Never thought I'd say this, but I'm glad she finally dropped VOL from the set. I think this is the first time since Abu Dhabi that she hasn't performed it.
Maybe that’s because the censorship authorities didn’t allow her to sing that song😂 There are words like ‘heaven,pray’ in VOL, which are not allowed there. You may notice that Fly Like A Bird was also not in the list.
Because her voice is not meant for tours honestly plus her nodules and she’s such a perfectionist because she knows she’ll be racked over the coals of it’s not perfect she’d rather use playback but she sounds good and seems happier
Although the lipping arrangements stay the same, this show gives me hope that she will slowly comeback to her 2023 arrangement soon, even pre-quarantine, as she attempted lots of adlibs here, and her energy was probably the best since LA 2023, which is an extremely good sign, seeing her actually enjoys the stage again makes me so joyous 😭😭😭
Great performance is much better than thinking about lipsyncing, it was normal to lipsyncing a lil, overall the stage is pretty and yes I agree everyone enjoys the concert and the singer herself, madam mariah carey also enjoy the concert is it? That was most mattered
tbh I think that the only thing that she needs is having her confidence back. You see her voice in a way better condition on the concerts/vids she's been posting so she just needs the confidence she used to have to be REALLY back again.
I mean I’ll start with the positive. I do see more energy. She’s a little more engaging. What is live sounds healthy to me which since you really haven’t sung live I’m guessing that is to be expected lol. If she can just do a setting like what she does on Instagram when she releases little clips; I think it would be better. I would say anything above a C5 is a push for her now. You can have very strong lows and mids though if you just focus on that area. Drop all the keys and you can still give us something solid and mostly live.
@@deadwalke9588 she sounded good and she also has nods which she could lose her voice all together if she removes them which is why she hasn’t Julie Andrew’s did and lost her voice for years and when when she was able to sing again it wasn’t the same and she post rehearsal vids where she’s singing live and sounds good
I never would have thought we would see the day when we would celebrate when THE mariah carey belts only a b4 live.. She should just get the nodules removed at this point
Not me over here getting excited for 3 minutes of live vocals 💀the bar is so low now😭 I love her but for some reason I thought she would return to her old formula by now and only lip the hard parts of songs opposed to the entire show 😢oh well guess this is just how it’s gonna be now forever :/ What makes it worse is that her live vocals actually sound really good so it’s such a waste to not even use her actual voice
I think it's within expectations that she didn't change anything for these one-off shows in September (though I am hoping for a live ending in I Want To Know What Love Is) cause it's just a couple shows so it probably isn't even worth it from her perspective... but I'm still optimistic that Christmas will bring a real change
@lovewhitneyhouston22lol I was probably gonna go too. I’ll just have to be temporarily delulu for one night and pretend that everything is live when I go💀🤣
Respectfully I see you hating on Mariah’s recent vocals … all the time and it’s getting tiring. As if her mother just didn’t pass away. It’s funny because the ones who actually attend the concert always enjoy their time and couldn’t care less about the pre recorded stuff.
Idk how people say lip syncing in China is illegal?? I am a singer myself who happens to live in Shanghai and sing for a living. I was invited to sing for a local TV show in Beijing because Chinese shows sometimes like to invite foreigners to sing just because … hear me out what was the deal which I didn’t accept cuz it was too cheap since Shanghai is a 2 hours flight from Beijing and they wanted to pay what I do in one day in Shanghai for two days in Beijing. The deal was: Day 1: RECORD VOICES AT A STUDIO. Day 2: Record “live” video WITH THE PREVIOUS VOICES RECORDING. In Chinese new year, Chinese National tv have a big show that pretty much everyone in China watches, according to my ex (Chinese) it is NOT ALLOWED for invited singers (and even actors cuz they also have some theatre acting going on) to sing OR talk live cuz Chinese TV wouldn’t allow any tiny little mispronunciation whatsoever. So, it’s fake. In China is 100% legal to lip sync. And about Mariah, she was phenomenal, I went to the concert, but after some things I saw on the concert (some whistles sounding that no one was doing) I ended up googling does Mariah lip sync and honestly, it was a lil disappointing since I love her and I made the effort to fly all the way to Beijing just to check her live singing
Ps. It seemed odd to me that she needed to use a teleprompter to sing her own songs?? Then it made sense to me and that’s how I ended up watching this video. Her voice was flawless and perrrrrfect in the concert
Clearly she is having confidence issues or she is doing some insane vocal preservation because her voice is perfectly fine when she sings live. Her voice sounds clear and not tired. She seems happier than her last few shows she has done too. The problem the last few shows she's done is at least before she would make it believable but this year... she went through the effort of re-recording new vocals (win!) but without the energy to match it.
