Who's the Meanest Member of Double Life?!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
  • This video is all in good fun! Obviously none of them are really mean. I just thought that was a funny way of presenting the question.
    Double Life Members!
    BdoubleO100:
    / bdoubleo
    bigbst4tz22:
    / @bigbst4tz22
    Dangthatsalongname:
    / dangthatsalongname
    EthosLab:
    www.youtube.co...
    GoodTimesWithScar:
    / goodtimeswithscar
    Grian:
    / grian
    ImpulseSV:
    / impulsesv
    InTheLittleWoods:
    / inthelittlewoods
    PearlescentMoon:
    / pearlescentmoon
    rendog:
    / rendog
    SmallishBeans:
    / smallishbeans
    Solidarity:
    / solidaritygaming
    Tango Tek:
    / tangoteklp
    ZombieCleo:
    / zombiecleo
    _____________________________________________
    Socials:
    Discord: / discord
    Twitter: / jayadonut
    TikTok: / jumpingjayofd
    Instagram: / jayadonut
    #doublelife #minecraft #lastlife #3rdlife

Комментарии • 200

  • @yMaxy
    @yMaxy 2 года назад +458

    Hey guys let's make Jay angry again:
    "I LIKED THE POINT SYSTEM MORE!!!"

    • @charlotte_piglover
      @charlotte_piglover 2 года назад +12

      I did like it better, but this was great! (Although if you have more free time… 👀)

    • @AK_804
      @AK_804 Год назад +4

      What's the point system?

  • @oliviadehart2882
    @oliviadehart2882 2 года назад +475

    I actually think Impulse and Bdubs should be a lot lower. Their gossiping was basically harmless (did less damage than Pearl’s stealing pranks at least, which unintentionally got 4 people killed). Also, Impulse especially was super helpful to people, trying to save others in the deep dark, telling people where to find iron, etc.

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +99

      Makes sense. I would keep them where they are because while they weren’t very good at breaking up couples, it was still their intention and that’s pretty rude. I see where you’re coming from tho

    • @eddog6666
      @eddog6666 2 года назад +21

      Zombiecleo definitely deserve the title of the meanest player on double life. To me it would have been Scott as number 1 but doing the sacrifice play to make pearl be the official winner while zombiecleo struck pearl from behind made them switch places for me. And that final fight. Talk about perfect timing. Even zombiecleo was surprised by how pearl got her in the middle of a jump.

    • @ghostie.writes
      @ghostie.writes 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@eddog6666 HOW DARE YOU NOT SCOTT

  • @anoki7889
    @anoki7889 2 года назад +447

    As someone who got very invested in Pearls perspective, I think where you put the members of the Divorce Quartet makes lots of sense.

    • @Hdifbfbr
      @Hdifbfbr Год назад +15

      I also got very invested in pearl’s perspective and i cried when her and scott were finally together then had to fight even tho the season before they partnered and SCOTT LITERALLY WENT AFTER SOMEONE BC THEY KILLED PEARL THE SEASON BEFORE

  • @AtakarBaSahlnyonmyy
    @AtakarBaSahlnyonmyy 2 года назад +194

    Probably your greatest video to date bro! Scott giving Pearl the “win” is why he’s 2nd while Cleo is 1st, if you still need a reason haha

  • @noatmealcookie02
    @noatmealcookie02 2 года назад +377

    Scott and Cleo DEFINITELY were the mean girls of this season and i LOVED it! lol
    Seriously, from widow's alliance in 3rd life that never happened, to a few sessions together in Last Life, and finally getting this duo in Double Life... It was worth the waiting!
    They were just in such a good balance with each other, every one of their interactions is iconic! Seriously, what a power couple, definitely my favorite duo in DL.
    As for a reason why Cleo would be higher on the list then Scott, I think it might be because she's more bold and straightforward about it? Like, Scott somehow still being nice, even when he's mean, and he often does good deeds too - he gave Scar his horse back as he promised (even tho Scar himself forgot about it), he gave ranchers windows (...and then stole their chickens but it wasn't a part of original plan lol), and even with Pearl - he mostly just was standing on his 'im with Cleo' position, he didn't do much torturing (besides the axe crits) and he wasn't trying to taunt her intentionally in any way. So they're both mean but Cleo's a bit more chaotic?
    And I guess we can also count that in the end Scott gave victory to Cleo, which might've redeem him a bit
    Anyway, it's so funny seeing most of infamously chaotic people like Grian and Joel not in top names lol
    (Here's a long comment for ya to make algorithm go brrrr~!)

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +32

      I love this comment so much lmao the algorithm appreciates it!

