SHADOW SHOWDOWN - Biba vs Rust - Same or Different? | kinkysweat

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 151

  • @yensid4294
    @yensid4294 4 года назад +52

    It looks like the overall color story of Biba is more subtle, a little softer/less opaque & more cool leaning with the browns being more pinky/red in comparison to the Melt Rust palette. I haven't seen either palette in person & judging the nuances of color is difficult on a monitor, but that is how it looked on your eyes/skintone in this demonstration. Melt shadows really pack a punch & I think that can be both a good & bad thing depending on the look you're going for & your application process. Biba seems like a good palette for someone who wears natural, neutral or soft looks daily. Really fun to see these palettes compared on each eye like this. Great job!👍

    • @Loralarify
      @Loralarify 4 года назад +1

      yensid Yes- agree!

  • @lifeonabudget8513
    @lifeonabudget8513 4 года назад +54

    Shadow Showdown should be a series! This was great

    • @angyeliz
      @angyeliz 4 года назад

      Life On A Budget great idea!

    • @Kdee1405
      @Kdee1405 4 года назад

      Seconded!

  • @christinechen2732
    @christinechen2732 4 года назад +15

    I’ve got Biba and a light-medium skintone, plus I’m north of 40 and not going anywhere with a dramatic smoky eye, so I guess I’m good! Thanks, Alicia, you just saved me $60!

    • @abdulazuzadel4768
      @abdulazuzadel4768 4 года назад +3

      On my aged oily lids even Pat's neutral shadows look harsh and crease. I am Natasha's addict. Never used coloured shadows in my youth, thanks to Natasha now I can enjoy colours without regrets. ( I can even take a nap, my eye shadows will still stay flawless).

  • @chic_brooklyn_beauty
    @chic_brooklyn_beauty 4 года назад +7

    No shade whatsoever to melt, but you can truly see a clear difference in quality, blendability, pigmentation, and overall beauty of ND eyeshadows.
    Love your in depth videos and content- thanks Alicia ❤️❤️

  • @cecen1500
    @cecen1500 4 года назад +27

    6 minutes in and I’m adding Biba to my cart to wait for Sephora’s sale. Cuz we broke right now! That’s girl. U do the most. I appreciate you.

    • @cecen1500
      @cecen1500 4 года назад

      “Thanks girl”*

    • @alyssar2742
      @alyssar2742 4 года назад +1

      I love my biba palette ❤ it's so pretty, smooth and just uhmazing!

    • @abdulazuzadel4768
      @abdulazuzadel4768 4 года назад +1

      With Biba you will not be disappointed. So love mine.

    • @sydt7104
      @sydt7104 4 года назад +1

      I would recommend the Alter Ego dupe palette named Sahara. Alter Ego does very excellent dupes for a much better price.

    • @pamelabynes4669
      @pamelabynes4669 3 года назад

      Syd, alter ego doesn’t match the Natasha Denona quality though. Her quality is worth the price.

  • @SaraFetene
    @SaraFetene 4 года назад +9

    Thank you for helping me makeup my mind & save some money. I don’t need rust. Because Biba is my EVERYTHING!!!

  • @Yofavhealer
    @Yofavhealer 4 года назад +19

    I’ve been watching your channel for a little bit now. You’re personality is just so lovely and your content is fantastic. I would watch you review cereal💙

  • @Loralarify
    @Loralarify 4 года назад +2

    Both beautiful but I think I prefer the ND overall look/blendability and formula- or just the tones on your skin. Don’t get me wrong, both are gorgeous on you- but I’m just going by how it looks on the video. Thanks Alicia! Great job and I love how you narrate your thoughts and perspective on each look and tone comparison! That last look was really pretty!!

  • @tammyvaught2210
    @tammyvaught2210 4 года назад +10

    I loved seeing more looks with Biba!! I haven’t had mine very long but it’s one of my favorite palettes and this has given me more inspiration. I’m gonna pass on the Rust palette but I’m definitely gonna get that gel liner. It’s so pretty!!

  • @KKN13
    @KKN13 4 года назад +3

    when it comes to this type of content, no one does it as good as you, A! love your personality and your views.