@@rogl3W Because she still cares enough to get out there and present all those songs she worked so hard to make. Paul McCartney lost his voice a long time ago, but he´s still touring and getting sold out shows because he´s a legend. We should appreciate the effort and value our legends while they´re alive.
Mariah preforming during the Asian swing! She sounds good. Now, we need her to make appearances at the tennis tournaments. Let's not talk about that random hit piece. We all know Spendriah isn't broke.
If you watch her Christmas concert in 2022, specifically the intro of all i wamt for Christmas on December 13th and 16th, it seems like that part really destroyed her confidence to sing live freely like before.🥲
@@VMariah I think it’s really funny how everyone keeps saying that lip syncing isn’t allowed in china or something along those lines. there is actually no proof of this actually being a real thing and plenty have lipped there before lol
There is no such thing as zero-lipsync policy in China. I live in Beijing and a lot of singers they perform for big events lip-sync when they are recording the whole event. Usually their mic is half-opened which means the live sound is half their live vocals and half the pre-recorded soundtrack.
I was there that night with my boyfriend and she was amazing. A bit disappointing that a lot of times I could not make out her voice against the huge waves of lambs who sang along, especially the girl sitting to my right, who was singing at the top of her lungs all the time. The sound system in Beijing Workers' Stadium didn't help either because it's an open area as opposed to an indoor one and the system definitely needs more work.
Incredibly sad that arguably the most gifted female vocalist of all time can only manage 3 minutes of live singing. It breaks my heart to see what's become of her voice. It must be even harder for her, to know you had so much vocal prowess at your disposal only to end up like this. Very sad indeed.
Someone needs to respect if she wasn't so willing to sing live since she is in a closed country like China and also she is still mourning the loss of her mother and sister!
Old as in late 2023 yeah, but still not as live as pre-2023. Cause some of the formulas had already been changed by then, e.g. WBT was fully lipped, Love Takes Time climax was fully lipped, etc. So I would say it was about the same/just a bit more than 2023 Christmas shows, 30%
At least the speeches were live this time xp, also i wonder how Christmas will be this year......2023 had no energy or spirit but served vocals....this year...the energy will be there and at least that's something right?
Okay well everybody's talking about Mariah's vocals which don't get me wrong or phenomenal as always can't we just take a second to talk about trays I mean LoL 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I've never seen a fandom as hateful as this one. I've never see an artist as viciously scrutinised and criticised as Mariah, which I suppose is a testament to her stature. I mean, people don't try dragging anything down if it is mot lofty and above them. This woman will never be able to sing well because, if she does, the accusations will come flying out from hateful, damaged people who know nothing. For the greatest artist and singer of all time to have such vile "fans" is truly a tragedy.
Well, as many haters as Mariah has she definitely has many more fans who are supportive and devoted in this fandom from what I've seen... Anyway, I don't know if a little scrutiny is that bad; like you said, Mariah is great which makes it natural that she gets scrutinized. Scrutiny is literally just another word for attention to detail so it can be appreciative too.
@@VMariah let’s not forget that Mariah has set the bar extremely high. She’s a legend. So obviously the expectations are always high of her. As they are for anyone on her level. Remember when a similar thing happened with Whitney. Her vocals declined so much( more so than even Mariah) and she could not sing like she used to. People were walking out of her concerts. Honestly I’m a die hard lamb and I will always support Mariah and have even been to a couple of her shows and enjoyed it because it’s Mariah Carey of course. But I’d be lying if I said the constant playback doesn’t annoy me. But it’s not even just Mariah. Celine lip syncs too and has prerecorded tracks. Michael Jackson had an entire tour lip synced completely. I wouldn’t say it’s hating to acknowledge a singer lip syncing. It doesn’t take away from their talent. It just makes the shows less interesting imo compared to if the show is live
No way back. She is not willing to. All we’ll ever have is 2 minutes of “uh uh ah ah, tururu” forever. I’ve been a hardcore lamb for 25 years but this is just a scam for whoever paid tickets to see her. You lost me this year, MC.
