Use Discount Code ARJ for StudyIQ Judiciary Courses at a Maximum discount! Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/9kiiOBrpbc Telegram Handle - t.me/arjitachaturvedi
The governor should resign and face the investigation or he should be discharged from his post by the president of India till he is proved innocent by the judiciary. No one should be deprived of one's fundamental right in a democracy.
Even if it's a fake case proper investigation should be done,and the blanket which is provided under Article 361 should be subject to condition and exceptions.
Each and every citizen including Governor and president and other's personnel, should be taken lawful action for illigel activities/offences done, during discharge of duty periods, as common citizen. Article 361 should be ammended and immunity should stopped.
What is the relevance of POCSO cases in case of President or Governor? When article was placed in the Constitution, no one would have imagined future President or Governor would abuse the article 361.
100℅ freedom to the Governor or president of India no any one can lodge any complain or any person cannot file any criminal case, that is why knowing ly the president and Governor will do many illegally or molestation to any girl or women. This section or Act should be abolished otherwise , the president and Governor can any illegal activities.
@@bijonpurkayastha5186 इसमें 99.99%वेस्ट बंगाल सरकार की मिलीभगत से गवर्नर के खिलाफ चलाया गया षडयंत्र मालूम होता है। वैसे भी बंगाल का सोनागाछी कुख्यात है ।किसी भी चरित्रहीन स्त्री को भारी धनराशि का लालच देकर उससे ऐसा घृणित कार्य कराया जा सकता है बिना सी सी टी वी फुटेज के आरोप को सत्य कत्तई नही माना जाना चाहिए।इसे मैं संदेशखाली घटना के जबाब में की गयी बदले की कोशिश के रूप में देखता हूं।
@@nyusa78 That's a good question....you must ask yourself. Unless you have made a faustian bargain with you-know-who, you couldn't have made such a comment. You neither know the wom nor the governor personally, yet you jump into the conclusion that the woman has been purchased. Isn't it you who have been purchased even without your knowledge? That must be the reason why you are so obsessed with 'purchasing' and 'selling'.
It's only a allegation primafacia case ke merits aur clue witness nahi case aqqit karte aap ke baap pe aata hai mere girl friend case Kiya tho aap ka jawaab minimum. Clue witness merits &primafacia. Necessary hai. Aap. Punjabi hai ghutne me se brain ko head me laloo
Why DA case against Wes Bengal govt Supreme Court giving date and date only date? while Calcutta High Court ordered against government. What is the problem of Supreme Court? What is the mystry?
in case of governor and President, after preliminary enquiry by the police the report should be submitted to to chief justice of High court or to the chief justice of supreme court to obtain the sanctions for prosecution of governor or president of India.
यह राजनीतिक षड़यंत्र मालूम होता है,।हो सकता है कि संदेशखाली मामले के जबाब में बंगाल सरकार की मिलीभगत से कराया गया हो।इसकी जांच ""अच्छी तरह से होनी चाहिए।""
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
12:54 blanket person should not be given. Guidelines should be framed so that under exceptional cases, proper investigation and Criminal cases can be instituted and continued. Victims fundamental rights should not be violated.
In the constitution of England it is said that "the King never dies".But in the constitution of India there is no provision of the king. It is therefore some rules can be considered to implement the rules in respect of serios offences conducted by the the Governor.
It is a Criminal offence that no case can be made on President or Governor, Why this people are not human being and would not commit any offence. Similarly case cannot be made against any person simply a complaint is made by a woman. Before a case is made investigation should be carried by neutral agency, if the outcome is true case should be made against men. if it is a false case women should be punishable as that men. Because false complaints are also more fatal and will ruine the life of men. One such false complaint is made by a woman on our the then SC chief justice Tarun Gogoi and the woman did not turn up to enquire giving her chance to prove her point. She was simply set free on false allegations on SC chief justice which is very Disaster for the country. In 498A case also women should be made punishable for a very blatant false case.
I personally fell president and governor must be immuned. The governor in interest of conflict and justice must himself get down in favour of law of the land.
While the Governor advanced her for sexual harassment what was her reaction? Is she raised her voice or cried or called others for help. The society ladies shall file such cases to trap the highest authorities for her advantage. The WB governor has no previous record of criminal conduct. He is a good person and very senior IAS officer. His record is very high.
