Canadian Shame: A History of Residential Schools | Ginger Gosnell-Myers | TEDxVancouver
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 июн 2024
- Ginger Gosnell-Myers, of Nisga’a and Kwakwaka’wakw heritage, is a policy expert, researcher, and activist whose work focuses on removing barriers between Indigenous peoples and all Canadians while fostering cooperation through open communication. Ginger was the City of Vancouver’s first Indigenous Relations Manager, where she advanced Vancouver as the world’s first “City of Reconciliation”, and ensured that Indigenous recognition and meaningful inclusion was reflected throughout all City departments and plans. Ginger was a lead on the Urban Aboriginal Peoples Study, Canada’s largest research study on Indigenous people’s living in urban centers. She has held key roles in Greenpeace Canada, the Inspirit Foundation, the Urban Native Youth Association, and the Assembly of First Nations. Ginger’s ultimate goal is to advance reconciliation and promote understanding of Vancouver as an unceded territory. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
Canada needs to stop saying “ sorry” and actually do the actions!
Get rid of the Catholic Church after forcing it into bankruptcy.
@@KenDavies-qv3fs but how? what about the other churches? and the queen's anglican church ?
@@MM22272 All of them that were involved.
@@lee02jepson agreed. then the question remains from ken davies - how to rid the churches?
@@MM22272 Perhaps you could parade outside Churches with signs saying, Bad men take land.
The best thing is to have a open heart and understanding and show some compassion ❤
Much love from New Zealand. A call for justice for all first nation tribes. Here in nz the state encourages all to learn the language of maoris te reo. Many free classes.
Kia ora Kathy
NZ children regardless of ethnicity have commonality in learning about many cultures here and the indigenous Maori language
It will be these kids whose future will be one of pride for themselves and their country
THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING FOR US ALL., MUCH LOVE
I was almost killed in residential school and today I'm a filmmaker telling our story.
Now that the 215 have been discovered ,the other thousands will find their voice .
I hope so. So tragic, more people support our indigenous than they know.
Thank you Ginger Gosnell-Myers, your talk will stand as our guiding light
Wow, finally a RUclips story about Canada's Residential Schools that allows comments. Suppression.
Cbc cnn even localized news don't even let natives comment our situations. Way to silence us.
@@marciashigak2976They're afraid you will shatter their glass house. I've been hearing lots of stories about Trudeau down here in the States. Lots of allegations similar to what happened to your people at those demonic Catholic schools. And with Canada's indigenous women still disappearing and/or being found murdered all across Canada, I fear these crimes are still going on with the complicit involvement of Canadian law enforcement.
1,000* sorry.
trudeau thinks the criminals will hand over their guns.
yes I noticed that on several of the news channels....Comments disabled
Wow. Great content, Ginger! This is a TEDx talk that needs to be spread far and wide. Every Canadian will benefit from your insightful and heart-felt talk. Thank you!
😭My sincerest sympathies to indigenous communities across the country 😭
I got a assignment on this video in high school can u help me put plss?
😉😉😉its all good
Time will not heal these atrocities. I'm hoping it brings attention, to the starlight tours in Saskatoon, where some can be held responsible.
As a canadian I didnt learn about residential schools until I learned that my great grandmother was taken as a child and placed in one. That's not ok. My 7 year old came home after learning about them with only the knowledge that you can be taken away from your parents and she was terrified I had to explain to her what it actually was and that her great great grandmother was in one. I grew up raised by my white mother I have limited knowledge of my heritage and the more I learn the angry I get about the lies taught in the education system..
The important facts that you can learn right now is that canada is not a real country, and that you are indoctrinated to be cog in a money making machine, and also that capitalism is a pyramid scheme.
@@stuart6478 please kindly go educate yourself. You have seen that 215 children’s bodies were just found right these were undocumented deaths, this is in addition to the 4100 from the same school that were documented. Maybe until you know what has actually occurred to the indigenous population you should not speak.
