Thanks for having me, Ryan! This was a lot of fun! Honored to be on your channel! 🙏 Great music from all the participants! Thanks for submitting your cues! 😊
I am an absolute beginner (still learning how to sight read) but these videos are golden. Having a look at how you think about the scenes and how you approach each frame gives us great insight. Props to the composers who offered their re-scores for this video, very brave.
Don't forget that this is from Desolation Of Smaug, where orchestrations were only sketched by Howard Shore, but were actually fully done by Conrad Pope, who also conducted the whole thing and made changes on the podium in New Zealand, while Shore was home in New York composing. Desolation Of Smaug would probably have sounded a bit different, had Shore done the orchestrating and conducting all himself like on An Unexpected Journey.
Hey Ryan! First off, I love your videos, and this series in particular is on of my favorites. Second, I was wondering if you could make a video on how chord changes work and how to choose which chords to use. I’ve been struggling with this for the last couple of weeks and it would be very helpful!
This is so good of a concept, is there any way to participate in the future? Or should I join a discord? love to hear a reaction. Feedback on a film score would be amazing
I'm really interested in doing rescores lile this on a personal channel, but i have no idea how to edit out music and keep natural sounds like talking, environmental sounds, sound effects, etc. How does one do this?
We’ll definitely do more! Although I am a bit limited by what scenes I can find with the music missing. Unless we do it with no dialogue or SFX either I guess
I love this series and would love to contribute something in the future, but if I had one criticism it would be to avoid using thumbnails that imply the 'amateur' submission is undesirable or actively bad in some way. Obviously there are going to be discrepancies in quality according to the experience of the people making the submissions, but this isn't constructively contributing to anyone's work and it betrays the encouraging spirit of the series, which is otherwise abundantly clear in the way you speak about each submission.
I only post about them in Discord to keep the number of responses low. I don't know when we'll do the next one but come join us and you'll hear about it when it happens! discord.gg/2hk66xgn
I even looked it up to double check, and I got the spelling right. The weirdest random trivia that sticks... I guess the books and movies were impressionable.
I must admit, this one is somewhat spoiled for me by the fact I'm a somewhat obsessive Tolkien fan who considers this scene to be extraneous filler for a subplot that wasn't in the book and which doesn't improve the movies by its presence. That doesn't really say much about the quality of the musical scores; it's a just a distraction for me when my brain won't stop going 'this shouldn't even be here. Why do I care what the music is?' Probably most of your viewers don't have that problem.
In the future could you include an artificial intelligence attempt? Maybe someone with some experience there could volunteer to do that part? It's probably the only way to do it without taking on too much extra work. Probably for the first couple of years, the AI example would be comic relief, but maybe someday...
I've attended super ultra greatest Marc course, and you know what?! Now I am the greatest composer in entire hollywood history! Hans Zimmer asked me to give him some lessons and John Williams gave me all copyrights to Star Wars scores because he felt ashamed by Jovani masterful lessons!!! Yes join his course! Join it! Join it! Now it is 3,5% cheaper SO DO IT NOW! DO IT!
![Eminem - Temporary (feat. Skylar Grey) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaK9Wi5ho0o/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for having me, Ryan! This was a lot of fun! Honored to be on your channel! 🙏
Great music from all the participants! Thanks for submitting your cues! 😊
Happy to have had you on, thanks for bringing such great energy!
I am an absolute beginner (still learning how to sight read) but these videos are golden. Having a look at how you think about the scenes and how you approach each frame gives us great insight. Props to the composers who offered their re-scores for this video, very brave.
the third one was great! It felt right from beginning to end without losing my interest or being over the top
Thanks!
All were great efforts, but the third was my favourite.
Thanks!
Thanks so much Ryan and Marc for the time spent listening and thoughtful comments! This was a really fun rescore to work on. 🙏🙏🙏
Great scene and story telling to craft some music to, liking the analysis on how to create something fresh for it.
Don't forget that this is from Desolation Of Smaug, where orchestrations were only sketched by Howard Shore, but were actually fully done by Conrad Pope, who also conducted the whole thing and made changes on the podium in New Zealand, while Shore was home in New York composing. Desolation Of Smaug would probably have sounded a bit different, had Shore done the orchestrating and conducting all himself like on An Unexpected Journey.
Hey Ryan! First off, I love your videos, and this series in particular is on of my favorites.
