Rhaegar & Lyanna | But that's a sadder story.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
  • "Prince Rhaegar loved his Lady Lyanna and thousands died for it."
    I think this video was one of the most challenging ones I've done this year. Not editing wise, of course (because my editing is simple and not hard to follow through), but I feel so rusty with crossovers and manips that I honestly thought I wasn't gonna be able to finish it xD Even though I made 0 masking this was still hard to accomplish, and I feel somewhat proud that I got it done after all.
    This is my take on the mysterious tale of Lyanna Stark, the woman that unintentionally ignited a rebellion. If I had any doubts before that she actually ran away with Rhaegar rather than got kidnapped by him, editing this video totally changed my mind. I am now 100% convinced that they ran away together because they fell in love, there's just too much indication for that. The fact that Lyanna was a wild spirit and was unhappy with her betrothal to Robert, the fact that Rhaegar was well loved by his people, and that everyone seemed to think highly of him (including Ser Barristan who was a very loyal and honorable man). Littlefinger's weird little smile when Sansa said Rheagar had 'kindapped and raped' her aunt, Lyanna holding roses in her deathbed, symbolism to the ones Rhaegar gave her at the tourney and the fact the prince whispered 'a woman's name' just befor he died...I mean....duhh??
    And weirdly enough, the biggest evidence for me (what makes me truly think they loved each other) is how much Robert despises Rhaegar, even after all these years.
    Now this is where my headcanon differs a bit from the most accepted ones xD
    I don't think Robert was clueless about Rhaegar and Lyanna's relationship, like most people believe. I do think he suspected it, or even knew, that whatever feelings Rhaegar made known on the day he crowned her queen of love and beauty, Lyanna reciprocated, and when she was 'kidnapped' he KNEW that she had gone willingly. That's why he hated Rhaegar SO much. Now, of course thinking your beloved was kindapped and raped would make you angry, disgusted, blind with ire...but idk, whenever Robert was talking about Lyanna it felt like, more than angry he was almost...hurt?
    In my head, Robert knew Rhaegar and her were taken with each other and he hated Rhaegar all the more because he was able to make Lyanna love him when he couldn't. And he let everyone believe the prince had truly done those awful things to the Lady Stark so Rhaegar would be a monster in people's eyes as much as he was in his.
    But there's no indication Rhaegar was a monster, there's plenty of evidence, however, that he was noble, and kind, and that he 'loved his lady Lyanna', not really the crazy rapist profile xD And I don't believe even Robert was thick enough to buy that.
    Of course I might have gotten this all wrong but, well, we don't really know a lot about their story do we? I'm a helpless romantic at heart and my mind wanders to the most unbeliveable, heart-breaking, Romeo and Juliet-ish theories by default LMFAO.
    Let me know what you think of this video in the comments, and also, let me know your theories too. I love reading about them.
    THANK YOU FOR WATCHING!
    Cast:
    Adelaide Kane as Lyanna Stark
    Bradley James as Rhaegar Targaryen
    Henry Cavill as Robert Baratheon
    Deepika Padukone as Elia Martell
    James Franco as Eddard Stark
    __________________________________
    Fandom: Game Of Thrones (A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE)
    Pairing: Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark (+ Robert Baratheon)
    Song: • Vast - Winter in my Heart
    Coloring: SunnyVids

Комментарии • 3,8 тыс.

  • @ipromisethatserendipityisa9656
    @ipromisethatserendipityisa9656 5 лет назад +2491

    Imagine being the peasant who was called into war just because some nobles can't keep it in their pants.

    • @seanbussing8316
      @seanbussing8316 5 лет назад +134

      I Promise that Serendipity is a Lie “Ah shit, here we go again.”

    • @kji794
      @kji794 5 лет назад +90

      I Promise that Serendipity is a Lie imagine a novel written by George RR Martin about the peasant POV or something

    • @NostalgicMem0ries
      @NostalgicMem0ries 4 года назад +65

      funny but most wars started like that in our real history :)

    • @chrisbolland5634
      @chrisbolland5634 4 года назад +33

      He did it because he knew he was Azor Ahai, and 'Lightbringer' was Jon snow. The Third attempt at making a weapon which could save the world from the white walkers and the mad queen. The show did it horribly, but in the books, he will always be the Prince that was Promised.

    • @20_foot_burmese_pyth0n
      @20_foot_burmese_pyth0n 3 года назад +32

      @@kji794 Imagine being a Northern peasant😂
      Robert's rebellion: Guess we're going to war🤷‍♂️
      Greyjoy uprising: Fucking again? Who is it this time?
      Robb's war: A war? Again? Who are we--you know what? Fuck it. Let's go to war.

  • @alltheragegeorgepageakatheperv
    @alltheragegeorgepageakatheperv 5 лет назад +4900

    They should do mini-series spin-off about Robert's Rebellion.

  • @caroline-zm2fq
    @caroline-zm2fq 4 года назад +3406

    Always when I see someone talking about Rhaegar and Lyanna, just one person come to my head: Elia Martell

    • @oliviatrahan1967
      @oliviatrahan1967 4 года назад +183

      yes, ccarfico right??? I read up on her story and actually cried.

    • @JustAChinesePleb
      @JustAChinesePleb 4 года назад +217

      She was actually okay with it tho. Read the books, she didn't love Rhaegar.
      But she, as well as Rhaegar didn't know that the fat, idiotic cuck Baratheon would allow the killing of Elia and her children. Rhaegar also put Jaime to guard her, but he was too busy killing the Mad King..

    • @cassandramcbride7007
      @cassandramcbride7007 4 года назад +400

      @@JustAChinesePleb But in the book Rhaegar was not that hero loving husband. He was obsessed by fulfilling a prophecy of 3 dragon head. That was the reason that he approch Lyanna. Lets not confuse books and TV Show.. Even if she had some agreement with Rhaeger in Tv show, he did broke that, once he annul their wedding in favoring Lyanna. Not only he puts Ellia in a difficult situation, also the kids were humiliated and in danger.
      Instead of putting Jaime to guard her, his first move should had been remove Ellia and his kids, and send them into Dorne. Instead, he was busy Shagging Lyanna.

    • @mel-lo8zg
      @mel-lo8zg 4 года назад +140

      First off, Rhaegar did not leave Elia and her children behind in the Capital, they were at Dragonstone, untill the Mad King summoned them. So even if Rhaegar was with them they would have to return to the court because the King ordered them to. Secondly, Elia’s reaction to Rhaegar giving the crown of roses to Lyanna is purposely left out, we don’t know if she was angry or alright with it, but text evidence suggests that she knew about the prophecy (from Dany’s visions in HotU) so there is a high chance that she gave her leave to Rhaegar to have another child. Because the prophecy means saving the whole world, all humans. Another thing we know from Dany’s vision is that Rhaegar saw his son from Elia, Aegon as his heir and the promised prince. So there is no way he left them without ensuring their safety first. Maegor’s Holdfast has fallen twice in like 300 years, so what was he supposed to think, there was no place safer than the Red Keep. When he rode for Trident he left a Kingsguard, and the whole City Watch to protect them. An it’s likely that Elia had a Dornish host with her, though this is neither confirmed nor denied. And lastly after killing the Mad King, Jaime sat on the throne and waited, mind you Gregor and Amory Lorch were still outside of the Red Keep when he killed him. So he had enough time to go to Elia and the kids, save them since the Lannister men wouldn’t hurt Tywin Lannister’s own son. Elia was not the poor abandoned wife y’all want her to be, and Rhaegar is not responsible for her and their children’s death. Only Tywin, Gregor, Amory and arguably Jaime.

    • @ellieg.9595
      @ellieg.9595 4 года назад +53

      I honestly think that Rhaegar took Lyanna as his second wife (like Aegon the conqueror) and that Elia had a thing for Lyanna as well. Like if she didn’t, she definitely would’ve made her displeasure known (she was Oberyn’s sister. A Dornish woman).

  • @Ce_713
    @Ce_713 5 лет назад +4039

    I will never get over the fact Henry Cavill would be perfect as a young Robert Baratheon

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +63

      Yes he would

    • @gentlejello
      @gentlejello 4 года назад +143

      Cecilia Borja seeing him as geralt in the Witcher, he would absolutely make an excellent young Robert holy fuck

    • @aranzalara1214
      @aranzalara1214 4 года назад +6

      Cecilia Borja thissssssss

    • @JustAChinesePleb
      @JustAChinesePleb 4 года назад +21

      @@gentlejello He looks like an elf, not Geralt in witcher. That's what happens when you try to erase Slavic people with Anglosaxon white guys.

    • @ShubhamPatil-rl4jk
      @ShubhamPatil-rl4jk 4 года назад +49

      @@JustAChinesePleb lol he was perfect as a witcher

  • @veronicawilliams6861
    @veronicawilliams6861 7 лет назад +8782

    The true victim of their relationship was Elia Martell

    • @andrears29
      @andrears29 5 лет назад +84

      :(

    • @xaph5575
      @xaph5575 5 лет назад +385

      To be fair she was from Dorne so she might have been okay if Rhaegar kept Lyanna as his paramour. That being said she equally might not have been okay with that and also Robert and all the Starks would be furious.

