Canticle gave me anxiety from start to finish but man what an adrenaline-inducing story of action, magic, and heart! Great video breakdown as usual, Jason!
I can't decide whether I think Canticle is a battery for a weapon or a cradle for forming new shard-like beings(or revive splintered ones). perhaps both and canticle is a battery/solar panel for the grand apparatus that is the cradle
Invention might be building these megastructures. Hoid seems to have trouble locating her so she probably doesn't reside on a single planet. Maybe she is busy building stuff like the grand appartus and canticle.
What I like the most about Canticle society is that it’s one that could only exist in the Space Age Cosmere. Could you imagine threnodites trying to outrun the sun with handcarts??
Everyone's out here asking "what is the grand apparatus" and I'm over here thinking about Canticle's possible sentience and WHO is the grand apparatus. Feels like a typical Brandon script flip.
you should have like turned up the brightness very slowly throughout the video, giving the effect of the sun slowly approaching, then at the end it being super bright.
I wanted to add, as someone who studied astronomy and physics in college, rings actually could potentially exist around a planetoid as small as canticle, especially given its high gravity. There are several asteroids, such as 10199 Chariklo, as well as a a couple dwarf planets, with ring systems. The asteroids are even smaller than canticle, at least by radius. There is also a strong possibility that the Earth has had rings at some points in its history (main one would be after the impact that created the moon, although there has been theories about possible other times), and Mars will eventually have a ring system because of its moons having decaying orbits that will eventually lead to them breaking up into rings. The big thing though, is that rings are inherently unstable, and the longest lasting rings are ones with small moons inside them that help maintain them through gravitational interactions. That being said, the cosmere as a whole, at least since the shattering, is young enough that a ring system around a body the size of canticle probably would be stable for a large portion of its history. Timescales for astronomy are typically on the scale of millions or billions of years, so 10 to 20 thousand years is a tiny blip in time on that scale
@@auroraourania7161 Would you happen to know how many moons or how big a single moon would have to be in order for a gas giant to maintain rings? Asking due to an ongoing world building project. Any elaboration would be helpful
I don't think the Thaylen sunheart had no Investiture... I think it was much smaller, had very little, and couldn't be used to power anything because it wasn't Connected to Canticle. They've said that you can't put Investiture into a completely empty sunheart, so Zellion's trick wouldn't have worked if it had been completely dead, I believe.
It has been over a year since the sunlit man came out and its really a shame how little of the details I remember. Yumi and this are the only cosmere books I haven't read at least twice and there is not really time for me to reread it before WaT comes out next week for I am still finishing up my reread of RoW before then
So, does a threnodite shade’s capacity for intelligence depend on their proximity to “The Evil” when they died? What I mean is those who died on Threnody are essentially mindless while those who died on Canticle can think, speak, and create. We’ve seen even more shades that are even more capable beyond that so as to retain their whole identity (SP5).
@@nwnate659 I was going to initially say that we'd need more data on shades on other worlds to be certain. But what other examples do we have? Threnody from The Forests of Hell, Canticle in The Sunlit Man. But I'm struggling to find another example. We did hear about a shade being mentioned in Scadrial broadsheets but not a lot of details there. Am I forgetting another book/ source of information?
@ at the end of Sunlit Man we got a glimpse on board the Night Brigade’s ship and there the captain had shades in the crew. Then in a special preview of Secret Project 5, we learn a Threnodite character we already know has passed away leaving a shade with full self awareness and a perfect sense of identity. A perfect cognitive shadow a la Secret History (Sorry for the ambiguity, trying to keep this spoiler free just in case someone stumbles on these comments in a few years)
Oh dang! So with the knowledge that sunhearts can be recharged, will people stop offering themselves to the sun? How soon will the planet be overrun with Shades?
I’m not sure. Maybe they’ll continue to sacrifice their sick and dying because the chorus says they should. Rebeke seemed to like the idea of not needing to sacrifice people anymore though
@@jasonioan Sorry to break the immersion for a moment, but people IRL choose to terminate to prevent their own suffering. Outside of the fact that the dying probably would to do that to ease their own suffering, most caring people would probably give themselves over to prevent the shade from terrorizing those that they love. This just stops the barbaric practice of having to maintain a level of sacrifices of healthy individuals in order to maintain sunhearts.
hmm I suspect either canticle is an engine of some kind that stores investiture to do something later or maybe more likely its some sort of investiture trap designed for something or someone highly invested.
If it's effectively collecting and condensing investiture in 1 spot. It could be an attempt to create a Shard or Dawnshard. Is there a stage after a perpendicularity? Or with the comparison to circuits, it could be part of a cosmere scale "circuit."
