Fallen Off the YNAB Wagon? You're Not Alone.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 янв 2025

Комментарии • 108

  • @Jennheartsqs
    @Jennheartsqs 2 месяца назад +47

    LOVED this style of video and couldn't agree more. A few years ago I'd also fallen off the YNAB wagon. I knew my finances were a mess, but I felt so guilty and avoided logging back in to the app because I felt like my old budget would just be judging me. When I finally decided to just do a Fresh Start (without even looking at my old budget), it was so freeing and showed me that there were no budget police who were going to come scold me for starting over. We're all just doing the best we can each day.

    • @NanetteLoves2Budget
      @NanetteLoves2Budget 2 месяца назад

      That we are!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      That's the way to do! Don't bother looking back, just move forward!! Ernie would approve 👍🏻
      🌻 Hannah

  • @jcw3rdy
    @jcw3rdy Месяц назад +1

    I've been doing YNAB since Aug 2013 and at most I might skip a few days, but I've NEVER missed my 15th of the month bill pay cycle or my end of the month bill pay cycle plus closing the 'books' for the month....NEVER. BTW, the closing the 'books' for the month involves reconciling all my bank an CC statements, updating my Net Worth, Portfolio Progress, and Asset Allocation spreadsheets. Plus making "adjusting" entries in all my off-budget accounts to account for changes in the value of all my investment funds...plus paying any outstanding bills due. Busy time.

  • @KTquiltsandsews
    @KTquiltsandsews 2 месяца назад +24

    Sometimes I just want to watch a YNAB video, especially by you Hannah with your sense of humor and extreme empathy. Life is rarely predictable. My husband just got a job again after four months without one and we made it. Thank you for being so authentic. This video is awesome. xx Karen

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      So kind 🥹 And WOW, way to go for navigating a tough season with grace!! Amazing! Thanks for the encouragement, Karen 🥰
      🌻 Hannah

  • @anthonyobrien3841
    @anthonyobrien3841 2 месяца назад +6

    After many years of trying ( and failing) to properly manage my finances I stumbled across YNAB. I signed up about four months ago and I'm already on track to kill my monthly reliance on credit cards before the end of the year. Not only that but I have enough money saved for Christmas. If I don't have enough I will just manage with what I have, no credit. I'm a data junkie, so being able to see all of those green lines is such a motivator for me. Thank you so much.

  • @YKKY
    @YKKY Месяц назад +1

    We have been on and off for years in this house.... it took us ages to get to it. But now we have been diligent for 5 months and we are loving it. So we decided to put YNAB into our priorities. We picked our priorities to do if all is falling apart around us, like take out the trash, let the chickens our and close them up every day, feed the dogs, cats, walk the dogs, for the love of all that's holy, do not forget we have a child for a second and eat, eat nutritious meals which we prepared for situations like this and are ready in the freezer together with the cookie dough balls that are there to pick us up. And we added YNAB to this list, it's like bare bones tasks. We did this because we realized just how much YNAB does for us. I mean, we brought down our groceries spending to the necessities and stopped food waste and as a result are on a track to save 1500 euro this year just on food. Yes, YNAB is our bare bones, survival tasks, because it has changed our lives. We love YNAB in this house.

  • @esskaym
    @esskaym 2 месяца назад +18

    So timely!!!!! I’ve fallen off the wagon and have been meaning to get started again. I’m off to get my laptop and do a Fresh Start!

