the way she said “there is someone on my side” makes my heart so broke rn. Feeling of losing someone who always stay our sides can’t be explained in words
I can't imagine how shua feel right now. She lost her brother forever. Shua, i hope you'll always strong. We'll always here to support you. Rest in peace, moonbin.
True. In the upcoming days, I hope everyone remember him for who he was. He done a lot of things that deserves to be mentioned. He’s more than his passing ♥️
I cant believe 😭😭 if she is crying now with his hyung what more today moon bin passed away 😭😭 I hope sua will keep up and may you rest in peace moon bin
I feel like the reason why he did not answer her calls was because he himself was going through a hard time and he didn’t want to talk to her about his hard times cause he wanted to protect her. It’s heartbreaking!
He was in too much pain but couldn't share his burdens with others. He even wanted her sister not to join the industry, but he knows that is also the dream of his sister. Moonbin, why did you give up your own precious life 😢
I think a bit of fault of his company. He's been constantly working since 5/6 months with his subunit comeback and tour. They didn't put his mental health into priority and made him keep working for tours. Kpop industry is very brutal, idol is just money making machine for the company. They had a concert in macau this Saturday as well. Imagine having to deal with all this stress when you're already depressed. 😢
@@abidakausar4426 you don't know what happened. stop assuming and respect his family's wishes. Speaking like you know everything.. he recently chose to sign again with his company.
@@they4852 No. His contract ended meaning he CHOSE to sign it again. They only pay a fee if they BREAK their contract and that's not what happened. So stop making up lies.
@@piedpiper1234 yes idk what happened. But he killed himself according to police. And ik Kpop idols who did the same. And I know Kpop industry is brutal It might not be major factor but still can't ignore it
Heartbreaking fact that she lost the only person she could rely on 💔 this situation making me feel worst 5he more I think about this tragedy the more I feel weak and heartbroken if I can feel that much pain for my idol she lost his brother can't even imagine
I am so heartbroken and devastated by Moon Bins passing. I really hope Sua and thier family are okay and can get through this. RIP Moon Bin, you will be missed. 💔
no matter how strong and independent she is, she still needs someone to share/lean on to remain normal/sane. grateful she chose her family to share many things. what you have done is very correct, sua.
I am feeling so sorry for her loss now😢 please stay strong and remember that moonbin will always look after you in heaven ❤😢and remember that he loves you so much moonsua..I can’t imagine how much she’s hurt now 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Bro, I want to give her the biggest hug in the world and tell her everything is going to be all right. The pain she must be going through right now is unimaginable. I hope she finds healing during this horrible time..
This broke my heart she always call him eventhough he wouldn't take the call but now is wouldn't ever take her call or comfort her like he did I feel really sorry for them they were really close RIP Moonbin
The way moonbin told his sister that he would not let her become entertainer if she wouldn't be trainee for so long shows how concerned he was for his sister because he know how dirty and strict such industries our where you have yo be pretendous 24/7 ...moonbin is no more now , cant stop crying ,moonsua pls held in there .stay strong
My heart is shattered. I can’t imagine what sua must be going through....... and binnie close friends like seungkwan, sinb, chanwoo, kayoung and astro members.
No one's gonna answer her calls now... someone has to step up to give her the comfort she needs right now and to the upcoming years in her career. That someone could be either her family, her group members, her friends, or her fans. I don't want to see her cry but now I can imagine her crying right now. This is a very sad and painful day for those who cares this man, Moonbin.
