But he wouldnt even have the strawhat so changing the colours doesnt make sense, and why would he even change it? I mean shanks had it with a red stripe
I mean, if you think about it, the majority of One Piece enemies are pirates. Like; Buggy - Pirate Kuro - Pirate Don Krieg - Pirate Arlong - Pirate Crocodile - Pirate Moria - Pirate Hoady - Technically called himself a pirate Doflamingo - Pirate Big Mom - Pirate Kaido - Pirate The only groups Zoro fought against that were not pirates as far as I can remember were Morgan, Enel's people, CP9, and the people at Sabaody, although Kuma was a pirate(ish). Even when the bad guy was Cesar, Zoro fought Monet, who was a Doflamingo pirate. Zoro does plenty of pirate hunting.
In regards to the end, there's actually some fanfics I read many years ago that explore a "what if" scenario of Luffy being a marine and what would happen as a result of Ace's execution being announced. One of them had a neat idea (though of course a lot more anticlimactic than Marine Ford) that Luffy goes to Whitebeard and makes a deal - he retrieves Ace, they don't go all out on the marine headquarters. He gets clearance to enter Impel down, and rearrange the orders of the ships - it's more complex then my summary but basically Ace is put on one ship instead of the other and there's all the miscommunication of "no WE have him," "NO, WE have him!" and basically Luffy pulls what he did originally at Impel down, getting Ivankov and Bentham's assistance - massive prison break - "hey guys wait a second Ace is not on the ship we're on wtf" - Whitebeard Pirates slip in and take advantage of the chaos and free Ace. And essentially onward from that moment Luffy and his crew become fugitives, 2 time skip - suddenly a new Pirate crew called the strawhats pop up in the New World, and y'all know the rest.
Yeah Coby is basically the result of what if Luffy had been trained by Garp, and you can see Coby‘s really fast progress. Pretty sure, that if Luffy started training by Garp as a child, he would be post-timeskip level at the beginning of east blue arc.
The crew would be a bit different, Coby would promise to join Luffy after he becomes stronger, Zoro wouldn't have trouble joining because it wouldn't interfere with his dream of becoming the Strongest Swordsman, Nami would be a bit reluctant to join due to Nezumi selling off her village but at the end she would join after seeing that Luffy's crew is how Marines are supposed to be. Ussop wanted to be a Brave Man of the Sea, his dream was not incompatible so he would join, the same going for Sanji. Smoker wouldn't chase after Luffy and remains at Roger's birth but suggests Tashigi to join Luffy's crew so she could get stronger. They still meet Laboon, Crocus and Vivi because Luffy wanted to see how pirates crossed the Red Line. The Alabasta Arc is almost the same with Luffy having less trouble to defeat Crocodile in their final battle, because in this reality they are Marines they are publicy lauded as heroes and get several promotions. Nico wouldn't join the crew, Luffy would let her escape after the Alabasta Arc, she probably be on her own again until the Revolutionaries find her. Luffy recognizes Blackbeard when they meet at the island below Skypea and they fight, it is a very hard battle but this Luffy was stronger than his canon self due to the training in Haki he got from Garp and wins, after Ace hears of that he returns with Whitebeard, during Luffy's recovery he is visited by Coby who joins his crew (Helmepo remains with Garp, wary of Zoro) In this reality they dont have the Sunny but a Marine ship, they don't travel to Water 7, without Robin around Luci and his group don't receive orders to act yet and remain as sleeping agents at Galey La Company. Luffy gets order to investigage Moriah, they meet Brook, Luffy offers him to join but he refuses because he is a pirate, after the Thriller Back arc ends Brooks agrees to join, Brook's bounty was already lapsed. Because they are not pirates they don't get Wanted posters, Duval is not hunted for resembling Sanji's portrait, he doesn't kidnap Hachi, Camie doesn't meet the crew and the Straw Hats don't have to free her. In the Sabaody Archpielago the imbecile Celestial Dragon still gets punched, in this case by Kidd. The Straw Hats come with Kizaru and everything goes relatively fine until they accidentally cross paths with Rayleigh who completely trashes them and takes away Luffy's hat after recognizing it, motivating Luffy to get stronger.
Thing is I feel like Ace's execution would make luffy fight the admirals, thus becoming a fugutive and ultimately making the straw hat pirates. he wouldn't just let them try to kill Ace.
