still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
its funny how mental you are everglowup to still think using scripts for your liikes and alts to defend urself would somehow undermine the eviidence confirming that you are narsuun1
Winter’s tone really pierces through and Ningning’s tone is sounds effortless and floating. They definitely are the main vocalists of their generation no one can convince me otherwise. Karina definitely is an all rounder. How can people sleep on her talents just because she’s pretty?! Giselle serves as the balance acting as the line that connects everyone and makes the whole group complete.
카리나 윈터 닝닝 고음 파트야 말할 것도 없이 잘했고 마지막에 지젤 저음 파트가 진짜 화룡점정이네. 완성된 노래 들으면서 이 노래가 훨씬 더 매력적으로 느껴졌던게 저음 파트 때문이었는데 진짜 넷이 목소리합 너무 좋네. 윈닝이가 고음 카랑카랑 지젤이랑 카리나가 저음 동글동글.
still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
im convinced ningning is a recording wizard. every behind the scenes i watch of her shes just in her prime when theyre recording. (they all are amazing but she just blows my mind in the recording booth!)
still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
As a vocalist i am very impressed with Giselle’s singing voice, she needs to have more singing parts in the future songs. Im a fan of all but her recording session here seems so short compared to the others.
Live my life = “we go “ vibe + “life is too short” core. Powerful vocal, perfect tone, and wide range of notes! Winter ❄️ well done! She is an amazing singer for sure 🐶👍
Obsessed with the layering and adlibs, this has got to be my favourite BTS Recording because of it. The song really showcases the girls’ wide range of vocals in the best possible way. Especially got chills listening to Giselle’s part here 10:33 wow 😭
Just saw the RV recording and came here. RV has mastered and evolved in singing. Aespa are such potential and strong juniors. Love Aespa and Red Velvet.
I like RV recording more because they show layer by layer of harmonies so its fun. But from aespa's recording, we can see they have really strong and solid vocal (maybe more than rv )
@@breadapple3552 Its roughly about the same on an individual level with Aespa having the slight edge simply bc Ningning vocal wise I believe is stronger than Seulgi by like one range perhaps. however as a group they're still behind RV bc Joy/Irene aren't completely matched by Karina despite Seuldy and ningwin canceling each other out. Gigi and Yeri are the balancing acts of their respective groups thts why I didnt mention them as much.
BOL4 released a song featuring GISELLE called ‘LIPS.’ Please go stream ‘LIPS SM refused to support GISELLE’s first feature. Let’s support her and make SM even more mad!
와 카리나 고음 시원하게 올라가는 거 보고 1차 놀람, 윈터 목소리 개시원시원해서 2차 놀람, 상상도 못한 닝닝 목소리가 이 노래에 너무 잘 어울려서 3차 놀람, 랩 담당 지젤 음역대 높아서 고음 쉽게 부르는 거 보고 4차 놀람 ㅋㅋㅋ 어떻게 멤버들 한명 한명 나올 때마다 이렇게 놀라움의 연속이냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Since noone as in NOONE is complimenting NINGNING in the comment section. I just want you to know NINGNING that you really did a great job and your tone is so beautiful, your adlibs are all chef's kiss 🦋
BOL4 released a song featuring GISELLE called ‘LIPS.’ Please go stream ‘LIPS SM refused to support GISELLE’s first feature. Let’s support her and make SM even more mad!
I like RV recording more because they show layer by layer of harmonization so its fun. But from aespa's recording, we can see they have really strong and solid vocal (maybe more than rv )
Okay, Winter wants us to sing that part with the highest note to relieve stress. Girl, we don't need to do that, we just need to listen and look at you to be stress free.
![[R(ae)cord] aespa 에스파 ‘Whiplash’ Recording Behind The Scenes](/img/1.gif)
개인적으로 카리나가 고음하는 부분이 너무,,, 울컥하고 좋다 😢 뭔가 벅차오르는 느낌이 잘 느껴지는듯
진짜 락커같은 소리가 나서 좋음
락에 잘 어울리는 음색같아요
인생에 정답이란 없어 파트도 ㄹㅈㄷ
카리나가 힘차고 노력하며 일어서는 곡 분위기랑 너무 어울리고
윈터는 그냥 음색이 너무 아름다움ㅜ
닝닝은 듣자마자 고음 너무 쉽게 내서 놀람 ㄷㄷ
지젤은 진짜 잔잔하다 저음 듣는데 포근하고 편함
이게... 4인 4색..??!