can't imagine sua's pain right now and even more so for their parents.. it hurts as an aroha but we all know it's even harder for bin's family.. i just hope they get all the strength they need to carry on and bin-ah, you'll always be loved and remembered our dearest sunshine
😭😭😭 moonbin left us too now… my heart is in so much pain rn, I can’t even imagine what Sua is going through. I just wish I could give her a big hug to let her know that everything will be okay. Gosh, I miss Moonbin, I found out in school right before class because and I couldn't stop crying 😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺😭😭
It's good that Sua was able to tell how she really feels about her brother. Please Bin, now answers her calls, I know you're acting tough but you love your sister very much and I know you're the one who understands her the most about being an idol and the problems that come with it ;__;
It's really heartbreaking. Can't imagine how Moon Sua feels right now. This programme just about several months ago and maybe through this they were just newly spending time together and knowing each other more than before. Seeing her crying here, makes me crying too. I hope she is stay strong to accept this and RIP for Moon Bin. My condolences too for Aroha
Oh no moon sua... we all love you and moonbin, it must be hard right now but pls pls try to stay strong, we're all here for you and will support the both of you forever.. ❤️
He said if he wasn’t be a singer, he would have been a swimmer. I wonder how his life would be if he didn't picked entertainment industry. He looks so worried for his sister in this clip. Rest in peace Astro's Moonbin. You will be in our hearts forever. We love you ✨✨
As we can see how he expressed all those things he was dealing in the kpop industry and to explained his sister not to become a entertainer and we can all see now why he meant that his every word he said to his sister and how he cares about her this is really sad…rip bright star we’ll miss u forever kpop industry should at least get alerted after this
I understand her. The idols world is lonely and they feel the stress and pressure of always being exposed. For a younger sister nothing it's better than the advice and company of a brother that can guide you and protect you.
IDK WHAT SUA MUST BE FEELING RIGHT NOW...EVEN THOUGH I DIDN'T STAN THEM ..I'm CRYING FR......MY DEEPEST DEEPEST CONDOLENCE TO HIS FAMILY FRIENDS AND FANS❤💐
He probably couldn’t answer b/c he might have been afraid that he couldn’t pretend to be strong enough for her to lean on. Things would slip through the cracks and it would have caused his sister further worry and anxiety. He perhaps did not want her to worry by answering the phone, revealing his low and dark points without intending, and tarnish the gleaming strong older brother impression that his sister had of him.
Oh sweet Moonbin and Sua. My heart aches. Rest in paradise, beautiful Moonbin. Lovely Sua, your brother will always protect you no matter what. He is your shining star. He loves you so much.
so now who’s gonna answer sua phone calls again? im sorry u must going through all of this pain, moobin. we’re sorry we didn’t know your pain. both of u don’t deserve this kind of pain. fly high, binnie. we love you sua. ❤️
Now she must have alot of pressure but there is no moonbin anymore she would be really sad😢😢😢she thought someone is her side to say how she is feeling but....
It all became clear now. All his words make sense now. Also if anyone who reads this message has ever written a hate comment on any idol’s post kindly go and delete it right now. We all should be ashamed of ourselves for judging people especially idols according to our convenience and hating them. If an idol is dating it’s his choice, if he is married it’s his choice again (this is in general not for moonbin) As bystanders we are no one to disrespect and reprimand them. They work so hard for us, to help us overcome our pain, to give the best quality content they can to us. It’s really shameful that even after seeing such incidents happen in the past as well, there still are people in this world who continue to nurture hate. Incidents like these do not happen in one day, it builds up for a long long time. The constant nagging, hate, lack of a healthy routine all lead to such incidents. Please guys if some of you can’t say good things about any idol at least refrain from spreading bad comments. Once again what has happened has happened but we as viewers can at least make sure that nothing like this happens again.
Moonbin... My Moonlight... Sua, please don't let the moonlight go out. Please stay strong and stay with us. Your brother would want it to be like that...
Only a sister would know the value of a brother. We go through ups and downs but the bond will remain forever. May MoonBin rests in peace. May Shua find the strength to keep moving in life with beautiful memories of him.
i hope that, now sua has debuted and has a whole team of friends who love and care about her very much, she still feels like she has people she can lean on and feel support from in difficult times. nothing could ever replace her brother, but as long as she doesn’t feel alone like she did here :(
God. Seeing this video after his death makes it even more heartbreaking for them both. I can’t imagine the pain this family is going through, the pain MoonBin went through
He wanted to proctect her from the industry bc ge knew how hard it was for him. He was a good brother, friend & entertainer. I pray his family & true friebds heak from this.💔🕊️
And now she really need her brother to pick her phone up and tell what's really going with her 😭 But...😭 I pray the God give energy to Moonbin's family to control their emotions. Sua please be strong.
if i ever lost one of my brothers... i can't even imagine. my heart aches so much i only got to know moonbin through the content with him and Sua.. i hope Sua takes all the time she needs to fully heal. there's nothing more important than this rn. and yes, cyberbullying and hateful comments can even tear siblings apart. please be mindful on the internet.