  • @debwhite5281
    @debwhite5281 4 года назад +2

    Like the looks from the Biba palette.

  • @AwakingOceanborn
    @AwakingOceanborn 4 года назад +9

    BRB, the RUclips did not tell me you actually had done the Rust review already. Gonna watch that, have a strong worded conversation with my account and come back to this.

  • @sandrift
    @sandrift 4 года назад +6

    What a great comparison - now I know I can forego Rust and just keep using my beloved Biba. I was already skeptical of the Melt palette because I’ve already returned two that just weren’t up to snuff. I’m glad it is an improvement for Melt tho because they do have interesting color ways.

  • @terrib.540
    @terrib.540 4 года назад +14

    Ok so as I drink a mimosa and live comment on this video it occurred to me ... why dont you do LIVE tutorials!?!?!?! Especially while we in quarantine and bored bored lol I'd watch it ✋🏾🙋🏾‍♀️🤗🥰

  • @redolentkate
    @redolentkate 4 года назад +15

    Adore my Biba, adore my MELT stacks (4) and palettes (2) One day I will adore the Rust Palette and it will become part of my shadow family, one day ~~~ for now, I will watch Alicia play, compare, create, scrutinize colors, hues, textures and tones. ♥
    Stay safe Alicia, thank you for you.
    Queen of delving, digging deep into color subtleties and stating the practical.
    From an unpractical girl ~~~ I want them all...okay, not all, a lot? Many? Most?
    Okay, all, but that is not practical or prudent.
    Hugs, from a gal on a no buy that was month to month, now a no buy for the for see able future.
    Time to love your stash more than ever!
    Your stash: your family, your friends, your loved ones.
    Stay safe.
    Everyone.

  • @kendricmaine1234
    @kendricmaine1234 4 года назад +4

    ❤️ the fairy lights in the back

  • @feliciab1334
    @feliciab1334 4 года назад +4

    I love the Melt Gemini palette! And I am really getting more into my Biba palette. Thx for the Rust palette review. I know I don't neeeed it but I want it!!

  • @MKgoob710
    @MKgoob710 4 года назад +2

    This is brilliant and so helpful! I love that you’re reviewing new stuff while also revisiting older products. It makes my no buy during this crisis easier than watching videos focused exclusively on new releases. I will be busting out my Biba palette to wear around my house today and be seen by no one! 😆 Thank you!

  • @taya12020
    @taya12020 4 года назад +9

    Yesss I love this video. I thought I could skip this melt palette but perhaps I will get it during a sale. 🤔

  • @Elisekimopie
    @Elisekimopie 4 года назад +1

    Thank you for such a thorough comparison. This really helped with my (potential) purchase!

  • @MsLovephoto
    @MsLovephoto 4 года назад +6

    I love Melt palettes, but they need to get their shimmers together. My Gemini palette (when it first come out), Gemini just crumbled with a brush or sponge applicator.

  • @kcaldwell1224
    @kcaldwell1224 4 года назад +1

    Darnit, did my eye look before I watched your video! Tempted to wipe it off and grab my Biba. Your looks were GORGE and inspired me to play with that palette more. Hearting your content right now!

  • @katrinaatkins6308
    @katrinaatkins6308 4 года назад +7

    I been making sure to watch allll the ads and I have been re-binge watching your videos. 💕💕

  • @PrettyPoodleChosen1
    @PrettyPoodleChosen1 4 года назад

    Thank you for the comparison. Your makeup skills are unmatched. Loved it.

  • @fromscratcheewithstef
    @fromscratcheewithstef 4 года назад

    THANK YOU for continuing to post content right now. These are truly unprecedented, somber times... But I would much, MUCH rather try to discern the differences between these 2 palettes than worry about whether or not I will be able to buy eggs for my children next week.

  • @TheBunnyBeatdown
    @TheBunnyBeatdown 4 года назад

    I love videos like these because of the detail in the comparison. Like I literally rewatch your comparison videos so often just because I think theyre so good.

