I really appreciate that SM let them to perform with live vocals at university festival this year to prove their capabilities, unlike a year ago. Thank u SM and good job aespa!
Their stage presence is amazing!! They’ve come so far and you can tell they practice so hard to be so confident to sing amazing live vocals on stage. I really love these girls!!
It wasn't her mic. She had problems with her earpiece as you can see she keeps saying she can't hear pointing at her ear. Then after she went backstage to get it fixed, during the next two songs she asked them to turn the volume from the earpiece up.
@@caioxalves it was actually both. During illusion bridge. Her mic was turn down and you can see her getting frustrated and annoyed at the staff. They didn’t even fix anything
에스파 이번음악은 기존음악과는 다른 변신이라 광야컨셉에 익숙한 대중들에게.다소 낯설었을수도있었다. 나역시도 그랬고. 하지만 노래와 무대를 보다보니 역시 sm은 sm. 역시 에스파는 에스파였다. 에스파가 하니 또 괜찮다. 에스파가 하니 또 된다. 대중들에게 받아들여지는 시간은 필요했지만 받아들인 이후부터는 다시 정상인것. 나는 한 회사가 여러 아이돌을 성공시켰다면 그런 역사가 있다면 거기에는 이유가 있다라고 본다. 누군가는 말한다. 대기업 기획사빨이지 대기업이라 다되지. 일리는 있지. 자본주의시장은 돈으로 움직이니. 다만 반대로 대기업 기획사에 들어가는덴 이유가 있겠지 그걸 알아야함..대기업이 뽑는덴.이유가있겠지. 수많은 아티스트들을 봐왔고 성공시켰는데 그런 데이터가 축적되어있겠지.
It's not ningning mic that had a problem guys, it's her in ear. She can't hear herself if the volume is too low and that's not a really comfortable thing to happen when they're performing in an open and noisy space like that, but yeah it's not the mic
if people understood how standing there like a droid ruins the energy...the performers feed off of the vibe of the audience and they give back as that feedback-loop occurs. Every single person recording is contributing to themselves being cheated out of what should be an amazing experience but instead is half dead.
For all MY in Hyper Line concert later please don't rise your phone so high like parents expectation yaaa. Please rise your phone until your eye level or max your head. Thanks
Imagine training & practicing & working for years to be a performer...and then go to perform live before an audience but instead find yourself in front of a 18,000-person camera crew just standing there like robots. So weird.
@@slimeboy5626 that is a fair point to make when it comes to what to expect to see for an audience reacting. Especially Korean audiences I've seen are pretty subdued. However, I believe it doesn't matter what the performance or event is...When the phone is between the artist & audience, it creates a disconnect. Something as simple as eye-contact can be interfered with. Also, things like just waving arms or even applause comes at the expense of the clicks & views gathering devices. Something as simple as a school play or choir performance - when recording - that device causes the person viewing to experience a level of being disengaged. It's different, no matter what.
@@Tina-pt4zp Presumably by "capture the moment", you mean "get as many clicks, likes, and subs as possible"? The energy of the experience is degraded by everyone recording. If that's what people want to capture, then ok.
@@ShastaBean Not everyone's uploading these vids on the intenet hello? Different ppl have different ways of appreciating memories. I literally take pics and vids everytime something special happens bffr
They're not turning down their mics don't worry, it's her in ear, she can't hear herself if the volume is too low and that's not a really comfortable thing to happen when they're performing in an open space like that, but yeah it's not the mics
They got a lot of better in sp, not like others gg only vocus in sp, but their voice is terrible only scream in high notes and wispering in low notes. Aespa and nmixx live is the best in 4gg, they got the power to support their notes.
@@92liayaa nah itzy voice isn't good. Their main vocalis lia isn't better than gissele and karina. Their rapper not as good as gissele and karina too. They are dancing queen I agree with that, but their vocal is weak, if yeji keep screaming like that, she will have problem someday. I always ask why jyp not give 2 members of nmixx in itzy it will be balance them. If you talk about vocal jyp best gg is nmixx.
@@Aura-xp3gj I didn't say their vocals are strong, they're stronger when they sing live and aespa playbacks more if they're so good why do they sing so little live?
![[아카라카 2023] 에스파 aespa - 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ynxvyOdmAEE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[아카라카 2023] 에스파 aespa - 1](/img/tr.png)
![[Hanyang University ERICA Department of Dance and Arts] | Jeongwaja ep.46](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EI8Lku5EdS0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[8K FULL] 에스파 aespa - 단국대학교 천안캠퍼스 축제 | 240522 | BOX (Supernova, BlackMamba, 시대유감, Spicy, Next Level)](/img/1.gif)
I really appreciate that SM let them to perform with live vocals at university festival this year to prove their capabilities, unlike a year ago. Thank u SM and good job aespa!