i vividly remembered the first time i saw this, my heart aches bcs they grew up separately bcs both of them trainee since young. and sua always adores and proud seeing her oppa didn't give up to debut and thats the reason she's not giving up too and debut last year. she even said that moonbin's concert are the one that comforts her while she's down and even cried when moonbin didn't answer her call bcs he is all she has and she felt like there's someone for her if he answer the callㅠㅠ and the moment i saw the article last night, this scene flashes in my head:((
she is in my heart right now. she is experiencing every sister's nightmare and I hope she has people by her side to let her process this horrible loss.
my heart hurts so bad rn and just listening to his voice its bringing tears to my eyes again 😓 I hope sua is ok and I send my condolences to the moon family ❤️ God I wish this wasn't true.. rest in peace moonbinie 🕊💕.
![ASTRO's Moonbin is so nice to his sister on their lunch date l DNA Mate Ep 46 [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yvtT8v_ibms/mqdefault.jpg)
![ASTRO's Moonbin is so nice to his sister on their lunch date l DNA Mate Ep 46 [ENG SUB]](/img/tr.png)
![[MY LITTLE OLD BOY] "I have no interest in giving you two dads." (ENGSUB)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Da_AbT21cs/mqdefault.jpg)
![The real reason Moonbin didn't answer Sua's calls l DNA Mate Ep 46 [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i4CUIdPjA0E/mqdefault.jpg)
I cannot imagine her pain now.. Stay strong moonsua... Your oppa will always be there to hear you...
............
You cannot say that now 😞
@@Marichika24 she wrote it after he passed
@@0000zz2 oh dear me, I Should've seen that
@@0000zz2 where did she wrote?
Bunları duyduktan sonra intihar etmez bence abi bu işte bir iş var
the way she said “there is someone on my side” makes my heart so broke rn. Feeling of losing someone who always stay our sides can’t be explained in words
This was the last straw. I was holding it all in after seeing the news but this made me cry
@@arlescenes Same 😭
same we are also feel same
@@arlescenes omg same. I am in tears rn
So sad 😔! How can she move on!!
I can't imagine how shua feel right now. She lost her brother forever. Shua, i hope you'll always strong. We'll always here to support you. Rest in peace, moonbin.
Her crying broke my heart 💔 can't imagine how much she has gone through
Now 💔💔
Man💔💔💔
I hope she stays strong...
imagine what she’s going through now😭😭
😭
guys please stay kind and don’t make moonbin’s memories sad ones
yes please, i dont like all the insensitive comments people are making when he is being praised... its unnecessary
True. In the upcoming days, I hope everyone remember him for who he was. He done a lot of things that deserves to be mentioned. He’s more than his passing ♥️
yes but that doesn’t mean everyone will do the same, they’re grieving throughout the years there will be happier memories of him
If she was this sad that he didn't answer her calls occasionally,
Imagine how agonizing that he won't answer them forever.
Damnn 😢
Bro....
no don't do this to me....
Wah this is making me cry again oh God idk i can't tolerate this
:(
I cant believe 😭😭 if she is crying now with his hyung what more today moon bin passed away 😭😭 I hope sua will keep up and may you rest in peace moon bin
Saddest part is sua will never be experience this again with moonbin. Really I'm crying while watching this.
I feel like the reason why he did not answer her calls was because he himself was going through a hard time and he didn’t want to talk to her about his hard times cause he wanted to protect her. It’s heartbreaking!
He was in too much pain but couldn't share his burdens with others. He even wanted her sister not to join the industry, but he knows that is also the dream of his sister. Moonbin, why did you give up your own precious life 😢
I think a bit of fault of his company. He's been constantly working since 5/6 months with his subunit comeback and tour. They didn't put his mental health into priority and made him keep working for tours.
Kpop industry is very brutal, idol is just money making machine for the company. They had a concert in macau this Saturday as well. Imagine having to deal with all this stress when you're already depressed. 😢
@@abidakausar4426 you don't know what happened. stop assuming and respect his family's wishes. Speaking like you know everything.. he recently chose to sign again with his company.
