Pro Tour Fate Reforged Quarterfinals (Modern): Justin Cohen vs. Seth Manfield

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии • 88

  • @mindgravybear2971
    @mindgravybear2971 10 лет назад +33

    seth is so anxious. body language says alot when playing magic. seths says "just pass the turn back to me so i can fire off all my burn spells and attack"

  • @JakeMGolle
    @JakeMGolle 9 лет назад +66

    Seth always looks like he's about to start crying or whine or something. I'm not sure if that's how his face sits but he just always looks really upset. Was he a former pod or delver deck pilot?

    • @MrGarruk123
      @MrGarruk123 9 лет назад +1

      I know he played some pod before its ban

    • @loganfredwest9651
      @loganfredwest9651 9 лет назад +1

      Lol I was just about to comment that XD

    • @JankyDice96
      @JankyDice96 6 лет назад

      Seth knows that you can't do anything in this format if you starts second...

    • @myaramiu
      @myaramiu 3 года назад +2

      @@JankyDice96 He started first :)
      And lost.
      I love comments like yours that don't age well at all.

  • @jeremygillespie4203
    @jeremygillespie4203 9 лет назад +3

    Technical director made a bit of a slip at 14:38 lol.

  • @alanyuan8565
    @alanyuan8565 8 лет назад +12

    What Seth should have done, and Seth admits this mistake later was he should have on turn 3, attacked with goblin guide and eidolon, bring Justin to 10, cast second eidolon and suspending rift bolt. If Justin casts the hive mind, summoner pact, take 4 of his eidolons then upkeep, rift bolt, stack bolt on top and then stack pact at the bottom so Justin loses first.
    Similarly, if Justin had a Titan, the bolt and rift could have killed the Titan and allowed Seth go in with a second goblin guide and swift spear.

    • @gasnaked
      @gasnaked 4 года назад +6

      He had only 2 lands. If he played second eidolon, no mana to suspend rift bolt.

    • @malcolmadair8373
      @malcolmadair8373 Год назад

      That is not how the stack resolves. Rift would be on bottom of the stack at all times. Active non active player.

    • @sytsmr
      @sytsmr Год назад

      @@malcolmadair8373 but it's seth's copy of pact though

    • @twosidedice3176
      @twosidedice3176 Месяц назад

      @@malcolmadair8373 Seth controls the pact copy, so he can stack them as he pleases

  • @hoiss
    @hoiss 10 лет назад +3

    Why not destructive revelry at about 37:20?

    • @ZakanaHachihaCBC
      @ZakanaHachihaCBC 9 лет назад +1

      Probably because popping off the Amulet would let Justin resolve a Titan if he had an untapped land in hand or on the draw rather then popping a land which would not allow a Titan to be played.

  • @Lemonducky86
    @Lemonducky86 10 лет назад +13

    (Spoiler) I'm so glad Justin won. The endless interactions and possibilities of Amulet Bloom are so much more interesting to watch than a flurry of red cards.

    • @SmellyJelly4MyBelly
      @SmellyJelly4MyBelly 9 лет назад

      Lemonducky86 ìf only he could've done it honestly :(

    • @stolenrims
      @stolenrims 9 лет назад

      SmellyJelly4MyBelly what are you talking about?

    • @SmellyJelly4MyBelly
      @SmellyJelly4MyBelly 9 лет назад +5

      stolenrims Actually, I'm wrong. I thought Justin Cohen was the Bloom Titan player
      that was disqualified for cheating, but I was thinking of Stephen Speck.
      Apologies to Cohen, he won this match fair and square.

    • @stolenrims
      @stolenrims 9 лет назад +2

      SmellyJelly4MyBelly Ah yeah. I feel like Speck gave the bloom deck a bad name for a lot of people. At least locally, a lot of people I meet seem to think that because Speck cheated the deck must not be good enough to win on its own. I think that it does have high variance but it's not as fragile as most combo decks, and it's certainly not "bad."
      Thanks a lot, Speck...

    • @ZakanaHachihaCBC
      @ZakanaHachihaCBC 9 лет назад +4

      +stolenrims speck is probly the reason almost every article about the deck talks about the T2-3 kill like it happens every few games and why people think its ban-worthy.
      If people took the time to watch the deck get played for real by a good player like Justin, they would see it's hard to pilot, the kill is inconsistent (Burn, Infect and Affinity are more likely to kill T2-3) and that it doesn't need to be banned. Speck should be but not Titan Bloom.

  • @Lifeispain99
    @Lifeispain99 10 лет назад +6

    I'm not sure why Cohen didn't grab Slayer's Stronghold and Boros Garrison with Primetime in game 3. He gets to grab 2 extra lands and deals 8 damage that way, with no downside.

