DENE-YENISEIAN?: NAVAJO & KET
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- Welcome to my channel! This is Andy from I love languages. Let's learn different languages/dialects together.
Please feel free to subscribe to see more of this.
I hope you have a great day! Stay happy!
Please support me on Patreon!
www.patreon.co....
Please support me on Ko-fi
ko-fi.com/otip...
If you are interested to see your native language/dialect be featured here.
Submit your recordings to otipeps24@gmail.com.
Looking forward to hearing from you!
Thank you, Andy for posting this! I love it!😊
I wait for it 12 years!
Ты дождался, поздравляю
Уважаемый дед Пихто, Вы случайно не специалист по кетскому языку лингвист Кирилл Решетников (он же поэт Шиш Брянский) ?
@@ingvardruid7997 К сожалению нет, я совершенно другая личность. Однако звучит интересно, хотелось бы узнать кое что о его поэзии?
@@їжакоднако к сожалению ссылки удалились, которые я вам прислал. Тогда просто загуглите «Шиш Брянский. Митин журнал- В нежном мареве» , и ещё загуглите «Друг большой литературы- о Шише Брянском». Также в Википедии наберите «Шиш Брянский»(он же Кирилл Решетников).
@@їжакоднако это очень интересный поэт, пытающийся совместить несовместимое- высокую утончённую сатиру и похабщину с матом. В гугле вбейте, там очень много инфы о Шише Брянском. Особенно его сборник «Митин журнал- В нежном мареве» и отзыв о нем «Друг большой литературы- О Шише Брянском».
I think Ket is the only language that refer 8 as 10-2 and 9 as 10-1😂
Actually this method exists in Uralic languages and probably in other language families, even if not with different words. For example in Finnic languages like Finnish we have numbers (and their inflectional roots):
1: yksi (yhde-)
2: kaksi (kahde-)
8: kahdeksan
9: yhdeksän
Element -ksan, -ksän doesn't mean anything, but you can see that 8 is formed from the root of 2 and 9 is formed from the root of 1. So, it seems this means 'less than 10'.
Zulu has the same system, “isishiyagalolunye” (9) literally means “leaving one finger behind”. Yoruba also does the same but only with numbers past 10
Also present in Malayic and Sundanese (both Austronesian language groups).
Delapan (Malayic)/Dalapan (Sundanese) = Dua alapan = Two removed (from ten)
Sembilan (Malayic)/Salapan (Sundanese) = Satu ambilan/Saalapan = One removed (from ten)
Ainu: tupesan / shinepesan
I think this fact is evidence of something hidden.
In Navajo 10- “neeznaa” . In Czech language “nezná” seems “he doesn’t know”. Or in Russian “neznaju”- “I don’t know”.
Neezná can also mean “they (2) died.”
Navaho hóla means I don't know
I've heard Navajo naa' (here take this) is similar to a Romanian word meaning the same thing
In Standard Bengali : "Jani Na" and in my dialect : "Zani na" . We usually put "No" after the verb but in songs and poems we can put it before the verb . So "Na jani" and "Na zani" .
@@19erik74 Navajo word for take "naa'" is similar to Bengali word for take "Ne" .
At this point I really wonder how Proto Dené-Yeniseian sounded like. I’m sad that there’s no reconstruction yet 😭😭
Recreating a Proto-Dené-Yeniseian language is basically impossible, the two are so divergent that the only really "recoverable" words are a few cognates
Great video duo thanks for posting.
I think it's safe to say that it's a stretch to say there's a connection.
The theory says there's a lot of separation between the languages. However, they have in common some overarching features. Linguist Edward Vajda, the guy who studied and analyzed both languages for years, has stated that he doesn't claim they're the closest families between each other, but they have a connection. Posibly they have some other languages more related to each.
Does the Ket speaker's pronunciation sound somewhat russified?
It wouldnt be surprising since the same happens with other “native” languages
@@citrusblast4372 is the Navajo speaker's accent also Americanified?
Ya because most if not all Ket people speak Russian and for some the majority they don’t speak their language as their first language so it’s no shocked it sound like that
Yes I detected a Russian accent
I also detect some Turkic influence. It sounds a bit like Kazakh at some points.
Ket-Korean
1 굿 Gut
2 인 In
3 동 Dong
4 식 Shik
5 꺽 Kkeok
6 아 A
7 옹 Ong
8 인(남 벤샹 꼬) In(nam bensyang kko)
9 굿(삼 벤샹 꼬) Gut(sam bensyang kko)
10 꼬 Kko
this isnt korean counting lmao, a simple google search will show you the correct pronounciation
Excellent video.
Amazing languages
3 and 4 of Navajo sounds like 3 and 4 of Hainanese
Their 3-5 sound very sino-tibetan
@@kiyomiflash2513 2 as well, it starts with N-
Even 7 and 8 of Navajo sound Tai-Kadai or Sino-Tibetan
Yupik vs Greenlandic?
