Protestant Interviews Catholic Priest (Cantius Part 2)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
  • After our tour Fr. Joshua graciously sat down with me to answer a few questions. What's a day in the life of a priest look like? How did Fr. Joshua go from a Charismatic teenager to the youngest head of a religious order in the world? As a Protestant I had a lot of questions. These questions and many more are covered in this interview. If you enjoyed the tour, you'll love this interview, and if you'd like to see more with Fr. Joshua, let me know in the comments!
    A big thank you is in order for Fr. Joshua. If you want to learn more about St. John Cantius, go to: www.cantius.org/
    Support this channel:
    / gospelsimplicity
    www.teespring.com/stores/gospe...
    Follow me on social media:
    IG: / gospelsimplicity
    FB: / gospelsimplicity
    Twitter: / gsplsimplicity
    Thanks to Luke Kegeris for filming:
    www.lukekegeris.com
    ruclips.net/channel/UChCu...
    About me:
    Hey! My name is Austin, and I'm a 21 year old guy with a passion for people. I believe the good news is that God is better than we could've ever hoped, and I love sharing this message of grace and love with anyone that will listen. I'm the former Digital Marketing and Video Production Coordinator at a large, evangelical church in Frederick, MD, and I'm currently a student at Moody Bible Institute in Chicago, IL. When I'm not writing papers or making RUclips videos, I do freelance work as a Wedding Photographer/Videographer and social media consultant. On any given day you can find me with my nose in a book or a guitar in my hands. Want to get to know me more? Follow me and say hi on Instagram at: @austin.suggs
    Bible I Use:
    ESV: Interleaved Edition
    Video Stuff:
    Camera: Canon 80d
    Lens: Sigma 17-50 F2.8
    Edited in FCPX
    Music:
    Bowmans Root - Isaac Joel

Комментарии • 1,7 тыс.

  • @MOrtiz-tm4qe
    @MOrtiz-tm4qe 3 месяца назад +7

    Thanks for bringing the faithful together. I was born Catholic, and at the age of 4, my mother "converted" the whole family to a Pentecostal faith. After years without visiting a church and not having a place to workship, I went back to the Catholic church, and I felt I found my home.

  • @juanarysantana
    @juanarysantana 3 года назад +257

    I like this priest, he is not afraid of telling the truth of our core beliefs in public.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +15

      He’s great

    • @artur048
      @artur048 3 года назад +4

      @@GospelSimplicity I agree.

    • @brigidhiggins2003
      @brigidhiggins2003 3 года назад +17

      I've been a parishioner here for the last 16 years (since I was 2/3 years old) - my whole family started going here the year after he and his older brother joined the order! He's truly one of those people who is just living in the joy of faith in every way!

    • @trizahmacharia2939
      @trizahmacharia2939 2 года назад +3

      @@brigidhiggins2003 i envy you,yr church is beautiful

    • @brigidhiggins2003
      @brigidhiggins2003 2 года назад +4

      If you ever find yourself in or near Chicago, please do come visit! 😊🙏

  • @brucejohnson4462
    @brucejohnson4462 Год назад +11

    The Holy Eucharist is life itself. The traditional Latin Mass has been a humbling experience for me in the past year. I left the Catholic faith as a kid and 35 years later came home. Now experiencing TLM once a month I'm blown away by the reverence I've been missing all my life. God is good. Always!

  • @johnkeenan5404
    @johnkeenan5404 3 года назад +102

    The additional beauty of the Latin Mass is its universality. Many years ago I was an altar boy in New York City. We had two Vietnamese priests in residence who had fled North Vietnam. They only spoke Vietnamese and French. I spoke or understood neither, but when I rang the bell and we went out to the altar and the priest said "Introibo ad altari Dei", it did not matter. Everyone in attendance knew the Mass and felt the universality. I have been to Mass in Italy, Japan, Germany and Korea and yes it was Mass but I wish it could have started with "Introibo ad altari Dei." I would have felt more at home.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +5

      Thanks for sharing that!

    • @Lerian_V
      @Lerian_V 3 года назад +6

      I remember growing up in Nigeria, every first Sunday mass is a Latin mass.

    • @paulineangelyna7453
      @paulineangelyna7453 3 года назад +7

      Yes! It is true. Latin unites Catholics all over the world ✝️. We in Asia, particularly may not be able to speak French / German etc..but when it comes to "Introibo ad altare Dei"..we all know how to respond well in Latin. Deo Gratias 🌹

    • @johngeraldoy2615
      @johngeraldoy2615 2 года назад

      I’m a cradle catholic from SE Asia and now living in northern Michigan. I have the opportunity to travel and I was surprised the universality of the Catholic Church. You just know what to do even with language barriers. I was moved with the actions of other nationalities and how similar we were. I guess when it comes to religion, we belong to one.

    • @davidestate
      @davidestate Год назад

      I know this is 2 year comment, but if you have never been to the Holy Land, ask your Priest at your Catholic Church and ask if you can take the Walk of Jesus. I did this and it brought me closer to God.. it's such an eye opening experience.

  • @albablanco9145
    @albablanco9145 3 года назад +148

    Fr. Joshua was so so great in this interview! This is the kind of men the Church needs...

  • @bezaleelcastillo9775
    @bezaleelcastillo9775 3 года назад +257

    Thank you AUSTIN and FATHER JOSHUA for being the bridge of understanding and love between protestantism and catholicism.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +18

      It's our pleasure!

    • @jollyabraham1830
      @jollyabraham1830 3 года назад +11

      Fantastic. I hope at least from now on, the protestants would love Catholics & vice versa.

    • @hiltonchapman4844
      @hiltonchapman4844 3 года назад +2

      @@GospelSimplicity To you, and especially to @Bezaleel Castillo, I just can't express my appreciation enough! Bottom line, we're all in this together. Let us just turn towards Christ our common Saviour, our universal Redeemer.
      The core is the Trinity. That's it.
      Thank you both, once again!
      With lots of love,
      HC-JAIPUR (27/10/2020)

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html

    • @wz5165
      @wz5165 3 года назад +3

      The Church is one, holy, universal and Apostolic

  • @joshuag.4873
    @joshuag.4873 3 года назад +210

    8:05... Yes!!! I completely understand this Catholic and Protestant comparison. I grew up Seventh-day Adventist, and "came home" to the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Discovered Catholicism in 2008 and was confirmed in 2010. I've thought of priesthood for many years, finally discerning with the help of a kind Benedictine priest. Whether or not that ultimately happens, I gladly serve God and His Church as a Music Director, Organist and Liturgist already...

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +5

      Thanks for sharing some of your story! God bless

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html

    • @joshuag.4873
      @joshuag.4873 3 года назад +4

      @@renaldosimmons9182 - A bunch of ignorant garbage. Looking at scripture through the foggy lens of fake and inaccurate history. I understand the Adventist faith far better than most Adventists do. I’ve read more Ellen White than most Adventists have. It’s very convincing stuff, until you see that the lens is completely wrong.

    • @joshuag.4873
      @joshuag.4873 3 года назад +4

      @@renaldosimmons9182 - Tell yourself whatever smug thing you must to feel self-righteous. Fake history... Trying to glorify the Waldenses and the Protestant reformers and vilify Constantine and the early martyrs and saints (Great Controversy). It’s exactly as the Scripture states, “calling evil good, and good evil.” The Scriptures are AN authority - not THE authority. The Church doesn’t come from the Bible - the Bible comes from the Church. Plus, your bible is incomplete and inaccurate anyway. Your post-enlightenment imitation of Christianity is greatly lacking the richness and depth of the true Faith of Jesus. Only Jehovah Himself can change minds as hardwired as this - only He can share the Light and Grace needed to see Truth - I know from experience... Everything you think you KNOW now is in vein - a glimmer at best.

    • @joshuag.4873
      @joshuag.4873 3 года назад +10

      @@renaldosimmons9182 - Jesus is the Word. He left us a Church, not a Bible. The Church centuries thereafter produced for us the canon of Holy Scripture as we know it today. Jesus established His One and Only Church when He was still here, and promised that He (the Way, Truth and Life) would be with us ALWAYS. He didn’t say He would disappear, let everything fall to apostasy, and then truth would be rediscovered in 1844 or reestablished in 1863... Imaginary nonsense. Anyway, this is a dead-end discussion. Saints Helena and Monica, pray for you...

