IKR. Nor was the meal the only scene where Shmi and Padme were together. So it would be more like: "Mom, remember Padme, that girl that was with Qui-Gon and Jar-Jar?"
@@moscanaveiamakes him look incompetent if 100s of people are working on something and nobody, not ONE person caught such a mistake before it's being read. It's like common knowledge, and the guy is CERTAINLY not the best dude for the job if he as director didn't catch it, and the person who wrote it isn't the best person for the job either, the person who touched up the script-same thing, all the other people that read that line and didn't force the change, same thing. This is proof to the millions of Star Wars fans that gave up that incompetents are working on it now, the production team is stacked with people who have less passion than a low-moderate fan.
@@moscanaveia A not serious mistake is still a mistake. A mistake being made by a group of people dealing with a multi million dollar franchise and such a 'minor mistake' in continuity shouldn't be happening on a series that doesn't have all that much in the way of official canon to begin with. Little mistakes add up over time. It shows a level of incompetence on behalf of the entire team involved and the company that owns it. If the company can't even keep their own shit straight, what does that say about them? This is been the problem with Star Wars ever since Disney got ahold of it. They can't even keep their own shit in order then goons online try to blame the audience who actually DOES care about the property for being 'nitpickers' for pointing out these so called 'small mistakes' that, if they were 'so small', shouldn't have even happened in the first place if the people in charge gave half a shit to proof read and give a quick cross reference to material that came before it. But yes, we the consumer are the problem. Not the multi billion dollar company who just can't be arsed to proof read their products.
Agreed but unfortunately that's probably why they wont get more work. They care just as much as the rest of us about the source material and because it goes against the hive mind of hollyweird, they're punished for it.
@@BansheeKing22 while i agree sam and cavill are good for when it comes to respecting the source material cavill has fallen to hollyweird when he dated his barely legal ex girlfriend people forget no celeb in hollywood is safe when they try to become famous they fall sooner or later sadly
and to be fair, you can still say, "i have a wife, i want you to meet her" and it be someone they already know from long ago So long as that part is addressed like "Wait a moment, i recognise you from that day anakin left!" So really, the line was probably fine
We're doing too much acrobatics to justify what is or would be a continuity error. "Technically correct" in this case is synonymous with "bad writing."
@@jasonlewis3742 Kind of, basically see how we're talking about it and sorta debating whether it was necessary? times that by 10000x if they'd left it in and the star wars fans found out.
No, this is why you hire competent writer's who research the existing content...Sam shouldn't have been the one to catch such a glaringly obvious plot hole.
@@phantomx2603 I mean shit happens. When you're creating a lot of new stuff that has to be connected to a lot of existing stuff sometimes you're going to miss something. What separates the good from the bad is when people in the room are comfortable enough to speak up that something isn't right and the people in charge are secure enough to listen to them.
@@JNArnold That sounds like the excuses of a writer. It's a well know franchise, this is plot hole is from the one of the MAIN films of the franchise. If you as a writer, couldn't have picked that up before getting to a table read, you don't deserve to be in that job
@@JNArnoldnah as a writer if you forget something that happened in front of your eyes in a main line movie, not some obscure deleted scene, or book nobody read, you deserved to get fired. With those guidelines all of Disney would have no writers. That’s how bad they are.
Nope. Not emotional. It's a cartoon. Saw a homeless teenager the other day. Now that's emotional. Or did you sheep forget what it means to turn off the TV and be human.
@@cwest394yes in an irl sense it means nothing but this is something that came out years ago and to some of us fans it's an emotional scene the problem being is your comparing fiction from reality kids being homeless isn't emotional it's sad there is a difference and no one should be homeless yet here you are commenting about it rather than doing something you and many others like you are what is wrong with this planet
Sam Witwer is an underrated legend. He made us control him in Force Unleashed. HE WAS DOOMSDAY and fought Superman in Smallville. And he gave us an amazing Darth Maul. He deserves more recognition in the industry.
One of my absolute favorite lines was one of Sam's as The Son in the Mortis arc. It's something along the lines of "He was just being so selfish and takibg too long to die, so I tried to help him" lol It's so dark, but I love it
Sam Witwer deserves a live action role. He has such a passion for Star Wars that just can’t be beaten. The fact that Disney hasn’t greenlit anything for him is such a shame.
Disney doesn’t care about star wars they care about money and profit and have a audience full of impressionable kids who will consume whatever they put out no matter what
Can we PLEASE have a live action series or movie with Sam Witwer as Starkiller? He’s such a passionate Star Wars fan and he deserves that honor. We have a great opportunity to have Starkiller in canon as an Inquisitor! Let’s not waste this! Lucasfilm, come on!!! 🤞
No way, not an inquisitor. If it’s star killer then it should be his original character as Vadors secret apprentice. They could do the story as him being some kind of force sensitive super clone to more specifically explain his powers.
If they have to de-power him and make him an inquisitor, I don't want it. I would much rather they just make legends shows/films that don't have to be connected to the main timeline and then we could have an actual real starkiller film/show
I can't believe they haven't made any live action with Starkiller. Look at all the crappie they are willing to do with "original" Disney characters. How can they not see how popular Starkiller would be.
@@InTheFastLain The way Disney is right now, I'd rather they didn't. And if they did, I'm sure they would make Starkiller into a patriarchy smashing feminist, and then she and Juno could be a lesbian couple.
Clancy Brown has ruined my experience of Detroit: Become Human. The game is supposed to give you all these different paths you can take in the game and wildly different outcomes. Connor can kill Hank at one point in the game, or drive him to self-deletion. But I can never do it. Hank is my guy, and the only other path I can find for Connor other than being bros for life, is to make him wildly incompetent at helping Hank solve his cases. Hank hates me, but I can take that hit for you. This is for your own good, buddy.
He forgot it, not that he didn’t know. Even your favorite Star Wars RUclipsr forgets basic facts about the franchise sometimes. Now imagine remembering every single detail of Star Wars every day and you’re responsible for production of a project and all that entails. You’re bound to slip up…at least he didn’t think Anakin blew up the Death Star or some shit like that
@@stonemanofgardnerville1162 The inhibitor chips annoy me so much. Why not just have the clones be totally obedient, like was intended with the movies. They simply are so good soldiers, they dont question their orders. They are also basically child soldiers, so forget about wisdom. And yes bonds to the Jedi they fought side-by-side with but is it really that much different to just say a few of them grew a conscience but most of them just dont question their commander in chief?
@@Sco10Karen Traviss had Order 66 down so freaking well… a lot of the Clones were embittered slave soldiers with not much love lost for the Jedi. Add to that the classical conditioning they were put through, ESPECIALLY some of their specialists like ARC troopers, it was a lot less of a hacky way to portray their betrayal of the Jedi than the ‘inhibitor chip’ nonsense.
Nah, when working on a really big project, it's easy to forget things. Honestly, it's easier to remember things when you are criticizing someone else's work...