6:16 i guess only Giselle lip syncing. Look at the screen
@@berobbong that screen's obviously a few seconds behind
@@alocaseanyuupp👍
@@berobbongoon kok dipeli hara
@@berobbongall of them sang live.. the screen behind them are few second behind...
Their stage presence is amazing!! They’ve come so far and you can tell they practice so hard to be so confident to sing amazing live vocals on stage. I really love these girls!!
aespa is just so amazing… their live sounds so goooddd
Those live vocals are crazy af. They slay so hard!!!
부럽다.. 에스파.... 요새 흔치않게 좋아
에스파 잘됐으면 좋겠당 ㅜㅜㅜ
이미 잘 됐는데 뭔 소리
Ning Ning is insane so 😍💓
Their Live is Amazing,Fighting and always supporting
I love Aespa. I love Karina, Winter, Giselle and Ningning! ❤
Its really fun to watch 😄
yes we are like the back row of spectators😂
So good to see them happy like that
Ningning's mic is always in trouble, so poor she went out to fix it and on stage asked to turn up the volume so proud of the four members
It wasn't her mic. She had problems with her earpiece as you can see she keeps saying she can't hear pointing at her ear. Then after she went backstage to get it fixed, during the next two songs she asked them to turn the volume from the earpiece up.
@@caioxalves it was actually both. During illusion bridge. Her mic was turn down and you can see her getting frustrated and annoyed at the staff. They didn’t even fix anything
역시 sm 에스파답다. 카메라밖에 안보일정도로 인기가많네
Yeah💃
근데 축제땐 누가오던 다 저럼
@@하이디라오-k3tSM 가수는 인기 넘사벽임. 소시 축제왔을때도 카메라오졌음
앞에 비투비땐 더했음
남돌이랑 비교하면 안되지. 여자들이 무지성으로 소리지름
Ningning such a cutieeeee🥰
닝깅 사랑해 ❤
블랙맘바 춤 빡쌘데 거기에 라이브 하고 나서 바로 인사하고 말하는데 하나도 안힘들어 보이네 개신기하다 개쩌네
Omg the vocal so clean, aespa so amazing
Love them so much and thanks for video
에스파 이번음악은 기존음악과는 다른 변신이라 광야컨셉에 익숙한 대중들에게.다소 낯설었을수도있었다. 나역시도 그랬고. 하지만 노래와 무대를 보다보니 역시 sm은 sm. 역시 에스파는 에스파였다. 에스파가 하니 또 괜찮다. 에스파가 하니 또 된다. 대중들에게 받아들여지는 시간은 필요했지만 받아들인 이후부터는 다시 정상인것. 나는 한 회사가 여러 아이돌을 성공시켰다면 그런 역사가 있다면 거기에는 이유가 있다라고 본다. 누군가는 말한다. 대기업 기획사빨이지 대기업이라 다되지. 일리는 있지. 자본주의시장은 돈으로 움직이니. 다만 반대로 대기업 기획사에 들어가는덴 이유가 있겠지 그걸 알아야함..대기업이 뽑는덴.이유가있겠지. 수많은 아티스트들을 봐왔고 성공시켰는데 그런 데이터가 축적되어있겠지.
I noticed that Koreans really love Next Level. 😅
Yes 😭🤣
Yup most of them even think it is their debut song.
Amazing! ÆSPA 💅💜🌙💙🦋
ning ning's mic no sounds 21:50
she pointed at the earphone and mic many times
Yeah 🥺
Poor my bby😢
22:34 n2 complaining her mic was lowered during her highnote moment
Not mic but her in ear, she probably can't hear her own self and that's crucial when singing in an open and noisy place like that
Thirsty is my favorite💙💙💙
the live vocals 😭🙌👏👍
The blending of vocals in this part!! 21:17
❄️❄️🥰🥰
It's not ningning mic that had a problem guys, it's her in ear. She can't hear herself if the volume is too low and that's not a really comfortable thing to happen when they're performing in an open and noisy space like that, but yeah it's not the mic
Wow
7:58 SO Satisfyingggggggggggg, fighting aespa
Aespa is happier when singing live
The Greatest Diva Queen of kpop vocal 10 ranking 2023 update
1 Ningnig
2 Wimter
3 Giselle
4 Karima
5 Nayoen
6 Lia
7 Sullyoon
8 Lily m
9 Liz
10 Hanni
라이브한건가요?
근데 에스파 행사 처음 맞냐? 멘트 센스 좋네!!
