There is a good reason why Mireille was allowed to sing this song.She has an incredible voice.She has sold 122 million records worldwide in 20 different languages.Anyone that says they don't like her singing doesn't know anything about music.
and have never heard her live in concert. I've been to four concerts and one was better than the other. Do I need to mention that I have over 20 of her records and CDs? 🙂
ABBA produced this version, they played the instruments and did the all backing vocals. Yes it's them you hear in French in that video, not the backup singers that accompany her, it's entirely lipped synched (including her) not live!! ABBA agreed that she sings their song only if they would produce the track, they didn't want anybody to mess with their material! You should check her rendition of Barbara Streisand's 'Woman in love'!
and what do you mean by this that the amazing performance of this song has become worse? yes, there are two dozen covers of this song in the world and everywhere the abbas ran to sing back vocals?, they just agreed if they thought that it would not ruin their song, and of course received money .. think what you write ...
Bravo, Mireille, les deux versions m'ont beaucoup plu, mais je dois reconnaître que l'interprétation de Mireille est fantastique. De plus, la chanson lui va bien, Abba ne sait pas trompé quand ils lui ont confié la reprise de cette chanson.
Mireille Mathieu a une des plus belle voix au monde ❤ Nous vous adorons Mireille : dommage que certains ne s’en rendent pas compte . Gros bisous de Belgique ❤
Mireille is a truly great singer with a fantastic voice. I’ve heard her three to,es live in concerts, and at 70 she is still great. I find it amusing that some Frenchmen pour out their hatred for her without realising that she is a true symbol of France whether they want it or not, and her voice is a national treasure that advertises French culture in much the same way as songs by Edith Piaf.
@@frederiquemartin223 Thank you very much for your answer, now I understand much better. 👍 You have no idea how lucky you are to have been to her concert. In my country, Argentina, Mireille is not known and I think she never came here. How is she in person? She must be a dream come true, right? 😍
"Bravo tu a gagné" is a song by the French singer Mireille Mathieu released in France in 1981 by Philips. This song is a French adaptation of the ABBA group's drama "The Winner Takes It All" with lyrics by Charles Level. Mireille is accompanied by: Benny Andersson, Björn Ulvaeus and Anni-Frid Lyngstad in the backing vocals for "Bravo tu a gagné". The artistic coordination is by Alain Boublil. 😍
Hi Dereck,the winner takes it all is a great song by Abba!I love Abba.Mireille Mathieu sang and performed it very well.Both versions are so painful and sensitiv!I like it!But my heart is for Abba!💝🐬
Listen, we don't care if the french people hate her or if she is old fashioned. There are people who likes her music. PERIOD. You are not held against your will to watch these reactions. All this hate is making me sick.
People who say they don't like the singer or the song don't mean they hate her or the song. There is actually a lot of room between love and hate. World is not totally black or white.
Dereck donne une leçon à tous en montrant qu’il a plus d’ouverture d’esprit que beaucoup qui se réjouissaient lorsqu’il réagissait aux tubes de leur enfance mais ne sont pas capables d’en faire de même pour des artistes d’une autre génération.
I am French. I discovered this song much later than the original by ABBA. The ABBA one, at the beginning, I didn't like it more than that. Until I understood the lyrics... and then I also felt all the pain and emottions in the voices. While the music was more uplifting and joyful than the cry of the soul. It became one of my ABBA preparations. Like you, I think it is untouchable. However, I think that Mireille did very well
Mireille es sin duda, la última DIVA de la canción FRANCESA, ya retirada, es el vivo reflejo de la gran época de oro de Francia. También tienes muchos temas en español : EMBRUJO 🇪🇦 VIVIR DE MIS SUEÑOS 🇪🇦 CARUSO 🇪🇦 y muchas más...👏👏👏 👋🇪🇦👋🇪🇦👋
Mireille Mathieu can sing whatever she wants, any style. She has complete control on her voice. But she’s been so strongly typecasted as the singer with one hair style, one type of song, one type of presentation. She’s prisoner of her image. Probably there’s no artist so prisoner of a style. As for her hair, forget about a change, too late to change something. She’s 76 years old. On her last photos, she looks rather like 80. She’s got it all. She doesn’t need anything now.
Mireille Mathieu has a great voice, it’s undeniable… But it’s hard for me to picture her singing this kind of song: too romantic… I agree about the covers: almost all original songs are better. I only found one cover being better…
I actually heard this version first and it (this song that is) was associated with Mireille Mathieu in my mind till I heard the original by ABBA later in life and I was pretty surprised that it was actually ABBA's song because I didn't know it as the ABBA's song before. Definitely suits Mireille although it's her cover.
I love crooners, chanson singers and any other "old fashioned" kind of singing. I also enjoy classical music, progressive rock, folk, black metal... all kinds of music. Yes, it's possible to do so and it's also possible not act like a petulant brat, when a reactor reacts to a song/cover someone may not like.