@@crazymadstriker766but what the OP is explaining is that ace wouldn’t be executed if luffy was a marine due to luffy fighting and defeating Blackbeard early. Remember that ace only got captured because he fought Blackbeard and lost, there would be no reason for ace to even fight BB if luffy encounters him first at Jaya and defeats him due to luffy being a marine receiving haki training from Garp. Ace would have no reason to ever leave whitebeard, the marineford war never happens
Will be so much trouble from upper high tho. They are rotten. Just like you can't be hero as politician when being revolutionary captain is more cool to destroy rotten world order. That's why Garp is passive, ice guy left, and Dragon chose violence way. Remember this is shonen manga. If it's the other way around it'll be like early seasons of AoT
He definitely wouldn’t. We know Luffy would’ve went and save Ace during the execution but i wonder how he would be able to stop it without losing his title etc cuz he’s technically going against orders. That would be an interesting story
There’s nothing Luffy values and Respects more than People’s Freedom. In this timeline I think he and Ace would have made Peace with the Fact they’re Enemies And as Such they shouldn’t Be lenient with each other if they ever Either meet at the Sea or the other is in Danger. It was Ace’s Choices,Born of his Own Free Will that Leaded to his execution and Death,And I firmly Believe he would be Just Like Garp:Silently Suffering yet Not Helping Ace until he explicitly Swallow his Pride and ask him to.
@@nicane-9966 Garp had to be held down by Sengoku. He didn’t physically get to interfere. Luffy on the other hand is straight up throwing hands with Admirals lol. In fact, had Luffy known they were about to get him in custody, he would’ve spazzed.
Namy: "why would i ever join the marines!!" Sanji : "Have you seen admirals paycheck? Plus you can legally seize pirates treasures for yourself" Namy: "So anyways i'm a marine now"
@@eyeclss773 acuttaly I'm curious how would he meet brook and the rest of the gang in the first place like Sanji and NAMI it would be easy but brook chopper and Franky ussop idk in mostly just curious about how marine Luffy would meet brook
This is exactly what I think Luffy as a marine would be like, he would basically be the exact same, fighting other pirates/marines. However he would SPECIFICALLY defeat the "evil" marines. Either pirate or marine, Luffy is good.
Nah, actually if he decide to become a marinez he wouldn't get gomu gomu no mi since shanks wouldn't let that fruit fall into the hand of a marine soldier. That details actually will make the story change for most part. And zoro wouldn't follow him. This video is wrong on a whole another level
@@Igivegdparent aaah but Luffy would still have known Yassop from his youth with Shanks still being around in the early days, sure its unlikely to happen, but unlikely doesnt mean crap if Luffy wants Ussop. Truly the only real impossibility is Robin because its not just the marine but the World Governement itself that wants her gone no questions asked
There would be another series about luffys son become a marine and the other one would be an pirate.dragon would be an admiral and would retain his position in the end of the series.
If Luffy were part of the Marines, the Gorosei would likely contact him and Garp to discuss Luffy's fruit, and with that, Luffy would come to know the name of Nika, and the fruit would be in the hands of the World Government. Luffy would undergo the most rigorous Marine training, acquire advanced Armament Haki and advanced Observation Haki. However, upon learning Imu-sama's plans for the rest of the world, he would join SWORD or the Revolutionary group, aiming to attain the title of "King of the Marines" or something similar. This would lead him to acquire Conqueror's Haki, which Garp would train him to use. Luffy would reunite with all his companions, this time as a Marine commander. Instead of the race for the One Piece, it would be a race toward a new dawn.
@Madalin Exactly. People forgot what pirates actually were like. Pirates were basically sea thieves. Luffy doesn't even steal lmao. He just goes on adventures and usually saves people more than hurting people
@beastinfection638 If the world government saw it this way they wouldn't be getting in his way only a few of them realized this but are just doing their jobs. In fact they could've been allies.
@@beastinfection638 This is the part that annoys me a little, but the bounty is a good measure of his reputation and influence in the world. It also reflects the flaws of the navy and govt systems.
Actually this plot / setting make more sense than being a Pirate King path cuz 90% of other pirates are evil and Luffy always try to act like a savior for wherever he visited.
Luffy has stated that he's not a hero. he's just doing whatever he pleases and only helps out when he has friends at risk or if the people are also willing to fight alongside him
@@Pandapanda004 The thing is he becomes friend with anyone he met so he ends up being savior for wherever he visited cuz that's the "formula" of One Piece.
nah so many plot points would not even come to fruition both ussop and sanji wont join since they are either raised by pirates or want to be pirates chopper and robin will also not join since chopper only likes pirates and robin would run away form the navy plus its not like make your own crew type its i''ll assign you to a battalion and youll have to stay in your region unless you are either under someone who is a vice admiral or you become a vice admiral
In this timeline i could see Shanks still coming to luffy’s village hanging out, luffy eating the fruit and inspiring luffy to be a pirate but this time however when the bandits came and kidnapped luffy Shanks was to late to save him and just as luffy was about to be eaten it was Garp that saved him instead sacrificing his arm and in turn precious fist to save his grandson as Luffy was thankful for his grandfather he joined the marines while still holding respect for shanks as shanks gives him the hat telling him to give it back when he becomes a great marine but luffy still being luffy i see him not taking orders from his superiors doing everything his own way and still getting promoted none the less
It'd be great to see this version of One Piece, instead of making a pirate crew Luffy swings by and nabs the strawhats making one of the best Marine squads instead, WITH Coby on the team too
@@mynamedontmatter4796 he’s the Hero of the Marine’s Grandson and Garp is a Close friend of Sengoku to Boot. Pretty Sure that Luffy has a Marine would have Way more Liberties than You think as Long as He Steadily report Progress.