@@stuart6478 ps bud I pay taxes and so do all the other indigenous people. Never touched a gun in my life or killed an animal. Actually you know what I’m being to polite what I really want to say is go take a flying leap bud.
I believe that we need a change in narratives not just BLM but that we all matter. So many stories of atrocities that were never addressed in regards in Native and Indian history. I am of Latin and Native American heritage and I don’t just learn about my heritage but as others as well. So many people have suffered from racism and bias. If want society to change we need to accept each other’s uniqueness and cultures. This cancer needs to be eradicated in every way. We all have common issues that can connect us instead of dividing us. Asians, Native and Indians, African Americans,Latin and Middle-eastern. people.
lol you didn't even delete my comment. how hingry for attention
There are those who still in denial about these ugliness that happened to Indigenous people.
It hurts so much to hear all these horrific stories.
I feel your strength and pride behind your speech. Great information.♥️🌼💫
I’m really ashamed that my country is throwing this under the rug and not addressing the issues these indigenous people had to and continue to endure. I’m in grade 11 right now and the only sort of education I actually got on this was a one minute video of the topic. That was in grade 7 and I’m in grade 11 finally getting a lesson on it. Better late than never I guess but still we deserve to be educated and understand the problems the survivors and victims endured and I will continue to support them until the end of my life
Hi Rae, Since you are still very young and impressionable, I would like to say a few things to you:
1) This is a propaganda play. Notice how only one side is shown and only bad things occurred.
2) The 'atrocities' were not just afflicted upon natives. Look at the history of the Catholic church and boarding schools. Look at the history of orphanages and son on. Understand the history of the wars in the 20th century and its impact on life in Canada. Understand how much harder lifer was compared to today.
3) The unmarked mass graves are likely from real public health emergencies. Look at how deadly spanish flu and tuberculosis were. Ask yourself why no one claimed the children that passed on at these schools.
4) Not too long ago teachers were allowed to use corporal punishment. All children got at least this level of abuse.
5) Reconciliation is a misnomer. There is no one in power or paying taxes that wants to abuse natives. At 8:45 the whole discussion shows that this is a money grab and the people pushing the narrative are hoping for moral shame among the politicians and taxpayers to get free money. They want restitution and feel empowered from the recent BLM contrivance in the states. (I'm hesitant to leave BLM in here as I am sure you are properly set straight on that topic by more propaganda.)
What's missing from conversation:
1) Why residential schools were created and the discussion on how good intentions can lead to negative results.. and who is actually responsible for this (catholic church). I am finding out that the government didn't administer some of these schools until after much of the 'atrocities' were committed. That is why the speaker calls them 'government sanctioned', it is vague enough for you to believe that 'atrocities' were committed at the behest of the government.
2) Why unmarked graves exist. If your child went missing what would you do to find them? Why didn't that happen?
3) Why they want you to believe that a boarding school closed in 1996 was still committing abuse as recently as 1996. Notice the trick here that they tell you the close date but not if anything bad even happened.
4) Why the news media (opinion and propaganda) want to frame everything through the lens of racism.
5) Why they are ignoring the 'atrocities' committed against non-natives in the same era.
6) Why they want you to be ashamed of your country. The story of residential schools has not been thrown under the rug. This isn't something new that was just found out in the last few months, once you get older you may see a news-cycle trend.
Anyway, if you read and digested this post good on you and I hope that you think critically about this topic. I am very highly skeptical of the way the information is being offered right now and think the media is missing out on a real opportunity to share what really happened.
@@milktobo7418 Well said, Mike. Thanks.
If you want a 'propaganda play' look no further than Milk Tobo's comment. The Canadian residential schools meet the definition of genocide as per the UN General Assembly Genocide Convention signed in 1948. Milk Tobo is nothing more than an apologist and denier. The historical record and facts speak for themselves. Residential schools were originally introduced to deliberately "get rid of the Indian problem” as per John A MacDonald and Duncan Campbell Scott's own words. See also the report by Dr. Peter Henderson Bryce published in 1922, titled 'The Story of a National Crime' which was suppressed by the Canadian government. This is not a new issue and mortality rates in the schools were known one hundred years ago.