Thank you for reacting to this, Dereck! I am a huge ABBA fan, too, and I've always felt Mireille's cover was good. I studied French in high school and college, and I loved how they translated the lyrics into French and made the song work.
ABBA have incorporated many influences into their songs, I have a dream (Greek), Mamma Mia (Italian), Fernando (Spanish). And the winner takes it all is basically a French chanson, so it's logical that Mireille sang it.
Seeing Dereck reacts to artists and songs from my childhood makes me wonder what were the songs that he listened to as a kid, and how he would react to them as an adult. Also, some suggestions: "Message personnel" by Françoise Hardy (music by Michel Berger), "L'opportuniste" by Jacques Dutronc, "Voici les clés" by Gérard Lenorman, and the french king of one hit wonders, Patrick Hernandez with "Born to be alive"
According to all official records Mireille has sold something between 175 and 200 million records. I have done my fair share of that number, 175-200 LP:s, EP:s, singles and cd:s👍😉❤🇸🇪
@@luc.hammond BONSOIR , JE SUIS D'ACCORD MAIS DIRE QU'ELLE EST UNE SOUS PIAF JE NE SUIS PAS D'ACCORD ELLES ONT TOUTES LES 2 DES TIMBRES DE VOIX DIFFÉRENTS DE PLUS ÉDITH PIAF ÉTAIT UN MODEL POUR MIREILLE , BARBRA CHANTÉ SEULEMENT EN ANGLAIS ET ÉDITH CHANTÉ ÉGALEMENT EN ANGLAIS QUAND ELLE ALLÉE EN AMÉRIQUE , MIREILLE ELLE , ELLE CHANTE DANS DIFFÉRENTES LANGUES DONC PLUS GRANDE QUE LES 2 AUTRES , EN FRANCE MIREILLE EST COMPARÉ A BARBRA , MERCI
i think there's plenty of covers that are better than the originals. Best exemple : Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley. There's also Valerie by Amy Whinehouse, If i were a boy by Beyonce etc...
@@DereckReacts Please don't !!! It s a great mistake, french people can't love Mireille Mathieu when we have Mylene Farmer and Lara Fabian !!! You will lost so much followers with this kind of lack of taste.
@@DereckReacts salut Dereck, merci pour tout ce que tu fais tu est unique .... le partage dd toutes ces chansons si différentes .. tu permet à plein de gens de decouvrir des trésors du passé S'il te plait continue, on kiffe.. ta chaîne. .. NANA MOUSKOURI est un trésor de voix ( ex "plaisirs d'amour')comme DEMIS ROUSSOS( ex'' Ever and ever'') longue vie à ta chaîne. ...
we must recognize that mireille mathieu is a very great voice of the song, with a lot of possibilities. She had great songs! the problem is that she got stuck in the 70s. It must be said that she tried the change of look and her fans were outraged. too bad because suddenly it has become outdated. And she plays plays too much on her accent from the south of France, she rolls the 'r' too much. But a very beautiful voice.
Hi dereck, can you reacts to ; "Moi vouloir toi" by Françoise Hardy, "Dessine moi" by Corinne Hermes and "J'aurais voulu te dire" by Caroline Legrand ???
bravo dereck. as you said ABBA is the best. on the other hand you recognized that she sang it well and I know that it is not obvious when we have the original song in the head so again well done I recommend une femme amoureuse (cover of women in love by barbra streisand) ruclips.net/video/2c3pqKrh1TA/видео.html for barbra streisand ruclips.net/video/CzQPJy8Q6qE/видео.html
At the time of the French release by Mireille Mathieu, everyone agreed that her version was better than the original from ABBA. Let's be honest, I love ABBA but Mireille Mathieu has a superior voice ... Note that Mireille Mathieu is a very very practicing Catholic who comes from a very large family (14 brothers and sisters ...) and who wanted to become a nun when she was a teenager before finally becoming a singer ...
@@dowdydow Wash your ears and compare the two versions vocally! I love ABBA but neither of the two singers in the group has the vocal power of this lady ...
N'IMPORTE QUOI !!! Comment OSER comparer la voix d'Agnetha, si riche et modulēe, avec cette hurleuse sans aucune nuance ??? Cette reprise, totalement inutile puisque les arrangements sont les memes en plus, est une insulte a cette chanson magnifique, et au genie d'Abba. Une honte, deja a l'epoque, je me souviens tres bien des reactions de rejets logiques.
nonsense. First of all, supposedly superior voice doesnt make any cover version better automatically. You have to catch the song's essense, emotionally get it right, with right approach and delivery. Just being overly dramatic doesnt make any cover version automatically better. Mathieu's version is confrontational and slightly aggressive (especially, in quiet parts where she almost theatrical - whereas in ABBA version Agnetha sings those parts with sadness and humility). Secondly, dont hear much difference vocally - both have intensity and power and ring or treble in their voice. Tone of their voices and singing style are different. Overall, imho, Mathieu's version is good but it's not superior to original. It's slightly aggressive and too theatrical in approach. and almost melodramatic. whereas ABBA's original is more nuanced in its emotional impact, with pure sadness and hurt and sense of regret.