@@mynamedontmatter4796 You gotta Remember how Fate is So Prevalent in One Piece. Who Knows,Maybe whatever Possible Reason would make Luffy start his Journey on the east, Maybe for Destiny Hazards he still meet and recruit the Original Straw hats or At least most of them, Things tend to work like that in the Series.
Here are the changes : Usoupps town gonna be dead , but the rest of the original crew still joins expect robin which will be either captured by garp or they didn't meet at all.
the ending got me. All i want is to see how the ACE's execution is going to take place after LUFFY becoming a marine!! Even the thought of it give me the chills🥶🥶🥶 make the 2nd part soon mate. thnx for the hard work tho. it was worth it.
Wow oda-san really should make side story where luffy is marine it would be fun to watch. And please make the part 2 I really want to see what happens in summit war of marineford.
So this is basically one piece but Luffy becomes an Internal Affairs officer (IA) Oddly enough this would make his fight with Rob Lucci have even more depth. Because it would be two different factions of enforcers. One hunts corruption on private orders. The other is more public and upfront.
This is amazing. I'd love to watch a spinoff of Luffy in the Marines, the problem is I can't see him actually staying there past Marineford (and let's not forget Enies Lobby too )
If luffy became a marine,Garp will make him stronger than he was when he was a pirate.good idea with blue straw hat btw(ts luffy would be stronger tho)
Now that Zoro joined, next Nami could have also joined as she would get a fat pay check, already hated pirates, her mom was in the navy and she can legally take their treasures. Sanji could also join as there is a huge amount of navy men that want to eat and there is Luffy who has a massive appetite. Next Ussop all he needs is some motivation and appreciation towards his snipper skills and how in the future he can have a huge fleet with many men. As for Chopper, Robin, Franky and Jimbei I doubt they will join, Chopper and Jimbei could be subject to discrimination due to their appearance, Robin is already being hunted by the govt and navy and she hates them so I don't see her joining either Franky absolutely hates the navy and govt for what happened to Tom san.
usopp probably wouldn't join. I can see the Marines using his connection as the son of one of Shanks' men who is yasopp and try and lure Shanks into the open and maybe take him down
Like you said, Nami hated pirates and still became one. So while Chopper and the others becoming Marines sounds stupid, it's not exactly something that can't be fixed with Luffy's Talk-no-Jutsu
@@oldaccount6152 Luffy could still convinced them by telling them that when he becomes the top marine, he'll create a world where no one is wrongfully punished
@@lunolionreacts2362 @lunolionreacts2362 i feel like both Franky and Robin joining will put them in heavy risk due to them being in the close vicinity of world government. (Manga spoilers ahead) knowing how WG was ok with eliminating their biggest asset and the smartest human all because he decided to just look into the void century, there is no way even luffy could save them both, it would be a situation of either Luffy quitting the navy to save them or him letting them die for the sake of navy. He can only save them after creating a world where no one will be wrongfully punished but wg would kill them before that.
To commerate the most recent chapter I guess (jokes, I highly doubt this animation was made that quickly, even if iBIJ read the spoilers) After Crocodile, I immediately thought of Marine Ford. Two possibilities: 1. Luffy fights on the side of the Whitebeard Pirates but still keeps his job similar to Koby and Boa 2. Luffy sides with Garp and the both of them sit next to Ace on the scaffold. And after Akainu kills Ace, Sengoku holds down Garp while Luffy jumps Akainu and eventually Luffy and Koby stall out Akainu enough for Shanks to show up Honestly, option 1 is more likely, but option 2 would be a really nice parallel universe where Luffy has as much loyalty to the navy cause as he does for the pirate life in the canon
The strawhats would probably end up being part of sword, considering the "free" aspect. But maybe luffy wouldve had an easier time to get to ace and saving him by sneaking a key or something.
Hmm kinda makes sense. He still would cause a lot of trouble but i wonder if fixing the problems in the marine he would not be seen as a revolutionary since some higher ups would not pet that slide
Luffy would still have the Will to liberate the world. He would basically be fighting for " his justice ⚖️". It would be an interesting dynamic with his Father being still the leader of Revolutionary Army. I wonder how his Navel career would change once that became world knowledge
I always feel that luffy as a marine would be cool but still end up with a bounty since he's following his own rules lol. But that ace execution would be an even bigger heart breaking moment.
You know how they did the role reversal between Naruto and sasuke lives/paths, they should actually do that with luffy, ace, and sabo like luffy becomes a marine, ace joins the revolutionary army, and sabo becomes a top pirate
If Luffy became a Marine, Garp would be the happiest grandfather on Earth.
But what will do Imu-sama when she knows that he ate the Ito ito no mi: model Nika??