    • @sansalannister3615
      @sansalannister3615 5 лет назад +551

      And her children. How could they killed children?

    • @chaimae3652
      @chaimae3652 5 лет назад +734

      @@xaph5575 No she wouldn't be ok with her husband running off with the daughter of the warden of the north causing a war and making her children's lives in danger she wouldn't be ok of her being hostage by her father in law
      She wouldn't be ok of her being humiliated by her husband who crowned another in her presence in public
      Dorne may be more modern than the rest of westerors but they have feelings too

    • @xaph5575
      @xaph5575 5 лет назад +10

      Chaimae ⵣ I’m saying that’s what could have happened I clearly say that she probably wouldn’t be okay with it. I’m just stating a possibility, even if I don’t think that’s what would happen either.

  • @Melissa-mn9vz
    @Melissa-mn9vz 5 лет назад +4286

    There's an even sadder story: the writing for season 8.

    • @TheSoprah
      @TheSoprah 5 лет назад +48

      why is there such a hype about downgrading s8? Cause the expectations were too big; cause we wanted a happy end for john and the dragon lady. Its game of thrones. you can never expect or predict anything.. you should know that after 7 seasons

    • @alienheston5748
      @alienheston5748 5 лет назад +15

      You must live in your parents basement to care that much about a script. I bet you signed that petition huh? LOL!

    • @Syberware
      @Syberware 5 лет назад +25

      @@TheSoprah one thing ive learned about the internet these days is: its REALLY cool/badass to not be impressed by anything anymore. Lmao....quite pathetic really.

    • @ComradeHellas
      @ComradeHellas 5 лет назад +3

      Salty tarDaryen fans

    • @revonz
      @revonz 5 лет назад +7

      The bells rang as the lannisters stormed into kingslanding killing everyone during roberts rebellion, the bells were heard with the people screaming and dieing, imagine this as a child, a girl traumatised because this was daenerys. Hearing the bells again brought her back to that time. The first time she feared for her life, knowing that people wanted her dead.

  • @Destiny_015
    @Destiny_015 8 лет назад +395

    This is the best VM I have ever seen on Rhaegar Lyanna. Not cause of the brilliant editing but cause of the possible proper rendition of the events of their story. It was not only Rhaegar Lyanna's story but Robert and Elia and Ned are as much important parts of it. Also I love how you took up on the side of Robert on the romantic grounds. He was not merely the third angle. And suffered great loss at the end of war. What's winning the war if you end up loosing what you fight for. " I can't remember what she lookee like " That's such a sad qoute . Also thanks tons for including Elia. What happened to her and her children was completely heartbreaking. Ned. Him loosing his sister and giving away his honor too. Eveyone suffered loss in this story. And this was a perfect cast. Absolutely spot on . Henry Cavill really makes the perfect Robert. Lyanna's was brilliant as well. Overall. This a masterpiece. Which I have watched uncountable times and can rewatch again and never get bored. Such is this beauty. Great work.

    • @morpheus2953
      @morpheus2953 7 лет назад +2

      u forgot oberyn and the mountain ,were also important

    • @omiorahman6283
      @omiorahman6283 7 лет назад +1

      CR7 Shady Ellia Martell you killed her murdered her children

    • @markolazic8875
      @markolazic8875 7 лет назад

      And all that looses and pain becouse Targaryan cursed bloodline

  • @whateverittakes5636
    @whateverittakes5636 8 лет назад +579

    damn, the transition from young Robert to old Robert at 01:19 and the quote "all I know she was the one thing i've ever wanted, someone took her away from me and seven kingdoms couldn't fill the hole she left behind" gets me evertime.

    • @mariomares6572
      @mariomares6572 7 лет назад +14

      Holy fuck same here. Manly tears may have been shed during that bit

    • @jamesmuhtar6586
      @jamesmuhtar6586 7 лет назад +6

      those of Robert' heart breaking words gets me everytime too

    • @marianpazdzioch3099
      @marianpazdzioch3099 6 лет назад +3

      Yeah, and the song in the background "I can't find all the pieces of my broken life", suddenly I feel really sorry for Robert

    • @onekingtoburnemall.7172
      @onekingtoburnemall.7172 6 лет назад

      First I thought that I heard Henry's voice.

    • @dersuddeutschesumpf5444
      @dersuddeutschesumpf5444 Год назад

      Worst of all, he (and everyone else for that matter) was completely convinced that she loved him and that she was raped and kidnapped by the mad king's son. That's why Robert killed him wo thoroughly and lives through that scene every night in his dreams. In the end he failed in his mind and was never able to recover from that, leading to him giving in to alcoholism and hedonism to fill the void

  • @danielstark8356
    @danielstark8356 2 года назад +261

    "Whoever Jon’s mother had been, Ned must have loved her fiercely, for nothing Catelyn said
    would persuade him to send the boy away."-Catelyn, A Game of Thrones
    Since finding out about Jon's parentage that line has become significantly more impactful, insightful, and powerful

    • @jeremyhuffman101
      @jeremyhuffman101 2 месяца назад +1

      Ned was so honorable that he sacrificed his own honor to uphold that promise.

  • @jamesmuhtar6586
    @jamesmuhtar6586 7 лет назад +3175

    "Even the seven kingdoms can not fill the hole she left in me". Heart breaking Robert Baratheon

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 7 лет назад +454

      What's even more heartbreaking is that he was in love with his idea of Lyanna, not with who she really was. Ned said Robert never really knew her, and saw her beauty but not the iron underneath.

    • @PinkDaisy57
      @PinkDaisy57 5 лет назад +134

      AnitaClue In Westeros people marry for alliance, for compromise at least he loved her for something. Even If Robert only loved her beauty then Lyanna was equally a shallow woman who fell in love with the most beautiful man, totally forgetting that he is already married and has kids.

    • @ctruth6185
      @ctruth6185 5 лет назад +78

      @@PinkDaisy57 Lyanna wasn't shallow she was ambitious. She knew that King Aerys' days were numbered. She knew Rhaeghar would become King and Lyanna wanted to become Queen of the 7 Kingdoms. This is the iron (ambition) that was in her all along that Ned spoke of.

    • @amitkenan3878
      @amitkenan3878 5 лет назад +14

      @@AnitaClue If it was like beauty and the beast, then Robert was Gaston and Rager was the animal

    • @amitkenan3878
      @amitkenan3878 5 лет назад +56

      @@ctruth6185 She did not want to be queen. She was as wild as a lion. She married Rager out of love

  • @jessekatsopolis7905
    @jessekatsopolis7905 7 лет назад +2831

    I need a Robert's rebellion movie right now!!!

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 7 лет назад +90

      Casting. Henry Cavill as Robert. Chris Hemsworth as Rhaegar. Rebecca Furgeson as Young Cersei (I'm sure they'd find an excuse to put her in the movie too). Georgie Henley as Lysa Tully. Bryan Cranston as Hoster Tully. Jason Isaacs as Aerys II.

    • @mostofanafis9203
      @mostofanafis9203 5 лет назад +6

      @Jack McLane Swordsking ser arthur?

    • @alexduran7108
      @alexduran7108 5 лет назад +4

      @@AnitaClue Please, where I find the movie!!

    • @haloumicheese
      @haloumicheese 5 лет назад

      BadLeo612 HAHAHAHHA best comment!

    • @samuelsteed3832
      @samuelsteed3832 5 лет назад +3

      Jack McLane They should keep the younger actors that already appeared in flashbacks, whilst Pycelle, Tywin and John arryn are probably fine

  • @danielstark8356
    @danielstark8356 3 года назад +343

    What everyone thought was Ned's greatest moment of weakness was actually one of the most honorable things he ever did. He was even more honorable then everyone thought he was, and that's saying something!

    • @Brandonhayhew
      @Brandonhayhew 3 года назад +5

      And his honor got him killed and lead his family to their tragedy

    • @danielstark8356
      @danielstark8356 3 года назад +7

      @@Brandonhayhew not really true. If Robert hadn't gotten killed from that boar things would have turned out very differently. There is no way Ned could have anticipated that. Robert had been out hunting countless times and killed countless boars without getting killed. Even if there were bandits he had freaking Barriston Selmy and the Hound. The chances anything terrible happened to Robert were super slim. Robert dying from the boar was just extremely bad luck, not stupidity that came from Ned's honor.

    • @Brandonhayhew
      @Brandonhayhew 3 года назад +2

      @@danielstark8356 I bet Robert was killed by a boar was that he was drunk. Cersei if she played a role, I can’t think how that would work?
      Ned informed Cersei of her secret. Maybe it was Ned impulsive honor or was it Ned still under drugs or something?

    • @seasoned_bitch_6932
      @seasoned_bitch_6932 2 года назад +2

      @@danielstark8356 if I remember correctly, it was cersei who actually killed Robert? I think varys told that to ned when he was in dungeon

    • @shareetz3154
      @shareetz3154 2 года назад +1

      @@Brandonhayhew ​ cersei purposely got robert drunk with some super strong wine while he went hunting. that’s how that boar was able to injure him. i believe cersei conspired with one of her lannister cousins, who was a squire or something in robert’s hunting party, to get the wine to the king. it’s been a while since i read the books though so i may be misremembering some details, but essentially cersei planned to have robert meet with *some* kind of accident that would kill him.