  • @dianat3836
    @dianat3836 3 года назад +92

    This Priest is awesome!

  • @MrKingsley16
    @MrKingsley16 Год назад +4

    Born a cradle-Catholic 57 years later stumbling into the TLM, it is refreshing and greatly reverent participating as a witness to the Passion of Christ, and not familiar with Latin, but now knowing it is our ancient Catholic language, I am hungry to learn it, the very least our common prayers and or the rosary. Deus benedicat Amen.

  • @ColleenB10
    @ColleenB10 3 года назад +329

    I must tell you how refreshing it is to see such a humble young man, such as yourself, being open to learning about faith systems other than your own. This past week i have been attacked for defending my Catholic Faith by my own friends - in the name of Jesus and the Bible. I have had kind comments deleted and been called part of a satanist and demonic cult. You, Austin, are a gift from the Lord. A breath of fresh air in this evil and self righteous world. God bless you.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +35

      I'm so sorry to hear about those other experiences. Glad that this can be a breath of fresh air. God bless!

    • @immaculateheart1267
      @immaculateheart1267 3 года назад +28

      Yes he is. We've all been there. And the latest PF nonsense has made matters worse. My evangelical friends always send me links to bad catholic news, as if I wasnt already aware. Thankfully my friends dont bash me. But strangers on Social, thats another story.
      Mr Austin is surely a beacon of light.

    • @annemoulding7215
      @annemoulding7215 3 года назад +24

      @@immaculateheart1267 it is so true that any negative news reflecting on the Catholic Church is always brandished upon the media. It is part of our martyrdom to withstand in the face of it. My dear friends we are on the true path....if it hurts (and it surely does) we are close to Him who fought for each and every one of us on the cross. Xxx

    • @mboudreaux2950
      @mboudreaux2950 3 года назад +15

      Hang tight & keep the faith, Colleen, they did much worse to our sweet Jesus, while He was on this earth! God Bless you!! ❤️

    • @jgil1966
      @jgil1966 3 года назад +4

      Best comment ever

  • @KristynLorraine
    @KristynLorraine 3 года назад +25

    I grew up in the Assemblies of God and became a Catholic in 2009. So much of what Fr. Joshua says resonates. I too pray that there will be a tent revival in my soul. Beautiful imagery!

  • @ishamanankitlakra8120
    @ishamanankitlakra8120 3 года назад +36

    I'm a Catholic Priest in India, I saw in RUclips simplicity gospel channel, I'm moved by you both brothers, conversation! u both are awesome instrument ofGod! GOD is working differently with us both protestants and Catholics. Let's move towards words of God which is our spiritual mannuel to preach the world!!

  • @jennbull0247
    @jennbull0247 3 года назад +21

    This was amazing. I am a convert baptized and received into the Church last July. The greatest gift during the pandemic was finding St. John Cantius online and watching their live streamed masses. I was blown away when I first started watching, I had never seen the litergy done in such a beautiful way. So happy to have found this tour and interview. Mass at St John Cantius is on my bucket list!

  • @Garrylsc
    @Garrylsc 3 года назад +92

    Austin, are you only 21? So profound for your age. Listening to you and father Joshua, I believe that the reunification of the Church of Jesus Christ is in the making. May God bless you both.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      I am. Thank you so much. God bless!

    • @masonthompson3284
      @masonthompson3284 3 года назад +11

      @@GospelSimplicity insanity, I just turned 21 and have been exploring the Catholic faith for well over a year. I’ve decided to convert one day (and think you should too full bias lol) but it’s seriously awesome to see how Christ is moving through young people like us! God a Bless you, fam.

    • @joecastillo8798
      @joecastillo8798 3 года назад

      @@masonthompson3284
      Many blessings in your journey.
      A Catholic apologist.

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html

    • @gilliangallagher8593
      @gilliangallagher8593 3 года назад +2

      @@masonthompson3284 I really long for reunion of our churches. I hear Mass now almost every day and thirst for God in my life

  • @phiustin
    @phiustin 3 года назад +28

    The humility, and the three theological virtues of faith, hope and charity in both of these men inspire me to become a better Catholic.

  • @raymondkoh1348
    @raymondkoh1348 Год назад +3

    Such a gentle sincere conversation between 2 men of faith. Christ was indeed present in this dialogue. Amen

  • @Shadeadder
    @Shadeadder 3 года назад +3

    As someone who attends Tridentine Latin Mass...the appeal to the youth is its stability. It is wholly unchanging, something that had withstood the weathers of time. It is knowing that the Mass you experience is the same one Christians and Saints participated in, down to every prayer, for over a thousand years (with a few minor changes over time). And knowing it connects you to Christians a thousand years after us. In a world that feels so transient these days, I think craving that immovable "sameness" makes perfect sense. To do that, the liturgy must be rooted in what will never change.

  • @mikkis668
    @mikkis668 3 года назад +89

    Fr. Joshua's description of the Latin Mass, is as beautiful and inspirational as his church building!

  • @dank1280
    @dank1280 3 года назад +13

    I have nothing but the utmost respect for Catholic priests like Fr. Joshua. I’m a Presbyterian pastor, but I was raised Catholic. I admire anyone brave enough to take a vow of celibacy, as that was the one BIG thing that made me become a Presbyterian pastor rather than a Catholic priest. I’m not sure I could’ve been strong enough as a man to do that, so I applaud anyone who can make that sacrifice.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for sharing!

    • @christenh359
      @christenh359 3 года назад +7

      I just want to mention that there is an important place for married men in the life of the Catholic Church.
      A man who wants to spread the good news, but also wants to be married is still welcome. He could become a deacon or a youth minister, and so much more.

  • @michaelking6747
    @michaelking6747 Год назад +2

    St John Cantis brings me back sixty years to the Latin Mass that no parishioner could understand at that time, I was very pleased when my wife and I stumbled into this Church this past Sunday, it brought back many fond memories.

  • @michaelbelmontes4046
    @michaelbelmontes4046 3 года назад +25

    As a devout Traditional Catholic who just discovered your channel!!! I am so excited to find such amazing dialogue and professionalism covering the different backgrounds!!! (but not that differen, right?) Amazing!

  • @aliszhinchaenz
    @aliszhinchaenz 3 года назад +20

    I really like the way you two talked. You both speaked gently, softly, and eloquently. It's like a powerful prayer.

  • @elvirabartolome954
    @elvirabartolome954 3 года назад +16

    Great job Austin, Father Joshua is so humble and a great speaker that's why he makes a wonderful priest. The church needs more like him. Jesus loves u, mama Mary loves u. Greetings from Manila philippines

  • @divinacabungcal9020
    @divinacabungcal9020 3 года назад +25

    excited here in the Philippines to see this video..❤️

  • @rebeccacarroll7913
    @rebeccacarroll7913 3 года назад +15

    Wow thank you , I really enjoyed the tour & the interview. I am a practising Catholic in Yeadon UK but was raised Cof E. It came across extremely well. Thank you from the bottom of my heart. We all must strive to become Saintly.
    May more want to join our strong faith & follow Mary too. The Rosary is so important as the brilliant artistry showed but also Divine Mercy is so needed as well & should be done every day with the whole world at 3pm.
    We need this more than ever in our lives with this Pandemic taking over & climate change too.
    God bless you all my brothers & sisters in Christ Jesus.
    Amen
    🙏🏼❤️📿❤️🙏🏼

  • @duncescotus2342
    @duncescotus2342 3 года назад +22

    Brother, kudos to you for having an ecumenical spirit. That is the sign of a true man of God.

  • @MP-oe7zr
    @MP-oe7zr 3 года назад +7

    I appreciate Latin Mass in that it shows the universality of the Church. If you take part in Masses said in St. Peter's with the Holy Father, people from all over the world take part in the Mass in Latin as a sort of unifying language for all the faithful. Not to mention the beauty of the hymns in the Missa De Angelis. It truly a foretaste of the heaven! Thanks for this series on your visit to St. John Cantius and the wonderful tour and explanation from Fr. Joshua. Thoroughly enjoyed watching!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for sharing! It's my pleasure

    • @lilikkrismantoro2027
      @lilikkrismantoro2027 Год назад

      Both masses are needed and beautiful. By Latin mass we can experience the universal things of our Church, in language everybody can be touched in their heart in their own mother language.