  • @leeforde6868
    @leeforde6868 4 года назад +7

    This is such a fun concept!! Maybe the next battle can be viseart’s rosé edit ( I don’t think you did a full review on this one) vs ND Love 🤗

    • @emw5
      @emw5 4 года назад

      Or the PMG VII

  • @pam8200
    @pam8200 4 года назад +1

    Hi Alicia, thank you for putting ND Biba and MELT to the same/different test. You're so amazing at doing these spot the difference reviews and go there with your level of detail! Appreciate your content and company always. 😘😘😘

  • @theresae6071
    @theresae6071 4 года назад +1

    Both are pretty but I think you can see the difference in quality - love Biba!!

  • @tammygratteau6136
    @tammygratteau6136 4 года назад

    I have Biba and haven't used it yet, now is the time to dive in. Thank you for all your recent videos and live feeds. you are helping us get through this!!

  • @linapatry
    @linapatry 4 года назад +4

    Whoop whoop 🙌 58.1k 🌸😘

  • @BrownGirlBella
    @BrownGirlBella 4 года назад +1

    Brilliant! Here lies the reason why you are the best at doing theses head to head , multiple look videos! While the goal may be to decide which one makes more sense for you, it made me want them BOTH 😂

  • @DawnD_
    @DawnD_ 4 года назад +1

    Nice video! Comparison videos are always good and helpful, especially if you were considering the Melt Rust palette

  • @cindybrat837
    @cindybrat837 4 года назад

    Alicia, this is an excellent comparison video! I didn't think that the palettes would have such a similar color story.

  • @deitralee6342
    @deitralee6342 4 года назад

    You are a breath of fresh. Love your personality and I especially like when you say, “that’s enough”.

  • @jocelynel-fab5214
    @jocelynel-fab5214 4 года назад +1

    Great video idea and execution! Want more like this.

  • @thisblackgirloverhere9013
    @thisblackgirloverhere9013 4 года назад +1

    You’re so awesome girl! You got me watching this even though I’m not even thinking of getting rust (but of course I already have biba😂). Your eyeshadow application and color pairing is so good! 🧚🏽‍♀️

  • @lubazak636
    @lubazak636 3 года назад

    Just got the Rust and She’s in Parties pallets, which seem to be their top pallets, at least for me. Love the BIBA and have that too. The Rust pallet is more of a grungy vibe and you need to dip out for a highlight shade, but I like both of these pallets; BIBA and Rust.

  • @amandablythe6515
    @amandablythe6515 4 года назад +3

    Why do we have people disliking this video? It's stupid. If you don't like it, just move alone. I hate people

  • @coralaila
    @coralaila 2 года назад

    I’m glad I found this video. I’ve been thinking about Rust but I already have Biba and I enjoy it. I don’t need another palette if I have biba.

  • @saphira4627
    @saphira4627 4 года назад +2

    Thanks Alicia, for me it's Biba by a longshot.

  • @NewBeginning828
    @NewBeginning828 4 года назад +8

    Thank you so much for all the content you've been putting out. You are truly keeping me sane ❤️

  • @thebeautyafterthe40s
    @thebeautyafterthe40s 4 года назад +1

    👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 this is the kind of videos I really enjoy of you alicia, thanks so much 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 great option but still IN LOVE OF LY BIBA PALETTE 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️❤️🥰🥰🥰🥰

  • @angyeliz
    @angyeliz 4 года назад

    Ok you’ve made me want Biba that I’ve been on the fence about. I don’t do smoky looks but love how it turned out on you.

  • @millicentspears
    @millicentspears 4 года назад +2

    Thank you for continuing to create content💙💙💜💜💜

  • @cherrymoon58
    @cherrymoon58 4 года назад

    Truly enjoyed this comparison.

  • @mylastestaddiction739
    @mylastestaddiction739 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for making this video I was wondering this.

    • @aliciaarcher
      @aliciaarcher  4 года назад

      Thank you for watching! Happy it helped!

  • @watada
    @watada 4 года назад +1

    What a great idea! Love your detailed breakdowns of these shadows.