Nice video !!! .... again 😉 For your next reaction, I offer you a challenge: a French song about cyber-bullying at school. It is a great french singer (great voice) called Keen'V and his song is Petite Emilie. It's very different from what you usually do and your reaction should be super interesting.
J'ai été censuré car à propos de la traduction j'ai utilisé les mots de chimpanzé mongoloïde et a.v.c quel mot insultant a entraîné la censure s'il vous plaît ?
Apparemment, les censeurs sont francais car mon commentaire plaignant les chimpanzēs pour la comparaison a disparu plusieurs fois. Merci de ta luciditē en tout cas, ca rassure :-)
To definitively silence the bitchy tongues, the bedridden lovers and the acute paranoids, I confess it loud and clear: no I am not a fan of MM. On the other hand, I love her cover of "Libertine". Nah, I'm kidding. Everyone will have grasped the irony. Except one, guess who 🤣🤣🤣. Not my trip but do represents a large chapter of French music
Franchement dereck Mireille Matthiou.... pourquoi tu n'essaies pas plutôt obispo William Sheller et si tu veux une femme pourquoi n'essaie tu pas Barbara c'est tout de même un autre niveau à tous les point de vue
@@bicou1320 ah bon parce qu'il faut être un bon patriote et donc aimer Mireille Mathieu parce qu'on est français... Je n'ai qu'un seul mot mon pauvre ami....
Merci de citer William Sheller, c'est rassurant. Ils ne sont pas si nombreux les compositeurs geniaux en France, et Derek avait eu la pertinence de tomber sur beaucoup d'entre eux. Ses recents choix ringards et surtout irrealiste de ce qu est vraiment la touche francaise commencent a foutre toute sa chaine e l'air ! Nos dislikes et commentaires peuvent peut etre sauver sa chaine de la faillite :-)
i really really dont understand you: you react since such a long time to french music. for me its not understandable that you dont care about the language.... its a typical american ignorance... that makes you not very sympathic.... after so many french titles, you should start to begin!
@Georges Thierry HENRY 2021 Allez Médor "ducon" va faire mumuse ailleurs et va dans ton panier écouter la plus ringarde de tes chanteuses et occupe toi de ton compte pour elle au lieu de venir perdre ton temps!
NO NO NO NO Derek !!!! France have so many genius composers and singers, with great original songs !! This bad choice is miserably ! You make so few videos to make suck mistakes. Mireille Mathieu didn t make any album 40 years ago because much french people hate her, she's old fashioned and only sell albums in 60's and 70's. New generations don't know she exists. Don't let believe that is the french music, it'a lie and a shame !!! You make us so disapointed this time, be careful of the real french touch.
What do you mean be careful?I ,m not a teenager anymore but i love Dereck very much!And so do many others on this channel.And i can,t stand it when someone talks like that.We don't need haters😒
@@bicou1320 Je suis bien d'accord avec vous. C'est hallucinant comment les gens dénigrent des artistes talentueux avec une carrière inégalée avec des pseudos stars qui chantent comme un cheval mais qui ne courent pas aussi vite. La médiocrité des artistes prétendument français a été à son apogée quand on a commencé à glorifier des artistes internationaux dont une en particulier dont je tairai le nom... Bref, comme l'a si bien dit "Litalicious" qui poste des vidéos sur les voix féminines, la France n'a jamais aimé les chanteurs à voix sauf un certain Johnny Hallyday. Après, chacun ses goûts bien-sûr. Quoiqu'il en soit, je pense que quand on se pâme devant Céline Dion et que l'on ose dire que Mireille Matthieu n'est pas très intelligente, cela me fait hurler de rire par tant de bêtise et d'ignorance...
@@bicou1320 Mireille Mathieu n'est-elle pas un erzhast d'Edith Piaf ? Elle a gagnē un concours de chant TV dans les annees 60, a fait beaucoup de shows des Carpentiers dans les annees 70. N'est-elle pas mēprisēe et moquēe depuis le debut des annees 80 ? Pourquoi n'apparait-elle plus a la tēlē (une fois tous les dix ans) depuis ? Elle a fait une courte apparition devastatrice avec l'election de Sarkozy, et a vite redisparu. Est-ce faux ? Aucun single marquant depuis 40 ans. Ce qui est vrai : elle a fait des tournees en Russie, Allemagne, Japon. Ce que font ceux qui n'ont aucun succes en France. Niveau voix, elle est supplantēe par Lara Fabian et Celine Dion depuis longtemps. Et enfin, est-ce faux que les nouvelles generations ne savent meme pas qu-elle a existē ? A moins de vivre dans un trou paumē qui ne recoit pas internet, vous etes quelques uns et tant mieux si un vieux pick up vous maintient des emotions. Elle a le droit d avoir ētē connue dans les annees 70, personne ne lui reproche son age. Des chanteuses de 50 a 70 ans ont vraiment fait carriere sur des decennies, mais pas elle, c'est un echec, tout le monde le sait. Mais sa confidentialitē ne retire rien aux gens qui ont raison de l apprecier, il ne faut juste pas mentir en ignorant sa ringardise, plus celebre que son talent.