  • @ramdevsamudrala
    @ramdevsamudrala 5 лет назад +2273

    It's true how many thousands had to die because Rheghar choose Lyanna, But now many thousands are gonna live( if they win the war against Night King) because of Jon Snow, result of their love.

    • @bnice6442
      @bnice6442 5 лет назад +30

      If...

    • @user-yj9qq2zd9i
      @user-yj9qq2zd9i 5 лет назад +194

      Nope, he didn't matter at all against Night King!
      Lazy writing!

    • @alexandrixtargaryen6404
      @alexandrixtargaryen6404 5 лет назад +65

      Хришћанин и Толкиновац He United the people, and brought Daenerys, there’s no way they could have made it without her, as Arya herself said.

    • @user-yj9qq2zd9i
      @user-yj9qq2zd9i 5 лет назад +6

      @@alexandrixtargaryen6404 Who are your father and mother? I don't remember you in the lineage of Targaryens:) Are you son of king Aegon VI and queen Daenerys, who are your siblings, and what is name of your dragon?:)

    • @sayantikamondal6402
      @sayantikamondal6402 5 лет назад +59

      Arya was the one who saved everyone, Jon Snow didn't do shit.

  • @xplodedimsso6273
    @xplodedimsso6273 4 года назад +479

    This 3 min are more emotional and better then complete season 8...

  • @icw3is
    @icw3is 4 года назад +144

    Arthur fought valiantly, Arthur fought nobly, Arthur died.

    • @kishoree4457
      @kishoree4457 3 года назад

      Which Arthur.....

    • @icw3is
      @icw3is 3 года назад +9

      @@kishoree4457 was making a reference because they used Arthur from Merlin in this, it's a great show!

    • @haziq12ish
      @haziq12ish 3 года назад +7

      Noo stop it hurts

    • @sundramrai2865
      @sundramrai2865 3 года назад

      😂😂💖💖💖

  • @NeoEspada6
    @NeoEspada6 8 лет назад +147

    1:15 - 1:35 Best dialogue I think I've heard in GoT. The emotion behind Roberts words when he says "seven kingdoms couldn't fill the hole she left behind" is amazing.

  • @Furby2118
    @Furby2118 5 лет назад +85

    Seeing Rhaegar pass Elia in a TV show or movie would probably be one of the most silent scenes ever. Also Robert smashing his chest in.

    • @magnusthered4973
      @magnusthered4973 3 года назад +18

      Nah I be cheering for Robert saying this is what you get rhaeger for leaving Elia like that

    • @charlinethom1624
      @charlinethom1624 Год назад

      @@magnusthered4973 Robert cared more about that Rhaegar took the pretty face that was Promised to him away from him.

    • @midorialexandros
      @midorialexandros Год назад +1

      I know this comment is old, but still slaps. You could have heard a pin drop no doubt.

  • @seemakhan5270
    @seemakhan5270 5 лет назад +210

    Bradley James as Arthur and Colin Morgan as Merlin were Perfection! Miss the boys...such amazing actors! Loved Merlin series!!

    • @donnell.charles77
      @donnell.charles77 5 лет назад +12

      Merlin my number 1 favourite series. My favourite episodes are The Coming of Arthur season 3 episode 12 & 13 and season 4 episode 12 & 13 The Sword in the Stone.

  • @ImpossibleGirledits
    @ImpossibleGirledits 8 лет назад +1781

    THIS. this is a freaking masterpiece omg I'm so shook I can't even begin to describe how perfect this video is. the editing, the music, everything flows so well this is so poignant

    • @Rhaniel
      @Rhaniel 8 лет назад +4

      Can't agree more! This is what I feel too!

    • @fupopanda
      @fupopanda 8 лет назад +6

      Ummmh, the music is much louder than the voiceover

    • @ImpossibleGirledits
      @ImpossibleGirledits 8 лет назад +21

      +fupopanda NOBODY ASKED YOU, PATRICE.

    • @naelr3714
      @naelr3714 8 лет назад +17

      Bradley James would make an awesome Rhaegar and this video alone is an inspiration for a game of thrones side story, btw spoiler alert for those who haven't seen Merlin yet!

    • @Chicken_Soup890
      @Chicken_Soup890 8 лет назад +2

      I had a HUGE Smile to be hearing VAST, it did make me get lost in the Story. Stupendous editing not only of the video but of the song. Winter in my Heart.

  • @LuthienThePirate
    @LuthienThePirate 7 лет назад +387

    this is the best fan-made video I've ever seen...I'm in shock, it's too beautiful

  • @satorugojo6579
    @satorugojo6579 4 года назад +1712

    Jon Snow may have Rhaegar's blood, but his father will always be Eddard Stark.

    • @SirVesa
      @SirVesa 4 года назад +146

      “He may have been your father, boy, but he wasn’t your daddy.” Yondu

    • @flashcool524
      @flashcool524 4 года назад

      SirVesa agree!!!

    • @MusaMansu
      @MusaMansu 4 года назад +39

      @Zencreation what was honest about sneaking away with Lyanna like a thief in the night? Why didn’t he tell Rickard or Eobert out right?

    • @googleaisystemmanager9393
      @googleaisystemmanager9393 4 года назад +8

      @@MusaMansu it was stated she disappeared not that she was stolen, it could have been her running off, I don't know but I do agree that relationship could've worked(and his entire family would've been better off) if they made there love known.

    • @MusaMansu
      @MusaMansu 4 года назад +12

      @@googleaisystemmanager9393 Lyanna was 15 at most when she left. She doesn’t get to make that choice.

  • @Lp-eg7kz
    @Lp-eg7kz 7 лет назад +1257

    Henry cavill as young robert baratheon? SIGN ME THE FUCK UP

  • @TheLekhakiran
    @TheLekhakiran 5 лет назад +935

    I don’t know you guys but the quote:
    “I can’t even remember what she looked like, I only know she was the one thing I ever wanted”
    Makes it so clear that Robert never loved Lyanna. He was obsessed with the idea of this girl. This girl who was carefree and loved by many. He wanted her but not for the reason that he can claim as true love
    Edit: it’s been two months and I still don’t believe in the depth of Roberts love but now I understand Elia Martel's pain. No matter what she didn’t deserve that. To be raped while your rapist's arms drip with your children’s blood... nothing will ever justify Rhaegar and Lyanna’s actions not even Jon Snow

    • @yaboyed5779
      @yaboyed5779 4 года назад +66

      Priyanka Kiran exactly, he remembers the people he killed exactly, even their last words as his hammer crushed them, but not the “love of his life”🤔🤔🤔

    • @lillia244
      @lillia244 4 года назад +138

      In the books Ned even said so. "You didn't know her. You only saw her beauty, but never the Iron underneath." or something like that

    • @-AgungDwiPutraBarmo-B-
      @-AgungDwiPutraBarmo-B- 4 года назад

      You dont damn it, its same as the reason why you here the proove of true love

    • @yousofzaid872
      @yousofzaid872 4 года назад +66

      In comparison to maester aemon, even after like 100 years he still remembered what the love of his life (ollena tyrell) looked like exactly how she smelt and sounded like

    • @sweetsmita8798
      @sweetsmita8798 4 года назад +1

      True

  • @LavinyaAPash
    @LavinyaAPash Год назад +28

    I love Littlefinger's phrasing: "... Rhaegar CHOSE your aunt". He didn't say took, kidnapped, raped, and so on. He said CHOSE.

  • @EmanuelNadera
    @EmanuelNadera 8 лет назад +1664

    God damn Henry Caville REALLY FITS THE GOD DAMN ROLE!

    • @RachCoelho
      @RachCoelho 8 лет назад +151

      Now im dreaming of a prequel qith him playing Robert!! Thats everything they ever used to describ the young Robert on his glory time!!

    • @sandrawaterlily4740
      @sandrawaterlily4740 8 лет назад +152

      Someone contact HBO immediately. They are talking spinoffs right? This is the perfect one!

    • @jackwood7178
      @jackwood7178 7 лет назад +6

      Emanuel Nadera just dye his hair silver and boom you got a Rheagar

    • @erikabautista7072
      @erikabautista7072 7 лет назад +17

      Jack Wood but Henry is Robert here, not Rhaegar

    • @shanek3453
      @shanek3453 7 лет назад +1

      Henry Cavill for Robert and Stephen Amell For Ned?

  • @megsmacgregs320
    @megsmacgregs320 7 лет назад +218

    I just want to see Bradley James and Adelaide Kane play as lovers now and for Henry Cavill to be fit in there somehow. I don't even care if it isn't GoT related, I need this to become a thing somehow.

  • @asosisos659
    @asosisos659 3 года назад +27

    This might be the best edit of all fandoms in the history of youtube

  • @lalitox1516
    @lalitox1516 7 лет назад +717

    “How many tens of thousands had to die because Rhaegar chose your aunt?..."
    ='/

  • @dianaa748
    @dianaa748 7 лет назад +578

    this video is better than the few scenes where they showed Lyanna and Raegar in got

    • @MiddleEarthGirl75
      @MiddleEarthGirl75 6 лет назад +1

      ^^^ This!

