Russia's Mobilization and Retaliation Exposed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2022
- Thanks to Raycon for sponsoring today’s video. Go to buyraycon.com/taskandpurpose and use code EARLYBF to get 20% off sitewide or 30% off when you buy holiday bundles!
Written by: Chris Cappy and Justin Taylor
Edited By: Michael M.
Task & Purpose is a military news and culture oriented channel. We want to foster discussion about the defense industry.
Email capelluto@taskandpurpose.com for inquires.
#ARMY #MILITARY #MOBILIZATION
I added a lot of NEW information that I wanted in there on the original upload. Huge thanks to Raycon for sponsoring today’s video.
Go to buyraycon.com/taskandpurpose and use code EARLYBF to get 20% off sitewide or 30% off when you buy holiday bundles!
Could you do a video on the Ukraine navy please
Please talk about the very common "Soldier's fail". A large majority of soldiers in WW2 deliberately missed their enemies and didn't shoot them (on all sides). Same goes for every other war that was predominantly fought with long range weapons, because it is very easy to disguise unwillingness to hit the target by pretending to be a bad shot.
COME ON !!!!!!!!!!! POLICE ARE SNATCHING THEM OFF THE STREETS?????? RUSSIA's security service which includes FSB, POLICE, MP, COBO e.t.c consist of 5 million personel !!! you guys need to relax.. you know its mandatory for every Russian to serve in the military in Russia just like South Korea?? every Russian boy has operated a gun before bro! what do you mean they have no experience??? this isn't pussyland
Why are Chechens the most perfect soldiers on the battlefield, cus they built a military school in Chechnya after they fought in Syria, Russia sent most of their Unit to Syria cus they were muslims, Please atleast give correct news or just ask
Sir you are a smart person. These guys are former active members. They have done their 4 years and they have been called back. we are talking about 12-18 divisions. In addition, they hate N A Zs. Ukraine had one advantage, men. Now that advantage is gone. BTW we can not compare the Russian military to our military. They are fighting for their nation. we bunch of N A Zs and NATO proxy running around in Ukraine killing Russians. So the Russians are very well motivated.
This guy has not fought in Ukraine. I have. The russians want to fight and their families are extremely proud of them.
This is not an easy war like Iraq and Afghanistan. (I was in Iraq, Afghanistan, and syria) and am saying this. This guy has been wrong all the time and this is no different.
Just a small correction. There were 2 people called Helmut von Moltke. One was the genius, pioneer of the modern warfare who fought and won franco-prussian war and second was his son which was far from genius, who lead german army at the start of WW1. The one on picture is the second one. So just keep that in mind if you hear some seamingly contradictory statements that he was simultaneoselly a genius and an idiot. Its because they were 2 :D
Thank you for the information
Moltke the Younger was also an extremely good general. The Race to the Sea didn't work out for Germany but the reasons for that are complex. One of his subordinates deserves more blame than Moltke.
a nephew ;)
@@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311 I mean thinning out forces on the west, when it was their main part of the plan was pretty bad idea. Battle of the marne was very close even dispite that but still. But okay sure, he wasnt as bad as Hotzendorf, Potiorek, or Cadorna
@@sixtheninth yeah you are right, idk why I thought it was his son
Kyiv civilian here.
One correction, it isn't impossible to heat our homes, not at all. There are just scheduled blackouts for a few hours a day, sometimes emergency blackouts too, but that's it.
No need to overestimate it.
but Kyiv isn't the worst affected part of Ukraine, the reports from some areas are incredible, not a window left in the town we see....
Hey. I want to bring my career of special operations medical experience, assets and supplies. Want to help? We have been looking for someone in country for some time, if you’re on this channel you have to be at least squared away.
Americans are great at exaggeration. He is speaking to people with the luxury of a constant heating fuel supply so exaggeration helps them understand.
EU citizen here. Terror against civilians never worked. It just strengthens resolve. Check the latest World War. UA will prevail! RU is desperate. And the civilized world will continue to support UA!
@@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 Americans are also totally reliant on the power infrastructure for heating and cooling. You won't usually find any other methods of heating in their homes. Especially any built over the last 40 or so years. same goes for food preparation and storage. Some people only buy what they need for the week and don't have any other emergency food stores at home.
Always appreciate your take on these issues. From a regular ground guy, who’s been there, seen it, smelled, heard it. I do feel bad for these guys. We went willingly, volunteering for war. They didn’t. They’re not trained properly, and even less equipped. Sad deal all the way around.
Don't worry, most of the mobilized have passed the hotspots, they just need a little training.
So what you are insinuating that Russian people are not patriotic ,only Americans ,your Government sent you not to defend America but to commit murder in the name of freedom what bull shit,The Russian are defending their country against American aggression, America are using Ukraine as a vestal state to them how meny Ukrainians dei soldiers or civilians as long Russia 🇷🇺 bleeds,your Government makes me sick 😷
@@antoniodefilippo8484 keep drinking that koolaid son 😂 I’ll be the first to say the US has done some shady shit, but Russia has been puffing up and bullying its smaller neighbors forever.
Now the world has called their bluff, and they’re getting their asses handed to them 🤣 ON YOUR OWN DOORSTEP!
I feel bad for the ones forced to go. For those willfully looking to dominate a smaller neighbor…I look forward to their reclassification to fertilizer.
@Cody Bailey Your country I'm assuming you are a Yankee. since the end of ww2 your country has invaded 50 or more countries killing millions of innocent men women and children,and you got the cheek to say that the Russians have done this and that. To me you sound brainwashed, you seriously need help
Despite what Russia has done to Ukraine, I also feel empathy for both sides. Not so much those who tortured, raped and kidnapped Ukrainians, but the civilians on both sides and most of the soldiers. Russia will not recover from this war for decades, and Ukraine will likewise require many years to rebuild. Tragic.
Task&purpose... unbiased, understanding mental health, entertaining. You're a champion bro. High. High quality content.