This is why it’s good to have a full team who are all knowledgeable and passionate about the source material of their projects, they can count on each other to stop mistakes like these
The Force Unleashed wasn't a good story, and Starkiller wasn't a good character. The whole point of the game was for players to go apesh*t with the crazy superpowers. Hence the title. Starkiller was merely a vessel to do that. It worked fine as a game, but neither the novel, nor the comic was either enjoyable, or thought provoking, proving that it's not a story worth adapting into different mediums.
I didn't know this guy still had a career. I've only ever seen him as the human side of Doomsday in Smallville. Horrible character, but memorable actor. A decade later or something and I still remember him. Very expressive eyes.
@@dm_ex_machina3395 Sam actually has a pretty solid career, most of it’s just off the camera and in the recording booth. He’s best known for voicing Darth Maul, Starkiller from The Force Unleashed and Deacon St. John from Days Gone
That takes balls can't imagine it would be easy to do, even if it was a super obvious reference it's like telling the VP of a company while being a new executive that he's wrong. Kudos.
You shouldn’t be fit for any job if you don’t point out mistakes someone is making even if it’s a ceo or manager. Sam saved Dave from making a really embarrassing mistake when it comes to Star Wars law. Fans would have roasted the episode
because a conscientious leader would be able to play it off. It doesn't matter that Shmi met Padme before. What matters is that NOW, Padme is Anakin's wife - which wasn't the case when they first met
it does matter. it matters because every moment of every dialogue is a precious thing with very limited time, and every line of dialogue needs deep meaning to actually enrich the audiences experience.
@Megaman-fe2ib Imagine Disney would allow us to have Legends movies! Completely unrelated to their Canon, but gives us the stories we've craved to see on the big screen. That'd be so cool, but we know Disney will never do it.
And even if Shmi didnt know the true identity of Padme at that time, they still met. So Anakin would be more inclined to say "You've actually met her before".
@@John-fk2ky so, she is almost 18 and met a 12 year old boy that later became her lover... let's be honest here, kinda weird. Even though the fact only happens when both are adults, it's still morally questionable if analysing from a psychological perspective.
@@FDJUwenot really, the boy had a crush on the girl, but even on earth little kids always have celebrity crushes etc of people older than them. She had no interest in the kid. Fast forward all the years for episode 2. Anakin forced into a life of no relationships and attachments, only having his memory of a girl he had a crush on, then meets her when properly aged. And that's when padme starts falling for anakin. I get some people might see it as weird, but I honestly don't think it's that weird. If padme had a crush on anakin in episode 1, then yes I'd agree it's weird. But she very clearly didn't romantically like anakin, she just thought he was a sweet kid in a slave world
@@FDJUwe It's not weird at all. Anakin at the time was 9 and Padme was 14. That's only a 5 year difference which isn't weird at all especially considering the average age gap between couples is 6 years. My in laws are 6 years apart in age so I know this is a real thing.
Now this is someone who truly loves Star Wars. Sam Witwer deserves all the praise for his contribution to the franchise. I can't decide which one of his roles I love more, Starkiller, or Darth Maul.
@@Malak1man lol good one! Bahaha. As a littlwnkid it was my favorite but the older I get the more I appreciate 3 the most in the prequels and actually enjoy the original trilogy the most
Tbh shmi and Padme only share like 2 or 3 scenes together in the phantom menace so I can understand how people can forget they actually shared screen time. Xx
Dude i didn't realize that. And yeah he did look and sound so familiar. Such an underrated game when it came out. Articles written on it started with political smear like how Deacon treated his wife to affectionately or commented on her ass "objecting" her. Then other articles came out saying that theres nothing really going on in rural Oregon and it's therefore a weird and boring choice to make for the games setting, something i absolutely disagree with even from a practical standpoint as cities would become death traps in a zombie apocalypse, but regardless i really enjoyed the fresh take on a zombie game including it's setting. Took so long for people to realize the game was actually good that any hopes the studio had for a sequel were dashed by then. This is one major reason i Don't listen to game articles anymore especially if it has any political arguments being tossed around. Sorry that a husband flirting on his wife causes you pain enough to write an article about it lol, hope she found someone to give her that affection she obviously craved
@@red-merlin That is actually when I stopped listening to what game reviews had to say. All the negative fuss about game glitches and bugs when all that got patched in the next few weeks.
Dave also straight up brought characters back from the dead like Adi Gallia and Eeth Koth, while also choosing to kill characters who were still alive like Evan Piell. Also thanks to Dave Barris went from being a respectable Jedi Knight healer to a traitorous Padawan who was somehow allowed to come back only to die on Kashyyyk during Order 66. A lot of Legends “inconsistencies” were because he went out of his way to ignore Leland Chee when he warned him about continuity mistakes.
George himself oversaw the creation of the Clone Wars, and fans like to forget George never took the EU seriously. He adopted some shit for cosmetic effect, like Anakin's scar, but discarded pretty much everything that he didn't come up with in the first place.
Comic book continuity for the Clone Wars was its own thing, has its own merits, but the higher canonicity of Filoni's work is just the franchise creator's own preference in the end
He probably will be eventually but right now he’s still younger than Dave. Dave made an honest mistake so I can’t blame him about it that’s what a team is for.
@@Darth_Arashino one’s blaming Dave, who wasn’t CCO at the time! Only that Sam would be on a level, if not more knowledgeable about Star Wars than Dave and Jon. All three of them together would produce some good soup.
Dave worked on SW for decades and decades and you see a 30 second video and want to give away his job? 😂 I'm going to put money on you're not in a job where you have power over people 😂😂
It's your focus right now, he had a million focuses. Not that hard to understand Mr perfect but is actually a dumbass that couldn't figure that out on his own
Bro Sam Witwer should get “the sabered hand” treatment and have Starkiller canonized but powered down a bit. Still plenty of room for it in the lore since he’s “the secret apprentice”.
Could bring him in as an Inquitor, whom Vader officially “killed off”, but secretly took to training as his own apprentice. I think he’d fit very well as the main antagonist in the 3rd EA Jedi: series. His interactions with Cal Kestis and Luke Skywalker would be really interesting.
Why would he even need to be powered down, considering what the last movie did with the force for why would he even need to be powered down, considering what the last movie did with the force for Palpatine and Ray, the force can be ultra powerful if we really want it to be. Who cares about Canon...RIGHT?!?!
I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment.
'Out-geek' Thats.... thats not like a minor detail.... like some hidden gem that only the deep geeks would know... how many layers did this process go through before this ?
well, i dont think her and Shmi exchanged 5 words, and the focus in that scene was on Qui-Gon and Anakin, so its pretty easy to forget they even were in the same room.
@@ЯАга-я4л I mean, yea, you could forget they were in the same room, but if I remember correctly, it also was on Tatooine that Anakin fell in love with Padme. Like she was some kind of angel from outer space.