Art. 361 of the Constitution provides immunity to The hon'ble president and governor from any kind of prosecution after due process of law, so long they discharge their respective duties, as envisaged in the Constitution itself. Is the allegation of sexual harrassment by any woman, who ever may be, applicable to the immunity granted by the Constitution without examining the verasity of allegation thus made? The spirit of Art. 361 has to be construed in the entirity of the provision(s) . Mere quoting of part(s) of Art. 361 may entail to wrong interpretation of the immunity provision. ...
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
Correction : Identity was not revealed by police. Governors office invited public to view cctv footage and revealed the victims identity in the process
Honble SC should be considered that, TMC govt intentionally created fulse allegation through a lady against Governors who raised objections TMC govt. inspite of alarming situation law and order. Complainer is supporter of TMC party.
In india the President and the Governors are given safeguards even over the constitution . In the country a person first a citizen and then the position/status . As a sample case if the President or a Governor does a heinous crime like murdering a person in open public , on strength of position they are above board & Scot free and the family has to keep shut up . What is the natural justice saying ? . Comments are received the case is TMC party influenced or politics oriente. GOD forbid , if same incident happens with family members they will brand it as political case . There is another such incident of sexual harrasement with a female in a hotel in Delhi as reported in newspaper . The same Governor is involved . Is this also a political case ? . The Governor is involved in two cases , still above board and Scot free under the cover of constitutional article . The same Governor/ WB filed a case against CM/WB but nobody can file a case against him ?. What a fallacy?.
Remove the blanket immunity, take action as par the law ,president or governor not came from sky-asmaan-akaash , law is no is above the law..then that girl go to international court of justice...
Jis aurat ko talibani ki tarah pita gaya, us aurat ne to apne video banane wale par hi case kar diya . Isse saaf hai ki TMC ki dhamki se darkar usne aisa step Liya. Phir Yaha par bhi TMC involve kyun nahi ho sakti.
By giving this blanket immunity to Governors and the President it's infact gives them the power to go ahead and misuse it ...99% people in power do misuse power ....we women know what we suffer in work places from lecherous bosses . Hence I believe the girl ...justice must be done to her
Tumne suna yes me se no, sansad me, unka bas itna kaam hai, report sunna aur bahumat par bil paas karna aur fadna, basharte not report coming of any person or rull,
👑👉 fake case he ❌ 👉 TMC chahti he ki 👉central government ka jo state government pr control hota he by govermener ke duara hota he 👉agar governor ko hata to state government kuch bhi kr sakti chahe to naya desh bana sakti he🤨🤨🤨 ye TMC chal he jisse Central Government ko State se dur kiya ja sakte
Yea sirf bjp ka ghatya log he kar sakta he...😂😂 Altu faltu case deta rehta he..Rahul gandhi ko to British citizen he bolke case de diya😂😂 matlab kuch bhi
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
सच में आपने सही कहा आपकी किस्मत खराब थी कि आप इस देश में जन्म हुए क्योंकि, इतने खुले रूप से इस देश के संविधान और इस देश की बुराई करने का अधिकार भी आपको इसीलिए मिला क्योंकि आप इस देश में जन्महुए हैं। कोई अरब कंट्री में जन्म हुआ होता या फिर रिपब्लिक ऑफ़ चाइना में हुआ होता तोशायद, आपको इससे बेहतर संविधान और इससे बेहतर देश मिलता है जहां पर खुल के आप उसे देश के संविधान और उसे देश की सत्ता को चुनौती देकर उसकी बुराईकर पाते हैं। दक्षिण कोरिया तो आपके लिए सर्वश्रेष्ठ राष्ट्र होता क्योंकि वह तो विकसित राष्ट्र है, जिस तरह से आपने कहा कि आपकी किस्मत खराब थी कि आप इस देश में जन्म हुए क्योंकि आपके यहां का संविधान और यहां की पूरी व्यवस्था खराब लगती है, तो दक्षिण कोरिया जैसा विकसित राष्ट्र आपके लिए बिल्कुल बेहतर होता। वहां की तो व्यवस्था भी सामाजिक व्यवस्थाहै, ना तो पूंजीवादी व्यवस्था है ना ही मिश्रित व्यवस्था है, पूर्ण रूप से सामाजिक व्यवस्था है,
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
Use Discount Code ARJ for StudyIQ Judiciary Courses at a Maximum discount!
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/9kiiOBrpbc
Telegram Handle -
t.me/arjitachaturvedi
The governor should resign and face the investigation or he should be discharged from his post by the president of India till he is proved innocent by the judiciary. No one should be deprived of one's fundamental right in a democracy.