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +13

      Can they recast Rhaegar and Lyanna as these two if they show up in the show again or if They do a prequel show like they said and cast them in it.

    • @hushamunnah7220
      @hushamunnah7220 4 года назад +3

      This is from Mary queen of scotts

    • @aranzalara1214
      @aranzalara1214 4 года назад

      Diana Araya Becerra I KNOW RIGHHTT! Omg

    • @tonymarshallgriffiths3302
      @tonymarshallgriffiths3302 4 года назад +1

      @@hushamunnah7220 ah, looking through the comments just to find out where the footage was from - thank you!

  • @gilbertdihayderich
    @gilbertdihayderich 4 года назад +50

    Gotta say Adelaide Kane would be perfect to act as Lyanna. So beautiful and bold, with a heart aching for freedom.

  • @MiddleEarthGirl75
    @MiddleEarthGirl75 6 лет назад +63

    This is honestly the best Rhaegar/Lyanna/Robert's Rebellion fanvid I have ever seen, and I've seen a lot! All the character playbys are the perfect choices and I'd kill for a full length feature film with Bradley James and Adelaide Kane as Rhaegar and Lyanna. They would be beyond perfect. My absolute favorite prequel storyline

  • @targaryenfire
    @targaryenfire 8 лет назад +140

    Okay, here it goes...
    Seeing this in my box today made me happy. Okay, not - because at first I didn't know it was about Lyanna and Rhaegar and Robert's Rebellion. But since I love your videos and your editing I was like - hell, I'mma click it. And then I see it. Little Lyanna. And I knew right away what this is gonna be about!
    Your editing + this part of Game of Thrones (which, in my eyes, is the best plot this sotry will ever have #sorrynotsorry) = perfection. And I knew that before I even watched it fully! And I was right.. oh, so right.
    Yes, it's simple, but it's what makes it so perfect. That you didn't overdo it! *I love it*. So glad that you decided to finish it. I can imagine you are proud of yourself, and really no masking needed to make it look realistic! You did a wonderful, breathtaking and mindblowing job here, honestly.
    I love how you showed the story no just from Lyanna's side or Rhaegar's or Robert's... but from each one of them which makes it full. As much as I love Lyanna and Rhaegar, I also can't deny that I somehow like the thought of Robert's love for Lyanna, so gald you included that, too, to make the story just as it was.. a love for one woman and hate between two men.
    Sorry for writing so much, but it's Game of Thrones.. it's Robert's Rebellion.. and it's your editing. I had to say few - *a lot* - words about this, because you've taken my breath away! I love seeing things anyway related to Lyanna as she is by far my favourite characters from the series.
    *jumps and dances happy*
    This has made my evening!

    • @AnneSoshi
      @AnneSoshi  8 лет назад +6

      you have no idea how happy this comment made me! thank you so much for your nice words, from the bottom of my heart. im so shshshsh ç___ç u are sweet

    • @toveluv
      @toveluv 8 лет назад +23

      would you consider making a video about Elia Martell? im sorry i just feel like people look over her

    • @jack-ym6ps
      @jack-ym6ps 7 лет назад

      wat is the actress's name

    • @theary29
      @theary29 6 лет назад

      I Love lyanna too
      She is my favorite ❤

  • @RachelAnnTaylor
    @RachelAnnTaylor 4 года назад +35

    I would love a spin off about this storyline. The whole Robert/rhaegar battle over Lyanna- a woman who is kept from us from most of the series. We seriously only get to really see her as she’s dying.

  • @JoonasObessedx
    @JoonasObessedx 7 лет назад +106

    jesus christ, I'm so thirsty for rhaegar being played by bradley james. brilliant video!!!!

  • @RenRen2453
    @RenRen2453 7 лет назад +1454

    RhaegarxLyanna for me is somewhat similar to ParisxHelen and the fall the Troy. Two people in love and willing to sacrifice everything for love despite the consequences and sufferings that follow. Doesn't make their love any less beautiful, just selfish, which is in its own sense beautifully human

    • @Queennatalie1999
      @Queennatalie1999 7 лет назад +47

      yeah probably GRRM was inspired by it

    • @moomimi
      @moomimi 7 лет назад +126

      Lalalalala2453 Very funny, so tragic indeed that they were fucking in Elia's birthplace behind Elia's back while the seven kingdoms went to war because of them. So tragic that he left Elia in the hands of his mad father, imprisoned in king's landing.
      So tragic that he annuled the marriage, making his children with Elia as legitimate bastards.
      So tragic that they caused thousands of lives to die from their actions.
      So many R+L fans makes me gag, how they fantasized the overglorified story of R+L and not looking pass what they did for their -love- prophecy.

    • @june7rose
      @june7rose 7 лет назад +44

      You can tell this part of the story was based on the Iliad, but I don't believe they were selfish. What do you call a man who slaughters thousands rather than let a fiance go to a man she loves more? Because that was Robert. And Menelaus.

    • @vahemartirosyan1268
      @vahemartirosyan1268 6 лет назад +1

      Nice

    • @parkeni424
      @parkeni424 6 лет назад +89

      june7rose Nah, Robert and everyone in Westeros were thinking that Lyanna was kidnapped and being raped. This is why her father and brother went to the mad king to free her, wich got them killed. If everyone knew that while the entire realm was at war, Lya was enjoying her time with her blonde prince, no one would have gone to war, and Brandon Stark and his father would have still been alive. Elia Martell too, she would have lived the life she deserves. And Lyanna and Raeghar would have been the enemies of Westeros, everyone would hate them, and think Lya is and idiot and selfish 14 year old, while Raeghar is a selfish and idiot cheater as well (the thing is that they are lmao). SERIOUSLY. Who would think that running away with a girl half your age who already have a fiancé would have no problems. And who would be able to enjoy their time with a blond guy while your father and brother are getting killed by HIS father and while the entire realm is at war. Seriously they both need a goooooodd slap.

  • @ginnyweasley5812
    @ginnyweasley5812 5 лет назад +79

    The amount of times I've watched this is unhealthy

  • @albamariacampillochiner5487
    @albamariacampillochiner5487 8 лет назад +719

    I though this was fycking real omg!!!! Crongatulations

  • @sybillestahl8646
    @sybillestahl8646 8 лет назад +441

    I am assuming that most of the people gushing here over Rhaegar and Lyanna are young, single, and childless, and that's why they don't sympathize with the wife Rhaegar humiliated, and who was ultimately murdered, along with her children, as his actions worked themselves to their conclusion.

    • @nicodemusfleur
      @nicodemusfleur 8 лет назад +120

      Exactly, because you can never enjoy anything fictional unless it perfectly parallels your real life! #sarcasm

    • @sybillestahl8646
      @sybillestahl8646 8 лет назад +9

      Ok, prove me wrong. Are you married with children?

    • @lenam.3834
      @lenam.3834 8 лет назад +96

      Hi! I'm 31, about to marry next summer, 10 years of relationship with my fiance and mother of a little girl of three. And I'm here enjoying this vid, loving Rhaegar/Lyanna and ALSO well aware of how unfair it was for Rhaegar's first wife. I do sympathize with her, but I still like Rhaegar/Lyanna which does not mean that I don't understand how problematic and selfish their decision to elope was (and not only because of Elia Martell and her children but because of the war it started and the consecuences for a lot of people: those who died in the war, catelyn, jon, robert, cersei, etc).

    • @jordanzappalal.b.d.4575
      @jordanzappalal.b.d.4575 8 лет назад +44

      lyanna is a dumb bitch the whole war was over her and she just let it happen she is the single worst most vile/dumb person in the entire story

    • @amandakesterson224
      @amandakesterson224 8 лет назад +41

      +jordan zappala how so? We know close to nothing of Lyanna's part except she bore a son of Rhaegar. Was she manipulated, lied to, did she know? What was she told? What did she know? Did he take her? Did he rape her? What made her go with him? We know nothing of her motivations or intentions. It's a pretty harsh statement to make with little basis. Even if we did, Rhaegar is the adult, the Crowned Prince, what on earth did he expect to happen?

  • @user-hk3iv3np3o
    @user-hk3iv3np3o 2 года назад +24

    It is a pure masterpiece, must be such hard work to create this inspiring and heartbreaking thing!

  • @Piratearicat23
    @Piratearicat23 8 лет назад +31

    THIS IS THE BEST RHAEGAR/LYANNA VIDEO I'VE EVER SEEN!!!
    Omg! congratulations!!!!

  • @Jowvich
    @Jowvich 7 лет назад +649

    Adelaide Kane is so perfect for Lyanna role!!!

    • @catherinekeller7184
      @catherinekeller7184 6 лет назад +2

      Alyanna Joan Ty thought so too

    • @a.sulejmani2856
      @a.sulejmani2856 6 лет назад +3

      Alyanna Joan Ty YOU ARE AN IDIOT BIG IDIOT WITHOUT BRAIN YOU ARE PATHETIC I SHUT YOU UP AISLING FRANCIOSI IS THE BEST LYANNA

    • @a.sulejmani2856
      @a.sulejmani2856 6 лет назад

      Catherine Keller YOU ARE AN IDIOT BIG IDIOT WITHOUT BRAIN YOU ARE PATHETIC I SHUT YOU UP AISLING FRANCIOSI IS THE BEST LYANNA

    • @jaimelannister2710
      @jaimelannister2710 5 лет назад

      Name that movie?!