Celune hat richtig abgerissen. Das Erzählstück über die Punisher im Altenheim war mit das witzigste was ich in nem Battle in letzter Zeit gehört hab. Und so ne Punchlinedichte hab ich überhaupt nicht erwartet. Die dritte Gänsehautrunde war die Kirsche auf der Sahnetorte. Krasser Sprung, gerne wieder Freekno hat mir auch super gefallen. Der schafft es mittlerweile auch durch Inhalte und nicht nur durch Performance zu glänzen. Und er packt sich auch schwere Themen an, ohne sich darin zu verlieren oder es komisch zu verpacken. Trifft nicht immer ganz meine Meinung aber sehr schlüssig ausformuliert Gerne wieder Super Battle, beide mit absoluter Bestleistung
Also, Padmé returned to Tattooine, after TPM and becoming a senator, to work with Shmi and invent devices that would disarm and remove the explosive implants that all the Slaves on Tattooine (and potentially other worlds as well) had. But secondly, it had been a long time since then, and Shmi never knew that Padmé and Anakin got married. So, if they had just explained that Anakin wanted to surprise his mother with the fact that he and Padmé were married, the original line would’ve worked perfectly. If they had had Anakin say “I want to introduce you to her”, then it would be wrong, but simply saying that he wants her to meet “his wife” would’ve been fine.
@@junkrat29boom40 They really aren't. Mando lost the plot before the first season finished and it went downhill sharply from there. Book of Boba was Mando season 2.5, Kenobi was an embarrassment, Ashoka I didn't watch because why bother when you haven't seen any of the animated stuff, and why watch the animated stuff when it's so terrible. At least at the start, I tried a few episodes and it was just bad saturday morning cartoon nonsense. Any of the rest I've forgotten or haven't even heard of. I've heard the name Bad Batch, but it doesn't mean anything to me. Then there's Andor. They made an actual TV show with actual characters, and told an actual story with them. Mindblowing.
@@QuinlanVoss.Dave was essentially a supervisor on the Clone Wars. His role was to make sure everything thing works, makes sense canonically, and just overall quality. Dave Filoni didn't write much of anything except for 2 episodes of the entire Clone Wars run. So while op's statement could be argued, it is not entirely false.
Dave Filoni taking off the hat and deciding to keep hiring him after getting saved from such a simple fandom plot hole trap is amazing. Filoni probably sweating bullets over such a simple slipup that would've had blogs and fans tearing him apart online for YEARS
Yeah, he only created Cad Bane, Rex, Fives, the Bad Batch, Kanan, Ezra, Hondo, Embo, Admiral Trench, Pre Vizsla, Savage Opress, General Krell, Captain Mar Tuuk, Cham Syndulla etc etc...
When the Corvette pulls up behind you to grid it apmost sounds like a geiger counter ticking. I thought the imagery of the dark grey vette being a radioactive monster hunting you was pretty cool!
I mean Dave feloni didn't mess up. She met padme as a young girl and while anakin was a child. Shmi doesn't know her as his wife yet. Still could've been used.
George has one foot in the grave. We need people like Sam or Henry Cavil, or hell, even Elon bloody Musk, to start making things. If that trio collaborated... man, could you even imagine?
In all fairness, Shmi met Padme when she was the queen of Naboo (or technically a handmaiden in disguise). Not Anakins girlfriend, or even as senator of Naboo. She wouldn’t have known Anakin was dating, let alone married. Padme was his wife. She never met wife Padme. It’d be like if I left home, didn’t stay in contact, got married, and showed up back home with a childhood friend as my wife. “I’d like you to meet my wife” still works.
So you marry someone your family is familiar with and you reintroduce her? She would leave you because I’d make you the household joke for eternity. Your logic is heavily flawed. Same person, different title. Titles don’t change who the person is. Titles don’t change relationships or memories. A title does change anything. 😂😂
@@WilliamGeorge-l2n i guarantee you my dad wouldn’t remember everyone I knew when I was 9 years old. “Dad, this is my friend Padme from elementary school. She kicked me in kindergarten. She came over for a few birthday parties”. He’d need to have a brief rundown of how he knew her. You have to remember Shmi met Padme once 10 years ago. They ate, but they hardly spoke. Padme grew up, changed physically.
@@jackshiels1206he also played Darth sidious/emperor palpatine in the game and rebels, also he voiced animated maul. Super talented guy, I wish he was the one in charge of star wars.
If Disney Lucasfilm wants to survive they’d give Sam Witwer more jobs. Acting, yea, but consulting on the writing too. This guy is a genuine fan, and we need more genuine fans making Star Wars, like Dave Filoni, like Jon Favreux. More of them, less of the bums who pay it lip service to land a lucrative and prestigious job.
What sucks is that producers, writers, and directors don't like it when somebody corrects them or "undermines them". This is why Henry Cavill left The Witcher. The 1st season he corrected the directors and writers constantly, which is why the 1st season is so amazing. But subsequent seasons they listened to him less and less, until he was just like "fuck it, either pay me a shit load of $$ or I'm gone". I'm not worried about Liam Hemsworth being a bad Geralt, I'm worried about the writers and directors giving him horrible direction and dialogue
Not Dave. This clip proved it prior, but after the Ashoka series, Filoni showed he doesn't care about Star Wars that HE didn't create. He is the epitome of "I'm angry that I didn't create that so I will destroy lore to make MY creations seem better."
@@domesticdragonwafflewhat?? How has he destroyed anything by explaining the force the way George Lucas had it in the original films? Like you just seem to be on the bandwagon of nonsense. I feel like no matter who is making what you’ll have problems because you didn’t do it.
Ironically, this error shows why Dave Faloni typically makes well-liked shows. While an egotistical showrunner would have brushed that comment off or fired him over that comment, Dave looked at Sam Witiwer's correction and thought, "I need him in my corner." Every writer makes mistakes, yet only good ones accept criticism and grow.
@@MON_KEY.I mean people usually cite The Clone Wars in much higher regard than Episode I, so it's not like he isn't respected. If Dave didn't care about the source material, he wouldn't have listened to Sam Witwer.
@@BatAmerica that's because George Lucas had involvement in The Clone Wars and most of it was made before Disneys purchase. If you look at shows Dave is involved with now they are very mediocre in comparison
@@MON_KEY. By that logic, George Lucas should be the only person who does great work despite Andor and The Mandalorian (Seasons 1-2) being made without his insight. Also, George had nothing to do with Rebels or Tales of the Jedi.
@@BatAmerica that makes no sense and filoni had nothing to do with andor, and barely anything to do with the mandalorian. Rebels was one of the worst pieces of Star Wars media out there, resistance was awful, ahsoka was awful, tales of the empire was awful, tales of the Jedi was mediocre at best. I never said George was the only one capable of creating good content, it certainly helps when the actual creator is around supervising and making decisions though.
