ויכוח הרמב"ן מול הכנסייה הקתולית משנת 1263 מ-ר-ת-ק!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 май 2024
- Help us combat aggressive Jewish evangelism in Israel: outreachjudaism.org/partners/
Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudaism.org/shop/lets...
outreachjudaism.org/
www.videvo.net
/ @rak_emet הרשמו לערוץ חדש נגד המיסיון
Music: www.purple-planet.com
www.toviasinger.tv/
#toviasinger #Judaism #Christianity #Messiah
I saw this movie like a month ago by a friend of mine who found it and send it to me, and it's amazing. I Recommend to see till the end, may Hashem be with you all Jews and Bnei Noach of the world and guide us to a better way of living with the true Messiah, amén. Much love from Puerto Rico.
*this is a great movie, specially for me, because im a jew south european descent, remember jwws are from syiria, morroco, spain, portugal, and some persians re Sephardic some of the ancestry were not affiliated to sefarditas(sephardics) but independent as my ancestors.and chow can i get this movie and use it also?
Jews with 613 mitsvot and Bnei Noach with 7 mitsvot
613+7 equals 620 which is numerical value of Keter
That's the way to combat antisemitism and bring el Rey Mesiyas
@@JapaChabad actually Bnei Noach have more than 60 mitsvots, not only 7. The Bnei Noach mitsvots are more, the 7 Bnei Noach mistvots arejust a more simple way to reffer to all the other mitsvots. And every person need to know that.
@@rafaelmartinez3226 yes sir, plus Bnei Noach can fulfill almost all commandments that one desires, with some exceptions (such as tefilin and shomer shabat) which are exclusively Jewish mitsvot.
@@JapaChabad If a Gentile observes any of the Jewish commandments from the Torah as a religious obligation (even if he does so from a desire to receive a spiritual reward), this is forbidden based on the prohibition of adding a commandment, and there is no spiritual reward to be derived from this.
כמה שהסרט הזה חיזק לי את האמונה. אין מילים לתאר. הדמעות היו לי בעניים. ממש דמעות של גאווה להיות לעם הנבחר המושפל והגאה.
אשריך, אחי ריגשת אותי
Ive seen this several times. I recommend it often. Glad I can now point people to Rabbi Singers channel when I do
חזק וברוך🙌
תודה רבה הרב טוביה על שהעלת את הסרט הזה.
אני לא אדם דתי, אבל עדיין נהנתי ממנו מאוד.
וגם החכמתי ממנו לא מעט :)
Rabbi trovia is a coward who can condemn what happen onoct 7
מדהים. מי כעמך ישראל גוי 1 בארץ. אשרינו.
Thank you Rabbi Tovia…so enlightening to hear of the Spanish Inquisition & the history behind Ramban - excellent!!
Thanks!
Todah raba! I am ever so grateful that you added the Hebrew translation and quotations to this already awesome movie. Watching on repeat and learning...
What an AMAZING person the Ramban was..
unbelievable
@Steve-lb6mo Why? Because he denies idolatry?
Be careful, remember Genesis 12:3, "I will bless those who bless you (as in bless the children of Israel), and I will curse those who curse you; And in you, all the families of the earth shall be blessed"@Steve-lb6mo
@Steve-lb6mo
Because what he said makes you uncomfortable?
@@RAK_EMETHe was GIANT in knowledge
@@RAK_EMET Yes. That. And because he put his life in danger for the truth and the Jewish people.
A very good movie. Thank you for sharing!
The Ramban was amazing. Every so-called "messianic Jew" and every "Christian" needs to heed the words and feel the energy of the Ramban. Baruch HaShem
Ramdam was a false prophet who never borned agai. In Christ.
@@ngonoeugene3817Judaism cannot be false and Christianity cannot be true.
Just a statement and nothing else. Judaism sinaic laws have been true during 1500 years till the great day of Pentecost. They are now over. True Christianity is on since then. Any priest or rabbi who teaches those laws today is false. Any person who believe today in it is out of the topic, out of God's salvation. Rejecting Jesus produces a lot of problems and will continue to produce them : shoah, pogroms etc...
Many see physical reasons, but the main is spiritual : selfish towards God by the rejection of his Messiah, Jesus-Christ, our common Savior. This is hard to believe. But it is the truth. May God touch hearts ! ! !
@@ngonoeugene3817
No Jew including Ramban EVER claimed him to be a prophet. If he or any Jew did, that would be a great sin. He is a great teacher and a learned person.