  • @elainebines6803
    @elainebines6803 4 года назад +1

    Thank you. I have the biba palette. Would love to see some looks with the bottom row too - sculpt etc...👍🏻

  • @jamiliawallace9103
    @jamiliawallace9103 4 года назад +1

    I have the Biba palette but I will still pick up this melt palette because the melt stack was a palette I had plan to buy last year and did not get around to and now it is discontinued. I feel melt will be very dark skin friendly. That does not mean my Biba does not do an excellent job on me.

  • @ForeignScammer
    @ForeignScammer 4 года назад +1

    I don't know. I like the looks with Melt cosmetics better. I'm going to pick up the Rust palette.

  • @Laura_________
    @Laura_________ 4 года назад

    Thank you Alicia! I really REALLY enjoyed this video. It helps with "comparison shopping". I feel now I have a better understanding of the similarities and differences between the pallets and can choose which one is right for me or if I maybe need both.

  • @mzbeatbarbie
    @mzbeatbarbie 4 года назад

    Loved these comparisons great video Alicia as always 😊

  • @Nerdydiva12
    @Nerdydiva12 4 года назад

    Thanks for the comparison. I don't have any melt eyeshadows so I may add this to cart

  • @AwakingOceanborn
    @AwakingOceanborn 4 года назад +1

    Ok back! Thank you for this comparisons! I found this super comprehensive. I was wondering, for the people who have/want Rust, when you said that Rubbish was not as peachy or as yellow as the shades you were comparing from Biba if you could dip a little into the peach or the apricot in to mix it with. Asking because that’s what I would do, but I’m also hella pale so I don’t know if that’d wash Rubbish out on a deeper skin tone.

  • @Briannadani
    @Briannadani 4 года назад

    Never stop making videos!
    🥺🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️

  • @roxanneotto
    @roxanneotto 4 года назад +1

    So excited to see this upload! Appreciate all the content and filming you are doing - your videos are always my respite from the real world and now even more so. I watched your Rust review earlier today while I was working (boss can’t see that now, haha) and I was so curious about the Biba comparison. Such a great idea to play with them like this! Thank you!! 🙏🏼😘

  • @J_loves_lu
    @J_loves_lu 4 года назад

    I have BIBA & love it ! I wanted rust but now I think I might save my coins or wait for a sale 😅 brilliant ideas Alicia & thx for saving me some money for now 💸💸💸 I used biba but now def need to use her again & try the looks you created xoxo thank you for giving us a breeze of fresh air in this difficult time 🙌❤️🙏🏼💪🏻 stay safe everyone !!

  • @pamelabynes4669
    @pamelabynes4669 3 года назад

    If you press the spot shade back into the pan it will stay. It’s a cream to powder formula so you just need to really press it back down firmly into the Pan like a putty.

  • @mspellz
    @mspellz 4 года назад

    Thanks for the quarantine content. Stay safe in NYC. I have both. I need both. Love the review and the looks.

  • @JennaiM
    @JennaiM 4 года назад +2

    All of these looks made me want both palettes 😂 what lash is she wearing? It definitely enhances the look without taking over I love it.

  • @terrib.540
    @terrib.540 4 года назад +2

    Girl I want everyone interpretation of every color palette lol 🤭

  • @sammysweetdesigns
    @sammysweetdesigns 4 года назад +1

    Oooo so glad you did this video! I want Gemini so badly! Was gong to order during their sale but they had to postpone it! Ugh!

  • @MsStephers
    @MsStephers 4 года назад

    👌🏾🤘🏾👍🏾 All of the things I am feeling rn. I should be asleep, but I needed to see this review before I rest my eyelids. Thank you for this! 🤗

  • @makingupthemagic
    @makingupthemagic 4 года назад

    It would have been nice to see that black in Biba... Because the biba pallete seem lighter and the blak is there to deepen your look. While in the mel pallette thet put the black pigment in the shades!

  • @imeldacampos8458
    @imeldacampos8458 4 года назад

    Finally ordered Biba so excited for it to be delivered.