@@Alexgram35ita nothing he will accept everything imu tells him.
@@apex_predator_04 like kill your bother Ace?? Maybe not everything.
@@Alexgram35ita no it's
HITO HITO NO MI SUN GOD MODEL NIKA
And eat*
Here before this blows up.
This is by far the most cleanest animation you have done. And I like how since he'll become a marine, the ribbon on his straw hat is of blue colour
But he wouldnt even have the strawhat so changing the colours doesnt make sense, and why would he even change it? I mean shanks had it with a red stripe
Now Zoro's title Pirate Hunter will remain Unchanged
The funny thing is that even today a lot of people in the world of One Piece still call him pirate hunter
@@cond.oriano3264 yea, He's a pirate who hunts other pirates 😂
I mean, if you think about it, the majority of One Piece enemies are pirates. Like;
Buggy - Pirate
Kuro - Pirate
Don Krieg - Pirate
Arlong - Pirate
Crocodile - Pirate
Moria - Pirate
Hoady - Technically called himself a pirate
Doflamingo - Pirate
Big Mom - Pirate
Kaido - Pirate
The only groups Zoro fought against that were not pirates as far as I can remember were Morgan, Enel's people, CP9, and the people at Sabaody, although Kuma was a pirate(ish). Even when the bad guy was Cesar, Zoro fought Monet, who was a Doflamingo pirate.
Zoro does plenty of pirate hunting.
No he's minority hunter
@@ProfiteerProphet yea, damn nerd u remember all the names. I watching the latest ep 1000 smthg i dont remember the number though. Damn bro 💀
In regards to the end, there's actually some fanfics I read many years ago that explore a "what if" scenario of Luffy being a marine and what would happen as a result of Ace's execution being announced. One of them had a neat idea (though of course a lot more anticlimactic than Marine Ford) that Luffy goes to Whitebeard and makes a deal - he retrieves Ace, they don't go all out on the marine headquarters. He gets clearance to enter Impel down, and rearrange the orders of the ships - it's more complex then my summary but basically Ace is put on one ship instead of the other and there's all the miscommunication of "no WE have him," "NO, WE have him!" and basically Luffy pulls what he did originally at Impel down, getting Ivankov and Bentham's assistance - massive prison break - "hey guys wait a second Ace is not on the ship we're on wtf" - Whitebeard Pirates slip in and take advantage of the chaos and free Ace. And essentially onward from that moment Luffy and his crew become fugitives, 2 time skip - suddenly a new Pirate crew called the strawhats pop up in the New World, and y'all know the rest.
oh i would absolutely love reading this!! do you still have the link for it?
@@hannah_mcgarden I will try to find it, but it's been at least three years - I know that Luffy had a different devil fruit, a dragon Zoan I believe.
@@Unnecessarilylongexplanations let me know if you find it, it sounds interesting
@@Unnecessarilylongexplanations did you ever find the link? i want to read it as well😅
sounds interesting
@@Unnecessarilylongexplanationsthe link please?
If Luffy decides to be navy, Garp would be his sensei and teach all Haki types before the first time he started sailing (17 years old).
In this scenario Luffy will be absolute monster
Yeah Coby is basically the result of what if Luffy had been trained by Garp, and you can see Coby‘s really fast progress.
Pretty sure, that if Luffy started training by Garp as a child, he would be post-timeskip level at the beginning of east blue arc.
@@cond.oriano3264 + luffy has far more potential
@@cond.oriano3264 and after his fruit awakens he'll probably hunted or keep in tab by the WG esp. Gorosei, Awakened Marine Luffy vs WG/Gorosei
Luffy was trained by Garp. Remember water7, Luffy resented the training, but Garp wanted Luffy to be strong.
The crew would be a bit different, Coby would promise to join Luffy after he becomes stronger, Zoro wouldn't have trouble joining because it wouldn't interfere with his dream of becoming the Strongest Swordsman, Nami would be a bit reluctant to join due to Nezumi selling off her village but at the end she would join after seeing that Luffy's crew is how Marines are supposed to be. Ussop wanted to be a Brave Man of the Sea, his dream was not incompatible so he would join, the same going for Sanji. Smoker wouldn't chase after Luffy and remains at Roger's birth but suggests Tashigi to join Luffy's crew so she could get stronger.
They still meet Laboon, Crocus and Vivi because Luffy wanted to see how pirates crossed the Red Line. The Alabasta Arc is almost the same with Luffy having less trouble to defeat Crocodile in their final battle, because in this reality they are Marines they are publicy lauded as heroes and get several promotions.
Nico wouldn't join the crew, Luffy would let her escape after the Alabasta Arc, she probably be on her own again until the Revolutionaries find her. Luffy recognizes Blackbeard when they meet at the island below Skypea and they fight, it is a very hard battle but this Luffy was stronger than his canon self due to the training in Haki he got from Garp and wins, after Ace hears of that he returns with Whitebeard, during Luffy's recovery he is visited by Coby who joins his crew (Helmepo remains with Garp, wary of Zoro)
In this reality they dont have the Sunny but a Marine ship, they don't travel to Water 7, without Robin around Luci and his group don't receive orders to act yet and remain as sleeping agents at Galey La Company.