    • @gpslentz
      @gpslentz 2 месяца назад

      Same!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      You got this!! I believe in us all!!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @angelabladow2081
    @angelabladow2081 2 месяца назад +10

    You have no idea how much I needed this message! I have fallen off more times than I can count and always felt like I was just bad at YNAB. I am currently doing catch up after a couple months of not being consistent. I have been using YNAB for a long time (like before YNAB 4, long time). I always come back to YNAB because nothing else works for me. My goal in 2025 is to be consistent the whole year and not get months behind. Wish me luck. On second thought, I may reduce my goal to just 3 months and see how it goes. Thank you for your compassion and humor❤

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +2

      Yes! That's a life hack I've found for myself. Whenever I set too lofty of goals, the moment I even *think* I might mess it up, I subconsciously give up on the whole thing. Seeing smaller, more tangible goals gets you to that feeling of accomplishment and pride MUCH faster, and gives you the energy to keep up with your good habits! I'd even say set yourself a goal of keeping up with YNAB for a MONTH, and pre-select a little treat you'll get for yourself if you do-your favorite latte that has way too much sugar, a much needed car wash, that cute little christmas door wreath that you don't really need but would look so cute on your front porch. Getting rewarded for your positive behavior changes makes a big difference in helping us maintain that momentum!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @myrajoyce3494
    @myrajoyce3494 Месяц назад +2

    I love that you did this video. It’s great to have the stories from inside and knowing no one is a perfect YNABer.

  • @awinnett
    @awinnett 2 месяца назад +7

    As someone with ADHD, I rely on automatic entry. I am on my 9th month of YNAB saving my life and I could not be where I am without it. There's some toxic culture with some YNABers where utilizing automatic entry is "not real YNAB" or "training wheels". That's nonsense. It is totally legit. It is totally a great way to use it. Because anything that works, works.

    • @ayasbudgetblueprint
      @ayasbudgetblueprint 2 месяца назад +1

      Sameee!!! Every time I fell off, I was trying to conform to the manual entry “gurus” but it just got too overwhelming and kept giving up. Finally switched to automatic, and I’ve been keeping up with my current budget since Sept 2023 🎉

  • @stephv1563
    @stephv1563 2 месяца назад +2

    I really loved this video! It was very helpful. The great thing is with time getting back on the wagon is so much easier and I truly do feel so much better when I pay attention to YNAB. I love this positive, non judgmental community.

  • @jimc12
    @jimc12 2 месяца назад +4

    For me, I’ve been trying to use YNAB for 6 years. I’ve have yet to complete two or three months without doing a fresh start. At a few points I stopped using it for over 6 months even though I pay yearly for the service. It was transactions, then I simplified my six accounts down to three. Then Chrissy said she overspent on categories and was frustrated and would just start over. That’s where I am at now. I keep telling myself just keep at it and I will get better.

  • @classicrockonly
    @classicrockonly 2 месяца назад +4

    6:58 legit thought I was hearing my baby lol. I'm new to YNAB, and it has been keeping my wife and myself honest with the money we have and spend. Our debts and bad spending have been pushing us in the negative this whole year. But seeing what we have and trying to keep true to our categories has been a massive help. We don't have some of our baby categories nailed though. This month we've been pulling money from our Clothing category to fund our baby's own clothing category as she's growing and needing things. Seeing our debts, money we have, and assigning money to categories has massively lifted a burden off our minds

  • @amberayers4058
    @amberayers4058 2 месяца назад +7

    I needed this video. I fell off the YNAB wagon for a few year and just willy nilly'd everything. I was over spending like crazy and really felt like a failure. I just started again 11/1 with the More Money Challenge. I never even thought to reach out to YNAB for help. Please post more video like this. We all need to feel human every now and then. I appreciate everyone sharing their stories.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      Totally reminds me of something both Ernie and Sarah said in their interviews (that I don't believe made the final video?): we stop using YNAB because we're afraid of a money system controlling us, but the reason we go BACK to YNAB is because we realize how much control it actually *gave us*! Isn't that fascinating? Resonated so deeply with me.
      🌻 Hannah

  • @p-j-y-d
    @p-j-y-d 2 месяца назад +16

    To roll with the punches also means to roll with your own punches. To yourself. And that's fiiiine.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      Hahahahahaha, this made me laugh out loud 😂😂😂
      🌻 Hannah

