really it amazes me that they can keep their eyes dry while performing this. our page brings tears to my eyes always. shinee fighting. forever and always five.
This is really a masterpiece, its pure, its honest, its full of feelings and its about something very real but mainly cuz they wrote it themselves...so why its not even candidate for best song of the year?? :,(
Shinee never performed or released this song to win something. They released and performed this song to just give a nice tribute to their own brother Jonghyun. They never thought to win any awards to this song, they just wanted to send a message to Jonghyun by this song
Onew oppa said "수고했어"( Good Job) at the end of the song, really made my eyes teary...😢 Indeed Jonghyun oppa done extremely well!👍 He's so perfect in every way that's possible~❤ ❤종현오빠, 수고했어요❤ *5HINee 영원히*
Oh i miss him too, I am so thankful that SHINee kept together over the years, that they have given us these gifts to remember him by. I will always support our boys.
heartbreaking lyrics... i'm sure jonghyun is crying up there in heaven.... shinee has shown how much they are meant to each other through this song... I know its hard to move on when you lose someone dear to you but we must move on.... shinee must move on... fight the battle of grief.... fighting!!
This is only my 3rd time watching this song since its release, not because I don't like it but because it's too painful. Each line reminds me on the moments they have had together,the moment they shaired with us, the happy moments, the sad, the emotional,the beginning, the laughter, the smiles... This song renders me to tears every time but I'm grateful for this song...
the lyric about jonghyun and their memories of friendship 😢😢... beautiful song.. beautiful liric beautiful friendship.. beautiful smile of jonghyun.. jonghyun member of shinee forever.. happy for you kim jonghyun up there.. "YOU DID WELL KIM JONG HYUN" 😘😘
me listening to this song in 2021 bcs I still miss Jonghyun sm :(( he's still a very sensitive topic to me :(( but i need to let jonghyun go, but its so hard :(( i love him sm and i miss him sm
No matter how many times i watch them perform this song i always cry every time. It’s amazing to me, out of this world even, how they can sing this song without breaking down crying or even without voice cracks. They are so strong, i love them.
Is it just me or maybe taemin oppa’s makeup...or his eyes just look emotionless every time he sings this song...it’s just like his eyes during jjong funeral...he doesn’t look at the camera much as well...but his voice is full of emotion... :( I feel sad every time i listen to this song
Rhoia Lity Taemin is very stoic & he’s good at hiding his emotions. But that makes it even worse because it doesn’t mean he hurts less, it means he’s hurting even more, because he’s suffering in silence. We know what Jonghyun meant to him. What he meant to all of them. If anyone had a doubt this songs lyrics, & how they sing it is enough to tell you. They will grieve him forever, but they will continue their lives too. That’s how it’s should be.
I wouldn’t want my emotions to show on camera as well. I would be pissed to have to sing about someone dear to me just few months after his death. I mean it’s just using this extremely sad moment to sell more. I understand why they had to sing a positive song and publish heartfelt letters on their social media. But I don’t find it okay, those kids are allowed to so little privacy. It breaks my heart.
@@TalyaSan They actually said in multiple interviews this was THEIR choice. They wanted to do it. They wanted to honor him. No one forced them to do this. It was part of their healing for themselves. This was just one of the first performances which made it all the harder to do.