카리나 팬이시구나ㅎ
WINTER HIT ALL THE NOTES EFFORTLESSLY and more importantly she sounds amazing in all range~~ She is really the vocal wonder of SM!
that's why she become the main vocal because she improved so much
still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
its funny how mental you are everglowup to still think using scripts for your liikes and alts to defend urself would somehow undermine the eviidence confirming that you are narsuun1
using your alts and scripts and copy pasting more comments meaning you are running away and with doing so you further admit that you are narsuun1.
pruit buddy you gotta stop making alts to support yourself
3:32 What a very unique voice... makes me want to replay this part again and again... Winter's very addictive heavenly voice ❤❤❤
Winter’s tone really pierces through and Ningning’s tone is sounds effortless and floating. They definitely are the main vocalists of their generation no one can convince me otherwise. Karina definitely is an all rounder. How can people sleep on her talents just because she’s pretty?! Giselle serves as the balance acting as the line that connects everyone and makes the whole group complete.
live my life 이 노래의 주인공은 카리나 같음 카리나 특유의 쇠목소리가 락 느낌의 노래와 너무 찰떡임
ㄹㅇㄹㅇ ㅠㅠ
오 내가 하고싶은 말이다
특히 윈터 닝닝은 고음 너무 쉽게 쇽올려서 감동?적이고 그런게없는데 카리나는 카랑카랑하게 고음될듯안될듯 이렇게 올리니까 '삶의주인공은나고 행복할거야 난' 라는 립마랖의 노래분위기랑 너무 감동적으로 어울림
닝닝 발성 진짜 탄탄하다고 느꼈는데 역시 고음 개잘올라감.. 게다가 여유롭게 음색까지 예쁘게 섞어서 하는거봐..미치겠다너무멋있다....❤❤
아니 이걸 풀어 준다고? 두 타이틀 다음으로 제일 듣고 싶었던 레코딩인데 에스엠… 감사합니다👽👽
이번에 뮤비 나와서 푼 것 같아용ㅎㅎ 빨리 다른 수록곡 뮤비랑 레코딩 나왔으면
에스파 팬도 아닌데 맨날 본다... 역시 에스파는 다르구나...개좋다...
그거 입덕부정기에요
지금쯤 입덕하셨을듯
I love how giselle always in dim led lights when recording. Shes getting into her vibe!
이노래 진짜 개높아…. 카리나 음색 너무좋다
Ningning’s voice is such a chefs kiss especially her falsetto.. You’re doing an amazing job
Wooahh Gigi and Karina's low notes 🔥. Gigi's high notes are also stable. Winter's voice is beyond doubt. Ningning's falsetto is very calming ❤❤❤
카리나 윈터 닝닝 고음 파트야 말할 것도 없이 잘했고 마지막에 지젤 저음 파트가 진짜 화룡점정이네. 완성된 노래 들으면서 이 노래가 훨씬 더 매력적으로 느껴졌던게 저음 파트 때문이었는데 진짜 넷이 목소리합 너무 좋네. 윈닝이가 고음 카랑카랑 지젤이랑 카리나가 저음 동글동글.
I love Giselle’s part🥹 when she said: life’s too short, no more I don’t care… SLAY
민정이 목소리가 그냥 너무 좋아요..
Winter is so talented I love her sm
0:08 KARINA
3:07 WINTER
6:29 NINGNING
10:30 GISELLE
I am glad Live My Life getting so much love, great B Side!
still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
요새 슈퍼노바 아마겟돈보다 이 노랠 더 들음 이번 앨범 수록곡 진심 1티어
Winter and Nigning voice are amazing..
Whenever I hear Winter singing, I always get chills
윈터님은 진짜 매미란 별명 잘 지으신듯
매미가 한마리가 아니라 여러마리가 들어있음
난 개인적으로 저음 부른 애리 파트가 듣기 좋았음 물론 고음파트도 듣기 좋은데 애리의 저음이 있어서 신나면서도 분위기 있는 곡이 된 거 같아서 듣기 좋았어 애리야 😭😍
5:58 맞아 콘서트에서 들으면 진짜 좋을듯‼️
love winter’s vocals in this song she hit all the notes effortlessly
im convinced ningning is a recording wizard. every behind the scenes i watch of her shes just in her prime when theyre recording. (they all are amazing but she just blows my mind in the recording booth!)