    • @aliciaarcher
      @aliciaarcher  4 года назад

      Ooooo I can’t wait for you to try Biba 😍

  • @c.o.s.ismyname7701
    @c.o.s.ismyname7701 4 года назад

    Yes! I've been waiting on my KS tute. I'm going to treat myself and get one of ND's palettes.

  • @nikkilynndefilippo5756
    @nikkilynndefilippo5756 4 года назад

    I see many similarities between rust and naked honey too🤔. Naked Honey is one of my favorites. As is Biba. I’ve never owned a melt palette

  • @mariamfawaz7927
    @mariamfawaz7927 4 года назад +1

    I have the Biba palette and I love it so so much. I think that as consumers we have to be more mindful about how to spend our coins. Personally I have 28 eyeshadow palettes and it is a lot for a makeup enthusiast. I gave away one MAC warm neutral palette for my cousin, a palette that I adore but I am sure I need two lives to get through my palettes. So if we have makeup that can give us similar look then we don’t have to hoard. Right?

  • @lolaphearse3688
    @lolaphearse3688 4 года назад +1

    You are so freaking beautiful! Thank you for consistently great content!

  • @MamaGoony
    @MamaGoony 4 года назад

    ooooooo both look sooooo good! Love this idea!

  • @handsomebynatasja2947
    @handsomebynatasja2947 4 года назад

    You dig it girl! Great content and ohh my, love to see you almost every day🤩🤩 Love you girl!💜

  • @Soleils
    @Soleils 4 года назад

    I did click to find the difference! you are the best mind reader! Usually I would be who has time to blend...but that's not an issue anymore. Gotta get the Biba out today.

  • @sunq3831
    @sunq3831 4 года назад

    Going against the tide but i really like the melt palette. I don't have biba though. Ahhh, if only for the money, money that i don't have for now for either, i would buy biba because of alicia's opinion.

  • @_Shawne
    @_Shawne 4 года назад +1

    Thank you Alicia for helping me see that I can achieve similar looks with my Biba palette until this whole debacle is over and I can order from Melt again! I was wondering if any of the shades in Rust may also be similar to ColourPop's California Love palette?

  • @Chocolateray7
    @Chocolateray7 4 года назад

    I enjoyed this video I own Biba will wait for a sale but definitely wanna purchase one or two of the stacks. Thank you for this helpful info👍

  • @veeluna308
    @veeluna308 4 года назад

    Thank you for the review & comparisons!!!! Makes my decision a lot easier. 😘

  • @pamelawolf313
    @pamelawolf313 4 года назад

    For me personally, if I had to only choose one fo these two palettes, I’d choose ND. There’s more shades to choose from and I’m so pale the Melt palettes are almost too much color for someone like me. (Even though I love them)

  • @jeniferjoseph9200
    @jeniferjoseph9200 4 года назад

    It’s very clear that the Biba palette is far more uniquely beigey than the Rust palette.
    HOWEVER you can find dupes for most if not all the Biba shades in the Sydney Grace formula. I’d love to see a comparison between those two formulas

  • @LovingFude
    @LovingFude 4 года назад +1

    Yay this gave me inspo to take Biba aka Beebs out tomorrow! 💋

  • @alja_jo
    @alja_jo 4 года назад +1

    Here I am 😘 Have been considering Biba, maybe one more look into it might help me.

  • @Christy-xw4ss
    @Christy-xw4ss 4 года назад

    The new artist couture eyeshadow palette is beautiful to me and I kinda want to have it in my collection but I do think the biba palette has similar shades. If you do get the new palette can you compare them😘

  • @shainacleverdon5204
    @shainacleverdon5204 4 года назад

    Keep the content coming girl! Hope you are well!! I had a video idea request.... this has inspired me to mash up palettes I have for new combos and I was wondering since you are the queen of tutorials IF you could also be inspired to continue to do mashups???? Examples Melt Gemini vs Rust, ND Safari vs Melt Rust or Gemini, CT vs ND, ND sunrise vs love, mother pat blonde platinum vs viseart paris edit, etc... inspires us to use what we have... make new looks with them AND passes time 🤟🏼