  • @HeavnzMiHome
    @HeavnzMiHome 3 года назад +102

    I agree a Novus Ordo mass can have its place along with a Tridentine mass. Both offered well are valid and can lead to excellent worship. However, I wish that the extraordinary form was more readily available.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Well said

    • @bijogeojose7209
      @bijogeojose7209 3 года назад +14

      As a traditionalist, I completely agree with you. The NO when celebrated in the way it's meant to be, is as much valid as the tridentine mass. However, I do not like the watered down version of the NO.
      John cantius is great example for this. They celebrate both forms in the way they were meant to be.

    • @nanagaga2001
      @nanagaga2001 3 года назад +8

      @Harry Waddington I have to wholeheartedly disagree with you. The intention of the NO was to make it more accessible to Catholics, not Protestants. It not simply a communal meal, it is a real sacrificial offering of ourselves to God and God's son to us. I will admit that some more liberal litergists have taken a very lax view of the mass and that is more than unfortunate. But that is certainly not true of all, I would even say most, priests. In my 60+ years in the church I have never seen anything other than reverence in both priests and parishoners. It is certainly not "less Catholic". I grew up with Latin mass and I much prefer being able to understand the language of the mass. Having to learn another language simply to worship God smacks of a clique-ish attitude to me. If you prefer Lain, fill your boots. But don't denigrate the NO. It is a fully sanctioned, worshipful, reverent, sacramental and "real" option.

    • @Steve_Milo
      @Steve_Milo 3 года назад +1

      @Harry Waddington well said. Not only are you factually correct, I'm glad you made your comments kindly.
      I would add is that even though both the NO and TLM have the infinite grace of the Eucharist, the NO even when done reverently and beautifully, by its design it puts most of the attention upon the people and when we are focused upon ourselves we become a more closed to that infinite grace.
      Also by design the NO makes the Mass about the priest's personal preferences, choosing which prayers to offer and so forth, which further distracts us from the central focus which should be on Christ's Passion and sacrifice. Unfortunately this has made the priests who say the NO think they have to put their personal signature, style, and interpretation on the Mass to meet fashionable tastes and desires and personal preferences of the people. It makes the people think that the Mass should be conformed to what they want, the songs they want, the style they want, what about my feelings, etc.
      The priests succumbs to the false notion that the Mass should be changed to meet where the people are comfortable and what they want, which is the opposite of what God wants. God wants us to approach Him in humility and confirm ourselves to Him, not to conform God to ourselves.
      The TLM put all the focus on God and so the people are more open to the infinite grace of the Mass, because they are naturally focused on God instead of themselves. The strip rubrics allow no room for interpretation or personal taste or fashion, and so the priest decreases so Christ may increase. And the people receiving and kneeling on the tongue which is required and not optional, makes them humble themselves before God who has already humbled Himself by becoming bread.
      I believe the NO, while valid with the true presence of the Eucharist, is what scripture refers to with man replacing God in the temple because it puts the focus on man and not on God. And since the NO takes attention away from God and puts it on the people, it is always illicit. Valid, but illicit by nature and design.

    • @nanagaga2001
      @nanagaga2001 3 года назад +1

      @Harry Waddington In the preparation of the gifts, we are literally offering what we have back to the Father. The priest says "Through your goodness we have this bread to offer, which earth has given and human hands have made. It will become for us the bread of life.
      Through your goodness we have this wine to offer, fruit of the vine and work of human hands. It will become our spiritual drink."
      This is l
      From the Liturgy of the Eucharist: Priest: Pray, my brothers and sisters, that our sacrifice
      may be acceptable to God, the almighty Father.
      All: May the Lord accept the sacrifice at your hands,
      for the praise and glory of his name, for our good, and the good of all his Church.

  • @catholicgentlemansguide7161
    @catholicgentlemansguide7161 3 года назад +46

    You’ve met a great guy! Father Joshua and I are old summer boys camp buddies! Say a Canadian hello from me next time you meet up!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +4

      Will do! Who should I tell him is saying hello?

    • @catholicgentlemansguide7161
      @catholicgentlemansguide7161 3 года назад +10

      @@GospelSimplicity That’s a good point! Matthew from camp should do. www.catholicgentlemansguide.com/about-us/. Yes, the last time I visited with Josh was back in 2005 when he was still just Brother Josh. How providential that the Lord would lead me to your channel back around Easter, and have you update me on an old friend!

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html

    • @bridgefin
      @bridgefin 3 года назад

      @True Messenger of God
      Nor does the bible teach that all doctrine and practices must be found in the bible. You issue is based on a false assumption.

    • @bridgefin
      @bridgefin 3 года назад

      @True Messenger of God ???? I said there was no Scripture to support your position. YOU need to convince me otherwise.

  • @alexandra6322
    @alexandra6322 3 года назад +82

    I can’t wait! You are definitely one of my favourite Christian RUclipsrs and it's so great watching your videos!

  • @nickymaz05
    @nickymaz05 3 года назад +6

    Thank you for the great video. I am a convert to the Catholic faith from evangelical protestantism and It's wonderful to see such respectful and fruitful discussions on these matters.

  • @manorama12
    @manorama12 3 года назад +13

    Austin.... ur so so so humble....I'm touched.....
    Fr. Joshua ur r amazingly humble n soft spoken n sweet.... when father was explaining d faith... it almost seemed like music to my ear....

  • @michaeltyl7697
    @michaeltyl7697 3 года назад +27

    Keep up your good work of bringing Christ to others. Please do more videos with Fr Joshua. He's a superb representative of the Catholic faith.
    God Bless!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад

      Thanks! I'd love to. Any particular topic?

    • @michaeltyl7697
      @michaeltyl7697 3 года назад

      @@GospelSimplicity the differently sacraments. The pope's in fallibility(when the pope is and not)

  • @CristinaaaMx
    @CristinaaaMx 3 года назад +67

    YES WE WANT MOREEE... LET ME THINK ABOUT A QUESTION! :)
    GOD BLESS HIS ONE AND ONLY CATHOLIC CHURCH

  • @SanctaThomas
    @SanctaThomas 3 года назад +68

    Hi Austin, as a young protestant with a similar church background to yourself, I'm eagerly following along with your journey as you ask some hard questions I have been thinking about. Almost makes me regret clicking on a Matt Fradd video months ago, but if we're on the path of the fullness of truth, we have no choice but to follow it to a conclusion.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +15

      Haha, your comment about Matt Fradd made me laugh. I can relate to that.

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html
      Psalm

    • @KathleenJ
      @KathleenJ 3 года назад +5

      Hi guys, I made the same journey about 20 years ago. I think you know where it leads. Save yourself some time and leap in now, the water is wonderful, clear and deep.

    • @saramolina8911
      @saramolina8911 3 года назад

      Hello, ill put a small quote from Augustine first, then the whole quote and then my comment, I hope you can read it.
      SMALL QUOTE
      _"The Lord says: Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you will not have life in you28. Here an iniquity or evil seems to be commanded; then it is a figurative phrase"_
      -AUGUSTINE-
      On Christian doctrine, 3,16
      If the phrase is mandatory and prohibits evil or vice, or iniquity or crime, or commands utility or beneficence, then the phrase is not figurative. But if it appears to command evil or iniquity, or prohibit utility or beneficence, in this case it is figurative. The Lord says: Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you will not have life in you28. Here an iniquity or evil seems to be commanded; then it is a figurative phrase by which we are recommended to participate in the Lord's passion, and we are admonished to gently and usefully retain in our memory that his flesh was wounded and crucified for us
      MY COMMENT
      augustine says that phrase jesus said in john 6:53 is a figurative phrase. Carholics base the real presence on john 6 being literal. But augustine says jesus was using figurative speech. As we believe, that jesus said it in a figurative manner.