Me too. Having been to both now I felt more unsafe on Threnody than I did on canticle. With modern tech, and my Windrunner friend there with me, I wasn’t worried about getting stuck in the sunlight. On Threnody it felt like there was nothing I could to expect hope my copper cloud would hide me.
@ Haha. Maybe get a bronze earning for that extra power. Anyways next week Wind & Truth will come out and I honestly can’t wait for your analysis on that. This is actually the best channel I’ve stumbled across regarding everything Cosmere. Your talent & dedication and to this series is inspiring brother. Maybe in a few years cosmere is gonna hit the mainstream and then this channel will be one of the front runners for the future.
Quite simple really. The planet gets a lot of rain and the highlands get cold really quickly due to the thin atmosphere! Nomad even encounters some in chapter 28!
Someone’s just waiting for the right moment to drain that sucker haha. I think invention is a really good bet, but the question remains as to WHY it was built.
@@asdrubalvect6328 I agree that Canticle was most likely built by Invention. But an equally interesting question is: Who made the Invested Star, and why?
I know you weren't able to travel to the actual planet for this video, but I do have to say, I would have preferred your studie at silverlight over this flat lightweaving you put in the background. How did you do that anyway? Managed to bond a Cryptic during one of your travels to Roshar or were you able to find an other for of lightweaving in the cosmere as it is mentioned existing. (Even though this looks quite Yollish in my opinion and the Rosharen version is set to be most close to that)
Considering the Scadrians monitoring and studying the planet from their hidden bases, I’m wondering if Kelsier or Sazed had something to do with the building of Canticle
Interesting. I hadn’t considered that because to me it reads more like they’re trying to figure out how it works too, but I suppose they could be monitoring it for that reason
I don’t think we know if the original Zellion was a native to Threnody, so someone from Scadrial could have at least had a hand in bringing people to Canticle
Props for not reading the sacramental prayer. It's open for the public anyone can take part and hear it no problem but it's not supposed to be recorded for most circumstances. Good job respecting it.
The video didn’t call for it. Besides, I would’ve just read D&C 20:79 which would’ve been fine. Seems kinda silly to me that there’s a distinction between it being okay to read the prayer from D&C and not okay to record the publicly available ordinance, but I’m sure they’ve got their reasons. Anyway, I did put thought into it and I’m glad you appreciated it.
@jasonioan it is strange. That's religion though haha. I just appreciate the respect. No matter what religion or views anyone has it should be respected. Great video! Hopefully I can say hi at Dragonsteel!
Bummer! Maybe next year? (Although idk if next year will be as big) If Canticle is one of Cephandrius’s ex’s, they must by trying to fill the hole in their heart with investiture
I don't think Harmony in his current form would have the capability to act in such a way as to create an entirely new planet. Although, Harmony is said to be changing...
I feel like the creator might be Invention, especially with the mention of the Grand Apparatus.
Just finished reading the Sunlit Man, in preparation for Wind and Truth, its become one of my favorite Sanderson books.
It is a good one. The amount of cosmere connections in it is crazy!
@@jasonioan I love looking at things like the conversation with Hoid and trying to figure out everything I can about the future of the Cosmere.
HYPED FOR THIS MAN'S PANEL AT DRAGONSTEEL!!
Hope to see you there!!!
@jasonioan if you don't see me, you'll need to get your eyes checked
Oh man, I didn't know he had a panel at Dragonsteel! That's super cool and absolutely well deserved!
Canticle gave me anxiety from start to finish but man what an adrenaline-inducing story of action, magic, and heart! Great video breakdown as usual, Jason!
Thank you!
I can't decide whether I think Canticle is a battery for a weapon or a cradle for forming new shard-like beings(or revive splintered ones).
perhaps both and canticle is a battery/solar panel for the grand apparatus that is the cradle
Invention might be building these megastructures. Hoid seems to have trouble locating her so she probably doesn't reside on a single planet. Maybe she is busy building stuff like the grand appartus and canticle.
What I like the most about Canticle society is that it’s one that could only exist in the Space Age Cosmere. Could you imagine threnodites trying to outrun the sun with handcarts??
Thank you so much for your channel. I can't tell you how much I look forward to seeing how you break down all things Cosmere.
Love the snow slowly melting in the background of the video. Seems like an awesome place to film!
It really was! Thanks for the help, my friend!
Everyone's out here asking "what is the grand apparatus" and I'm over here thinking about Canticle's possible sentience and WHO is the grand apparatus. Feels like a typical Brandon script flip.
Jasonioan puts put a video i watch it, the best things in life are simple
Sunlit Man was such a fun book to read, great video!