![Реакция немца на Мэри Попинс - до свидания [Русские субтитры]](/img/1.gif)
Mireille Mathieu the best Singer in the world 🌍💗🇬🇧🇬🇧
There is a good reason why Mireille was allowed to sing this song.She has an incredible voice.She has sold 122 million records worldwide in 20 different languages.Anyone that says they don't like her singing doesn't know anything about music.
and have never heard her live in concert. I've been to four concerts and one was better than the other. Do I need to mention that I have over 20 of her records and CDs? 🙂
ABBA produced this version, they played the instruments and did the all backing vocals. Yes it's them you hear in French in that video, not the backup singers that accompany her, it's entirely lipped synched (including her) not live!! ABBA agreed that she sings their song only if they would produce the track, they didn't want anybody to mess with their material! You should check her rendition of Barbara Streisand's 'Woman in love'!
Mireille went to Stockholm and Polar studios to record her voice track? Or how was it done, practically?
@@herrbonk3635 Yes, she came to Polar Studio and they recorded everything with her presence.
Mireille Matthieu has never lip synced. Garbage.
@@herrbonk3635 Yes, she did, just shortly after the release of The Winner Takes It All, Alain Moublile was the facilitator. She told me this!
and what do you mean by this that the amazing performance of this song has become worse? yes, there are two dozen covers of this song in the world and everywhere the abbas ran to sing back vocals?, they just agreed if they thought that it would not ruin their song, and of course received money .. think what you write ...
Bravo, Mireille, les deux versions m'ont beaucoup plu, mais je dois reconnaître que l'interprétation de Mireille est fantastique. De plus, la chanson lui va bien, Abba ne sait pas trompé quand ils lui ont confié la reprise de cette chanson.
Merci chère Mireille d'être cette merveilleuse chanteuse avec cette voix sublime ❤❤
Thank you to give French this singer from love of all french
Mireille Mathieu a une des plus belle voix au monde ❤ Nous vous adorons Mireille : dommage que certains ne s’en rendent pas compte . Gros bisous de Belgique ❤
Mireille Mathieu a une très belle voix c'est magnifique
Mireille is a truly great singer with a fantastic voice. I’ve heard her three to,es live in concerts, and at 70 she is still great. I find it amusing that some Frenchmen pour out their hatred for her without realising that she is a true symbol of France whether they want it or not, and her voice is a national treasure that advertises French culture in much the same way as songs by Edith Piaf.
I totally agree with you
Could you please tell me why do french people hate her? I am from Argentina and don' t understand french. :'-(
@@KirishimaKakashi some people consider that she is the older generation that s all. No one really hates her
@@frederiquemartin223 Thank you very much for your answer, now I understand much better. 👍 You have no idea how lucky you are to have been to her concert. In my country, Argentina, Mireille is not known and I think she never came here. How is she in person? She must be a dream come true, right? 😍
Tanto Mireille, como Agnetha cantaron fabulosamente esta cancion, cuando sus cuerdas vocales estaban en su mejor momento❤❤😂
"Bravo tu a gagné" is a song by the French singer Mireille Mathieu released in France in 1981 by Philips. This song is a French adaptation of the ABBA group's drama "The Winner Takes It All" with lyrics by Charles Level. Mireille is accompanied by: Benny Andersson, Björn Ulvaeus and Anni-Frid Lyngstad in the backing vocals for "Bravo tu a gagné". The artistic coordination is by Alain Boublil. 😍
Mireille- MAGNIFIQUE! ❤️
Thank you, thank you! Absolutely beautiful. She does a duet with Charles Aznavour that's absolutely heart-stopping. Cheers!
Hi Dereck,the winner takes it all is a great song by Abba!I love Abba.Mireille Mathieu sang and performed it very well.Both versions are so painful and sensitiv!I like it!But my heart is for Abba!💝🐬
Que dulzura de voz tiene esta mujer
Thank you!!!!! Gorgeous version in my opinion.
Did you know Abba sang her backing vocals as they are friends with Mireille.
Frida, Bjorn & Benny did the backing vocals Agnetha wasn't present during the recording.
@@AdamDawson3 3 is better than noone
One of Agnetha's first swedish songs was a cover of a hit single of Mireille Mathieu. Nobody seems that to know nowadays.
Mireille, nous t'aimons ♥
Yes, Mimi is the best singer in the world !
