@@KaraAlexandraTM That is only an assumption, it has never been confirmed. Only statement grrm has said regarding dune is that he liked it but it wasnt one of his favorites.
@@EwaldBE it is pretty obvious to be fair. There’s like three different versions of Paul in ASOIAF. All good don’t get me wrong and none of it is a bad thing.
apparently due to Imperial bureaucracy House Atreides was given full stewardship instead of partial, which was how the Harkonnens ruled Arrakis. the difference being they had to relinquish control of Caladan because plot convenience (maybe ‘stretched too thin’ if you want a lore explanation)
The landsraad doesn’t work like that. The harkonnens were given contractual control over spice production but Arrakis was never their fief, it was under direct imperial control politically - hence why Count and Lady Fenring resided there as imperial governors. Leto was given the fief in totality and the houses can only have one fief. Accepting Arrakis meant surrendering Caladan. The book explains this better.
Yes, there was special sanctuary planet for houses who failed (was unable to hold their ground) and chosen to move there rather than face annihilation. But that means just pure survival as they loose their status, planet, resources - simply everything. And there is no way back as I recall. So those were 2 only available options - either accept or go there with all consequences
Yeah he never assumed the harkonnens would use so much resources to attack them and thought that they actually had a chance of surviving on arrakkis. Many houses looked forward to the atraides house for leadership. TL;DR basically it would’ve made their political position worse off and Duke Leto thought there was a good chance of surviving
😂why have you been commenting this on every dune post, I saw you arguing with dozen guys in Another video, has personal beef with the movie makers 😂?!!
@@unpopular_opinion8615 Ive seen this, they look like bots, they always comment the same thing with few changes. I do think many of them are bots trained to hate on something and they steal replies
Makes perfect sense, Leto Atredies was extremely popular among Landstrad, the ruling houses. The Emporer felt threatened, so he arranged take Stewardship of Arrakis from Harkonens, mortal enemies of Atredies, held Stewardship for 80 years.
Do tej aktorskiej równości rasowej brak mi Rodowitych Amerykanów i żółtych. Rodowici Amerykanie najbardziej pasowaliby na Feemenów. Plany w planach. Pułapka w pułapce.
@@Orbowitz Oczywiście. Ale czy Liet Kynes był afroamerykańską kobietą? Dużo bardziej pierwsi pasowali by wśród fremenów. To mogli być na przykład wśród saraudukarów. Żółci także. Ale to nieważne. Film jest dobry. A ja stary i mogę sobie ponarzekać
Кино
This was his death sentence 😢
Thanks to Dr. Yueh.....
@@juletaurusnope. Apparently it was inevitable. Dr. Yueh simply made it easier
@@juletaurus is yueh's wife a be ne gessirit?
@@kiranraveendran2437 yeah she was
@@juletaurusit would have happened regardless the dr just wanted a chance at killing the baron
"Smile Thanos."
"I am smiling."
Ohhhh wooooooow so he was thanosssss!.
Yeah did you not know it was Josh Brolin? The legendary actor who also started in The Goonies
@maplethebunny1936 nooo, I didn't, I only realised when I saw this comment then the voice clicked!
Red flags stronger than Ned Stark becoming hand of the king😞
Facts 😂
Fun fact Leto Atreides is the inspiration for Ned Stark
good old harold
@@KaraAlexandraTM That is only an assumption, it has never been confirmed. Only statement grrm has said regarding dune is that he liked it but it wasnt one of his favorites.
@@EwaldBE it is pretty obvious to be fair. There’s like three different versions of Paul in ASOIAF. All good don’t get me wrong and none of it is a bad thing.
Herald of The Change actor had like 10 lines and 1 minute on screen but absolutely nailed it
I Know Right
It's done 🫥
He's a musician called Benjamin Clementine, known for super theatrical and emotional performances. Great casting
Yup. Great scene.
"Smile Gurney"
Gurney😠 I am smiling
😂😂😂😂
jessica's eyes are so beautiful
Shoulda ruled from the homeworld and sent a governor in his place. That's what the harkonens did.
From what l remember Harkonens has hit all worlds Atredies had at the same time
@@ausar3852they had to give it up when they took arrakis. They obviously get it back too.
apparently due to Imperial bureaucracy House Atreides was given full stewardship instead of partial, which was how the Harkonnens ruled Arrakis. the difference being they had to relinquish control of Caladan because plot convenience (maybe ‘stretched too thin’ if you want a lore explanation)
And they were cowards and thieves.
The landsraad doesn’t work like that. The harkonnens were given contractual control over spice production but Arrakis was never their fief, it was under direct imperial control politically - hence why Count and Lady Fenring resided there as imperial governors. Leto was given the fief in totality and the houses can only have one fief. Accepting Arrakis meant surrendering Caladan. The book explains this better.