    • @anirmouha2867
      @anirmouha2867 2 года назад +15

      Scott gave the victory to cleo ,somthing ayent right

    • @noatmealcookie02
      @noatmealcookie02 2 года назад +11

      @@anirmouha2867 oh, right, my mistake lol

    • @Hdifbfbr
      @Hdifbfbr Год назад +3

      Scott and Cleo were mean but they would both be kinda sweet with Pearl bc that time Cleo visited Pearl’s tower was just so wholesome and just after around session 4 Scott was to sweet towards Pearl so yea

    • @noatmealcookie02
      @noatmealcookie02 Год назад +1

      @@Hdifbfbr yep, they are all friends after all^^

  • @attmay82
    @attmay82 2 года назад +149

    Scar being scar and being that high kind of implies alot about every othet season. And Joel is so epically bad at being bad. Which is part of what what makes smalletho so good lol. And personally I would have put Pearl lower because the only two things she did was pretend to steal something for a couple seconds too long and do a funnier torture bit against her soulmate who was the second meanest person and did worse torture bits to her

  • @lolli_popples
    @lolli_popples 2 года назад +147

    “It was almost a cute story about picking who you want to be with-
    -But they were too toxic.”
    Instead it was an extremely entertaining story about picking who you want to be with.

  • @monbaar2704
    @monbaar2704 2 года назад +65

    the reason scott is second is because in the final moments he was super nice to pearl killing himself so she could win with an amazing quote "TILLY DEATH DO US PART"

  • @noatmealcookie02
    @noatmealcookie02 2 года назад +96

    Oh, also when you said how Joel & Etho were being mean - killing ranchers, when they were being good to boat boys - you didn't mention that it was in fact Scott and Cleo who payed them for this murder which I think is even MORE mean then simply killing someone (also it was right after they stole their chickens and then threatened to burn their ranch (tho tbf who didn't))
    But that's just another point proving that Scott and Cleo were the real mean girls :D

  • @naimac1015
    @naimac1015 2 года назад +76

    I honestly wanted to disagree … but really you are correct. The gaslighters were the worst, which really if you think about it they brought the most drama to this series.
    Which also probably explains why most of the animatics for this season are of Scott, Scar, Pearl, and/or Cleo.

  • @lolli_popples
    @lolli_popples 2 года назад +44

    Also, I think that while Scott and Cleo were probably equally “mean” this season, and Scott maybe did more overall, if we’re counting intention and outcome, Scott is definitely second place.
    Once he left Pearl she tortured him and went insane. I can kind of understand why he didn’t want to rejoin with her at first. But Martyn was fairly sane and tried to win Cleo back, so the vibes are definitely different.
    And while Cleo and Martyn teamed up at the end, Scott actually chose to kill himself rather than Pearl in the end, where I feel like Martyn and Cleo would have just fought.
    So I agree about Cleo definitely having meaner vibes than Scott despite not doing the inciting action most of the time.

  • @demonkid8284
    @demonkid8284 2 года назад +29

    Uhhh. No. Martin was the reason Pearl didn’t meet up with others sooner. She couldn’t in good conscious leave him after he mentioned the nether. Then he ditched her. I think you need to factor in my point to understand why I think him leaving Pearl was so so mean

  • @EYEfacer
    @EYEfacer 2 года назад +29

    "Almost cute, if it wasn't so toxic" is helpful classification to have in general

  • @KeitieKalopsia
    @KeitieKalopsia 2 года назад +37

    I didn’t watch Cleo’s perspective, but now I have to! I didn’t realize how much chaos and mean girl shenanigans she took part in, but it turns out she might make a really good cartoon villain. Her power isn’t brute force or PvP, but rather intimidation (we all knew that), manipulation, sheer audacity, and… okay, she did brute force her way into the Ranchers’ chicken pen.

  • @ctom42
    @ctom42 2 года назад +95

    The only real places I disagree with you are Ren , Scar, and Martyn.
    I feel like Ren deserves to be much higher, not in the top 2, but either in 3rd or 4th. He constantly blamed other people for his own failings and also treated big b pretty poorly too. You mentioned not treating killing as mean in itself but the intentions behind it, and I feel like that should extend to some of the other actions as well. In that sense the only purpose most of Ren's actions served was to deflect his own failures onto others (mostly Pearl, but also Bdubs and a few others) which to me is pretty mean.
    Scar on the other hand I feel like should be lower. Again with that same concept of intentions mattering more. As you say yourself most of Scar's shenanigans were just expected Scar shenanigans. Aside from burning down the ranch he never did anything that actually upset anyone. At most he made people roll their eyes a bit. The powder snow and the burning of the ranch are enough to prevent him from being on the bottom, but seems crazy to me to put him higher than both of the people who burnt down every base on the server in a rampage.
    I also think I'd put Martyn higher than you did. The way he treated Pearl in episode 1 as well as killing Cleo. I know it was meant to be a joke, but even if she had lived it would have been a pretty mean one. One big thing that I think you missed was that Martyn was pretty consistently helping cause chaos even if he wasn't usually the chief instigator. Prior to the last episode just kept casually helping the reds with their plots for no real reason. Cleo and Scott hired Etho and Joel to kill Jimmy and Tango, but they just watched. Martyn showed up and was the one to actually light the skyfort on fire seemingly just for the choas. Same with the pool party. Ren made it clear to Martyn that he intended to do something devious with the party and Martyn proceeded to make sure everyone on the server was invited and encouraged to attend. Ren didn't even ask him to do that, he took the initiative to put them all in danger himself.

