I think this is a GREAT version of the classic song.... I guess you have to be a musician to really appreciate that yes? Paul has always loved the old classics and did many with the beatles and wings that he wrote in that style whichi is a testament to him considering the time he did it back in the 1970's. A FABULOUS song and dvd that everyone should have in their collection. so please, just appreciate the beauty of the song and the musicianship not too mention pauls great vocal. peace
Bella interpretación de este romántico Beatle!!! Su voz es tan cálida y al cerrar los ojos es como estar en los 50' .....como en las películas... bailando apasionadamente, suavemente...y llevarlo a la vida real un placer.Me enamoró.
Produced by Tommy LiPuma, Recorded by Al Schmitt. This team produced and recorded all of Diana's sessions until Tommy and Al died. It was Tommy's idea to use Diana as the pianist. That's the "Sinatra mic" he's singing into. The entire CD was recorded live in the studio.
Sir you and the general public are tone deaf and probably can not carry a tune in a bucket. That's why they cannot see any difference in this artist and other artist compared to real vocalist who sing in tune without any gadgets other than the aid of a microphone for example Ray Charles and Frank Sinatra. The tone deaf teeny boppers made many a celebrity rich and famous especially in more recent years.
Gosh, what an idiot you are. Macca was highly respected and covered by many great jazz artists from Ella to Frank Sinatra to Grant Green to Brad Mehldau. Are those tone deaf? Miles Davis invited Paul McCartney to play with him. Was he also tone deaf? Check your ears first.
Sinatra has a great version of this. I read somewhere one of Paul's ambitions before the Beatles became famous was to write a song Sinatra would record. I know Sinatra covered George Harrison, not sure if ever McCartney.
AMAZING AND AWESOME VIDEO WITH MANY GREATS . THE VIDEO WAS EVEN BETTER SEEING THE ARTISTS IMAGE AS WELL AS THE SOUND [ESPECIALLY DIANA KRALL WITH PAUL MCCARTNEY .
I fear this isn't the greatest vehicle for the great, amazing Paul McCartney, or Macca as he's called. Maybe when he was younger, but his voice has to strain a bit too much -- the song requires sublime relaxation. check out Johnny Hartman singing this with John Coltrane.
The woman in the piano is Diana Krall!!! It was preferable she was who was singing!! The better version of this song is that Laura Cole performed with Cris Botti with his trumpet. But this song is also for be performed by Diana Krall perfectly.
Just because the performer's name is McCartney doesn't mean he knocks this out of the park. He doesn't - this ain't his thing, and the emperor has no clothes. Listen to Hartman or Sinatra cover this. On a positive note, let's be grateful it wasn't Krall singing, which might have been even worse.
Together with Lennon, McCartney's was the voice of the sixties - a great rock n roll shouter and pop balladeer BUT he is not a jazz singer as this embarrassingly out of tune rendering proves. Jazz requires a musical sophistication that was way above this Scouser's ability. Yeah, yeah, yeah...
Willie Otoole, I'm a jazz nut. I played tenor sax many years in New Orleans. I now play as a One Man Band entertaining with an arranger keyboard and I do vocals. I'm maybe an average musician or a tad above average. I can't sing this tune any better than Paul here, so I don't sing it. I stick with what I can do and Paul should do likewise. I found out years ago for the most part the public is tone deaf. Most of them can not sing do re me fa so la te do in tune in any key. Thus we have rich and famous out of tune singers who need pitch correction gadgets today. It's really depressing to real musicians with an ear! Sir, are you a musician or are you the one in thousands of the general public who can hear when a person sings out of tune. I'd really like to know. Thanks for reading my comment.
no sophistication in jazz...jazz is life , jazz is the street, a music from the heart...i don't find Paul's effort good, but it's not appalling. Not lousier than if a jazz singer tried to sing "Get back" or " Hi, hi, hi"... Music would be sad if every musician sticked to his comfort zone...
One of the best versions of this song. Paul’s always super at singing romantic songs.
The lyrics of this song is very romantic. I asked my husband that we dance to this music on our 40th anniversary.
Diana K….you’re the one so special for this recording! Paul M…the legend genius.
I love him singing this❤
I think this is a GREAT version of the classic song.... I guess you have to be a musician to really appreciate that yes? Paul has always loved the old classics and did many with the beatles and wings that he wrote in that style whichi is a testament to him considering the time he did it back in the 1970's. A FABULOUS song and dvd that everyone should have in their collection. so please, just appreciate the beauty of the song and the musicianship not too mention pauls great vocal. peace
Listen to Sting’s version.
Beautifully done by McCartney and Krall. I'm never very impressed by his voice at later age but this was superb.
If only I had known he was a gesticulator a long, long, long, long time ago.... There coulda been trouble!
😄🎶🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗
I believe it doesn't get any better than this.
Beautiful song, great singer!
I love this song and the entire album.
He sings it with feeling. Lovely❤
Très beau, très romantique... et en plus la voix de Paul McCartney, j'adore !
Beautiful rendition Paul
Bella interpretación de este romántico Beatle!!! Su voz es tan cálida y al cerrar los ojos es como estar en los 50' .....como en las películas... bailando apasionadamente, suavemente...y llevarlo a la vida real un placer.Me enamoró.
Produced by Tommy LiPuma, Recorded by Al Schmitt. This team produced and recorded all of Diana's sessions until Tommy and Al died. It was Tommy's idea to use Diana as the pianist. That's the "Sinatra mic" he's singing into. The entire CD was recorded live in the studio.
贅沢なバックミュージシャン（笑）
Thank you for your information, I really appreciate it...
Is it my imagination, or is that Diana Krall on piano. Looks and sounds like her, but no mention can I find!