What’s funny is that this wasn’t even an obscure reference at all
IKR. Nor was the meal the only scene where Shmi and Padme were together. So it would be more like: "Mom, remember Padme, that girl that was with Qui-Gon and Jar-Jar?"
Right! It's basic knowledge.
Filoni pulled the wool over everyone. He is and has been a hack the whole time.
@@Habu12 I have been saying this for YEARS
Shows how little Filoni cares about continuity which sucks
I feel like he was trying for very emotional moment and completely overlooked that detail
Dave taking his hat off realizing what a bullet he barely dodged
Because that breaks the plot right? Such a serious mistake it is
@@moscanaveiamakes him look incompetent if 100s of people are working on something and nobody, not ONE person caught such a mistake before it's being read. It's like common knowledge, and the guy is CERTAINLY not the best dude for the job if he as director didn't catch it, and the person who wrote it isn't the best person for the job either, the person who touched up the script-same thing, all the other people that read that line and didn't force the change, same thing. This is proof to the millions of Star Wars fans that gave up that incompetents are working on it now, the production team is stacked with people who have less passion than a low-moderate fan.
Typical Dave Filoni moment. This what happens when George is gone
@@moscanaveia A not serious mistake is still a mistake. A mistake being made by a group of people dealing with a multi million dollar franchise and such a 'minor mistake' in continuity shouldn't be happening on a series that doesn't have all that much in the way of official canon to begin with.
Little mistakes add up over time. It shows a level of incompetence on behalf of the entire team involved and the company that owns it. If the company can't even keep their own shit straight, what does that say about them?
This is been the problem with Star Wars ever since Disney got ahold of it. They can't even keep their own shit in order then goons online try to blame the audience who actually DOES care about the property for being 'nitpickers' for pointing out these so called 'small mistakes' that, if they were 'so small', shouldn't have even happened in the first place if the people in charge gave half a shit to proof read and give a quick cross reference to material that came before it.
But yes, we the consumer are the problem. Not the multi billion dollar company who just can't be arsed to proof read their products.
Black Mesa!!!!! HL3 confirmed!
Dude has a Black Mesa shirt as well. Legend.
What's Black Mesa? Is that a music band or some kind of video game
@@tsohgallik Black Mesa is the fictonal science research facility from the game Half-Life.
@@tsohgallikLooks like you’re not out-geeking anyone around here buddy
Yep! When I noticed I was like: WTF!? I want one of those! now!
@@tsohgallik Half-Life facility go boom boom
He is StarKiller, voices Darth Maul and wears a Black Mesa shirt.
I just love him
He sounds like Anakin in clone wars though and I wouldn't mind seeing him as Anakin if not for hayden
he's just like Alyx Vance fr!
Also voiced sidious
He is also in the 2005 Battlestar Galactica.
He will always be Deacon St John to me
We need more actors like Sam Witwer and Henry Cavill. They have so much respect for the source material
Agreed but unfortunately that's probably why they wont get more work. They care just as much as the rest of us about the source material and because it goes against the hive mind of hollyweird, they're punished for it.
@@BansheeKing22 you mean hollywoke
The guy is wearing a Black Mesa T-shirt, so he's okay in my book.
They should team up
@@BansheeKing22 while i agree sam and cavill are good for when it comes to respecting the source material cavill has fallen to hollyweird when he dated his barely legal ex girlfriend
people forget no celeb in hollywood is safe when they try to become famous they fall sooner or later sadly
I get the confusion though. Shmi didnt mean Padmé when they were married. But she did meet her nonetheless
and to be fair,
you can still say, "i have a wife, i want you to meet her" and it be someone they already know from long ago
So long as that part is addressed like "Wait a moment, i recognise you from that day anakin left!"
So really, the line was probably fine
We're doing too much acrobatics to justify what is or would be a continuity error. "Technically correct" in this case is synonymous with "bad writing."
@@DishyLemonSo you mean it's true... From a certain point of view?
@@jasonlewis3742 Kind of, basically see how we're talking about it and sorta debating whether it was necessary? times that by 10000x if they'd left it in and the star wars fans found out.
@@SambaJones97would have made more sense if anakin asked his mother if she remembered padme from way back, and then reveal the marriage
And this is why you get actors who are 100% invested.
No, this is why you hire competent writer's who research the existing content...Sam shouldn't have been the one to catch such a glaringly obvious plot hole.
@@phantomx2603 I mean shit happens. When you're creating a lot of new stuff that has to be connected to a lot of existing stuff sometimes you're going to miss something. What separates the good from the bad is when people in the room are comfortable enough to speak up that something isn't right and the people in charge are secure enough to listen to them.
Never go full method actor
@@JNArnold That sounds like the excuses of a writer.
It's a well know franchise, this is plot hole is from the one of the MAIN films of the franchise. If you as a writer, couldn't have picked that up before getting to a table read, you don't deserve to be in that job
@@JNArnoldnah as a writer if you forget something that happened in front of your eyes in a main line movie, not some obscure deleted scene, or book nobody read, you deserved to get fired. With those guidelines all of Disney would have no writers. That’s how bad they are.
Shmi and Padme also watched the pod race together along with Qui-Gon.
Wait was shmi there for that?
@@yulabbott6317yes she was. if I remember correctly it was Padme Shmi Qui Gon and I swear there was a forth like C-3PO I’m not to sure
@@venomxfallx1743 - Jar-Jar. Threepio carried Anakin's flag out onto the field before the race started.
Nope. Not emotional. It's a cartoon.
Saw a homeless teenager the other day.
Now that's emotional. Or did you sheep forget what it means to turn off the TV and be human.
@@cwest394yes in an irl sense it means nothing but this is something that came out years ago and to some of us fans it's an emotional scene the problem being is your comparing fiction from reality kids being homeless isn't emotional it's sad there is a difference and no one should be homeless yet here you are commenting about it rather than doing something you and many others like you are what is wrong with this planet
Finally someone who calls out inconsistencies before they are filmed.
When Starkiller "um, actually" Dave Filloni
Give him a goddamn cameo.
@@JnEricsonxhe voices Maul as well in the cartoons
@@RusoOutOfContext I mean a live action one.
@@JnEricsonxAshoka he... Could... Be in there... If they continue it .. 👀👀👀
@@ambuknight *Ahsoka, and by that time Maul is dead, and Starkiller is non canon.
Sam Witwer is an underrated legend. He made us control him in Force Unleashed. HE WAS DOOMSDAY and fought Superman in Smallville. And he gave us an amazing Darth Maul. He deserves more recognition in the industry.
One of my absolute favorite lines was one of Sam's as The Son in the Mortis arc. It's something along the lines of "He was just being so selfish and takibg too long to die, so I tried to help him" lol It's so dark, but I love it
Being Human was a good live action show. He was amazing as a young vampire
Also a great Palpatine in Unleashed.