"They will be permanently changed." Yeah, I've been out of Vietnam for over fifty years, and I still have those damned dreams and (sometimes) am swallowed by a darkness understood only by those who walked the walk. I feel for these young men, they are not the enemy, their government is.
My sympathies to you, but these young men definitely are the enemy. They are in Ukraine willingly killing citizens of a foreign country. Many times these citizens they kill are civilians. They also conduct a multitude of war crimes.
"I was only 19...."
Try visiting, it's a nice place n0w. People are very friendly.
Yeah... They ARE victims of Putin's megalomania, too... But I am finding it DIFFICULT to keep seeing these Russian BOYS as forced to kill their own cousins because they KEEP COMMITTING HORRENDOUS WAR CRIMES!?
Yes... I have empathy for the unwillingly "mobilized" Russian youths - but they are going to be regarded by the WORLD the way former Nazi soldiers were for the rest of their lives because their fellow soldiers, and obviously some of themselves, keep raping and looting and MURDERING... WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO MURDER AND RAPE IF YOU'RE MISERABLY HATEFUL OF THE WAR YOU HAVE BEEN FORCED UNDER SEVERE PENALTIES TO GO TO? Is there a cultural THING about SPREADING THE MISERY THAT PUTIN HAS INFLICTED UPON THEM AND THEIR FAMILIES? Seriously. I know that HORRIFIC behaviour is a consequence of war's utter brutality - Abu Ghraib - the Mai Lai Massacre - just for some examples of AMERICAN soldiers committing war crimes - but the RATE AND THE LEVEL OF TOTAL INHUMANITY among the Russian invaders is just at the SICKEST LEVEL... It's not a TERRIBLE, NATIONALLY SHAMEFUL, but (fortunately) SMALL group out of the total number of Russian soldiers who have been committing war crimes against civilians and soldiers alike and on a DAILY BASIS - and that is the part that I CAN'T understand.
Welcome home, L M.
One thing that didn't get a mention is that the conscripts also consume resources. And that means tying up logistics just to transport and feed them. Which competes with logistic resources for other things you might actually need. Also, the act of putting poorly trained conscripts into armoured vehicles which are then more likely to be destroyed is a good way of increasing the rate at which you lose valuable resources. I think the recent figures back this up.
That's assuming they'll get a tank, or a tent, or even food. Prospects are bleak. Actually training, equipping and supplying them would have tied up important resources Russia can ill afford to divert, so they don't
On top of that, they actually have to feed and supply the civillians in the occupied territories
Russian solution to supply problems, I know, don't supply them! Don't feed the conscripts!, Fukk our own troops, they can loot from the houses and their own dead for a pocket-ful of crumbs!
Exactly
they are just dumping them and leaving... no support, no supply, nothing to fight for, i'm sure they'll turn it around after they hear the tsar spoke with some mothers. ))
Best military channel on YT, great content, well researched, and always some humor where appropriate
So glad I found this channel. Thank you. incredible coverage
Demonetised, now you are a real RUclipsr.
youtube has it out for me lately it's like every 5th video get suppressed and yellow dollar signed
he can always run a “fundraiser “ for Ukraine to get a cut
@@Taskandpurpose Keep up the good job.
@@Taskandpurpose it like a signal from youtube that dosnt like the content you make bro i have the same issue
@@Taskandpurpose props to a fake business conconnoisseur.
Yet they commit warcrimes in a systematic and large scale. As one General in Norway said; "It shows that it is not a few bad apples, when liberated city after city warcrimes is uncovered"
Yeah i find it hard to feel bad for the average Russian
The best point you made was between the 700K who are thought to have fled the draft and the >300K reported to have been conscripted , that leave 1M less in the labor market. I would hate to have been the foreman at the construction site that had 200 guys conscripted. It will be weeks or months to get new hires and few would be worth a damn.
I like that Task & Purpose has become decidedly more serious.
There is a precedent in that in WWI the French after Somme and Verdun refused to attack (but only to defend) and some regiments revolted.
And a lot executed and jailed
They experienced the horrors of trench warfare and refused to attack again.
And it was not only the French also British and German troops revolted against their commanding officers.
Shellshock now beter known as PTSD victims were also shot.
Eh, a different situation but still a valid point, much more justifiable to yourself to defend your country than to fight in a different country for something you don't agree with.
Putin took a lesson from Genghis Khan; force newly conquered people to storm the walls first and use them as human shields...
And they got shot !
My Russian friend of almost 6 years is being drafted. He leaves tomorrow. I feel so much for him; I cannot imagine how he feels. He was recently talking of leaving Russia, too, as he had just finished college recently.
I hope your friend gets to go home after this, and perhaps even keep to any plans of leaving Russia.
Not sure if I believe you, I have a suspicion you are a troll.
Giving you the benefit of the doubt lets address your comment.
Why are you dramatising his military service?
Every man 18-27 serves 1yr in the military.
Conscripts are not sent to Ukraine.
@@fryertuck6496 With the newly "annexed" eastern Ukraine, Russia in their eyes can send conscripts to the front so they can "defend Russia."
Edit: Every man is supposed to serve 1 year in the military is correct... on paper. Paper doesn't always translate well in the real world
@@fryertuck6496 He said he's being drafted. I take that as mobilization. Not conscription. Although I do see your argument, him being fresh out of college, he is now eligible for conscription again.
@@nick4819 The mobilisation consisted of 300,000 reservists who had been serving professional soldiers within the past 5yrs.
In addition 80,000 men volunteered.
Of those numbers 50-70,000 have moved into theatre, these would be troops who left military service within this year and needed a short refresher course to get them to standard.
I believe a brigade were reactivated paratroopers.
The other mobilised troops are still in training in bases from Murmansk to Kherson.
Emphasis on modern implementation of integrated warfare.
No conscripts in the SMO.
Anyway your friend should have some pride in his country and not be afraid to stand up and be counted.
He was happy enough to take his free education and health care but not to defend his country?