    • @maxpeeters8688
      @maxpeeters8688 10 лет назад

      Summoner's pact costs 2GG on his next upkeep.
      If he did pick Boros Garrison and Slayers' Stronghold, he would not have 2 green mana sources and would lose the game.

    • @Lifeispain99
      @Lifeispain99 10 лет назад +5

      Max Peeters No; after Garrison and Stronghold untap from Amulet, he activates them, then returns Stronghold to hand with the Garrison Trigger, then he attacks, gets a second trigger, searches up Radiant Fountain/Khalni Garden/Tolaria West and another green Karoo, returns the other effect land and ends up with 2 more mana, plus another effect, with his opponent at less life.

    • @maxpeeters8688
      @maxpeeters8688 10 лет назад

      Lifeispain99 Oh of course, I didn't account for the titan's attack trigger.
      My bad.

    • @Adman234videos
      @Adman234videos 10 лет назад +13

      If Seth had boarded in paths to deal with the titan, he could have pathed the titan before the attack trigger. If Justin had gotten the boros garrison and slayer stronghold (seth was even representing path with an open fetchland), then Justin would have lost on his next upkeep, unable to pay for the pact because of the required green mana. So there is not "no downside", he was playing around something very specific that could have lost him the game.

    • @alexjorg8463
      @alexjorg8463 10 лет назад

      ***** since when does burn run path?

  • @joshdodson555
    @joshdodson555 6 месяцев назад

    Modern was the best during this time.

  • @borkman5576
    @borkman5576 3 года назад +2

    Justin - Cool, calm, collected
    Seth - Looks like he's gonna cry, vibrates so much it seems like the friction he'd make could lite a fire.

  • @staticdecoy
    @staticdecoy 10 лет назад +3

    couldnt seth pay for the pact at the end he had stomping ground out? O.o

    • @Lemonducky86
      @Lemonducky86 10 лет назад

      The payment for Summoner's Pact is 2GG and Seth only had one green.

  • @nicolaslandau4692
    @nicolaslandau4692 10 лет назад +2

    Couldn't seth have won game 1 by playing guide, attacking with both and suspend rift bolt? that would have left Justing at 8 life, pact would leave him at 6 and on upkeep rift bolt + lightning bolt = 0

    • @devilboy561
      @devilboy561 10 лет назад

      unfortunately no the pact trigger would happen before suspended rift bolt trigger due to active-player-non-active player ordering (APNAP)

    • @nicolaslandau4692
      @nicolaslandau4692 10 лет назад +5

      devilboy561 but seth controls both the pact trigger and the rift bolt trigger if im not wrong

    • @devilboy561
      @devilboy561 10 лет назад

      Nicolas Landau jus watched that game again n seth took another line where he didnt want to give lands to cohen cause cohen needs lands to go off as u saw that game, all cohen needs are more lands plus an amulet off the top to go off n kill via prime time, again seth doesnt have information from cohen's hand. BUt u are right seth does control both those triggers so my previous statement is wrong.

    • @DonCamilloLP
      @DonCamilloLP 10 лет назад

      Nicolas Landau yea i think you are right. they both happen at the same time during his turn so ge got to stack them

    • @Nr4747
      @Nr4747 10 лет назад

      Nicolas Landau Seth ideed gets to stack the triggers.

  • @johannesderspinner
    @johannesderspinner 3 года назад

    Modern looked different back then, but not so much as you'd think

  • @apospap2120
    @apospap2120 10 лет назад

    Can anyone explain me why the burn deck is playing Eidolon of the great Level?To burn itself??

    • @DonCamilloLP
      @DonCamilloLP 10 лет назад +10

      to make his opponent burn himself for every small spell he wants to play, it does not matter if you burn yourself if it makes you faster

    • @Nr4747
      @Nr4747 10 лет назад +11

      The vast majority of spells in Modern (easily 80-90%) of ALL decks cost 3 or less mana, meaning the Burn deck gets a free Shock for every one of those spells the opponent plays. Since Burn barely cares about its own life total and only wants to get the opponent's life total to 0 as fast as possible, Eidolon is a great card (in most match-ups).

    • @MrGarruk123
      @MrGarruk123 10 лет назад +2

      Against Storm, it's like an instant win

    • @apospap2120
      @apospap2120 10 лет назад

      Ok thanks!

  • @evanhendrickson3449
    @evanhendrickson3449 9 лет назад +3

    At the start of game one, is it just me or does it look like justin has 9 cards in hand. After drawing and before playing a land

    • @evanhendrickson3449
      @evanhendrickson3449 9 лет назад +1

      At 01:47

    • @AmazingAlec93
      @AmazingAlec93 9 лет назад +10

      Seth swung with goblin guide, justin revealed a land off of goblin guides ability, added it to hand, then drew a card for turn

  • @nitale55688
    @nitale55688 9 лет назад

    does the hive mind trigger stack? i mean, does the opponent have to pay dpuble the pact price, when i have 2 hive minds in play???