Leto was too pure for this world 😢
Starks from Space.
Josh Brolin saying "I am smiling " sound reminds me of Thanos
Gee I wonder why lmao
I would love an alternative version where Leto just said "No, and screw you" 😅
"Screw you, mf"
An risk going to war with the emperor army
Yes, there was special sanctuary planet for houses who failed (was unable to hold their ground) and chosen to move there rather than face annihilation. But that means just pure survival as they loose their status, planet, resources - simply everything. And there is no way back as I recall.
So those were 2 only available options - either accept or go there with all consequences
Good ending
Epic movie. Fantastic score from Hans Zimmer. Home run performances from everyone
If something sounds too good, u can be sure theres something in it.
Atreides! Atreides! Atreides! Atreides!
Not gonna lie, their uniform looks nice.
Benjamin Clementine!! Superb and Magnificent!!
Wow, I knew he looked familiar.
House Atreides shall immediately take control of Arrakis and serve as its steward....literal goosebumps
bro gave him the nod like yea you screwed
Paul is gonna betray a faith....😢
Because Paul is faith
What betrayal? Fremen saw him as a messiah and he delivered.
It was this moment that he knew: he fucked up
one of the best scenes
Such an amazing movie...
Nah, we good
The herald sounds like the guy Ming The Merciless fried in Flash Gordon.
Shame the Spacing Guild weren't in part 2.
Facts, we should of been able to see all of the great houses
When is a gift not a gift!
Little did he know
This is my favorite scene in the first movie
Spacing guild representative costumes look fire🔥🔥🔥
So good❤
This is sci-fi film that respects the material and its fans...but Star Wars....
Who is a gift, not a gift
When…when is a gift not a gift
@@sawtooth808lol
Ned stark in parallel universe
God they look so well polish. They got messed upppp
"Erm, I mean tell The Emperor Thanks and all that.....but .... .
What happen to the human computer?
What would happen if Duke Leto said "Nahh."
Would have tarnished the Atreides name quite a bit, but that’s just my guess.
Yeah he never assumed the harkonnens would use so much resources to attack them and thought that they actually had a chance of surviving on arrakkis. Many houses looked forward to the atraides house for leadership. TL;DR basically it would’ve made their political position worse off and Duke Leto thought there was a good chance of surviving
why is it spelled Atraides?
IM PAUL MUADDIB ATREIDES, DUKE OF ARRAKIS. A HAND OF GOD MY WITNESS - IM THE VOICE OF THE OUTER WORLD. I LEAD YOU TO PARADISE ✊✊✊
Maybe there should’ve been a call you don’t accept.
Now I wonder, what happened to Caladan after the massacre? I mean, I assume Paul stays on Arrakis as the Emperor.
I love Oscar Issac but he was wrong for this role in my opinion.
Are the dudes with orange helmets the navigators?
Yes
This does not put a smile on my face
What happens to this planet after he died in the arrkies and paul was struck at arrikes??
It still remains as Atreides property. After war in Arrakis, Jessica return and lives in Caladan
The plot of dune makes no sense
😂why have you been commenting this on every dune post, I saw you arguing with dozen guys in Another video, has personal beef with the movie makers 😂?!!
@@unpopular_opinion8615 Ive seen this, they look like bots, they always comment the same thing with few changes. I do think many of them are bots trained to hate on something and they steal replies
I saw you alot commenting like this about Dune plot. Just go back to your disney starwars already
Haters thats all
Makes perfect sense, Leto Atredies was extremely popular among Landstrad, the ruling houses. The Emporer felt threatened, so he arranged take Stewardship of Arrakis from Harkonens, mortal enemies of Atredies, held Stewardship for 80 years.
The original was better than this crap👎
Totally agree. It’s very cringe.
Thank you glad somebody said it.
As if either one of you clowns could make anything better.
Y’all on something
nostalgia is blinding you. Old dune is mediocre and rushed.
Good to see daft punk is still kicking around
eeeeEEEEEeEEeeeeeeEEeEe XD
Do tej aktorskiej równości rasowej brak mi Rodowitych Amerykanów i żółtych. Rodowici Amerykanie najbardziej pasowaliby na Feemenów. Plany w planach. Pułapka w pułapce.
Except it doesn't. The Fremen are based on Middle Eastern and Islamic culture not First Nation peoples
@@Orbowitz Oczywiście. Ale czy Liet Kynes był afroamerykańską kobietą? Dużo bardziej pierwsi pasowali by wśród fremenów. To mogli być na przykład wśród saraudukarów. Żółci także. Ale to nieważne. Film jest dobry. A ja stary i mogę sobie ponarzekać
Nah, we good