    • @yutaluv9068
      @yutaluv9068 2 года назад +13

      agreed with everything; also, Martyn instantaneously turning on Scott the second they were the last 2 pairs, he didn't even try to negotiate with his soulmate's ally

    • @KeitieKalopsia
      @KeitieKalopsia 2 года назад

      You make some good points!

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +11

      Makes sense. Tbh, I wasn’t really sure about where I put Ren and Martyn but just had to settle for something. I still stand by where I put Scar tho. But if there was anyone I was wrong about, I knew it would be those two… and maybe Pearl

  • @LitaWannamaker
    @LitaWannamaker 2 года назад +15

    My new favourite saying: "The thing about Etho, is that he's too Canadian to be all that mean."
    😂😂😂

  • @ashspectrum
    @ashspectrum 2 года назад +20

    i think that cleo being higher then scott makes sense. even though you didnt include deaths i got the vibe that once the divorce quartet was the last ones standing scott was perfectly willing to give himself over to cleo or at least set up a fair 2v2, whereas cleo and martyn almost immediately went to sneak attack pearl. plus scott did forgive pearl in the end when he sacrificed himself rather then making her kill him.

  • @TheEpicKoala
    @TheEpicKoala 2 года назад +21

    I can’t believe you forgot Grians kill on his secret soulmate!

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +14

      Goddangit! You’re right! That was a big one too. I don’t even know how that passed my mind!

    • @TheEpicKoala
      @TheEpicKoala 2 года назад +1

      @@JayADonut I know right!

    • @lyricalnonsense625
      @lyricalnonsense625 2 года назад +9

      it was technically an accident though. Grian was probably so focused on Ren he forgot.

  • @darkeyeprobe88
    @darkeyeprobe88 Год назад +14

    I love how 13:40 - 13:58 was just genuinely complimenting Etho in a video evaluating meanness :)

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +5

      Etho is one of my favorite people I don’t know personally. He’s just so fun

  • @celestialwish1478
    @celestialwish1478 2 года назад +13

    I really like this list but I think Pearl was too high. I don't really.. think Pearl did anything wrong? As you said she was really misunderstood and all of her 'stealing' was meant as a joke (I.E. She returned the majority of the stuff she stole unless it was a red-life kill). She was repeatedly beaten down and turned away, even killed once for it when she was trying to be lighthearted. She tries to joke around or do something good and she was immediately shot down. If I were in her situation I would've gone more nutty than she ended up being. I think that inherently makes everyone who tormented her meaner than her. She was definitely less mean than Grian was-- Grian was complacent and enabling of Scar's meanness which I think adds to his own meanness score and he should have been higher (as much as I love Grian). I think all of the Red Lifes making her sit out of the Red Life Circle and then saying she didn't have a say was really mean. I think it was awful when the final few Red Lifes kicked her out of the group, too.
    I think Martin was meaner than Pearl was- despite Pearl 'torturing' her soulmate, at least she overall left Scott alone and towards the end they even kind of made up. Martin was the clingy ex boyfriend. Even if he didn't do anything wrong he couldn't just accept being broken up with. Imagine breaking up with someone and they build a GIANT HEART IN THE SKY, ruining your property value and overall kind of harassing you. That's why I'd put Martin higher. He also was one of the people who screwed over Pearl after being with her in the beginning which I think makes him meaner than her.
    Idk how I'd restructure it personally but that's just my two cents. I also haven't seen all of the perspectives so I'm not all that well-informed.

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +7

      What you said about Martyn and the heart in sky made me laugh a little too much lmao

  • @Pm7MightExist
    @Pm7MightExist 2 года назад +18

    Great vid, I definitely agree that Scott and Cleo were at the top this season. Also nice bloopers reel

  • @blinky_6664
    @blinky_6664 2 года назад +14

    I feel like you could maybe say that the reason Scott got seconded to Cleo was, in the end, he was willing to blow himself up for his soulmate, even though he had pretty much disowned her just about the entire duration of the series. But ya know, " Tilly death do us part."