Her voice isn't getting any better. These aren't even vocals, she's just half talking, barely singing. The Christmas Tour is gonna be 100% lipped, mark my words.
well it's just a few extra adlibs so obviously there is some talk-singing going on. But on the parts where she is truly singing I think her voice is objectively better than at least 2022.
Just waiting for the Brazil shows with the exact same pre-recorded vocals we’ve has this year for the entire show and everyone saying ‘100% live in Brazil’ and ‘she rested her vocals to slay in Brazil’ ‘she loves her Brazilian lams’ 🙄🥱
After rewatching certain parts *with headphones* I kind of convinced myself that there were actually far more live vocals than I originally suspected... especially in the Circles & DFAU performances 🤗 ???
Some of it does sound a lot like her live voice especially because the sound system in the stadium was so good, but I think it’s the same tracks she used earlier this year😅
Ok, if you need someone to constantly help you around on stage, you either need to lower your heels or have less restrictive clothing. It looks painful.
kinda, there's nice moments here and there but in general, her voice has been on the decline for a while already. But it's also that this time she's holding herself back alot from singing live
We're slowly getting more seconds
LOL
GAHHAHAHAHAHHAA
Seconds!!! 😂😂😂
The shadeeee
BYE ☠️
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
LMAO at all dululu lambs saying she was 100% live bcoz lipping is illegal in china😂
LMAOO
its so annoying 😭😭 ‘you get fined for it’ meanwhile the fine is $11,000 and it’s hardly ever enforced
Wdym by lipping is illegal in China 💀
and the fact that it isn't illegal either 😭😭
It strikes me how people would believe literally anything
Her voice actually sounds so good
@@b.k.471 say it again maybe I’ll care this time
@@b.k.471 this video is literally showing completely live parts of the show without playback
@@b.k.471Stop lying all the time
Never thought I'd say this, but I'm glad she finally dropped VOL from the set. I think this is the first time since Abu Dhabi that she hasn't performed it.
Yeah I’m glad too ngl. No point in including it if it’s just gonna be the same ole recycled track😅
Thank god
no cause we did not get that “Turned out to”
Maybe that’s because the censorship authorities didn’t allow her to sing that song😂 There are words like ‘heaven,pray’ in VOL, which are not allowed there. You may notice that Fly Like A Bird was also not in the list.
@@franktom2446In Brazil she won't sing vol and flb
Tbh she seems happier and that’s all that matters to me at this point
Side note I’m happier she’s singing more she went from two minutes to three😭
she actually does like she was hopping off the stage at one point like 2022riah😭
@@dariusc1030 let’s hope for 4 minutes next time😭
Bounceriah is back😭
@@andrewgarfield9898let’s not be delusional now lmao
PLEASE NOT THE SPEECH BEING INCLUDED WERE SO LOST
we’ll take what we can get even if it’s crumbs 😫
we love a supported and resonant speech
@@withyouonemogenstawp we musically analysing her speeches now? 💀
@@rainbowstarmced191 I mean… it was clearer, smoother and less cracky, airier than it used to be way back 2023ish 😍😍
At least we're not yet tracking what notes she's hitting in her speeches...
Damn she paid the fine lol
It was worth it for her I fear 😭
For playback?
How do u know please?
huh?
what do u mean?
It's so sad such a great vocalist refuses to sing live. Her voice seems in good shape at least.