I will add only that you do not need to be ashamed of your country, this is an opportunity for Canada to move forward with recognition and support of the first peoples for the betterment of our nation as a whole.
@@milktobo7418It's funny how ppl make it about there selves like don't make me feel bad for the past or other cultures went through trauma too yours is the same get over it, its just about what happened, your way off topic Mike I know what happened my dad went residential school in kamloops and barely survived you can live in denial if makes you feel better but it wont make you right, let me guess and insinuate on you also your probably catholic or believes in God
EXCELLENT! There is much work to do.
Thank you for speak about the true history...
Heartbreaking that innocent children went through this
Thank you for sharing 🙏🏽❤️
Today june 1, 2021 and 215 dead bodies of children were found in school of Canada......
It's scarring
Canadian history has many dark spots, residential schools were often not spoken much about before I was in college. I was lucky to be aware of that part of history and Canadian institution's for disabilities ( not my favourite word). We have much to move forward and accept to grow
I got a assignment on this video in high school can u help me put plss?
look up the duplessis orphans, they weren't even special needs, they just we're classified as "mentally deficient" to get more money from the federal government. There's even strong allegations that the children we're beaten, tortured, elcotrocuted, water boarded so they could be used in experiments with the anti psychotic thorazine as part of project mkultra. Canada has a super dark history when you look into it.
Her suggestions and comparisons were extremely well thought out. It's shameful to see the government fumbling to find solutions when there are clearly many available... I loved her reference to the way NZ as a whole adopted Maori pride. I too would love to see this happen in Canada in respectful ways.
I got a assignment on this video in high school can u help me put plss?
We could adopt the NZ and a Bolivian hybrid system.
All those stories still need to be told. The Canadian Government needs to to continue hearing and publicly letting those stories to be known. Not letting those stories getting told, is denial that history happened to those people.
They were told. $72 million was spent over six years as testimonies were collected from all over the country. Anyone who wanted to join the TRC was welcome. You can read them on Canada's government website. This woman neglected to mention a lot of the actual facts of the TRC including that many of the testimonies were positive.
As a native man my mom went threw residential school and it affected are family I have 3 siblings I was fortunate to stay clean most of my life but my siblings all have addictions and depression runs deep you just don't get over it I was just fortunate to surround myself around good people and sports played a good roll in my life.
As a Canadian, I am ashamed by this. I was blessed to have many Indigenous friends and had the opportunity to learn so many things about their culture. I got to work in many reservations and I was invited to many ceremonies that showed me such an incredible strength. When I learned of this, I became physically sick and I have been ashamed of my country ever since. Please accept my sincere apology for what my countrymen did to you and your culture.
easy there.... let's not get carried away. This was the action of big government. Not your fellow countrymen. It wasn't my idea and I'm sure it wasn't yours.....
im native american and i dont have any hatred or ill will toward people because of race the blame lies in government and who ran those schools. i do have issues with people that hate on my culture and spread lies and misinformation
@@delmarsimpson8117 so much of what happened was during a time when we as Canadians were really steeped in the monarchy culture of England. That does not act as an excuse though, it comes down to the individual as you have said. Stay strong in your culture.
Thank you xo
RUclips Algorithm is getting better and better with time. Thanks to AI. Recommendation timing is on Point. 👌
so hard I understand I went through something similar I am 2nd generation residential schooling
it s so much wounding I was a mess in so many parts of my Life because of this and other things
I ve just grown stronger thats all
@@RaeZoladawn777 Great that you take an empowering view from it.
I'm sure & hope that you are doing well in life.