He is wise and far too successful in far too many subjects. But he is not a prophet and he didn't give any prophecies nor did he claim to have.
Neither was Jesus a prophet nor a Messiah nor God.
Like the comment above me said...
If Christianity is true, then Judaism is true.
If Judaism is true, Christianity is false.
All those who wrote in the Bible about Jesus were Jew prophets. Himself is not God, but his Son. He is the unique Messia of the kingsdom of God, ben Yosef and ben David. He is te greatest prophet of God, even above Moses. Those are truths to believe for salvation, instead of repeting vain statements that will condamed you eternaly. The person who is speaking to you is God's prophet.
Thank you Rabbi Singer
תודה שחלקתם. סרט מצוין, מרגש ומאוד מעניין
Marvellously executed bringing to life our legendary Ramban . Thanks so much for this production.
אשריינו שזכינו להיות יהודים איזה זכות יש לנו תודה להשם יתברךך
Thank you Rabbi Tovia for sharing an illustrated way to understand better the historical events. I follow your teachings that have been helpful in my personal connection with The Creator. 💙🇮🇱🕊️🫂🇵🇪🇺🇲
Thank you, Rabbi Singer. I look forward to anything you post.
Very insightful video & excellent valid points of arguments! which came to a very resounding conclusion. thanks for sharing left a like on the video 📚
What a gem is this movie! Thanks for posting it!
thanks Rabbi for uploading this
This great debate should've been done in Spanish because all of this took place in Spain!
Todah Rabba!
Todah Rabah
THANKS, TOVIA! aweswome AND INSPIRING
תודה רבי
מעולה,פשוט מעולה,חייבת להראות למשפחה,תודה רבה❤
This was a great film
Thank you Rabbi Singer. So nice to hear the history behind the Rambam.
RambaN the rambam was a different rabbi
@@yechielblack9245 Thanks for the correction.
Rambam was Mimonydis
What an inspirational film.
Thank you and bless you and your family and all jews.
Baruch Hashem!!
Am Israel chai❤
בשקיקה עיניי חזו במעללי רמב"ן, נפלא לדעת מהיכן הגיע הטלאי ליהודים בצרפת, שכוייח טוביה ותודה.❤
It's nice that intelligence was part of such debates with Jews. "Lions vs mouse" Then The Jewish Faith must be mighty as a 🦁 lion in connection but christians of no connection to strength.
Blessed be The God of Jewish Faith Hashem ✡️.
Amen! ✡️❤️
@yvonnegordon1952 I see no point in what you're trying to say. I'm not a christian. If you exclude intelligence as part of religion and faith, then the jesus religion you speak of is senseless. NOTE THAT THE SO-CALLED knosis thing of jesus worship by blood drinking, saying that it defies logic, makes it even more idolatry.
When you so blindly remain loyal to jesus beyond good reason and logic and intelligence, then there are NO GOOD words for it.
Your belief has nothing to do with anything good at all. When all debates are heard, it becomes blind loyalty to idolatry by brainwashing, not faith.
You will over and over defend jesus without good reason to do so. That is insanity. Calling you insane is practically accurate.
@yvonnegordon1952 Go and ask a Rabbi a Rabbi how to get law into your heart not wreck like me(Not even Jew yet and not even a nice person) that's not your friend. That's a progress question you ask when you seek KNOWLEDGE!!! Instead of bashing Jews that try to help you. You shouldn't ask a bad guy like me.
@@yvonnegordon1952you want to HEAR Hashem today?
His mitzvot are not in heaven, nor over the sea. They are in Chumash.
If you do not understand or disagree with how those mitzvot are to be interpreted or applied you are REQUIRED to obey the rulings of the Jewish courts as recorded in Talmud.
Therefore no one has any need to hear your opinion, your ideas, your assertions, rather you need to make yourself humble and with the fear of Hashem seek wisdom from your local orthodox rabbi.
If you have to impose rules on the opponent that favor yourself, that means you're losing and/or afraid to lose.
👏👏👏❤️
May Hashem end this idolatry✝️ soon...May God guide everyone to the truth...✡❤
B’H
@buitienanhdung
So he quoted Deuteronomy?
So what? 🤷🏼♂️
😅
@@MosheBenChaim the Lord thy God is one
But everyone cannot be Jewish
@@kyleauthman All Gentiles have to keep the 7 Noahide laws.
