Subvocalization: Are you saying these words in your head?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024

Комментарии • 137

  • @hads5279
    @hads5279 3 года назад +203

    I am extremely confused as to how it’s even possible to not say a word in your head when you read. How in the world do you comprehend a word without saying it in your head?

    • @ckthomas5756
      @ckthomas5756 3 года назад +16

      by visualizing hte words as sentences

    • @destoothebarber929
      @destoothebarber929 3 года назад

      @@ckthomas5756 woahhhh

    • @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs
      @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs 3 года назад +21

      2:20 explains that you can only water down the habit, no one can get rid of it fully:)
      I was also confused, because I felt like it was impossible... because it is!!

    • @renelesch6244
      @renelesch6244 3 года назад +39

      If you look at a stone, you dont have to tell yourself „stone“ in your head...

    • @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs
      @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs 3 года назад +1

      @@renelesch6244 doesn't that only work for nouns?

  • @amorestperpe
    @amorestperpe 3 года назад +89

    Hahaha lord 🤣😂 I was trying to follow along at the 350 wpm pace and was like holy shit I'm dumb... That's way to fast. Then I remembered I'm watching this video on 2x speed lmao.

  • @blueshoes915
    @blueshoes915 3 года назад +25

    Thank you so much for this! I’ve heard the counting out loud while you read method and it’s impossible for me to do. I am then not reading anything, just counting and looking at symbols. I tend to talk a lot faster than I read though. 😬 I have a lot of books I want to read but it takes me so much longer to get through them than other people. I’ve been trying different methods but the subvocalizing is a hard habit to break. This tool seems to work much better for me. I am definitely going to practice with this.

    • @bmwmga7192
      @bmwmga7192 2 года назад

      How is it going so far? Have you reduce subvocalisation since?

  • @suhilkoul4850
    @suhilkoul4850 2 года назад +2

    I watched 6 videos right now on this topic, hands down this was the best

  • @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs
    @OneOfYourFrenchGirIs 3 года назад +23

    Thank you for 2:20 other videos were making me think subvocalization could be eradicated fully!! I felt like that was impossible, and now I know it is 😂

  • @DannyBridie
    @DannyBridie Год назад

    man, thank you SO much for this! every. single. video. on this topic is someone just telling us what it is & that we should reduce it, without much info on how we CAN reduce it. this video, along with the website you've created, really made a difference.
    THANK YOU!

  • @anncabras3961
    @anncabras3961 2 года назад +13

    For me focusing on my breathing helps me a lot in reducing it. Of course I still say the words in my head but if I don’t focus completely on the reading but partly focus on something else like my breathing it gets a lot less:)

    • @dovafx9170
      @dovafx9170 2 года назад +1

      Bro I do the same I'm not alone

  • @stitchfan_8290
    @stitchfan_8290 3 года назад +11

    I can't read without my inner monologue.
    i see words as a visual representation of noises made by the human mouth.
    To read with out the inner voice is like trying to experience music by looking at an oscilloscope.

    • @diegovera1353
      @diegovera1353 3 года назад

      Then just forget about the sound altogether, see words as if you were a person who had never ever heard any human talk in his life

    • @stitchfan_8290
      @stitchfan_8290 3 года назад +1

      @@diegovera1353 I am not even shore what that would be like.
      what do words even mean with out sound?
      If I learned to read and write before learning to talk and listen maybe I could do it.
      But I was late learning to read and write.

  • @astrocat9216
    @astrocat9216 3 года назад +17

    Im bad at learning from reading, my comprehension is bad when reading too fast and subvocalization is good for me.

    • @denis3208
      @denis3208 3 года назад +6

      Its good for everyone because without it you wouldn't know what you read you would only see shapes. Keep practicing, reading is a skill like anything else everyone can get better ! Try if you can to buy a book of Jim Kwik he is a great teacher for all sorts of learning, including memory and reading.