I agree with you. I have a big collection of her disques vinyl, CDs and DVDs. Fabulous voice and lovely personality.
she also done an other great cover " je suis une femme amoureuse " , barbra streisand " woman in love "
Good job Mireille!
Mireille is VERY GOOD singer and yes Frida and Angnetha singing backround👍👍👍
She can sing Mozart's operas, and Tchaikovsky's. Santa Maria de la mer is another you should check. Good reactions by the way 👍🇮🇪.
Listen, we don't care if the french people hate her or if she is old fashioned.
There are people who likes her music. PERIOD.
You are not held against your will to watch these reactions. All this hate is making me sick.
People who say they don't like the singer or the song don't mean they hate her or the song. There is actually a lot of room between love and hate. World is not totally black or white.
@@samueldevulder I am talking about the haters who are saying that and talking in behalf of the people from France. You can see it in the comments...
@@nomi.hagen. You speak about "hate" which is too strong a word IMHO.
@@samueldevulder And I think you are under reacting mr Samuel
Dereck donne une leçon à tous en montrant qu’il a plus d’ouverture d’esprit que beaucoup qui se réjouissaient lorsqu’il réagissait aux tubes de leur enfance mais ne sont pas capables d’en faire de même pour des artistes d’une autre génération.
I am French. I discovered this song much later than the original by ABBA.
The ABBA one, at the beginning, I didn't like it more than that. Until I understood the lyrics... and then I also felt all the pain and emottions in the voices. While the music was more uplifting and joyful than the cry of the soul.
It became one of my ABBA preparations.
Like you, I think it is untouchable.
However, I think that Mireille did very well
Mireille es sin duda, la última DIVA de la canción FRANCESA, ya retirada, es el vivo reflejo de la gran época de oro de Francia.
También tienes muchos temas en español :
EMBRUJO 🇪🇦
VIVIR DE MIS SUEÑOS 🇪🇦
CARUSO 🇪🇦
y muchas más...👏👏👏
👋🇪🇦👋🇪🇦👋
Mireille Mathieu a une voix incroyable dommage qu'en France ça ne fonctionnais plus alors que dans d'autre pays elle cartonne
She was/is great.
L♡VE IT! 😍
der Spatz von Avignon, meine Kindheit und Jugend. Super.
Mais quelle puissance de voix cette mireille! Et toujours en live. J aime rien chez elle mais quel talent, bravo
Pas mal ta réponse mais j'aurais préféré que tu t'arrêtes à j'aime rien chez elle point final....
Mireille sings in the fashion of the great Edit Piaf.
Mireille Mathieu can sing whatever she wants, any style. She has complete control on her voice. But she’s been so strongly typecasted as the singer with one hair style, one type of song, one type of presentation. She’s prisoner of her image. Probably there’s no artist so prisoner of a style. As for her hair, forget about a change, too late to change something. She’s 76 years old. On her last photos, she looks rather like 80. She’s got it all. She doesn’t need anything now.
Mireille Mathieu has a great voice, it’s undeniable… But it’s hard for me to picture her singing this kind of song: too romantic…
I agree about the covers: almost all original songs are better. I only found one cover being better…
Fantastic singer! Soooooo many great recordings over the years. Too bad I don't understand a word in french, but still she reaches me.
I actually heard this version first and it (this song that is) was associated with Mireille Mathieu in my mind till I heard the original by ABBA later in life and I was pretty surprised that it was actually ABBA's song because I didn't know it as the ABBA's song before. Definitely suits Mireille although it's her cover.
I love crooners, chanson singers and any other "old fashioned" kind of singing. I also enjoy classical music, progressive rock, folk, black metal... all kinds of music. Yes, it's possible to do so and it's also possible not act like a petulant brat, when a reactor reacts to a song/cover someone may not like.
Thank you for reacting to this, Dereck! I am a huge ABBA fan, too, and I've always felt Mireille's cover was good. I studied French in high school and college, and I loved how they translated the lyrics into French and made the song work.
"Une femme amoureuse" of Mireille Mathieu is marvelous!
Quelle voix!
ABBA have incorporated many influences into their songs, I have a dream (Greek), Mamma Mia (Italian), Fernando (Spanish). And the winner takes it all is basically a French chanson, so it's logical that Mireille sang it.
Now look up "Himno al amor". A performance in Spanish
she has a great unique voice. crystal clear. like a xmas bell
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
She is good, my Mother had an album of her in the 70s when i was just a kid and i remember that i liked it.
Hi Dereck,you should react to the song a woman in love interpreted by mireille mathieu !
Seeing Dereck reacts to artists and songs from my childhood makes me wonder what were the songs that he listened to as a kid, and how he would react to them as an adult.
Also, some suggestions: "Message personnel" by Françoise Hardy (music by Michel Berger), "L'opportuniste" by Jacques Dutronc, "Voici les clés" by Gérard Lenorman, and the french king of one hit wonders, Patrick Hernandez with "Born to be alive"
The background voices in French are the real Abba's voices
Yes, Frida, Björn and Benny are singing backing vocals on this cover, not sure why Agnetha didn’t participate
@@JF-sh2sm May be she disagreed the cover ?