Ginger is not only a brilliant story teller and speaker like many other Nisga’a people, the ideas and models espoused here have to be spread more widely and acted upon. We need both greater awareness and capacity building for indigenous peoples if we're to truly have a nation of equals and all prospering.
Now I know why Canadians say sorry so much ... there is so much to be sorry for.
i was just thinking that.
Indeed however US did the same to a greater extent... it's not just Canada. They don't care though
You are absolutely correct, only half done!
Churches should pay taxes like everybody else. These newfound funds can go to the survivors and their needs.
True..
That would just promote the victim mentality..and would be another waste of tax dollars.
Sadly wasn’t limited to Canada 😞
Yeah! All the countries in the American continent are guilty of the ongoing genocide to the people of the First Nation!💔 The sad reality is that Canada is the one doing the most efforts for reconciliation while we all know they should be doing WAYYY more. In the States, I looked up some stats and....oh my god!!! The representation of the Natives in the medias are less than 1% for all the spheres! In school, american kids don't learn anything about the First Nations after the 1900 which causes people to think that they have gone instinct! In the States and in South American countries, women and kids of the First Nation are more likely to get kidnapped and sold for HUMAN TRAFFICKING because the laws do not protect them enough!! Now all I hope is that Canada will lead the way for all American countries to change their ways. I would also like to point out that the President of USA, Bernie Sanders had recognized the Armenian genocide earlier this year...so there might be hopes!
indigenous need fair power for reconciliation and to stop corrupt policies. Ginger for senator. Canada senate has 15 vacancies. Trudeau can appoint 15 indigenous women for senators now. Trudeau can appoint more indigenous women liberal candidates for liberal majority
@@SimplyStinco Canada has had documents on this abuse for years (govt well aware) court battles with survivors etc some ongoing.. can look up 5th estate documentary on St Anne's (mid to latter portion talks about the govt "reconciliatory" measures) to get an idea. Suppressed records and dismissed majority of claims as false
My husband wrote a very moving song a couple of years ago about the cruelty of the residential schools. Worth listening to because the lyrics tell it like it was! On RUclips Glenn Snow residential truth
Amazing speaker, as a white male I look forward to a time when forgiveness and love between all peoples is the norm. Inter generational pain along with horrifying amounts of PTSD and all its challenges (Addictions corruption etc). I cannot and do not speak for anyone else but if it helps us find love and peace I will walk beside you my brothers and sisters of color. Not in from or behind but right beside you as we trudge the the road of happy destiny.
@@mattk234 There are many narratives. There is space for them all. Distinguishing what is real truth from falsehood is a matter of group perspectives. There is a kernel of truth even in opposing viewpoints. This is not an All or Nothing matter. The Western Worldview is the problem. Nothing is fixed. Everything is in process. Always. Nobody was or is perfect. That doesn't make any one group "all" right and another "all" wrong. Thinking in extremes is the problem. Think about the middle.
@@lyndawise1042 what if the real truth is in the minority and the false truth has the power? then the real truth has to take over the false truth for the real truth to complete the narrative, but if nothing is fixed, how to be sure of the real truth in the middle? if we're all in the west with the western world view, how can we escape it and find the real truth?
1000 kids throughout the land so far..... why is mainstream media silencing the comments? We know the archeological significance of it.
Exactly bro. They don't want us to point the finger at the obvious perpetrators. This was an obvious genocide. Just so sad we had to LITERALLY find these corpses to start believing this was happening. I swear by God it doesn't matter what religion you follow but what goes around does come around. There was a reason those bodies were found and there will be consequences.
My grandfather was taken from his family and "raised" in a residential school. He was 17 when he met my grandma (15). They got married in their 20s, then spent their life together 'til he died when he was 82. She said, even though he was in a residential school, he still thought in Mohawk. He spoke in Mohawk - and took so long to speak in English because he had to translate English words to Mohawk back to English. When I was a kid, he'd call me by my Mohawk name (and not my legal English name). One of the strongest men in my life. He didn't let WHO HE WAS be taken from him.