Second, I was wondering if you could make a video on how chord changes work and how to choose which chords to use. I’ve been struggling with this for the last couple of weeks and it would be very helpful!
Really love the analysis and this series of videos! Please do more of these 😊
Thanks, will do! Any guest hosts or films rescore you have in mind?
@@RyanLeach PLEASE DO VIDEO GAME RESCORING. Please.
@@RyanLeach maybe Guy Michelmore? or
Anne-Kathrin Dern? both are my favorites!
Hey Ryan, this episode was awesome having Marc on your show. I love you guys. Hey, Ryan, where can I find your music? Would love to listen.
Thanks for the useful video! Both of your channels are amazing!!!
I love this concept!
Good video, I watch Marc often. Thanks for doing this, always interesting to hear the commentary and the music.
very epic! i love these types of videos!
Thanks for the analysis that helps to improve our next scores ...
Would love to see Guy Michelmore do this with you next time! Thanks, Ryan! :)
Where would I get the film footage to re-score this myself?
Keep up the great content to you both!
Amazing ! But how do you go about finding a scene without the music ? 🎶
Oh is that dude from the ads! Nice video :)
ooooh ... that was interesting!
This is so good of a concept, is there any way to participate in the future? Or should I join a discord? love to hear a reaction. Feedback on a film score would be amazing
Yes the Discord server is the best place to hear about this kind of thing
I'm really interested in doing rescores lile this on a personal channel, but i have no idea how to edit out music and keep natural sounds like talking, environmental sounds, sound effects, etc. How does one do this?
We intentionally found a scene without music, so yea it's limiting to what you can find. Or you just mute everything!
Heyy Ryan, do you guys think you can do another rescore video but this time it's a scene from Kung Fu Panda 2? Maybe the final battle scene
We’ll definitely do more! Although I am a bit limited by what scenes I can find with the music missing. Unless we do it with no dialogue or SFX either I guess
I love this series and would love to contribute something in the future, but if I had one criticism it would be to avoid using thumbnails that imply the 'amateur' submission is undesirable or actively bad in some way. Obviously there are going to be discrepancies in quality according to the experience of the people making the submissions, but this isn't constructively contributing to anyone's work and it betrays the encouraging spirit of the series, which is otherwise abundantly clear in the way you speak about each submission.
Marc Jovani!
How can I practice re scoring film scenes? I would love to participate.
I only post about them in Discord to keep the number of responses low. I don't know when we'll do the next one but come join us and you'll hear about it when it happens! discord.gg/2hk66xgn
Sigh. Technically, uruk hai, not orc. I shouldn't know that...
I even looked it up to double check, and I got the spelling right. The weirdest random trivia that sticks... I guess the books and movies were impressionable.
lol I knew someone would come through
Haha when you know the technicalities, but it's not worth correcting the minutia.
Hey, is there a specific reason why i can't find any link to participated composers channels or just their credit in the video?
I was only provided with first names, not RUclips channels or links
Hey Jacob, I posted my full clip here: ruclips.net/video/cB9RkFJo970/видео.html
I must admit, this one is somewhat spoiled for me by the fact I'm a somewhat obsessive Tolkien fan who considers this scene to be extraneous filler for a subplot that wasn't in the book and which doesn't improve the movies by its presence. That doesn't really say much about the quality of the musical scores; it's a just a distraction for me when my brain won't stop going 'this shouldn't even be here. Why do I care what the music is?' Probably most of your viewers don't have that problem.
I think it was a deleted scene which is how we were able to find it without music already there
@@RyanLeach Oh, that makes so much sense.
In the future could you include an artificial intelligence attempt? Maybe someone with some experience there could volunteer to do that part? It's probably the only way to do it without taking on too much extra work. Probably for the first couple of years, the AI example would be comic relief, but maybe someday...
Good idea
I can't fathom why on earth anyone would want that
Hell fucking no.
For what?? I don't know what ia could add?? Never replace humain emotion. Ia could do good music but never replace humain ideas.
That's definitely what will happen in the futur even if I don't want to
I've attended super ultra greatest Marc course, and you know what?! Now I am the greatest composer in entire hollywood history! Hans Zimmer asked me to give him some lessons and John Williams gave me all copyrights to Star Wars scores because he felt ashamed by Jovani masterful lessons!!! Yes join his course! Join it! Join it! Now it is 3,5% cheaper SO DO IT NOW! DO IT!