    • @10hyossi
      @10hyossi 5 лет назад

      @@jaimelannister2710 reing tv serie

  • @ingridmatias9300
    @ingridmatias9300 4 года назад +10

    OMG, I'm obsessed with this edit! It's so beautiful, touching and heartbreaking! And I agree 100% with what you said in the description. There's to many evidences that they really love each other

  • @deepaka3668
    @deepaka3668 8 лет назад +11

    I love G R R M.... Raegar fought valiantly, Raegar fought nobly and died. Falling in love with a character is possible.. then i have head over heels for raegar.... gotta love martin.... his words.... they way he portrays the character.....

  • @jordanrivers5825
    @jordanrivers5825 7 лет назад +403

    I love Rhaegar but at the same time I'm mad at him. Elia and his children died partly because of his actions.

    • @parkeni424
      @parkeni424 7 лет назад +122

      Destiny Sulfridge I can't ship Raeghar and Lyanna because of what happend to Elia, we can understand Oberyn wish of vengence, his sister was humiliated, her children died in a horrible way in front of her before she get raped and killed, and all of this because of two people "in love" who want to live their stupid love story. Seriously if Lyanna went with Raeghar by herself I think I would hate her, I really wish she was actually abducted.
      I can't understand the people who want a spin off about their "love story" so bad, it'll be full of tragic death and injustice. Like little finger said, how many died because of Raeghar and Lyanna?

    • @jordanrivers5825
      @jordanrivers5825 7 лет назад +41

      Arden Depp Ikr? I feel like Rhaegar could have been such a great man if so many things hadn't happened. If Aerys hadn't been mad, if he hadn't been forced into his marriage in the first place, if he had never met Lyanna and kick started the war. He sounds a lot like Dany. But unfortunately he did what a lot of men do and chose a woman. I also blame Lyanna a lot as well. She knew he was married and had children. She knew she was betrothed to Robert and she knew that he was hot headed. As much as I love Rhaegar, it was his and Lyannas fault, I wish Rhaegar had lived and sought out Dany and Viserys. Dany needed her family.

    • @badshahkazmi7009
      @badshahkazmi7009 7 лет назад +35

      Daenerys Targaryen in my interpretation of all of this, rhaegar didnt exactly ran off and had a child with lyanna just for love, although it was a factor, but rhaegar was too noble and righteous to doom the kindoms with such conflict just for his own sake. it is to my understanding that rhaegar hoped to fulfill the prophecy of the dragon's three heads or the prince that was promised, and in that attempt he had a child with lyanna with lyanna being ice and him being fire, they literally had their song of ice and fire which was in a way jon snow who to careful speculation is going to play a pivotal role in saving westeros from white walkers
      so hold your judgements at the moment, we dont know that we might end up thanking rhaegar for indirectly saving the whole of westeros

    • @jordanrivers5825
      @jordanrivers5825 7 лет назад +5

      Badshah Kazmi good point, I've already had thoughts about this

    • @parkeni424
      @parkeni424 7 лет назад +13

      Badshah Kazmi Yeah you're may be right, he was described as noble many times, and he wanted to fulfill the prophecy, also the Dornish people are known at beign open minded, so maybe Elia agreed that Raeghar makes a third child with another girl. Well I hope so but I doubt it. And let's not forget that this is Game of Thrones, no one is good and pure.

  • @crabfoo7451
    @crabfoo7451 5 лет назад +224

    If rhaegar and lyanna just kept it in their pants and stuck with Robert and Ellia than maybe millions wouldn’t die and rhaegar could’ve been a great king....

    • @EzraDair
      @EzraDair 4 года назад +8

      Elia would kill herself before going with a bad person like Robert , It may even start a war between Starks and Baratheons

    • @crabfoo7451
      @crabfoo7451 4 года назад +26

      What are you smoking? I was saying that rhaegar should’ve stuck with Ellia and Lyanna with robert. Did you read what I fucking said

    • @ddfstar7588
      @ddfstar7588 4 года назад +6

      @@crabfoo7451 then the whole world probs die with the others. The books aren't finished yet tho. So who knows what will happen.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 3 года назад +14

      Yeah, but then, Jon, Robb, Sansa, Arya, Bran, and Rickon wouldn't be born and the great story that is Game of Thrones never would have happened.

    • @MusaMansu
      @MusaMansu 3 года назад +8

      @@EzraDair What exactly makes Robert a bad person before the Rebellion? He’d literally done nothing wrong.

  • @julioacceus253
    @julioacceus253 6 лет назад +249

    Glad to see that most people agree that Henry Caville would make a great young Robert Baratheon.

  • @mohrchenstarwars7239
    @mohrchenstarwars7239 5 лет назад +324

    Hey Arthur Pendragon in Game of Thrones. Welcome 😅😅🙊. More Merlin Fans here? *-*

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +10

      I'm here present

    • @Cleptrio
      @Cleptrio 4 года назад +10

      Möhrchen starwars this video is great, but honestly I’m laughing every time Arthur comes up. I can’t see him out of context.

    • @nataliekelley7942
      @nataliekelley7942 4 года назад +6

      I love Merlin!

    • @andywoIl
      @andywoIl 4 года назад +3

      Yeah ajajajja

    • @johnlewis2883
      @johnlewis2883 3 года назад +2

      I'm here

  • @nikolaoneill198
    @nikolaoneill198 7 месяцев назад +2

    By far the best GoT tribute there is, and it's been 7 years already...

  • @hailey5179
    @hailey5179 8 лет назад +49

    This is amazing and I do agree because Rhaegar from how he was described by everyone, was noble, I think they fell in love and ran away together, I don't think he raped her. I also feel so bad for Elia Martell and her children they didn't deserve any of that, and god, I mean I don't think Rhaegar didn't care for Elia not with two children but I think he just wasn't in love with her. I believe this was a bad situation in which at the time being in love was more of a problem as opposed to something beautiful. Love got both Rhaegar and Lyanna dead, Elia dead, her children dead, Robert miserable and then dead by the manipulations of a wife who he threw away the chance of love with because he was still in love with Lyanna. I love and hate Game of Thrones.

  • @superstar082100
    @superstar082100 8 лет назад +379

    elia martell deserved better than rhaegar, sure maybe they were in a loveless marriage but he had no reason to humiliate his poor wife in public. his stupidity and impulsive behaviour led to the death of thousands. i can't sympathise with him or even lyanna at this point. what they did was stupid. what's even worse is what happened to oberyn when he tried to avenge the rape and murder of elia and her children

    • @superstar082100
      @superstar082100 8 лет назад +25

      i hope later on we'll get a better explanation as to why this happened...maybe robert was abusive? but at this point it seems like just a stupid romeo and juliet love story

    • @hierophantpurple5163
      @hierophantpurple5163 8 лет назад +22

      +Shehzadi “sprincess0821” Aziz I don't think Robert was abusive. Probably insensitive, and also he might have been a cheater despite loving Lyanna. After all there was line he told Ned about loving to have sex with girls until Jon Arryn set him straight.

    • @sophiawilson8696
      @sophiawilson8696 7 лет назад +15

      Aziz the reason why Rhaegar gave Lyanna the circle of blue roses because he found out that she was Laughing Tree Knight. It later on that Rhaegar did humiliate Elia, but they hints that Elia Martell knew what Rhaegar doing and agree with it because she couldn't have any babies.

    • @natashanajam3499
      @natashanajam3499 7 лет назад +10

      it was realistic this kind of shit happens everyday men leave their wives for newer hotter younger women.

    • @katsurachan13
      @katsurachan13 7 лет назад +5

      Shehzadi Aziz completely agreed. felt so bad for poor ellia

  • @itzkirml
    @itzkirml 3 года назад +33

    Man I always get sad about Elia and her kids when anyone brings these two up

    • @bellereinette2938
      @bellereinette2938 3 месяца назад

      Honestly (& I say this cuz we still don't know the book ending though though Jon's parentage pretty much confirmed), With Elia being from Dorne I don't think she would have minded too much if Rhaegar took Lyanna as a paramour or second, let me be repeat, SECOND wife (since his a Targeryen they can do that!), where she would mind is what happend in the show where her marriage was annulled she cast aside & her children was put in danger.

    • @jorgebersabe293
      @jorgebersabe293 8 дней назад

      ​​@@bellereinette2938😂😂😂😂😂😂 If you think that about Elia, then you are as dumb as you look.
      -Elia would never agree to Rhaegar trying to recreate Daemon Blackfyre, whose Rebellion was caused because of the anti-Dornish sentiment against Myriah Martell and her son Baelor, a centuries old conflict that ended on Elia's lifetime. Her agreeing to Rhaegar and Lyanna's "affair" would be agreeing to put her children in danger. And if the Targaryens got unscathed, nobody in the realm would want a northern Daemon Blackfyre, specially one who has such a big body count before he was even born.
      -Dorne is sexually liberated in many things, but its still a class society. (Ex. Arianne would never marry Daemon Sand because he is a bastard, despite her genuinely loving him) And polygamy isn't among those liberties. (Maegor the Cruel had the blade of the Conqueror, the sword of the Conqueror and the dragon of the Conqueror and even he couldn't make polygamy stick.) In fact, polygamy is illegal under the Old Gods, the Faith and Jaehaerys I's laws.
      Your vision is not only boring as hell, but also utterly unrealistic.