He should be thankful he is not Ukrainian or he would be sent straight to the front to step into dead men's shoes of a unit reduced to 50% with the life expectancy of a house fly.
Thank you for the work you put into this.
Outstanding video as always, outfreaking standing!
Russian mobilization reminds me of McNamara in the Vietnam era. McNamara came from the Detroit auto business. He had the number of bullets needed to kill a Vietnamese calculated and then figured that if just more bullets were fired, Vietnamese casualty numbers would increase proportionately. This led to a lot more bullets being fired but the Vietnamese casualties didn't rise in proportion to what essentially was just an increase wastage of bullets. Yeah, it worked some, but it didn't win the war.
He also was responsible for tons of intellectually disabled people being hoodwinked into service.
Relax, US didn't lost a single major fight in Vietnam, this was that rock and pop era that destroyed the support for it. BTW, I am a rock fan :)
Vietnam was a chess move to check the Soviet Union. Eventually, China and Russia split, which, made the Vietnam War a no longer needed move.
@@petrumoldovan2598 just lost the war.
The McNamara fallacy is named after him.
I'd like to see you talk about how hard it is for troops- particularly poorly trained ones- to survive outdoors in the winter. These kids are going to suffer a lot of casualties from trench foot and frostbite.
good
Kids? The majority of them are oldheads
Like any other military, Russia has trained tens of thousands recruits every year. Germny 1945 still had several hundred thousand men with weapons and artillery. Russia is calling up their reservists. 1 or 2 million soldiers. Why do you think they have to call in untrained kids?
yeah the winter will be a bitch to those poorly equipped and trained russians.
@@Sir_Godz Big talk from someone who isn't being forced to or have children, selected to fight. They're fed misinformation and are considered expendable by the Putin regime. Be mad at the leaders, not the individuals.
Thanks brother always enjoy the content
Very good analysis.
Sometimes refusing to fight for an unjust cause is the bravest thing a person can do.
Exception: IF you're supposed to be fighting Commies, in support of an independent nation that does not wish to join the Communist encroachment being imposed upon them, THEN you would be a Coward. I'm speaking about the hippies during Vietnam. If there had not been that Hippie Counter-Culture in the 60's, which the Commies actually loved, then the draft dodging would never have happened in noticeable numbers. Had it happened in the 50's, as in the Koreas, there would have been no issue. But drugged out hippies enjoying great music and free sex had no interest in removing their dirty, smelly T-shirts or cutting their ratty hair. The troops were probably better off without them by that point. But when they spit on our returning soldiers and called them baby killers, playing right into the Commie propaganda, they became shameful and shameless cowards.
Not tht you got any chance of knowing what is going on in Russia.
@@Barefoot433 My high school history teacher is a Vietnam war veteran and he’s not really proud of being a part of that war, he’s proud of answering the call of his country but not of what he and his fellow soldiers did in the name of freedom and duty. I don’t think you can justify killing just because the people you are shooting at are communists, especially when a lot of them didn’t choose it willingly, my grandparents was born and raised in communist China and that’s all they’ve ever known, people like them didn’t choose that way of life because there were no other options
@@mastergecko1178 When you grow up you will understand
and then the whole world will hate you anyway, because if you're Russian, you're cursed. I can say that out of my experience.
It's always important to see the person behind the soldier. The father, the brother, the friend, the neighbour, the son. If we could see our self in all human kind no matter were we were born, the world would be spared a lot suffering. Thank you for sharing this!
“One death is a tragedy, a million is a statistic.” -Joseph Stalin.
Oddly enough looks like nothing has changed in 100 years.
@@reboundrides8132 yes, it's sad 😔
All that goes out the window the moment your survival instincts kicks in. It’s either them or you. Regardless of the circumstances. That’s war for you.
on many of those videos with conscripts they rebel not because Russia is sending them to kill Ukrainians but because they did not receive pay or proper equipment. It is hard to make any empathy with that. Ukrainians know that. So for them every 200 russian is a good one. And what will be with all that soldiers during/after the war? As modern day proverb say - Motherland will leave you, son. always.
@@reboundrides8132 такого Сталин не говорил
Thanks for your service cap
Really excellent video, Kappy.
The empathy you show for these individuals speaks very highly of your character. Here's hoping they're all able to recover enough to be able to emotionally move past this circus and show the same kind of compassion to others.
Yep, empathy to people who can break their leg or arm, or simply go to jail to avoid killing ukrainians and stay alive :)
Genious parallels from those, who know 0 about russian society - 90% of them support the war since 2014, it's really bad to percept Russia using Western paradigm of it being a healthy society with sane people. Again - no fighting with the police, no powerful protests, as in Iran, everyone is ok with everything, yep, very good society, that instead of fighting with their dictator, goes to war as a herd.
I have sooo much empathy to these "good people")
there is no sanctions for evading mobilization. those individuals effectively volunteered to murder and plunder. so yeh, compassion.
@@mezmerya5130 they are proud of their country, blame the concept of a "country which kills millions because they idolize imaginary borders and a flag.
@@mezmerya5130 well, there are some sanctions, but not really fearsome. You see, the problem is that most of Russians doesn't know their rights and how laws work in Russia. So, they listen to their common sense which says that if they refuse to mobilize they will be punished by jail or even death sentence. And actually there are unofficial punishments for those who refuse to participate in war, but I am not sure that they are used for mobilized. But it's enough to make rumors too.
Most in Russia want to Ukraine destroyed they just don't want to do it themselves or want better equipemnt to do it with
One Soldiers war In Chechnya Is a great book that presents all the complaints of the current war in Ukraine eerily similar to the complaints he gave about his time In Chechnya It's extradionary how similar these both correlate nearly 30 years apart the book mentions things which are currently listed in Ukriane:
-Tractors stealing armoured vehicles
-Lacking supplies and needing to rob or even in one chapter eat a dog or a cow "
-and many complaints about officers and corruption
I am surprised no one has spoke about this yet (to what i know of)
Interesting... it's almost as if the same mistakes are being made *by the same head of state who shouldn't have started either conflict and even be in power no more...*
Perun’s YT video on “how corruption destroys armies” covers this very well.