Good stuff. Proud to be an Aboriginal - only because Canada and America tried to erase us and we're STILL here, speaking OUR language. You tried to take that away from my grandfather yet HE STILL SPOKE IT. And his GRANDKIDS still speak it. His great grandkids, who will never meet him, still speak it. You have GOT to respect that diligence, that perseverance, that spirit, that willingness to keep our culture alive.
But nah, we're just all a bunch of drunks and druggies who throw our lives away.
Shame shame shame !!!
When I emigrated to Canada I watched movie called " the last of the Mohicans" I cried for many days as it touched my heat so deeply , I prayed that all natives forgive me for coming and living here whole they are struggling in reservations having no basic needs such as water food, safe shelter ! I prayed 🙏 to be forgiven as I didn't know that I occupy their very land as I know how it feels when others take away all from you including your dignity, ethnical cleansing genocide is the worst than any person can experience these harmful scars will never be erased .
Don't be so quick to believe what you hear.
Respect and reconciliation and foremost truth. We can all do better.
The Canadian government opened the door to allow these atrocities and the Catholic Church closed the door and carried them out.
france shut down the church in1793
MIIGWECH from Orilla Ont 🥰🧡🇨🇦
I was a part of the 60ds🥰
Well said.
I can't believe that people that believed strongly in God, can do this to children!!!
Sadly that is a story remade many times other times and places also. Though I understand your repulsion and disbelief.
They served the SATANS
I wonder what she would say about the situations contining to go on now in 2021
This generation provides safty.....for all
Well said 😁
I must apologize for the continued abuse and misuse of all the people... it makes me sick 🤒 to my stomach because of my ancestors!
Such a beautiful society when allowed to be who you were meant to be ❤️
I’m sorry that the Canadian government has been, and continues to, dawdle when it comes to reconciliation and restitution 😡
It’s like they are waiting for the last person from the residential schools to die so they can save some money!
I want Canada 🇨🇦 to become like New Zealand 🇳🇿 NOW!!!
God bless the people of Turtle 🐢 Island
Unless ur family was a member of the royal family, an oligarch, a eugenicist or a member of the Catholic Church, they weren’t responsible.
I wished this video was in French or at least with French subtitles too! Any leads where I could find it?
Why all of a sudden the censorship on these stories ??
@@marilyn9138 follow the money ... the guilty run
Kinda insane I’m 21 and from the US and had never heard of these schools until I saw the story about the 214 body’s and decided to dig deeper. 150,000 effected throughout the 1900s and it’s only now getting talked about is sad.
Residential "schools" also took place in the USA and Australia. Across the board a specific pattern. i don't know the numbers for Au but USA had a greater number of these prisons than Canada even . There's a ted talk given by a survivor from Australia
Catholic, united church, methodist and anglican all had hospitals or re training internment camps called residential schools. RIP Danse and Frank.
As a non-Canadian, my impression: Canadian Govt is to blame for annihilation of indigenous cultures. And what about the Church?
THERE ISN’T ENOUGH BEING DONE!
This video is from years ago, yet most of the rest of the world doesn’t know much about this. I personally have never heard about this until today. This is a problem, if you think about it if this happened in China or India the government would be destroyed and word of it would have spread far and wide, yet Canada is allowed to get away with it (so far).
Where are the people? Only a few people from countries without these schools know of this, compare this to the vast majority of people who haven’t heard of (or don’t know much about) this, only a small proportion can do anything about it.
Also, where are the people who were trying to raise awareness of China’s concentration camps? Just because Canada is a developed and western country doesn’t mean we can turn a blind eye to this.
Don’t even try to say ‘at least the didn’t try to hide it’ because yes they did, through the ignorance of their people, through not telling the people about this despite it being YEARS since they found out about it.
The best way to fix this is by educating.