  • @TheEscMoon
    @TheEscMoon 7 лет назад +8

    This is, hands down, the best edit of GoT i've ever seen, i have the video saved and watch it very often, i especially love when Barristan Selmy says ''rhaegar fought valiantly rhaegar fought nobly rhaegar fought honorably, rhaegar died'' close to the end, it gives me goosebumps. Thank you AnneSoshi for this STUNNING video!

    • @renegadexblackout
      @renegadexblackout 7 лет назад

      Matto Skum that was jorah, not barristan selmy

    • @TheEscMoon
      @TheEscMoon 7 лет назад

      RenegadexBlackout Very true, thanks for correcting me!

  • @taylorbeckett9686
    @taylorbeckett9686 8 лет назад +307

    I got a theory... what if Lyanna took Rhaegar.... mind blown

    • @lucashiroyuki9392
      @lucashiroyuki9392 7 лет назад +22

      such a perfect crime

    • @Quilgen
      @Quilgen 7 лет назад +1

      GoT 7x6 Sam read in a book, that they got married ;)
      Joh Snow is John Targarian, rightful heir to the throne ....

    • @danielkohl94
      @danielkohl94 7 лет назад +5

      She was 14 at that time. Gross.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад

      @@danielkohl94 no she was 16 and even still in those times that was the appropriate age for a woman to be married off.

  • @mozorellastick2583
    @mozorellastick2583 5 лет назад +4

    An even sadder story is elia martell being humiliated by her husband when he publicly declared lyanna stark as the queen of love and beauty, left her and her children and bastardised them to be with lyanna, and let them die when he ordered them to go to kings landing during the siege, with only one guard to protect them, held hostage by the mad king. Never got why oberyns revenge for the rape and death of his sister was directed to the lannisters and not the targaryens

  • @OrlanLupogan
    @OrlanLupogan 8 лет назад +810

    I just hope they will make a separate movie of the story of Lyanna, Rhaegar and Robert. :)
    It would be very interesting of what happened behind their love story, What was between Lyanna and Rhaegar, was it love or something else? :) It's not clear though.

    • @anycullen21
      @anycullen21 8 лет назад +28

      No one knows for sure, but Jon doesnt look to me as someone born out of rape.

    • @ScreamGaming484
      @ScreamGaming484 8 лет назад +39

      she didnt get raped

    • @anycullen21
      @anycullen21 8 лет назад +7

      ScreamGaming484 Exactly :D

    • @ScreamGaming484
      @ScreamGaming484 8 лет назад +2

      oh !! hahah I thought you said she was raped my mistake :D

    • @avitheshit
      @avitheshit 7 лет назад +33

      It wasn't love, it was two selfish horny teen cunts who destroyed and cursed westeros and its people for decades to come

  • @huuphuocle2633
    @huuphuocle2633 7 лет назад +828

    Robert made 179 accounts to dislike this video

  • @Phoenix_yang
    @Phoenix_yang 5 лет назад +108

    Poor Elia Marttel 😢

    • @dinisrino681
      @dinisrino681 3 года назад +3

      No one remenbers her 😞

    • @axellancaster4571
      @axellancaster4571 3 года назад +2

      Also her children, Rhaenys and Aegon:(

    • @Perkyclo
      @Perkyclo 3 года назад +2

      @@axellancaster4571 I was always stumped why on earth Lyanna would name her newborn the same as her new husband's jilted, murdered Wife's recently-murdered Baby son..... Like, no other names available??? Sad.....

  • @neerajrana2943
    @neerajrana2943 6 лет назад +593

    Game of thrones + reign + the Tudors + Merlin + padmaavat

  • @d.oertliche
    @d.oertliche 7 лет назад +409

    Can just take a moment and talk about Bradley James? He's awesome
    even tho I think he'd be more of an lannister than an actual targaryen.

    • @maissa1983
      @maissa1983 5 лет назад +21

      I loved him as Arthur

    • @andrears29
      @andrears29 5 лет назад +4

      Arthur💜 the one true king

    • @jivettefhaye6796
      @jivettefhaye6796 5 лет назад +2

      King Arthur😂

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +2

      I can see him playing either or it really just depends on the specific Lannister or Targaryen. Like if you said cast him as Aegon the Conqueror I would actually agree with that if it was a young Tywin Lannister I can see that too. It all really depends.

    • @AviNewatia
      @AviNewatia 5 лет назад +1

      I could see him as an alternate Jaime or maybe even Rhaegar tbh.
      Or yk bring back Merlin somehow, never enough of that.

  • @gracefulbaker5996
    @gracefulbaker5996 4 года назад +27

    Petition to make a movie or a mini tv series with the exacta same cast as in this edit Video. I love Bardley James as Rhargar !!

  • @hibahtashfeen756
    @hibahtashfeen756 5 лет назад +38

    The cast of merlin had some brilliant actors, more of them should be acknowledged

  • @skyfireanthem
    @skyfireanthem 7 лет назад +185

    I can't tell you how many times I've watched this video, I come back to it over and over and over because it really is just that good.
    I know you said you worked really hard on it and it was all worth it, this is the best R+L video I have ever seen and possible the best fan video I've ever seen, it flows perfectly, the casting is spot on and the music and choice of voiceovers literally make it appear as a cohesive story or real tv show.
    Absolutely amazing and I hope you are so so proud of this because it's spectacular.

    • @alexpaul5783
      @alexpaul5783 6 лет назад +4

      Krstn95 this. I watch this all the time! It makes me sad that this isn’t real. It’s such a beautiful video!

    • @sallygiangreco8834
      @sallygiangreco8834 5 лет назад +5

      Took the words out of my mouth

    • @Aspeod
      @Aspeod 5 лет назад +1

      feels same

    • @aranzalara1214
      @aranzalara1214 5 лет назад +1

      S A M E !!!

    • @ginnyweasley5812
      @ginnyweasley5812 5 лет назад

      Preach

  • @anabeatrizr3499
    @anabeatrizr3499 Месяц назад +4

    This cinematic values more than the end of GoT. For me, this is the real Rhaegar 😂

  • @wadnamj.2088
    @wadnamj.2088 7 лет назад +892

    The truth is Rhaegar left his wife and his 2 young children with his mad father during the time of war. And then he ran away with the other woman. Sorry, I can't see how it can be a love story. He got the best knight guarding his mistress but left no one to protect his wife and his own babies.

    • @Tertius711
      @Tertius711 6 лет назад +105

      HE left jaime if u read the books he asked Jaime to protect them but jaime failed because he killed aerys and saved the city and did nit make it in time to msave them

    • @a.sulejmani2856
      @a.sulejmani2856 6 лет назад +59

      Ryan Wong HE LEFT ONLY JAIME AND HE LEFT TWO KINGSGUARD THE WHITE BULL AND THE BEST SWORDSMAM SER ARTHUR DAYNE TO PROTECT LYANNA ELIA WAS BETTER PERSON BETTER WIFE BETTER SISTER BETTER MOTHER ELIA WAS BETTER IN EVERYTHING THAN LYANNA ELIA DESERVED TO LIVE ELIA DESERVED BETTER ELIA DESERVED THE BEST RHAEGAR SHOULD HAVE PUT MORE SECURITY TO ELIA THE BEST WERE GUARDING LYANNA AND THEY SHOULD HAVE GUARDED ELIA YOU ARE AN IDIOT BIG IDIOT WITHOUT BRAIN YOU ARE PATHETIC I SHUT YOU UP.

    • @loudggtv5544
      @loudggtv5544 5 лет назад +79

      In the books, he left three kingsguard to protect Lyanna brought two to protect him, and only Jaime to protect Elia.

    • @teamoon1681
      @teamoon1681 5 лет назад +2

      Согласен

    • @theary29
      @theary29 5 лет назад +53

      Elia was in the red fortress with a lot of guards, good or not and Lyanna was alone in a tower with only three, which however good they were, was not enough. Elia was also with her uncle.

  • @sanvalentine23
    @sanvalentine23 7 лет назад +901

    If only Game of thrones used this Raegar instead of the one we got in episode 7...

    • @maxwhd2832
      @maxwhd2832 7 лет назад +50

      sanvalentine23 ik bradley james woulda been great

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 7 лет назад +100

      We don't really get to see Rhaegar's face in that episode. How can people be disappointed in the casting when all we get is a few seconds of side-view? Give the guy a chance, for crying out loud.

    • @tttttttt7533
      @tttttttt7533 6 лет назад +91

      Rhaegar and Viserys are looking similar , so they needed an actor who looks like viserys.

    • @TheRaymundo13
      @TheRaymundo13 6 лет назад +61

      If they used this Lyanna instead of the one we got, I swear there are more beautiful characters than the Lyanna we got.