@@Anino_Makata Yeah, i agree - Korean and Vietnam wars was a mistake...
@@Anino_Makata this how cleptocracy works. Those who are the best at convincing that problems are solved got promoted, not those ones, who actually goos at solving problems. So even when there is time to solve problem, the chain of liars is already established, so you are not able to even get problem known by meant for that means. Everything's fine 24/7.
@@micaheiber1419 Yep, i agree - it is a USA Police all the way.
Bcs in Russia - you can't be arrested by "watching on Police's faces". If you believe this myth - then you are more idiot, to believe such lies from russian libtards.
Want real truth - from your people? "EXPAT American" Channel, "Travelling with Russell" (NZ guy, living 1 year already in Russia).
Factchecking all myths - you dum-dum.
Even Railways in Russia - are better, than USA, AND EVEN Ukraine (i am not shitting on them - it is a real fact.)
I’m so glad I came across this channel @Task & Purpose and me and my wife speak about this all the time. And I’m glad that you were able to come out and explain it the way I wish I could. The whole world basically not only hates the Russian government but also the Russian citizens. And anyone who knows any history on the USSR or Russia knows how much corruption and how little bit of say so the Russian citizens have. I know a lot of Russian people and the majority of them are very cultured, warm, and welcoming people. And the Russians, who didn’t have money to just get up and leave everything behind had only two choices if they got that mobilization letter, 1 go out and fight their neighbors/friends/family because the Russian government tells them to or 2 go to prison for refusing the mobilization. And I think by now we all know how harsh the Russian judicial system can be. It really is a sad situation. Praying for peace for both sides. 🙏🏽🙏🏽❤❤
Thank you for your thoughts!
Part of keeping the RU mil-bloggers is pragmatism.
It allows truth to be spoken to power and an avenue for average soldiers to voice complaints so resentment doesn't boil over into open revolt (this might be due to them actually reading history about the deprivations that caused large sections of the Tsar's army to join the 1917 Revolutions) and the mil bloggers serve as a canary in the coal mine to ensure problems don't fester untreated.
The other pragmatic reason to keep them is they can give evidence that can be used to fire Russian Generals or other high level officers that may have been promoted for political reasons and would otherwise be hard to remove.
The Russians do in fact want the incompetent, sycophantic, political appointees in their officer corps to be removed, if for no other reason than they want their military to actually be effective at making their irredentist imperialist goals a reality, but first they need to find them and have some kind of evidence.
Hard to change culture of lying and corruption in the army as long as the upper echelons of the government are leading by example.
There's no point in firing the incompetent, sycophantic, political appointees if you don't also fire the incompetent politician who appointed them. It isn't the officers, it's the system which appoints them, which is why the British Army stopped selling commissions two centuries ago.
Where can I find links to these Russian Military bloggers?
The problem is, a competent military leader can easily see this is a lost cause and order their troops to be withdrawn from the conflict, something Putin can't do. Because of this, Putin will keep appointing yes men and then firing them for incompetence until he himself is removed.
or to show Russia is open and criticism is possible, while in reality its tightly controlled.
The main difference between your military service and anyone drafted or conscripted is that you volunteered to join the military. I am Vietnam Era USAF veteran. I joined the USAF 3 months before my 18th birthday. i received my draft notice while in my first tech. school. I was fortunate and did not go to Vietnam. If I had waited to be drafted that would likely have been in the cards for me.
Aka you draft dodged by joining the air patrol? 😂
@@dambigfoot6844I was an Aerospace Medical Tech. working in the Flight Surgeons' office. I was a first responder to "Broken Arrows", i.e., in-flight emergencies and crashes. Later I was at Vandenberg AFB where the deadliest weapons in any military were tested. So yeah I was in the air patrol for 4 years. I wasn't in the army for 2 years as a clerk typist.
Haha at first I've read it as you were vietnamese and somehow draft-dodged joining the Vietcong and joined their MiG airforce instead XD
Thank you for your service. I hope after DEROS, that coming home wasn't as bad as movies like to picture it.
If it was I'm sorry about that but being Canadian, not much I could of done except thank you now.
Americans have kept Canadians from speaking Russian for a long time.
My uncle joined the US army and did go to Vietnam, but he was able to get a guaranteed no infantry, and worked in Intelligence working on sending leaflets to the VC and NVA. His office did get mortored and destroyed one day, fortunately he was out of the office that day, he was blessed and returned from Vietnam to the states and led a blessed life after his service.
Man, this channel grew fast. I didn't realize how many subscribers you had already. wowzas
Finally someone that understands the situation on both sides.
I was faced with that decision, to leave or face conscription, in ‘68. I wondered how many Americans left for Canada 🇨🇦 or elsewhere. I’m surprised, 60,000 is far less than 700,000.
What did you do?
I remember my father talking about how his university dorm in Edmonton had become an unofficial halfway house for Americans fleeing the draft. Lots of Canadian students hotbunking with American draft dodgers. Turned into a bit of a confrontation with university admin apparently.
Great video!
I just love the fact that Chris is feeling empathy for his fellow average infantry men 👍
There civilians who where litteraly draged and forced to the front line some of them are 18 years old
As a native speaker who follows this war 24/7 ,.. I have to say that you got very correct information .. amazing for english channel
I really enjoyed the balanced approach to empathizing with the conscripts.
thanks, I can understand that a lot of people won't agree with how I see it but I feel like it needs to be said. If you're a ukranian soldier you can't have sympathy for the Russian conscripts. I get that. But I can at least point it out.
@@Taskandpurpose In all fairness, I think there is a certain degree of sympathy for Russian conscripts in Ukraine, and the Ukrainian military. Fnctionally speaking, they're victims of this conflict, too; they wouldn't be in this difficult situation, and risking death and injury, if it wasn't for the bad decisions of Putin and his clique. And the fact that Ukraine has taken great pains to offer multiple avenues of surrender to Russian troops indicates that they view this war very differently than the Russians do. While it is a very practical thing to do, as it draws troop strength away from the Russians, it's very telling when one of the sweeteners offered in surrender is essentially offering to protect these conscripts from their own country.
