'No climate of fear in Hong Kong' as city marks five years since 2019 protests: Regina Ip

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
  • Hong Kong marks five years since the anti-extradition Bill protests that rocked the city. CNA's Deborah Wong sits down with Convenor of Hong Kong’s Executive Council, Mrs Regina Ip, to discuss what has changed.

Комментарии • 113

  • @JonKino828
    @JonKino828 3 месяца назад +5

    Hong Kong is lucky to have Regina Ip as one of their leaders.

  • @acuantjahyadi7393
    @acuantjahyadi7393 3 месяца назад +4

    CNA alangkah adilnya jika laporan Anda ini disertakan juga cuplikan orang tua yang di bakar hidup hidup dan tanggapan Narasumber dan Anda tentang peristiwa itu dan siapa harus bertangung jawab. ????????
    Apakah anda mendapat pesanan dari NED kasus itu sama sekali tidak boleh di bahas ???????
    JANGAN !!!!!!!?
    MENGHAPUS KOMENTAR SAYA INI !!!!

  • @catinbootsnow4267
    @catinbootsnow4267 3 месяца назад +16

    No more freedom of "separation, subversion, sedition, terror and vandalism" in Hong Kong.
    Nowadays patriotic HKers are living in happy mood while those China-haters in HK are living in depression mood.
    Were Lee Kuan-yew still alive today, he would applaud Hong Kong for maintaining order and pushing reforms.

    • @vincenttay2812
      @vincenttay2812 3 месяца назад +5

      Great security law China. Every country has their own security law some worse than the Hong-Kong. Try breaching the security law in Malaysia and Singapore or even the US and see what will happen.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +3

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @skazka3789
      @skazka3789 3 месяца назад

      ​@@yipzoe3865Freedom of movement, or do you dumbass gazaats oppose that too

    • @vincenttay2812
      @vincenttay2812 3 месяца назад +1

      Spend all their life savings and doing odd jobs in the 🇬🇧 The price of freedom

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +2

      @@vincenttay2812 do you know that the whole family of Hong Kong chief executive, former chief executive and many senior politicians are still holding British citizenship until now, why did they apply for British citizenship in 1990s if they really support the return of Hongkong ? Why don't they give up the British citizenship evan under so many criticisms?

  • @happymelon7129
    @happymelon7129 3 месяца назад +9

    Relatively , HK is so kind.
    HK Legislative Council Complex RIOT sentence for 4 years.
    U$A Capital Hill Riot "Proudboy" sentence for 22 years.
    Stewart Rhodes: 18 years
    Peter Schwartz: 14 years
    Thomas Webster: 10 years
    Jessica Watkins: 8.5 years
    .......

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @argus-r1j
      @argus-r1j 2 месяца назад +1

      @@yipzoe3865 It is legal, just like you can also choose to live abroad.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 2 месяца назад

      @@argus-r1j how come she always praises China and critizes the western countries and asked Hong Kong people to send our children to China for study, but she sent her own daughter to USA?

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI
    @Fr.VeniceLAI 3 месяца назад +4

    :Indeed, "No Climate of fear in Hong Kong" over HongKongers street protests and demonstrations ...but these days replaced by different types of "Fear".

  • @franz.k
    @franz.k 3 месяца назад +6

    Die laughing at this interview. Asking Regina Ip about Hong Kong is like asking the Nazis about their exclusive clubs for Jews out in Poland.

    • @MiguelDLewis
      @MiguelDLewis 3 месяца назад

      "Exclusive clubs"🤣🤣🤣

    • @catinbootsnow4267
      @catinbootsnow4267 3 месяца назад

      Glad you are laughing. Most China haters in HK now live in depression.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +2

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

  • @GeographySingapore
    @GeographySingapore 3 месяца назад +4

    No fear cos those who are fearful are arrested?

  • @ThickBanana
    @ThickBanana 2 месяца назад +2

    Those were protests, not riots.

  • @chuasc1356
    @chuasc1356 3 месяца назад +5

    Good for Hong Kong to have National Security Law. Western media and operatives in Hong Kong now got to be careful not to be inciting political violence

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      The land of Hongkong should belong to Hong Kong people, we should have the right to determine our fate, Hong Kong was returned to China against the will of majority of Hongkong people, there's why many riots after the handover in 1997

  • @yipzoe3865
    @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +5

    her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university. Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China or stay in Hong Kong for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @vincenttay2812
      @vincenttay2812 3 месяца назад +1

      The pasture will always look greener on the other side. Do not matter where these young people choose to stay .Give them some breathing space and freedom. Try not to make a mountain out of a mole hill

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      @@vincenttay2812 who sent their little children to western countries while they asked Hongkong to send our children to Mainland China in the same time?