    • @jugheadjones5473
      @jugheadjones5473 3 года назад +1

      @@denis3208 Limitless by Jim Kwik

    • @jigneshpadia
      @jigneshpadia 3 года назад

      @@denis3208 Any suggestion on how to start getting pictures from reading words without having to subvocalize it. Clarification - English is a 2nd language so we never learned basic vocabulary through picture words.

  • @denis3208
    @denis3208 3 года назад +7

    I can do 3 words at a time by 600 words per minute, 800 was a struggle and 1200 (reading speed of JFK) my comprehension was stretched. I still have to practice. But now I know what you mean by reducing sub subvocalization, thank you !

    • @amoszander047
      @amoszander047 3 года назад +2

      Jeez 1200?? I guess great ppl are great for a reason 😭

  • @jimbojimson
    @jimbojimson 2 года назад +4

    I think I'd be throwing all of my comprehension out the window if I tried this. I usually can't comprehend what I'm reading if I read as fast as I talk, I have to slow it down and then still catch myself reading without paying attention so I have to reread a lot of paragraphs twice, or sometimes three or four times before I actually pay attention to what was said.

  • @jasonschempp3766
    @jasonschempp3766 3 года назад +2

    You got me with the stop-word list and earned a like. Thanks for the insight.

  • @davem16
    @davem16 4 года назад +3

    Thanks Paul, have been a fan of your product for years now.

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  4 года назад +1

      I appreciate that! Thanks for all the support! -Paul

  • @ranjan_v
    @ranjan_v 3 года назад +3

    THank you very much

  • @iquanta2968
    @iquanta2968 3 года назад +7

    The moment he mentioned that u can't eliminate sub-vocalization, liked it

  • @jacobthemaster66
    @jacobthemaster66 3 года назад +4

    350 wasn’t that fast, still said everything in my head

  • @odelyalevy
    @odelyalevy 4 года назад +4

    Very appreciative for this video. Thank you. It is limiting my speed reading. Seems that I have difficulties to eliminate it from my reading. Blessings.

    •  4 года назад +1

      Eliminating subvocalization is impossible. Everybody needs to subvocalize words.

  • @nyahavi
    @nyahavi 3 года назад

    This is super cool, I’m definitely going to use your site to practice

  • @youreadthisinyourmindright2604
    @youreadthisinyourmindright2604 3 года назад +34

    My name is an enigma for most people

    • @kegan9015
      @kegan9015 3 года назад +1

      Shaun

    • @federtm2
      @federtm2 3 года назад +1

      Yeah, cut it Shaun.

  • @Miguel-eh6jh
    @Miguel-eh6jh 2 года назад +4

    This feels like skimming and only getting half of the information or I'm probably just stupid. reading is fun but reading like this feels like it takes away from it.

  • @TheJvillafan
    @TheJvillafan 3 года назад +1

    Great tool guys. Thank you so much. this is very helpful

    • @seemathapar4385
      @seemathapar4385 3 года назад

      Really ...let me see whether it work on me ...cause Its difficult for me to understand stuff ..

  • @master-oh6zn
    @master-oh6zn 3 года назад +5

    if you subvocalize that means you are gonna read as fast as u can talk.
    Eminem: MENACING

  • @healthloverscircle5005
    @healthloverscircle5005 3 года назад +1

    Quite an incredible tool 👏

  • @jean-baptiste9230
    @jean-baptiste9230 3 года назад +8

    So you never remove the sub voice in your head, you just jump from word that has meaning and put them together?

    • @littlehighheels
      @littlehighheels 2 года назад

      Yeah, that’s exactly how I understood it too. Hmm 🤔

  • @greghiggins7045
    @greghiggins7045 3 года назад +6

    A simple way to increase your reading speed by eliminating sub vocalization, is to recite a number sequence very softly like "1 2 3 4, 1 2 3 4, ..." . or sing a familiar song like "Mary Had A Little Lamb". At first it seems impossible but soon you will be on your way to reading without having to hear the words in your head. Try it. Stay with it- it works.
    Also practice a "soft focus" kind of like staring in the air, by looking just below the print. This allows you to to see phrases rather than single words. When you use a "hard focus", it makes you stop for just a moment on each word- greatly reducing your speed and believe it or not your comprehension.