Crazy part is I didn’t even recognize him from any of these rolls but instead as him being the fake ice truck killer on season 1 of Dexter lol
He was the best in Being Human@@zacharyash2050
As if I couldn't love this guy more, he has a Black Mesa t-shirt
Sam Witwer deserves a live action role. He has such a passion for Star Wars that just can’t be beaten. The fact that Disney hasn’t greenlit anything for him is such a shame.
He was the shore trooper on niamos in Andor... But yes... He needs a bigger one but done by competent people and not Filoni
Disney doesn’t care about star wars they care about money and profit and have a audience full of impressionable kids who will consume whatever they put out no matter what
He was the vampire guy in the american version of Being Human
But he's not a female or person of color, so Disney won't hire him for a new STar Wars movie
He was also in my sexy dream last night
W for the Black Mesa shirt
W
Glad I wasn't the only one
Rise and shine, Master Skywalker
im glad more noticed
That was a joke. Haha. Fat chance.
Anyway, this cake is great. So delicious and moist!
🎂
Can we PLEASE have a live action series or movie with Sam Witwer as Starkiller? He’s such a passionate Star Wars fan and he deserves that honor. We have a great opportunity to have Starkiller in canon as an Inquisitor! Let’s not waste this! Lucasfilm, come on!!! 🤞
No way, not an inquisitor. If it’s star killer then it should be his original character as Vadors secret apprentice. They could do the story as him being some kind of force sensitive super clone to more specifically explain his powers.
If they have to de-power him and make him an inquisitor, I don't want it. I would much rather they just make legends shows/films that don't have to be connected to the main timeline and then we could have an actual real starkiller film/show
@@prismatic9890yes.
Starkiller got crazy powered in the second game.
I am hoping Sam can do something before he gets too old.
Inquisitors are straight trash
They'd make him gay now..... he'd be the background character to a green haired they/them and somehow get saved by them.
Its funny cause sam witwer looks like the animated clone series version of anakin skywalker
fucking hell he kinda does hahah
He actually does though lmao
Great I cant unsee it now.
He is Starkiller
THAT'S WHY HE'S THE STARKILLER THE STARKILLER.!!!
I can't believe they haven't made any live action with Starkiller. Look at all the crappie they are willing to do with "original" Disney characters. How can they not see how popular Starkiller would be.
@@InTheFastLain The way Disney is right now, I'd rather they didn't. And if they did, I'm sure they would make Starkiller into a patriarchy smashing feminist, and then she and Juno could be a lesbian couple.
I was wondering why he looked so familiar. Thats awesome
@@InTheFastLainstarkiller literally cannot be made canon. He killed half the main SW cast in his games.
@@tempest8920 Starkiller is Canon at least as a Deathstar
Bro really pulled the "well actually☝️🤓"
Sam's passion for Star Wars is really fantastic to see, I trust any project he or Clancy Brown are part of.
Clancy brown is the goat
Good old mr crabs
Hell yea Clancy Brown aka The Kurgan!
Clancy Brown has ruined my experience of Detroit: Become Human.
The game is supposed to give you all these different paths you can take in the game and wildly different outcomes. Connor can kill Hank at one point in the game, or drive him to self-deletion. But I can never do it. Hank is my guy, and the only other path I can find for Connor other than being bros for life, is to make him wildly incompetent at helping Hank solve his cases. Hank hates me, but I can take that hit for you. This is for your own good, buddy.
@@TheSchaef47thought you really did hate hank in dbh lol
Sam is a gift to the Star Wars community
He truly is. They should have him head any project if they really wanted to make money.
The video game community
@@Ashtor1337im begging for a starkiller show that would be insane
Sam Witwer should have been named CEO of Lucasfilm instead of Kathleen Kennedy!!
Change my mind!!!!
That’s kinda worrying that they didn’t know that…
He forgot it, not that he didn’t know. Even your favorite Star Wars RUclipsr forgets basic facts about the franchise sometimes.
Now imagine remembering every single detail of Star Wars every day and you’re responsible for production of a project and all that entails.
You’re bound to slip up…at least he didn’t think Anakin blew up the Death Star or some shit like that
Nah dave folni fucked up A lot of star wars lore....inhibitor chips anyone@JakeTylenol
@@stonemanofgardnerville1162 The inhibitor chips annoy me so much. Why not just have the clones be totally obedient, like was intended with the movies. They simply are so good soldiers, they dont question their orders. They are also basically child soldiers, so forget about wisdom. And yes bonds to the Jedi they fought side-by-side with but is it really that much different to just say a few of them grew a conscience but most of them just dont question their commander in chief?
@@Sco10Karen Traviss had Order 66 down so freaking well… a lot of the Clones were embittered slave soldiers with not much love lost for the Jedi. Add to that the classical conditioning they were put through, ESPECIALLY some of their specialists like ARC troopers, it was a lot less of a hacky way to portray their betrayal of the Jedi than the ‘inhibitor chip’ nonsense.
Nah, when working on a really big project, it's easy to forget things.
Honestly, it's easier to remember things when you are criticizing someone else's work...
This is why it’s good to have a full team who are all knowledgeable and passionate about the source material of their projects, they can count on each other to stop mistakes like these
That awkward moment when you don't remember something a main character did
Filoni isn't the starwars savior people think he is.
Filoni is a furry degenerate
At least he didn’t forget that Natalie Portman played padme like how taika watiti did
@@Mike_____ you have anyone better?
Its a small detail and unless you're a super fan, it's easily forgotten. Most of Padmes, at least at the start of TPM, scenes weren't that memorable
The fact that we still don't have a movie about The Force Unleashed is baffling to me. Disney has no clue what to do with their IP's
It's not baffling, it's common sense. Wtf is the point of making a movie about a mid character?
The Force Unleashed wasn't a good story, and Starkiller wasn't a good character. The whole point of the game was for players to go apesh*t with the crazy superpowers. Hence the title. Starkiller was merely a vessel to do that. It worked fine as a game, but neither the novel, nor the comic was either enjoyable, or thought provoking, proving that it's not a story worth adapting into different mediums.
Love the fact that he's in the franchise for so long
fuckin nerd with his black mesa shirt lol. love it.
Agreed! Love half life!
I didn't know this guy still had a career. I've only ever seen him as the human side of Doomsday in Smallville. Horrible character, but memorable actor. A decade later or something and I still remember him. Very expressive eyes.
@@dm_ex_machina3395 He was also in a popular Sci-Fi channel show called "Being Human"
@@dm_ex_machina3395 Sam actually has a pretty solid career, most of it’s just off the camera and in the recording booth. He’s best known for voicing Darth Maul, Starkiller from The Force Unleashed and Deacon St. John from Days Gone
He's also in The Mist. Good movie.
Filoni must be super easy to "out geek"
That takes balls can't imagine it would be easy to do, even if it was a super obvious reference it's like telling the VP of a company while being a new executive that he's wrong. Kudos.