    • @JonKino828
      @JonKino828 3 месяца назад +3

      If you see what brutish implemented before leaving HK in 1997, then you will understand why many people left HK.
      brutish did that in the education system. Haven't you heard of 10 kids, 9 are yellow?

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      @@JonKino828 do you know that the whole family of Hong Kong chief executive, former chief executive and many senior politicians are still holding British citizenship until now, why did they apply for British citizenship in 1990s if they really support the return of Hongkong ? Why don't they give up the British citizenship evan under so many criticisms?

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      do you know that the whole family of Hong Kong chief executive, former chief executive and many senior politicians are still holding British citizenship until now, why did they apply for British citizenship in 1990s if they really support the return of Hongkong ? Why don't they give up the British citizenship evan under so many criticisms?

  • @kokliangchew3609
    @kokliangchew3609 2 месяца назад

    During the protest, pre-pandemic, I was in touch with some of my HK friends, who, without exception were in support of the protest. I actually told them that the protest was meaningless and that they would be lucky if China did not send in tanks like they did during Tianamen. They were actually not that well briefed about how the Basic Law and how the Handover came about.
    I followed the negotiations for the Handover and Basic Law in the early 1980s in the UK when Thatcher was negotiating it with Deng. Simply put, the Chinese thought that they were getting back HK in the same format existing during the negotiations, which was direct rule by way of an appointed leader. At that time, HK was ruled by a Governor General appointed by the UK.
    However, after the treaty was done and signed off, the UK government suddenly decided to set up a HK democratic legislative assembly to elect HK's leader, in essence handing over a poison pill to China. Of course China was furious about it but could not do anything as the treaty allowed UK to do that. Many commentators in UK at that time lambasted Thatcher's government for the pure hypocrisy of the move. As they rightly pointed out, HK had never ever had any democratic rights and any attempts to do so had being firmly quashed by the British as seditious during their rule! The British used the same sedition law that they had introduced into Malaysia and Singapore, and which long after their independence from the UK, continued to be use by both the Malaysian and Singaporean governments against their political opponents.
    Suddenly, after signing off the treaty with China and years of suppressing any democracy movement in HK, the British government decided to introduce democratic elections for HK's leadership, which was not what China had expected! In essence, the British had shafted China, again! HK was given to Britain as a result of the two Opium Wars where the British had fought China to continue as state sponsors in pushing opium into China. Read that shameful history of Britain's Opium Wars where it became the only country in history which became an international state-sponsored Opium pusher.
    I told my HK friends that did they expect UK or US to invade or challenge China militarily? Like they did in Vietnam, Afghanistan or Iraq? Those were minor countries with very weak military and financial clout. Which was not the case with China.
    www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/30/the-hong-kong-unofficials-who-advised-britain-on-the-handover-and-were-ignored
    "When the decision to relinquish Hong Kong in 1997 was finally announced on 20 April 1984, ironically it brought a sense of liberation to the advisers. Emboldened, a nine-member delegation - led by Chung - went to London to try to exert pressure on the government.
    But London was prepared. The press were briefed against them before their arrival and described their statement as “militant”. Their crucial questions to their colonial masters were: what would happen if China breached the Sino-British joint declaration? Would residents of Hong Kong be able to cast their vote on the joint declaration? If so, how?
    It was a controversial visit at home, too. Pro-Beijing newspapers accused the delegation of “spreading gloom in Hong Kong”, despite Hong Kong’s stock exchange index having already fallen by 200 points since the 20 April announcement. “We are here to try to reflect the Hong Kong people’s aspirations,” said Selina Chow, a member of the delegation, as reported by the Guardian on 13 May 1984. “We are asking the British government: ‘How are you going to fulfil your obligations to me? How are you going to protect me against these doubts?’”
    But before they received any answer from London, they were dismissed - including by their former boss, MacLehose, who by now had been given a life peerage. To Chung, it was unforgivable. “I shall never forget the words of the MPs who criticised us, saying that the unofficial members of the two councils were not elected so how could they represent Hong Kong? … I said to them: ‘How can you claim that you can negotiate for us? You have no mandate from us either; I never elected you,’” he later recalled to Tsang."
    As I kept reminding my HK friends during the protests, the Handover was negotiated by an Imperialist Conqueror and Colonist, which was never elected by HK! And who negotiated not what was in the best interest of HK but in the best interest of the UK. However, conveniently, both the HK younger generation and British commentators conveniently glossed over that!