2:16 KARINA PEEKING ON CAMERA before ending recording like she always do.... hahahah SHE IS SO CUTE FOR THIS!
still running away after you got xpsd 2 weeks ago for being narsuun1 when you used it seconds after aedark and bshd kepler in their stream and wished them to d13 and when they stopped seconds later you came back again giving once more solid eviidence that you are behiind it thats why you go off sppming so many copy paste comments and use so many alts to support urself.
using your alts and scripts and copy pasting more comments meaning you are running away and with doing so you further admit that you are narsuun1.
As a vocalist i am very impressed with Giselle’s singing voice, she needs to have more singing parts in the future songs. Im a fan of all but her recording session here seems so short compared to the others.
Cada vez le dan menos líneas y eso es muy muy molesto
I agree with you.
윈터랑 닝닝이 기술적으로 잘부르고 명창이네요!
Winter is so cute
Live my life = “we go “ vibe + “life is too short” core. Powerful vocal, perfect tone, and wide range of notes! Winter ❄️ well done! She is an amazing singer for sure 🐶👍
윈터 가성도 좋지만 카랑카랑 진성으로 내뱉는 고음은 더 좋음 진짜 속이 다 시원하달까..🥹🥹
Giselle has a really versatile voice... I hope we will see more of it !!❤❤
윈터는 역시 매미가 맞다 진짜 잘함ㅋㅋㅋ
김민정 목소리 따숩고 닝이줘 목소리 촉촉해ㅜㅜㅜ 넘 좋다
I love how the recording studio is dark when it's Giselle's turn. She love it dark. Everytime.
Karina described it perfectly💙
Great for live concerts
Obsessed with the layering and adlibs, this has got to be my favourite BTS Recording because of it. The song really showcases the girls’ wide range of vocals in the best possible way. Especially got chills listening to Giselle’s part here 10:33 wow 😭
Just saw the RV recording and came here. RV has mastered and evolved in singing. Aespa are such potential and strong juniors. Love Aespa and Red Velvet.
I like RV recording more because they show layer by layer of harmonies so its fun. But from aespa's recording, we can see they have really strong and solid vocal (maybe more than rv )
@@breadapple3552 Its roughly about the same on an individual level with Aespa having the slight edge simply bc Ningning vocal wise I believe is stronger than Seulgi by like one range perhaps. however as a group they're still behind RV bc Joy/Irene aren't completely matched by Karina despite Seuldy and ningwin canceling each other out. Gigi and Yeri are the balancing acts of their respective groups thts why I didnt mention them as much.
영상을 재생하자 민정이가 노래로 맞이해주는거 같아서 너무 좋아요!!
너 너무 잘 불러!! 사랑해🤍🤍🤍🤍
애리의 녹음 후 멘트랑 소개들이랑 감상평이 너무좋다....
BOL4 released a song featuring GISELLE called ‘LIPS.’ Please go stream ‘LIPS SM refused to support GISELLE’s first feature. Let’s support her and make SM even more mad!
와 카리나 고음 시원하게 올라가는 거 보고 1차 놀람, 윈터 목소리 개시원시원해서 2차 놀람, 상상도 못한 닝닝 목소리가 이 노래에 너무 잘 어울려서 3차 놀람, 랩 담당 지젤 음역대 높아서 고음 쉽게 부르는 거 보고 4차 놀람 ㅋㅋㅋ 어떻게 멤버들 한명 한명 나올 때마다 이렇게 놀라움의 연속이냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I can’t get enough of Karina’s tone ❤
윈터 보컬은 진짜 미쳤다❤😂
Since noone as in NOONE is complimenting NINGNING in the comment section. I just want you to know NINGNING that you really did a great job and your tone is so beautiful, your adlibs are all chef's kiss 🦋
윈터의 목소리 너무 행복하네요
윈터 이번에도 너무 귀여워 영원히 사랑합니다♥️♥❄️☃️
카리나가 하는말 보고 깜짝놀람
내가 좋아하는 노래,최애파트,그이유들까지 똑같아서😢❤
Karina low tone is always so chef kiss but when she does high she sounds like a rock stat love it
冬子のbetter ideaが好きすぎて一生リピしてる
the solo part of giselle is the most emotional overwhelming. it has warmth. Wish she will get more solo parts in future.
Giselle is so talented! I love how she harmonize the songgg 😗😗
Giselle is the backbone of harmony
Love Winter voice❤
민정이 음색 미쳤다❤❤
와 닝닝 이정도 음역대에서 진짜 안정감은 쩐다 윈터가 애드립 등에서 찔러주는 쇳소리라면 닝닝은 전반적인 부분에서 안정적인 금속느낌을 주네.. 먼가 쇠보다는 좀더 무른 알루미늄같은 늑낌 암튼 넷다 조합지림
カリナの中音域の引っ掛かりのある歌い方が良すぎる
Love Ningning’s voice!