  • @maskedshadow2458
    @maskedshadow2458 2 года назад +11

    The divorce group was who I watched so I saw how toxic they were

  • @BluejaySerenade
    @BluejaySerenade 2 года назад +7

    I personally think Joel and Etho should be a bit higher, you didn't really mention how they burned everyone's bases down. I know it was a revenge but I mean they did it to people who didn't start the fire and were pretty nice to them.

  • @koo2463
    @koo2463 2 года назад +9

    just saw the video, totaly agree on scott and cleo being the meansest. peals point of view during the eintire series was amazing to watch. oh and algorithm and suscriping

  • @pancakesareawesome3121
    @pancakesareawesome3121 2 года назад +10

    I feel like Cleo and Scott’s placements should be switched. Mainly for the fact that it seemed like Cleo was at least trying to let Martyn down easy. She even gave him a diamond sword! As for Scott, he didn’t even bother trying to be nice to pearl. And for another gave Cleo the idea to do the axe crit every episode in the first place

    • @salem-01
      @salem-01 Год назад

      I feel like although Scott probably did a few more mean things, the flaw of this video is that it didn’t consider any of the kind actions of the players. The main reason Scott is second for me is because of that sacrifice he made for pearl at the end. “Tilly death do us part” kind of negates a lot of his unkind actions towards her

  • @starhaylo7736
    @starhaylo7736 2 года назад +11

    cleo being number one makes sense because of her betraying scott

  • @marbleminion
    @marbleminion 2 года назад +15

    Nice rankings! I think it was a good list, and your content is really improving!

  • @CharlCharl_
    @CharlCharl_ 2 года назад +8

    I would argue Joel being more mean that Scar. Joel burnt every burnable building on the server. That deserves 4th place, doesn’t it? Also I mean this is in a nice way, I was a huge fan of the last life one so I’m not a hater in any way!

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +4

      Wdym, that was Scott. Ship burns everything burns. jk Yeah, of course that was super mean, but that’s the only big thing he did the whole season. Scar was consistently doing things. I think the burning down of the bases might be what justifies him being 5th, he doesn’t deserve any higher tho.

    • @CharlCharl_
      @CharlCharl_ 2 года назад +1

      @@JayADonut that’s a fair argument. It comes down to personal opinion really. Which is worth: continuous small torturing actions, or one massive horrible action

  • @icantthinkofagoodname9786
    @icantthinkofagoodname9786 2 года назад +6

    Quotes from the beginning until 8:10 (part one) that sound absolutely insane out of context and yet describe empires perfectly
    "The gaslighting and gatekeeping went so far further than it ever has before!!!"
    "You can't gaslight the gaslighter"
    "Arson is Arson"
    "No wonder Pearl was unhinged. Everything was going so wrong. Also it was 5 AM for her but whatever-"
    "Tango is an absolute madman. Nothing really came of it."
    "Pearl continued her general unhingedness"
    "And to top it all off, she THREATENED TILLY"
    "He decided to remedy that by bullying Jimmy"
    "Their relationship therapy was so cute. Until it wasn't."
    "Scar was trying to scam people, but honestly if he wasn't I'd be very concerned."
    "Can't run very fast so receives constant verbal abuse" (Me in gym)
    "How the turns have tabled the turning tabley tables"

  • @shidoulover48
    @shidoulover48 2 года назад +6

    Martyn should be higher in my opinion. I feel like he and Pearl should swap places. Seeing as he was generally pretty mean-spirited towards everyone in the divorce quartet, and Pearl never had mean intentions, if you don't consider her anger when her dogs were hurt and her unhinged behavior towards Scott and Cleo.

  • @kristeenlivesay2664
    @kristeenlivesay2664 Год назад +2

    I think by default Scott and Cleo are 1st and 2nd simply because their actions created the “Red Witch”. They could have done nothing else but that and I think they would be the 1st and 2nd even then.

  • @CharlCharl_
    @CharlCharl_ 2 года назад +5

    Cleo is definitely the meanest. If it wasn’t for Scott’s sacrifice at the end, then Scott would have

  • @ThemightyTho
    @ThemightyTho 2 года назад +3

    Pearl should be so much lower and Martin so much higher

  • @aqua3723
    @aqua3723 2 года назад +5

    Good to see how far you've come with your content, here's a reward comment for the algorithm

  • @darkdragoness5
    @darkdragoness5 2 года назад +3

    I feel you are very valid in your number one pick, as it was Cleo who convinced Scott to choose each other as soul mates, and reacting very harshly to her soul mate taking large amounts of damage like she was the only person who had to deal with it, when everyone else had to deal with it at some point. Like Grian freaked out because Scar took an axe hit from Joel, and Jimmy found out who his soul mate was because Tango died.
    Cleo did stick by with Scott until the end, and got very upset at the thought of betraying him, Martyn pretty much forcing her hand by attacking Scott and pressuring her to go for Pearl so she wouldn't have to face up to her trying to kill Scott.
    She also ended up resolving some her issues with Martyn enough to team up with him by the last episode.
    (Martyn definitely deserves the Guilt Trip title he got for joining the Gaslight, Gatekeep and Girl Boss group)

