • @MEPS1996
    @MEPS1996 11 лет назад +1

    the inequality at 9:27 should have or equals signs in because at x=0, all the areas are zero.

  • @aciken7563
    @aciken7563 7 лет назад

    It's official. I love Calculus

  • @dishonesttAbe
    @dishonesttAbe 14 лет назад

    Very fascinating way to prove the limit, very lucid presentation!

  • @BagaJr
    @BagaJr 12 лет назад

    SQUEEZE Theorem is the best theorem ever because it's called squeeze theorem.

  • @VedantSrikar
    @VedantSrikar 10 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks 😊

  • @ArborealOreo
    @ArborealOreo 11 лет назад +1

    when he finally got to the big point, I was like "cool story bro!"