@@samueldevulder No, nothing to do with this cover! Already concerns of agreements in the group at this time unfortunately ...
@@bicou1320 Indeed, there are some pictures with Mireille and all of them together
@@evasiondreams3376 Every picture I find doesn’t have Agnetha in it. Can you please tell me which pictures you’re referring to?
Quelle voix magnifique bravo Mireille 👏👏👏👏❤️
Là pace dellanima del singnore schende su tutti noi amen gesu mio cuore amen
1200 songs, 120 million opus sold, a beatuful and powerful voice
According to all official records Mireille has sold something between 175 and 200 million records. I have done my fair share of that number, 175-200 LP:s, EP:s, singles and cd:s👍😉❤🇸🇪
Definitely one of the best female voices!
Try "Paris en colère" from her
Lol for the hair BUT Lady Gaga in Alejandro has the same cut 😂 in blonde
MERCI DERECK 👍 , MIREILLE IS BARBRA STREISAND FRENCH , FROM FRANCE 🇫🇷
je trouve ça juste, mais elle a une carrière plus longue heureusement
Hallucinant
Euh....La voix de Barbra Streisand est mille fois plus belle et modulēe que cette sous-Piaf....
@@luc.hammond BONSOIR , JE SUIS D'ACCORD MAIS DIRE QU'ELLE EST UNE SOUS PIAF JE NE SUIS PAS D'ACCORD ELLES ONT TOUTES LES 2 DES TIMBRES DE VOIX DIFFÉRENTS DE PLUS ÉDITH PIAF ÉTAIT UN MODEL POUR MIREILLE , BARBRA CHANTÉ SEULEMENT EN ANGLAIS ET ÉDITH CHANTÉ ÉGALEMENT EN ANGLAIS QUAND ELLE ALLÉE EN AMÉRIQUE , MIREILLE ELLE , ELLE CHANTE DANS DIFFÉRENTES LANGUES DONC PLUS GRANDE QUE LES 2 AUTRES , EN FRANCE MIREILLE EST COMPARÉ A BARBRA , MERCI
Could you please tell me why do french people hate her? I am from Argentina and don' t understand french. :'-(
Hi Dereck, you should try Vicky Leandros - Apres Toi, greetings from Brazil!
Goosebumps ! Amazing voice !
Is there an American, German or British Mireille Mathieu? Why do the French deserve this attention?
Hi Derrick.. good choice even I think the song "On ne vit pas sans se dire adieu" is much better.
Mauvais prénom. Tu confonds avec un inspecteur allemand qui fait fureur (jeu de mot?) dans les maisons de retraite. :) :)
she created the playmobil hair!!
i think there's plenty of covers that are better than the originals. Best exemple : Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley. There's also Valerie by Amy Whinehouse, If i were a boy by Beyonce etc...
Hi Derek, another great ABBA cover you should give a listen to is " I Have a Dream" by Nana Mouskouri
Thanks for the recommendation
@@DereckReacts Please don't !!! It s a great mistake, french people can't love Mireille Mathieu when we have Mylene Farmer and Lara Fabian !!! You will lost so much followers with this kind of lack of taste.
@@luc.hammond It seems that s just the opposite
@@DereckReacts
salut Dereck, merci pour tout ce que tu fais
tu est unique .... le partage dd toutes ces chansons si différentes .. tu permet à plein de gens de decouvrir des trésors du passé
S'il te plait continue, on kiffe.. ta chaîne. ..
NANA MOUSKOURI est un trésor de voix ( ex "plaisirs d'amour')comme DEMIS ROUSSOS( ex'' Ever and ever'')
longue vie à ta chaîne. ...
Song.. je suis une femme amoureuse ....Barbara stresan song
Indochine
Les Tzars
Tes Yeux Noirs
Kao Bang
La Machine à Rattraper le Temps
Le péril jaune,musique extraordinaire
I'm french bonjour je suis français
Bonjour, on s'en fiche :)
Could you please tell me why do french people hate her? I am from Argentina and don' t understand french. :'-(
I never heard it, but the translation is a lot better than I thought. Not a litteral translation, but an idiomatic one. That's what I do for a living.
we must recognize that mireille mathieu is a very great voice of the song, with a lot of possibilities. She had great songs!
the problem is that she got stuck in the 70s. It must be said that she tried the change of look and her fans were outraged. too bad because suddenly it has become outdated. And she plays plays too much on her accent from the south of France, she rolls the 'r' too much.
But a very beautiful voice.
Faites lui écouter du Patrick Sebastien … il trouvera ça magique !!!! Derek aime tout … sans exception… surtout avoir des pubs
Mauvaise langue : il a quand même eu du mal avec Karen Cheryll ! :D
@@Djefer69 oui mais qui n a pas du mal avec elle ;)
mais non, stop !!!!!