Because her voice is not meant for tours honestly plus her nodules and she’s such a perfectionist because she knows she’ll be racked over the coals of it’s not perfect she’d rather use playback but she sounds good and seems happier
Well her voice is in a fragile state so to her she wants to protect it the same way celine
She can't handle a full concert live. Her voice is super fragile
Live vocals: "baby baby baby, dudududu, ey hey," xd😂
@@KaMillo538 6 words iktr
I'm dying 😂😂😂
😁😁😁
I be saying, “Mariah you better ad-lib that damn 1 note”😂😂
Bars are so low for her now and she’s still struggling 😢
Voice is so good in here
And she tried to singgg more
I’m crying❤
Lmao yall really get impressed at the bare minimum. 😭
@@yureinoWell yes, and what exactly are you going to do about it?
Her wardrobe appeared demure and very respectful..
She didnt have her chi chi's or ta ta's out. She looked very mindful. Very demure.
Ngl I was GAGGING watching this like , this is more than the entire Vegas residency put together 😭
Although the lipping arrangements stay the same, this show gives me hope that she will slowly comeback to her 2023 arrangement soon, even pre-quarantine, as she attempted lots of adlibs here, and her energy was probably the best since LA 2023, which is an extremely good sign, seeing her actually enjoys the stage again makes me so joyous 😭😭😭
Great performance is much better than thinking about lipsyncing, it was normal to lipsyncing a lil, overall the stage is pretty and yes I agree everyone enjoys the concert and the singer herself, madam mariah carey also enjoy the concert is it? That was most mattered
She had the biggest smile in the intro of Emotions. A little debutriah like swivel as well!
tbh I think that the only thing that she needs is having her confidence back. You see her voice in a way better condition on the concerts/vids she's been posting so she just needs the confidence she used to have to be REALLY back again.
2:04 "New speech" 😭😭😭you're so unserious 😭
😂😂😂
I mean I’ll start with the positive. I do see more energy. She’s a little more engaging. What is live sounds healthy to me which since you really haven’t sung live I’m guessing that is to be expected lol. If she can just do a setting like what she does on Instagram when she releases little clips; I think it would be better. I would say anything above a C5 is a push for her now. You can have very strong lows and mids though if you just focus on that area. Drop all the keys and you can still give us something solid and mostly live.
But I think if she lowered it the lows would be too low and wouldn't be like supported more strained/tensed and airy,
She's not a low voice; just a damaged voice that refuses to utterly improve. These excerpts prove nothing except that she is lazy.
@@deadwalke9588 she sounded good and she also has nods which she could lose her voice all together if she removes them which is why she hasn’t Julie Andrew’s did and lost her voice for years and when when she was able to sing again it wasn’t the same and she post rehearsal vids where she’s singing live and sounds good
the audio quality tho, it's like so freaking clear especially with headphones on
0:26 LMAO PLS
I never would have thought we would see the day when we would celebrate when THE mariah carey belts only a b4 live..
She should just get the nodules removed at this point
That lil C5 abmb tho 😍
Queen Of Resonance
queen of adlips
wait this is so creative I love it😭
sounds amazing
Slowly coming back to that confidence!!! Love it.
That was an amazing performance !! And Mariah looked gorgeous !! XOXO❤
Voice is nice and clear here ! 👌🏻
The Asian crowds def make her happier here 😄 i wish one day Mariah come to my country🇻🇳 Love the vids btw ✌
Not me over here getting excited for 3 minutes of live vocals 💀the bar is so low now😭
I love her but for some reason I thought she would return to her old formula by now and only lip the hard parts of songs opposed to the entire show 😢oh well guess this is just how it’s gonna be now forever :/
What makes it worse is that her live vocals actually sound really good so it’s such a waste to not even use her actual voice
I think it's within expectations that she didn't change anything for these one-off shows in September (though I am hoping for a live ending in I Want To Know What Love Is) cause it's just a couple shows so it probably isn't even worth it from her perspective... but I'm still optimistic that Christmas will bring a real change
@lovewhitneyhouston22lol I was probably gonna go too. I’ll just have to be temporarily delulu for one night and pretend that everything is live when I go💀🤣
I expected this. Did you watch her video greeting the Chinese lambs she said "The Emancipation of Mimi will *play* there"
Respectfully I see you hating on Mariah’s recent vocals … all the time and it’s getting tiring.
As if her mother just didn’t pass away.
It’s funny because the ones who actually attend the concert always enjoy their time and couldn’t care less about the pre recorded stuff.