Never forget what Queen Elizabeth did to the Native American Children at Kamloop///!!!!
@@azuraroycroft2419 it's very true ' look it up
What?
What did Queen Elizabeth do?
I blame Catholics not the Queen as we have been an independent country since 1867.
Or the catholic church who condoned and carried out a genocide .
It is the church that turned these places into sorrowful heartless prisons. It could have been a whole different experience. My mind simply doesn’t understand how children can be taken away from their parents like this, just because we didn’t like their culture.
I adore their culture! Everyone should learn about it! I simply fell in love with their philosophy regarding the cycle of life!🤍
It was much deeper than just not liking their culture, it was about money, about trying to kill them, if not in body, mentally, it was about shutting them up about the country being grabbed from them. The government gave a lot of money to people/organizations to run the school (for want of a better word, b/c they were not schools) + many people were involved in getting that money. Wasn't just religious organizations who made money from this, it was companies that made money producing things like handcuffs for children of different ages, clothing they had to wear and so on.
And the RCMP knew that these crimes were happening, when a child was murdered + the parents wanted an inquiry they were often told to drop it or they would end up in jail.
I agree with her that one of the things that needs to happen is what happened in Germany + their atonement for WW1, WW2 and the death camps, through education of the population starting in primary school. This will never be done with the present governments we always vote in (PC + Liberals). Just recently a Progressive Conservative MP in Alberta stated that the Native people need to get over it and just work hard. So it definitely won't happen with a PC government. We can't let someone as cold, uncaring + mean spirited as that come into a place of power. And I hate that he lives off tax payers money. We need to really consider who we vote in next time around if we want this to be addressed properly.
nice
also canadas 1st prime minister used starvation as a tool to force indigeous into treaties. part of why uprising began
I wanted to ask this to be as respectful as possible. but is it offensive to call native Americans “Indians”? Because my family was at a pow wow (idk how to spell it) and my mother asked one of the natives there if it was and he said yes but I keep seeing conflicting info. Thanks for the help.
👍👍👍
PM Ginger
right now group of lawyers taking canada and the vatican to court after kamloops find of the unmarked graves......hope theirs justice....canadas day of reckoning....usa had 400 schools hope theirs comes too
Who is here after 215 dead bodies found in schood of Canada 1 june 2021
215.......751........
Land......religion.....culture....and lives
I wish I could have stayed proto BC. Just like the ipd Columbia.
When there was peace for 50 years between all US and Canadian Western tribes and the settlers. What changed? War
Nobody reading this better be celebrating the 4th of July today...
The West should come together and slap sanctions on Canada 🇨🇦, instead of criticism of other human rights in other societies let’s make a example of Canada. Let us show the rest of the world that the West not only just use human right as talking point but lead by example. Let us ban Canadian goods, let us close borders!
I feel physically sick.
Mussia Media Inc needs the refgee status from a Canadian First Nations Nation, so they can fight for our rights
Canada is on trial and WE CHILDREN OF OUR CREATOR WILL NOT BE PASSIVE BUT HOLD YOU EACH AND EVERYONE ACCOUNTABLE FOR YOUR LIFE HERE ON EARTH. WITH US. I APPLAUD THE COURAGE AND BRAVERY OF ALL THESE WITNESSES FOR SHARING THEIR TESTIMONY WITH US! BLESSINGS FROM CREATOR HE WILL FILL YOUR LIVES WITH HIS HOLY SPIRIT AND LIGHT UP YOUR LIVES WITH LOVE TO SHOWER UPON YOUR FAMILY.
sounds real serious ... why not plain compensation
those people lost everything
Please watch your kids everybody.