Even if it's a fake case proper investigation should be done,and the blanket which is provided under Article 361 should be subject to condition and exceptions.
An investigation should be carried out by CBI
Each and every citizen including Governor and president and other's personnel, should be taken lawful action for illigel activities/offences done, during discharge of duty periods, as common citizen. Article 361 should be ammended and immunity should stopped.
What is the relevance of POCSO cases in case of President or Governor?
When article was placed in the Constitution, no one would have imagined future President or Governor would abuse the article 361.
Central Government of India should remove the Governor of West Bengal.Victim can also approach the leader of the opposition of Lok Sabha.
The right of woman must protected by the law
100℅ freedom to the Governor or president of India no any one can lodge any complain or any person cannot file any criminal case, that is why knowing ly the president and Governor will do many illegally or molestation to any girl or women.
This section or Act should be abolished otherwise , the president and Governor can any illegal activities.
THE WEST BENGAL GOVERNER SHOULD QUIT HIS POST TILL HE IS PROVED INNOCENT.
IF HE HAS THE MORAL COURAGE TO DO SO.
Thank you Madam for the wonderfull presentation.🙏
Interesting & informative case study, well presented.
The Female Is Politically Motivated
@@bijonpurkayastha5186 यह ममता बानो की एजेंट मालूम पड़ती है,इसे भारी धनराशि दी गई
होगी यह सब करने के एवज में।
@@bijonpurkayastha5186 इसमें 99.99%वेस्ट बंगाल सरकार की मिलीभगत से गवर्नर के खिलाफ
चलाया गया षडयंत्र मालूम होता है।
वैसे भी बंगाल का सोनागाछी कुख्यात है ।किसी भी चरित्रहीन स्त्री को भारी धनराशि का लालच देकर उससे ऐसा घृणित कार्य कराया जा सकता है बिना सी सी टी वी फुटेज के आरोप
को सत्य कत्तई नही माना जाना चाहिए।इसे मैं संदेशखाली घटना
के जबाब में की गयी बदले की कोशिश के रूप में देखता हूं।
YOU MUCH YOUR MOTHER AND WIFE GET TO LET THEM FUCK ??????????
TMC has purchased that woman against governor
How do you know?
@@josephjames859WhatsApp
@@josephjames859 mR Joseph 😅😂 when did you sell your soul, or parents sold you.
@@nyusa78
That's a good question....you must ask yourself. Unless you have made a faustian bargain with you-know-who, you couldn't have made such a comment. You neither know the wom nor the governor personally, yet you jump into the conclusion that the woman has been purchased. Isn't it you who have been purchased even without your knowledge? That must be the reason why you are so obsessed with 'purchasing' and 'selling'.
????
YOU R EXCELLENT 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Since it's WB it can be a frame from TMC, but investigation should be done parerally without hindering the work
The brainless bhaktas find loathsome politics everywhere if it's against their political parents.
Well explained Madam, thanks.
No person can be blamed falsely.he is after all Governor. Proper investigation should be done.
It's only a allegation primafacia case ke merits aur clue witness nahi case aqqit karte aap ke baap pe aata hai mere girl friend case Kiya tho aap ka jawaab minimum. Clue witness merits &primafacia. Necessary hai. Aap. Punjabi hai ghutne me se brain ko head me laloo
How mischievious r the orthodox bhaktas!
Why DA case against Wes Bengal govt Supreme Court giving date and date only date? while Calcutta High Court ordered against government.
What is the problem of Supreme Court? What is the mystry?
Criminal case is not allowed but civil case is allowed then after can impeach and remove president or Governor.
in case of governor and President, after preliminary enquiry by the police the report should be submitted to to chief justice of High court or to the chief justice of supreme court to obtain the sanctions for prosecution of governor or president of India.
Tasting their own medicine?
Thank You Arnita ji for debate.
यह राजनीतिक षड़यंत्र मालूम होता है,।हो सकता है कि संदेशखाली मामले के जबाब
में बंगाल सरकार की मिलीभगत से कराया गया हो।इसकी जांच ""अच्छी तरह से होनी चाहिए।""
है ना,
है ना,
है ना,
If so called victim become spoil herself, enough to establish blame.
How ferocious r the bhaktas! See their political parents as Almighty.
Why Government is not removing him?
Delhi CM can be put into jail but governor can't.