카리나가 톡 쏘는 느낌 잘 살려서 찐으로 좋다
Wait!! No one talk about NingNing's amazing vocal!? Literally Heaven!!
Ningie you're the best singer for me, I love you so much 🎉❤
윈터 고음 미쳤다.. 이번 컴백 노래 진짜 좋다🤍
Winterrr❤️🔥😍😭
타이틀 곡은 중독성이 강하다면 수록곡은 마치 발라드를 좋아하는 사람들에겐 더욱 안식처 같네요 너무 좋아요!
NINGNING AND WINTER ARE LITERALLY AMAZING
윈터 병아리같이 입고와서는 찢어버리네
I love how Giselle always records in the dark
Is it to just make her more comfortable or is there a specific reason for that?
@@Sunshainn I also think the reason behind it is for her to be comfortable or get in the mood of the song. I really don't know
i can't help but to stan them because their songs, voices, stage presence even visual? are soooo perfect!❤
믿고 듣는 윈터~👍👍👍❤
노래 정말 좋아요
킴민정... 말라입~ 말라입~ 왜 이렇게 귀여운 거야 =.=
Aespa voices are so beautiful to hear, I love to see these recordings
락발라드?도잘해ㅜㅜㅜ❤콘서트에서너무좋았어
Im AMAZED with Winter's vocals
카리나가 저렇게까지 고음하는건 처음보네용😂
우리 민정이 공주님 목소리도 너무이뻐 얼굴도 예쁘고 ㅎㅎ쪼꼬미
다들 너무 잘하셔요!!
BOL4 released a song featuring GISELLE called ‘LIPS.’ Please go stream ‘LIPS SM refused to support GISELLE’s first feature. Let’s support her and make SM even more mad!
립마라 노래 너무 좋아 진짜 홍보 많이많이 해죠!!! 역주행 쌉가능이야
Winter voice is the best, love you my ACE 😌🩶🩶.
에스파 진짜 능력치 대박이긴하다..
ホントに全員歌が上手すぎる…4人ともaespaの音だわ~を感じるんだけど、それぞれ個性ある声してんの好き
producer having the best time of his life recording with aespa vocal talents
에스파 보컬 실력으로 녹음하면서 인생 최고의 시간을 보내고 있는 프로듀서
윈터 고음봐라 이야~~
Winter warming up was so adorable and sweet🥰
와 윈터 너무 좋아
BAHAMA 녹음도 보고 싶다. 그 곡은 다른 앨범 곡들에 비해 조회수가 100만 뷰에 달하고, 지젤, 카리나, 윈터, 닝닝 녹음도 보고 싶고, 랩에 푹 빠져 있다 gigi❤❤
Live My Life 레코딩만을 기다렸습니다... 제 최애 수록곡이 Live My Life라 진짜 너무 기대된 레코딩 영상인 것 같아요😊
I like RV recording more because they show layer by layer of harmonization so its fun. But from aespa's recording, we can see they have really strong and solid vocal (maybe more than rv )
Okay, Winter wants us to sing that part with the highest note to relieve stress. Girl, we don't need to do that, we just need to listen and look at you to be stress free.
윈터는 진짜 보컬로 나가야한다
창법을 자유자재로 구사함에 모자라 목소리도좋고 쩌렁쩌렁 울린다.
매미별명 참잘지은듯.. 결론은 윈터사랑해❤
레코딩 비하인드 너무 좋음 카젤윈닝 항상 발전하고 또 발전하는거 칭찬해!!! 이번 레코딩은 애리 인터뷰 길어서 너무 좋다 항상 진지한 자세 보기 좋다 애리야❤❤
4:16 HER VOICE IS SO CUTE
민정인 항상 찢네… 최고야
3:37 I AM MELTING AGAIN HELP ME PLS THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL
Many appreciate the voices of Winter and Karina but I appreciate the voices of Ning2 and Giselle, I love their vocals, anyway all 4 of them sing well
aespaで1番好きな曲🎧
GISELLE's low tone of voice is so cool 🥰
시원시원한 음색~~ 역시 는 역시다 에스파 최고다❤❤❤
윈터는 각 음역대마다 각기 다른 목소리 나옴 음역대마다 다른 매미가 들어있는거같음 신기함
winter has such an ideal voice❤
시험기간에 힐링이다 진짜 에스파❤❤
I never thought Karina would hit those high notes so effortlessly. Damn I'm getting in love with her every single time.