@@piedpiper1234 but you don't know why he still sign the money taking some company rule if member left they have pay bunch money
@@they4852 No. His contract ended meaning he CHOSE to sign it again. They only pay a fee if they BREAK their contract and that's not what happened. So stop making up lies.
@@piedpiper1234 yes idk what happened.
But he killed himself according to police.
And ik Kpop idols who did the same.
And I know Kpop industry is brutal
It might not be major factor but still can't ignore it
it breaks my heart to see this after the news :(
Heartbreaking fact that she lost the only person she could rely on 💔 this situation making me feel worst 5he more I think about this tragedy the more I feel weak and heartbroken if I can feel that much pain for my idol she lost his brother can't even imagine
I am so heartbroken and devastated by Moon Bins passing. I really hope Sua and thier family are okay and can get through this. RIP Moon Bin, you will be missed. 💔
no matter how strong and independent she is, she still needs someone to share/lean on to remain normal/sane. grateful she chose her family to share many things. what you have done is very correct, sua.
i genuinely cannot imagine how she’s feeling right now.. oh my god. i wish her so much strength, poor girl..
I am feeling so sorry for her loss now😢 please stay strong and remember that moonbin will always look after you in heaven ❤😢and remember that he loves you so much moonsua..I can’t imagine how much she’s hurt now 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Rest in Paradise, Moonbin. 🕊️
Stay Strong, Sua. 🤍
And our Deepest Sympathies to His Family, Friends and Loved ones.
Bro, I want to give her the biggest hug in the world and tell her everything is going to be all right. The pain she must be going through right now is unimaginable. I hope she finds healing during this horrible time..
im just crying so much i hope she knows her brother will always be on her side
Can't imagine her pain now losing her oppa 😢
Feel so sad for her....he was her only brother and the person on whom she could reply.....he strong moonsua
Rip moonbin fly high angel
I feel soooo bad for sua I cant imagine what shes going through right now 😢😢😢 rest in peace moonbin😔
I can’t imagine how broken she feels now.
I can’t imagine the pain she’s in right now.
How is she gonna live from now on.... My heart goes for moonbin and people who are close to him.
tightest hug for moon sua right now :
This broke my heart she always call him eventhough he wouldn't take the call but now is wouldn't ever take her call or comfort her like he did I feel really sorry for them they were really close
RIP Moonbin
Hearing the news that he passed away I can’t imagine how Sua is feeling right now 😢
it always the brightest person that left us .. imagine what sua is feeling right now , she was super close with moonbin :((
She cries when binnie dont answer her call what more now that binnie cant really answer her call forevee😭😭
The way moonbin told his sister that he would not let her become entertainer if she wouldn't be trainee for so long shows how concerned he was for his sister because he know how dirty and strict such industries our where you have yo be pretendous 24/7 ...moonbin is no more now , cant stop crying ,moonsua pls held in there .stay strong
I can't imagine how hard the news must've been to her. Hope you can stay strong, sua
My heart is shattered. I can’t imagine what sua must be going through....... and binnie close friends like seungkwan, sinb, chanwoo, kayoung and astro members.
No one's gonna answer her calls now... someone has to step up to give her the comfort she needs right now and to the upcoming years in her career. That someone could be either her family, her group members, her friends, or her fans. I don't want to see her cry but now I can imagine her crying right now. This is a very sad and painful day for those who cares this man, Moonbin.
I can't even imagine how Sua feels right now. 🥺 This is so heartbreaking.
can't imagine sua's pain right now and even more so for their parents.. it hurts as an aroha but we all know it's even harder for bin's family.. i just hope they get all the strength they need to carry on and bin-ah, you'll always be loved and remembered our dearest sunshine
😭😭😭 moonbin left us too now… my heart is in so much pain rn, I can’t even imagine what Sua is going through. I just wish I could give her a big hug to let her know that everything will be okay. Gosh, I miss Moonbin, I found out in school right before class because and I couldn't stop crying 😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺😭😭
This feels incredibly different now. May Moonbin be the prettiest star in the sky
It's good that Sua was able to tell how she really feels about her brother. Please Bin, now answers her calls, I know you're acting tough but you love your sister very much and I know you're the one who understands her the most about being an idol and the problems that come with it ;__;
this is even sadder considering how moonbin just died....