As a Ukrainian, I cannot relate to this. What I understand is: the more of those mobilised untrained soldiers die, the smaller is the chance for my son to die to their children in the future, so this is exactly what I wish for them.
@@Taskandpurpose perhaps your next video could be about the difficulty the ruzz FSB agents face in Ukraine. I mean all that rape and torture they dole out, it must be exhausting to those orcs
@@Taskandpurpose sorry, Cappy, but i don't agree that this is some vital information that needs pointing out.
As a Ukranian, the only conclusion I can come to from this video, is that even in such great numbers and with free weapons, these conscripts are still just spineless ruzzky monkeys, that can't even wipe their own ass, let alone stand up for their own lives and country.
Lol Seeing you on the big screen really cracked me up.
Alexander with 50,000 soldiers beat Darius III's army of 1 million because Alexander had excellent generals that he trusted by his side. He knew that every soldier was hand picked and that his leaders wouldn't settle for unmotivated, poorly trained soldiers.
Darius would take any "soldier" that he could get his hands on and they ended up crowding the battlefield and causing mass panic when push came to shove. Alexander exploited this to the best of his ability
Don't take that 1 million figure seriously. Also in that battle, Alexander's typical tactic of hammer and anvil couldn't work because he couldn't outflank Darius' army due to it's sheer size, so it was an entirely valid tactic. Alexander nearly died in the battle leading from the front and mounting a frontal assault against Darius' center. It could have been a coin toss as to who won that battle if Alexander's head was paraded up and down the lines.
@@Edax_Royeaux Alexander was a commander, fighter, soldier and King. His men had so much respect for him because he led from the front. He was almost killed many times, the point remains the same, he had the option to expand his military but he chose to keep it smaller and more elite to have better maneuverability and control over his troops. I don't think it was really a cointoss, battlefields were Alexander's canvas and he was a master artist, he would take any little opportunity and exploit it. Of course luck had some significance but Darius would have crushed a lesser foe
@@Maksymetzmj Keeping a army smaller and more elite is not necessarily a "correct" choice, it's just a choice. The Swedish used this type of small elite army well in their invasion of Russia, but then at the Battle of Poltava (1709), the vastly more numerous, but inferior quality Russian soldiers defeated Charles XII and was thus the greatest military catastrophe in Swedish history. Command and control is an asset, but so is quantity. It was Xerxes, not the Spartans who won Thermopylae after all.
If you’ve slung a rifle for any army you can feel for the guys on either sides . Politics are politics and we’ve all been sent out to do the governments work, on the governments terms . Saying goodbye to our family and friends is the one thing we’ve all felt and can identify with. This was some seriously good work , I’m sharing the hell out of this .
Yep! Sucks to be mobilized. Got to be worse when you didn’t even know it could happen. Got to be even worse when you see hear & know most of the guys before got killed or maimed. I do feel sorry for the common Russian conscript. He’s got no reason to even get motivated!
Too bad Putin won’t announce Ukraine is free of NAZIs, declare patriotic victory and bring all forces home, including Crimea.
Well said.
DOUG out
I've talked and assisted many bright Ukrainian and Russian young men who were escaping war and mobilization (most of whom I met personally were engineers and IT specialists) since the invasion.
Most Russians were saying that they'd understand and probably accept the mobilization should someone else invaded Russia.
But in fact since it's their government that is invading ( not just another country but a "brotherly" Ukraine), they want have no affiliation with the stupidity of their government and Putin.
It's sad to see them leaving their homes and dear ones in a hurry hoping for the best in new country.
A big "brain drain" for Russia.
Also, many Ukrainians despite expressing their hate towards Putin and Russian government, also acknowledged the stupidity and corruption of their own government.
Just a sad moment for both side as I see.
@@0bserver416 they are no brothers to us.
Nope, one thing is feeling bad for the average troop (example Armenian or Azerbaijani soldier) the fact is it’s well documented what the average russian soldier is doing to Ukrainian civilians. Not a single ounce of sympathy for them. Fuck the russian troops.
Very informative, thank yoy
great video!
Your initial comments on conscripts are spot on. EVERY ONE is a casualty.
As member of IT which are excluded from mobilization we're still have plenty of example of our brother being taken into mobilization pool. I still arguing with my family about relocation into foreign country, but number of variants are quite limited.
do you really believe that if Russia lost this war, the Russian people would magically receive a good outcome?
Dude get out of there before your regime realises their conventional military is not enough and uses the unconventional ones in which case at least Ukrain and Russia and most parts of the world are dust. In case you decide to stay to overthrow the regime, then I will be the first person to fund a Guillotine for Putin and his friends :)
Just stay where you are, and protest or stop paying your taxes.
@@penultimateh766 Then they go to jail and get forcefully mobilized.
maybe you guys should stop being serfs to oligarchs and actually protest, Iranian school girls have more balls than you, funny how none of you cared about russian forces completely destroying Ukrainians cities but when faced with your own dangers it now becomes real. the rest of the world doesnt want you stay where you are
Thank you for your service
My mobilization orders for the 1st Gulf War was 2 years + 6 months or the duration of the war. After going all the way to Safwan as member of a APSYOP tactical team I was mobilized foremost 4 months.
I remember reading somewhere that besides the dead, the biggest losers in any war are those who lose their humanity. I think that goes for both winners and losers. There's nothing that says you can't be more humane than your enemy, and when it comes to sticking knives and bullets into each other, it's really the main thing that'll set you apart.
The biggest loser are the civilians who didn't ask to be in the middle of a war between East and West. The civilians always lose in war which is why the sooner it needs the better and everyone should be working towards that end instead of trying to one up the other side.