Absolutely fabulous ❤
I started following you and listening to you a week ago! Brought up in Christianity! Thank you so much for reaching me and spreading the truth! 😢🤍
❤❤
Excellent video
Thank you Rabbi for posting this...
סרט מדהים
מי שרוצה לקרוא את הוויכוח המקורי ,זה נמצא בכתבי הרמבן בשם "הויכוח"
Imagine... THE CAESAR' MESSIAH THESIS
Exposed and widely circulated at that time..
Wow!!!
@Steve-lb6mo Ehhhhhhh.....
What's up Doc? 🥕🥕🥕🐰🐰🐰
@Steve-lb6mo You can’t fool people anymore.
*_The central thesis of Caesar's Messiah is that the Gospels of the Bible were written -- and the character of Jesus Christ was created -- by Roman intellectuals under the direction of Caesar Titus Flavius primarily with the intention of domesticating the Messianic Jewish movements which were resisting Roman occupation_*
@Steve-lb6mo your false religion fooled people LONG ENOUGH
The beauty in our time is that there is no need to argue with the crusaders. The very return of the Israelis to the land of their forefathers is on the one hand the fulfillment of the prophecies of the Bible (what they call the "Old Testament") and on the other hand a complete refutation of the so-called "New Testament" according to which as long as the Israelis refusing convert to Christianity they will not have a redemption. The establishment of a Jewish state In the Land of Israel, with Jerusalem as its capital, it is actually a total collapse of Christianity
Unless you live in a rock, you should realize that Israel is facing huge violence and instability from all sides. That is NOT REDEMPTION
@@TarunKumar-sp2ls
And yet, the Jewish people remain, despite all the violence that surrounds them and all the idolators who try to convert them to falsehood.
Who wants to hear the ramban dubed in Hebrew by Ha'Rav Tovia Singer
It would be too weird hearing the Ramban speak with an American accent and Ashkenazi pronunciation 😀
This is perhaps the most important video that every Christian needs to see and consider. When you watch and listen 👂🏻 to it ALL, you will not remain Christian.
🎉🎉❤🎉🎉
תודה רבה
Excellent performance by Alan Dobie (still alive) & Christopher Lee (r.i.p) I guess my biggest question is, "If King James wanted to convert, whom would he want to give his life to?"
My Father translated The debate to Russian
where is it?
Yes, I’ve read it many years ago. It’s an excellent translation.
Would you know where I could find it?
thank you rabbi
Wow. Amazing such a film existed. It is incredible we are still having the same discussions with the same points today.
Why were we always a threat to them?
Because they inherently KNEW that we would eventually out them and their false created god man hoax.
@Steve-lb6mo You worship a “god-man.”
And it sure IS Jesus!
SAD
VERY SAD
My friend, do remember that the "threat" started with Saul of Tarsus (a Roman from what is now Turkey) and his followers. Saul's letters e.g. epistle to the Galatians, were full of hatred towards Jews- understandably, since Saul's purpose for writing the epistles was typically Roman. It was a a calculated attack to destroy Judaism (and therefore Israel) from within. Do not forget that Saul's epistles reached their popular status about the same time as the war with Rome accelerated and as the Temple was destroyed. The epistle to the Hebrews and the Book of Revelation clinched it. The epistle to the Hebrews is chock-a-block full of Christian superiority, full of hatred towards the Jews. The Book of Revelation describes Judaism as "the synagogue of Satan".
A medieval clergyman had no real knowledge of the fact that Christianity was invented and popularized by the (pagan) Romans. Remember that Bibles were hand-copied and extremely rare at that time. They were written in Latin as a rule. And so most clergymen had a very limited knowledge of what the Bible actually says- they were given only certain, permitted parts to read. The common man had absolutely no idea what was said at the mass since the mass was always said in Latin. The people followed what they had been told and it could be summed up into: ora et labora (pray and work), do what you are told and DON'T ask any questions!...or you will be thrown into an oubliette or an iron maiden.
It took many centuries before people could read the complete writings, gospels and epistles and started to question Roman Catholicism (they were burned at the stake for it too)...and it took many centuries for the people- who didn't know any better- to realise just how many lies they had been told.