Ugh... punch to the gut. So devasting. 💔
I hope he called her plenty of times… but no amount of phone calls could have prepared her…
This got me crying because now he can’t answer her calls anymore
How he is no more won't answer her calls but will protect her😢
It's really heartbreaking. Can't imagine how Moon Sua feels right now. This programme just about several months ago and maybe through this they were just newly spending time together and knowing each other more than before. Seeing her crying here, makes me crying too. I hope she is stay strong to accept this and RIP for Moon Bin. My condolences too for Aroha
Can't believe moon soobin is gone now. Rip to his family especially for his sister
She said it was hard for her when moonbin didn’t answer her call. But what about now 😢 please stay strong sua ❤🥺😢😭😭
Now, there's no brother Binnie to answer Sua's call and breaks my heart just imagining
Oh no moon sua... we all love you and moonbin, it must be hard right now but pls pls try to stay strong, we're all here for you and will support the both of you forever.. ❤️
Idk why I’m torturing myself by seeing this after seeing the news of moonbin. I love him and hope for the very best for sua and his family and friends
I hope she's allowed to take as much of time she needs to grieve. please show lots of love and support for sua. ❤
I feel sad for moonsua right now.
😭
In the end he had no one to lean 💔 R.I.P. moonbin
This is too heartbreaking to watch after finding out the news.....
and now she’s lost that someone
He said if he wasn’t be a singer, he would have been a swimmer. I wonder how his life would be if he didn't picked entertainment industry. He looks so worried for his sister in this clip. Rest in peace Astro's Moonbin. You will be in our hearts forever. We love you ✨✨
As we can see how he expressed all those things he was dealing in the kpop industry and to explained his sister not to become a entertainer and we can all see now why he meant that his every word he said to his sister and how he cares about her this is really sad…rip bright star we’ll miss u forever kpop industry should at least get alerted after this
May god give her strength to bear the loss of her brother ❤️
I can't imagine what sua is feeling right now
I understand her. The idols world is lonely and they feel the stress and pressure of always being exposed. For a younger sister nothing it's better than the advice and company of a brother that can guide you and protect you.
Poor Sua 🥺 I hope she is okay...
now he lost her brother 😢we love you moonbin I watch you before with your sister it was happy to see them
IDK WHAT SUA MUST BE FEELING RIGHT NOW...EVEN THOUGH I DIDN'T STAN THEM ..I'm CRYING FR......MY DEEPEST DEEPEST CONDOLENCE TO HIS FAMILY FRIENDS AND FANS❤💐
Sua, I hope you're taking care of yourself well. Your brother will always be there with you forever.
Can't imagine how she's feeling now 😭😭😭 wishing her the best.
정말 너무너무 안타깝다... 가장 힘든게 뭐였을지는 모르겠지만... 우리 연예인들한테 악플은 달지 맙시다... 상처주고 그런 말들 하지 맙시다...
This clip will never be the same :((
Poor girl. She loved her big brother so much. I truly hope she has people around her able to help her through this and support her
He probably couldn’t answer b/c he might have been afraid that he couldn’t pretend to be strong enough for her to lean on. Things would slip through the cracks and it would have caused his sister further worry and anxiety.
He perhaps did not want her to worry by answering the phone, revealing his low and dark points without intending, and tarnish the gleaming strong older brother impression that his sister had of him.
I can't imagine sua's feeling rn. Watching this makes me cry. Rest in paradise angel. 🕊️
Oh sweet Moonbin and Sua. My heart aches. Rest in paradise, beautiful Moonbin. Lovely Sua, your brother will always protect you no matter what. He is your shining star. He loves you so much.
imagine her pain now. that she wont be able to call bin forever. pls stay strong, sua. :(((
i can’t help but cry now
watching the video now after the news breaks my heart, i cant imagine how hard it is now for her
stay strong, we are here to support you 🥺✊
so now who’s gonna answer sua phone calls again? im sorry u must going through all of this pain, moobin. we’re sorry we didn’t know your pain. both of u don’t deserve this kind of pain. fly high, binnie. we love you sua. ❤️
SuA, it must be hard, harder than even now. But please be strong, for yourself and for Binnie 💜
We love you
Please stay strong SUA❤
Your brother is always with you in your heart❤
Now she must have alot of pressure but there is no moonbin anymore she would be really sad😢😢😢she thought someone is her side to say how she is feeling but....
