It's great, but they could've made something better if they would've used another topic or not exagerate this one, the giant bird looked pretty cool though
For all the English people, in the French chorus, they say: "Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime, s'aime, s'aime" And that's how we love, love, love " C'est comme ça qu'on consomme, 'somme 'somme" That's how we buy, buy, buy. But Stromae is so a genius that, in French the "That's how we buy" the "buy" that is "consomme" in French, the last two syllables ("somme") continues to echoes, and "somme" also means "are". So in the original chorus, with the auditory illusion, it sounds like: "C'est comme ça qu'on somme (que nous somme) " So basically, "that's how we are" Sorry if it's bad written, I'm not the best at English.
Try the other films by Sylvain Chomet (the guy behind the animation here) like Les triplettes de belleville, La vielle dame et les pigeons (short film on youtube) x)
I love how deep he makes his Videos. Social media (twitter bird) is killing all human relations, makes us believe that we are happy, when in fact we're all alone. Love this song
hmmm depends social networks get their advantages, it all depends about how we use it, I personnally use Facebook for keep contact with some friends and organize some ways to meet eachother, then it can be used well too ^_^
This might be realistic to his own experience. The way famous people (with thousands and thousands of followers) experience social media can be radically different from the way the average person experiences it. Most research points to social media making us more connected rather than less connected but that doesn't mean all relationships on social media are rich, many can feel just as hollow, like the people who we friended because they went to high school with us but haven't communicated with in 10 years. Stromae may seek personal connection but as a public figure social media doesn't really make it easier to make connections because he might constantly be bombarded with tweets. I do think he tries to make a broader statement as the video goes on. I'm not sure it necessarily hits the mark though.
when i was 8, i never understood what stromae’s motives were no matter how many times i watched and listened to the lyrics, now that i am 15, i realize that he has describe and resumed our generation exactly how it is, so raw and so true, how the screens, the social media captivate everyone and i think that this idea was genius, not only for its concept but also for its warning to the viewers.
I love that the Twitter bird's beak is animated to sync with the beat. It really represents that background, incoherent, omnipresent noise of social media. That it looks so damned angry all the time suggests most of that noise is rage. Amazing little touch.
Same! I also had a weird theory that in the beginning when the Twitter bird opened its beak, it was sometimes happy or sometimes angry. As it would represents the times when person using the twitter would ‘tweet’ their thoughts to the public both with positive or negative thoughts. But as time progresses, the twitter bird most of the time just open its beak in a angry like manner as it could mean that the person is getting very negative most of the time.
@@AnnSpecter I didn't even notice that! You're right, it suddenly turns dark, doesn't it? Goes from birdsong into the beat. Representing the downturn as someone is infected with Twitter's negativity. I mean, maybe we're overanalysing, but ain't that part of the fun? XD
Yes but the translation French to english for this song is quite impossible ! There are more details in french with the words plays that the english translation can't reproduce
***** If you agree with me, don't contradict me. "I don't think it's about" "But I agree that the translation isn't that great"...Like ,shut the fuck up and stop commenting just because you can.
I’ll never forget this really popular and smart Tumblr user criticizing this song for being corny and simplifying it as “old person says not to use phone a lot just like every other old person, but really they don’t get that it’s just not that serious.” I felt so silly for liking this song at the time and felt corny for thinking this was a deep message… now in 2024 the message here is still so relevant. It was always a deep and important message.
Nobody’s talking about the fact that this is originally from an opera, called Carmen by Georges Bizet and the song is (wonderfully) remixed from this opera ? The original music is also mesmerizing ✨
I KNEW it sounded like that song!! I was like ‘did stromae use a sample from that old opera song? (I didnt know it was called Carmen until I just searched)
I was looking for French music to help passive learning and came across Stromae. Out of any artists I've ever heard and seen in any language, Stromae is one of the greatest. So glad I found him.
This song was years ago when internet addiction was at a really low rate. This just showes that it was so easy to see what would come for us and that we nurture addiction till it takes control for us.
Stromae is not a singer, he is an artist. He talks about real problems of the world and the humans. He leads his people by telling the truth by his art. Such a genius. Belgian people should know the value of him more. Greetings from Turkey to Stromae and French&Belgian people.
9 years later, i just understood the message he was trying to share, we did not got it at the time, we did not see the evil hidden in the shape of social media. i can write about this for hours but the animation said everything. to everyone reading, get back to reality, sleep early wake up early eat healthy reduce your time screen as much as possible, go visit someone you love, don't facetime him, take a piece of paper and write don't use notes, do any kind of sports, eat healthy, work hard , build a family, and keep everything PRIVATE, not everybody will wish good for you...
je trouve ça hyper impressionnant le nombre de personnes qui écrivent en anglais ce qui prouve bien que stromae est vraiment très fort pour avoir réussi à se faire autant connaitre à l'étranger et pas seulement dans les pays francophones je trouve ça cool :)
Jade Guilbot Ce ne sont pas forcément les meilleurs les plus connu, loin de là. La popularité tend à s'opposer au talent de plus en plus. Mais dans son cas, il est fort! :)
Øyvind Jørgensen yeah, it's definitely a great shame as i personally love to hear songs like this, i don't mind that it is not english, i guess others don't really agree with me
This song is genius in so many ways : - It's called carmen because the main melody is sampled from "L'amour est un oiseau rebelle" from the theatre play "Carmen". - It revolves around birds not only because of Twitter but also because the original song translates to "Love is a rebel bird". - The cry of the bird emulates Twitter notifications. - The hook is "Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime, et c'est comme ça consomme". It translates poorly in English but it's a really clever pun. - The clip is in sync with the beat of the song. I love Stromae. Sérieux je l'adore, j'ai hâte à son prochain album (oui je commence à parler français en plein milieu)
My French teacher played this in class and me and my friends were shook- everyone was laughing and screaming at the same time and now this is my favorite music video
dude i freaking love the message of this video. how the obsession of social media can can control our actions, relationship, etc the song was amazing and the animator did a stunning job
Yeah being leftovers. It's kinda sad to see all these people sharing a constant flow of pictures on Twitter or Instagram just by the impression that it makes their life more interesting. I'm a computer scientist and a huge gamer, but I've taken a huge step back from taking pictures, I'd rather live the moment than immortalize something I've not lived fully anyway. Social networks have completely overstepped their purpose, and it's not even on them, it's on their users. The technology itself isn't bad and makes some good thing (sharing with distant relatives, organizing and keping up to date with news on what you like) but people have made it integral to their life to the point it might as well be stitched to them. There's also the reaction to the little girl that is interesting. At the beginning she's out of the system, she doesn't have an account or a device, and no care is given to her by the "social bird", she doesn't deserve to be even considered.
@@emilykubik115 The melody (and the first few words of the lyrics) in the beginning is from the opera Carmen by Bizet: ruclips.net/video/KJ_HHRJf0xg/видео.html
Absolutely incredible song. It is so very very true. The music, the lyrics, the vocals, this is truly fantastic. A masterpiece. Un chef d'oeuvre. Bravo Stromae
I still remember that I was so traumatized when I first watched this MV maybe not understanding the true message of the MV at that time, but now I watch this 7 years later, the power that social media has and how people easily became slaves to social media is so true. This MV is well made even the little detail that the bird came to that little girl. This MV alert the danger of social media can happen to anybody with any age.