Yes it was!
LAST TIME I WAS THIS EARLY I COULD SEE THE SUN DISAPPEARING AWAY OVER THE HORIZON, RESHAPING THE TERRAIN.
Can’t wait to learn who/what built Canticle
I'm more interested in why
@@dyodelta1182true, and if it has anything to do with the Grand Apparatus
Me too. Is it just a battery? Or is it actively powering something?
Dude your videos are always so high quality, keep up the great work!!
Glad you like them!
you should have like turned up the brightness very slowly throughout the video, giving the effect of the sun slowly approaching, then at the end it being super bright.
YOOO - so glad you did this, Sunlit might be my favourite Cosmere book
Love the content man! Keep up the great work! I know you put a ton of work into these videos.
Thank you!
Wake up babe Jasonioan posted!! thanks king
This yt channel deserves much more views
I wanted to add, as someone who studied astronomy and physics in college, rings actually could potentially exist around a planetoid as small as canticle, especially given its high gravity. There are several asteroids, such as 10199 Chariklo, as well as a a couple dwarf planets, with ring systems. The asteroids are even smaller than canticle, at least by radius. There is also a strong possibility that the Earth has had rings at some points in its history (main one would be after the impact that created the moon, although there has been theories about possible other times), and Mars will eventually have a ring system because of its moons having decaying orbits that will eventually lead to them breaking up into rings.
The big thing though, is that rings are inherently unstable, and the longest lasting rings are ones with small moons inside them that help maintain them through gravitational interactions. That being said, the cosmere as a whole, at least since the shattering, is young enough that a ring system around a body the size of canticle probably would be stable for a large portion of its history. Timescales for astronomy are typically on the scale of millions or billions of years, so 10 to 20 thousand years is a tiny blip in time on that scale
@@auroraourania7161
Would you happen to know how many moons or how big a single moon would have to be in order for a gas giant to maintain rings?
Asking due to an ongoing world building project.
Any elaboration would be helpful
perfect timing! Just finished sunlit man, it has me so stoked for the space age novels that are coming! AND WIND AND TRUTH AAAaaaaaaaaa
The amount of hype coursing through my veins is immeasurable.
Seriously love your content!
Only threnodites would think and look at this planet and say "hey I could live here heh heh"
“Better than literally hell. Let’s go for it!”
Been binging your Cosmere videos! Amazing stuff!
Thank you! I’m glad you’re here and that you’re enjoying the videos! 😁
I don't think the Thaylen sunheart had no Investiture... I think it was much smaller, had very little, and couldn't be used to power anything because it wasn't Connected to Canticle. They've said that you can't put Investiture into a completely empty sunheart, so Zellion's trick wouldn't have worked if it had been completely dead, I believe.
That’s true. I thought it was more of a connection thing but there does have to be a tiny bit of seed investiture
It has been over a year since the sunlit man came out and its really a shame how little of the details I remember. Yumi and this are the only cosmere books I haven't read at least twice and there is not really time for me to reread it before WaT comes out next week for I am still finishing up my reread of RoW before then
So, does a threnodite shade’s capacity for intelligence depend on their proximity to “The Evil” when they died? What I mean is those who died on Threnody are essentially mindless while those who died on Canticle can think, speak, and create. We’ve seen even more shades that are even more capable beyond that so as to retain their whole identity (SP5).
@@nwnate659
I was going to initially say that we'd need more data on shades on other worlds to be certain.
But what other examples do we have?
Threnody from The Forests of Hell, Canticle in The Sunlit Man. But I'm struggling to find another example.
We did hear about a shade being mentioned in Scadrial broadsheets but not a lot of details there.
Am I forgetting another book/ source of information?
@ at the end of Sunlit Man we got a glimpse on board the Night Brigade’s ship and there the captain had shades in the crew. Then in a special preview of Secret Project 5, we learn a Threnodite character we already know has passed away leaving a shade with full self awareness and a perfect sense of identity. A perfect cognitive shadow a la Secret History
(Sorry for the ambiguity, trying to keep this spoiler free just in case someone stumbles on these comments in a few years)
Oh dang! So with the knowledge that sunhearts can be recharged, will people stop offering themselves to the sun? How soon will the planet be overrun with Shades?
I’m not sure. Maybe they’ll continue to sacrifice their sick and dying because the chorus says they should. Rebeke seemed to like the idea of not needing to sacrifice people anymore though
@@jasonioan Sorry to break the immersion for a moment, but people IRL choose to terminate to prevent their own suffering. Outside of the fact that the dying probably would to do that to ease their own suffering, most caring people would probably give themselves over to prevent the shade from terrorizing those that they love. This just stops the barbaric practice of having to maintain a level of sacrifices of healthy individuals in order to maintain sunhearts.
hmm I suspect either canticle is an engine of some kind that stores investiture to do something later or maybe more likely its some sort of investiture trap designed for something or someone highly invested.