If you havent seen it check out documentary of Tony Vaccaro
@@shadowreaver1851
What are you even talking about? This is Putin's regime versus the whole world. There is no 'east', there is only Putin's regime.
@@nvelsen1975 lol bullshit. This is an internal civil war with international interference. You are a puppet if you look at the available evidence and claim anything else.
@@sumduma55
Hey Sergei, you've been hitting the vodka a bit too hard? Took a few too many punches in the head during Nashi camp? You just said a Russian invasion into Ukraine is somehow an 'internal war'.
My late brother had his all expenses paid one year Army action filled vacation in Vietnam. He definitely didn’t return the same
Great video Cappy. This war is a tragedy.
Love your shirt! Def one my top 10 fav sci fi movies
I have friends in Russia, it's difficult because I want to know that they are safe but they've been practically silent on social media since this whole thing started.
Why didn't you help them? A friend gives refuge to friends, posting on Twitter and RUclips won't help
@@Roccinante because they've been silent on social media, the primary method of world wide communication
You are a true professional... even if you keep trying to convince us you aren't.
Thank you for your balanced and HUMANIZING insights.
Lest we forget.
Good luck with channel:)
When Russia says they are only drafted 300000 troops and then they say it again and again you know the numbers is going to be a lot higher.
Wow! Awesome you added that intro (: It really helps change the viewers mindset going in, especially with a lot of the younger adults
A superb analysis of the Russian, Ukraine war. This is why I listen to RUclips and only take with a grain of salt the regular media. Thank you, Chris
Wonderfully produced. Do you have a team or is this all you?
Just wanted to take a moment to appreciate your editing. I love how you put yourself into certain images. It make it so much more fun 🙏😁
Wonderful opening. This needed to be said and you approach the issue with sensitivity and authenticity. Thank you, Cappie.
I agree. Ahmad; Salaam; Cappie is LIVING WITH 2 TARGETS ON HIS BACK !!! THE GLOBAL LETTERED AGENTS ARE AFTER HIM & SUCH Guys (SNITCHES RATS etc.!! )
I like how you don’t live in Russia and you know like everything we feel! Magician....
Brilliant 👏
I remember seeing my parents before my first deployment with the 82nd 1st/504th. My family was so proud of me, my mom who was a teacher for a class of developmentally disabled middle schoolers actually had me come in during Christmas time in my Class A’s and answer questions and what not but in all reality she just wanted to show me off. It felt good, I mean I volunteered and here I was about 9 months out of high school about to deploy. By my last deployment a lot of who I was had changed but the one constant was that regardless of how many times we rotated in it was just as hard on my parents as it was the first time. I’m empathetic to a degree to the Russians as I can’t imagine having some college freshman thrown into our unit that had established solid cohesion and for many wasn’t their first deployment. We also had TRAINING and more importantly trained as a unit.
I want to ask your opinion on something that felt right to me...
I can't accept that Russia can't take Ukraine... To me, that is so outlandish.
It would be the equivalent of someone forcing you to believe they have seen a flock of flying pigs.
If I had to guess, it would take Russia no more than two weeks to have total control over Ukraine, preferably one.
This entire experience clarifies the term "theatre of war."
There is always a rabbit hole in every major war
@Tin Watchman I didn't mean like betting on a football game I meant
, It feels like Putin Joey and Ukraine's Installed screen guild card holder collaborated in the largest atm transfer
in History
@@philobetto5106 I think its a new country the old ones are trying to build. Imagine all the people who ran from war going to one new up and coming country protected by all the biggest nations.
@@philobetto5106 I think that this only seems strange to you because you have a massively overinflated opinion of the Russian military to begin with.
Cappy, you are living proof of just how much Fuckery a single soldier can do with a phone and connection to the Internet. 😂
Love you brother!
You hit the nail on the heat at last. The person who put a video camera in a cellphone should get a Nobel prize. 🤔
very empathetic view on the situation.
It is a shame what's happening to these conscripts. I'm old enough to remember my mom's friends coming back from Southeast Asia. And yeah they were changed forever
Thank you for staying human and showing empathy. We shouldn't forget that people living in authoritarian states and dictatorships to a certain degree hostages - knowingly or unknowingly.
This is the only reason not to nuke USA.
For sure dude these people have been battered for generations by bolshevik terrorists and now being thrown into a war they probably don't even believe in.
Issue is many Russians’ don’t have a problem with the war.
@@alexsilent5603 You realise that in the case of a nuke dropped on the U.S, they would retaliate back and strike just as hard?
It's all flowers and empathy untill it's your country that's being destroyed. When every day you read news about bombed maternity wards, killed newborn babies, people who died slowly under collapsed buildings, death, destruction, death, destruction. All those photos of blood and pain. When you wake up to the sounds of sirens and multiple explosions and then stay with no light, water and heat for two days, because your whole country in a total blackouts after another massive attack on infrastructure facilities...Yeah, I have zero sympathy left for any ruZzian soldiers on our land.
Excelente 👌
You are the most professional RUclips presenter i have seen. I would be embarrassed to tell you how much time i spend on youtube.
This what we used to call "broadcast level" journalism/commentary, well done. You've taken a very nuanced and unbiased approach that seems to be in short supply these days.
thanks I really appreciate that, I'm trying my best to present different points of view
@@Taskandpurpose Keep it up, You are doing really well with these posts. Thanks for this content.
Wouldn't call this unbiased. For example, the alleged message from 155th has long been proven to be untrue. Members themselves stated that they had sustained losses but nowhere near as much as there was in the initial message.
Additionally, the video of rusty AK proved to be fake.
However, I am surprised not to see the video of radio specialists complaining about shitty old radios they were issued and ordered to bring into working order, which turned out to be true and was immediately rectified by a man with big stars personally delivering a fresh batch.
@@MrJohnTripperson There are a lot of reports of different sources about the lack of equipment that conscripts get.
They get lists about what items they should bring with them - nothing new here, that is the case in every military.