They were taken by force by gouverment threats. But you are right we still have to watch them.
i am curious, why do we never hear from the administrators of the residential schools, and, why did our government believe that indiginous children should be brought into mainstream society
indigenous need fair power for reconciliation and to stop corrupt policies. Ginger for senator. Canada senate has 15 vacancies. Trudeau can appoint 15 indigenous women for senators now. Trudeau can appoint more indigenous women liberal candidates for liberal majority
permanent seats in government
@@delmarsimpson8117 yes, a permanent majority over the settler parties
the Indian Act is a joke get rid of it !!
ok. then what about the monarchy? the queen?
Mussia Media Inc needs refugee status from the First Nations of North America Via consensus agreements with the Canadian First Nations
How’d you guys remember all of this?
The criminals forget, the victims don't !!!
簡直不是人做的事，邪恶不能勝正義，把所有的苦和受的罪都說出来，說给全世界聽
Canada is a peaceful country oh wait a minute what has done to the native children of Canada
Way to go girl, tell your story. damn churches
even the queen's church? she's head of canada and the anglican church?
So sad.
Stop saying sorry and do something to stop systemic racism in Canada
Mussia needs the benevolence of the Canadian First Nations, will you adopt our company? Will you litigate for our rights as your own rights?
We need a new set of Intellectual Property rights, the british bamboozeld Canadians and now we are refugees, Mussia needs refugee status from a Canadian first nation
you are correct. Now that you are needed by them please do not commit societal suicide. That’s what it looks like you’re doing.
It’s kind of like peeing your pants to warm yourself up
News: More unmarked graves found today in Canada.
Canada: Let’s lecture China about human rights abuses.
Did we not make progress or are we still committing these same atrocities?
@@milktobo7418 When these are the skeletons in a country’s closet, they have no right to grandstand and lecture others.
@@neerdowell2010 Lets focus on everything you did wrong in your lifetime and see if you have the right to share your opinion on this matter. You are right nothing and no one changes... so don't try and make things better.
Good presentation, needs to be further fleshed out but is food for thought. Canadian government is getting rich off of First Nations lands, its time that they revenue shared with our First Nations with crown land resources instead of the foreign companies getting rich off what should be the First Nations lands and resources.
how would that happen?
@@MM22272 they (government) have their policy analyst people that analyze how this can happen and they are aware of which First Nations people are in which area. It can be done but whether or not there’s a willingness for it to happen on the crown behalf I’d the real question.
@@gwen6453 ok. so the first nations have all of their boundaries mapped out because there are different groups? true, there's no willingness. that's a good point, but now it's hopeless, no? they'd need more first indigenous in the parliament and senate, a majority or it won't happen. all those foreign companies can pay taxes and royalties direct to first indigenous, right? only when money's involved, people care
@@MM22272 yes I agree, I always believed that a revenue sharing model should be done whether it’s taxes or the revenue raised from the resources. And yes First Nations need to be part of the decision making with the crown. They do need to have first indigenous in the Houses of Parliament and the senate.
@@gwen6453 how about first indigenous becomes the crown and the monarchy can retire and everyone else fits under that model. Trudeau can start by filling the 15 vacancies in the senate with first indigenous. transformation begins.
one event that happened..documented ..was that there was an uprising from metis//indigenous were captured taken to the res school and the priests bought out the children....indigenous were executed in front of the kids to break their spirit or cultural pride. and as a lesson from the government...this is what happens
say something if this happened in China
Nobody mentioned China here except yourself.
what would happen in china
It’s 0300 hours time to sleep
The most fair things that the Canadian Government can do is: "Close all Religions based school"
Native Elders are asking AGAIN TO SHOW HOW A MOUNTAIN TURNS TO PASTURE WALKING FLAT AND UPRIGHT LANDS ... YOUR BIGGEST FUQQING MOUNTAIN 🌞
AMIN³
mera na mera na, hah, har passe har thaan, hah
An Apology now from that Pope guy at this point , would sound very disingenuous and very very hollow!!!!
I think even God would have trouble believing him .
what about the queen too as head of the anglican church? then maybe there's the other churches with leaders outside canada? God believing ... doesn't it only matter if canadians believe him?