Same...I watched it when I was in 6th grade. I got the message almost vaguely but not quite. Now that I'm older I understand to the full extent what Stromae expressed in the song
I was in like 3rd grade when this MV came out and they played it for us at assemble and I still get shivers when I hear the line about dying like rats, and the more I think about it it actually did form part of how I think about social media, they just played it cause it was a french school and Stromae was trending at the time but it has resonated through my brain for the past 9 years
@@awakewemaiga6831 je viens de revoir mais quelqu'un t'as déjà donne la ref^^, perso ma version préféré de cette chanson est celle chanté par nana Mouskouri.
Slt Je viens de sortir un son qui parle d'amour, votre soutien m'apportera beaucoup merci ruclips.net/video/ZdQbpxOZplw/видео.html Ps: laissez votre avis
yes i do realize that. But the social media im talking bout is where you gain followers with your selfies and just always obssessed with having good angles and lightning for one selfie to get like what?100 likes. Okay cool, like seriously whats the point of all this? I do have a youtube account obviously but where do you see a selfie exactly lol
I really like that between 0:50 and 1:15 he is doing these activities alone, including his own birthday. Even though his followers were increasing. I think what the artist was trying to show was that even though your followers are growing and you feel like you have become popular, they are not really your friends.
If you really pay attention to the video, you can learn a lot. The bird eating his food symbolizes that society forgets to even eat, instead choosing to use social media. The bird on his back shows that Twitter weighs us down. The bird being between the two shows that it drives a wedge between us and our loved ones. The bird picking him up and carrying him on his back shows us that Twitter, or social media, has finally taken complete control over his life, to the point that he cares about literally nothing, even as it drives him into hell. Finally, his love tries to save him by reaching out to him, but she is unable to convince him to give up social media, and is crushed. Likely, she is crushed emotionally, rather than by a giant twitter bird, but the point remains the same. The video tells just as important a story as the song, and even without it, is still a perfectly comprehensible work on its own.
In french "consomme" or "consommation" has many meanings, and I understand that he jokes with the meanings during the song and the video. He is talking about love and in this situation "consommation" means how people relate to each other. He says that love is a son of the relationship, depends on what kind of relationship we have, love is builded by choices day by day. It's like in the offert and demand law - when somebody don't give himself to the relationship the love of the other ends. But "consomme" can mean also "to use”, so he links social medias and relationships; and can mean also "to buy", so he links the song with the consumption habits; and can mean “to end little by litte” like something being absorbed. It's possible analyzing the song from any of these points...
Stromae's music is like that poem your Literature teacher told you to dissect. A phrase can have a lot of intended meaning based on literal words, societal context, historical context, etc.
"consomme" is even "consume", like consuming things or relationships or people, burning them. And love is still a kind of consume, mostly the love for yourself. One of the meanings is that Twitter and the socials are creating a mass of self-lovers that consume themselves (I think).
Oh, I thought he was trying to get in a jab at capitalism. I'll cut some slack then. Twitter is a consumer product. Power users don't play with censored platforms and Silly Cunt Valley corporate culture reflects this. They have posters banning the use of the word user. More stitches means less riches, right? Just throw it away and buy a new one instead of fixing it or building things to last in the first place. Disgusting.
*Here is my analysis:* At 0:04 he adopts a bird (symbolic). 0:25 , he keeps feeding him by using more and more of the social networking sites. Soon, the bird starts to have an influence on him. 0:40 Shows that the bird has an impact on his life. 0:49 shows that the bird is scaring away his real life connections. 0:52 The more he needs the bird, posts more on his feed, the bird gets bigger. 1:08 just as our phones are giving us bent necks, the bird is also giving him a bent neck. 1:33 The bird is coming between him and his family. 1:56 Now it is the turning point. HE IS NOT CARRYING THE BIRD ANYMORE, THE BIRD IS CARRYING HIM. That means, he is not controlling the phone, the phone/social media is controlling him. 2:01 We get to know that he is not the only one in the game, there are many other famous people too. 2:31 Now it is too late to understand. 2:35 The people have been fed to the mother bird, maybe it refers to the companies who want the money. They consumed the people with their lives. 2:57 Even in danger, when everyone must be helping each other, the person is busy clicking pictures. 3:13 The bird has now caught the attention of the young girl (representing the children) and now, the history repeats itself. *Vraiment, Stromae est un génie.*
Someone remarked somewhere that he is the Mozart of today. Sometimes I want to agree. His music is complex yet refined. His music carries message, yet is universal across languages. At least in enjoyment. Either way, he is a blessing to the Music of today.
L'amour est comme l'oiseau de Twitter On est bleu de lui, seulement pour 48h D'abord on s'affilie, ensuite on se follow On en devient fêlé, et on finit solo Prends garde à toi Et à tous ceux qui vous like Les sourires en plastique sont souvent des coups d'hashtag Prends garde à toi Ah les amis, les potes ou les followers Vous faites erreurs, vous avez juste la côte Prends garde à toi Si tu t'aimes Prends garde à moi Si je m'aime Garde à nous Garde à eux Garde à vous Et puis chacun pour soi Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme L'amour est enfant de la consommation Il voudra toujours toujours toujours plus de choix Voulez voulez-vous des sentiments tombés du camion L'offre et la demande pour unique et seule loi Prends garde à toi Et j'en connais déjà les dangers moi J'ai gardé mon ticket et s'il le faut je vais l'échanger moi Prends garde à toi Et s'il le faut j'irais me venger moi Cet oiseau d'malheur je le mets en cage Je le fait chanter moi Prends garde à toi Si tu t'aimes Prends garde à moi Si je m'aime Garde à nous Garde à eux Garde à vous Et puis chacun pour soi Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme Un jour t'achètes, un jour tu aimes Un jour tu jettes, mais un jour tu payes Un jour tu verras, on s'aimera Mais avant on crèvera tous, comme des rats
I remember watching this 9 years ago, thinking the twitter/social media rage wasn't so bad, now 9 years later, social media has only gotten worse, and most people have become slaves to their phones, they consume more and more each day, I have as well for years. Only since the beginning of 2024 I have made big improvements to stay away from social media and it lead me back to this song. Stromae knew before us, how social media would end up, all consuming and we consume more every day.
This song got me into Stromae when I decided to search my name on RUclips to see what would come up I couldn't have predicted all the beautiful, artistic, deep meanings that I'd end up enjoying from each of his songs!! Stromae is amazing
I love this song.:( it reminds me when I was in 6th grade learning French and almost 80% of our school picked Spanish. I’m so happy I learned French is one of the most beautiful languages of the world. Lovely songs and lovely memories of being a child
tu pourrais m'expliquer le métaphore de cette chanson stp? je comprends plus ou moins maus je voudrais qu'on me l'éxplique plus clairement, surtout l'allusion des paroles, normalement je comprends assez façilement les métaphires dans les paroles des chansons mais là c'est un peu plus compliqué pour moi
@@tonynambs3232 en gros la chanson parle de l'effet des réseaux sociaux sur la vie des gens et comme on peut se perdre et s'éloigner des gens qui sont dans nos vies à cause de ça. C est pour ça que Stromae dit "prend garde à toi si tu t'aime, garde à moi si je m'aime" il nous dit de faire attention à se qui peut se passer à cause de nos actions
@@aikonunesdasilva3681 ta explication m'a aidé a faire mes devoirs de français, merci beaucoup, je la compris mieux! :) (j'espère que mon français est bon)
Bonjour! Je parle Le Francais mais je suis anglais. J'adore la music video parce que c'est importante et c'est in veritable message. J'adore la France! Bon journee, au revour!