    • @saramolina8911
      @saramolina8911 3 года назад

      Here another
      -Augustine-
      Letter 98,9
      9. According to our frequent way of speaking, we usually say, when Easter approaches: "Tomorrow or the day after tomorrow will be the passion of the Lord." But the Lord has suffered many years ago and the passion has only taken place once. On the same day as Sunday we say: "Today the Lord was risen", although many years have passed since he was resurrected. Nobody is so stupid that they throw lies in our face when we speak like that. We name such days -by their resemblance- to those others on which the above events took place. We say that it is the same day, although it is not the same, but another -similar- to it in the turning of the ages. Likewise, when we refer to the celebration of the sacrament of the altar, -we say that on that day happens- -what did not happen on that day- , but happened in the past. Christ was slain only once in person and is slain not only on the solemnities of Easter, but also every day among peoples, in that sacrament. That is why the person who answers that he is immolated now does not lie, when asked. The sacraments would not be sacraments at all if they did not have -certain similarities with those realities- of which they are sacraments. For that similarity they are usually called the same realities. -Just as in its peculiar way- -the sacrament of the body- -of Christ is the body of Christ-, and the sacrament of the blood of Christ is the blood of Christ, so also the sacrament of faith is faith. Now, believing is nothing more than having faith. Therefore, when you answer what a child believes that does not yet feel the affection of faith, it is answered that he has faith through the sacrament of faith and that he is converted to God through the sacrament of conversion, because that same answer belongs to the celebration of the sacrament.
      SMALL QUOTE
      We say that it is the same day, although it is not the same, but another -similar- to it in the turning of the ages. Likewise, when we refer to the celebration of the sacrament of the altar, -we say that on that day happens- -what did not happen on that day- , but happened in the past. Christ was slain only once in person and is slain not only on the solemnities of easter but also every day among peoples, in that sacrament
      MY COMMENT
      Augustine before this, says sometimes we say an event is happening on a day although we know is not happenig on that day. Its a way of speaking. He gives the example of holy sunday we say today the lord resurrected (but we know he didnt resurrected today but a day like this many years ago) ill give an example of christmas, on christmas we say ''today the lord is born" (althoug we know he wasnt born today). Then he says likewise, when we refer to the eucharist (sacrament of the altar) we say its happening something that its not happenig. We say the sacrifice of christ is happening (although we know its not happening but happened in the past). So christ isnt born every 25th of december, he doesnt resurrect every holy sunday, and he is not sacrified in every eucharist althought we say he is. So if augustine was at the eucharist and he said "the lord is being sacrificed", in his mind and in his heart he knew that day jesus wasnt being sacrified but was sacrified just once many yeaes ago. If augustine was on holy sunday , and he said "today the lord resurrected", in his mind and in his heart he knew jesus didnt resurrected on that day, but just once many years ago. So for augustine no sacrifice takes place at the eucharist. The catechism says indeed theres a sacrifice at the eucharist. So they dont think as augustine thought.
      Why is this important? The book of hebrews ch9 and 10, says when sacrifices are efficient they stop. They acomplished the goal so they are not performed anymore. Ineficient sacrifices are done again and again. So literal and figursrive meaning of the eucharist matters, and a lot. If its literal then a sacrifice takes place, and is repeated at each mass and that is calling the sacrifice ineficient. If its symbolic, its a memorial and no sacrifice happens, then its not repeated and so, we dont call the sacrifice inefficient.
      What happened? In israel when people sinned they sacrificed a lamb, but they didnt care about sacrificing that lamb, so they sinned again and sacrified a lamb, and again and again. That saceifice didnt make people turn away from sin. They didnt care. So God, as his wish has always been that his people are holy and abide to his law, made a better sacrifice, one that truly turn people away from sin. So nobody cared about killing a lamb, but when people saw the son of god was the one that died, people cared, it touched the heart of people, and people (the elect) turned away from sin, they dont want to dishonor that sacrifice by sinning. So the elect stopped stealing, left the mistress, stoped lying, stoped being bad sons to their parents and never did that again. The sacrifice was eficient. No need to perform it again. Read the book of hebrews from ch 5-10 specially 9-10. Jesus cannot be offered several times. His sacrifice was eficient.
      Then for me, the literal - symbolic debate is not a thing about fighting cause we like fights, its a thing about calling the sacrifice efficient or inefficient. Augustine here acknowledges no sacrifice happens (although we could say this is the sacrifice of the lord because of a way of speaking) so its very important that he has said that.
      And that is why i couldnt ever be a catholic. Because offering jesus several times is saying his sacrifice is inneficient. So it pleases me to see augustine didnt thougt the sacrifice was taking place although he could say it was taking place.

  • @crimsontwins6612
    @crimsontwins6612 3 года назад +39

    It's so amazing to see the conversion of a Protestant into the Catholic church, established by Christ, our Lord.

    • @taylorcanon8890
      @taylorcanon8890 3 года назад +4

      He's not converting but hopefully someday he will! :)

    • @tristankramer4636
      @tristankramer4636 3 года назад +2

      I don’t recall Christ Saying Thou Art Peter, and upon this rock i will build the Roman Catholic Church. The Christian Church is not restricted to the Roman Church

    • @elizabethf794
      @elizabethf794 3 года назад +1

      @@taylorcanon8890 Maybe Crimson Twins was referring to the priest's story of HIS conversion to Catholicism from Pentecostal.

    • @crimsontwins6612
      @crimsontwins6612 3 года назад +1

      @@tristankramer4636 That's not what I meant. Peace be with you.

    • @tristankramer4636
      @tristankramer4636 3 года назад +2

      @@crimsontwins6612 I know i was just answering to you saying “The Church that Christ established” Peace be with you

  • @basiaw.3912
    @basiaw.3912 3 года назад +6

    Absolutely love father Joshua for the excellent explanation of the beautiful churches built by my ancestors.Yes, I'm Polish and I am proud of it.They were poor people and they dedicated all they had it at that time so now other people can have a gorgeous temple to worship. Hats off to Poles!
    Hats off to all priests of St.Cantius and especially to Fr.Joshua!

  • @ClarkKasheta
    @ClarkKasheta 3 года назад +26

    Hey Fr. Joshua, I still have that crucifix you gave me at Holy Apostles. Hope all is well, and I'm praying for your success.

  • @Powerranger-le4up
    @Powerranger-le4up 3 года назад +7

    Thank you for being open to what we Catholics believe. I’ll be praying for you.

  • @immaculateheart1267
    @immaculateheart1267 3 года назад +100

    I cant believe Im saying this but I got a strong impression, spirituallly, that Austin may become a priest one day. No pressure, Austin, was just a fleeting feeling. 😊

    • @annemoulding7215
      @annemoulding7215 3 года назад +11

      I had the same feeling as I listened to this beautiful young man today! He is earnestly seeking the truth

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +38

      I'll respond as I do any time someone says this: that terrifies me. But, I suppose I should also say thank you.

    • @thereselastname9197
      @thereselastname9197 3 года назад +11

      I thought the same thing he mentioned he wanted to become a pastor...but in his discernment of truth it would be a magnificent thing to see him become a catholic priest we sure do need young, good holy men for this and Austin appears to have a pure heart he would make a great Catholic priest if he wished to be one and if that is truly the path that God wants him to take.

    • @annemoulding7215
      @annemoulding7215 3 года назад +7

      @@GospelSimplicity yes it must seem terrifying but if He our adorable Jesus wants you He will find a way to let you know xx don't worry too much🥰🥰🥰