  • @icekitty15
    @icekitty15 2 года назад

    Hello Alicia, I know this is a old palette. But I have been going through my eyeshadow palettes trying to see the looks influences have done with them. I have a lot of eyeshadow palettes and I want to use palettes that I haven’t used. I been on a low buy No buy and I have a small space & I don’t have the room to keep adding more palettes. Anyway I enjoyed the looks you did here. But then again I always enjoy your looks. Thanks for sharing and always making us if we need both or not. Most will just say buy both. At list your honest. Big blessings Alicia.🥰🥰

    • @aliciaarcher
      @aliciaarcher  2 года назад

      Hey Iris! Yes, this is one of my favorite Melt palettes and a great one to revisit!

  • @dragonscorpio2864
    @dragonscorpio2864 4 года назад

    Thank you for the video!🌹Awesome as always🌸

  • @audreyn1000
    @audreyn1000 4 года назад

    Hi,
    First at all hope your family and you are fine. Please can you tell me which lashes did you wear in the first makeup?
    Thank you!!!

  • @Paola_Saa
    @Paola_Saa 4 года назад

    Nice comparison!!! Can you find a dupe for Tom Ford cocoa Mirage!!

  • @rehtseus23
    @rehtseus23 4 года назад

    Alicia I had a mini heart attack when you put the brush to your eyes in the second look😂. That was too close for comfort. Thank you for your awesome reviews. Be safe!

    • @rehtseus23
      @rehtseus23 4 года назад

      Also, third look was crazy similar! I love Biba and will have to recreate it.

  • @veronicaarana1568
    @veronicaarana1568 4 года назад

    Love love the lipstick also. I do not own biba or Rust..the rust kit is sold out. :-( can't afford ND. Thank you for your review 🥰🥰

  • @sepideharfazadeh542
    @sepideharfazadeh542 4 года назад

    And the oscar of the best comparisons go to .... Aliicia. Thank you soooo much xoxo

  • @asha.m
    @asha.m 4 года назад +1

    I dont want either palette, I do however want your eye brush collection 😂😂😂🙏

  • @annamarie6228
    @annamarie6228 4 года назад

    Thank you friend! I so appreciate these videos! 😘 Stay safe!

  • @Pilatesdxb
    @Pilatesdxb 4 года назад

    Heyyy hun I am a pilates instructor and all the mascaras I have tried transfer...(Dior, Tom Ford all, Chanel, Giorgio Armani, Too Faced...and more) Can you pleaseeee recommend a mascara that doesn’t transfer? ( I do set my under-eye with some translucent powder then a little finishing powder but I hate to bake because of lines) thank you! Love your videos 😘💕💕

  • @TheLevada05
    @TheLevada05 4 года назад

    Would you be willing to do rust + 27 or rust + Gemini? 😍😍😍

  • @isabelab6851
    @isabelab6851 4 года назад

    I love melt...but I am going to wait. I have the Biba palette and do not use it as much as I should

  • @taniaelgaard
    @taniaelgaard 4 года назад

    Dear Alicia 😊 Love your videos. A happy place when i need to relax. Stay safe 🥰

  • @LeeLee-vy1bq
    @LeeLee-vy1bq 4 года назад

    Ok girl, now I know this is completely off topic but I need retail therapy. I need your help bc I can’t decide. CT pillow talk palette, or ND love palette. What I want is rust and Gemini but waiting for melt to reopen and these 2 palettes I have talked myself out of numerous time. Or should I just get biba? Seriously help me make the choice.

  • @albertamezzacapo4457
    @albertamezzacapo4457 4 года назад

    Excellent work!!

  • @MoniqueVanRey
    @MoniqueVanRey 4 года назад

    I’ve been waiting! Lol who else is waiting for rust to drop at Sephora.com

  • @JoAnnaTheSoulStringerJohnson
    @JoAnnaTheSoulStringerJohnson 4 года назад

    As if this decision wasn't already hard. LOL!!!! I love Melt! Guess I'm probably getting this one. I love my stacks! But if this palette is hitting this hard. Hmm...I don't know. 🥰💖💕😍