Omg he's just saying that he can speak French, and that he loves France. he didn't say Stromae is French, he has the right to just enjoy the language he sings in. Stromae might be from Belgium, he sings in French, rather you want it or not.
Honestly with the amount of Twitter arguments and Dream Stan’s and people being cancelled this song is still sorta relevant today Twitter truly destroys humanity
Actually it's not the app's fault but the PPL out there ruined everything it was supposed to be a normal social media but every social media has a bad side and good side :D
@@cakiEDITS Nah, actually, social media is intentionally designed to promote and amplify negativity and misery because that's what drives the most engagement and clicks. Look into the ways Twitter and Facebook especially are designed to modify our behaviors in some truly destructive ways.
Amazing art, my beautiful brother showed me this song in 2015, then I sadly forgot about it. Until today where I saw in my memories that he shared the video with me in 2015, 9 years ago today 🫶🥰❤️✨Love you angel bro ❤
i always loved stromae as one of my favourite french singers and this was the best thing ever. the way he depicted everything and hopefully made people realise that social media destroys you , makes you alone and then kills you. it is not only eye-opening but terrifyingly accurate
CARMEN LYRICS [In French] [Couplet 1] L'amour est comme l'oiseau de Twitter On est bleu de lui, seulement pour 48 heures D'abord on s'affilie, ensuite on se follow On en devient fêlé, et on finit solo Prends garde à toi Et à tous ceux qui vous like Les sourires en plastique sont souvent des coups d’hashtag Prends garde à toi Ah les amis, les potes ou les followers Vous faites erreur, vous avez juste la cote [Refrain] Prends garde à toi Si tu t’aimes Garde à moi Si je m’aime Garde à nous, garde à eux, garde à vous Et puis chacun pour soi Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme [Couplet 2] L’amour est enfant de la consommation Il voudra toujours toujours toujours plus de choix Voulez voulez-vous des sentiments tombés du camion ? L’offre et la demande pour unique et seule loi Prends garde à toi "Mais j’en connais déjà les dangers, moi J’ai gardé mon ticket et, s’il le faut, j’vais l’échanger, moi Prends garde à toi Et, s’il le faut, j’irai m’venger moi Cet oiseau d’malheur, j’le mets en cage J’le fais chanter, moi" [Refrain] Prends garde à toi Si tu t’aimes Garde à moi Si je m’aime Garde à nous, garde à eux, garde à vous Et puis chacun pour soi Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme [Outro] Un jour t’achètes, un jour tu aimes Un jour tu jettes, mais un jour tu payes Un jour tu verras, on s’aimera Mais avant on crèvera tous, comme des rats
Aight but is no one gonna talk about how GREAT this animation is!?
I KNOW right?!!!
It's great, but they could've made something better if they would've used another topic or not exagerate this one, the giant bird looked pretty cool though
Yep
It's pretty nice
Right??
For all the English people, in the French chorus, they say:
"Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime, s'aime, s'aime"
And that's how we love, love, love
" C'est comme ça qu'on consomme, 'somme 'somme"
That's how we buy, buy, buy.
But Stromae is so a genius that, in French the "That's how we buy" the "buy" that is "consomme" in French, the last two syllables ("somme") continues to echoes, and "somme" also means "are". So in the original chorus, with the auditory illusion, it sounds like:
"C'est comme ça qu'on somme (que nous somme) "
So basically, "that's how we are"
Sorry if it's bad written, I'm not the best at English.
Glad someone else noticed that 👍 C’est incroyable
hey thank you for this!
S’aime means love, is there more than one one to say “love “ or “i love you”?
@Emporio Polary 👌
He's a genius....
This got dark really quickly, didn't see that coming
This video always creeps me out!! Stromae is a genius tho
He just told us that twitter will ruin your life if yo use it to much
@@MonchiMochiXT If you use it for the wrong reasons mainly but at the end result is ruining your private life.
@@Smertaf ueeeeee pema ouja
.
we’d watch this in french class in middle school and it still freaks me out
Pareil ! Je dois l'apprendre pour le français au collège 😁
Un bonjour de la France
🇨🇵🎌🇬🇧
@@Octaveunmeccool bonne chance à vous!!! ☺️🇫🇷💙
@@YBMendako Thanks you very much ! Good luck ☺️🇬🇧
I watched this in High School
Nah fr it traumatised me when I first saw it
I have returned way too many times the past 6 years, WHY IS NO ONE STILL NOT TALKING ABOUT THE ACTUAL ANIMATION BEING SO GOOD..?
FR OMG
Right?! the acting in the bed scene is insane
Try the other films by Sylvain Chomet (the guy behind the animation here) like Les triplettes de belleville, La vielle dame et les pigeons (short film on youtube) x)
@@moogyaka8940 also Le Illusioniste
IKR
"comme ça qu'on s'aime"
"comme ça consomme"
Jeu de mots absolument masterclass, un véritable maitre lyrique
Ouais et un poète philosophique avec l'existentialisme.
je m’en suis rendu compte tellement tard mais t’as raison quel poète
dans les crédit c'est sylvain chomet et orelsan qui sont crédité comme parolier
Un poète
@@captaineflowchapka5535 c'est plutôt Stromae et Orelsan les paroliers. Sylvain Chomet est le dessinateur.
I love how deep he makes his Videos.
Social media (twitter bird) is killing all human relations, makes us believe that we are happy, when in fact we're all alone. Love this song
hmmm depends social networks get their advantages, it all depends about how we use it, I personnally use Facebook for keep contact with some friends and organize some ways to meet eachother, then it can be used well too ^_^
Jag älskar Stromae jätte mycket!!
Yes he is so deep, thats why I love his music!
This might be realistic to his own experience. The way famous people (with thousands and thousands of followers) experience social media can be radically different from the way the average person experiences it. Most research points to social media making us more connected rather than less connected but that doesn't mean all relationships on social media are rich, many can feel just as hollow, like the people who we friended because they went to high school with us but haven't communicated with in 10 years. Stromae may seek personal connection but as a public figure social media doesn't really make it easier to make connections because he might constantly be bombarded with tweets.
I do think he tries to make a broader statement as the video goes on. I'm not sure it necessarily hits the mark though.
Sam Masghati FINALLY! Someone who is willing to speak english for the Stromae lovers who don't know French!!!!
when i was 8, i never understood what stromae’s motives were no matter how many times i watched and listened to the lyrics, now that i am 15, i realize that he has describe and resumed our generation exactly how it is, so raw and so true, how the screens, the social media captivate everyone and i think that this idea was genius, not only for its concept but also for its warning to the viewers.
phone bad, such an innovative and genious thing to say
sameee
@@nicol64paTo be fair, the song/video isn't really new.
@@nicol64pa twitter* , and furthermore the social media. Not the phones.
I'm so happy he's back. His music spans so many important topics. A voice we've missed all these years. Welcome back Stromae, thank you.