    • @CMA0333
      @CMA0333 3 года назад +1

      @@GospelSimplicity Hello, Thank you so very much for the interview with Fr Joshua Austin, he is a truly HOLY, caring Priest. Thank you also for showing us the beautiful interior of the Church.
      By the way, don't be upset, by I wondered ALSO if the Lord might be calling you to His Holy Priesthood. The Old Covenant Priesthood was very much similar to Christ's New Covenant Priesthood. When their Lamb was slain by the Priest in the Temple in Jerusalem, it seems, that the penitent, was first called to confess first his sin,, whilst putting his hand on the lamb, so that his sin would pass over to the Lamb - then the Temple Priest would kill the Lamb, and grant the penitent forgiveness.
      During the days of the Old Priesthood in Jerusalem, there were so many Priests, that each Priest was called on a rota to minister in the Temple. Oftentimes, just a brief stint, over a yearly period would be possible. During that period, the Married Priests would vacate their homes, and go to serve The Lord in celibacy lodged in private quarters at the Temple.
      It was never permitted that Priests were carnally active as they ministered before God. Not many people realise that, but I discovered it not long ago whilst studying the origins of the Celibate Priesthood.
      www.unamsanctamcatholicam.com/history/79-history/465-celibacy-in-the-early-church.html
      www.catholicapologetics.info/apologetics/general/celibacy.htm
      Celibate Priests are historically the norm. During the Old Covenant, each Priest would minister so rarely, that they were permitted to take wives, yet were to remain celibate for an entire 3 days prior to taking their places in the Temple. These days of course, Priests minister and stand before the Lord every single day. Believe me, Our Lord would call an end to His celibate priesthood a grave sin. An added point, on the Liturgical vestments of the high priest of the Old Law were inscribed the words: "Holy to the Lord" - To signify that this man was sanctified for God and set apart from the rest of men.
      Thanks again Austin. Were you aware that the 144,000 men that are closest to the Lord in Heaven will be Priests?
      Rev 14
      . [3] And they sung as it were a new canticle, before the throne, and before the four living creatures, and the ancients; and no man could say the canticle, but those hundred forty-four thousand, who were purchased from the earth. [4] These are they who were not defiled with women: for they are virgins. These follow the Lamb whithersoever he goeth. These were purchased from among men, the firstfruits to God and to the Lamb: [5] And in their mouth there was found no lie; for they are without spot before the throne of God."
      www.drbo.org/cgi-bin/d?b=drb&bk=73&ch=14&l=3%23x
      God Bless you. Thanks again. Great show. Hope you managed to view the 4 videos I put on the other page, if not, I'll post them again. They are really, really Super!
      Dr Brant Pitre - Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist ruclips.net/video/P45BHDRA7pU/видео.html
      Documentaries filmed in the Holy Land
      Dr Steve Ray - Footprints of God - Peter
      gloria.tv/?media=403923
      Dr Steve Ray - Footprints of God - Mary
      gloria.tv/?media=404384
      Dr Steve Ray - Footprints of God - Paul
      gloria.tv/?media=404823

  • @jtconvert_2160
    @jtconvert_2160 3 года назад +3

    Thanks. On a journey, I think to Rome. Thanks Father Joshua and Austin. Was helpful

  • @mk_78
    @mk_78 3 года назад +4

    I'm catholic and I loved this tour and interview so much. Father is an inspiration and the beauty of that church is astounding! Thank you †

  • @avi4989
    @avi4989 3 года назад +20

    Both of you are so calming and eloquent. I’d love to see a video meeting with Quakers, being such a unique and wildly different community with a strong history in the US.

  • @tijojoseph3315
    @tijojoseph3315 3 года назад +11

    I love how you acknowledged the 'The Ten Minute Bible Hour' for influencing videos like this at the end. Good man!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +3

      It was my pleasure to give credit to where it's due!

  • @bridgetmichalowski7109
    @bridgetmichalowski7109 3 года назад +4

    Proud to call this wonderful Church my Parish 💙

  • @patriciabarry6027
    @patriciabarry6027 3 года назад +4

    The best dialogue and educationI have heard that eliminates misconceptions of the Catholic Church...A refreshing understanding..
    Thank you Austin and Fr. Joshua...

  • @deannastroth2000
    @deannastroth2000 Год назад +1

    I am a cradle Catholic and was intrigued with your visit to St. John Cantius, and may I say that Father Caswell was THE perfect priest to guide you through the physical Church, Church and Mass elements, and Church history. He is a true shepherd of Christ's flock and I thank you for interviewing him and for all his extremely interesting information.

  • @myronmercado
    @myronmercado 3 года назад +26

    Excited.

  • @AaronSmith-xx5zb
    @AaronSmith-xx5zb 3 года назад +37

    Can't wait for this! Loved part one!! Thanks so much for making such an interesting video. I am a parishioner at another Catholic Church which is also ran by the Canons Regular of St. John Cantius. The church is St. Peter in Volo, Illinois. They also run a parish in Springfield, Illinois. Our pastor is Father Nathan Caswell who is Father Joshua's brother! He is an awesome priest too! You should come check out our parish if your ever in the area!

    • @TyroneBeiron
      @TyroneBeiron 3 года назад +2

      Found this video about the restoration of the parish, and of the formation of the Canons Regular SJC: ruclips.net/video/ejwhzxQL5s4/видео.html

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +6

      I would love to! Fr. Joshua talked to me about his brother and that parish

    • @beautifulspirit7420
      @beautifulspirit7420 3 года назад +2

      @@TyroneBeiron Tom thank you so much for posting this video! Truly inspiring and encouraging.

    • @1Hope4All
      @1Hope4All 3 года назад +1

      @@GospelSimplicity His brother is also a Priest at another Canonary. Fr. Joshua told my daughter and me his conversation story several years ago before he became a Priest. We were at their Ordination.

    • @AaronSmith-xx5zb
      @AaronSmith-xx5zb 3 года назад +1

      @@GospelSimplicity You are more than welcome at our parish anytime!

  • @mabee_regional_heritage_center
    @mabee_regional_heritage_center 3 года назад +3

    Everyone say a quick little prayer for Austin and the priest as a thank you for doing this interview.

  • @piafounetMarcoPesenti
    @piafounetMarcoPesenti 3 года назад +150

    All I can think of - without any offense intended - is: You're almost home.

  • @jalildragneel2674
    @jalildragneel2674 3 года назад +23

    I was like... This one popped up in my recommendations, I kinda went for part one... I wanted to see all in one go 😁 well I'll wait, patience is good. Austin, I really appreciate the way you go out of your way to give an answer to your commenters. Cheers.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +1

      Glad to hear you're excited about it! It's my pleasure to respond to as many as I can.
      PS - If you really can't wait, it's out on my Patreon😁

  • @patrickcassidy65
    @patrickcassidy65 3 года назад +3

    Austin, very well done, I am a cradle Catholic re converted back, in love with all beautiful Churches that glorify God.

  • @TracyW-me8br
    @TracyW-me8br 3 года назад +12

    I grew up Charismatic Catholic. CCRNO in New Orleans. True blue, rock solid Catholic

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Thanks for sharing!

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html
      Psalm

    • @daviddestefanis2989
      @daviddestefanis2989 3 года назад +3

      Like Amy Coney Barrett

    • @KathleenJ
      @KathleenJ 3 года назад +2

      @@daviddestefanis2989 and me!

    • @beautifulspirit7420
      @beautifulspirit7420 3 года назад +2

      I came into the church as an atheist through a Catholic Charismatic youth group. The young leaders were so devout and joyful, many young people came to Christ through their prayers, fasting and witness.

  • @tasiaflynn3549
    @tasiaflynn3549 Год назад +1

    Thank you Austin and Fr Joshua to bring us together to love one anotherm ❤❤

  • @imanol3878
    @imanol3878 3 года назад +10

    I'm not sure if you'll see this since it's a few days after the fact, but I wanted to sort of affirm you. You obviously do not know me or the others commenting here (though perhaps there have been some recurring characters in the comments section!), and I have seen people trying to tell you that you're going to be a priest or become Catholic or telling you you shouldn't become Catholic. You have taken this so graciously and I sincerely want to thank you for that and say how impressed I am with that, because from my experience it is really indescribably frustrating when people who do not know you attempt to tell you how to live your life, especially in your relationship with God. Bias disclosure, I am a Catholic, and I think it'd be pretty neat if you became Catholic, but I don't think it's right to pressure you into that, even if that comes from a good place. You are clearly an incredibly nice and holy man, and I cannot wait to see where God takes you. If you get married, God be praised, if you become a priest, God be praised, if you remain Protestant, God be praised, if you become Catholic, God be praised. No matter where you end up the Spirit will be working through you, and I'm so honored that you're allowing us to come with you on your journey. If I'm ever in your area, I'll be sure to stop by your church. Happy All Saint's Day and God bless!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Wow, thank you so much for the encouragement. I really appreciate that. It's my pleasure to bring you all along for the journey. Happy All Saint's Day to you as well! God bless!