  • @hufled
    @hufled 2 года назад +2

    i agree with the theivery point, it was kinda out of control this season

  • @MicMac7773
    @MicMac7773 Год назад +2

    11:04 Boy have I got news for you

  • @blazeexcaliber5274
    @blazeexcaliber5274 2 года назад +3

    martyn was deserving of being above pearl just like move pearl wher martyn is and move martyn up like 2 and pretty much perfect

  • @ripbiscuit392
    @ripbiscuit392 2 года назад +4

    This seems pretty cool.
    If only I understood what was going on.

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +2

      I would really recommend checking it out! Super funny series

  • @gillenkids3825
    @gillenkids3825 2 года назад +2

    I have reason I think scott got lower than cleo and it was because he sacrificed himself so pearl could win.

  • @familytablet6453
    @familytablet6453 Год назад +1

    I just think it's Jimmy because of one thing.
    "Hey Martyn! YOU SUCK!"

  • @rosesaysmeow8358
    @rosesaysmeow8358 Год назад +1

    DO THE MEANEST MEMBER OF 3RD LIFE AND LIMITED LIFE! It'd be fun. Sorry for shouting. I'm excited.

  • @rosesaysmeow8358
    @rosesaysmeow8358 Год назад +1

    "Poor Pearl"? Seriously! She's gotten... SPOILER
    4th then 1st then 4th. I'm sorry. She's not poor. More like it's time for her to lose. Even Scott has one bad ranking. Every good player must have one.

  • @Wither02
    @Wither02 2 года назад +4

    As soon as I saw this, I couldn't stop myself from watching it! Good job, I love these videos!

    • @Wither02
      @Wither02 Год назад

      Still agree with this statement.

  • @turbotastic7493
    @turbotastic7493 2 года назад +1

    I think Joel was the meanest because
    1. He burned alive scar’s pandas
    2. He stole grian’s sugar cane even after he said he will give sugarcane
    3. He went to war with scar and grian
    4. He is just his normal psychopathic self

  • @L0nelyghoul
    @L0nelyghoul 2 года назад +2

    Just to say:
    Scott (+pearls) ending was the best.
    No context

  • @LaMadriguera
    @LaMadriguera Год назад +1

    Here is the thing: Cleo and Scot were mean, really mean, but also were loyal as heck towards each other. That duality of being the Best and the worst, plus the fact they decided their own soulmates and were Open and honest, and not just cheated (like Grian and BigBeast) Made them the GOAT of the series

  • @bookmarkobjectanimations123
    @bookmarkobjectanimations123 9 месяцев назад +1

    Cleo and scott being the meanest is funny, but i wouldn't really call it toxic, because we saw a little bit in season 2 aswell that cleo is the one person that can stop scott from being overtly passive, and make him even more fun.

  • @XStudio0
    @XStudio0 2 года назад +2

    The funny thing is impulse would still probably be the least mean if Bdubs wouldn't have been such a bad influence lol

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад

      That’s actually v true lmao

  • @cooledplains5044
    @cooledplains5044 2 года назад +3

    lol as some one who loves this series, I love this!. Hope the mebers see this! This is incredible!

  • @jfmusic1671
    @jfmusic1671 Год назад +1

    Honestly AS JUSTIFIED as Scott and Cleo were from their POVs with breaking up from Martin and Pearl, and how they treated other people….
    THEY REALLY WERE THE MEAN GIRLS!! They Gaslight Gatekeep Girlboss EVERYONE. That’s what happens when you’re liberated from your soulmate

  • @Savariable
    @Savariable 2 года назад +3

    I think martyn should get some points in the finale for when he hit impulse off the platform in the deep dark, it was a really stupid play alongside the fact that he literally was the one who STARTED the fight with a red that previously, while clearly not being an ally, was sort of messing around (yes he was trying to summon a warden, but cleo was close enough to safety that she would've been out of range by the time it spawned), and was very unlikely to attack them, and he didn't even wait for cleo to get up first, so impulse started fighting cleo and martyn did basically nothing. martyn 100% deserves to be at least a bit higher on the list, but either way this is a great video and I probably am misremembering that encounter a bit-

  • @skittyscooters
    @skittyscooters Год назад +1

    I feel like Martyn needs to be higher on the list for leaving pearl in the beginning and telling her it was her fault scott and cleo left, when he wanted to go into the nether