@@StevenSenjayaplay there is a very interesting choice of words, but she wasnt wrong 😭
1:35 She was running 😍
First time she has ran on stage since beacon theatre.
She looks and sounds happier.
Awesome ❤
Idk how people say lip syncing in China is illegal?? I am a singer myself who happens to live in Shanghai and sing for a living. I was invited to sing for a local TV show in Beijing because Chinese shows sometimes like to invite foreigners to sing just because … hear me out what was the deal which I didn’t accept cuz it was too cheap since Shanghai is a 2 hours flight from Beijing and they wanted to pay what I do in one day in Shanghai for two days in Beijing. The deal was: Day 1: RECORD VOICES AT A STUDIO. Day 2: Record “live” video WITH THE PREVIOUS VOICES RECORDING. In Chinese new year, Chinese National tv have a big show that pretty much everyone in China watches, according to my ex (Chinese) it is NOT ALLOWED for invited singers (and even actors cuz they also have some theatre acting going on) to sing OR talk live cuz Chinese TV wouldn’t allow any tiny little mispronunciation whatsoever. So, it’s fake. In China is 100% legal to lip sync. And about Mariah, she was phenomenal, I went to the concert, but after some things I saw on the concert (some whistles sounding that no one was doing) I ended up googling does Mariah lip sync and honestly, it was a lil disappointing since I love her and I made the effort to fly all the way to Beijing just to check her live singing
Ps. It seemed odd to me that she needed to use a teleprompter to sing her own songs?? Then it made sense to me and that’s how I ended up watching this video. Her voice was flawless and perrrrrfect in the concert
Clearly she is having confidence issues or she is doing some insane vocal preservation because her voice is perfectly fine when she sings live. Her voice sounds clear and not tired. She seems happier than her last few shows she has done too. The problem the last few shows she's done is at least before she would make it believable but this year... she went through the effort of re-recording new vocals (win!) but without the energy to match it.
These videos are slowly but surely getting a little bit longer so I’m happy lmao
Well, the live vocals sound good, so that's a win!
She sounds much better actually, pitch improved a lot, tone is closer to caution, overall more stable.
1:06 sounds like her in the musicbox Era
1:54 She sounds so 2018
How does that sound like music box 🥴
@@Gievyji I mean it sounds like the voice sounded back then in The musica box Era!
@@GoldenAnjel1834does it though
@@Gievyji yess
@@GoldenAnjel1834 🤥
1:35 Runriah in a ruby ensemble 😭😭😭
Just be positive and enjoy and support Mariah, regardless.
HER CURRENT TONE IS JUST PURE MAGIC
I LOVE THIS
1:11 the way my delusion thought she was about to sing the dreamlover whistle live 😭😭
❤my angle butterfly dahlin mariah love u
I LIVE FOR THE COMMENT SECTION
Yk… she seems happier so that’s all that really matters - I wish she would have incorporated the vocals from the rehearsals tho they were so good😭
is it me or her recent pics kinda show her new set of veneers?? I love itttt she looks even more stunning
I NEED TO SEE SEP 16 ILL BE THERE OUTRO 😭
She does the absolute minimum ! And everyone who says the truth is a hater 😡 the show is 95% lipped !
this, this, and *this.*
Exactly ! Now she’s gonna do this forever since her shows are still selling out. Why why people could have such low standards.
@@rogl3W Because she still cares enough to get out there and present all those songs she worked so hard to make. Paul McCartney lost his voice a long time ago, but he´s still touring and getting sold out shows because he´s a legend. We should appreciate the effort and value our legends while they´re alive.
Her mom just died and just sister that’s crazy wow I love it omgg
Wow xie xie Beijing, she speaks Chinese too!! ❤
Finally is not just call my name and jazz improv from vol
Serving looks and not vocals
Y'all love to lie on Mimi; Mariah has served vocals to last many lifetimes, and sounds amazing here too!!
hey now let's be a bit more positive. At least things are going in the better direction
Very dumure, very mindful
She loves to be travelling far away, as a normal person. That's what it seems.