It all became clear now. All his words make sense now.
Also if anyone who reads this message has ever written a hate comment on any idol’s post kindly go and delete it right now. We all should be ashamed of ourselves for judging people especially idols according to our convenience and hating them. If an idol is dating it’s his choice, if he is married it’s his choice again (this is in general not for moonbin) As bystanders we are no one to disrespect and reprimand them. They work so hard for us, to help us overcome our pain, to give the best quality content they can to us. It’s really shameful that even after seeing such incidents happen in the past as well, there still are people in this world who continue to nurture hate.
Incidents like these do not happen in one day, it builds up for a long long time. The constant nagging, hate, lack of a healthy routine all lead to such incidents. Please guys if some of you can’t say good things about any idol at least refrain from spreading bad comments.
Once again what has happened has happened but we as viewers can at least make sure that nothing like this happens again.
May god give her enough strength to face this biggest loss😢💔
My condolences to Moon Sua she has to stay strong
Moonbin... My Moonlight...
Sua, please don't let the moonlight go out. Please stay strong and stay with us. Your brother would want it to be like that...
😭lets protect Sua for him
Her crying is breaking my heart because now who will comfort her , be on her side and who will she call
Sua Cride because Bin didn't receive a few calls, But now he left for good.There will be no one beside her. This is sad.
Now, who will listen her concerns since Moon Bin can't answer her calls 😢
this video was...a painful foreshadow. I think he was speaking from his pain. :(
Only a sister would know the value of a brother. We go through ups and downs but the bond will remain forever. May MoonBin rests in peace. May Shua find the strength to keep moving in life with beautiful memories of him.
Let's continue to support astro and billlie for Moonbin wishes
i hope that, now sua has debuted and has a whole team of friends who love and care about her very much, she still feels like she has people she can lean on and feel support from in difficult times. nothing could ever replace her brother, but as long as she doesn’t feel alone like she did here :(
God. Seeing this video after his death makes it even more heartbreaking for them both. I can’t imagine the pain this family is going through, the pain MoonBin went through
Im praying for Sua I can’t believe this is happening
His voice is sooo cute 😭💙... when he talking... and they always the best Siblings of k-pop 💜......
She said I have no one else to let myself out to except you( moonbin)
Her crying broke my heart 💔 can't imagine how much she is going through 😭 Rest in peace moonbin 🕊️
He wanted to proctect her from the industry bc ge knew how hard it was for him. He was a good brother, friend & entertainer. I pray his family & true friebds heak from this.💔🕊️
And now she really need her brother to pick her phone up and tell what's really going with her 😭
But...😭
I pray the God give energy to Moonbin's family to control their emotions.
Sua please be strong.
if i ever lost one of my brothers... i can't even imagine. my heart aches so much i only got to know moonbin through the content with him and Sua..
i hope Sua takes all the time she needs to fully heal. there's nothing more important than this rn.
and yes, cyberbullying and hateful comments can even tear siblings apart. please be mindful on the internet.
i vividly remembered the first time i saw this, my heart aches bcs they grew up separately bcs both of them trainee since young. and sua always adores and proud seeing her oppa didn't give up to debut and thats the reason she's not giving up too and debut last year. she even said that moonbin's concert are the one that comforts her while she's down and even cried when moonbin didn't answer her call bcs he is all she has and she felt like there's someone for her if he answer the callㅠㅠ and the moment i saw the article last night, this scene flashes in my head:((
Omg 😭
We need to support and take care her instead her brother
My condolences to his family and friend , I just really shockd when i hear the news!!!
May his soul rest in peace
she is in my heart right now. she is experiencing every sister's nightmare and I hope she has people by her side to let her process this horrible loss.
my heart hurts so bad rn and just listening to his voice its bringing tears to my eyes again 😓 I hope sua is ok and I send my condolences to the moon family ❤️ God I wish this wasn't true.. rest in peace moonbinie 🕊💕.
My God.....Sua i don't know how much she will b without moonbin,moonbin...how can u leave us 💔
we’re with you sua