    • @jacobthemaster66
      @jacobthemaster66 3 года назад +1

      I counted and I just said the words more quiet and couldn’t read anything

    • @willie6981
      @willie6981 Год назад +1

      Wow I tried it it works i can understand some but Idk if i can remember it later

  • @davef.5131
    @davef.5131 2 года назад +1

    There is a difference between reading something and comprehending something.

  • @roesjadi
    @roesjadi 4 года назад +1

    Thanks, Paul. Its very helpfull

  • @ysaysaysaysa
    @ysaysaysaysa 2 года назад +1

    Does anyone else subvocalize extremely quickly? When I read I subvocalize faster than I can talk so basically It’s like a sentence in my head is being read at 2x speed if that makes sense. Can anyone relate?

    • @luis-alberto.
      @luis-alberto. 2 года назад

      Eminem can subvocalize quicker than you do

    • @willie6981
      @willie6981 Год назад

      Yeah same! Im a fast talker too So I read fast. so when I figured out that hearing what I read is slowing me down I want to learn to remove it.

  • @sagarjamwal4637
    @sagarjamwal4637 3 года назад +1

    My speed is 448 wpm with subvocalisation
    with 50-60% of comprehension
    Can I be a god without subvocalisation

    • @travistouthang341
      @travistouthang341 5 месяцев назад

      What god man?? You’re just a human being.

  • @ibthat1guy
    @ibthat1guy 4 года назад +34

    This gets annoying especially when you watch anime

    • @Momo4579
      @Momo4579 3 года назад +3

      That's the main reason im here.

    • @S3TTED
      @S3TTED 3 года назад +2

      Literally the reason I’m here

    • @frenchfries1328
      @frenchfries1328 3 года назад

      Natsu

    • @asadorama
      @asadorama 3 года назад +1

      I thought I was the only one it's why I'm here too :')

  • @ashton3417
    @ashton3417 3 года назад +2

    I went at 700 wpm and still kept up

  • @sanujamethmal9188
    @sanujamethmal9188 3 года назад

    Thanks, i got the point

  • @jigneshpadia
    @jigneshpadia 3 года назад +1

    What to do if you can read it but can't remember, recall or comprehend it at higher speed?

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  2 года назад

      Hi Jignesh! We offer online courses to help you learn to recall and comprehend information that you read. Please head to our website irisreading.com to see a list of the courses we offer.

  • @SaiKumar-gb6lk
    @SaiKumar-gb6lk 7 месяцев назад

    I have a doubt with having a subvocalization how can we understand?

  • @melatonin1371
    @melatonin1371 3 года назад +4

    I unknowingly say my inner thoughts out loud in class. It's embarrassing because I apparently i say my thoughts in third person out loud and people just look at me weirdly and I don't know why.

  • @menonguy
    @menonguy 2 года назад

    thanks man

  • @LukeXlll
    @LukeXlll Год назад

    This video is great, it really helped me understand subvocalization

  • @melissarose6901
    @melissarose6901 3 года назад

    thank you!

  • @brainengine5444
    @brainengine5444 2 года назад +1

    I just can’t fathom that some people don’t hear a mind voice. Hell! I even read each comment with a different voice. Even as I type this comment it has one.

    • @davef.5131
      @davef.5131 2 года назад

      You should get that checked out

    • @willie6981
      @willie6981 Год назад

      Im reading this using spongebob voice

    • @Luneytoon
      @Luneytoon Год назад

      Same tho

  • @paulinetayloe9988
    @paulinetayloe9988 2 года назад

    I can listen to a you
    Tube audiobook at 2x yet I can’t speed read, I talk fast because my dads dad is abadonian from the uk, I took a speed reading test and I’d i had a good rest I can read a paragraph in one min and 350mph honesty.