Mariah preforming during the Asian swing! She sounds good. Now, we need her to make appearances at the tennis tournaments. Let's not talk about that random hit piece. We all know Spendriah isn't broke.
The whistle at the beginning of Dreamlover is also real, I was there on the 15th and 16th, and the sound of the two days is different.
the fact that it's just intros and outros 😭
I wonder what is holding her back because u can tell she wants to sing more.
her nodules
If you watch her Christmas concert in 2022, specifically the intro of all i wamt for Christmas on December 13th and 16th, it seems like that part really destroyed her confidence to sing live freely like before.🥲
@@sunsunwon67 her lack of any tehcnique
Her zionist handler/manager
Her technique is good
0:27 girl- let’s be serious 😭
1:33 cause of the gospel chords in the back i can’t unthink of the whistles she did in osaka 😭
Love the live vocals, surprised they allowed her to lipsing?
I guess the stadium or whoever invited her to China took care of that
@@VMariah I think it’s really funny how everyone keeps saying that lip syncing isn’t allowed in china or something along those lines. there is actually no proof of this actually being a real thing and plenty have lipped there before lol
@@andrewgarfield9898 I mean technically there is a law from 2021 that it isn't allowed but it's VERY loosely enforced that it's good as nonexistent💀
There is no such thing as zero-lipsync policy in China. I live in Beijing and a lot of singers they perform for big events lip-sync when they are recording the whole event. Usually their mic is half-opened which means the live sound is half their live vocals and half the pre-recorded soundtrack.
@@andrewgarfield9898 It does exists tho cause of that one taiwanese band got sued or something
Não vejo a hora dela chegar aqui no BR 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
前天我在现场😊😊😊😊
Thank you for the video but wow how disappointing lol
I was there that night with my boyfriend and she was amazing. A bit disappointing that a lot of times I could not make out her voice against the huge waves of lambs who sang along, especially the girl sitting to my right, who was singing at the top of her lungs all the time. The sound system in Beijing Workers' Stadium didn't help either because it's an open area as opposed to an indoor one and the system definitely needs more work.
Omg 3 minutes???
mariah :yeah yeah yeyeyeyeah
me: 🥰🥰😍😍😍😍😱😱🙊🙊🙊🥹🥹🥹🤯🤯
Incredibly sad that arguably the most gifted female vocalist of all time can only manage 3 minutes of live singing. It breaks my heart to see what's become of her voice. It must be even harder for her, to know you had so much vocal prowess at your disposal only to end up like this. Very sad indeed.
Now all she does is to continue milking the dumb and stupid fans who have very low standards
i thought from the intro she was gonna sing vol lol
you can tell she wants to sing live so baddd hahaha.
Only 3 Minutes of Live Vocals from an entirely lipped concert? 😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫
What a shame for a diva like her
Someone needs to respect if she wasn't so willing to sing live since she is in a closed country like China and also she is still mourning the loss of her mother and sister!
I mean... it was the same situation in Vegas this whole year so I doubt that's the reason.
Why is she protesting to not sing live😂. Her voice seems in good condition
please do the second date
So out of a 2 hour show, there’s only 3 minutes of actual live singing? At least the set list is better
They said 90 min show….
i was wondering in Abu Dhabi what was the live vs lipped percentage? i think it was old formulas still right?
Old as in late 2023 yeah, but still not as live as pre-2023. Cause some of the formulas had already been changed by then, e.g. WBT was fully lipped, Love Takes Time climax was fully lipped, etc. So I would say it was about the same/just a bit more than 2023 Christmas shows, 30%
@@VMariah i hope she somewhat reverts back to that formula for atleast christmas cus having 1/2 mins vocal showcases is bleak. 😭
@@callisto132it’s to quote her daughter : BOEINGGG
At least the speeches were live this time xp, also i wonder how Christmas will be this year......2023 had no energy or spirit but served vocals....this year...the energy will be there and at least that's something right?
the lipped speeches in vegas is WILD to me
Okay well everybody's talking about Mariah's vocals which don't get me wrong or phenomenal as always can't we just take a second to talk about trays I mean LoL 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I've never seen a fandom as hateful as this one. I've never see an artist as viciously scrutinised and criticised as Mariah, which I suppose is a testament to her stature. I mean, people don't try dragging anything down if it is mot lofty and above them. This woman will never be able to sing well because, if she does, the accusations will come flying out from hateful, damaged people who know nothing. For the greatest artist and singer of all time to have such vile "fans" is truly a tragedy.