Me too iam happy he is back
This song is of 6 years ago
@@crumbzsy now 7 even
@@crumbzsy yes is true
@@crumbzsy they meant that this song is an important topic, so it’s good he’s back right now
I find this song not only to be terrifying but a bop as well.
Same but the message is very true
😔
yeah also its so old i ised to hear when it came out
Facts
@@yasxyas4712 me too
Si
Stromae's music is amazing.
Deandra Baker he is actually from belgium but he sings in french
hij is een waal gedverdoeme
Layal Firdaws Noooooo whyyyyy did you say that :'( I was proud to be french (I'm joking I'm not upset x'D)
c est belge
Ah mais lol quoi la mauvaise foi ! Z'êtes juste jaloux qu'il soit pas Français xD bande de rageux
Love the detail that the lady still loved him and tried to reach out for him but she was just tired of all his social media bs
I remembered listening to this song 5 years ago without understanding anything
Now it's just astonishing how this dude saw the future.
Totally.
and yet, it wasn't the future. we think he saw the future because of things drastically turned for the worse
@@Hlua.tochhawng shut up chinese bot
respect
@@dxrvio Japanese but yeah shit bot
I love that the Twitter bird's beak is animated to sync with the beat. It really represents that background, incoherent, omnipresent noise of social media. That it looks so damned angry all the time suggests most of that noise is rage. Amazing little touch.
Same! I also had a weird theory that in the beginning when the Twitter bird opened its beak, it was sometimes happy or sometimes angry. As it would represents the times when person using the twitter would ‘tweet’ their thoughts to the public both with positive or negative thoughts. But as time progresses, the twitter bird most of the time just open its beak in a angry like manner as it could mean that the person is getting very negative most of the time.
@@AnnSpecter I didn't even notice that! You're right, it suddenly turns dark, doesn't it? Goes from birdsong into the beat. Representing the downturn as someone is infected with Twitter's negativity. I mean, maybe we're overanalysing, but ain't that part of the fun? XD
@@mor-leidr1705 yes. I mean overanalysing is a thing I always do, and ye it is very fun!
Nice theory
No sh!t Einstein, pretty clear for everyone, nothing "little" about it
Everyone is talking about the story/animation but the music is actually pretty good
Normally it's other way
Yeah 👀
... yeah but did you see the English lyric i'm French and actually tha't true
ThatBrownRabbit yeah
"pretty good" well YES lmao that's stromae
Stromae, you are more than a poet. Your words go beyond verses; they touch deeply. Your art is truly exceptional.
Music is truly a language understood by people from all walks of life. You don't have to speak French to enjoy this masterpiece. LOVE IT
Yes but the translation French to english for this song is quite impossible ! There are more details in french with the words plays that the english translation can't reproduce
Antoine J I can translate this fine. People who try translating things are generally not pure bilingual.
***** If you agree with me, don't contradict me. "I don't think it's about" "But I agree that the translation isn't that great"...Like ,shut the fuck up and stop commenting just because you can.
This finna be the duolingo owl when you break your French streak
Pretty much what happened to me, I just deleted the app since I'm in a real French class now lol
it is
Hoydogge exactement la même pour moi!!! Je pense qu’il est TREEEESSS fâché...
Lol
LMAOO YEP
This song is true and scary at the same time....
Stromae is such a incredible musician 🙏🏼
use
It's true, Twitter killed Barack Obama
А пісня и клип про рак?посмотрите
this
I’ll never forget this really popular and smart Tumblr user criticizing this song for being corny and simplifying it as “old person says not to use phone a lot just like every other old person, but really they don’t get that it’s just not that serious.” I felt so silly for liking this song at the time and felt corny for thinking this was a deep message… now in 2024 the message here is still so relevant. It was always a deep and important message.
and you are older now 😈
Damn that Tumblr user doesn't seems to know Stromae is still quite Young
They don't sound particularly smart at all, tbh. This isn't a "phone bad" message at all, just social media.
Duolingo: finally, a worthy opponent, our battle will be legendary.
@Nicole Theunissen uhm what?
I Eat M0ths. Don’t mind him, he’s gone nuts
Have you tried Rosetta Stone? Big sales this time of year
Ovo
😂
Nobody’s talking about the fact that this is originally from an opera, called Carmen by Georges Bizet and the song is (wonderfully) remixed from this opera ? The original music is also mesmerizing ✨
I KNEW it sounded like that song!! I was like ‘did stromae use a sample from that old opera song? (I didnt know it was called Carmen until I just searched)
El Arreglito (Sebastián Yradier)
yes in fact that is also the name of this good ass song
-the management
EXACTLY
We know , I thought the original Carmen was made by Chopin but ok
I was looking for French music to help passive learning and came across Stromae. Out of any artists I've ever heard and seen in any language, Stromae is one of the greatest. So glad I found him.
+chapachuu he is indeed a really good french singer
He's not french. He's belgian
You're half right, his roots are from Belgian. But he is French. So 50/50 :)
+William Jørgensen he was born in Belgium, he studied in Belgium and he lives in Belgium.
Nothing French.
Okay, go look it up then.
This song was years ago when internet addiction was at a really low rate. This just showes that it was so easy to see what would come for us and that we nurture addiction till it takes control for us.
Stromae was a genius for this one. ART!!!!🏆
He basically predicted the future, recently elon exposed twitter for what it is
@@mdnishere9683 Elon didnt do sh/ it
@@placeholder670elon is the hero we need
@@blood2272fuck you mean? He is ruining the whole point of Twitter 💀
Stromae is not a singer, he is an artist. He talks about real problems of the world and the humans. He leads his people by telling the truth by his art. Such a genius. Belgian people should know the value of him more. Greetings from Turkey to Stromae and French&Belgian people.
he isn't french, he's Belgian
@@TheChill001 but he sings in french. French people should know the value of him too as well as belgians.
@@TheChill001 thanks for the info btw
@@nihatcanuner2183hes Belgian, should dutch people take value of flemish speaking singers just because they speak the same language? No.
I would recommend you to listen to Ren a britan artist who also very often make songs about problems around the world my personal fav is Dominos
I don't think stromae likes twitter very much
Fishylad Twitter bad no no
En effet, on dirait bien
ni les oiseaux bleus-
@@karstheultimatelifeform7827 IT'S MORE BAD
It shows the bad side of social media 😂
9 years later, i just understood the message he was trying to share, we did not got it at the time, we did not see the evil hidden in the shape of social media. i can write about this for hours but the animation said everything.
to everyone reading, get back to reality, sleep early wake up early eat healthy reduce your time screen as much as possible, go visit someone you love, don't facetime him, take a piece of paper and write don't use notes, do any kind of sports, eat healthy, work hard , build a family, and keep everything PRIVATE, not everybody will wish good for you...
The animation is wonderful and the message is very impactful. You can really tell alot of love went into this.
Quartz x i
je trouve ça hyper impressionnant le nombre de personnes qui écrivent en anglais ce qui prouve bien que stromae est vraiment très fort pour avoir réussi à se faire autant connaitre à l'étranger et pas seulement dans les pays francophones
je trouve ça cool :)
Jade Guilbot Ce ne sont pas forcément les meilleurs les plus connu, loin de là. La popularité tend à s'opposer au talent de plus en plus. Mais dans son cas, il est fort! :)
Le plus impressionnant c'est que les anglos le like même s'il chante en Français !!!!