??
Tout à fait d'accord..
d'accord aussi ... arretez le massacre !
@@jorgetrincheira2120 VOUS PARLEZ pas de mireille mathieu quand même ?
Si bien sûr si c'était Barbara on réagirait pas comme ça !!
Hi dereck, can you reacts to ; "Moi vouloir toi" by Françoise Hardy, "Dessine moi" by Corinne Hermes and "J'aurais voulu te dire" by Caroline Legrand ???
bravo dereck. as you said ABBA is the best. on the other hand you recognized that she sang it well and I know that it is not obvious when we have the original song in the head so again well done
I recommend une femme amoureuse (cover of women in love by barbra streisand) ruclips.net/video/2c3pqKrh1TA/видео.html
for barbra streisand ruclips.net/video/CzQPJy8Q6qE/видео.html
The dislike are Mireille haters :)
Or just people who .. dislike. There are many feelings between love and hate.
Could you please tell me why do french people hate her? I am from Argentina and don' t understand french. :'-(
merci
c'est manifique
At the time of the French release by Mireille Mathieu, everyone agreed that her version was better than the original from ABBA. Let's be honest, I love ABBA but Mireille Mathieu has a superior voice ...
Note that Mireille Mathieu is a very very practicing Catholic who comes from a very large family (14 brothers and sisters ...) and who wanted to become a nun when she was a teenager before finally becoming a singer ...
@@bicou1320 Pourtant je me souviens d'une interview dans laquelle elle le disait mais bref...vous êtes biographe apparemment...lol
@@dowdydow Wash your ears and compare the two versions vocally! I love ABBA but neither of the two singers in the group has the vocal power of this lady ...
@@dowdydow You do not accept reality because you are too fan of Abba .... the explanation is obvious ^^
N'IMPORTE QUOI !!! Comment OSER comparer la voix d'Agnetha, si riche et modulēe, avec cette hurleuse sans aucune nuance ??? Cette reprise, totalement inutile puisque les arrangements sont les memes en plus, est une insulte a cette chanson magnifique, et au genie d'Abba. Une honte, deja a l'epoque, je me souviens tres bien des reactions de rejets logiques.
nonsense. First of all, supposedly superior voice doesnt make any cover version better automatically. You have to catch the song's essense, emotionally get it right, with right approach and delivery. Just being overly dramatic doesnt make any cover version automatically better. Mathieu's version is confrontational and slightly aggressive (especially, in quiet parts where she almost theatrical - whereas in ABBA version Agnetha sings those parts with sadness and humility). Secondly, dont hear much difference vocally - both have intensity and power and ring or treble in their voice. Tone of their voices and singing style are different. Overall, imho, Mathieu's version is good but it's not superior to original. It's slightly aggressive and too theatrical in approach. and almost melodramatic. whereas ABBA's original is more nuanced in its emotional impact, with pure sadness and hurt and sense of regret.
Nice video !!! .... again 😉
For your next reaction, I offer you a
challenge: a French song about cyber-bullying at school. It is a great
french singer (great voice) called Keen'V and his song is Petite Emilie.
It's very different from what you usually do and your reaction should be super interesting.
J'ai été censuré car à propos de la traduction j'ai utilisé les mots de chimpanzé mongoloïde et a.v.c quel mot insultant a entraîné la censure s'il vous plaît ?
Et non je ne suis pas le traducteur mais peut-être est-ce toi vu le niveau ?
Apparemment, les censeurs sont francais car mon commentaire plaignant les chimpanzēs pour la comparaison a disparu plusieurs fois. Merci de ta luciditē en tout cas, ca rassure :-)
@@luc.hammond et oui ya que des ecerveles comme mimi pour ne rien comprendre
@@bicou1320 vraiment quel niveau de vulgarité allez je te laisse avec Michelle Torr ou Mireille Matthieu bref c'est pareil
To definitively silence the bitchy tongues, the bedridden lovers and the acute paranoids, I confess it loud and clear: no I am not a fan of MM. On the other hand, I love her cover of "Libertine". Nah, I'm kidding. Everyone will have grasped the irony. Except one, guess who 🤣🤣🤣. Not my trip but do represents a large chapter of French music
Quelle horreur lol
Que invecil
Okay, it's a very good cover, but it's a cover. I thought you only took the originals.
He reacts to covers only after listening to the original.
Franchement dereck Mireille Matthiou.... pourquoi tu n'essaies pas plutôt obispo William Sheller et si tu veux une femme pourquoi n'essaie tu pas Barbara c'est tout de même un autre niveau à tous les point de vue
Chaque chose en son temps, il le fera
@@bicou1320 ah bon parce qu'il faut être un bon patriote et donc aimer Mireille Mathieu parce qu'on est français... Je n'ai qu'un seul mot mon pauvre ami....