  • @HershLundy
    @HershLundy 2 месяца назад +6

    There's a sermon in here somewhere. Getting "off the wagon" is more common than we realize. All sorts of people and groups live this, and it takes courage and charity to bring it home.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      It's certainly true for more than just money!! I feel ya! Have grace for yourself-we're all doing the best we can.
      🌻 Hannah

  • @libbysworld7649
    @libbysworld7649 2 месяца назад +4

    This meant the world to me this week. Thank you. I just went into open enrollment at work and everything increased, plus both hubby and I decided to increase our HSA to the maximum and save the difference between that and our max out of pocket, just in case. Not cheap! This helped me breathe a bit. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      Yes, I feel this! We also just went through open enrollment, upped our HSA contribution, upped our 401k contribution, AND unexpectedly bought a new car (and being 11 years newer than our last, also means more insurance!). We're feeling it right now too, but I know we can just rearrange our dollars and priorities in YNAB and it'll probably feel like nothing ever even happened. A lifesaver!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @Leavingforthelasttime
    @Leavingforthelasttime 2 месяца назад +6

    I really needed to hear this. It's such a weight off my shoulders to know I am not alone. And you helped me answer the "what next" question. I wasn't looking for a video on YNAB when I came onto RUclips today, but I'm so happy I decided to watch this. Now I don't feel like a financial failure.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      YAY! So glad to hear it. It's so easy to struggle with that "I'm behind" or "I'm not doing it right" feeling. You got this! Just time to ask new questions, reshuffle, and reprioritize. We have everything we need already within us!!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @jennivanhart3016
    @jennivanhart3016 2 месяца назад +7

    Ooof, this hit home big time. October required us to do some fancy footwork. We had my father-in-law move in with us thanks to hurricane damage to his home, so finding funds to cover the additional expenses incurred with his move and his life was craziness. This Budget Nerd had to let go of all my rules to just make it work for October. November will look similar but it is feeling more in control than October. #dumpsterfire. My YNAB brought me comfort though as it was the only thing I could even slightly control in October. It was my safe space of sorts.

  • @janesprague1
    @janesprague1 2 месяца назад +4

    Hannah, I think this is your best video ever! Well, maybe not the best as there are soooo many others that are outstanding, too, but this particular video is the most human and inclusive (vs. instructional) one. I knew I just couldn't be the only one struggling, and although I haven't fallen off YNAB (because not knowing my financial picture (good or bad) causes me waaaaay more stress than I want in my life), I've often considered Fresh Start-ing or simplifying or or or ... and just not coming up with the "right" plan. There is no forever right plan! Life and finances are constantly changing! OK, I think I could go on and on, but what I learned from my YNAB support team (yes, MY YNAB team - I love these folks!!) is that they sometimes feel exactly the same way I do, and that's a comfort and an encouragement, and now I'm able to impart that same comfort and encouragement to the YNABers in my life. I hope you're able to do another interview video again sometime. All of you are just awesome, and I'm so grateful to the entire YNAB team for showing me how to have peace of mind. Love ya!

  • @Kathleenthefernwayflipper
    @Kathleenthefernwayflipper 2 месяца назад +3

    Oh wow!! Like a balm to my financial soul. Perfect timing. Thank you. YNAB is truly an app with a heart. ❤

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      And your comment was like balm to my financial soul, too 🥰
      🌻 Hannah

  • @tetrealll132
    @tetrealll132 2 месяца назад +3

    Hanna, this is your best yet! I really enjoyed this episode!

  • @judymccarver5833
    @judymccarver5833 2 месяца назад +4

    Great idea for encouraging people in their budgets. The very thing I love about YNAB is that after a while when you have your budget set up (auto imports!!!) YNAB runs itself. All I do is -1 check my budget before I spend and --2 categorize -automatic imports. Period. So literally I never fall off of YNAB when following these twin/two steps. Direct imports are paramount. If I were manually entering my transactions, I would drown and be among the throngs who stop budgeting. Who would not?