Oui! J'aime ecouter stromae, car en ce moment j'etudies la langue. Les chansons de strome m'aide avec l'ecoute! C'est tres genial :)
Je suis entièrement d'accord avec toi!
Yeah, I love him and his music! He is very deep.
Stromae is not popular at all in England, and with songs like this, he really should be. I think this is an amazing song though ♥
Nathen Kiruba Because in England (like in the US) they only listen songs in english, I never heard any music without english lyrics in radio, in UK...
Øyvind Jørgensen yeah, it's definitely a great shame as i personally love to hear songs like this, i don't mind that it is not english, i guess others don't really agree with me
Øyvind Jørgensen there was we no speak americano all those years ago butur right its v v rare:'(
His song Papaoutai was popular here in America. A lot of people know about it but it never played on the radio
Ka Wi yeah, that's my fave song by stromae, but sadly, that was never popular in England either :/
"Un jour t’achètes, un jour tu aimes
Un jour tu jettes, mais un jour tu payes" cette ligne ma mit des frissons, la vérité blesse
This song is genius in so many ways :
- It's called carmen because the main melody is sampled from "L'amour est un oiseau rebelle" from the theatre play "Carmen".
- It revolves around birds not only because of Twitter but also because the original song translates to "Love is a rebel bird".
- The cry of the bird emulates Twitter notifications.
- The hook is "Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime, et c'est comme ça consomme". It translates poorly in English but it's a really clever pun.
- The clip is in sync with the beat of the song.
I love Stromae. Sérieux je l'adore, j'ai hâte à son prochain album (oui je commence à parler français en plein milieu)
Yor comment is underrated
I understand the pun to so funny im French so that's normal enfaite 😐
Merci, vous m'aidez beaucoup pour mon devoir sur cette chanson!😊
@@mariev1525 god damn it 😂
good luck thougth !!!
Thank you very much!😂
My French teacher played this in class and me and my friends were shook- everyone was laughing and screaming at the same time and now this is my favorite music video
You are a nice person.
@@_Zeozed huh?
ZeozedIG what do you mean?
yooooo same
Same
Everyone gangsta, until the bird starts speak in bass
Everyone gangster till bird start to speak bass..but then,everyone panicked when it started speaking dub step
Everyone gangsta until the bird starts pooping you out to the rhythm of the song
Ahaaga
1:43
I would like to speak bass
Je me souvient en quatrième année, et notre professeur nous a montré cette chansons. Ça me terrifie encore 😭
dude i freaking love the message of this video. how the obsession of social media can can control our actions, relationship, etc the song was amazing and the animator did a stunning job
Yeah being leftovers. It's kinda sad to see all these people sharing a constant flow of pictures on Twitter or Instagram just by the impression that it makes their life more interesting. I'm a computer scientist and a huge gamer, but I've taken a huge step back from taking pictures, I'd rather live the moment than immortalize something I've not lived fully anyway.
Social networks have completely overstepped their purpose, and it's not even on them, it's on their users. The technology itself isn't bad and makes some good thing (sharing with distant relatives, organizing and keping up to date with news on what you like) but people have made it integral to their life to the point it might as well be stitched to them.
There's also the reaction to the little girl that is interesting. At the beginning she's out of the system, she doesn't have an account or a device, and no care is given to her by the "social bird", she doesn't deserve to be even considered.
DevilBlackDeath nice I also never take pictures I think it's stupid
*Is using social media*
*gets 312 likes*
Oh the irony
+Meara Valla totally true dude
Hawkulous yessss
Moral of the story: close your window
Lmao 😂😂😂
That's all you remember after all this scenes🤣🤣🤣🤣(but it's totally true) 😂😂😂😂😂👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Moral of the story: Stromae hates twitter.
Ik it's a joke but let's hope you also get the real moral of the story as well.
Exacttly
this guy knows something we dont , always a deeper message
Real
this was the original “we live in a society”
yep
Well right now we don't live in a society, we live in our homes, specifically away from society
@@hiiistrex2838 not if you live in the USA, they prefer to die, it's different
@@jeanmarc9843 I live in the USA, and that's (mostly) a myth
@@hiiistrex2838 Except what can we do, go outside? Nope, Mr virus will terminate you.
Stromae: writes a song about how social media slowly consumes us and turns us into asocial fucks
The internet: haha funny in sync bird poop
ahaha there was 222, but I broke it😅
Sorry)
Oh my god, its pinky guy jr???
2021 and now the social media giants have us where they want us.
everyone was laughing at that scene when the philosophy teacher showed us this in class
snurk agurk 😂🤡
Someone: Hey, why don't you use Twitter?
Me: *sweats in Stromae*
I wish i had made the decision to not make a twitter account a few years ago
I just installed Twitter ro make people uninstall. Lol
@@emilykubik115 bruh
@@maybeoptify what does carmen mean PLS it’s for homework
@@emilykubik115 The melody (and the first few words of the lyrics) in the beginning is from the opera Carmen by Bizet: ruclips.net/video/KJ_HHRJf0xg/видео.html
Absolutely incredible song. It is so very very true. The music, the lyrics, the vocals, this is truly fantastic. A masterpiece. Un chef d'oeuvre. Bravo Stromae
I still remember that I was so traumatized when I first watched this MV maybe not understanding the true message of the MV at that time, but now I watch this 7 years later, the power that social media has and how people easily became slaves to social media is so true. This MV is well made even the little detail that the bird came to that little girl. This MV alert the danger of social media can happen to anybody with any age.
Same...I watched it when I was in 6th grade. I got the message almost vaguely but not quite. Now that I'm older I understand to the full extent what Stromae expressed in the song
At least I know im not the only one, the end part really got me scared.
Le message est clair et précis
Prenons garde
LMAO LITERALLY
I was in like 3rd grade when this MV came out and they played it for us at assemble and I still get shivers when I hear the line about dying like rats, and the more I think about it it actually did form part of how I think about social media, they just played it cause it was a french school and Stromae was trending at the time but it has resonated through my brain for the past 9 years
Personne ne parle de la qualité de l'animation simple mais vraiment jolie ? J'aimerais savoir combien de temps ça a pu prendre :3
Moi je vois surtout que personne ne parle de la chanson originale qu'il a parodie ici
Je ne dirais pas qu'elle soit si simple, perso j'aimerais bien voir le making of du clip
Fan de manga s’il te plaît c’est la quelle qu’il a parodié
Charlotte Bastenier merci 😊
@@awakewemaiga6831 je viens de revoir mais quelqu'un t'as déjà donne la ref^^, perso ma version préféré de cette chanson est celle chanté par nana Mouskouri.
La chanson est belle et est encore d'actualité aujourd'hui c'est ce qui fait la puissance de Stromae,
Franchement respect
bizaremen quand les chanteur tentent de pondre des texte qui ont du sens ou qui parle de quellque chose cça crée des perle
Incroyable enfin un commentaire en français enfin bref complètement d’accord ✌️
N'a jamais été + d'actualité qu'aujourd'hui
Slt Je viens de sortir un son qui parle d'amour, votre soutien m'apportera beaucoup merci
ruclips.net/video/ZdQbpxOZplw/видео.html
Ps: laissez votre avis
Je l'écoute tous les jours car c'est une vérité qui ne changera jamais
This man is an actual genius and this song is a masterpiece.
Après 8 ans, cette chanson résume le problème de la société et des écrans.