You r right
The point is that law can not punish governors and the president but should recognize the offense
Tainted Governor should be removed right now
क्या henious crimes means महिला और बच्चो के विरुद्ध ही कहलाएंगे, क्या पुरुष के साथ रेप हो या उनके genital काट दे तो क्या वो henious crime नही है
Should modify article 361
Where is rule of law in India?
सब कार्यालय मे कॅमेरा जरुरी है सच झुठ पकडा जायेगा
ट्रायल चलाओ पदसे मुक्त होते ही सजा होनी चाहिए
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
Exception hona chahiye, investigation bhi hona chahiye wrna ye khula saad ki tarah ghumenge
Who is paying her Supreme court lawyer fees ? She was just a intern in the Governer's office. The matter should be investigated by the CBI
Will you say same thing if your relative is molested ...shame on you.
12:54 blanket person should not be given. Guidelines should be framed so that under exceptional cases, proper investigation and Criminal cases can be instituted and continued. Victims fundamental rights should not be violated.
In the constitution of England it is said that "the King never dies".But in the constitution of India there is no provision of the king. It is therefore some rules can be considered to implement the rules in respect of serios offences conducted by the the Governor.
It is a Criminal offence that no case can be made on President or Governor, Why this people are not human being and would not commit any offence. Similarly case cannot be made against any person simply a complaint is made by a woman. Before a case is made investigation should be carried by neutral agency, if the outcome is true case should be made against men. if it is a false case women should be punishable as that men. Because false complaints are also more fatal and will ruine the life of men. One such false complaint is made by a woman on our the then SC chief justice Tarun Gogoi and the woman did not turn up to enquire giving her chance to prove her point. She was simply set free on false allegations on SC chief justice which is very Disaster for the country. In 498A case also women should be made punishable for a very blatant false case.
Why the full cc tv footage not disclosed.
Remove governor
I personally fell president and governor must be immuned.
The governor in interest of conflict and justice must himself get down in favour of law of the land.
While the Governor advanced her for sexual harassment what was her reaction? Is she raised her voice or cried or called others for help. The society ladies shall file such cases to trap the highest authorities for her advantage. The WB governor has no previous record of criminal conduct. He is a good person and very senior IAS officer. His record is very high.
Misuse of law
Art. 361 of the Constitution provides immunity to The hon'ble president and governor from any kind of prosecution after due process of law, so long they discharge their respective duties, as envisaged in the Constitution itself. Is the allegation of sexual harrassment by any woman, who ever may be, applicable to the immunity granted by the Constitution without examining the verasity of allegation thus made?
The spirit of Art. 361 has to be construed in the entirity of the provision(s) .
Mere quoting of part(s) of Art. 361 may entail to wrong interpretation of the immunity provision. ...
Changes krne chahiye
Pura frame kiya case hai. Ladki TMC worker hai. Naushad Siddiqui ISF MLA ka upar same case daala
Remove this Governor. Amend the Constitution. Law shd be equal for anyone
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
Correction : Identity was not revealed by police.
Governors office invited public to view cctv footage and revealed the victims identity in the process
पद ओर सत्ता का दुरुपयोग..m
Honble SC should be considered that, TMC govt intentionally created fulse allegation through a lady against Governors who raised objections TMC govt. inspite of alarming situation law and order. Complainer is supporter of TMC party.
In india the President and the Governors are given safeguards even over the constitution . In the country a person first a citizen and then the position/status . As a sample case if the President or a Governor does a heinous crime like murdering a person in open public , on strength of position they are above board & Scot free and the family has to keep shut up . What is the natural justice saying ? .
Comments are received the case is TMC party influenced or politics oriente. GOD forbid , if same incident happens with family members they will brand it as political case .
There is another such incident of sexual harrasement with a female in a hotel in Delhi as reported in newspaper . The same Governor is involved . Is this also a political case ? .
The Governor is involved in two cases , still above board and Scot free under the cover of constitutional article .
The same Governor/ WB filed a case against CM/WB but nobody can file a case against him ?. What a fallacy?.
Madam your study contents are provocative based on the false allegations on WB Governer.
Dharam sankat b/w women favour - powerful man
361 me special guidelines hona chahie
Mai kab aisha kar diya, aisha kuchh bhi abhi tak nahi hua,
Kothay kar sab ki fit ke janei?
Kise hoy ke jane sab to tai bole calcutta high courter verdict palte jabe.