Luffy gets order to investigage Moriah, they meet Brook, Luffy offers him to join but he refuses because he is a pirate, after the Thriller Back arc ends Brooks agrees to join, Brook's bounty was already lapsed.
Because they are not pirates they don't get Wanted posters, Duval is not hunted for resembling Sanji's portrait, he doesn't kidnap Hachi, Camie doesn't meet the crew and the Straw Hats don't have to free her. In the Sabaody Archpielago the imbecile Celestial Dragon still gets punched, in this case by Kidd. The Straw Hats come with Kizaru and everything goes relatively fine until they accidentally cross paths with Rayleigh who completely trashes them and takes away Luffy's hat after recognizing it, motivating Luffy to get stronger.
Thing is I feel like Ace's execution would make luffy fight the admirals, thus becoming a fugutive and ultimately making the straw hat pirates. he wouldn't just let them try to kill Ace.
@@crazymadstriker766but what the OP is explaining is that ace wouldn’t be executed if luffy was a marine due to luffy fighting and defeating Blackbeard early. Remember that ace only got captured because he fought Blackbeard and lost, there would be no reason for ace to even fight BB if luffy encounters him first at Jaya and defeats him due to luffy being a marine receiving haki training from Garp. Ace would have no reason to ever leave whitebeard, the marineford war never happens
Luffy even with Haki is not beating Blackbeard at that point in the story. BB was stronger than Ace, a whitebeard division commander.
Will be so much trouble from upper high tho. They are rotten. Just like you can't be hero as politician when being revolutionary captain is more cool to destroy rotten world order. That's why Garp is passive, ice guy left, and Dragon chose violence way. Remember this is shonen manga. If it's the other way around it'll be like early seasons of AoT
Bro writing a plot here
No matter how he loves being a marine, I'm sure he won't abandon ace. I'm sure of it
He definitely wouldn’t. We know Luffy would’ve went and save Ace during the execution but i wonder how he would be able to stop it without losing his title etc cuz he’s technically going against orders. That would be an interesting story
you dont need the what if it wouldnt be so different compared to Garp... he is still a Marine.
There’s nothing Luffy values and Respects more than People’s Freedom.
In this timeline I think he and Ace would have made Peace with the Fact they’re Enemies And as Such they shouldn’t Be lenient with each other if they ever Either meet at the Sea or the other is in Danger.
It was Ace’s Choices,Born of his Own Free Will that Leaded to his execution and Death,And I firmly Believe he would be Just Like Garp:Silently Suffering yet Not Helping Ace until he explicitly Swallow his Pride and ask him to.
@@nicane-9966 Garp had to be held down by Sengoku. He didn’t physically get to interfere. Luffy on the other hand is straight up throwing hands with Admirals lol. In fact, had Luffy known they were about to get him in custody, he would’ve spazzed.
@@justlad6080 interesting take.
I love how the subs said "I'm gonna become a marine", while Luffy clearly says "kaizoku"
Namy: "why would i ever join the marines!!"
Sanji : "Have you seen admirals paycheck? Plus you can legally seize pirates treasures for yourself"
Namy: "So anyways i'm a marine now"
typical nami
@@eyeclss773 acuttaly I'm curious how would he meet brook and the rest of the gang in the first place like Sanji and NAMI it would be easy but brook chopper and Franky ussop idk in mostly just curious about how marine Luffy would meet brook
@@megamaxmixer9524 he wont meet most of them or at the very least not sail with them
@@eyeclss773 shut up
@mynamedontmatter4796 tbh I think it would still be the same Laffy being a marine everything would still happen the same way
2:40 Luffy arrested his mom😂😂😂
Haaaa nooo wayyy male can born a child nowww 😲😲😲😲
Yeah
@@MrBacon_123brother is not a one piece fan until they hear about crocomom theory
After the one piece ended, this is definitely what I hope to watch next, Luffy as Marine.
theres already an anime that does that, watch two piece, in that buffy wants to be fleet admiral just like this video
@@sathviksurabhi6382 wait 2 piece actually exists?!
Or am I getting woooshed rn
what bro you want other 1000 eps
@@e.5r I mean who doesn't want it👀
Luffys son **
This is exactly what I think Luffy as a marine would be like, he would basically be the exact same, fighting other pirates/marines. However he would SPECIFICALLY defeat the "evil" marines. Either pirate or marine, Luffy is good.
I think Luffy's adventures as a marines wouldn't be so different in the end
Yeah, he still would have the same enemies, mostly
@@RandomPerson-zy5pr would Rob and Luffy be allies or will Luffy be against Rob and his ways ?
It would be the same for sure. He wouldn’t be able to turn a blind eye to all the bad things that goes on. Different goal same path.