  • @adamirving7387
    @adamirving7387 Месяц назад

    Loved the shout out (around 13 minutes) to the support team. What a phenomenal group of people!

  • @VioletEmerald
    @VioletEmerald Месяц назад

    I loved this one so much! Really unexpected format and it was so cool to hear all these voices.

  • @sherrydiddle
    @sherrydiddle 2 месяца назад +1

    I loved this, Hannah! A good reminder that we are all human and deserve a little grace!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      You are not alone!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @VeloLisa
    @VeloLisa 2 месяца назад +3

    I can’t imagine YNAB not being a daily part of my life. 🤷‍♀️

  • @Morales13795
    @Morales13795 2 месяца назад +1

    Love this! ❤ I had been off YNAB for a couple of weeks and felt awful about it. Love to hear YNAB employees offering advice from personal experience.

  • @cathyvazquez5034
    @cathyvazquez5034 2 месяца назад +5

    This was so helpful. I was so scared to go back in since I fell off. But now I know that it’s ok. Giving myself grace❤

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      You are not alone! You got this!!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @santizo715
    @santizo715 2 месяца назад +3

    Damn, this episode was 🔥I’m guilty of falling of the YNAB wagon but keep coming back, better than before. It’s progress over perfection and a beautiful reminder to be kind to yourself, and to remember “you are not alone.”

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      BETTER THAN BEFORE is the best part! Sometimes falling off is what we need to actually come back with MORE CLARITY! Love it. You're definitely not alone!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @davidmstone1
    @davidmstone1 2 месяца назад +8

    I totally relate to Sarah. If I'm not approving transactions daily and reconciling, my budget goes off track. Back in February my age of money was 41 days. After a month and a half of not keeping up, it dropped to 27. 9 months later and I'm only back up to 32. Quite a few of those February/March purchases were for things in the end I didn't even need. Now, I check my budget before I make most purchases.

  • @jonahrees9144
    @jonahrees9144 2 месяца назад +1

    Such a good video and thanks to everyone for sharing. Direct import really works well, reliable and accurate, and makes it easy to keep up with little hassle.

  • @tinas8807
    @tinas8807 2 месяца назад +1

    👏👏👏👏👏👏 So needed to hear this. Thank you for this behind the scenes look at real people doing real life.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      Anytime! We're all just out here doing our best!!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @MetalSamantha
    @MetalSamantha Месяц назад

    Fell off too
    I just made a fresh start today
    Thanks YNAB
    I felt so guilty and ashamed and that was keeping me from setting up a new budget
    This really helped

  • @yuhz1m1
    @yuhz1m1 2 месяца назад +1

    This was the most validating video. Thank you so much.

  • @ErnieV76
    @ErnieV76 2 месяца назад +6

    I CANT LIVE without YNAB. When I finally got it down, it just gives me peace of mind. (I wanna work there😁) Especially now that I am using credit cards for Traveling miles, budgeting is essential.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      Same dude, same. You fit in well here!
      🌻 Hannah

    • @ErnieV76
      @ErnieV76 2 месяца назад

      @ 😊🙏🏼

  • @jamischlafer7804
    @jamischlafer7804 2 месяца назад +3

    Direct import is key: set it, review 5 minutes daily, then forget it. The iphone widget makes it so easy to check before buying.

    • @girl-wonder-here
      @girl-wonder-here 2 месяца назад

      I had no idea there was a widget! Thanks for sharing

  • @mistygood7202
    @mistygood7202 2 месяца назад

    This video was so wonderful and perfect timing to get me back in YNAB! Thank you!

  • @candicewilliams5081
    @candicewilliams5081 Месяц назад

    Needed to hear this today! Thank you.

  • @jordanwilliams9300
    @jordanwilliams9300 2 месяца назад +2

    What a great episode!

  • @drloveslearning4744
    @drloveslearning4744 2 месяца назад +1

    I also find vacations are when I tend to drift away from my normal use of YNAB, though outside of that I use it quite methodically - interesting to find out that I'm not the only one to experience the occasional drift - as someone else noted, when I'm on vacation there are a lot more transactions and it can feel overwhelming.