Remove the blanket immunity, take action as par the law ,president or governor not came from sky-asmaan-akaash , law is no is above the law..then that girl go to international court of justice...
Ye hi to samvidan ki kmi hai . Chota chor chor bda chor sahukar
If case is false then ,?
Jis aurat ko talibani ki tarah pita gaya, us aurat ne to apne video banane wale par hi case kar diya . Isse saaf hai ki TMC ki dhamki se darkar usne aisa step Liya. Phir Yaha par bhi TMC involve kyun nahi ho sakti.
Total political conspiracy
झुठा केस दाखल करना चाहती है ममता बानो
Abb shi hai
Dekhte hai abb women biased system kya krta hai against a governor
By giving this blanket immunity to Governors and the President it's infact gives them the power to go ahead and misuse it ...99% people in power do misuse power ....we women know what we suffer in work places from lecherous bosses . Hence I believe the girl ...justice must be done to her
Article 361 need an amendment
First Cover your arms fully
Women & Child Development Department mai Navlender kumar bhi assault krta u female staff ko lekin koi bhi drr ki vjh se nhi vol paa raha hai😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
itna darr kyun hai?
This is very wrong
Ye sab Mamta ki politics hai 100%
Tumne suna yes me se no, sansad me, unka bas itna kaam hai, report sunna aur bahumat par bil paas karna aur fadna, basharte not report coming of any person or rull,
Poisa de ke khorid ki hai....
Political game
👑👉 fake case he ❌
👉 TMC chahti he ki 👉central government ka jo state government pr control hota he by govermener ke duara hota he 👉agar governor ko hata to state government kuch bhi kr sakti chahe to naya desh bana sakti he🤨🤨🤨 ye TMC chal he jisse Central Government ko State se dur kiya ja sakte
मैम ये तो बता दो कि जिसने भी संविधान में ये बात लिखी है वो क्यों लिखी है उसने भांग खा के लिख दिया था क्या
Ye apne galat bola madam arjita wb police ne victim ka face Public nehi kiya gvnr ne kiya apki proper jan ke video banana chaiye tha
Yea sirf bjp ka ghatya log he kar sakta he...😂😂 Altu faltu case deta rehta he..Rahul gandhi ko to British citizen he bolke case de diya😂😂 matlab kuch bhi
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance
Sandeshkhali
इस कुर्सी में बैठकर 100 मर्डर कर सकते हैं ये लोग। घटिया संविधान। कभीकभी लगता है, मैं बदकिस्मत था जो भारत में पैदा क्यों हुआ?
Really!!!!!!!
सच में आपने सही कहा आपकी किस्मत खराब थी कि आप इस देश में जन्म हुए क्योंकि,
इतने खुले रूप से इस देश के संविधान और इस देश की बुराई करने का अधिकार भी आपको इसीलिए मिला क्योंकि आप इस देश में जन्महुए हैं।
कोई अरब कंट्री में जन्म हुआ होता या फिर रिपब्लिक ऑफ़ चाइना में हुआ होता तोशायद, आपको इससे बेहतर संविधान और इससे बेहतर देश मिलता है जहां पर खुल के आप उसे देश के संविधान और उसे देश की सत्ता को चुनौती देकर उसकी बुराईकर पाते हैं।
दक्षिण कोरिया तो आपके लिए सर्वश्रेष्ठ राष्ट्र होता क्योंकि वह तो विकसित राष्ट्र है, जिस तरह से आपने कहा कि आपकी किस्मत खराब थी कि आप इस देश में जन्म हुए क्योंकि आपके यहां का संविधान और यहां की पूरी व्यवस्था खराब लगती है, तो दक्षिण कोरिया जैसा विकसित राष्ट्र आपके लिए बिल्कुल बेहतर होता। वहां की तो व्यवस्था भी सामाजिक व्यवस्थाहै, ना तो पूंजीवादी व्यवस्था है ना ही मिश्रित व्यवस्था है, पूर्ण रूप से सामाजिक व्यवस्था है,
Shame on you
Pehle to tu teeno sanhita pad le. Kanun state of transition me hain.
BJP propaganda channel running behind the facade of education
Waste bengal ❌ mini pakistan ✔️
Kya janta hai to kutia West Bengal ka bareme
Aaj kal लेडकियों ke pass sabse hathiyar mila hua hai
BNSS 144 की वीडियो बनाओ
The case is politically motivated. If the immunity is removed, the lady will be in trouble. Constitution provides that protection because of these kind of nuisance