Nah, actually if he decide to become a marinez he wouldn't get gomu gomu no mi since shanks wouldn't let that fruit fall into the hand of a marine soldier. That details actually will make the story change for most part. And zoro wouldn't follow him. This video is wrong on a whole another level
@@lockkeythetrickstar5359 oh shut up and enjoy the fucking video 😮💨
Essentially. Luffy became a naval marine.....and nothing in this timeline changed. Luffy still did the same things! I love it!🤣👏
Only thing thzt would change really is Robin not joining the crew because the World governement wants her dead, and not just a bit
@@Freedmoon44 plus would usopp still join since his father is a pirate and he wants to be just like him?
@@Igivegdparent aaah but Luffy would still have known Yassop from his youth with Shanks still being around in the early days, sure its unlikely to happen, but unlikely doesnt mean crap if Luffy wants Ussop.
Truly the only real impossibility is Robin because its not just the marine but the World Governement itself that wants her gone no questions asked
@@Freedmoon44 that makes sense and I definitely agree about Robin
Garp was so happy that luffy said that he'll become the fleet admiral, so this is the one piece but marine version
There would be another series about luffys son become a marine and the other one would be an pirate.dragon would be an admiral and would retain his position in the end of the series.
@@johncane8684
That's Buffy right?
2:08 I love how he just slides out of frame😂😂😂 you do a really good job with these videos! Keep it up🎉
Please continue this will be a good what if series. It has a VERY VERY big potential to be one of your finest what if work.
Could be as good as madaras
@@Ryuk4599what if madara was at marineford
@@thechamp742 Ace would still be alive i guess
@@Ryuk4599 and why exactly?Maadara Wouldn’t really Care if Ace Lives Or Not,he prob would just Kill everyone on the Battlefield.
@@justlad6080 read the whole sentence
If Luffy were part of the Marines, the Gorosei would likely contact him and Garp to discuss Luffy's fruit, and with that, Luffy would come to know the name of Nika, and the fruit would be in the hands of the World Government. Luffy would undergo the most rigorous Marine training, acquire advanced Armament Haki and advanced Observation Haki. However, upon learning Imu-sama's plans for the rest of the world, he would join SWORD or the Revolutionary group, aiming to attain the title of "King of the Marines" or something similar. This would lead him to acquire Conqueror's Haki, which Garp would train him to use. Luffy would reunite with all his companions, this time as a Marine commander. Instead of the race for the One Piece, it would be a race toward a new dawn.
Brooooo I don’t even know how I feel about this lol. To me Luffy is the great pirate of all time but damn him as a marine gave me chills
@Madalin
Exactly. People forgot what pirates actually were like. Pirates were basically sea thieves. Luffy doesn't even steal lmao. He just goes on adventures and usually saves people more than hurting people
@beastinfection638 If the world government saw it this way they wouldn't be getting in his way only a few of them realized this but are just doing their jobs. In fact they could've been allies.
@@beastinfection638 This is the part that annoys me a little, but the bounty is a good measure of his reputation and influence in the world.
It also reflects the flaws of the navy and govt systems.
0:19 bro🤣🤣💀💀
That laugh
Actually this plot / setting make more sense than being a Pirate King path cuz 90% of other pirates are evil and Luffy always try to act like a savior for wherever he visited.
Luffy has stated that he's not a hero. he's just doing whatever he pleases and only helps out when he has friends at risk or if the people are also willing to fight alongside him
@@Pandapanda004 The thing is he becomes friend with anyone he met so he ends up being savior for wherever he visited cuz that's the "formula" of One Piece.
Also the navy is also looking for the one piece so Luffy would still be looking for it he would just have a different reason
nah so many plot points would not even come to fruition
both ussop and sanji wont join since they are either raised by pirates or want to be pirates
chopper and robin will also not join since chopper only likes pirates and robin would run away form the navy
plus its not like make your own crew type its i''ll assign you to a battalion and youll have to stay in your region
unless you are either under someone who is a vice admiral or you become a vice admiral
@@Pandapanda004 he doesn't want to be a hero because he doesn't want to share a meat?
One Piece is so good man, I literally want to watch more alternate routes like this
In this timeline i could see Shanks still coming to luffy’s village hanging out, luffy eating the fruit and inspiring luffy to be a pirate but this time however when the bandits came and kidnapped luffy Shanks was to late to save him and just as luffy was about to be eaten it was Garp that saved him instead sacrificing his arm and in turn precious fist to save his grandson as Luffy was thankful for his grandfather he joined the marines while still holding respect for shanks as shanks gives him the hat telling him to give it back when he becomes a great marine but luffy still being luffy i see him not taking orders from his superiors doing everything his own way and still getting promoted none the less
He could join g-5 rogues marines
Honestly, even with him being a Marine in this scenario, I see Luffy having an even more serious feud against Akainu.