I was brought up in a non-religious family but in a strongly Catholic country (I moved overseas 15 years ago). When I visited the country last year (after 9 years pause), I felt an immense pity for the people. Because they live exactly the same way as the peasants in the medieval times: they do what they are told by the priest but have never held the Tanakh in their hands (they are handed a prescribed hymn and rosary book only). If you ask them basic questions from the Torah, they have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. They may have heard that there was a prophet called Isaiah but they have never read his prophecies. The Church simply tells them what to think...and since they don't know how to do any better, they do as they are told. No questions asked. And so, when they are told to hate the Jews- they do not ask why. They simply obey. It's a heart-breaking situation.
Very important film beautiful 😊💯
Wow!
סרט מעולה
מעולה
🙏🏽✡️🧿
וואוו
גאון עצום
❤
Wait I think we should give credit to King James I of Aragon, seems like a really honorable man. He could have easily walked back his word to Nachmanides and killed him for his "heresy". I see him as a good man in this amazing story.
It is my belief, that much of the turmoil in the world that exists today would cease to exist, if Christianity admitted its flaws.
Phenomenal film. Who put this out and when was it produced?
40:33
His face is like - Shouldn't have said that, I should not have said that
Is this from a movie? this stuff is gold.
theres a whole genre of these collected in the book polemics and disputations, JD eisenstein, NY 1921.
what is this movie?
מקור:
The Disputation (1986)
סרט טלוויזיה לערוץ 4 הבריטי.
מבוסס על המחזה של חיים מקובי.
wish the movie was much longer
It's a slow burn of a film, but the dialogue is fun,
Hahaha...what a great clip.
What is the name of this movie?
בין החסידות לנצרות יש דימיון חזק אשמח עם הרב יוכל להתייחס לזה
*this is a great movie, specially for me, because im a jew south european descent, remember jwws are from syiria, morroco, spain, portugal, and some persians re Sephardic some of the ancestry were not affiliated to sefarditas(sephardics) but independent as my ancestors.and chow can i get this movie and use it also?
Wow they should remake this !
There’s no way King James would have known Jesus being born on September 11, 3 BC.
16:27 the disputation.
Listening to this as the world praises Hamas and the other Islamists is deeply worrying. When will we learn?
What concerns me is that there are certain individuals that are held up and venerated as if they’re semi-saviors. This can easily cross the lines into idolatry.
Jews are commanded to honor those who teach and know Torah in Leviticus 19:32.
The only good that came from this disputation is from our perspective today.
Whoever it was that played the Nachmanides character in the film did a fantastic job, and certainly more accurate portrayal of a sage than for instance in a Mel gibberish film
indeed. And luckily for us, Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman wrote fast, so they couldn't stop him
I like to correct the name in the text 28:57 it is ישוע as based on historical scriptures Pershitta Mattityahu 1:1
כּתָבָא דִּילִידֻותֶה דּיֶשֻוע משִיחָא בַּרֶה דּדַוִיד בַּרֶה דַּאברָהָם ׃
and also in New Testament (Brit Chadasha) Hebrew translation:
:ספר תולדת ישוע המשיח בן דוד בן אברהם
I didn’t know there were cameras back then
🍎🌋🦖
How much of this is creative licensing?
Doesn't Walter mention ramban in big lebowski?
Cross vs ✡️ Faith, seems like worshipping and idolizing a decaying carcass crucified on a cross vs a mountain ⛰️ of greatness and endless unfinished discription.
If jesus is messiah then a vain self-obsessed body eating and drinking celebrity is worthy of praize. That is a disgusting messiah type. Also that jesus was labeled as king without achieving good and deceitfully achieving evil.
VS
A messiah that would actually change reality end spiritual babalon without wanting to be declared God. ✡️ That seems more like my kind of excellent. The bad label and disapear is fine, 🤴 ship is men.
Blessed be The God of Jewish Faith Hashem ✡️.
@Steve-lb6mo: You need to realize, research, and accept, that NOWHERE did God ever mention the "Jesus" character to us, NOWHERE did He tell us that we need to be "saved", and NOWHERE did He tell us that He requires HUMAN BLOOD (a purely pagan ritual that God ABHORS!!) as atonement for our sins.
NO FURTHER SCRIPTURES were given to mankind by God AFTER Mt. Sinai, therefore, Christianity absolutely did NOT come from God!
PLEASE buy a Hebrew Bible (says "Stone Edition TANACH" on the cover), and Rabbi Tovia Singer's books, as well as Rabbi Stuart Federow's book "Judaism and Christianity: A Contrast", to help you understand why Christianity absolutely did NOT come from God.