    • @saramolina8911
      @saramolina8911 3 года назад

      @@GospelSimplicity stay protestant. Are you really on a journey? I hope not, but some of us get that, and are happy (catholics) or concerned (me).
      But i will give you some reasons to stay protestant, cause i want you to be saved
      1. Bowing to statues is a sin. We can not do this even if it is a statue of the lord himself. Deuteronomy 4:15, isaiah 40:18. And in acts 17, paul says God forgave the sillyness in the past but he will not continue doing it (thinking God can be represented with gold or such (in a statue))
      2. The sacrifice of the mass calls the sacrifice of christ an ineficient one. Hebrews 9-10 ssys when sscrifices are eficient they stop. No need to offer them again. This notion of catholics that they sin and in the eucharist the sin is forgiven is ignoring that christs sscrifice turned away people from sin, it was efficient, so sons of God, dont live in sin, says 1 john 3. And if we sin (this shouldnt be, but could happen, we make a sacrifice our own bodies in obedience, not offer christ again)
      So consider this, and remember catholics say church farhers say this and that, but many times its not true church farhers say what they say they say. And remember fathers say this sort of things catholics like to mention but they seem to forget protestants can agree with that. Like if ignatius says.
      The bread is the body - protestants can agree with this.
      The eucharist is remedy for immortality, - also csn agree (it makes us remember. And that way we dont sin)
      If iraneus says
      We dont receve it as common bread - we agree is not common bread
      Or if augustine says
      The bread becomes the body at the eucharist - we can agree cause also people BECOME sheep at baptism
      God bless

  • @snoopdog3771
    @snoopdog3771 3 года назад +9

    Thank you Austin and Fr. Joshua! Many many blessings to you both and all you hold dear 🙏🙏

  • @davidodoherty8494
    @davidodoherty8494 3 года назад +9

    I'm a Catholic. Loved this interview! Father had exactly my view as to the LM/NO question. Would love to see another interview like this! Subbed! ✝️🇻🇦

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Glad to hear that! Thanks! Grateful to have you as a part of the community here at Gospel Simplicity. God bless!

  • @maureenkeane3157
    @maureenkeane3157 3 года назад +1

    Fr. Is such a holy priest what a beautiful church I am catholic all my life learned so much form Fr. tour of church so much I did not know. Listening from Ireland. God bless

  • @Infj6569
    @Infj6569 Год назад +1

    I truly appreciate and enjoy your talk with Fr. Caswell who’s so charming and knowledgeable, so supportive of the TLM which I really enjoy attending online. I’m looking forward to seeing more talks with Fr. Caswell and Austin.

  • @sabrehohoho7681
    @sabrehohoho7681 3 года назад +4

    Happy morning from Borneo...thanks father

  • @rsmyth75
    @rsmyth75 3 года назад +4

    Being raised hard core Irish Catholic I can find it very hard to reach out to protestants. But your channel is inviting and your humility is very disarming!!! Ur authentic love of Christ shines bright!!!

  • @Dodoviko
    @Dodoviko 3 года назад +2

    Fantastic, good video Austin, well done you. We Catholics are blessed for having Our Lord Jesus in the Eucharist daily, lets continue growing in love. Thanks fr. Joshua for sharing

  • @elispena1719
    @elispena1719 3 года назад +2

    Wow what a beautiful Church, would love to visit, thank you for the tour. Austin you will be Catholic before you know it. The Catholics faith is the plenitud of the truth. beautiful program.

  • @benjamin927
    @benjamin927 3 года назад +16

    After this, You have my subscription man!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Thank you so much! Grateful to have you as a part of the community here at Gospel Simplicity. I truly believe the community gets stronger as more voices come to the table, and I'm excited to hear some of your thoughts going forward! God bless

  • @hewhanstud7
    @hewhanstud7 3 года назад +9

    Thanks for the video! The Canons helped me out a lot too. Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam.

  • @tonycevallos7513
    @tonycevallos7513 3 года назад +10

    Young man, I love your channel. You are a very special soul. I can see the Holy Spirit in you bigtime.

  • @SharonCullenArt
    @SharonCullenArt 3 года назад +49

    Can’t wait. Thought it was already out! Ha. I’m a Catholic subscriber.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Soon! Grateful to have you as a part of the community here on the channel.

    • @learnbibleversethroughpict6027
      @learnbibleversethroughpict6027 3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/GiXzV5nA4T0/видео.html
      Psalm

    • @SharonCullenArt
      @SharonCullenArt 3 года назад +1

      @True Messenger of God well you are getting your information from someone who has poor information. There is no age set on baptism. The Bible doesn’t say to only baptize adults does it? Nope. You see, baptism is about cleansing us from “original sin” and to receive the protection of the hOnly spirit. Original sin is the sin that prevented us from eternal life and that was the sin of Adam and Eve. Protecting our children from the soles of the devil by instilling the Holy Spirit through baptism is a good thing. I don’t see why evangelicals get hung up on it,
      And when it comes to the rosary... it is all scripture. Luke 1:28 and
      Luke 1:41-43 is the first half of the rosary prayer. Each ten beads of the rosary hold ten scriptures related to a mystery of Jesus, life death and resurrection and his miracles performed. So today being Friday we pray the sorrowful mysteries which are, the agony in the garden, then the next set of ten are on the scourging at the Pilar, and then the next set of ten are on the crowning with thorns, then the next set of ten, carrying his cross, and finally the last ten, the crucifixion. Each bead has a verse from scripture related to each of those mysteries. Each one is different. We meditate on the scripture. It draws us closer to Christ. The other prayers used are our Apostles Creed, The Our Father, and Hail holy Queen. So by saying it is not based on scripture means you never bothered to research it but took the word of another in your religion that spreads these falsehoods. As far as lighting candles in front of statues... they are always in front of statues, but they aren’t in a birthday cake! Where should we put these symbolic candles? Under the church pew? It will catch fire. We do not pray to statues if that is what you are getting at. Statues within a church are there as visual reminders. To help us meditate or pray to God. If you are concerned about “the Mary thing” this is a very long discussion. But first of all if I started talking smack about your mom would it bother you? If I came into your home and said why do you have a picture of your mom on the mantle you’d think I was nuts right? Because she is your mom. God the father chose her to have his son. Doesn’t this make her the mother of God? She gave him his humanity, and God gave him his divinity. We honor her. She deserves honor, just as you honor your mother. We do not adore her. That is reserved trinity. Father, son and Holy Spirit. We speak to saints. They are alive with Christ. We ask them to pray for us. Who better? We ask people here on earth to pray for us and we aren’t even saints! So why not ask those who have died and gone to their heavenly home?
      As far as solo scriptura, the a[ostles taught about the traditions of the church that were not in the Bible.
      2 Thessalonians 2:15 states,
      So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter.
      Instead of coming at a Christian and telling us about things you don’t understand in the true church, why not ask nicely rather than coming at me like this? Why such unrighteousness anger? If you are against wrong teachings I’d like to teach you correctly whenever you are ready, because you have been taught the classic misinformation all evangelicals are taught. Read Scott Hahn’s book called Home Sweet Rome. He was an evangelical pastor who became Catholic. He has many degrees including theology and could teach you a lot. Or also I recommend someone right here on YouTibe that has more than 10- videos answering every misinformed statement you make her channel is Lizzie’s Answers. She was also Protestant. As I was. I am a convert.

    • @SharonCullenArt
      @SharonCullenArt 3 года назад

      @True Messenger of God it was late as I wrote a response to you early in the morning here, so I will finish with all of your list. Mary is in the Bible at least 19 times. Jesus spoke of different things less often than Mary is spoken of so Mary plays a key role in our salvation. Beginning in Mary at enmity with Satan- Genesis 3:15, then Christ born of a Virgin-Isaiah 7:14, then full of grace before the incarnation, 1: 26-28, Mary sanctifies the greatest man (John the Baptist) while he is still in the womb Luke 1:15, and 1:42, Mary’s blessed fruit 1:41-44, Luke 6:43-44 , Mary is the mother of God Luke 1:43, Mary’s need of a savior Luke 1:47, most blessed woman of all time Luke 1:48, what God has done for her Luke 1:49.Then Mary’s sufferings united with Jesus Luke 2:34-35, Mary’s total obedience to God more important than her motherhood 11:27-28. Then in John Mary’s roll in intercession with Jesus (this is the part where you all say we worship her but this is where we get the prayer to her to intercede for us to her son 2:3-5, Then Mary is our mother John19:26-27 and Revelation 12:17. Mary and Jesus united as one (as are all the saints in heaven) 1Cor 6:17. Then Mary the New Testament ark of the covenant Revelation 11:19-12:1. Mary’s body is in heaven and Mary is queen of heaven Revelation 12:1. Mary still at enmity with Satan Revelation 12:17. So that is what I have found about Mary in the Bible. She plays an important Roll and ought to be respected. We do not worship her!