Stromaé est un génie.
Aujourd'hui, j'ai re visionné le clip et ré écouté la musique..... Je confirme totalement tes propos....
alors meme que je suis anglais, je comprends cette chanson et comment est parlé des problèmes d'aujourd'hui.
Mon esprit pleur
Pareil@@JosephCummington
Il un ÉNORME cerval🤣
This video gave me chills... I'm so glad I don't have any social media nor am I obsessed with taking selfies and having many followers and likes
Same
Sorry but you do realize that RUclips is a social media, right? Not saying you're obsessed with selfies but you do have a social media account...
yes i do realize that. But the social media im talking bout is where you gain followers with your selfies and just always obssessed with having good angles and lightning for one selfie to get like what?100 likes. Okay cool, like seriously whats the point of all this? I do have a youtube account obviously but where do you see a selfie exactly lol
i dont have instagram, twitter,] you name it, i dont have any. ,except for facebook where i dont have any pics either i only use it to see posts.
BeautifulLavaMonster same
you have no idea how right you were 9 years ago ! you have no idea what is yet to come. The complexity of everything that is yet coming to us.
Why does this feel like a black mirror episode
Lol it does!!!
You've right
Because the globalists turn their scripts into media to get the little froggies accustomed to the water temperature rising.
And why do there faces look like if James Charles and Michael Jackson had a kid
because it is real
This song always creeped the hell out of me when i was 11 years old now im 15 and i understand that this is a life lesson
@@ali-mithaabou1386 On est d'accord, c'est juste du copié/collé + google trad ksksks
this was posted 3 years ago not 4
@@DasBlueStorm cest vrais
Same here, Now I can read the English subtitles,
Wow aren't you just sooo D E E P
I really like that between 0:50 and 1:15 he is doing these activities alone, including his own birthday. Even though his followers were increasing. I think what the artist was trying to show was that even though your followers are growing and you feel like you have become popular, they are not really your friends.
VocaloidLiveConcert thats vary true and yet vary sad...........
VocaloidLiveConcert omg that feels so true
VocaloidLiveConcert i
I know right depresing
VocaloidLiveConcert Oui j'aime l'endroit aussi
Before Black Mirror, we have Stromae
Stromae : I made a new music
Animator : *I HAVE ONE IDEA*
One ikea
Goblins Art work ^^
Stromae is the Animator lol it says in the description
All of his songs have a meaning, they are specifically written. Also, all of his clips are related to the lyrics.
@@aguaralpsanimations2136 he may have had the idea but he was not the animator
This guy is a genius, I follow him on twitter :)
LMAO
Lmao... Tbh I do too
Ironic
+Krystal Pentaholic is that mitch
+Ghassan B lmfao
If you really pay attention to the video, you can learn a lot. The bird eating his food symbolizes that society forgets to even eat, instead choosing to use social media. The bird on his back shows that Twitter weighs us down. The bird being between the two shows that it drives a wedge between us and our loved ones. The bird picking him up and carrying him on his back shows us that Twitter, or social media, has finally taken complete control over his life, to the point that he cares about literally nothing, even as it drives him into hell. Finally, his love tries to save him by reaching out to him, but she is unable to convince him to give up social media, and is crushed. Likely, she is crushed emotionally, rather than by a giant twitter bird, but the point remains the same. The video tells just as important a story as the song, and even without it, is still a perfectly comprehensible work on its own.
True!😃
r/im14andthisisdeep: The Video.
@@KaijuDino well not gonna lie the vieo isn't really wrong on this one
Dang
I love being on social media, but i eat to
2024 quelqu’un ?
Toujours présent !
moi
Toujours 😊
Ouèche
Oui toujours
In french "consomme" or "consommation" has many meanings, and I understand that he jokes with the meanings during the song and the video.
He is talking about love and in this situation "consommation" means how people relate to each other. He says that love is a son of the relationship, depends on what kind of relationship we have, love is builded by choices day by day. It's like in the offert and demand law - when somebody don't give himself to the relationship the love of the other ends.
But "consomme" can mean also "to use”, so he links social medias and relationships; and can mean also "to buy", so he links the song with the consumption habits; and can mean “to end little by litte” like something being absorbed. It's possible analyzing the song from any of these points...
Stromae's music is like that poem your Literature teacher told you to dissect. A phrase can have a lot of intended meaning based on literal words, societal context, historical context, etc.
"consomme" is even "consume", like consuming things or relationships or people, burning them. And love is still a kind of consume, mostly the love for yourself.
One of the meanings is that Twitter and the socials are creating a mass of self-lovers that consume themselves (I think).
Obviously..
Oh, I thought he was trying to get in a jab at capitalism. I'll cut some slack then. Twitter is a consumer product. Power users don't play with censored platforms and Silly Cunt Valley corporate culture reflects this. They have posters banning the use of the word user. More stitches means less riches, right? Just throw it away and buy a new one instead of fixing it or building things to last in the first place. Disgusting.
Im trying to learn french this year and I love Stromae, thx for explaning that part. Curiosity: in Brazil 'consume' have all thats meanings as well
My french teacher just showed this to us today, and one of my friends was dying of laughter while the other ones were traumatized 😂👌🏻
😆😆😆😆
Ton prof de français et bizzare de montrer cette vidéo 😂traduction english : your french teacher is weird to show dis vidéo
In class is everythink 10x funnier 😂
mine showed us the one where he sits still..i can’t remember the name of it
@@mrcheddar-_-4428 moi aussi ma prof me l'a montré !
Stromae is so underrated
That's not true...he is very popular where I come from
definitely
@Princessunderdog pareil
He has 3.7 Million subscribers...
@@dijaaaaa the amount of subscribers doesn't matter
Super clip, super sujet, super paroles, super reprise, une super musique qui va rester longtemps je pense.
*Here is my analysis:*
At 0:04 he adopts a bird (symbolic). 0:25 , he keeps feeding him by using more and more of the social networking sites. Soon, the bird starts to have an influence on him.
0:40 Shows that the bird has an impact on his life.
0:49 shows that the bird is scaring away his real life connections.
0:52 The more he needs the bird, posts more on his feed, the bird gets bigger.
1:08 just as our phones are giving us bent necks, the bird is also giving him a bent neck.
1:33 The bird is coming between him and his family.
1:56 Now it is the turning point. HE IS NOT CARRYING THE BIRD ANYMORE, THE BIRD IS CARRYING HIM. That means, he is not controlling the phone, the phone/social media is controlling him.
2:01 We get to know that he is not the only one in the game, there are many other famous people too.
2:31 Now it is too late to understand.
2:35 The people have been fed to the mother bird, maybe it refers to the companies who want the money.
They consumed the people with their lives.
2:57 Even in danger, when everyone must be helping each other, the person is busy clicking pictures.
3:13 The bird has now caught the attention of the young girl (representing the children) and now, the history repeats itself.
*Vraiment, Stromae est un génie.*
J'approuve tu l'a en français le commentaire ?
Hena Adlakha
Ummm hello
Je suis d’accord , très bonne analyse. Bravo
U r a genius
genius
I'll start learning french soon because of this man .. keep it up you have fans all over the globe
WaelGham Good luck!
Lol just kidding don't worry, it's not as difficult as it seems
WaelGham Wael? u're arabic ?
yeah
I will do the same!