@Steve-lb6mo erm... If you call christianity faith, then your standards are too low. To believe in salvation by human sacrifice, then that stupidity is blind.
@Steve-lb6mo You call me blind. I say you are blind.
ראיתי את זה לפני 30 שנה כמעט
Whats the title of the movie for all those who cant read Hebrew 🤷
Was posted on this channel without hebrew subtitles not long ago.
צריך לראות מה אלוהים אומר ושום דת לא מייצגת את אלוהים כי עם רק את עצמה ואת חכמיה הגדולים מאלוהים ממש כמוך הרב הגאון
עכשיו סוף סוף אני מבין מה המשמעות של רב שזה פשוט לריב עם אלוהים
אחי מה אתה רוצה???? צריך לראות מה אלוקים אומר, אז אתה יכול להיות חילוני ולחשוב מה אלוקים רוצה ממך (לייצג את אלוקים) או להיות דתי ולהאמין שהדת מביאה לך את דבריו של אלוקים, ורב אמור להביא לך את זה בצורה ברורה כי הוא ישב ולמד את זה, והם מסרו את זה מדור לדור, רק חשוב לראות שהרב אדם עם כבוד ולא מחרטט אותך ואומר מה שבא לו. לכן יש שאלות.
@@user-ml1xs1kl2j זאת דוגמא אתה קורה לו אלוקים בגלל שהרבנים לימדו אותך כך וזה ממש כאילו מנסים לעבוד עליו
בדיוק כמו שלישוע קוראים ישו והעין שחסרה לא רואה את אלוהים ממטר
גם אני יכול להקליט עם האייפון את המסך טלויזיה שלי בערוץ המדע הבדיוני
שיראו את הסרט בטלויזיה
Pongan porfavor subtituloa en español.
Nos seria de mucha ayuda.
Shalom
RUclips is now even throwing ads on none ad videos and extending the normal ads.
Time to root my TV and get rid of them.
Yeah you're right. I don't pay attention to those ads and I skip them every time. Don't let them stop my learning.
למה שנוצרים יעשו סרט כזה שסותר את עצמם? מי הפיק את הסרט הזה? כבר מגיל 5 קראתי את הספר הזה בבית של ההורים שלי
נוצרים לא עשו את הסרט הזה..
מי שעשה אותו רק עשה אותו בסגנון נוצרי כי העלילה מתרחשת בספרד הנוצרית- חרדית.
מה שם המקור?
the disputation
Is this a re-enactment of a real debate?
As mentioned in the movie, the ramban had to write a documentation of the debate and spread it because the church has been spreading a false accounting of the disputation to try to convert jews. I guess this movie is based on the account written by the ramban at the time, I know we still have a copy of it, but I don't know to what degree this movie followed the account written by the ramban and what is just creative freedom by the script writer since I haven't read the account of the ramban.
כן. הויכוח המקורי נמצא בספרים שנקראים "כתבי הרמבן"
Who plays the king
Apparently the same man who played in Lord of the rings as that character I forgot the name of...
Christopher lee
לא הבנתי מאיזה סרט לקחו הקטע הזה? מה שם הסרט???
זה סרט על וויכוח הרמב"ן משנת 1623 עם הכנסייה. יש גם ספר כזה.
הסרט נקרא באנגלית: the disputation
@@RAK_EMET
תודה רבה! (:
The god of israel gave us the jews the most wonderfull leadres our belived rabbis to guide us with wisdom and love until the messiah would come .
No wonder the gentils are in grif they dont have such a gift , they are waiting in vain for their jewish messiah ,we know that our beloved rabbis with tge grace of god would asher the arrival of our true jewish messiah blessed the nation that have such graces of god no one but the jews.
Noahides have rabbis.
Sorry didnt mean to offend our beloved nohaid
But the men inside reached out and pulled Lot back into the house and shut the door. Then they struck the men who were at the door of the house, young and old, with blindness so that they could not find the door. The two men said to Lot, “Do you have anyone else here-sons-in-law, sons or daughters, or anyone else in the city who belongs to you? Get them out of here,. Genesis 19:10-12 very complicated verses.
Rabbi Singer, we ❤U! Thank you for dedicating your life to discussing Yeshua! He is the most popular Jewish Rabbi of all history.
We don't even have a source for him being a Rabbi
Actually Rabbi Manis Friedman is the most popular