God closed his ears and turned the face away !
so this is what i don't understand right. How do we actually solve the problem instead of just talking about it forever.
According to indigenous eye witness accounts, Queen Elizabeth visited one of these residential schools for a scheduled "royal picnic/lunch date" with 12 indigenous children whom were seen leaving with her but never returned.
This talk is barely scratching the surface.
I have never found evidence of this story being true
every person in earth is tortured to death by god. we must start a revolution against the heavens.
Residential Schools are better than teepees.
That has got to be the dumbest comment ever written on you tube
@@krugerparksafari LOL!
Shows how little you know about history when you treat an entire northern part of the continent as one giant group
So we need every Indian language officially spoken now. New Zealand only had 1 other language to acknowledge
Public school systems could give students the choice to learn the Indigenous language local to that area instead of French for example. Students already sing the national anthem every morning. It would be easy to add a land acknowledgement and learn one sentence or phrase of significance to honor the local Indigenous language.
Why not? They are not important people to you?
My country has hundreds of local languages and children study local language in schools.
@@ukholidavivo1284 I totally agree
@@annelisedugas not allowed in quebec. quebec decides for canada, no?. quebec started canada in 1608, no?
Fund and support indigenous languages. Make them recognized. Also have an indigenous studies course be implemented/mandatory in high school.
if you want big government - this is what you get.
Hi. Can someone suggest to me a video talking about how First Nation Chiefs are planning to give their children a modern education? What is Plan A and B? While most of the World is very busy educating their populations (India, China, Middle East nations, South Africa, Mexico... 100% of nations have a clear plan. What/who is holding the young children from having a great education. If assimilation is the answer, that doesn't seem to be negative. I'm a regular Canadian, and i don't have or need a lot 120' x 120' land to be happy. I'm educated, i work, i am healthy (hospitals). I get along just fine, thank you, without owning land (real estate)
please educate yourself....start with Indigenous Writes: A Guide to First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Issues in Canada
by Chelsea Vowel. Removing Indigenous peoples from their land has removed us from our culture. We don't have the same worldview or values as "White" Canadians and assuming that just because you have no care about land that we shouldn't either is the epitome of your privilege. Our culture, lifestyles and spirituality revolve around our connection to the land. Severing our language and culture and removing us from the land is how the government identified a way to destroy our culture. You're Canadian and you don't care about land. I'm First Nations and I do.
@@jengreen6859 Thank you for this. I have to read up a lot more. CBC (mostly radio) have been having many more native speakers on their stations, and that's a good thing, cause we're (whites) stuck in the past tense.
Many nations are only educating a fraction of their population, and usually that fraction is male. Education in many countries has a long way to go. Our education system isn't inherently "bad" but I do think we are on a brink of education systems changing, and Covid has pushed that a bit. For First Nations communities, what matters is access to education--in whatever form that is--that is equally funded to education of other students (in Ontario, at least, the funding formula is different for First Nations students vs other students), that includes teaching of the languages so they thrive, that has teachers who are First Nations running classrooms--and ensuring that access exists for young people to become teachers. Classrooms that also are 'modern' but include the Indigenous Worldview would help also.
@@jengreen6859 that's a lot to learn ... what is this connection to the land. if the government gave reserves to the first indigenous people, then they have the land connection, no? maybe more land is required like a whole province? would they buy the land from the private owners or just given for free? what's the answer?
Although the implementation might have been flawed, the basic concept of the residential schools to inculcate a modicum of ambition and personal worth, was valid. Several generations after the cancellation of the program, we still have our natives indulging in their "cultures" of indolence, dependency, addiction, etc. Like any family's wayward son, some "tough love" is appropriate: IF YOU PERSIST IN YOUR WRONG LIFESTYLE, DO NOT EXPECT ME TO SUPPORT YOU!!!
Oh wow, its almost like residential schools were oppressive and the simple closing of them didn’t fix the problems it helped create.