라이브임
Seru sekali
Omg the camera are no joke 😂 y’all need to dance not hold a camera 😭 aigo if I were there probably out of breath already😂
if people understood how standing there like a droid ruins the energy...the performers feed off of the vibe of the audience and they give back as that feedback-loop occurs. Every single person recording is contributing to themselves being cheated out of what should be an amazing experience but instead is half dead.
Don't worry ppl were screaming and cheering for them while filming, It was so load that I couldn't even hear them talking.
노래하다가 중간중간 한양대, 에리카, 애드립 넣으면서 라이브 인증도 하는데 ㅂㅅ들이 진짜 그놈의 대첼라 때문에 립싱크 그만하라 이지랄 1위 앵콜무대를 보세요 거긴 거의 무반주로 부르니까 ;;;; 걍 음웜이랑 똑같음 진짜
For all MY in Hyper Line concert later please don't rise your phone so high like parents expectation yaaa. Please rise your phone until your eye level or max your head.
Thanks
Woaa woaaa 😂 😮
Black Mamba
Small winter : coming out and sing her part with powerfull voice
People : waaah waaah waaah 😂
plssss i'm laughing at all what the crowd is sayingggg 😭😭 they really can't believe aespa is in front of them
Haters ear were too spicy
카리나 이쁘다.
Why is it that Ningie always has the technical difficulties? I hate to think about it but are the purposely sabotaging her?
Chinese get out of here
애스파 공연 대략 몇 시 부터 몇 시 까지 한 지 아시는 분 계신가요????
거의9시넘어서 9시30-40분 이욤
Ini beneran thirsty nya live? It's so good
Iya mereka bawain semua lagunya live.
Mereka live kok, cuma ngeselin bgt suara MR nya lebih kenceng dibanding mic nya 😩
Imagine training & practicing & working for years to be a performer...and then go to perform live before an audience but instead find yourself in front of a 18,000-person camera crew just standing there like robots.
So weird.
Kpop music isnt like american hip hop where everyone is mosh pit and jumping
@@slimeboy5626 that is a fair point to make when it comes to what to expect to see for an audience reacting. Especially Korean audiences I've seen are pretty subdued.
However, I believe it doesn't matter what the performance or event is...When the phone is between the artist & audience, it creates a disconnect. Something as simple as eye-contact can be interfered with. Also, things like just waving arms or even applause comes at the expense of the clicks & views gathering devices.
Something as simple as a school play or choir performance - when recording - that device causes the person viewing to experience a level of being disengaged. It's different, no matter what.
Well ppl were actually singing along as well as cheering for them while filming and tbh isn't it obvious we would want to capture the moment as fans?
@@Tina-pt4zp Presumably by "capture the moment", you mean "get as many clicks, likes, and subs as possible"? The energy of the experience is degraded by everyone recording. If that's what people want to capture, then ok.
@@ShastaBean Not everyone's uploading these vids on the intenet hello? Different ppl have different ways of appreciating memories. I literally take pics and vids everytime something special happens bffr
카리나랑 윈터만 찍네 그 맘 알긴해...
OMG what the speaking?
팔 아프게 왜 찍고있냐?
유튜브에 누군가는 올리잖아.
바보들이네
춤 추고 같이 놀아야지
인스타 스토리용이지뭐
I’m not hearing girls, just boys🤔
360p 실화임?
they ruined energy by holding phones.
koreans sabotaging foreign members by turning off their mic. sigh what’s new 🤦🏻♂️
They're not turning down their mics don't worry, it's her in ear, she can't hear herself if the volume is too low and that's not a really comfortable thing to happen when they're performing in an open space like that, but yeah it's not the mics
Chinese get out of here
no sp
They got a lot of better in sp, not like others gg only vocus in sp, but their voice is terrible only scream in high notes and wispering in low notes. Aespa and nmixx live is the best in 4gg, they got the power to support their notes.
@@Aura-xp3gj itzy sings live at every concert, sp and singing live is the best of them all,there is none other than them
@@92liayaa singing live doesn't always mean they sing well
@@92liayaa nah itzy voice isn't good. Their main vocalis lia isn't better than gissele and karina. Their rapper not as good as gissele and karina too. They are dancing queen I agree with that, but their vocal is weak, if yeji keep screaming like that, she will have problem someday. I always ask why jyp not give 2 members of nmixx in itzy it will be balance them. If you talk about vocal jyp best gg is nmixx.
@@Aura-xp3gj I didn't say their vocals are strong, they're stronger when they sing live and aespa playbacks more if they're so good why do they sing so little live?
또 립싱크야?
걍 음원 수준이라 나도 립싱크인가 했음 근데 라이브~ 진짜 그만 해라
You cam hear, if they are sing a live!
Sorry to disappoint you it is LIVE!!
the most boring public ever
mr키고 하다 안하다
하는척
연습좀더해라ㅜㅜ
치열하게