    • @whothefisalys
      @whothefisalys 6 лет назад +33

      sanvalentine23 we should have never been able to see his face, just his silhouette, casting rhaegar is impossible

  • @Rae-Annechu
    @Rae-Annechu 3 года назад +5

    I love how you combine merlin, the Tudors, reign and game of thrones together to make a great story

  • @JoshuaFagan
    @JoshuaFagan 7 лет назад +172

    First off: you were right. :) But secondly, can I just say how fitting this whole tragic love story is to the Game of Thrones universe? A key element of this whole world is showing the gritty consequences of classic fantasy tropes; e.g. Ned's relentless commitment to his honor got him killed. But one of Game of Thrones' most pointed critiques is of the whole concept of classic fantasy romance. The Red Wedding happens because Robb follows his heart instead of staying with the less appealing, but more practical, arranged marriage he had agreed to. Sansa was obsessed with marrying Joffrey until she found out how awful he was. Even Cersei was happy about marrying Robert, renowned as this brave warrior who had saved the Realm, until he staggers into bed with her drunk and calls her Lyanna. So it makes sense that Robert's Rebellion, the central event setting up the world as we're introduced it, was caused by this naïve act of love. Lyanna and Rhaegar were rapturously in love, which is beautiful, but that love cost much, including, as Littlefinger (who developed into a conniving monster because of his own heartbreak) says, "tens of thousands" of lives.
    That's why I love this storyline. It perfectly represents the Game of Thrones universe as a whole.
    Thanks for reading.

  • @supperesc
    @supperesc 7 лет назад +114

    I loved Merlin, I love Game of Thrones. You madam have made me feel the feels of both shows, splendid job but damn you.

    • @carlosweaver6763
      @carlosweaver6763 5 лет назад +1

      Marlon W. Also Reign. The girl shown as Lyanna.

    • @matthewhyland8129
      @matthewhyland8129 5 лет назад

      Marlon W. What’s the show with Henry cavil do you know?

    • @matthewhyland8129
      @matthewhyland8129 5 лет назад

      Carlos Weaver what’s the show with Henry Cavil

    • @carlosweaver6763
      @carlosweaver6763 5 лет назад

      Mirrored Jeremy the tudors. Pretty sure.

  • @thechangamire3495
    @thechangamire3495 2 года назад +82

    >Be Rhaegar
    >Humiliate wife in front of hundreds of people
    >Leave her when she's giving birth on an island
    >Abduct/elope with the betrothed of your cousin
    >Marry Lyanna, annuling his marriage with Elia and making her children bastards
    >Causing a war that killed thousands
    >Refuse to elaborate
    >Die
    Gods, I hate him.

    • @willnotkind
      @willnotkind Год назад

      He does the right thing, made John Snow.

    • @EmyEgy31
      @EmyEgy31 Год назад +2

      @@willnotkind he has son already , daughter ,brother and sister, those 4 taregyran, he didnt needs more.

    • @nutsfromberserk247
      @nutsfromberserk247 Год назад +3

      @@willnotkind and what exactly jon did? Arya killed night king lol

    • @willnotkind
      @willnotkind Год назад

      @@nutsfromberserk247 when the books stories ending, i come back here to say what Jon did

    • @nutsfromberserk247
      @nutsfromberserk247 Год назад +3

      @@willnotkind I'm waiting

  • @katie5998
    @katie5998 7 лет назад +111

    I believe that Lyanna was the mystery knight of the Laughing tree at the tournament, and when Rhaegar went looking for the knight (under the orders of his father) he discovered Lady Lyanna to be the knight. I also believe that he was there to make forced ally agents him in order to take down his fathers tyrannical ruling. Also, during the tournament it's said that Rhaegar played a song, a song that made Lyanna cry. I think that when she did cry, Rhaegar was surprised and interested in her, and when Robert teased her about crying and she blew up, I think it only made Rhaegar more interested. In her. I also think that maybe he also witnessed something between Robert and Lyanna, something not talked about, and he felt pity and outrage for the wild stark. Something like Lyanna telling Robert she didn't want marriage, and them getting into a fight in which Lyanna says something Robert doesn't like, and he ended up hitting her or something like that. I think that when he witnessed that, he became very saddened and heartbroken for her, making him feel a mass amount of pity, and when he chased after the knight and upon discovering it was her, maybe he asked why, and maybe she gave him an answer that surprised and baffled him, and maybe they made a deal to maybe get her away from her engagement to Robert. And in order to get her away from the engagement without embarrassing and damaging her family, it had to look like she was kidnapped by Rhaegar. But I believe she went with Rhaegar because se wanted to, and because she didn't want to be tied to Robert anymore, who was sort of boarding the line on obsession.

    • @tylerbaldwin3269
      @tylerbaldwin3269 7 лет назад +8

      though it was Brandon Stark who teased Lyanna, not Robert.

    • @Watdefakkel
      @Watdefakkel 7 лет назад +12

      It was Benjen Stark.

    • @tylerbaldwin3269
      @tylerbaldwin3269 7 лет назад

      You are correct, couldn't think of the name

    • @sophiawilson8696
      @sophiawilson8696 7 лет назад +14

      ps Lyanna knew what was Robert about he may loved her, but she knew that will NOT stop him from cheating.

    • @johnnyskinwalker4095
      @johnnyskinwalker4095 6 лет назад +1

      Katie that's interesting. More interesting than just "Raegar and Lyanna loved each other".

  • @jasminecrawford42
    @jasminecrawford42 8 лет назад +82

    I hate that I think Henry Cavill is perfect for young Robert and Brandon Stark lol anyways this is the best rhaegar, lyanna vid I have seen

  • @hussainhasan2968
    @hussainhasan2968 Год назад +11

    All these years later, I return to this video. Maybe the greatest love story that never happened and yet one that had to happen for the prince that was promised

  • @chozenheart
    @chozenheart 7 лет назад +50

    Why has this amazing story Martin has created in his head taken over my life?

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 7 лет назад

      Are you on the fan site? If not, it hasn't truly taken over your life...yet.

    • @a.sulejmani2856
      @a.sulejmani2856 6 лет назад +1

      Take this L YOU ARE AN IDIOT BIG IDIOT WITHOUT BRAIN YOU ARE PATHETIC I SHUT YOU UP THIS IS STUPID STORY THEY ARE BAD COUPLE ONLY A STUPID LIKE YOU CAN SHIP THEM ELIA IS GREAT CHARACTER SHE MAKES GREAT COUPLE WITH RHAEGAR LYANNA IS A COWARD STUPID GIRL LIKE YOU SHE DESERVED WHAT HAPPENED TO HER

    • @abrown6789123
      @abrown6789123 5 лет назад +5

      @@a.sulejmani2856 Elia and Rheagar were friends at best. They cared for each other but they weren't in love. You have a right to your opinion but you can't insult and freak out on people who don't agree.

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 5 лет назад

      @@a.sulejmani2856 stop being a troll. Take your caps lock off and write like a grown up. Elia is a great character? What books are you reading or show are you watching? She's barely mentioned.

  • @KHH595
    @KHH595 6 лет назад +114

    I LOOOOVE Henry Cavill as a young Robert Baratheon! Also, Bradley James as Rhaegar Targaryen would have been a good choice. I'm not sure who the actor was that actually played Rhaegar but he was not what I had been picturing. This is great. :)

  • @lyapendragonn
    @lyapendragonn 5 лет назад +154

    me, seven years ago: omg true love, they deserved to be happy 😭
    me, now: THEY ARE MONSTERS god really how many people died for them -.-

    • @fixlovenbarath1343
      @fixlovenbarath1343 3 года назад +2

      😂All coz of mad fucking King😪

    • @charlinethom1624
      @charlinethom1624 Год назад +1

      It's meant to be a Shakespearen tragedy, think Romeo and Juliet.

  • @TastyxLove
    @TastyxLove 8 лет назад +5

    this is what I call a *true masterpiece* - I can't even imagine *how much* effort and love you've put into this. thank you so much for such a beautiful work of art! I love this from the bottom of my heart! ♥♥

  • @cecelight
    @cecelight 8 лет назад +61

    I have major feels. OMG. The cast is perfect. Bradley James would be a perfect Rhaegar Targyen :O

    • @radovanjankovic7797
      @radovanjankovic7797 7 лет назад

      RebelY he will need silver hair

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 7 лет назад

      Chris Hemsworth would be the perfect Rhaegar Targaryen, and more of a match for Henry Cavill's Robert Baratheon.

    • @MiddleEarthGirl75
      @MiddleEarthGirl75 6 лет назад

      Chris is too muscle-y. Despite winning the tourney, he was known more for a peaceful man who played music rather than a fighter so to speak.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +1

      @@radovanjankovic7797 there's platinum blonde hair dye at Sally's Beauty Supply on sale for 50% off. Bradley you better start making your way there.