    • @SharonCullenArt
      @SharonCullenArt 3 года назад

      @True Messenger of God I am trying to respond to your many many statements and there’s. Lot to respond to here...confession of sins to a priest. First we don’t think of him as God but he sits in the chair and Christ hears our sins as we tell the priest. He then counsels us on the sin so that we don’t continue to repeat these sins over and over. But in the Bible since everything you need must be in the Bible.... here goes... Leviticus 19: 20-22: A man who committed adultery had to bring a guilt offering for himself to the door of the tent of meeting (holy place where the ark of the covenant, which contained God’s true presence was kept). But then it adds “And the priest shall make atonement for him …before the Lord for his sin…and the sin which he has committed shall be forgiven.” (see also Leviticus 5: 5-6) The priest could not make atonement if he were not aware of the man's sin. He is acting as a mediator for the repentant sinner. Matthew 3: 6 (and Mk 1: 5): “. . . they were baptized by him [John the Baptist] in the river Jordan, confessing their sins.” So he who prepared the way for Christ, listened to confessions of sin. We learn in Luke's account of the Baptist that he answered many questions for the people concerning the behavior they should follow, but freely confessed that he was not the Christ (Luke 3: 16-17). He doubtless heard countless confessions of sin, but he knew where forgiveness of sin came from for when Jesus approached he declared, "Behold the Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world" (John 1: 29). Jesus than sent his disciples to baptize throughout Judea (John 3: 22) and they too, doubtless heard the confessions of many sinners as they traveled from village to village. So Jesus used his disciples and John the precursor to hear confessions of sins, but this is not the sacrament of confession, anymore than the baptism of John was the baptism of the Holy Spirit, which came after John the Baptist's time. Let's see if the New Testament shows men receiving the authority to forgive sins in God's name.
      Matthew 9: 6-8: Jesus tells us that He was given authority on earth to forgive sins (a power reserved to God alone) and proves it with miraculous healings and then Scripture notes this same authority was given to “men” (plural). Is this merely a figure of speech? No, John's Gospel makes it clear Jesus intended to give this sacrament to men:
      John 20: 21-23: In his very first Resurrection appearance our Lord gives this awesome power to his Apostles with the words:
      “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” How could they forgive sins if they were not confessed? They could not. This authority comes through the gift of the Holy Spirit which precedes it.
      Does this remind of you what He told Peter (Mt. 16: 19) and then the other apostles (Mt. 18:18)? “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” This includes sins. Jesus allowed for us to receive spiritual consolation and counsel in this beautiful sacrament of the Church. We see this awesome power in other sacraments as well. What today we call the sacrament of the sick. Again, we look to Scripture: James 5: 14-17: "Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord; 15 and the prayer of faith will save the sick man, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. 16 Therefore confess your sins to one another …”
      Notice the command does not say confess your sins straight to God. Notice also who they are to go to the “elders” (bishops or priests-see the Acts 14: 23; 15: 2 for example).
      1 John 1: 9: “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, and will forgive our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” The word confess has an oral/verbal or proclamation meaning. St. Paul describes his ministry as one of reconciliation of sinners:
      2 Corinthians 5: 18: “All this is from God, who through Christ reconciled us to himself and gave us the ministry of reconciliation . . .”

  • @onetradcat4203
    @onetradcat4203 3 года назад +6

    So very grateful that you are learning and are seeking more deeply into the Catholic Church. Keep going!!! Love the videos. Will keep you in our 🙏 prayers. God bless you.

  • @daviddestefanis2989
    @daviddestefanis2989 3 года назад +4

    I'm Catholic, but I loved both of these videos. When I was Confirmed as an adult, in RCIA class, one of the most powerful classes was the priest giving us a tour of our Church. It was a much more simple Church than this one, and I've been in Catholic Churches my whole life. And I still learned quite a bit about the different symbols and meanings of things in the Church and during Mass. Like you said, someone could do a PHD Thesis on this stuff. Just imagine being a poor illiterate Catholic going to a Church like Notre Dame. Not only is it incredibly beautiful, but the depth of the meaning feels like theirs a wealth of unknown mystery there. Like you could only ever just scrape the surface of those mysteries, even though you might go to Church there all the time.

  • @angelamote19741
    @angelamote19741 8 месяцев назад

    As a convert from evangelicalism it’s the Catholic faith that brought the reality of Gods presence in my life through the Eucharist. To receive him body, soul and divinity brings him so close.

  • @kragar4
    @kragar4 3 года назад +1

    Lovely interview! Fr Josh is amazing...and his brother is a priest!! Their mom had no idea what God would do when she said yes to Jesus’ leading her to the Catholic faith

  • @jgil1966
    @jgil1966 3 года назад +12

    Today i recommend the film Lilies of the Field (1963), i believe if you haven’t seen this film, it will bless your ecumenical heart. God bless you. Another awesome video of yours!

    • @fawn1785
      @fawn1785 3 года назад +4

      I loved that movie! Never say no to a German Nun. 😇

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +3

      Thanks! I haven't seen that. I'll try to look into it!

    • @brucebarber4104
      @brucebarber4104 3 года назад +1

      One of my favorite movies. Sidney Poitier's performance is excellent!

  • @Italiana3343
    @Italiana3343 3 года назад +3

    Thank you Austin for your respectful demeanor and thoughtful questions and thank you Fr. Joshua for giving generously of your time for these two videos. The Holy Spirit was there with you both. I am not fortunate enough to live in Chicago and to be able to attend services at this beautiful church but, thanks to the generosity of the Canons Regular sharing their services via livestream, I feel as if I am there with them. During the last several months this has been a beautiful gift for which I can’t adequately express my thanks.
    May God bless you you both for these inspiring and enlightening talks.

  • @judethbn7415
    @judethbn7415 22 дня назад +1

    Thank you bro. The priest is inspiring

  • @duaneadams5210
    @duaneadams5210 3 года назад +2

    I once was a part of a parish ran by the St. Pius X order. The pastor was very against any Protestant evening visiting because he felt they profaned the sacred space of the church. He very often and openly criticized anything Protestant and was offensive to them and never missed an opportunity to attack. He missed many good opportunities for gently teaching and sharing and drove many people away with his forceful demeaner, never showing Christian love and eventually driving me away too. This video was very well done and St. John Cantius is very lucky to have this priest. Too bad more priests can't be as good.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад

      Sorry to hear about that. Glad you enjoyed the video!

  • @mercedestaveras6462
    @mercedestaveras6462 3 года назад +6

    I am Catholic and I love your work, I signed up for your channel

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Thank you so much! Grateful to have you as a part of the community here! I look forward to hearing more of your thoughts going forward.

  • @tesschavit3009
    @tesschavit3009 3 года назад +3

    Father Joshua is a living saint. God bless you father. Let us pray for all good and faithful priests, who dedicate themselves to their people with generosity and unknown sacrifices.🙏🏻❤️

  • @luigidemaio6111
    @luigidemaio6111 8 месяцев назад

    Father Joshua is our direct blessing from God

  • @kashi75
    @kashi75 3 года назад

    Fr. Joshua, you are a blessing to the Catholic Church.

  • @alessandrositopu
    @alessandrositopu 3 года назад +6

    I really love this video. Fr. Joshua changed my thoughts a bit about Traditionalists. I really hope that the dichotomy inside the Church could be ended by building bridges like what he said. Thank you, Austin - Gospel Simplicity, for this video. This is different from other videos alike cause it is at St. John Cantius. I thank Fr. Joshua too for agreeing to be in this video.

  • @RGTomoenage11
    @RGTomoenage11 3 года назад +6

    I watch you and Matt, nothing but Love from a catholic brother.
    God bless and thank you both.