👏👏👏
If it's effectively collecting and condensing investiture in 1 spot. It could be an attempt to create a Shard or Dawnshard. Is there a stage after a perpendicularity? Or with the comparison to circuits, it could be part of a cosmere scale "circuit."
I still wanna know what the Evil is on Threnody that made those people leave and actually think Canticle is a better place to live
Me too. Having been to both now I felt more unsafe on Threnody than I did on canticle.
With modern tech, and my Windrunner friend there with me, I wasn’t worried about getting stuck in the sunlight. On Threnody it felt like there was nothing I could to expect hope my copper cloud would hide me.
@ Haha. Maybe get a bronze earning for that extra power.
Anyways next week Wind & Truth will come out and I honestly can’t wait for your analysis on that.
This is actually the best channel I’ve stumbled across regarding everything Cosmere. Your talent & dedication and to this series is inspiring brother. Maybe in a few years cosmere is gonna hit the mainstream and then this channel will be one of the front runners for the future.
How is there snow on Canticle?
that's not snow! its obviously ash!!!
The highest the rains reach would be cold enough to have snow I expect
Quite simple really. The planet gets a lot of rain and the highlands get cold really quickly due to the thin atmosphere! Nomad even encounters some in chapter 28!
My bet is that Canticle was made by Invention.
That or is a really big Unsealed Nicrosilmind.
Someone’s just waiting for the right moment to drain that sucker haha. I think invention is a really good bet, but the question remains as to WHY it was built.
@@asdrubalvect6328
I agree that Canticle was most likely built by Invention.
But an equally interesting question is:
Who made the Invested Star, and why?
RIP to the poor Shin warrior that somehow found his way to Canticle only to turn into a sunheart.
He was a real one 🫡
Nomad is by far my favorite Cosmere character. Only Taln or Jasnah come close.
I know you weren't able to travel to the actual planet for this video, but I do have to say, I would have preferred your studie at silverlight over this flat lightweaving you put in the background.
How did you do that anyway? Managed to bond a Cryptic during one of your travels to Roshar or were you able to find an other for of lightweaving in the cosmere as it is mentioned existing. (Even though this looks quite Yollish in my opinion and the Rosharen version is set to be most close to that)
Considering the Scadrians monitoring and studying the planet from their hidden bases, I’m wondering if Kelsier or Sazed had something to do with the building of Canticle
Interesting. I hadn’t considered that because to me it reads more like they’re trying to figure out how it works too, but I suppose they could be monitoring it for that reason
I don’t think we know if the original Zellion was a native to Threnody, so someone from Scadrial could have at least had a hand in bringing people to Canticle
That’s true. All we know is the name itself is Yolish in origin
My brother in Christ is holding an actual sunheart in this video
Canticle...perhaps homage to the classic a canticle for lebowitz
Props for not reading the sacramental prayer. It's open for the public anyone can take part and hear it no problem but it's not supposed to be recorded for most circumstances. Good job respecting it.
The video didn’t call for it. Besides, I would’ve just read D&C 20:79 which would’ve been fine.
Seems kinda silly to me that there’s a distinction between it being okay to read the prayer from D&C and not okay to record the publicly available ordinance, but I’m sure they’ve got their reasons.
Anyway, I did put thought into it and I’m glad you appreciated it.
@jasonioan it is strange. That's religion though haha. I just appreciate the respect. No matter what religion or views anyone has it should be respected. Great video! Hopefully I can say hi at Dragonsteel!
Soooo maybe the crust of this planet has a high aluminum content. To provide resistance to flow
Eeble beeble
Maybe, someone is trying to become a god.
A mechanical god. This makes my Arcane brain tingle. Such a cool idea!
@@jasonioan It takes a lot of....Ambition.😜
Very sad I chose last year to go to dragonsteel instead of this one. Also Canticle is obviously just one of Cephandrius’ exs
Bummer! Maybe next year? (Although idk if next year will be as big)
If Canticle is one of Cephandrius’s ex’s, they must by trying to fill the hole in their heart with investiture
Could Cantical have been built by Harmony? To study investager?
I don't think Harmony in his current form would have the capability to act in such a way as to create an entirely new planet.
Although, Harmony is said to be changing...
I can see that, but this thought is based on the Scadrian's presence there
Need to read Sunlit man so I can fully appreciate this video
Are you LDS talking about the sacramental prayer? lol