  • @MyNameIsMashmallow
    @MyNameIsMashmallow 2 года назад +2

    I feel like Scott, Pearl, and Scar we're on main character duty this season

  • @redhead_bebs
    @redhead_bebs 2 года назад +2

    I agree to Cleo being higher than Scott, because Cleo was more willing to actually fight once she, Martyn, Scott, and Pearl were the final 4. AND because Scott sacrificed himself for Pearl to win.
    HOWEVER!!! You were like, "You guys are probably going to be surprised Pearl is so low"... Buddy, I was surprised Pearl was SO HIGH! Her chaos was always just tomfoolery. She PRETENDED to steal a horse, and then returned it (trying to save Ren and Big B's stuff), then she PRETENDED to steal Oreo, but kept her when Scar just left before Pearl could return her, then she didn't give Oreo back because Scar attacked her on sight and almost killed Oreo in the process, then Pearl PRETENDED to steal the chest plates, and was killed for the same joke she had been pulling all season. Even her kills in the last episode were just avenging Tilly and then defending herself from Martyn and Cleo. Literally the only truly bad thing she did all season was stand in powdered snow a lot, and even then she was ALWAYS careful to make sure she and Scott were never in any real danger. She even did a lot of nice things like trying to help Scar and Grian when no one else would.

    • @redhead_bebs
      @redhead_bebs 2 года назад +3

      Also, forgot to mention, I think that Martyn should have been A LITTLE higher. He definitely made up for a lot of mistakes later on, but there is a lot of evil in dragging Pearl to the nether (when she had almost figured out who her soulmate was, he had no clue, and she just didn't want him to die), and then ditching her when his plan resulted in them both getting dumped. Then in the next episode he tries to get back with Cleo by ACTIVELY insulting Pearl, saying it was annoying having to spend time with her (even though she probably is responsible for him not dying episode 1). Plus, he later feigns being her friend with Ren as a way to use her strength. It is twisted and if Martyn had only TOLD SCOTT AND CLEO THE TRUTH OF THE SITUATION... Scott and Cleo might have forgiven Pearl sooner, preventing her from going crazy, and reuniting Gaslight/Gatekeep/Girlboss because Pearl is the only one able to rein in the Mean Girls energy. Like, I know we're entering theoretical territory, but Martyn MIGHT be the reason for all of the "evil" things to come from Pearl, Scott, and Cleo. He wasn't actively evil most of the time, but he was an enabler for evil across the server.

  • @rockassassin64
    @rockassassin64 2 года назад +1

    Okay no Jimmy is definitely not the nicest and in fact I think that's not even what Jimmy wanted his character to be. Episode 1 I'm fairly certain unprompted after they give him food because he has fucking nothing Jimmy call Scott and Cleo fake soulmates. He does it again episode 4 is he also did like lie to Scott's face about the chickens and lied to a bunch of people was a big part in Tango trying to get the fucking awarded on the surface and if you said that was mean for Tango that was mean for Jimmy as well. But you know like the biggest thing is and you never mentioned to this the calling Scott and Cleo fake soulmates yes they weren't so bound to each other but like they are found family. Give me essentially did the bullshit where your parents Gaslight you and tell you that blood is thicker and water and that your friends are less important than your family when that is absolutely not true and that's what Jimmy did and something that I'm honestly fairly certain of myself is that this is actually kind of just how Jimmy wanted his character to be. I don't think Jimmy thought he was going to get out first again but I think it's fair to say that if there are underdogs on This Server most people consider it to be Scar and Jimmy but scar is often times like more lovable and funny than Jimmy usually is like I think Jimmy recognizes that scar is going to get the lovable underdog treatment so Jimmy makes himself a comedy villain he's not actually threatening but he definitely tries to be like he's not being reasonable when people are being mean to him he just doesn't have any of the skills to back up anything he says with like his PVP and it works out for him and he's very funny at doing stuff like that essentially Jimmy kind of makes himself the butt of the joke and that actually very much works out for him in the long run he is incredibly entertaining by doing that especially in this series

    • @rockassassin64
      @rockassassin64 2 года назад

      That being said I do absolutely agree Scott and Cleo are the Mean Girls and probably the meanest I just think you gave Jimmy way too much of a past because you do he literally did do bad things you didn't say any of them

  • @foop204
    @foop204 2 года назад +2

    Love this! I'd totally watch one on 3rd life but I understand if this is getting repetitive for you ^^

  • @catpartyfor1
    @catpartyfor1 Год назад +1

    Your wrong, double life is a romcom. Get your facts straight 🤬

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +1

      Oof I’m sorry. This is on me tbh, I apologize profusely

  • @amiablereaper
    @amiablereaper Год назад +2

    The funniest part of the "mean girls" is Cleo goes by they/them (though idk when that started) meaning there were no girls in the mean girls

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +2

      Oh wow, I actually just learned about this through this comment. Good for them!!