  • @kimfleury
    @kimfleury 3 года назад +2

    Father spoke words that convicted me, and I take them to heart. Especially realizing that saying "Yes" to God each morning is an act that brings grace into the world. I begin each day with thanksgiving as my eyes open, then inviting God to possess me fully as my feet are heading to hit the floor. At the point when I'm sitting up, I pray, "Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done." Then I give Jesus my will and ask for His in return. Little acts that seem invisible with all that's going on in the world. It can feel fruitless. But the assurance that it brings grace into the world gives me hope. May God's kingdom come and may His will be done on earth as it is in heaven, and may He keep Father, and all of you, safe from all dangers to soul and body all the days of your lives.

  • @christinemcguiness9356
    @christinemcguiness9356 Год назад +1

    Beautiful conversation. Didn’t want it to finish! God bless🙏

  • @elinkristin
    @elinkristin 3 года назад +4

    Enjoyed this conversation greatly! Blessings from a pentecostal in Norway

  • @flamesfan1417
    @flamesfan1417 3 года назад +4

    I would be fascinated to see a video of you just reflecting on your experiences at Cantius and conversations with Fr. Joshua in light of your own faith background and perspective of the Catholic faith. Thanks for letting God reach out to us through your channel!

  • @richardmagale8405
    @richardmagale8405 3 года назад +1

    Christianity= Belief in incarnation, resurrection, and finally discipleship... to me. So, as a Catholic/Christian I really enjoyed your interview. You've and openness to educate yourself and your viewers. Peace!

  • @anastasiae7392
    @anastasiae7392 10 месяцев назад

    I, too, discovered this beautiful church in the pandemic and would love to visit there at St. John Cantius, definitely light a candle in honour to God.
    I thank God for feeding my soul online during the lockdown😊 discovering the
    TLM is an undisputed heavenly blessing.

  • @18Tonks
    @18Tonks 3 года назад +3

    WOW!!! Okay, so many things--So glad you mentioned Matt's channel, because it was watching him explore the Catholic Church that made me excited to see the video where you visited St. John Cantius for the first time. Fr. Caswell is an absolute treasure of a priest. You can feel his love and devotion every time he speaks. He profoundly understands the beauty the Church holds for us all; and his response to your questions about unity and the TLM really moved me and brought so much light to my experience as a traditionally-minded Catholic. It feels amazing to have the TLM explained through this platform, and to also acknowledge well-said ordinary form masses. I personally see a well-said NO as a bridge to loving the TLM (Catholic Whole Foods hahahaha). Lastly, Austin, you are such a blessing to the Christian world...Because of you saying yes to God, many souls will be restored to Christ, through your willingness to lovingly expose the beauty of the Church to the world. Thank you!!! Can't wait to grab some merch and support your efforts on Patreon!

    • @amandah8178
      @amandah8178 3 года назад

      Amen!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад

      Wow, thank you so much for your kind words and support! That truly means so much to me. God bless!

  • @Steve_Milo
    @Steve_Milo 3 года назад +3

    You did your homework and since you're so charitable, you're starting to feel like a younger brother. Proud of you!

  • @elsamatiwas6731
    @elsamatiwas6731 3 года назад +2

    Thank you Austin god Bless you

  • @matthewcauthorn9731
    @matthewcauthorn9731 3 года назад +1

    Thank you for your kindness to Catholics like me, You are in my prayers Young Man

  • @Stormlight1234
    @Stormlight1234 3 года назад +6

    Austin, you ask such good questions! I am very amazed at your grace, humility, and charity in all of these discussions too. I can still really sense that you are genuinely trying to learn from others and seeking after only what is true. God bless you on your search for truth!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +2

      Wow, thank you so much! I really appreciate that

  • @laurieb2747
    @laurieb2747 3 года назад +3

    Austin! This is your (former 😢) neighbor Laurie. How did I not know you had such a great RUclips channel! I look forward to watching more!!

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад +1

      Hey! Thanks for watching! Hope you enjoy the channel and take good care of the neighborhood!

  • @silvaemiliani-mowrey4463
    @silvaemiliani-mowrey4463 3 года назад +2

    Attended my first Latin Mass not long ago and I loved the reverence and the focus on Christ during the entire Mass. After seeing how some of the hierarchy of the Catholic Church is departing from the true magisterium I am longing to live the Truth in the Catholic Church like never before. The Latin Mass is great!
    Thanks Father for all the recommendations to keep the sacred alive in our hearts! Wherever we are!

  • @mboudreaux2950
    @mboudreaux2950 3 года назад +2

    Love this interview, Austin & Fr. Joshua, so looking forward to the next one(s)! I’m Catholic and appreciate your going straight for the truth about Catholicism, instead of relying solely on what you’ve been “taught/told/sold” about us.
    I went to services a few times, for my own curiosity, of the Baptist & Protestant experience. I was sad that I was hearing outright falsehoods from the main pastor. My Baptist friend, who had attended a few Catholic services with me, agreed that it was an attack on us. (ie: Mary worship, as opposed to Mary veneration)
    I sincerely appreciate you seeking out the authentic truth for yourself & sharing it.
    Thanks & God Bless!!

  • @HeavnzMiHome
    @HeavnzMiHome 3 года назад +4

    Latin is a universal language. Our prayers are shared around the world.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад

      What makes you say it's a universal language?

    • @HeavnzMiHome
      @HeavnzMiHome 3 года назад

      @@GospelSimplicity
      Latin transcends the local languages and unites us as one.

    • @HeavnzMiHome
      @HeavnzMiHome 3 года назад

      I’ll try again. Lol. Latin was one of the languages posted on the cross of Christ. It is one of the languages that has preserved the faith through millennia. Technically, it’s not absolutely universal, but, like English, it has a very widespread base around the world. Even before I became Catholic (Latin rite), I learned some basic prayers, songs, and expressions largely through choral music. Latin was even offered in my secular high school as a language option because of its usefulness in the sciences.

    • @javier6926
      @javier6926 3 года назад +1

      @@GospelSimplicity during the Roman Empire and the medieval period , Latin was the main language of Europe (Western Europe , at least ) . During the medieval period , Latin was the language used in the liturgy, and was also used by educated people to communicate to each other. If Portuguese and Polish diplomats wanted to communicate , they used Latin. If an Irish scholar wanted to debate a Sicilian one , they used Latin. And if a Frenchman wanted to write a book that could be easily read by educated people across the whole continent , he used Latin. Even after the Reformation , Protestant countries kept using Latin for centuries as a diplomatic and scholarly language ( until the 18th at least ).

  • @ransomcoates546
    @ransomcoates546 3 года назад +8

    Fr. Phillips would be so proud.

    • @GospelSimplicity
      @GospelSimplicity  3 года назад

      Forgive my ignorance, but who's that?

    • @ransomcoates546
      @ransomcoates546 3 года назад +2

      Gospel Simplicity Fr. Frank Phillips was the founder of the Canons who took a virtually derelict Polish church in Chicago and by the grace of God turned it into what you see today. Several years ago he was accused of impropriety and completely exonerated after investigation. But Cardinal Cupich expelled him from the Archdiocese. I believe he lives in St Louis now. Many of us have no doubt this was orchestrated by the very liberal authorities in Chicago to get rid of the local symbol of liturgical tradition. I feel sure Cardinal Cupich would shut the whole place down were it not for the income it generates in diocesan taxes from the large and generous congregation.

    • @beautifulspirit7420
      @beautifulspirit7420 3 года назад

      @@ransomcoates546 no good deed goes unpunished.

    • @greenacresgirl6259
      @greenacresgirl6259 3 года назад

      @@ransomcoates546 My thoughts exactly. I pray for their protection.

  • @sheryllanderson1394
    @sheryllanderson1394 3 года назад +1

    Fr. Joshua- loved listening to you and the Joy you have.
    I found St. John Cantius by asking Alexa to play "Salvation is Created" . It's SO beautiful ,as well as the struggle of the original composer.
    Alexa brought me to your choir(!)
    I am Catholic, and look forward to visiting your church. One of my favorite activities, to visit beautiful churches.
    Thank you for sharing, both of you.
    This is truly a "God wink"🌺 in my life

  • @cleolawilson6473
    @cleolawilson6473 3 года назад +2

    As a cradle Catholic in the Bahamas I truly appreciate this interview. Real Catholic. Thank you.