+Jazzwayze Yes it is Diana is all her splendor
I should have known from the changes! Thank you.
In the liner notes
Love this
Pure magic
I like this McCartney version of a now American classic.
Sir you and the general public are tone deaf and probably can not carry a tune in a bucket. That's why they cannot see any difference in this artist and other artist compared to real vocalist who sing in tune without any gadgets other than the aid of a microphone for example Ray Charles and Frank Sinatra. The tone deaf teeny boppers made many a celebrity rich and famous especially in more recent years.
Gosh, what an idiot you are.
Macca was highly respected and covered by many great jazz artists from Ella to Frank Sinatra to Grant Green to Brad Mehldau. Are those tone deaf? Miles Davis invited Paul McCartney to play with him. Was he also tone deaf?
Check your ears first.
American classic ? . Music by an Englishman , lytics by a Russian ,
Awesome job.
Sinatra has a great version of this. I read somewhere one of Paul's ambitions before the Beatles became famous was to write a song Sinatra would record. I know Sinatra covered George Harrison, not sure if ever McCartney.
One of the best recording is by John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman.
AMAZING AND AWESOME VIDEO WITH MANY GREATS . THE VIDEO WAS EVEN BETTER SEEING THE ARTISTS IMAGE AS WELL AS THE SOUND [ESPECIALLY DIANA KRALL WITH PAUL MCCARTNEY .
try chet baker version if you like this one.
Is there a live video version of Chet Baker doing this song?
He's like the wine.
this song comes from heaven
Wow. I think I'm in love with Diana Krall.
Wonderful music...!!!
The Best recording is an Instrument version by Benny Carter. I can't believe this is a same guy who recorded Hi Hi Hi, how times have changed...
Excelente
I fear this isn't the greatest vehicle for the great, amazing Paul McCartney, or Macca as he's called. Maybe when he was younger, but his voice has to strain a bit too much -- the song requires sublime relaxation. check out Johnny Hartman singing this with John Coltrane.
I think the key was a bit low for his voice. And, yes, Hartman's rendition is sublime.
It does not get better fantasy my skin is chilled
# 1 EVER .... ❤️
❤❤❤❤
amo troppo questo brano per commentare la prestazione di Paul che comunque mi sembra dignitosa.
wow with Diana Krall !!!
GENIAL !!
This song comes with certain age !!
😍👏❤️
alguin lo podría pasar al español?? sería maravilloso
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
ВЕЛИКИЙ МУЗЫКАНТ!!!!!!!
dina makes a boo boo at the end but i still think she is a great jazz pianist
😄
Who can sing with Diana Krall on piano on that world ?
🖤
The woman in the piano is Diana Krall!!! It was preferable she was who was singing!! The better version of this song is that Laura Cole performed with Cris Botti with his trumpet. But this song is also for be performed by Diana Krall perfectly.
Please, Sir Paul cannot carry a note. Diana is a gift.
🌱🌾💚🙄
Cocktail hr.
Just because the performer's name is McCartney doesn't mean he knocks this out of the park. He doesn't - this ain't his thing, and the emperor has no clothes. Listen to Hartman or Sinatra cover this. On a positive note, let's be grateful it wasn't Krall singing, which might have been even worse.
😂😂😂
Nice song and a fair arrangement but alas not Paul`s bag.Who did the arrangement,George Martin?
Actually it was George Martini! 😂
Looks like Diana Krall
Would Paul McCartney let George Harrison sing one my only love would Paul let geogre give it a try ?
Great sentimental song , unfortunately Sir Paul has lost his. Voice. ...
It seems her, who else????
la version de sting es mucho mejor pero McCartney es McCartney aqui y en china
He should have done it in a lower key
I am fan of Paul,but I think his performance here is far behind Sting !
ポール。
ダイアナかな。
I'm sorry but this doesn't do it for me . I love Paul, but no.
No offense to P.M. but listen to Sing’s version of this same song. (Way better.) It’s not a competition of course. Just saying…
The.
Is ten to John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman version. Superlative.
ピアノは、ダイアナ・クラール違うの？ 違うな・・・
All that talent in one place , but sounds like a bad Karaoke .
May have been , notice the piano keeps playing after she stop playing at the end .
Willie otoole you are so right! He lacks as you say the musical sophistication that the song needs. And you are right also, he sings out of tune!
Altijd een fan van Paul geweest maar je kunt nu eenmaal niet alles zingen....
Sorry to say that, but Sir Paul wil not become a jazz singer, he is a great po star though my 50 cent
On key but voice is so-so, let's be honest. Compare to Johnny Hartmann
Together with Lennon, McCartney's was the voice of the sixties - a great rock n roll shouter and pop balladeer BUT he is not a jazz singer as this embarrassingly out of tune rendering proves. Jazz requires a musical sophistication that was way above this Scouser's ability. Yeah, yeah, yeah...
Willie Otoole, I'm a jazz nut. I played tenor sax many years in New Orleans. I now play as a One Man Band entertaining with an arranger keyboard and I do vocals. I'm maybe an average musician or a tad above average. I can't sing this tune any better than Paul here, so I don't sing it. I stick with what I can do and Paul should do likewise. I found out years ago for the most part the public is tone deaf. Most of them can not sing do re me fa so la te do in tune in any key. Thus we have rich and famous out of tune singers who need pitch correction gadgets today. It's really depressing to real musicians with an ear! Sir, are you a musician or are you the one in thousands of the general public who can hear when a person sings out of tune. I'd really like to know. Thanks for reading my comment.
no sophistication in jazz...jazz is life , jazz is the street, a music from the heart...i don't find Paul's effort good, but it's not appalling. Not lousier than if a jazz singer tried to sing "Get back" or " Hi, hi, hi"...
Music would be sad if every musician sticked to his comfort zone...