You shouldn’t be fit for any job if you don’t point out mistakes someone is making even if it’s a ceo or manager. Sam saved Dave from making a really embarrassing mistake when it comes to Star Wars law. Fans would have roasted the episode
because a conscientious leader would be able to play it off. It doesn't matter that Shmi met Padme before. What matters is that NOW, Padme is Anakin's wife - which wasn't the case when they first met
it does matter. it matters because every moment of every dialogue is a precious thing with very limited time, and every line of dialogue needs deep meaning to actually enrich the audiences experience.
Sam witwer has been one of my favorite actors since force unleashed. I really want to see him in a big movie
Not a movie, but he's in the US version of Being Human :
He was in The Mist (2007 movie)
Wish we could have a starkiller movie that would be awesome.
@Megaman-fe2ib Imagine Disney would allow us to have Legends movies! Completely unrelated to their Canon, but gives us the stories we've craved to see on the big screen. That'd be so cool, but we know Disney will never do it.
Sombody should had told feloni that Anakin and dooku were not supose to meet in the clone wars
At least not in the last few seasons.
And even if Shmi didnt know the true identity of Padme at that time, they still met. So Anakin would be more inclined to say "You've actually met her before".
"Oh, that woman that is like 8 years older than you? What about her?"
@@FDJUwe In-universe, Padme is only five years older than Anakin.
@@John-fk2ky so, she is almost 18 and met a 12 year old boy that later became her lover... let's be honest here, kinda weird. Even though the fact only happens when both are adults, it's still morally questionable if analysing from a psychological perspective.
@@FDJUwenot really, the boy had a crush on the girl, but even on earth little kids always have celebrity crushes etc of people older than them. She had no interest in the kid. Fast forward all the years for episode 2. Anakin forced into a life of no relationships and attachments, only having his memory of a girl he had a crush on, then meets her when properly aged. And that's when padme starts falling for anakin. I get some people might see it as weird, but I honestly don't think it's that weird. If padme had a crush on anakin in episode 1, then yes I'd agree it's weird. But she very clearly didn't romantically like anakin, she just thought he was a sweet kid in a slave world
@@FDJUwe It's not weird at all. Anakin at the time was 9 and Padme was 14. That's only a 5 year difference which isn't weird at all especially considering the average age gap between couples is 6 years. My in laws are 6 years apart in age so I know this is a real thing.
A sleep paralysis demon but it's Witwer explaining these hyper details in the animated star wars
Why do I WANT this
hyper details, like two characters having shared multiple scenes in a mainline movie.
Your can't move but your eyes are open and you hear a voice: "You know I was thinking about the Sith creed when voicing Maul and...
I love it when actors (voice or live action) love and respect the stuff they're in, it's so refreshing to see in this day and age!
Now this is someone who truly loves Star Wars. Sam Witwer deserves all the praise for his contribution to the franchise. I can't decide which one of his roles I love more, Starkiller, or Darth Maul.
I'd definitely say Darth maul. His ability to add realistic animosity and pure rage is unmatchable.
I just love that homie has a Black Mesa shirt on
That is an outstanding bit of Star Wars trivia!!!
The animated Anakin looks like Sam
I thought the same thing
lol ya he has the same face shape and chin dimple lol
Give this man Star Wars
Sam needs to REPLACE Dave.
Its not out geeking. It's actually knowing the material ur job is based around.....
To be fair, my mind tends to block out The Phantom Meanace too. Can't really blame Dave on this one.
@@Malak1man lol good one! Bahaha. As a littlwnkid it was my favorite but the older I get the more I appreciate 3 the most in the prequels and actually enjoy the original trilogy the most
It's his job that he gets paid for to know these things@@Malak1man
Exactly 😂 I’ve seen the prequels ONE TIME as a child and even I remembered that
Tbh shmi and Padme only share like 2 or 3 scenes together in the phantom menace so I can understand how people can forget they actually shared screen time. Xx
Deacon St John is one of my favorite video game characters. He did the role fabulously I wish they'd make another.
Thank you I knew deacon looked and sound familiar
Holy shit I didn’t put the two together either. His VA Is incredible
Dude i didn't realize that. And yeah he did look and sound so familiar. Such an underrated game when it came out. Articles written on it started with political smear like how Deacon treated his wife to affectionately or commented on her ass "objecting" her. Then other articles came out saying that theres nothing really going on in rural Oregon and it's therefore a weird and boring choice to make for the games setting, something i absolutely disagree with even from a practical standpoint as cities would become death traps in a zombie apocalypse, but regardless i really enjoyed the fresh take on a zombie game including it's setting. Took so long for people to realize the game was actually good that any hopes the studio had for a sequel were dashed by then. This is one major reason i Don't listen to game articles anymore especially if it has any political arguments being tossed around. Sorry that a husband flirting on his wife causes you pain enough to write an article about it lol, hope she found someone to give her that affection she obviously craved
@@red-merlin That is actually when I stopped listening to what game reviews had to say. All the negative fuss about game glitches and bugs when all that got patched in the next few weeks.
What a fantastic game and story that was!….
Sam Witwer is a huge reason why starkiller is my favorite stars wars character, he is a phenomenal voice actor!
If you’re going to be that guy to make people redo work, then ya gotta be right. What a legend
Dave also straight up brought characters back from the dead like Adi Gallia and Eeth Koth, while also choosing to kill characters who were still alive like Evan Piell. Also thanks to Dave Barris went from being a respectable Jedi Knight healer to a traitorous Padawan who was somehow allowed to come back only to die on Kashyyyk during Order 66. A lot of Legends “inconsistencies” were because he went out of his way to ignore Leland Chee when he warned him about continuity mistakes.
George himself oversaw the creation of the Clone Wars, and fans like to forget George never took the EU seriously. He adopted some shit for cosmetic effect, like Anakin's scar, but discarded pretty much everything that he didn't come up with in the first place.
Comic book continuity for the Clone Wars was its own thing, has its own merits, but the higher canonicity of Filoni's work is just the franchise creator's own preference in the end
To Dave's credit, he only really remembers his own characters and wants to push his own characters.
If only the current executives and directors had a 1/4 of the passion he has.
This dude should be star killer in live action
hot take star killer should remain as not canon
I don't think he ever was, just apart of the expanded universe which is different from the main cannon. Just like everything declared as legends stuff
@@starwinters39naw star killer needs to be Canon just to annoy Kathleen Kennedy as another strong male character, even if he is evil, but not evil.
This just makes me want more starkiller, either live action or games
The black mesa shirt though 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I will never get tired of this story.
Whenever he's in a Star Wars related thumbnail, it's always an instant watch, he's awesome
His portrayal of Maul was 👌
I love that Sam is wearing a half life black mesa shirt
First I was happy they made Dave the head creator of Star Wars, but the more I learn about Sam, I might reconsider it
Did not expect to see you here lol, I just saw one of your videos today
@@Bane520 lol hi 👋🏻
Sam should be running Lucas film! He understands star wars more than any person working there right now
For sure
He probably will be eventually but right now he’s still younger than Dave. Dave made an honest mistake so I can’t blame him about it that’s what a team is for.