  • @merelogics
    @merelogics 3 года назад

    Does this mean that rather than not saying all words in your head, you only say like 50% of the words in the head and completely skip the rest of the words as if they didn't exist. So for example. The previous sentence is read in the head like "Does this mean not saying all words only say 50% words skip rest didn't exist". Is it possible to read the sentence without reading any single word in the head?

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  2 года назад

      Hi Muhammad! It takes lots of practice, but it is possible to reduce subvocalization.

  • @paulinetayloe9988
    @paulinetayloe9988 2 года назад

    I have a memory like a dead squirl and not good memory maybe it’s because I’ve got a minor learning disability maybe I can’t speed read and patialy sighted, maybe that’s why, if you don’t know what you read how can you enjoy the book? If I just look at the words how can I enjoy the book if I can’t remember it?

  • @Fivioxo
    @Fivioxo 4 года назад +1

    good work

  • @omerkaya545
    @omerkaya545 2 года назад

    I have no idea how someone can read something would a inner voice.
    How does that work?

  • @karlino3338
    @karlino3338 3 года назад +1

    But if u read like that you will understand less then when u read normaly, idk am i right?

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  2 года назад

      Hi! Your brain actually retains information that it sees. We also include strategies such as inspecting material before you read, and more! Please visit our website to see the courses that we offer to help you in the areas of speed reading, comprehension, and memory! irisreading.com

  • @benis87
    @benis87 3 года назад

    Awesome explanation

  • @birendratamang8127
    @birendratamang8127 2 года назад

    While i read subvocalization not hear word aloud in my head

  • @jgc1077
    @jgc1077 2 года назад

    I don't understand how it's possible to read without saying the words in your head.

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  2 года назад

      When you see a "STOP" sign, do you say "stop"?

  • @willie6981
    @willie6981 Год назад

    Thank god im a fast talker so I read fast too. But I want to remove it but I cant understan sht

  • @uuuseful9962
    @uuuseful9962 4 года назад +20

    start at 0:58

  • @chez.bkfood
    @chez.bkfood 2 года назад

    why if I can't stop repeating everything I hear too like I am constantly hearing thing twice I hate that

  • @wendigo8204
    @wendigo8204 2 года назад

    I'm trying to pray without ceasing and it is hard while reading

    • @OPsommie
      @OPsommie Год назад

      I think a little thank you Lord now and then will suffice

  • @anyonymswede
    @anyonymswede Год назад

    If I read non-fiction I do not sub vocalise.

  • @tristanvdw
    @tristanvdw 2 года назад

    I could do subvocalization at 350wpm watching the video at 1.25 speed.

  • @nadienadie6335
    @nadienadie6335 2 года назад

    If I was able to learn how touch type, I can do this

  • @amoszander047
    @amoszander047 3 года назад +1

    When you kept up but don't comprehend 💀

  • @llamalatte
    @llamalatte 2 года назад

    wow i talk really fast

  • @RajinderYadav
    @RajinderYadav 3 года назад +2

    this is like reading and missing all the details, i can't imagine how anyone could read a technical book like this, this is a useless skill imho

  • @gaaraxpo
    @gaaraxpo 3 года назад +2

    I can hear fast audio, but I can't read fast

  • @squidface666
    @squidface666 3 года назад

    i have a 27 inch pc monitor and i spent the majority of this video watching through a matchbox.

  • @mangoldm
    @mangoldm 3 года назад +1

    That’s just not enjoyable.

  • @marinechapssemperfiout9939
    @marinechapssemperfiout9939 4 года назад

    I enjoyed the presentation. Please pardon my saying but the acoustics are sharp allowing me to hear each time your swallow. Quite distracting. Sorry.
    Semper Fi

    • @paulnowak
      @paulnowak  4 года назад +2

      Noted! We'll clean up the audio in future videos. -Paul

  • @jacobthemaster66
    @jacobthemaster66 3 года назад +1

    This is a useless skill, takes all the fun out of reading if you just read really fast, talking in your head is much more fun and you understand everything better

  • @CAVEDATA
    @CAVEDATA Год назад

    Cool. Now dont do it in life ever and become the GodHead