    • @bigj123bigj6
      @bigj123bigj6 9 лет назад +1

      no the hivemind trigger just copy the pacts.

    • @thonk7611
      @thonk7611 3 года назад

      if you have two hive minds they pay two pact triggers

  • @TizTheThief
    @TizTheThief 9 лет назад +1

    I love Lowell.

  • @xavierlane2898
    @xavierlane2898 8 лет назад +2

    im soooo happy bloom got banned. its fucked. the first time i ever played modern i played a green devotion deck and in that day all 4 of my rounds were against amulet bloom. and there were 2 more people playing that deck out of the total 18 i didnt play again for a few weeks cause thats what i thought modern was. everyone playing the same couple of top teir decks without any innovation

    • @jayceehampton6121
      @jayceehampton6121 8 лет назад

      But that's what Modern is suppose to do. WotC defines it as a wide-area format due to using all of these interesting spells, and potentially break any card people underestimates. For Summer Bloom and Splinter Twin being banned absolutely makes any sense because these are cards thst can easily be countered or played around.

    • @xavierlane2898
      @xavierlane2898 8 лет назад

      the issue is that everyone was playing the same deck. i go to modern now and in my LGS i dont think anyone plays the same deck as someone else there

    • @jayceehampton6121
      @jayceehampton6121 8 лет назад

      +Aquaman That's how the deck gain popularity. Like the commentators implied, Amulet Bloom used to be a deck that never got its shine in modern, until someone finally modified it to make it better. Now that people know it's good, people will find different angles to make it even better via mainboard or sideboard.

  • @BloodRoyal16
    @BloodRoyal16 10 лет назад

    Awesome

  • @jbs6614
    @jbs6614 4 года назад

    Seth looks sleepy.

  • @jeffreybella4521
    @jeffreybella4521 9 лет назад +7

    how is this even a format?

  • @lefeal9707
    @lefeal9707 2 года назад

    Big misplay in game 3 by justin. No reason to not get a slayers stronghold + boros garrison and attack right away.

    • @eduardo_magnefico
      @eduardo_magnefico 2 года назад

      Yeah there is. If Justin gets stronghold + boros garrison and Seth Path to Exile the Titan before the attack, Justin loses because he can't pay the pact.

    • @lefeal9707
      @lefeal9707 2 года назад

      @@eduardo_magnefico Assuming burn even runs path, remember the second part of the spell. If it gets pathed he gets a forest with the path.

    • @eduardo_magnefico
      @eduardo_magnefico 2 года назад

      @@lefeal9707 It does and he knows it does post sideboard. Also, he only has one copy of a basic Forest, that it's in his hand.

  • @SkipToYourOwnLou
    @SkipToYourOwnLou 3 года назад +1

    Kills me how slow Cohen plays...

    • @RandomGuyCDN
      @RandomGuyCDN 2 года назад

      Who cares when rounds are untimed. If GP's are ever back literally everyone under the sun plays slow as fuck during timed rounds too.

    • @malcolmadair8373
      @malcolmadair8373 Год назад

      I mean dude is playing a deck that takes a lot of thinking. Not something that is like I hit your creature or you. In this match up he is always going to be the slowest of the players. When you play burn you legit map out the first few turns(if not the whole game) around your opening hand.

  • @RaEndymion
    @RaEndymion 4 года назад

    Always a good day when burn loses. Even yeara later.

  • @JankyDice96
    @JankyDice96 6 лет назад

    It's fun to see how much proplayers try to make games difficult...
    This format is totally brainless, if you play first you win 90% of the time, 1 drops are too strong.
    Look at this game 1!!! If manfield would have played second he would have lost so bad...
    Every one who play a lot could achieve a lot, if rules does not change (like "if you play second you can put 2 lands the first turn).
    Or "you have 1 mana flooting that you can spend only one time in the match whenever you want" like heartstone...
    Wake up blizzard

  • @Fiskie666
    @Fiskie666 7 лет назад +2

    How did Cohen win the first game? Maybe some people are new to magic and want to understand as well? The commentators didn't even bother to explain.

    • @NuxTheDragonSlayer
      @NuxTheDragonSlayer 6 лет назад +3

      Cohen had the Card "Hive Mind" on the board. What it does is make your opponent copy spells that you cast. Then Cohen played Summoners pact. Seth was forced to play Summoners Pact because of the Hive mind. Summoners pact has the caveat that on your next upkeep you must pay 2 Green and 2 colourless mana or else you lose the game. Seth couldn't pay for it so he lost the game.