@@Darth_Arashino one’s blaming Dave, who wasn’t CCO at the time! Only that Sam would be on a level, if not more knowledgeable about Star Wars than Dave and Jon. All three of them together would produce some good soup.
for remembering one of the most boring movies ever?
Dave worked on SW for decades and decades and you see a 30 second video and want to give away his job? 😂 I'm going to put money on you're not in a job where you have power over people 😂😂
My boy is wearing a black mesa t-shirt!
As a amateur writer, this moment is so fucking relatable When you discover you have to scrap a scene cos you did it already lol
How would Dave not know that. Thank you for saying something. Sheesh.
Things slip people's minds.
It's your focus right now, he had a million focuses. Not that hard to understand Mr perfect but is actually a dumbass that couldn't figure that out on his own
There’s a lot of shit Dave doesn’t know.
He doesn’t care
Because Dave Filoni is a fraud and a dumbass
crazy how this guy survived the zombie apocalypse and is a jedi
And also is a vampire
He also got killed fighting the Cylons.
Didn't he almost get rick from the walking dead when he crawled into the tank while heading to Atlanta?
I once out-nerded somebody about the lightsaber color Obi-Wan used to kill Maul in Episode 1. Good times.
Bro Sam Witwer should get “the sabered hand” treatment and have Starkiller canonized but powered down a bit. Still plenty of room for it in the lore since he’s “the secret apprentice”.
Could bring him in as an Inquitor, whom Vader officially “killed off”, but secretly took to training as his own apprentice.
I think he’d fit very well as the main antagonist in the 3rd EA Jedi: series.
His interactions with Cal Kestis and Luke Skywalker would be really interesting.
Why would he even need to be powered down, considering what the last movie did with the force for why would he even need to be powered down, considering what the last movie did with the force for Palpatine and Ray, the force can be ultra powerful if we really want it to be. Who cares about Canon...RIGHT?!?!
@@smackmmk we don’t acknowledge those things here lmao
Oh my god i just realised he has a blakc mesa shirt on. Dude gets cooler every second.
I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment. I will not edit this comment.
His portrayal of Lt Alex "Crashdown" Quartararo in BSG was also another amazing performance. He is an incredible actor.
'Out-geek'
Thats.... thats not like a minor detail.... like some hidden gem that only the deep geeks would know... how many layers did this process go through before this ?
Keep in mind that almost everything Obi-Wan said to Luke in their first conversation in ANH was later retconned to all be lies by the prequels.
well, i dont think her and Shmi exchanged 5 words, and the focus in that scene was on Qui-Gon and Anakin, so its pretty easy to forget they even were in the same room.
@@ЯАга-я4л I mean, yea, you could forget they were in the same room, but if I remember correctly, it also was on Tatooine that Anakin fell in love with Padme. Like she was some kind of angel from outer space.
@@daniels7907those were retconned to lies when the reveal happened in empire strikes back, not the prequels.
We see what happens when Dave works on something by himself. So...yeah
Can we please get this guy a Disney plus series
Nah, he needs to be on the team with Cavil. Two uber geeks creating something amazing.
Celune hat richtig abgerissen. Das Erzählstück über die Punisher im Altenheim war mit das witzigste was ich in nem Battle in letzter Zeit gehört hab. Und so ne Punchlinedichte hab ich überhaupt nicht erwartet. Die dritte Gänsehautrunde war die Kirsche auf der Sahnetorte. Krasser Sprung, gerne wieder
Freekno hat mir auch super gefallen. Der schafft es mittlerweile auch durch Inhalte und nicht nur durch Performance zu glänzen. Und er packt sich auch schwere Themen an, ohne sich darin zu verlieren oder es komisch zu verpacken. Trifft nicht immer ganz meine Meinung aber sehr schlüssig ausformuliert
Gerne wieder
Super Battle, beide mit absoluter Bestleistung
Also, Padmé returned to Tattooine, after TPM and becoming a senator, to work with Shmi and invent devices that would disarm and remove the explosive implants that all the Slaves on Tattooine (and potentially other worlds as well) had.
But secondly, it had been a long time since then, and Shmi never knew that Padmé and Anakin got married. So, if they had just explained that Anakin wanted to surprise his mother with the fact that he and Padmé were married, the original line would’ve worked perfectly. If they had had Anakin say “I want to introduce you to her”, then it would be wrong, but simply saying that he wants her to meet “his wife” would’ve been fine.
You know it’s serious when Dave Filoni takes off his hat.
It's the source of his power, after all
A whole army of Sam Witwer's wouldn't be enough to correct Lucasfilm at this point.
it's no surprise that the main guy and lady in control of Star Wars don't know much about it. Kinda what fans been saying since day one
The stuff jj abrams touched is bad. The other movies and shows are actually good.
@@junkrat29boom40 They really aren't. Mando lost the plot before the first season finished and it went downhill sharply from there. Book of Boba was Mando season 2.5, Kenobi was an embarrassment, Ashoka I didn't watch because why bother when you haven't seen any of the animated stuff, and why watch the animated stuff when it's so terrible. At least at the start, I tried a few episodes and it was just bad saturday morning cartoon nonsense. Any of the rest I've forgotten or haven't even heard of. I've heard the name Bad Batch, but it doesn't mean anything to me.
Then there's Andor. They made an actual TV show with actual characters, and told an actual story with them. Mindblowing.
Sam did more for TCW than Filoni.
Where are the facts behind this statement 😪😪😪😪
@@QuinlanVoss.Maul
The fact that all the trash would be, well, NOT absolute trash if it was Sam calling all of the shots.
@@QuinlanVoss.Dave was essentially a supervisor on the Clone Wars. His role was to make sure everything thing works, makes sense canonically, and just overall quality. Dave Filoni didn't write much of anything except for 2 episodes of the entire Clone Wars run. So while op's statement could be argued, it is not entirely false.
@@OG-ColorfulAbyss. If he was the one in charge you would be hating on him as much as Filoni
Dave Filoni taking off the hat and deciding to keep hiring him after getting saved from such a simple fandom plot hole trap is amazing. Filoni probably sweating bullets over such a simple slipup that would've had blogs and fans tearing him apart online for YEARS
Another thing Dave forgot is that the Star Wars galaxy is full of competent and compelling male characters.
Yeah, he only created Cad Bane, Rex, Fives, the Bad Batch, Kanan, Ezra, Hondo, Embo, Admiral Trench, Pre Vizsla, Savage Opress, General Krell, Captain Mar Tuuk, Cham Syndulla etc etc...
That’s such a MASSIVE failing on Filoni’s behalf. Out-geeked?! Man was completely and narratively WRONG
Because Dave Filoni is a fraud and a dumbass
Ahsucka clearly shows his writing capabilities, or lack of
@@1shogunate696ah is someone upset? Ashoka wasn’t perfect, but was good! So shut up and go watch the third trilogy kid!