It'd be great to see this version of One Piece, instead of making a pirate crew Luffy swings by and nabs the strawhats making one of the best Marine squads instead, WITH Coby on the team too
two piece
i dont think they can just join all willy nilly they need to do discipline training and the sorts
chances are luffy wouldbe assigned to a battalion
@@mynamedontmatter4796 he’s the Hero of the Marine’s Grandson and Garp is a Close friend of Sengoku to Boot. Pretty Sure that Luffy has a Marine would have Way more Liberties than You think as Long as He Steadily report Progress.
@@justlad6080 then that would mean he would not meet any of the east blue crew coz he'd go directly to the grandline
@@mynamedontmatter4796 You gotta Remember how Fate is So Prevalent in One Piece. Who Knows,Maybe whatever Possible Reason would make Luffy start his Journey on the east, Maybe for Destiny Hazards he still meet and recruit the Original Straw hats or At least most of them, Things tend to work like that in the Series.
Here are the changes :
Usoupps town gonna be dead , but the rest of the original crew still joins expect robin which will be either captured by garp or they didn't meet at all.
Please make this a series
He always do, dont worry.
@@death2ablewhere
the ending got me.
All i want is to see how the ACE's execution is going to take place after LUFFY becoming a marine!!
Even the thought of it give me the chills🥶🥶🥶
make the 2nd part soon mate. thnx for the hard work tho. it was worth it.
Wow oda-san really should make side story where luffy is marine it would be fun to watch.
And please make the part 2 I really want to see what happens in summit war of marineford.
There is Boss Luffy.
I could be wrong but didn't he already make one? It's called romance dawn
So this is basically one piece but Luffy becomes an Internal Affairs officer (IA)
Oddly enough this would make his fight with Rob Lucci have even more depth. Because it would be two different factions of enforcers. One hunts corruption on private orders. The other is more public and upfront.
Garp laughing is really funny
You and the Amagi need to team up to make the perfect anime theory video.
this is good, i imagine luffy creates his own marine unit with his strawhat friends. Eventually helps the revolutionaries clear their name
ok wait that would actually cool, luffy making the marines good again
Bruh thats insane
Bro 🔥🔥🔥 this has the potential to be your best series. Keep up the great work as always!
This is definitely one that needs to be continued!
I love the small detail on how Luffys hat band changes from red to blue to indicate the marine side
It's hard, but not impossible. I mean Luffy in nevy. This is really outside-the-box thinking🤣🤯🤝
I can so picture it Luffy being a Marine. Looks awesome.
In this timeline, Luffy at 17 yrs old already knows the 3 types of haki taught by garp
Yooo the increase in quality. Well done my guy keep going.
Need a part 2!!!!
If he become a marine he wouldn't be having STRAW HAT OF SHANKS
Every video story and animation is better than previous and all videos are pure gold
Fr
Bro I have to tell you keep it up. You are the best animator ive seen so for. Watching your animation is like watching the show💯💯
This is amazing. I'd love to watch a spinoff of Luffy in the Marines, the problem is I can't see him actually staying there past Marineford (and let's not forget Enies Lobby too )
In this timeline luffy is a captain in sword that goes full revolutionary
If luffy became a marine,Garp will make him stronger than he was when he was a pirate.good idea with blue straw hat btw(ts luffy would be stronger tho)
"The true definition of a marine"
:)
If luffy listened to garp
Now he wants to become a fleet admiral😂😂
Now that Zoro joined, next Nami could have also joined as she would get a fat pay check, already hated pirates, her mom was in the navy and she can legally take their treasures. Sanji could also join as there is a huge amount of navy men that want to eat and there is Luffy who has a massive appetite. Next Ussop all he needs is some motivation and appreciation towards his snipper skills and how in the future he can have a huge fleet with many men. As for Chopper, Robin, Franky and Jimbei I doubt they will join, Chopper and Jimbei could be subject to discrimination due to their appearance, Robin is already being hunted by the govt and navy and she hates them so I don't see her joining either Franky absolutely hates the navy and govt for what happened to Tom san.
usopp probably wouldn't join. I can see the Marines using his connection as the son of one of Shanks' men who is yasopp and try and lure Shanks into the open and maybe take him down
Like you said, Nami hated pirates and still became one. So while Chopper and the others becoming Marines sounds stupid, it's not exactly something that can't be fixed with Luffy's Talk-no-Jutsu
@@lunolionreacts2362 that actually makes sense, chopper could run the greatest marine medic team, but still have no hope franky and robin
@@oldaccount6152 Luffy could still convinced them by telling them that when he becomes the top marine, he'll create a world where no one is wrongfully punished
@@lunolionreacts2362 @lunolionreacts2362 i feel like both Franky and Robin joining will put them in heavy risk due to them being in the close vicinity of world government. (Manga spoilers ahead) knowing how WG was ok with eliminating their biggest asset and the smartest human all because he decided to just look into the void century, there is no way even luffy could save them both, it would be a situation of either Luffy quitting the navy to save them or him letting them die for the sake of navy. He can only save them after creating a world where no one will be wrongfully punished but wg would kill them before that.