  • @romivr03
    @romivr03 7 месяцев назад +1

    So we have king arthur as rhaegar, henry as robert, uther Pendragon as the mad king and mary stuart as lyanna. Love it

  • @cristanwilliams4943
    @cristanwilliams4943 6 лет назад +477

    I am sorry but I could never like them too together. Maybe because I always think about Elia Martell when I see them together and how her kids was killed and she was raped and killed. Like did
    Rhaegar not even think about his WIFE and how she was going to be affected . What he thought she going to be safe with his crazy father?! But that is just my opinion and I just really want some more good videos about Elia and her story because I think she deserves it after all the pain she went through.

    • @AnitaClue
      @AnitaClue 5 лет назад +55

      Oddly enough, Elia and the children were safe with Rhaegar's crazy father. Aerys never harmed a hair on their heads. It was Tywin Lannister who ordered the deaths of those children. Rhaegar had no reason to believe his family would be in danger, or that a war would start. Still...not a nice thing to do, and yes I feel bad for Elia too.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +14

      Exactly and he actually tried to get them to go to Dragonstone but the Mad King wouldn't let them leave which led to Tywin ordering their deaths. Rhaegar was trying to do the right thing in the end it just didn't work out. He wanted both his families safe. And if things turned out differently and they lived along with Lyanna, Rhaegar would have tried to make peace with Robert or at the very least convince Ned not to let Robert kill him with Lyanna's help.

    • @alleycat4312
      @alleycat4312 5 лет назад +5

      Elia cheated with Arthur Dayne. Neither of her children were Rhaegar's. Varys knew. Varys tells Tyrion Elia cried a certain name before she died. The name is Arthur

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад

      @@alleycat4312 wait seriously? how do you know?

    • @grievousbutworse4085
      @grievousbutworse4085 5 лет назад

      @@alleycat4312 how

  • @Ashley_e
    @Ashley_e 8 лет назад +134

    do you read the books? this great. my dream scene is Rhaegar singing, and lyanna crying to how pretty it was.

    • @crashboy0
      @crashboy0 7 лет назад +34

      She didn't cry because the song was pretty but because the song was so very sad...

    • @Just_Joro
      @Just_Joro 7 лет назад +1

      what's name of the song ?

    • @vanderburgvv
      @vanderburgvv 7 лет назад +1

      Георги Янчев vast- winter in my heart

  • @jaderandrade4924
    @jaderandrade4924 5 лет назад +6

    this is not a love story, it is a tragic story and should be seen as such. Elia Martell was the only one for whom Rhaegar should have faced a war. Woman and mother dedicated and passionate.

  • @l_baez
    @l_baez 8 лет назад +120

    OMG Bradley would made a really good Rhaegar! Totally love the videoo.
    I really think that Uther could have a name like Mad King, after all he kill a lot of people.
    PS: Thanks for remember me the Merlin's end, I'm still crying for it.

  • @sofiahshakeel4641
    @sofiahshakeel4641 7 лет назад +5

    I've been watching this on repeat and crying. this is a masterpiece you are amazingly talented.

  • @SAMANTHAPERKINS
    @SAMANTHAPERKINS 2 года назад +4

    Doesn't Rhaegar and Lyanna's hyped love story mirror that of Charles and Camilla? I know the assumption is very weak and highly disputable. But the one who suffered the most was the person who was sidelined because of these two infamous lovers. Liana Martell as well as Princess Diana suffered throughout their marriage, bore heirs to the Royal throne, but still died for no fault of their own. Elia Martell's life was like a torn page whose life had been brutally ripped because of the devastating desires of others.

  • @sassyb58
    @sassyb58 5 лет назад +14

    Interesting! Never would have thought to use these shows to portray GoT. Works really well and love Arthur and Mary so it's really effective. We never get emotionally involved with the characters bc we dont get to know them but anyone whose seen Merlin or reign? can easily transfer these emotions to the Got characters!
    Interesting! And Good work editing them to play against each other.

  • @lorenapatrignoni8991
    @lorenapatrignoni8991 8 лет назад +5

    I've seen this video about 1000 times. I love it. It's so perfectly done.

  • @lonestarwolfentertainment7184
    @lonestarwolfentertainment7184 4 года назад +4

    The true victim of this relationship is Ned Stark, because of Lyanna’s selfishness the most responsible and dutiful of the Starks couldn’t have the happiness he deserved with the woman he was in love with (Ashara Dayne who would have been a valuable asset to The North due to her experience at Court) and instead ended up with the Lady Stoneheart who would go on to cause the near extinction of one of the oldest Houses in Westeros. Gods I hate R+L and I really really hope Jon Snow is not the product of these two horrible human beings in the books.

  • @dopeflamingo
    @dopeflamingo 5 лет назад +46

    I think james bradley would've been nice if he plays the young jaime lannister in the prequel... just saying.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад +9

      FINALLY! someone with a brain around here. Although, I can still see him as a Targaryen, but I would much rather see him as Jaime... But who'd play young Cersei?

  • @aggieherondale-edits
    @aggieherondale-edits 8 лет назад +5

    OMFG!!! I'M CRYING IN HOW BEAUTIFUL IT IS!
    Rheagar&Lyanna are my otp!!
    I love your dreamcast!

  • @donkissph
    @donkissph 3 года назад +1

    it has been 5 years, and keep coming back here. its the best

  • @charlinethom1624
    @charlinethom1624 7 лет назад +76

    Now that's Lyanna spot on!
    I'll be honest I was quite disappointed of shows casting for this character...
    Anyway great video I really love your editing.

    • @diegocobosanchez4373
      @diegocobosanchez4373 6 лет назад +2

      +Charlie Thom
      I wasn't disappointed with the Got casting at all, the actress was indeed very beautiful and excellent acting on Lyanna's deathbed.

    • @struggleskywalker1025
      @struggleskywalker1025 5 лет назад

      Yeah

  • @graceramey4443
    @graceramey4443 3 года назад +33

    Wish people would quit calling Rhaegar and Lyanna's relationship as something "they couldn't keep in their pants." They were selfish for love while everyone else was selfish for a throne. Maybe people died because power causes greed.

    • @Lite727
      @Lite727 3 года назад +2

      We don’t know what exactly happened at Harrenhaal, and we will never know exactly until Roberts Rebellion is explored in full depth. I have a theory that the Azor Ahai prophecy drove Rhaegar made into manipulating Lyanna into a forced marriage and abandoning his wife and kids.

    • @Bardhyl01
      @Bardhyl01 2 года назад +9

      Rhaegear was 22-23 while Lyanna was 14 when they meet. You'd expect the mature crown prince to know what sort of a vile beast his father is, and not disappear from sight for a year while they waged war only to appear to get smacked around by Bobby B. He's a delusional kid whose personality revolves around prophecies. Reality smacked him right in the face curtsy of Bobby B

    • @someonelol9999
      @someonelol9999 8 месяцев назад +1

      They were selfish and killed thousands. End of story. Disgusting

  • @DollarBillMuayThai
    @DollarBillMuayThai 3 месяца назад +1

    It’s 2024 and I still come back to this absolute masterpiece

  • @Vampirewolf7lover
    @Vampirewolf7lover 7 лет назад +31

    Todo acerca de este vídeo es perfecto. Lo he visto unas 10 veces y no me canso. Los actores que eligió la persona que lo creo encajan a la perfección en los roles, la música es fantástica y los efectos son dignos de aplauso. Una obra de arte y solo puedo decir, GRACIAS.

  • @mimplech
    @mimplech 5 лет назад +8

    I will NEVER get tired of watching this video, thank you so much for doing it!

  • @Maxspeedfree27
    @Maxspeedfree27 2 года назад +7

    How come no one is mentioning how Deepika Padukone as Elia is PERFECT !

  • @Melody51433
    @Melody51433 8 лет назад +191

    If Henry Cavill was Robert Baratheon and I was Lyanna, I would NEVER have picked Rhaegar. Coz Cavill is hot damn...

    • @madz5560
      @madz5560 7 лет назад +52

      Yusra Nadir but she hated his attitude. She hated the fact that he slept with innumerable women.

    • @katsurachan13
      @katsurachan13 7 лет назад +14

      Yusra Nadir yeah the only off putting thing would have been that he was sleeping around :/

    • @satyagolu
      @satyagolu 7 лет назад +8

      Mαddιє n lyanna liked a married man lol

    • @181diane
      @181diane 7 лет назад +8

      yeah but in bookcanon apparently Rhaegar was a beautiful man, loved by his people. Cersei even thought when she saw him "Had any man ever been so beautiful?"-so as much as I love Arthur (from Merlin), he doesn't do justice to beautiful book Rhaegar lol I hope they find a really handsome actor to depict him if they make any flashbacks in GoT!

    • @shahrukh8654
      @shahrukh8654 7 лет назад +2

      Yusra Nadir in westros u dont have to pick ur husband. There u are betrothed for the sake of alliances :)

  • @joapinero9401
    @joapinero9401 7 лет назад +18

    A m a z i n g
    Brutal la secuencia de escenas, personajes y sonido. Felicidades para el creador.

  • @TruthisBeauty2007
    @TruthisBeauty2007 2 года назад +10

    So original and well-done! You combined five (or even six?) characters from different shows together and they all blend together as if they exist in the same world.

  • @Ceibhfhionn
    @Ceibhfhionn 5 лет назад +11

    This gives me chills every time. I love the dialogue!