    • @amiablereaper
      @amiablereaper Год назад +1

      @@JayADonut glad to be a help!

    • @Login2play
      @Login2play Год назад +3

      actually their pronouns are she/they so you're half right

  • @shortcactus1192
    @shortcactus1192 2 года назад +1

    I’m not gonna lie, I almost completely excuse Grian of cheating on Scar cause I’m gonna be honest, he was probably one of the worst people to be soul mates with (not in a mean way). I just mean it took him awhile to figure out who his soul mate was and as completely reckless. In conclusion Scar’s gonna get you killed(Don’t get me wrong I love scar but he’s never gonna be calm Anlaufhäfen to not die)

    • @shortcactus1192
      @shortcactus1192 2 года назад

      Enough* (why did it auto correct to whatever that was-*

  • @zoemmckenna
    @zoemmckenna 2 года назад +1

    YAS CLEO WE STAN MEAN GIRL CLEO

  • @pokefanplayz3068
    @pokefanplayz3068 2 года назад +3

    The Good:
    Jimmy - A nice, forgiving guy who made some mistakes.
    Bigb - decent, but he cheated on ren
    Tango - good, but he put a warden on the surface.
    The Grey:
    Martyn - kinda an idiot, but pretty loyal
    Etho - Chill until red
    Grian - Rational, but a jerk
    Impulse - A nice villian
    The Bad:
    Ren - a jerk (mainly to pearl)
    Pearl- evil because she was treated bad
    Joel - A killer, but not that chaotic
    Scar - Scemer, torturer, robber, killer, etcall things a chaotic evil would do. One redeeming quality was he was mistreated and this made him do the torture part.
    Bdubs - Just evil. He was just tryna cause problems and he backstabbed everybody. Poor impulse.
    Scott - Mean girl #2
    Cleo - Mean girl # 1

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад

      Hahahaha this is great🤣🤣

    • @pokefanplayz3068
      @pokefanplayz3068 2 года назад

      @@JayADonut yeah lol. It's inspired by wickedbinge

  • @kalaismyoc689
    @kalaismyoc689 Год назад +1

    Scar made it 4th. Scar.SCAR.

  • @GlimmerGirlAnimation
    @GlimmerGirlAnimation 7 месяцев назад +2

    I cidnt see pearl on th list

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  7 месяцев назад +1

      14:53 she’s in there lol.

  • @rockassassin64
    @rockassassin64 2 года назад +1

    But even though they were definitely the meanest Scott and Cleo are the heroes this season or maybe Pearl is more of the hero she does win after all and like so she is very much misunderstood the entire time also like there has to be something to be said for Scott killing himself just so Pearl is considered the ultimate winner like the sweetest moment in the entire series but the reason why I think people are saying that Cleo and Scott are in fact the heroes and I 100% agree with this is because they are found family I think for a lot of people of myself is definitely one of these people so this is where my bias is found family is very important for a lot of people who don't have great relationships with with their family and like arguably like Scott and Cleo saying that the soulmate system is not what should actually choose your alliance and deciding to be with each other does kind of become a very interesting thing and if you're telling a narrative story which this isn't the narrative in that sense because it is all Improv but them essentially all making it the Final Four would also kind of essentially make them the protagonist of the series although again probably Pearl for the most part she does win they are still definitely the meanest though like I will not dispute you on that I just think they are both the meanest thing kind of Heroes of the server

  • @ashcamaya6595
    @ashcamaya6595 Год назад +1

    Lol Jimmy dying first a fourth time will get old...did not age well😂

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +1

      I uhhh yeah… about that…

  • @whitemink0939
    @whitemink0939 Год назад +1

    My favorite part of this whole thing was, (Etho) “he’s the kind of person who would stab you and you would thank him for it.” This is amazing and true.

  • @littlelucas553
    @littlelucas553 Год назад +1

    Now do a limited life one

  • @ItzLucky90
    @ItzLucky90 2 года назад +1

    although Grian did apologize to Bigb about killing him, i just think a kill on their "secret soulmate" should make Grian a bit more evil (not justifying cheating)

  • @swanmc
    @swanmc Год назад +2

    11:06 little did he know...

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +2

      Yeahhh this is just awkward now lmao

    • @swanmc
      @swanmc Год назад

      @@JayADonut yeah, i feel really bad for him now lol

  • @gg.7900
    @gg.7900 Год назад +2

    11:03 oh boy

  • @Starymixx
    @Starymixx 7 месяцев назад

    But Pearl’s 1v4 is really impressive!!
    BRING BACK UNHINGED PEARL!!