Luffy as Pirate-One Piece
Luffy as Marine-Two Piece
To commerate the most recent chapter I guess (jokes, I highly doubt this animation was made that quickly, even if iBIJ read the spoilers)
After Crocodile, I immediately thought of Marine Ford. Two possibilities:
1. Luffy fights on the side of the Whitebeard Pirates but still keeps his job similar to Koby and Boa
2. Luffy sides with Garp and the both of them sit next to Ace on the scaffold. And after Akainu kills Ace, Sengoku holds down Garp while Luffy jumps Akainu and eventually Luffy and Koby stall out Akainu enough for Shanks to show up
Honestly, option 1 is more likely, but option 2 would be a really nice parallel universe where Luffy has as much loyalty to the navy cause as he does for the pirate life in the canon
This is really well done
I love your style bro
Defínete your skills are EPIC
Can’t wait to see more
Wait a min...if luffy want's to be a marine then he would never met shank's crew and eat the rubber fruit
if luffy became a marine, he would never have gum gum fruit
I can't see Luffy being this thoughtful
But he is in serious situations, he usually understands people intentions
Marine Luffy. Pirate Hunter Zoro and Koby.
...
MARINEFORD HIT DIFFERENT!
The strawhats would probably end up being part of sword, considering the "free" aspect. But maybe luffy wouldve had an easier time to get to ace and saving him by sneaking a key or something.
Garp:😁😁
Straw hat member:💀💀💀💀💀💀
Especially Robin who hates Marines and WG 💀💀💀
Then Luffy and Robin would be still enemies
I would rewatch the entire show as him as a marine
I would love to read/watch a one piece reboot where luffy would become a marine. But only after finishing the original story.
I wanna see more of this "what if"
Luffy should be in special forces that can move freely to search dangerous pirate and corrupt marine.
Imagine koby now becoming the King of Pirates
Luffy is doing marine's job without actually being marine
Garp would have taught him haki at a young age.
Seeing Garp laugh like a proud grandpa made me tear up a bit 😢
THE ENDING 🔥🔥🔥 what do you think, will luffy save ace or act like garp ???
Save Ace. No question.
Garp wont even allow luffy to pick himself, he probably say go and save ace. This is the one that Garp is dead but ace is alive.
@@can-usa he will be treated as a traitor then
@@NINJA_AMARA he'd join revolutionaries and meet sabo
I think ace is a marine too 😂
I NEED THE WOLE SERIES OF THIS MAN
ITS TOO GOOD TO BE A FAN MADE
Can i vote for next part who is with me on this??
I love the attention to detail w/ Luffy’s hat, the red representing Luffy as a pirate in the og, but here it’s blue like the marines
OH MY GOD! ❤❤❤
I'm so popular in the comment with 79 comment in him XD
Luffy is probably become the leader of SWORD or something like that.
coby should become a pirate king
Solid animation man, that must have taken a while.
If Luffy wanted to be a marine, then he wouldn’t have Shanks’ hat
I see the evolution of your animation they gotten way smoother
Hmm kinda makes sense. He still would cause a lot of trouble but i wonder if fixing the problems in the marine he would not be seen as a revolutionary since some higher ups would not pet that slide
I love it how luffy is just in sanders casually fighting
This needds a part 2 A S A P.
Luffy: i have someting to tell you
Garp: what
Luffy: il be a marine some day
Garp: youre the best grandson i ever had
This looked better than the actual anime
You are so goofy, it does not
Luffy would still have the Will to liberate the world. He would basically be fighting for " his justice ⚖️". It would be an interesting dynamic with his Father being still the leader of Revolutionary Army. I wonder how his Navel career would change once that became world knowledge
If Luffy wants to become a Marine, Garp will teach him haki since childhood.
Imagine.....
Luffy and Dragon both were Marines....
End game for Pirates 🥶
GARP+Dragon+Luffy...🔥🔥🎇🎇
This is intresting can you make part 2?
I love how he used a shot of luffy after the training in the timeskip for a east blue arc scene lol.
The fact that the line around his hat is blue for marine is such a nice detail
I always feel that luffy as a marine would be cool but still end up with a bounty since he's following his own rules lol.
But that ace execution would be an even bigger heart breaking moment.
You know how they did the role reversal between Naruto and sasuke lives/paths, they should actually do that with luffy, ace, and sabo like luffy becomes a marine, ace joins the revolutionary army, and sabo becomes a top pirate
but neither is marine?
Broooo the animatations getting so good now
This is an amazing concept please do more
i mean the blue stripe on Luffy's hat makes sense because marine's color is blue
Honestly id like to see luffy as a marine it would be cool.
Is it just me or the animation was so smooth
Nice animation and nailed all the facial expression!
If Luffy became a marine, the entire Coby character would fade away.
Good.