  • @MT-hk9cp
    @MT-hk9cp 2 месяца назад +3

    This pops up while for the past several days of file importing, reconciling months of transactions

  • @NameGoesHere-rw4ji
    @NameGoesHere-rw4ji 2 месяца назад +1

    I absolutely love how much YNAB has helped my family, but most of all - I love pronouncing it to my wife as "YaN-Bee" :D

  • @jordanwiebe7309
    @jordanwiebe7309 Месяц назад

    Loved the Butter & Margarine Joke!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  Месяц назад

      Hahahahahahaha... thank you 🤦🏻‍♀️🧈
      🌻 Hannah

  • @p-j-y-d
    @p-j-y-d 2 месяца назад +3

    My "solution" to vacations budget indiscipline (when it happens, and probably when it will happen) is doing a huge Balance Reconciliation (my bank accounts know better). No manual or automatic transactions entering. Just the big number to reconciliate. And assigning that to Vacations category. No one will take away what you've enjoyed during that period. Move on, and keep budgeting as usual. No fresh start needed. After that, "Reflect" reports will be your friend, giving you insights for better budgeting in the future.

  • @isaohara-screencasts
    @isaohara-screencasts Месяц назад

    Caroline! Yes!! The Cobbler's kids have no shoes! As an IT person - I completely avoided the computer when I would get home. (Back in the days when people went to an office to work)

  • @gabriellejoyce1415
    @gabriellejoyce1415 2 месяца назад

    So moving, bringing me back to the light! 💡

  • @anditippie5923
    @anditippie5923 2 месяца назад

    😭 the kindness and compassion of YNAB touches my soul and heals my financial trauma. Thank you!🥰😍💕

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      🥹 Well if this didn't just make our day 🥰
      🌻 Hannah

  • @gpslentz
    @gpslentz 2 месяца назад

    Thank you, thank you, thank you! This video made my day.

  • @ASan512
    @ASan512 2 месяца назад +1

    Oh man, I've been diligent about using YNAB for about a year and half now. I overspend almost every month, but I never stopped using it. I wonder what it'll do to me when I do fall off. I'm YNAB broke every month and if I ever feel like I suddenly have 2 months worth of funds to spend however I want....well, I'd rather not think too hard on it.

  • @JK13A
    @JK13A Месяц назад

    When I first started I had to start over I think 3 times before I figured out how YNAB works. For now I haven't needed to for almost 1.5 years.

  • @chopstickhero
    @chopstickhero 2 месяца назад +1

    it's nice to hear "there's no perfect budget."

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      Amen! We're all just doin' our best!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @carolynw2747
    @carolynw2747 Месяц назад

    This was so helpful. I had to straighten out my mother's budget and mine fell apart. I am coming back today.

  • @UnknownUser12396
    @UnknownUser12396 2 месяца назад

    Loved this one!

  • @George0lavaillance
    @George0lavaillance Месяц назад

    Thanks you so much for this video.

  • @jennpatterson8802
    @jennpatterson8802 2 месяца назад +1

    This video was amazing

  • @stanislavasrbova7017
    @stanislavasrbova7017 Месяц назад

    I keep falling off the wagon every year at the same time, during a season when I am extremely busy at work (my business fluctuates with seasons very much). There is always a two-month period, when I just can't keep on top of transactions, and after it passes, it's too many transactions to get back on track and reconcile. Unfortunately, there is not automatic import of transactions for me (different country). I assume that would help a lot.