  • @ArabicReja973
    @ArabicReja973 3 месяца назад +7

    Xi Jinping visited Hong Kong 🇭🇰, and no one welcomed him. He didn't dare to stay overnight in the city.
    - Pelosi visited Taiwan🇹🇼, thousands lined up on the street to welcome her. Taiwanese were thrilled and felt thankful that she could visit their country under the circumstances.

    • @MiguelDLewis
      @MiguelDLewis 3 месяца назад +2

      @@ToiChutGongWu wumao

    • @Lucky55Blue
      @Lucky55Blue 3 месяца назад

      @@MiguelDLewis Dimwit, not everyone that disagrees with you is a “WUMAO”. Find a better childish insult. WUMAO

    • @vincenttay2812
      @vincenttay2812 3 месяца назад

      Another carrot head comment from a forked tongue

    • @wynn3077
      @wynn3077 3 месяца назад +2

      @@ToiChutGongWu You tell him Wubot 😜

    • @GameChanger-cr4hx
      @GameChanger-cr4hx 3 месяца назад

      Pelosi is about to be locked up for her corrupt insider trading. Thousands will line up the streets to see her go to jail.

  • @johnny-ih5es
    @johnny-ih5es 3 месяца назад +5

    Look at the brighter side.
    HK becoming a part of the Greater Bay Area could make public housing become really affordable. Cage homes will be a thing of the past.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +2

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @htahtoo8851
      @htahtoo8851 3 месяца назад

      @@yipzoe3865
      Did she give up her Chinese citizenship?

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      @@htahtoo8851 no, because Hong Kong people are allowed to have dual citizenship.
      How come she always praises China and critizes western countries, but she sent her only child to USA instead of China when her daughter is still a little girl? She asked Hong Kong people to send our children to China for study

    • @htahtoo8851
      @htahtoo8851 3 месяца назад

      @@yipzoe3865 I don't know much about her but she was born into a rich family. So she has privileges. So long as she retains her Chinese citizenship, she's still Chinese. If she has not broken the law, she's free to move about. She may want to return to HK, China one day.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      @@htahtoo8851 how come the rich people send their kids to western countries for university only during colonial period, thier kids completed primary and Secondary school in public schools in Hong Kong?
      After the handover from 1997, evan the pro China politicians and celebrities send their kids to western countries from primary school, even in Hong Kong, their kids study in international schools only, they are so scared to let their own kids to study in public schools in Hong Kong. The pro China politicians support Patriotic education, they said it was a must and forced our kid to be brainwashed by CCP' distorted history, forced our kids to go to China for exchange, but their own kids never study in HK Public schools, they don't take the Patriotic education lesson, why? They sent their own kids to western countries when their kids are still very little

  • @ngfamily1397
    @ngfamily1397 3 месяца назад +1

    No matter what the reason is, if you committed a crime and proven guilty, you must bear the consequences. This applies universally.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      The land of Hongkong should belong to Hong Kong people, we should have the right to determine our fate, Hong Kong was returned to China against the will of majority of Hongkong people, there's why many riots after the handover in 1997

  • @chewie94116
    @chewie94116 3 месяца назад +2

    No one is showing fear but real estate is crashing. That is hidden fear.

    • @vincenttay2812
      @vincenttay2812 3 месяца назад +2

      BS real estate are crashing everywhere due to the economic slow down

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

  • @flowertowerrr
    @flowertowerrr 3 месяца назад +2

    No climate of fear, she said, fearfully

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

  • @kinmantai2095
    @kinmantai2095 3 месяца назад

    hk is finish,all foreign investment now go to singapore

  • @patrickchen1382
    @patrickchen1382 3 месяца назад +1

    Another excellent CNA production, excellent interview.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

  • @NoFrillz-G
    @NoFrillz-G 3 месяца назад

    Prior the protest Hong Kong was a den of spies. Truly a set from James Bond movie. Spies from all nations from Korea to Aussies and of course mainland spies.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      The land of Hongkong should belong to Hong Kong people, we should have the right to determine our fate, Hong Kong was returned to China against the will of majority of Hongkong people, there's why many riots after the handover in 1997

  • @pehclark7256
    @pehclark7256 3 месяца назад

    Sure, whatever. Stop those deepfake ads can Liao. Also congrats on cracking Sora long attention video generation. You guy copied the French guy work without giving him credit and sell to bytedance. Kinda lame. Moonshot still sucks btw. Also stop using the pickle attack create by the government funded apts.