they all look like they’re having a bad time, compared to their recent comeback where they’ve been all smiles, the energy is different, and i’m glad. getting swallowed by grief is very easy if you aren’t careful
😍😍😍😍😍 SHINee is the best kpop for me #SHINee #Ourpage #PHshawol I love SHINee very much 💚💚💚💚💚❤❤❤❤❤ I'm proud of them good singer good rapper good actor amazing dancers & beautiful Man model all of them #Onew #Key #Minho #Taemin #Jonghyun
Absolutely for jjong they closed the page where Jonghyun was there and they turn another page with his memories again the lyrics we’re so complicated hurtful but they need to do it to continue to shine without Jonghyun present but his memories remains each hyungs heart ♥️ they already accepted that Jonghyun isn’t coming anymore and yet he has always place in their heart forever sounds like that
Jonghyun-ah I mis you so much now😭 I'm sorry but I'm a new SHAWOL🙏❤😭 Every day I promise to you oppa I'm here for SHINee forever🙏💎 I love you🙏❤😭 you di well oppa Rest in peace😭🙏
I'm hearing this for the 3rd time in a row, and I'm crying all 3 times. 네가 남겨둔 예쁜 말들은 한 편의 시가 되어 노래가 되고 목소리 날아 너 있는 곳에 닿을 거란 걸 우린 알잖아 별이 사라진다면 모두 잊혀질까 소중했던 널 안아 내 품에 끝나지 않은 이 소설의 페이지 마지막까지 함께 채울래 The pretty words you left Behind become a poem, become a song Our voices are flying We know it’ll reach you wherever you are If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten? I’m holding the precious you in my arms I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet Until the very end This touches my heart a lot. 2008년 5월 25일 소년들환히 빛난 봄날의 초록빛 물결들그 시간은 또 영원히 더 흘러펴져 갈 거야 Translation: May 25, 2008, Boys shining brightly Like green waves of spring That time will spread and flow forever This breaks my heart that he had to take his life. Every single lyric they used, I think everybody would be heartbroken. And the fact that he had to take his life... 2021, and I still don't want to accept the fact that he's gone, so I won't. He's still with us. R.I.P Angel. Fly High. We have and will ALWAYS love you🤎🤎💜💙💕💛🧡🧡🤍🤍🤍🤍❣💕💕💓💓💞💗💖💖💘💘💝
![[Comeback Stage] SHINee- Our Page ,샤이니 - 네가 남겨둔 말 Show Music core 20180630](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ifXi0uecKW4/mqdefault.jpg)
![(ENG)[MusicBank Interview Cam] 샤이니 (SHINee Interview)l@MusicBank KBS 230630](/img/1.gif)
"There's five overlapping hands, tears and memories" :( Yes this song is about Jonghyun...
really it amazes me that they can keep their eyes dry while performing this. our page brings tears to my eyes always. shinee fighting. forever and always five.
SHINees comeback needs more recognition all of their songs are so soulful, raw and amazingly well put together.
SHINee fighting!!!
I can see Jjong sitting in the middle of the stage with his arms to the sky waving with the song with his beautiful big smile and watery eyes.
When you feel that they're singing their hearts out.
Those lyrics huhuhu it's just so real~
Love you boys! Shinee❤❤
We'll Support you until the End
This is really a masterpiece, its pure, its honest, its full of feelings and its about something very real but mainly cuz they wrote it themselves...so why its not even candidate for best song of the year?? :,(
Shinee never performed or released this song to win something. They released and performed this song to just give a nice tribute to their own brother Jonghyun. They never thought to win any awards to this song, they just wanted to send a message to Jonghyun by this song
Onew oppa said "수고했어"( Good Job) at the end of the song, really made my eyes teary...😢 Indeed Jonghyun oppa done extremely well!👍 He's so perfect in every way that's possible~❤
❤종현오빠, 수고했어요❤
*5HINee 영원히*
Jonghyun always wanted to hear that 수고했어, I was crying at that point too!😢😭
😢😢😢😭😭😭
Today is 25th of May. Exactly 13 years ago, 5 shining boys came to our life :))
How many international shawol are here?
Me!!
Me too!🇸🇮
i can't even imagine how hard it must have been for them to record this and then even singing it live :(
Oh i miss him too, I am so thankful that SHINee kept together over the years, that they have given us these gifts to remember him by. I will always support our boys.
heartbreaking lyrics... i'm sure jonghyun is crying up there in heaven.... shinee has shown how much they are meant to each other through this song...
I know its hard to move on when you lose someone dear to you but we must move on.... shinee must move on... fight the battle of grief.... fighting!!
This is only my 3rd time watching this song since its release, not because I don't like it but because it's too painful. Each line reminds me on the moments they have had together,the moment they shaired with us, the happy moments, the sad, the emotional,the beginning, the laughter, the smiles... This song renders me to tears every time but I'm grateful for this song...
I'm not crying, you're crying T^T That 수고했어 honestly broke me
Their eyes revealed all the emotions inside :')
I just noticed their mic colors Onew: aqua Key: pink Minho: blue (Jonghyun's color) and Taemin: black (instead of yellow)
Blue is minho's colour. Jjong's colour is red 😊
Onew's color is green 💚
Jongs color has always been red and Minho's has always been blue while Taemins is yellow, Keys color is pink and Onews is green
Happy Anniversary my shining SHINee 🎉
Miss you Jonghyun oppa
Doing a great job as always... love you SHINee! Fighting.
Also thanks for the subs!
i only had the courage to watch their live stages singing this today and that 수고했어 really got me ㅠ
They were really singing their hearts out at this stage
That "GOOD JOB" made me broke the tears I've been holding up since the start of this vid.