However, that you are supposed to provide your own medical supplies, body armor and helmet is just insane. And impossible for most consrcipts.
The lack of training / bad quality training is another thing.
And again, we do not need to rely on foreign sources. Just check the footage that was shown in Russias television. Footage they recorced themselves and chose to be shown to the russian people. What we can see there is very sub-par.
And somehow I doubt they chose the worst example to sho won TV. Don't you agree that they probably chose some of the best to show on TV?
If what we see there is sub-par, what do you think the rest will look like in average?
Right, much worse.
There are way too many sources to dismiss them all as fake. And what we see in official russian TV reinforces the view that there is a lot of stuff seriously wrong in the mobilisation, the equipment and the training of the conscripts.
@@wedgeantilles8575 by no means I said that all of it was fake. However, the rusty AK and the huge losses in 115th, for example, were. However, you are correct about the body armour and other equipment situation. It is a tragic situation when one is going back to active duty (not being conscripted) and is rolling the dice on the armour plates.
As for poor training, that is a bit of an exaggeration. Firstly, check the criteria for this mobilization. The mobilised are the ones who have a military specialisation and/or combat experience. That criteria excludes those who peeled potatoes, trained in pen-lifting and piloted in paper plane airforce.
As for the sources of fakes: as you may be aware, there is a lawyer of society who is against Putin. Those are very active in social media and being the opposition, they try to get more people on their side. The easiest way for them to do it is by showing and exaggerating the worst of things, painting the picture that everything is bad. There is a term for them and the things they say, roughly translated as "everythingisdoomed". For example, some rich kid hits someone with a car. If police arrest and detain him in prison, those people will criticise Putin's police for being heavy-handed. If that person will not be detained in custody until court date, the same people will criticise Putin's police for being lenient to the rich kid. So, if someone from that layer of society is ordered back to active duty, they will do what they usually do. Their videos (sometimes fake, sometimes exaggerated, something absolutely correct and sometimes something that should have been addressed through the chain of command and easily fixed) usually find their way to Western commentantators (like this RUclips channel). However, the proof of the issues raised in the videos being rectified does not find it's way to the same Western commentantators, neither does proof that the videos were fake. It is understandable why, as Western commentantators prefer to stick with "Russia is about to fall apart" line of thought.
This was one of your best videos so far, thank you 👍🏻
Totally off topic but I really like the District 9 shirt.
Pretty good video.. the cell phone is the new telegraph..
Great Videos, but RUclips just messes your videos up. Thank you for actually handing out this info because I am actually interested in this topic and your videos help a lot with all my topics that interest me, And thank you for your service in iraq.
it's unfortunately something I have to deal with all the time. I'm trying to get better at staying friendly to a wide audience. I appreciate your support thank you for watching .
@@Taskandpurpose Another Great Video! You should Really watch this video, it explains a LOT behind Russia Blaffing Decisions in this War, why they Keep making the same mistakes and explains it's entire Military really and exactly how their army were so Completely unprepared for the Ukraine Wa and everyone in their Military kind of always knew that: ruclips.net/video/Fz59GWeTIik/видео.html
@@Taskandpurpose You are welcome! Keep up the good content man!
Excellent video Cappy thanks for all your hard work
17 minutes 20 seconds in I think I see the cheapest rifle ever made the Hi-Point carbine.
Speaking as a russian, I do have a way harsher view of this conscripts. The point of "well if they refuse they will be kept in the basement" which is first of all preferable to commiting war crimes, but that aside, that's only true if you are already in the war zone and then you refuse. The point is refusing before you go. See, the thing is, they can't really do much to you back at home. Also the military recruitment office keeps all their records on paper with an address you had at birth. You can literally move next door and you're dead to them. There are currently talks about modernising this system, but as it stands now it's non existent (and considering how many IT engineers left the country probably will never exist). So yes, every single person that's in there is there by their own volition, they can save their "I only followed orders" for the Hague.
Won't they send you to prison if you refuse to go?
Also, how feasible is it for the average young person to move next door (or anywhere for that matter) to avoid the draft?
@@Ignozi No they won't. They can only send you to prison if you are already considered an active personnel. And for it to happen you have to go to your military conscription office. Otherwise at worst - it's just fines, and even then it'll happen only if they have a hard proof that you're avoiding the draft. That being said, bear in mind that in Russia, if some official will get a hard on for you for some reason - you'll go down, the letter of the law does not really apply. But, majority of people are not that interesting and no one going to care that much about them.
How feasible it is for anyone to just move next door - for the majority of people it is extraordinarily easy. Bear in mind that Russia is a country with a high rate of home ownership, a lot of families have multiple apartments and summer houses. And even if you don't have that - chances are someone in your family does. And if they don't, you just go outside of big cities and get a flat for a price of the pack of gum and a worn shoe. You have to be ridiculously unfortunate for it to not be an option.
Even if all of that would not be true - going to prison is still preferable.
That was really interesting. Haven't seen the topic covered as well as this video. Well done. More like this 👍
So good to see the video redone, couldnt stop thinking about this while watching the prior version
What can I say? War is hell. Forced to fight your relatives and friends. To be dragged away to a death sentence or worse insanity and terror. You would just have to except the situation in the end. Then you have to work out who is your enemy and give your best to destroy that enemy; whomever you decide is your enemy. What a thing to say!
This was a great video. There was quite a few less jokes but really got down to the knit and Grit and even spoke through the fog of War. Fantastic.
the shot of you behind putin has got to be the best editing in any youtube channel.
not sure if you covered it but in addition to focusing on low income civilians for "recruitment" other Russian subcultures that aren't the mainstream "Russian" are also more heavily recruited. We think of European and Asian nations as monocultures, but in reality there's plenty of secondary groups. Chinese Huighers is a great example, but both Russian and China have several subgroups within their borders, including discrete languages
Partied with a bunch of Russian’s during the World Junior Hockey Championship. I often wonder if they are fighting
I get that you added updated information. Could you please do us a favour and date your videos.