Well, as many haters as Mariah has she definitely has many more fans who are supportive and devoted in this fandom from what I've seen... Anyway, I don't know if a little scrutiny is that bad; like you said, Mariah is great which makes it natural that she gets scrutinized. Scrutiny is literally just another word for attention to detail so it can be appreciative too.
@@VMariah Mhm Thiss!!!!
us lambs hoping that she sings live more (at least Caution era level) and drop some of the playback is us being hateful? alr bro
@@VMariah let’s not forget that Mariah has set the bar extremely high. She’s a legend. So obviously the expectations are always high of her. As they are for anyone on her level. Remember when a similar thing happened with Whitney. Her vocals declined so much( more so than even Mariah) and she could not sing like she used to. People were walking out of her concerts. Honestly I’m a die hard lamb and I will always support Mariah and have even been to a couple of her shows and enjoyed it because it’s Mariah Carey of course. But I’d be lying if I said the constant playback doesn’t annoy me. But it’s not even just Mariah. Celine lip syncs too and has prerecorded tracks. Michael Jackson had an entire tour lip synced completely. I wouldn’t say it’s hating to acknowledge a singer lip syncing. It doesn’t take away from their talent. It just makes the shows less interesting imo compared to if the show is live
@@andrewgarfield9898especially when you know she is very creative with her live impromptu moments !
Maybe in brazil she realmente sing live and forget the playback
No way back. She is not willing to. All we’ll ever have is 2 minutes of “uh uh ah ah, tururu” forever. I’ve been a hardcore lamb for 25 years but this is just a scam for whoever paid tickets to see her. You lost me this year, MC.
yes. and when the other defensive lambs see your *honest* opinion about Mariah, they'll just call you a plain hater.
@@akosiiannnexactly ! I don’t care I say what I want to say. Her shows are now so boring and unethical
didnt she do whistle in the beginning of i'll be there?
you mean the can't let go whistle?
Her voice isn't getting any better. These aren't even vocals, she's just half talking, barely singing. The Christmas Tour is gonna be 100% lipped, mark my words.
I hate the fact that your prediction will most likely be true😭at this point it’s just time to accept that the days of live vocals are long gone.
well it's just a few extra adlibs so obviously there is some talk-singing going on. But on the parts where she is truly singing I think her voice is objectively better than at least 2022.
Her last Xmas tour had lots of live moments
@@VMariah yeah I definitely agree her voice is SO much better than 2022. Yet the playback has only increased since then which is a bit odd
Just waiting for the Brazil shows with the exact same pre-recorded vocals we’ve has this year for the entire show and everyone saying ‘100% live in Brazil’ and ‘she rested her vocals to slay in Brazil’ ‘she loves her Brazilian lams’ 🙄🥱
Yes exactly. Wonder if people ever have their ears checked😂
you’re so hot
After rewatching certain parts *with headphones* I kind of convinced myself that there were actually far more live vocals than I originally suspected... especially in the Circles & DFAU performances 🤗 ???
Some of it does sound a lot like her live voice especially because the sound system in the stadium was so good, but I think it’s the same tracks she used earlier this year😅
Ok, if you need someone to constantly help you around on stage, you either need to lower your heels or have less restrictive clothing. It looks painful.
what happened to her voice
Did she sing any song live?
What about most of I'm that chick? I thought it was live 😶
It was? honestly I don't hear it😭
doesn't really make sense tbh for just one song to be mostly live so probably not
OMG BHAHAHAHA NGAKAK YA LORD..
So she lost her voice? 😭
kinda, there's nice moments here and there but in general, her voice has been on the decline for a while already. But it's also that this time she's holding herself back alot from singing live
I think it’s more of her not using it then losing it entirely
Long gone mate
stop fooling the fans, she can never sing live the high notes
"Live" yah, right 😂
did you even watch the video?
These are the live parts mate. Trust me this channel owner is a solid fan.