  • @sleepingchaser
    @sleepingchaser 2 года назад +2

    This was a really fun video!

  • @LBTS1389
    @LBTS1389 2 года назад +1

    Scott was slightly less mean, as he did a Katniss Everdeen for Pearl l, but he still caused a lot of chaos and was mean multiple people.

  • @rosesaysmeow8358
    @rosesaysmeow8358 Год назад +1

    6:18 Scott is the best at being Awesome!

  • @savant_games
    @savant_games 2 года назад +1

    I am privileged to be ur 1k subscriber

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад +1

      I am so privileged to have you!!!

  • @Mixedemotions-aaaah8766
    @Mixedemotions-aaaah8766 2 года назад +1

    Omg my favorite got meanest 😆. We take what we can get, and I support women's rights and wrongs.

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  2 года назад

      Women’s rights and wrongs🤣

  • @squiddorito
    @squiddorito 2 года назад +1

    Scott did let Pearl win in the end, so that I guess could justify him being placed slightly lower than Cleo

  • @roseswonderland8757
    @roseswonderland8757 2 года назад +1

    Honestly I don't really care much for the placements I just really like the watching desert Duo because you could clearly tell how upset Grian was with the situation
    Also I'm not really sure who the healthiest couple of award should go to I'm debating between the ranchers and the homewreckers because they were definitely the two healthiest couples

  • @k_asternix3114
    @k_asternix3114 Год назад +1

    You're so right about Jimmy by the way. Seems he's always getting the short end
    of the stick.

  • @jaythesock
    @jaythesock Год назад +1

    for desert duo being wholesome, it is really more like a business arrangement because they are the absolute opposite of ‘I would choose you in every universe’ it’s more like ‘I don’t want to be near you, because bad things happen around us when we’re together, but however hard we try, my guts tells me to run back to you and protect you.’

  • @kk_4730
    @kk_4730 2 года назад +1

    I very much enjoyed watching Scott's pov. Didnt realize how 'mean'(rp wise ofc) he actually was compared to the other. But tbh im not mad, it made a for an amazing series to watch and follow along with

  • @xinruzhang1643
    @xinruzhang1643 2 года назад +1

    the fact how joel is married and also how he and etho gave scar helmets

  • @kezberry21
    @kezberry21 Год назад

    I am soooooo with you on Cleo and Scott . I don't think Scar should be that high up . I mean, they set his jelly pandas on fire.

  • @natalierizk2519
    @natalierizk2519 2 года назад +1

    I’m being honest, I’m upset that satellite kill wasn’t in this video

  • @rosesaysmeow8358
    @rosesaysmeow8358 Год назад

    Martyn was nice... this time... wait till the LImited Life video comes out :)

  • @DirectorAmelia
    @DirectorAmelia Год назад +1

    🎵"Glasses dirty, makes it hard to read the script when your glasses are dirty so you gotta clean your glasses 'cause the script is hard to read when your glasses are super duper dirty BOWW!"🎵

    • @JayADonut
      @JayADonut  Год назад +1

      Was definitely the theme of my recording of this video😂

  • @catonahampsterwheel
    @catonahampsterwheel 6 месяцев назад

    i think grian was meaner than scar. he was honestly kinda tokic to his soulmate

  • @graciewilliams90
    @graciewilliams90 2 года назад +1

    And we love them for it ❤️

  • @howdoiturnssj3
    @howdoiturnssj3 11 месяцев назад

    No. No. Martyn was trying to intentionally kill Tilly in the finale. He is NOT that low.

  • @marinagulline9533
    @marinagulline9533 9 месяцев назад

    Ok I think u forgot the meanest thing which was grains drip stone kill on ren

  • @scarlettcapone1562
    @scarlettcapone1562 Год назад

    Dude, I died when you said "etho is to Canadian to be that mean" and yes it would be an honor to be stabbed by etho😃

  • @michaelgamel5915
    @michaelgamel5915 Год назад

    Welp time to take this SUPER SIRUSLY

  • @gamesgalore9183
    @gamesgalore9183 2 года назад

    Copper golem is better
    and that's final

  • @sibongilemthethwa5028
    @sibongilemthethwa5028 Год назад

    I felt the same way when grian cheatad on scar
    why is the wholesome desert duo

  • @uncannybirds2386
    @uncannybirds2386 Год назад +1

    THIS video is FANTASTIC oml

  • @kieraazzz
    @kieraazzz Год назад

    I agree but joel like 8th instead

  • @frightno928
    @frightno928 2 года назад +1

    I'm here to help the algorithm

  • @Umbertron05
    @Umbertron05 10 месяцев назад

    i think the nicest thing scott did this season was giving the win to pearl