@@bicou1320 il y en a qui ont de la terre dans leur souliers mais toi tu as dû marcher dans du crottin
Merci de citer William Sheller, c'est rassurant. Ils ne sont pas si nombreux les compositeurs geniaux en France, et Derek avait eu la pertinence de tomber sur beaucoup d'entre eux. Ses recents choix ringards et surtout irrealiste de ce qu est vraiment la touche francaise commencent a foutre toute sa chaine e l'air ! Nos dislikes et commentaires peuvent peut etre sauver sa chaine de la faillite :-)
@@luc.hammond oui il ne manque plus que Michèle Torr et Dick rivers et je pense que ce sera complet
No Dereck !!!! No Mireille !!! Nooooooooo !!!!!
Get a grip
Could you please tell me why do french people hate her? I am from Argentina and don' t understand french. :'-(
i really really dont understand you: you react since such a long time to french music. for me its not understandable that you dont care about the language.... its a typical american ignorance... that makes you not very sympathic.... after so many french titles, you should start to begin!
Rah non pas elle!!!!! Qui l'a ressortie de son donjon? Qui est le ou la coupable et lève son doigt! Au piquet!!!Ou pire....
@Georges Thierry HENRY 2021 Allez Médor "ducon" va faire mumuse ailleurs et va dans ton panier écouter la plus ringarde de tes chanteuses et occupe toi de ton compte pour elle au lieu de venir perdre ton temps!
Get a life
Mon Dieu!! La honte!🤦♀️🤦♀️ Y'a pas plus kitsch??!! On se couvre de ridicule là sérieux!!!
😔😔😔😔
Pas plus kitsch qu'autre chose.
Tout à fait d'accord... Complètement inutile, ridicule et démodé... On touche le fond.
Et pourquoi pas Dick autoreverse !!!(
@ULM Du rap français ? il faut les bases ! #orelsan
@@bicou1320 non il a tout à fait raison Dick rivers est 100 fois plus intelligent
NO NO NO NO Derek !!!! France have so many genius composers and singers, with great original songs !! This bad choice is miserably ! You make so few videos to make suck mistakes. Mireille Mathieu didn t make any album 40 years ago because much french people hate her, she's old fashioned and only sell albums in 60's and 70's. New generations don't know she exists. Don't let believe that is the french music, it'a lie and a shame !!! You make us so disapointed this time, be careful of the real french touch.
Ugh disgusting opinions like this should be kept for themselves
I think so too,what you say Nomi
What do you mean be careful?I ,m not a teenager anymore but i love Dereck very much!And so do many others on this channel.And i can,t stand it when someone talks like that.We don't need haters😒
@@bicou1320 Je suis bien d'accord avec vous. C'est hallucinant comment les gens dénigrent des artistes talentueux avec une carrière inégalée avec des pseudos stars qui chantent comme un cheval mais qui ne courent pas aussi vite. La médiocrité des artistes prétendument français a été à son apogée quand on a commencé à glorifier des artistes internationaux dont une en particulier dont je tairai le nom... Bref, comme l'a si bien dit "Litalicious" qui poste des vidéos sur les voix féminines, la France n'a jamais aimé les chanteurs à voix sauf un certain Johnny Hallyday. Après, chacun ses goûts bien-sûr. Quoiqu'il en soit, je pense que quand on se pâme devant Céline Dion et que l'on ose dire que Mireille Matthieu n'est pas très intelligente, cela me fait hurler de rire par tant de bêtise et d'ignorance...
@@bicou1320 Mireille Mathieu n'est-elle pas un erzhast d'Edith Piaf ? Elle a gagnē un concours de chant TV dans les annees 60, a fait beaucoup de shows des Carpentiers dans les annees 70. N'est-elle pas mēprisēe et moquēe depuis le debut des annees 80 ? Pourquoi n'apparait-elle plus a la tēlē (une fois tous les dix ans) depuis ? Elle a fait une courte apparition devastatrice avec l'election de Sarkozy, et a vite redisparu. Est-ce faux ? Aucun single marquant depuis 40 ans. Ce qui est vrai : elle a fait des tournees en Russie, Allemagne, Japon. Ce que font ceux qui n'ont aucun succes en France. Niveau voix, elle est supplantēe par Lara Fabian et Celine Dion depuis longtemps. Et enfin, est-ce faux que les nouvelles generations ne savent meme pas qu-elle a existē ? A moins de vivre dans un trou paumē qui ne recoit pas internet, vous etes quelques uns et tant mieux si un vieux pick up vous maintient des emotions. Elle a le droit d avoir ētē connue dans les annees 70, personne ne lui reproche son age. Des chanteuses de 50 a 70 ans ont vraiment fait carriere sur des decennies, mais pas elle, c'est un echec, tout le monde le sait. Mais sa confidentialitē ne retire rien aux gens qui ont raison de l apprecier, il ne faut juste pas mentir en ignorant sa ringardise, plus celebre que son talent.