Can’t believe your video got demonetised, just keep on pressing forward your content is always 10/10
The channel is pro-Ukraine and therefore pro-democrat money laundering also, not sure why GOOGLE would demonetise this...🤔
Lots of pro putin biden democrats
it seems that when trolls report videos, youtube puts the burden of proof on the victims.
even when there is a history of spam troll reports.
this is not surprising at all, as many authoritarian governments are making use of the system to harass youtubers telling the truth.
and they will continue to do it for as long as it bears fruit.
some youtubers upon challenging the demonetizations are getting told their video has been thoroughly re-revied, and the call stands... even if they are responding ~7 minutes after the request for review over a 30+ min video.
china uncensored (a channel about the abuses of power of the chinese communist party) would have been entirely killed but for patreon, since it's youtube revenue has been eviscerated.
every video now tells you when the commercial breaks are, so you can track if trolls have been successful at demonitizing it.
Russian bots flag unflattering videos on mass which causes age restriction - end result you need a YT account to watch the video
@@Mwwwwwwwwe it's even worse than that MA
youtube completely stops promoting the video as well, and it completely kills the view count from then forward.
and it's even worse than that.
having your videos age restricted makes your entire account look worse, because there are fewer views and interaction on your account, so they promote your other videos less too.
and even if you win, you lose, because if you video is un-agerestricted, it's too late, as the critical watch period has passed, and you won't get the views you were going to get, just later. your reach is eviscerated by the trolls, even if you win.
but if you download videos, youtube assumes you watched the whole thing, so you can go download and delete and redownload a bunch of his videos to help offset the scumbags
I like your videos, very sharp analysis and I think they are thorough and well put together. Looking back on your previous videos they also seem very accurate.
I doubt Russia will pay all their troops.
This is one of the best videos I've seen from this channel. I realize there was a lot of thought put into it.
Oh this is a year old. K. Get it now
@23:50 I knew the Russian units were understrength, but I didn't know how bad it was till you mentioned that a company is just two men.
I spent 4 months in Russia in 2016. _Everybody_ said war with Ukraine was just fratricide. Everyone was sad about the conflict as it was back then. There was one old lady who was originally from Balaklava, Crimea, who was very happy that Crimea was back in Russia, but even she was still sad that there was fighting against Ukrainians.
Bingo. There's the problem. That lady identifies as Russian. Maybe she should go to Russia
I expected that he would annex those regions and that would be it but not the war itself.
@@TmackSD184 Crimea was Russia before it was gifted by Khrushchev to Ukraine.
@@TmackSD184 You misread what I said. She was born in Crimea, she was living in Russia. She was an ethnic Cossack and had spent most of her life in Rostov-on-Don where she had worked as an engineer before she retired. She probably moved to Rostov before Crimea was transferred to Ukraine. She definitely identified as Cossack first, then Russian, then Crimean. But the point is that even she, the closest I got to encountering someone who was an exception, while happy that Crimea was back to being Russian territory, was sad that Russia was fighting Ukraine, and viewed war between the two as nothing but fratricide. And I got a lot of people's opinions about it. _Every single time_ I got out of a taxi the driver would grab me by the ankle and plead with me "when you go back to the West, tell everyone: we never wanted the war". The only time I got out of a taxi and that didn't happen, the driver had already told me 5 minutes into the journey. And I took a lot of taxis - the premium tier taxis on Yandex Taxi were cheaper than buses are in England.
The point is that what he said about these young Russians being ripped away from their lives and sent to fight in a war they don't want to be in is exactly right. It's exactly like the old Cossack lady's grandfather who fought in the civil war for the Red Army and the White Army and the Red Army. He didn't want any part of it, most of them didn't. Most of what most of the people who were conscripted to fight the civil war did was just shoot their own brothers and cousins purely because they lived in the next town over, and they didn't have a choice. The state their morale will be in it's amazing the Russian military has done as well as it has.
@@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311 and before that it was ukrainian.
thats like me stealing your shit, givjng it back to you and then 5 years later show up and steal it again and when people complain i tell them i gave it to you in the first place.
absolutely fucking disgusting that people keep regurgitating this revisionist propaganda.
Thank you for the nuance and knowledgeable analysis. Some of the best coverage around
based on what? not trying to be rude here but how do you assume hes correct?
Your presentation and analysis are great, i have also seen an interesting analysis on the mobilization regarding future generational problems for Russian economy and labor force, no matter how it ends the damage to future generations of people to grow the economy etc had already started with deaths of people in the wars in Chechnya and is now being accelerated by the Russian losses in Ukraine..
@Taskandpurpose can you make a video about what happend in your point of view and your experience during your military service in iraqi war?
I love your compassion with all the people. Not just your allies. Hope this demonetised video does not do you any harm and that you will continue with commenting on this situation with your personal view and experience ❤️
You can't compare the surrender of a voluntary enlistment to the unwillingness of participants called up by this mobilization. Two completely different situations. But I'm really happy that you're discussing the conscription practices that's taking place in Russia.
I heard that 120,00 volunteers signed up
@@anthonyhowrard526 Good for them, i'm referring to the people who didn't
@@theterminaldave Those people should have fought back. Oh well.. they are doomed now.
@@0816M3RC good luck "fighting back" against an authoritarian regime. There's a reason why they stay in power for so long, and it's not because they take kindly to people fighting back.
You can not compare Russian draftees with 2 weeks training and thrown into combat with some not even that. With American Vietnam era draftees with 6 weeks basic training and additional infantry or specialized training
Thank you for the update. Much appreciated. It's both sad and infuriating to watch all the cruelty the Russians are doing to innocent people who just want to live their lives in freedom. I hope the day will come when Putin pays for his crimes, and there are too many to count at this point.
I appreciate your cogent & lucid analysis! You have an excellent ability to pull together many divergent threads to make an understandable story! Thanks
Did you swallow a dictionary?😬
I love the historical context that contrasts the individual level weapons/gear review! Great balance and very timely.