Could you compare Finnish and Mongolian 🇫🇮 and 🇲🇳, also Japanese and Even, the Nagoya dialect (if a volunteer is found), and the Estonian and Japanese 🇪🇪 and 🇯🇵, they maybe unrelated except for the Nagoya dialect if you compare with Japanese 🇯🇵?
Tlingit and Avar, please!!!
Would be interesting to see.
Yeah, please
Can you do Finnish and tundra yukaghir next? 😊
Perfect video!!
Amazed with this channel! You can find the native speaker of the language to do voice over on this youtube video
Fascinating unique, yet similar, languages.
FINALLY MY REQUEST !!!
Are these two related? I don't hear the connection.
Now about Sino-Caucaisian Hypothesis comparison?
(Basque, Chechen, Chinese, Ket, Navajo)
that's the full Dene-Caucasian not just Sino-Caucasian and also include Burushaski and Adyghe
Maybe a connection between Sino-tibetan and Ienisseian
Thank you so much!!
Could you also do languages like Quenya vs Klingon
Or Persian vs Afghan Dari
But, can I ask, where did the language of Navajo and Ket come from?
Navajo comes from the southwestern US, Ket is from central Siberia (Russia). Both of them come from the same language family and are distantly related to each other.
@@felixb6a solid link hasn't been proven yet, it's still only a hypothesis that they're related.
@@felixb6nope.
The only way these languages are related is that they are both spoken with the mouth.
@@tonyrodd6348 😅🤣
Love to hear this rare languages representing on RUclips
The word for six is somewhat similar
I believe in Dene-Yenisein Superpower 🛐
Создатель почему в приведённом переводе на Кетский язык "э стало ә" и почему появились удвоенный гласные? Почему просто написали "святыйтаӄ" вместо "къняй"? Где мягкий знак почти во всех словах и что такое "алгераӈ"?(Но спасибо за старание ведь это огромный вклад в Кетский язык и интернет.)
|||
The creator of why in the above translation into the Ket language "э became ә" and why did double vowels appear? Why did they just write "святыйтаӄ" instead of "къняй"? Where is the soft sign in almost all words and what is it "алгераӈ"? (But thank you for your efforts, because this is a huge contribution to the Ket language and the Internet.)
Did Turkic, Uralic, Mongolic, Japonic, Koreanic, and Native Americans come from same ancestors?
Yeah, just like everyone else
Dene-Yeniseian doesn’t include Turkic, Uralic, Mongolic, Japonic, or Koreanic languages
no, they don't
Japonic and Koreanic are isolated languages
That's language, but let's talk about genes. Mongols, original turks, tungusic people are north east asians, ANEA. Japanese are a mix, with a mix of proto-siberian, ANEA and ASEA. Koreans are mainly ANEA in genes from what i recall.
Navajp is the Best language in the world, but it should have its own writing system
It does. We teach it in schools. Based on English letters but with unique sounds. We've made it our own
I mean A non-latino system. Like cherokee but not This one
i would like for more of these videos including Ket! its one of my favorites (my channel name is coincidental)
How tf did these two end up in the same language family? They sound nothing alike
İ agree
Just like how Celtic or Serbian sounds nothing alike Sanskrit yet Sanskrit is their ancestor
@@ernstjung6234Sanskrit isn't their ancestor. Proto-Indo-European is
Altai languages origin?
"Ťááłá'í" was my favorite.
Finally
What is Navajo language?
A Native American language in South-Western US
It's an Amerindian tongue originating in the desert of the modern U.S. South West. Which, according to their oral tradition, was exported in the Northern direction during migration out of Dinétah within the last 2000 years.
Acehnese with Rade or Cham please
What is Ket language?
An indigenous Siberian language in central of Russian Siberia
A Native tongue spoken in modern Siberia originating from Amerindian migrations into the Asian Mainland from the modern U.S. South West. As per Navajo oral tradition speaking of Diné clans who severed from the community and migrated to the Arctic North, explaining the presence of Diné speakers throughout Canada and Alaska and an outlier in the Asian mainland from a migration out of the Americas within the last 2,000 years.
@@JonDoeNeace incluso es probable que los xiognu(ancestros de los hunos) y los jie descendan de los yeniseianos ...
@@CabradeMontaña69 They don't.
@@CabradeMontaña69 descenden de los hunos es en Hungary, Danube Swabia, etc. no en los Amercas.
Языки такие же красивые
Navajo and Blackfoot, silakan.
ket has big influence from russian, like "святый"
The creator wrote from bolda, it seems to me that my translation is more accurate, but come on. The saint will be - Къняй .
Russian itself has been obviously influenced by native siberian languages and vice versa
Navajo Sounds like aramic
I don't buy it, but, I'll be honest, I'm a "splitter" :)
Ket = Slavic Navajo
Please do rai language
What an Language 🤣 so Crazy
Im hungwie
Ket Cyrillic 😂