WaelGham
all smotrae’s songs have some point. he is absolutely amazing.
Smotrae
are you serbia vuk cetu
stromae *
Varvariiii
Someone remarked somewhere that he is the Mozart of today. Sometimes I want to agree. His music is complex yet refined. His music carries message, yet is universal across languages. At least in enjoyment. Either way, he is a blessing to the Music of today.
This aged like fine wine
...not that I know anything about wine, but you get the idea
*The way she smacked him still has me wheezing 5 years later 😂💀😭☠️*
And it matched the beat too!
Mans couldn't even fold he was hit so hard
Same 😂😂😂 tht skinny ass body flailing off the bed
IM WHEEZING😭💀💀
@@fatoumfatoumeh LMFAOOOOO💀
Me, in the beginning: lol is that Obama or something
Me towards the end: Oh
lee_n_doodles I agree
GMDRuby Good job getting the joke there, buckaroo
its stromae (the artist of the song), look him up he looks like that
@@valuabledoodles good job misunderstanding his comment
*facepalm*
L'amour est comme l'oiseau de Twitter
On est bleu de lui, seulement pour 48h
D'abord on s'affilie, ensuite on se follow
On en devient fêlé, et on finit solo
Prends garde à toi
Et à tous ceux qui vous like
Les sourires en plastique sont souvent des coups d'hashtag
Prends garde à toi
Ah les amis, les potes ou les followers
Vous faites erreurs, vous avez juste la côte
Prends garde à toi
Si tu t'aimes
Prends garde à moi
Si je m'aime
Garde à nous
Garde à eux
Garde à vous
Et puis chacun pour soi
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
L'amour est enfant de la consommation
Il voudra toujours toujours toujours plus de choix
Voulez voulez-vous des sentiments tombés du camion
L'offre et la demande pour unique et seule loi
Prends garde à toi
Et j'en connais déjà les dangers moi
J'ai gardé mon ticket et s'il le faut je vais l'échanger moi
Prends garde à toi
Et s'il le faut j'irais me venger moi
Cet oiseau d'malheur je le mets en cage
Je le fait chanter moi
Prends garde à toi
Si tu t'aimes
Prends garde à moi
Si je m'aime
Garde à nous
Garde à eux
Garde à vous
Et puis chacun pour soi
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Et c'est comme ça qu'on s'aime s'aime s'aime s'aime
Comme ça consomme somme somme somme somme
Un jour t'achètes, un jour tu aimes
Un jour tu jettes, mais un jour tu payes
Un jour tu verras, on s'aimera
Mais avant on crèvera tous, comme des rats
Muchas gracias, estoy aprendiendo frances y me ha ayudado mucho💛
Merci
Tu t’ai fait chier
Bonjour j'aimerais un monteur pour monter mon cahier dans ma chambre merci l'oiseau de Twitter vert
Merci mais j'ai les paroles que mon prof de musique m'a donner
I remember watching this 9 years ago, thinking the twitter/social media rage wasn't so bad, now 9 years later, social media has only gotten worse, and most people have become slaves to their phones, they consume more and more each day, I have as well for years. Only since the beginning of 2024 I have made big improvements to stay away from social media and it lead me back to this song.
Stromae knew before us, how social media would end up, all consuming and we consume more every day.
C'est tellement beau quand on réécoute la chanson des années plus tard et qu'on comprend vraiment la signification de la chanson
tout a fait d'accord
Mais grave avant jmoi jeprenaît trop ça a la rigolade mais il a vrm raison les réseaux ça bouffe nos vies !
my friend: why dont you use twitter?
me:
Жиза
Hhhhhhhhh
Yap
I made this 1K likes
@@Eldfell yea boy u r Awesome
Animation is soooooo great! Very stylish and fresh. Respect to the animators!
If you like it, the animator made a whole movie a few years ago called "Les Triplettes de Belleville".
I knew it looked similar! I just coudn´t remember the name of the movie, it was a while since I watched it. Thanks for reminding.
Crazy how this music video aged like wine compared to reality 😢 he really saw what was becoming of that platform (twitter)
La plate-forme c’est nous et le devenir c’est eux…
je crois que ce clip est encore plus efficace que les vidéo de prévention du danger des réseaux qu'on nous met a l'école..
Ça c'est sur!
pourquoi "encore"? t'es en train de dire que les vidéos à l'école sont utile?? ceci dit c'est vrai qu'ils devraient passer ça à la place
on nous a passé ça en 4eme à mon école en musique et on a fait toute une séquence dessus
Dans notre collège on travaille cette musique pour la prévention des réseaux sociaux, on a de la chance
Moi sa ma fait tellement flippé, que je veux plus télécharger twitter
Conclusion : cette video est TRES efficace TvT
He is incredible. Back then twitter didnt have the political power it has now. Stromae was ahead of his time.
edit: R.I.P twitter
It may not have had the political power then, but it still had its social power over the masses.
It's not only about twitter tho...
Social media has always had a hold on people and the more technology advances the more this song rings true
the music is not about political power it is about consumerism, and social media addiction.
@@pierremalis2576 never said it was. But okay. I agree.
0:03 Fun fact:
Climatically speaking, If the window was closed, this song wouldn't exist
If social media didnt exist this clip wasnt gonna exist
@Julian Ong Hwei Shen Why do I see this account everywhere ?? Is this account a bot?
@@NoName-nn9xn what do you think
@@NoName-nn9xn Yeah, this is a bot
@@callmekhaleesi if social media didnt exist, youtube wouldn't exist
This song got me into Stromae when I decided to search my name on RUclips to see what would come up
I couldn't have predicted all the beautiful, artistic, deep meanings that I'd end up enjoying from each of his songs!! Stromae is amazing
“Aggressive French Twitter isn’t real, he can’t hurt you.”
Aggressive French Twitter: *non, c’est impossible!*
tealeyez004 uh...it’s Belgian, though.
@@LittleSparklingStars I know, but it's a satire comment so it doesnt really matter to me
hein ? xD
C'est vrai que les français sont agressifs, surtout sur Twitter x)
mais si c'est possible avec la-
Everybody gangsta till the blue bird steps on ya girl.
Depraved Diptera. Lol
*BLUE*
It looks like Stromae!
Depraved Diptera lol
And then you are ded
C'est incroyable de voir que même 5 ans après c'est toujours autant d'actualité.
A ba moi 5ans après ou pas j'adore quand même cette chanson alors...😍
Ouai c'est dingue !
Mais trop wshh
Plus que jamais...
Finally a comment different than the English ones
Se qui regarde sa en 2024 ?
Moi
Moi
Moi
Moi
Moi C'est la meilleure chanson qu'ils puissent créer et un Italien le pense
My God ,Stromae Is The Greatest Singer Of Europe, Maybe The Planet, Love From Canada
god is great
Ammar Iftikhar The type of genius that is born only every hundred years.
Ammar Iftikhar Love from Malaysia! He is freaking talented!
Love from Sweden 😍😍🇸🇪❤️
love from Germany
Stromae should be popular here in America, his music isn't trash
Jasmine Chapman I guess that's the reason he's not popular in America lol
Rolo FIIIRREEEE 🔥🔥🔥🔥😂😂😂😂 YOU'RE SAVAGE 😂😂
Ahah Hello Fat Burger's eaters !