SHINEE FOREVER 5 💎💎💎💎💎
the lyric about jonghyun and their memories of friendship 😢😢...
beautiful song..
beautiful liric
beautiful friendship..
beautiful smile of jonghyun..
jonghyun member of shinee forever..
happy for you kim jonghyun up there..
"YOU DID WELL KIM JONG HYUN" 😘😘
I just want to say something
Shinee,thank you for existing 😇😇
We really have to thank their parents for giving birth to them😭😭😭😭😭. These boys are legends kings and everything. PROUD BEING A SHAWOL💎💎💎💎💎
❤
😭😭♥️
It's so a obvious their still in pain over jonghyuns passing and singing their hearts outs for him, this is a special performance!! Job well done!!
Key 😭😭😭😭😭.
THE JINKI "WELL DONE" PLS IM CRYING
수고했어요 “You did well”
May 25th 2008, their debut date 😭😭😭
SHINee is still five!💎
I just can't stop sobbing and crying listening to this song😭😭
Finally strong enough to listen....
im crying everytime i heard thid song 😭❤
Did Taemin changed his mic color from yellow to black?? I didn't know about it. All of you did very well. Proud of you my boys.
me listening to this song in 2021 bcs I still miss Jonghyun sm :((
he's still a very sensitive topic to me :(( but i need to let jonghyun go, but its so hard :(( i love him sm and i miss him sm
1:39 miss u JY 🙏🏻
love u shinee, you are so talented and strong... ✨✨✨✨✨
I'm not crying, my eyes are just sweating
i get chills every time i watch their performance with our page. these men doing great!
I'love this songs
I miss you I miss you I miss you
There aren't much words needed: Thank you SHINee💕
No matter how many times i watch them perform this song i always cry every time. It’s amazing to me, out of this world even, how they can sing this song without breaking down crying or even without voice cracks. They are so strong, i love them.
I'm crying ugly over and over again everytime coming back here. This is so pure;_;
Thank you SHINee for existing
still sobbing.
I’m sure Jonghyun is happy with how you sing this song....he’s in tears of joy 💖❤️❤️❤️❤️
this song became a work of art for me, you will always shine.
Is it just me or maybe taemin oppa’s makeup...or his eyes just look emotionless every time he sings this song...it’s just like his eyes during jjong funeral...he doesn’t look at the camera much as well...but his voice is full of emotion... :(
I feel sad every time i listen to this song
Rhoia Lity Taemin is very stoic & he’s good at hiding his emotions. But that makes it even worse because it doesn’t mean he hurts less, it means he’s hurting even more, because he’s suffering in silence. We know what Jonghyun meant to him. What he meant to all of them. If anyone had a doubt this songs lyrics, & how they sing it is enough to tell you. They will grieve him forever, but they will continue their lives too. That’s how it’s should be.
I wouldn’t want my emotions to show on camera as well. I would be pissed to have to sing about someone dear to me just few months after his death. I mean it’s just using this extremely sad moment to sell more. I understand why they had to sing a positive song and publish heartfelt letters on their social media. But I don’t find it okay, those kids are allowed to so little privacy. It breaks my heart.
@@TalyaSan They actually said in multiple interviews this was THEIR choice. They wanted to do it. They wanted to honor him. No one forced them to do this. It was part of their healing for themselves. This was just one of the first performances which made it all the harder to do.
ikr, i also noticed it. Just like how his eyes were in the funeral. Your comment just makes me bawl my eyes out more..
they all look like they’re having a bad time, compared to their recent comeback where they’ve been all smiles, the energy is different, and i’m glad. getting swallowed by grief is very easy if you aren’t careful
This song makes me cry everytime....😔😔😔
Shinee will always be my first love... ❤❤When it comes to kpop..
😍😍😍😍😍 SHINee is the best kpop for me #SHINee #Ourpage #PHshawol I love SHINee very much 💚💚💚💚💚❤❤❤❤❤ I'm proud of them good singer good rapper good actor amazing dancers & beautiful Man model all of them
#Onew
#Key
#Minho
#Taemin
#Jonghyun
SHINee 😍😍😍😍shawol 😘😘😘😘
oh my god it's beautiful... Their voices are phenomenal!
a movie about our dearest blingbling ♥
we all can feel it honestly their teary eyes it must be so hard to perform after what happened
SHINee is Forever!!!😍
The lyrics the lyrics the lyrics...beyond beautiful! Tears every time I listen to this.
It’s just the human way of living am sure they misss him sooooooo much
This song with their Incredible Voices ... Hits the Heart Dead Center!!!