  • @hollygordon1693
    @hollygordon1693 Месяц назад

    Exceptional video! ❤

  • @danwilliams582
    @danwilliams582 2 месяца назад +2

    I would like to use the moble app to enter purchases as I make them but I don't. I think because entering via my phone isn't as easy as it is at my pc keyboard. With AI becoming so good at so many things, has the YNAB developers taken a look at the possiblity of using AI to "look" at paper receipts that get when I purchase most things, and having the YNAB app examine the receipt and process it for me? I suspect that it would take some "training" so that the AI would recognize where the important information is on each receipt and a bit more difficult would be recognizing where the expense or expenses "go" in my categories. Please give it some consideration as if YNAB could make it work, or work reasonably well enough, it would make keeping up with entering purchases so much easier! Oh, I would be glad to be a "beta tester".

  • @chelliebellie4443
    @chelliebellie4443 Месяц назад

    Gteat video, im new to ynab, but not new to trying (and failing) to stay on budgeting (well, actually just tracking where my money goes). Thsnk you ynab team!

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  Месяц назад

      You got this, friend!! It's all about flexibility and remembering to ask yourself "what does this money NEED to do before I get paid again?" That may change from day to day, week to week, month to month, but always keeping our most recent priorities in sight is what keeps our spending plan alive and serving us well!! You got this!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @deborahrives1184
    @deborahrives1184 2 месяца назад

    Great episode!

  • @AnaTirolese
    @AnaTirolese Месяц назад

    Does YNAB only hire attractive people? Wow. What a good-looking bunch! Wait! Is that all I got out of this video?! No. It was really good to see that I am not alone. Thank you. I mostly am on the wagon but now and again the brat in me refuses to be on a routine and goes nuts spending, then regretting the spending, and gets back on the wagon. Again, thank you.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  Месяц назад

      😂 Maybe we all glow-up once we start working here?! 😅 You are not alone, Ana!! Glad this video hit at the right time for you!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @acf3727
    @acf3727 2 месяца назад

    That was awesome 👏 🎉

  • @andrewpierce6137
    @andrewpierce6137 2 месяца назад +1

    Are those discs on the wall?! I wonder what overlap there is between YNAB and the best cheap sport on the planet

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +2

      They ARE discs on the wall and the overlap is my husband 😂😂
      🌻 Hannah

  • @ForrestNovak
    @ForrestNovak 2 месяца назад +1

    You've got every right
    To a beautiful life
    Come on
    Who says, who says you're not perfect?
    Who says you're not worth it?
    Who says you're the only one that's hurting?
    Trust me, that's the price of beauty- Selena Gomez & the Scene Who Says

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад

      Selena sang a song about being gracious with your YNABing habit?! What a gem, we knew we liked her.
      🌻 Hannah

  • @NightwindArcher
    @NightwindArcher 2 месяца назад +3

    My broke ass needed this.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      😂 Don't we all!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @yam1212
    @yam1212 2 месяца назад +3

    I only saw the first two seconds but Hannah pod???

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      😂😂 Nope, just branchin' out!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @blessedwhitney
    @blessedwhitney 16 дней назад

    I definitely felt like Sarah in that direct imports felt like cheating. But when I had kids (third on the way) I realized that... for some it's really essential. Even if it is cheating (it's not), if it's going to keep you from ynabbing at all, you just need to do it.

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  14 дней назад

      It's absolutely not cheating! The REAL work is categorizing, which you still have to do with DI, even if it's just approving the pre-categorized transaction. There's not as *long* of a touchpoint as when you enter transactions manually, but it's certainly still there, and it can still create all the awareness you need to stay informed with where your categories are at! Do DI on 💪🏻 No shame in the DI game!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @lisaroper421
    @lisaroper421 2 месяца назад +4

    Comment for the algorithm!

  • @ravenclawrebel89
    @ravenclawrebel89 2 месяца назад +6

    Persistence at whatever level that you’re at compounds over time.” 🤌🏻🤯

    • @YNABofficial
      @YNABofficial  2 месяца назад +1

      YES!! Isn't Caroline a gem?! Love her!
      🌻 Hannah

  • @benmcintyre9490
    @benmcintyre9490 2 месяца назад +2

    "I'm going to forgive myself for what I didn't do, and I'm just going to start." 🔥🔥🔥