@@crazysoundman shit was ass boy
@@crazysoundman but merry Christmas
When the Corvette pulls up behind you to grid it apmost sounds like a geiger counter ticking. I thought the imagery of the dark grey vette being a radioactive monster hunting you was pretty cool!
Sam Witwer Just needs to be hired more, dude’s awesome
Sam is such a cool guy, knows his star wars, and was great in days gone such a slept on actor
Dude is a 10 for all the right reasons.
Darth maul: you know they met before
How
Darth maul: i was there with Kenobi
I mean Dave feloni didn't mess up. She met padme as a young girl and while anakin was a child. Shmi doesn't know her as his wife yet. Still could've been used.
Considering how literally Star Wars fans tend to take things I can understand it lmao
Love this dude. Days Gone, Force Unleashed, total badass
Filoni is so overrated. Sam needs to be promoted. George needs to be reinstated. Let’s get some good Star Wars back.
George has one foot in the grave. We need people like Sam or Henry Cavil, or hell, even Elon bloody Musk, to start making things. If that trio collaborated... man, could you even imagine?
That hack was lucky to have Sam around
I tip my hat to you one legend to another - Rango
Sam was awesome in "Being Human"
That's the other thing I know him from! I was wondering what he's done other then pulling destroyers out the sky.
The first time I saw him was on Smallville! He was awesome!
Filoni really has no clue what he’s doing
Of course it is pure, it was forged by the light of the emperor, and his light, beloved by all…. Is pure.
In all fairness, Shmi met Padme when she was the queen of Naboo (or technically a handmaiden in disguise). Not Anakins girlfriend, or even as senator of Naboo. She wouldn’t have known Anakin was dating, let alone married. Padme was his wife. She never met wife Padme. It’d be like if I left home, didn’t stay in contact, got married, and showed up back home with a childhood friend as my wife. “I’d like you to meet my wife” still works.
Also, Anakin might not have known that Schmi had met Padme before
EST: Clearly I'm not very attentive lol
@@neonmenace1592 I think Anakin would know that. They all sat and had dinner together in the phantom menace, that part was true.
@@neonmenace1592they all met together. Did you not see the picture they showed of the three of them with Qui-gon and Jar Jar?
So you marry someone your family is familiar with and you reintroduce her? She would leave you because I’d make you the household joke for eternity. Your logic is heavily flawed. Same person, different title. Titles don’t change who the person is. Titles don’t change relationships or memories. A title does change anything. 😂😂
@@WilliamGeorge-l2n i guarantee you my dad wouldn’t remember everyone I knew when I was 9 years old. “Dad, this is my friend Padme from elementary school. She kicked me in kindergarten. She came over for a few birthday parties”.
He’d need to have a brief rundown of how he knew her. You have to remember Shmi met Padme once 10 years ago. They ate, but they hardly spoke. Padme grew up, changed physically.
“Dave Filoni needs to hire Sam Witwer more”
What? More than every single time he makes a fuckin show? 😂
No, get rid of F(il)oni completely and put Sam in charge of every last thing.
@@OG-ColorfulAbyss. Sam is an actor not a general...
@@trainknut and yet he still knows more about Star Wars than F(il)oni and would do a monumentally better job.
@@OG-ColorfulAbyss. I'm sure Dave is shaking in his cowboy hat because you keep spelling his name as "foni"...
@@trainknut besides his utter ruination of the franchise I honestly don't give a single quarks particle of a fuck what he's does doing.
Sam Witwer had gone through the same frustration I went through in Half-Life. _happy tears_
Mans really went all “🤓☝️” on em
Is this the dude who played starkiller too ?
Yep. In my opinion he belongs in that top tier of Star Wars actors.
@@MrMgkman13 those games are so underrated I recently just played both of the force unleashed. I just wish they could have made the third 😂
@@jackshiels1206he also played Darth sidious/emperor palpatine in the game and rebels, also he voiced animated maul. Super talented guy, I wish he was the one in charge of star wars.
As a supreme mega nerd, I always love it when someone catches something I can't belive I overlooked or forgot!
If Disney Lucasfilm wants to survive they’d give Sam Witwer more jobs. Acting, yea, but consulting on the writing too. This guy is a genuine fan, and we need more genuine fans making Star Wars, like Dave Filoni, like Jon Favreux. More of them, less of the bums who pay it lip service to land a lucrative and prestigious job.
What sucks is that producers, writers, and directors don't like it when somebody corrects them or "undermines them". This is why Henry Cavill left The Witcher. The 1st season he corrected the directors and writers constantly, which is why the 1st season is so amazing. But subsequent seasons they listened to him less and less, until he was just like "fuck it, either pay me a shit load of $$ or I'm gone".
I'm not worried about Liam Hemsworth being a bad Geralt, I'm worried about the writers and directors giving him horrible direction and dialogue
Not Dave. This clip proved it prior, but after the Ashoka series, Filoni showed he doesn't care about Star Wars that HE didn't create. He is the epitome of "I'm angry that I didn't create that so I will destroy lore to make MY creations seem better."
@@domesticdragonwafflewhat?? How has he destroyed anything by explaining the force the way George Lucas had it in the original films? Like you just seem to be on the bandwagon of nonsense. I feel like no matter who is making what you’ll have problems because you didn’t do it.
It's almost like Filoni has no idea what the freak he's doing 🤔.
This makes sense now that he’s in charge and is ok with lore breaking
He's doesn't even know his source material
Feloni has been dropping the ball a lot with Starwars, not just there.
U got that right
The one time doing the ol "um, actually" to your boss actually works out
Ironically, this error shows why Dave Faloni typically makes well-liked shows. While an egotistical showrunner would have brushed that comment off or fired him over that comment, Dave looked at Sam Witiwer's correction and thought, "I need him in my corner." Every writer makes mistakes, yet only good ones accept criticism and grow.
Shows that Dave doesn't care about the source material which is why his shows are generally bad
@@MON_KEY.I mean people usually cite The Clone Wars in much higher regard than Episode I, so it's not like he isn't respected. If Dave didn't care about the source material, he wouldn't have listened to Sam Witwer.
@@BatAmerica that's because George Lucas had involvement in The Clone Wars and most of it was made before Disneys purchase. If you look at shows Dave is involved with now they are very mediocre in comparison
@@MON_KEY. By that logic, George Lucas should be the only person who does great work despite Andor and The Mandalorian (Seasons 1-2) being made without his insight. Also, George had nothing to do with Rebels or Tales of the Jedi.
@@BatAmerica that makes no sense and filoni had nothing to do with andor, and barely anything to do with the mandalorian. Rebels was one of the worst pieces of Star Wars media out there, resistance was awful, ahsoka was awful, tales of the empire was awful, tales of the Jedi was mediocre at best. I never said George was the only one capable of creating good content, it certainly helps when the actual creator is around supervising and making decisions though.