Still, every time I watch or listen to our page I can't help but shed tears. 5HINee always forever 💎💙💎💙💎💙💎💙💎💙
Beautiful song amazing vocals 💎💎💎💎💎
Pfft im not the one crying...ur the one crying
SHINee FIGHTING
let me cry please.
Why i'm still crying 😭😢
it feels like this song is for JONGHYUN
King Baekh the fact is they wrote it for him and it's the closure song for their comeback
This song is indeed for Jonghyun. They write this while think of him... How beautiful 😊
King Baekh that’s because it is.
Absolutely for jjong they closed the page where Jonghyun was there and they turn another page with his memories again the lyrics we’re so complicated hurtful but they need to do it to continue to shine without Jonghyun present but his memories remains each hyungs heart ♥️ they already accepted that Jonghyun isn’t coming anymore and yet he has always place in their heart forever sounds like that
It is
Onew Saying good job, just broke my heart again such amazingly talent singers and wonderful brotherhood
IIYAQ NA LANG AKO DITO.
We still miss you jjong! Everyday 💚💚💚 I'm happy we got to knew you and your beautiful mind and voice. Please rest well in the sky.
SHINEE💎💎💎💎💎 2019
is 25march2008 their debut date?
@@fyiilysm may
Support SHINee forever!
SHİNee forever 5
Jonghyun-ah I mis you so much now😭
I'm sorry but I'm a new SHAWOL🙏❤😭
Every day I promise to you oppa I'm here for SHINee forever🙏💎
I love you🙏❤😭 you di well oppa
Rest in peace😭🙏
I'm sure Jonghyun is very proud of his brothers💖
Jonghyun “you did well”❤️💎
It hurts still to is day
Nossa essa homenagem foi linda,chorei tanto ao ouvi-la 😭Jonghyun você foi incrível❤Saudades meu Lindo Príncipe💎⭐💖
I cry 😭😭😭
Still here waiting for your comeback Shinee! Shawols are waiting ❤️
Not me crying out my eyes while going through this era's 3 album💎
Shine more brighter SHINee
Sure Jonghyun is shining for you in sky you shine nowww
I hope SHINee comebacks againnn😍😘😢😭 5hinee💎😢💖
Knowing the lyrics hits me. 💎💎💎💎💎
So sweet ♥️ Fighting SHINee
I’m not a SHINee fan but after listening to this song , I think I’m going to become one . The lyrics really hit hard , I’m crying 😭
#ThankYou_SHINee 💎💎💎💎💎
수고했어
I'm hearing this for the 3rd time in a row, and I'm crying all 3 times.
네가 남겨둔 예쁜 말들은
한 편의 시가 되어 노래가 되고
목소리 날아 너 있는 곳에
닿을 거란 걸 우린 알잖아
별이 사라진다면 모두 잊혀질까
소중했던 널 안아 내 품에
끝나지 않은 이 소설의 페이지
마지막까지 함께 채울래
The pretty words you left
Behind become a poem, become a song
Our voices are flying
We know it’ll reach you wherever you are
If a star vanishes, will everything be forgotten?
I’m holding the precious you in my arms
I want to fill the pages of this story that isn’t over yet
Until the very end
This touches my heart a lot.
2008년 5월 25일 소년들환히 빛난 봄날의 초록빛 물결들그 시간은 또 영원히 더 흘러펴져 갈 거야
Translation: May 25, 2008, Boys shining brightly
Like green waves of spring
That time will spread and flow forever
This breaks my heart that he had to take his life.
Every single lyric they used, I think everybody would be heartbroken. And the fact that he had to take his life... 2021, and I still don't want to accept the fact that he's gone, so I won't. He's still with us.
R.I.P Angel. Fly High. We have and will ALWAYS love you🤎🤎💜💙💕💛🧡🧡🤍🤍🤍🤍❣💕💕💓💓💞💗💖💖💘💘💝
수고했어요. My boys
that expression can't lie
Happy 5HINee Day my boys❤
My babies 😩😩😩❤️
forever 5 shinee
Cada vez que la escucho lloro, es demasiado hermoso!
I started crying when they mention their debut date
SHINee and Shineeworld Forever🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
I love you SHINee 💖💖💖💖💖
5HINee Is FIVE Forever 💎💎💎💎💎
5hinee forever
I promise my bling bling that i wont cry that i will be strong but i failed i miss him so bad 💔😭😭
3:05 ALL you need to here from SHINee
This power of sharing emotions through... only SHINee :")
i love you boys you indeed shine💓thank you for shining😭😭
一生大好きです
Still can’t believe JH LEFT
💎💎💎💎💎 always...