Yoann le meur What type-a meth you taking? Lmao
Jasmine Chapman I know, but I feel like because it's in french most Americans would rather ridicule the song then appreciate it.
Did this song for a French music project, everyone was both blown away and amazed at the powerful message. Plus it's such a good bop.
obrigado xandão, vc é o cara!!!
CARA SIM KKKKKKKKK IA COMENTAR ISSO AGR
American music - drugs, love.....
French music - life
He is belgian
that's not the point
Jean Poli he said "french music", that means "chanson française", and Stromae sings in French. We all know where he is from.
Exactly. Music here in U.S. Is horrible.
Brayden Vanmilligan Music around the world is horrible, but sometimes art like this comes up
I love this song.:( it reminds me when I was in 6th grade learning French and almost 80% of our school picked Spanish. I’m so happy I learned French is one of the most beautiful languages of the world. Lovely songs and lovely memories of being a child
@@TK-317 хех, ну тут наверно надо сказать хеллоу йес?
Exactly
@@Ego_sum_mortuus ???
@@TK-317 😐
I agree with you! French is literally a love language! Like it sounds so beautiful!!
Moi, ici présente, l'une des rares personnes qui comprennent vraiment la chanson vu qu'on est français, toujours la en 2021
Y'a la traduction anglaise des paroles juste en dessous du clip...
tu pourrais m'expliquer le métaphore de cette chanson stp? je comprends plus ou moins maus je voudrais qu'on me l'éxplique plus clairement, surtout l'allusion des paroles, normalement je comprends assez façilement les métaphires dans les paroles des chansons mais là c'est un peu plus compliqué pour moi
@@tonynambs3232 en gros la chanson parle de l'effet des réseaux sociaux sur la vie des gens et comme on peut se perdre et s'éloigner des gens qui sont dans nos vies à cause de ça. C est pour ça que Stromae dit "prend garde à toi si tu t'aime, garde à moi si je m'aime" il nous dit de faire attention à se qui peut se passer à cause de nos actions
@@aikonunesdasilva3681 ah d'accord, merci
@@aikonunesdasilva3681 ta explication m'a aidé a faire mes devoirs de français, merci beaucoup, je la compris mieux! :) (j'espère que mon français est bon)
Finalement 10 Ans après ont n'aura jamais été aussi prés de cette vérité ...
Bonjour! Je parle Le Francais mais je suis anglais.
J'adore la music video parce que c'est importante et c'est in veritable message.
J'adore la France! Bon journee, au revour!
Au revoir* ;)
sorry to tell but he is Belgium
Omg he's just saying that he can speak French, and that he loves France. he didn't say Stromae is French, he has the right to just enjoy the language he sings in. Stromae might be from Belgium, he sings in French, rather you want it or not.
Au revoir*. Autocorrect, désolé :p
Guillaume K French is one of the three official languages of Belgium and is the native language of 40% of belgians, including Stromae.
*finishes video and sees a blue bird outside my window*
...
oh shiz -
also you have 69 likes now
@@s_w_a_t9357 *noice*
*Oh wait*
@@livingvampgirl *n o I c e*
Shoto *oop-*
Honestly with the amount of Twitter arguments and Dream Stan’s and people being cancelled this song is still sorta relevant today Twitter truly destroys humanity
@@lumizu2091 so sorry that happened to you hope your ok now
@@presidenthwasa5505 I understand the message of the song I was just simply making a connection/joke to Modern day Twitter
"still sorta relevant????" um. its entirely relevant unless uve been living in a cave.
Actually it's not the app's fault but the PPL out there ruined everything it was supposed to be a normal social media but every social media has a bad side and good side :D
@@cakiEDITS Nah, actually, social media is intentionally designed to promote and amplify negativity and misery because that's what drives the most engagement and clicks. Look into the ways Twitter and Facebook especially are designed to modify our behaviors in some truly destructive ways.
Amazing art, my beautiful brother showed me this song in 2015, then I sadly forgot about it. Until today where I saw in my memories that he shared the video with me in 2015, 9 years ago today 🫶🥰❤️✨Love you angel bro ❤
I think this video kinda scary or something but I can’t stop watching it-
Same-
Yeah idk why.. it’s so unsettling but yet again it has a story which I can respect
You're like 12
@@indydd yea says the 8 year old
@@indydd ok says you
Now that twitter is X, the new generations will not appreciate appropriately this masterpiece
Now, i imagine all the clip but the bird is replaced by a letter... *X*
@@Yvan713 Brooo, lmao
If we're being honest, the masses don't have enough respect for Twitter anymore to call it X. At least I don't haha.
It's basically twitter but a mf called it x bc he wanted to and also worse
i don't think anybody with a functioning brain actually calls it X
When I was younger I didn't understand the real meaning of this song.
*Now, I see everything clearly*
I like you Drew
He was warning us all along
I feel like when u say ur younger u mean u were 7 but now ur 8
I'm 11 hi
I get it bye-
Well that was wEiRd-
I don’t understand what does it mean
This aged like fine wine
Now we need the sequel with an evil X letter
i always loved stromae as one of my favourite french singers and this was the best thing ever. the way he depicted everything and hopefully made people realise that social media destroys you , makes you alone and then kills you. it is not only eye-opening but terrifyingly accurate
He’s belgian but yeah, we claim him as an international personnality 👀
@@Skyfusemog whoops ! i didn't know that 😅 thanks for letting me know !
@@Skyfusemog so he is french
@@kuroyami84 He is francophone, if you would like to express the language he sings in.
Terrifying indeed! No wonders I decided to "ditch" my facebook account...
CARMEN LYRICS [In French]
[Couplet 1]
L'amour est comme l'oiseau de Twitter
On est bleu de lui, seulement pour 48 heures
D'abord on s'affilie, ensuite on se follow
On en devient fêlé, et on finit solo
Prends garde à toi
Et à tous ceux qui vous like
Les sourires en plastique sont souvent des coups d’hashtag
Prends garde à toi
Ah les amis, les potes ou les followers
Vous faites erreur, vous avez juste la cote
[Refrain]
Prends garde à toi
Si tu t’aimes
Garde à moi
Si je m’aime
Garde à nous, garde à eux, garde à vous
Et puis chacun pour soi
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
[Couplet 2]
L’amour est enfant de la consommation
Il voudra toujours toujours toujours plus de choix
Voulez voulez-vous des sentiments tombés du camion ?
L’offre et la demande pour unique et seule loi
Prends garde à toi
"Mais j’en connais déjà les dangers, moi
J’ai gardé mon ticket et, s’il le faut, j’vais l’échanger, moi
Prends garde à toi
Et, s’il le faut, j’irai m’venger moi
Cet oiseau d’malheur, j’le mets en cage
J’le fais chanter, moi"
[Refrain]
Prends garde à toi
Si tu t’aimes
Garde à moi
Si je m’aime
Garde à nous, garde à eux, garde à vous
Et puis chacun pour soi
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça, consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
Et c’est comme ça qu’on s’aime, s’aime, s’aime, s’aime
Comme ça consomme, somme, somme, somme, somme
[Outro]
Un jour t’achètes, un jour tu aimes
Un jour tu jettes, mais un jour tu payes
Un jour tu verras, on s’aimera
Mais avant on crèvera tous, comme des rats
Merci pour les paroles
Merci bro