  • @bernardlee5732
    @bernardlee5732 3 месяца назад +1

    Anyway, it is good for SG as more funds are exiting HK

  • @happymelon7129
    @happymelon7129 3 месяца назад

    2024-5-28, man who was convicted of assaulting Pe1osi's husband in 2022 was re-sentenced to 30 years.

    • @happymelon7129
      @happymelon7129 3 месяца назад

      Relatively to Pe10si, HK is so kind..
      sentenced to 30 years requested by this _e,,,1_ woman

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      The land of Hongkong should belong to Hong Kong people, we should have the right to determine our fate, Hong Kong was returned to China against the will of majority of Hongkong people, there's why many riots after the handover in 1997

  • @chenghonggoh4746
    @chenghonggoh4746 3 месяца назад

    Even their foreign justices are running away...😂

  • @kelvin-2204
    @kelvin-2204 3 месяца назад

    Pelosi once described HK riots “a beautiful sight to behold.” Not so long after, similar scene happened in US Capitol.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      The land of Hongkong should belong to Hong Kong people, we should have the right to determine our fate, Hong Kong was returned to China against the will of majority of Hongkong people, there's why many riots after the handover in 1997

    • @kelvin-2204
      @kelvin-2204 3 месяца назад

      Hong Kong and Taiwan were once part of the great Chinese civilization. HK and Taiwan were then reluctantly given away to more-powerful foreign powers because of the massive suffering, chaos, killings, rapes inflicted upon weaker China by the foreigners. They were then inevitably returned to China as China grows stronger today. It remains a wonder that a minority of youth continues to worship foreigners who used to inflict heavy suffering on their predecessors

    • @kelvin-2204
      @kelvin-2204 3 месяца назад

      HK and Taiwan were once part of the great Chinese Civilization. During the Century of Humiliation, HK and Taiwan were reluctantly given away to much more-powerful foreign powers due to the massive suffering, killings, rapes and chaos inflicted upon China. Now, as China naturally grows and returns to the peak position of the world, its natural that HK and Taiwan return to China. Its a wonder and shame for the Chinese people that a small minority of youth continues to worship foreigners who once terrorized their predecessors
      HK China will be governed by the Chinese Hong Kong people, no doubt about that. Only defence and foreign affairs matters will be handled by the central government.

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад

      @@kelvin-2204 How about Vladivostok? It was ceded to Russia under unequal treaty in Qing dynasty, but never returned
      Chinese Communist party claims that they don't recognize all the unequal treaties in Qing dynasty, why China doesn't ask Russia to return Vladivostok?

  • @Lucky55Blue
    @Lucky55Blue 3 месяца назад +1

    Why do they always pronounce years per number. It’s two thousand and whatever year, not a code 123456789 😂 so cringe

  • @KMLogKM
    @KMLogKM 3 месяца назад +1

    HK under control
    😅

    • @robocop581
      @robocop581 3 месяца назад +1

      Like Singapore

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +1

      Do you know that her only daughter is sent to USA when she was just a little girl and never returned evan after graduated from university? Why didn't she send her only child to Mainland China for study? Why doesn't her daughter return to china or Hongkong if Chinese rule is so good?

    • @robocop581
      @robocop581 3 месяца назад +1

      @@yipzoe3865 Why is that any of your business? Don't have much of a life huh?

    • @yipzoe3865
      @yipzoe3865 3 месяца назад +2

      @@robocop581 I am Hong Konger live in Hong Kong now, I know Hong Kong much better than the outsiders.
      do you know that the whole family of Hong Kong chief executive, former chief executive and many senior politicians are still holding British citizenship until now, why did they apply for British citizenship in 1990s if they really support the return of Hongkong ? Why don't they give up the British citizenship evan under so many criticisms?

    • @robocop581
      @robocop581 3 месяца назад +1

      @@yipzoe3865 So what? I live in HK. What makes you so special? Go get a life and stop worrying about trivial stuff